STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. NOTES AND DISCUSSIONS ON CICERO DE DIVINATIONE i. 80 Mr. Pease's proposal (Classical Philology, XIII [April, 1918], 211) to move mentis away from sensu seems unquestionably correct. But it should be put between eum and vis quaedam. The "homoeographon" mentis vis was the cause of the omission of the word which was subsequently restored to the text but not to its right place. j. p. postgate Liverpool THE STATUS OF CALLISTRATUS IN THE LITIGATION OVER THE ESTATE OF CONON [DEMOSTHENES], xlviii. 31, 43 ff. In Callistratus v. Olympiodorus suit is brought for the moiety of an estate, left by one Conon, which has been adjudged to the present defendant. The plaintiff's account of the circumstances which led up to the suit is as follows : In the SiaoWcria, which resulted in the judgment, both Callistratus and Olympiodorus had filed claims, separately, the former for half of the estate, the latter for the whole. Olympiodorus succeeded in establishing his title through fraud, with the connivance and actual co-operation of Callistratus. Subsequently he refused to carry out an agreement by which the two were to share equally whatever property or moneys either might secure from the estate. The present action seeks to enforce fulfilment of this agreement. 1 In the plaintiff's account of the proceedings before the court in this SuiSiKao-ia are found the following statements: (31) ko1 ovtcxti 'OX.viJ.m68u>pos ^ywi£ero wpcoTos, (cat i\eyev o tl ifiovkero, ko.1 [tupTvpias irapei^eTO as i&oKu tovtio- Kayh) m avSpes Sucaoral ctmottij iKO.0r\p.rjv iirl tov kripov fttf/JLO.TO'i. (44) xayoi ovS' otiovv avriXtyov tovtois, ovS' r/Kovak /uov o>vr)V ovSas av6pv, ore ovtos ■qyu>vi£eTo, ovrt ftxKpav ovre /xiydKrjv, aXXa it pofi.o\6yovv a\r)0rj aval wavd' oo-a ovtos r)($ov\eTo \eyeiv. The problem here is to determine the status of Callistratus in the SiaSwcao-ta. Was he at the time of the hearing a party to the suit ? 1 For the details of the case and the interpretations here discussed, see Schaefer, Demosthenes und seine Zeit, III (Leipzig, 1858), 236 ff.; Kennedy, The Orations of Demosthenes, IV (London, 1880), 366 ff.; V (1878), 100 ff.; Bonner, Evidence in Athenian Courts (Chicago, 1905), pp. 89-90; Leisi, Der Zeuge im Attischen Rechi (Frauenfeld, 1908), p. 120, n. 2; Lipsius, Das Attische Becht, II (Leipzig, 1912), 782, n. 16 fin. 410 Notes and Discussions 411 Bonner, who first raises the question, infers from Callistratus' allusions to his silence that he had not carried his claim into court. 1 Leisi also (loc. cit.) takes these passages to mean that Callistratus did not address the court, though he maintains, as does Lipsius {loc. cit.), that he was still a party to the suit at the time of the hearing. Bonner is unquestionably right in declining to regard the phrase em tov iripov firj/uiTos as proof positive that Callistratus was a party to the suit, but his view involves other more serious difficulties. In the first place, the statement (31) koX p-era ravO' o dpx aveKpive irauiv rjpZv tois a./Avr]V oiSets avOpomiav (44) to mean that Callistratus made no address to the jury. In the first passage quoted above does not the imperfect iKaO-qpvqv balance ^y .... wap«x«To? Does it not really mean " Olympiodorus was argu- ing his case, the first, and was saying what he pleased, and presenting what testimony he liked, and I (while that was going on) was sitting in silence" ? Here is at least an ambiguity, and that ambiguity is noticed by the speaker and cleared up in the second passage by the clause ore ovtos yyiavi^eTo. "And no man heard my voice, while he was arguing his case." Nothing could be more explicit than this, and it is strange that it has been overlooked. Callistratus denies, not that he addressed the court in due form, but that he interrupted Olympiodorus during the latter's speech. 2 1 Loc. cit. Bonner's later views on this case are reported by the writer in Classical Philology, XI (1916), 379, n. 3. 2 The words ovre vuKpav ovre y.eyaKriv, which Kennedy renders "not a word, not a syllable," although they are a formula merely of emphatic denial, nevertheless suggest informal interruption or protest rather than a set speech. 412 Notes and Discussions The working out of this neat coup appears to have been about as follows : Callistratus and Olympiodorus filed separate claims in order to secure two chances, and with the understanding that whatever either might receive was to be shared equally. But it was to their advantage to establish the claim of Olympiodorus, if possible, rather than that of Callistratus, who would be co-heir with his brother and could hope for only a moiety. Consequently, when the "case " of Olympiodorus was working out well and his argument was seen to be making a good impression, it devolved upon Callistratus to "play into his hands." This he could easily do, simply by not challenging the truth of the assertions Olympiodorus had made and by devoting most of his argument to attacks upon the claims of the other suitors. Perhaps he even contrived adroitly to create the impression that he had always recognized the validity of Olympiodorus' claim, and had been induced to become a suitor only by the advent of other claimants. As to his real reasons for preferring to divide with Olympiodorus rather than his own half-brother, we may note, in addition to the motive suggested by Kennedy (loc. cit.), the fact that at the time of Conon's death the brother was absent from Athens while Olympio- dorus was on the spot, and the distinct possibility that the latter's claim was in reality as good as his own or better. 1 If this analysis of the case seem startling, one has but to turn to the speech Against Macartatus to find a parallel. 2 Practically the same maneuver is executed on a more elaborate scale. George Miller Calhoun University op California NOTE ON DIOGENES LAERTIUS ix. 108 ovre yap raS' IXov/xeOa rj ravra cvyeiv, s to ireivrjv Kal Stt/rcjv Kal aXyeiv. Should we not read here -nap' r)aas instead of irepl rjuas ? In later dis- cussion of freedom of the will to nap' r)p.as is almost technical, though it seems to be overlooked in the grammars and lexicons. I cannot find that irepl -ij/iSs is so used, trepl fipJas might conceivably be understood here of the things that really concern us. But that would yield a very imperfect antithesis with v Kal to avre^ovcnov p.era rfjs dvdyKrjS, with Aetius Plac. i. 27. 3 [Diels, Doxographi Graeci; p. 322, 5] : liXarav eyKpivei p*v rr/v elfux.pp.evr]V ori tS>v avOpum-ivwv xj/vx^v Kal /SiW, o-weicrayei 8e Kal rrjv Trap rjaas airtav. ol Stohkoi IIXaTcon o-Te to. uev eiaapOai, ra Si aveipApdai. 1 Cf. Libanius in hypothesis 1 : dXXA tovto uev rax' &" ^eMorro, ktX. 2 7 ff. Cf. the writer's Athenian Clubs (Austin, 1913), p. 88, n. 1.