STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Volume XVI April. IQ2I Number z THE TRADITION OF GREEK ARITHMOLOGY Br Frank Egleston Bobbins The problem attacked in the following pages is the determination of the sources and relationships of the ancient arithmological writings, including principally those of Varro, Philo, Nicomachus, Theon of Smyrna, Anatolius, the compilator of the Theologumena Arithmeticae, Chalcidius, Macrobius, Martianus Capella, Favonius Eulogius, and Johannes Laurentius Lydus. The difficulty of the problem, the necessity of hypothetical reasoning, and the ease with which error may be committed are acknowledged at the outset. The situation presented by the above-mentioned writings much resembles that seen in the Synoptic Gospels, and methods similar to those used by New Testament critics should be employed in its elucidation. Whole passages of one authpr are repeated in one or more others, and the topics of arithmology are so frequently paralleled that to determine the exact provenance of any one may be well-nigh impossible. The problem therefore has to be handled in a large way and the main currents of influence determined, a thing which the previous essays in this field 1 have not satisfactorily done. They have, moreover, without exception followed Schmekel in regarding 1 The following are most frequently referred to : A. Schmekel, Die Philosophic der mittleren Stoa in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwickelung, Berlin, 1892; G. Borghorst, De Anatolii fontibus, Berlin, 1905; G. Altmann, De Posidonio Timaei Platonis commen- tatore, Berlin, 1906; B. W. Switalski, "Des Chalcidius Kommentar zu Platos Timaeus," Beitr&ge 2. Gesch. d. Phil. d. Mittelalters, III (Munster, 1902), 6; F. Skutsch, "Zu Favonius Eulogius und Chalcidius," Philologus, LXI (1902), 193 ff.; C. Fries, "De M. Varrone a Favonio expresso," Rheinisches Museum, N.F., LXVIII (1903), 115 ff. [Classical Philology XVI, April, 1921] 97 98 Frank Egleston Robbins Posidonius as the universal source of arithmology — an error, as I have shown elsewhere. 1 The results won in the previous paper may serve as a starting- point for the present inquiry; namely, that Posidonius was not the author of the arithmology seen in Philo, Theon, and the rest, but quoted from an already existing arithmological work, the introduction of which Sextus Empiricus reproduces quite fully in Adv. math. iv. 2 ff., Anatolius and Theon in abridged form, and other parts of which were used by many authors. The existence of this work, at least, is proven, and if it be granted that Posidonius quoted it, it existed before his time, that is, by the last half of the second century b.c. For the reasons collected in the former article and for others that may appear later, the writer is ready to abandon the noncom- mittal attitude previously adopted and to believe that he actually did quote it, as Sextus Empiricus Adv. math. vii. 91 ff. shows. Since this document was so universal a source for later writers, it will for convenience be referred to as S ("source"). Anatolius 2 and Theon 3 give the best idea of the character of S, preserving as they do its introduction and a considerable part of its ten chapters on the numbers of the first decade. Since any reader can see in a moment that they ultimately come from a common ancestor, 4 this will be assumed without argument. These two writers, in fact, may be used as a sort of standard for judging whether others have drawn upon S. It may safely be believed that material common to both of them is from S; if we find the same matter in other writers, they also derived it from S. If certain other writers, 1 "Posidonius and the Sources of Pythagorean Arithmology," Classical Philology, XV (1920), 309-22. 2 Ed. J. L. Heiberg, Annales internationales d'histoire, Congres de Paris, 1900, S e section, Hisioire des sciences, Paris, 1901, pp. 27 ff. Anatolius is also extensively quoted in the Theologumena Arithmelicae (ed. Ast, 1817). * Expositio rerum mathematicarum ad legendum Platonem utilium, ed. E. Hiller, Leipzig, 1878. 4 Except in one place, to be discussed below, these two are never at variance in making different statements about the same topic; one of them, however, usually Anatolius, may present topics which the other omits. Anatolius' treatise is apparently a set of notes for the use of students, hence a mere outline, devoid of literary elabora- tion. Theon's too is greatly condensed but somewhat more elaborate rhetorically; he is apt to say more about a given topic than Anatolius, while the latter preserves many more topics than Theon. Some of Anatolius' material, not found in Theon, is perhaps not from S ; but this forms no great part of the whole. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 99 of whom it is thus known that they used S as a source, parallel material in Anatolius not attested by Theon, this too may be claimed for S, and so, when reasonable presumptions have thus been created, the circle of the influence of S may be enlarged and defined. I do not, however, intend to point out all the S material that can be identified in ancient literature, but will turn to the real point at issue, the method of transmission of S material. Very little inquiry shows that Theon and Anatolius both present S in an abridged form. Philo, who in the De mundi opificio certainly used S, has in cc. 30-42 of that work a treatment of the number 7 which in general agrees throughout with Anatolius, the latter here as usual being more voluminous than Theon. Philo's account, however, is far longer even than Anatolius', containing many more topics and saying more about each one; yet probably every one of these topics, whether or not paralleled by Anatolius, is from S; the exceptions are certainly very few. This is proved by the fact that practically all of them are found, in connection with S material, in still other writers, Lydus 1 in particular showing a close likeness to Philo. But though Philo's chapters give us our best idea of the original text of S, still even they are abridged, for they omit several topics which must certainly be referred to the anonymous source because of their occurrence in several of the writers of our group. 2 Evidently some had only abridged versions of S, while others used full or but slightly abridged texts. Among the descendants of S, Philo, as far as the De mundi opificio is concerned, Anatolius, and Lydus give evidence of forming a closely related group. Theon, as far as he goes, generally agrees with them, but he differs from them radically in the insertion in the seventh chapter of a block of material, set in a context showing the closest agreement with Anatolius, but differing wholly from the pro- nouncements of the three first mentioned upon the same subject, the control exercised by the number 7 over birth and the "ages of man." It will later be seen that by agreeing here with Theon rather than with Anatolius, Philo, and Lydus, a group including Chalcidius, 1 De mensibus ii. 12. 2 E.g., the 7 numbers used in Plato's Timaeus, and the flow of euripi, both to be found in Theon, Anatolius, and Lydus. 100 Fbank Egleston Robbins Capella, Favonius, and others show that they belong to the subfamily of which Theon is an example; but we must first examine certain peculiarities shared by Philo and Lydus which prove that they are more closely related to each other than to Anatolius. Most important for this purpose is the following passage 1 dealing with the number 7 : Philo De mundi opificio c. 33: Toaovro Si iv ifiSo- paSi v'&pvKai tlvai rb UpoirpeTis Siart it-alperov ix* 1 " ^°- yov 7rapd robs iv SckclSi iravras apiS- pobs' iKtlvwv yap ol fiiv ytvvGxri ob y&v&pAvoi, ol Si ytvvwvTai p-iv, ob y€vv&ai St, ol Si dju- brepa koX y&v&o'i Kal ytwdiVTai' p.bvi\ Si ifiSoixas iv obScvl fiipet. dewpelrcu. . . . . Si ijv alriav ol flip aXXot ij>i\bao- ot. rbv hpiBixbv tov- tov iippoiovai r% ap.i)Topi viicy Kal irap6iva\ijs ava$avrji>ai X070S ?X") ol Si Jlvdayo- p&oi T riyepbvi T riyepovi toO iravrbs rrjv 4(356- pi\v avarlQevTai., TOVTicTTl n? ivl, Kal paprvs 'Opfabs \iywv oStcos, 'E/356- in), ijv il\r)a€v &vai inatpyos 'AirbWiov bpSSis obv aiiJ)Topa rbv iirTi. apiBpbv b $1X6X00$ irpoo-Tj- ybptvoe pbvos yap ovt€ yarrav ovrt ytwaodai ritpvue to Si jtt^re ytvvwv /i^rc yevvebpevov iuctvTiTOV iv Kivijcru yap 17 yivvijais, to piv tva yevvficrg, t6 Si tva yevvijdjj, toiovtos Si 6 Oeds, cl)5 Kal abrbs 6 pi)Taip 6 Tapavrivos. 4>i)irl Si ovtcos' "E(TTt yap iiytpiiv Kal apxoiv airavTiov ktX. Philo Leg. all.i.5: Kara, riva \byov ol ivrbs SeKaSos apiB- Anatolius, p. 35, 6ff.: i@Sop.as fiovTj twv ivrds SexaSos ob yev- vq. obSi yatvarai bir' oXXou apiSpov irXi)i> bird povaSos' Sid Kal KaXeiTai bird 7w HvSayoptlaiv irapBivos d/t^rcop. TWl' Si fiXXcoi' TWV ivrds 5e/cd5oy 6 p&v S' bird SvaSos 7€j»»»o- rai, ytvv^. Si abv Tjj ofirg rbv i)', ktX. Theon, p. 103 (Hiller): fibvos yap t&v iprbs t^s StKaSos OVTt yevvi} irtpov ovt€ 7€»»i'OTat b)', ytwarai Si biro SvaSos, kt\. Chalcidius, c. 36 (p. 102, 6ff., Wrobel): .... itaque om- nibus partim nas- centibus, partim parientibus, par- tim et nascentibus et parientibus, solus septenarius numerus neque ex duplicatione al- terius nascitur 1 Cf. also Hierocles In carm. aur. ap. Mullach, FPG, Vol. I, p. 465; sohol. cod. Laur. in Met. 985 6 23 ; Alexander in Met. 985 6 26; Isidore, Capella, Favonius ; Theo- logumena Arithmeticae, p. 44 Ast; Anon. Prol. in introd. arith. Nicomachi ap. Tannery, Diophantus, Vol. II, pp. 73 ff. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 101 Philo: iva ytw^ay, ri> Si Iva 7€vv^Tat' pbvov Si ofrre Kivdov o&re Kivoiiiitvov 6 irp«rj9fr- repos apxtov Kal ijyeu&v, ov Xeyotr' av xoootjkoctojs «l- kuiv ifiSopas. pap- rvptt Si pov rtp \6y ToirtMS. "Eort yap, tftalv, 6 ^ye- liuiv ktX. Lydus: pot yevvStvrai rj ytv~ v&ffi rotfs ivrds Sck&Sos nal airiiy. ij Si ye iffSopas otJre ytvvq. Ttva tup ivris SiKaSos apiB- p€yp o6t€ yevv§Tat vw6 twos, rap' 8 pvBebovres oi Uv6a- ySpeioi tj) atitrap- Oivtf Kai apijTOpi airijv i.wtiKa$ovrjp/irKrjpobpa>os % 4{ ainav i)plaovs pip rpiaSos, tpItov Si Svi.- Sos, eKTov Si povaSos. Kal cbs iiros elirclv appr\v re xal SijXus tlvai irivK( Lydus: v *a£ "is Spaari- Krjs obaias (cord r6v irtptfrbv Kal rrjs b\ucijs Kara riv UpTlOV S6ev xal ol apxaToi yapov Kal appovlav airrdv ixaXeaav. Anatolius: tui> yap 6.T& povaSos p6vos ri\ti6s iari rots airrov piptai, o~vpir\rjpo(ipevos ix tG>v airr&v, rjplaovs piv rpiaSos, rplrov Si SvaSos, Zktov Si povaSos. xal dx'Xus eiTrelv apprjv re Kal $rp\us ttvai rbpvKtv, ws Kal avri] 'A(f>po- Slnf rtiv toO &pptvos 4|ds Tpwros riXeios dpiBpbs, toij yap airrjs plpcoip apiBptl- rai, a' /3' y', a ttokl t6v C- diroj Q' Q'- Sis y' C'- rpls 0' ?'• irpdros avyKelrai 0- ■fiplutm rpirov Iktov' rerpayuvL^Spevos ire- pt^X" adrdv .... Theon: 6 Si s' T^X«K>S' (Cf. Censorinus De die not. 11. 4: nee immerito senarius fundamentum gig- nendi est; 4 nam eum teleion Graeci, nos autem perfec- tum uocamus, quod eius partes tres, sexta et tertia et dimidia, id est I et Capella: senarium uero per- fectum analogicum- que esse quia dubi- tet, cum suis parti- bus impleatur ? nam et sextam sui intra se continet quod est unus, et tertiam quod duo, et medietatem quod tres hie autem numerus 1 Cf. also Macrobius Comm. in somn. Scip. i. 6. 12-13; Favonius; Isidore; Theol. Arith., p. 36, bottom; Philo Leg. all. i. 2. 2 Philo Qu. in Gen. iii. 49: ". . . . quod ueracissime quidam uocant harmoniam uel matrimonium." * Fries, op. tit., regards it as important that both Capella and Favonius use forms of -plere. To judge from Philo, S originally had a double form (Urobpevos .... Kal avpwKripoipevos) , the latter part being transmitted in the branch to which Capella and Favonius belong. Theon does not have it because he has only the second occurrence of this topic. Cf. also Lydus iv. 88, p. 136, 17 ft. 4 This shows that Censorinus' sources had ytwr)TiKTaTos or something like it. 6 Nicomachus ap. Photius cod. 187 has this topic. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 105 Here, the statement that 6 is yevvqriK&raTOS, in Philo and Lydus but not in the others, 1 is associated, in Philo directly with S material paralleled by Anatolius et al., in Lydus with the same material, but after the intervention of a passage the agreement of which with Quaest. in Gen. iii. 38 could not be closer. In view of the occurrence of yevvrjTUi&TaTos in both Philo and Lydus, in an S context, and because of the difficulty of wrenching away what follows in Lydus, confirmed as it is by Quaest. in Gen. iii. 38 (itself somewhat resembling S material), the best judgment, I think, will decide that the whole passage of Lydus and Quaest. in Gen. iii. 38 both come from S, and 1 Except, perhaps, Censorinus. 106 Frank Egleston Robbins show again that Philo and Lydus possessed a particularly voluminous source. Note also the evidences of special relationships. The parallel cos eiros eiirelv — cbrXws dirtiv in Philo and Lydus is most remarkable; that in the words &s oeSetKrcu used by both Anatolius and Theon equally so. In Anatolius they refer to the first occurrence of the topic at the beginning of the chapter; Theon, however, has omitted this mention of the topic and has given only its second occurrence, unnecessarily including «s 8&>et/crcu, unless this is regarded as a reference to another part of his book. 1 To me, however, it seems to be another example of agreement between these two upon the merest matters of detail, comparable to the use by both of the words "as the diagram shows" in the fifth chapter. 2 However else they differ, such things show Theon and Anatolius to be extremely closely related. The passage above may also be used to show that Philo is not the source of Lydus; the detail about Aphrodite, not in Philo, but in Lydus, is also seen in its proper connection in Capella, which testifies to its presence in the original source. Philo, as a Jew, would have none of it, and Lydus cannot have taken it from him. There is no reason to believe that Philo would have included it in his lost Ilepi api0fiu>v, s and that this was Lydus' source. The following series of passages shows a similar situation: Lydus ii. 7: Philo, Quaest. in Anatolius, p. 30, Theon, p. 100, Gen. ii. 12: 23 ff.: lOfif.: .... iird toO apriov Kal vXikov apiBpov' to yap apriov ixkaov St- aa-warai Siaipoipie- vov rod h>br nbvos 5i adiaiperos b irepiTTOs. 6 nkv •yip appriv apiffuds Terp&ywvos, afryi) Kal 0Ss, J| labnyrm vXevpuv avvearws' 1 It could refer to the incidental remark at p. 101, 7, or to p. 45, 11 ff. 2 Theon, p. 101, 19, tbs SijXot t4 Siaypapixa =Anatolius, p. 34, 4. Perhaps the moat notable agreement is in the introduction to their arithmologies. 3 Cf. Classical Philology, XV, 320, n. 4. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 107 Lydus: 6 Si OijXus irtfio- M*)k?;s, vilKTO. Kal anbrov ixw Sib. ri\v ipujdrriTa' 6 Si ire- po/iriKTis Tijv pip kKarrova T\tvpav i\6.TTova ?x« i»l, rip> Si iM(l'(oi irtpir- rorkpav ivi. &are 6 Stoo 6.pL0nds oi KaBapbs, irpwrov piiv Srt Ktvfc han Kal oh vaarbs, 1 rb Si pi/ xXijpts oi KoBa- pbv, dpx4 SI &ir«- pias Kal b.viabnf tos' artcaplas piv Sia 't))v uXtjv, av- wdrriTot Si Sia rois irtpopi]Ktir oBtv ol ■KaKaxol cos lik-qv Kal ixtpAnjTO Tijv SvaSa irapa\aixfia- vavai. rb\pav Si Kal ol irtpl QtptKb- Jijv inahizcsav rijv SvaSa t Kal bpjiijv Kal Sb£av xaXovaiv, in rb &Xij0Js Kal tcvSis iv Sofa iari. Trav aptraXs avSptla' wpofihpTiKt yap fjSij' Slit Kal rb\p.av inakovv Kal bpp-qv Kal Sbl-av Si cbv6pa£ov, in rdXijdis Kal ipevSos ivSbfr In the beginning of the chapter on 2 Anatolius has several topics not represented by anything that Lydus says. The latter, then, if he is using material from S, begins at some point in the middle of the chapter. Now we have seen in a previous instance how Anatolius summarized in one or two words all that Philo and Lydus said about the topics aprtowiptTros and apvevWrjXvs, where 1 Philo Qu. in Exod. ii. 100: " . . . . ternio est condensus plenusque numerus, nullam habens uacuitatem, sed quicquid in dualitate discerptum erat adimplens." This passage is so similar in character that there need be no hesitation in pronouncing it based on something in S. Cf. Favonius' remark on 5, "constat hie ex pleno et non pleno, tribus uidelicet et duobus." 108 Frank Egleston Robbins they were drawing upon a version of S fuller than his; it is a tempting conjecture that he has done the same with the topic 6A77 here, which Lydus and Philo have preserved more nearly in full; and again, the use by Lydus of unquestionable S material in the context, and the support of Philo, lend color to the assumption. Perhaps — but this is not so certain — Lydus represents S even in what follows the quotation given and Anatolius, supported by Theon, gives a rough summary. For the portions quoted, at any rate, we probably rightly assert that their source was S. From the material quoted or cited above it is clear that Lydus utilized an S source of a form closely resembling that of Philo's, and more voluminous than the source of Anatolius and Theon, and finally, since we see that Philo and Lydus, when they agree in material not found in Theon and Anatolius, are often merely following their more comprehensive source, it becomes probable that eVen when the fact cannot be proved by Philonian parallels Lydus may sometimes be quoting S. For many passages, of course, this cannot be claimed, but for a considerable part of that section into which the bulk of his arithmology is collected, De mensibus ii. 4-12, the state- ment should hold. For there are, in the first place, close verbal agreements throughout this section with the best representatives of S, Philo, Theon, and Anatolius, 1 as well as others, only slightly less significant, with Philo outside the De mundi opificio and with the Theologumena Arithmeticae; 2 furthermore, it is hardly questionable that if S was the source of part of this section — as we know it was — its influence extended over the whole. Most important of all, in the one place where Lydus can be compared with a practically unabridged S text, that is, in the discussion of 7, where Philo can be used, 3 it is seen that Lydus employed very little other than S material. 4 In 1 These are cited above, p. 102, n. 2. 2 E.g., of. Lydus, p. 23, 7 ff., with Philo Qu. in Gen. iv. 110, and with both of. the statements of Capella and Favonius about the monad; p. 25, 12 ff., with Philo ibid. iv. 8 and Theol. Arith., p. 16; p. 28, 8 ff., with Philo loc. cit. and Theol. Arith., p. 8; p. 26, 13 ff„ with Theol. Arith., p. 15; p. 26, 18 ff ., with Theol. Arith., p. 16; p. 27, 1 ff., with Theol. Arith., p. 13; p. 31, 8, with Anatolius and Favonius on the pentad, Macro- bius i. 6, 18, Capella vii. 735, [Plut.] Epit. iii. 14. 1, Philo De mundi opif. 20. 3 De mensibus ii. 12 and De mundi opif. 30-42. 4 Generally there is close correspondence throughout these passages, but Lydus does not preserve as many topics as does Philo, nor at such length. In some places, however, by giving something lost by the others, even Philo, but yet undoubtedly from S, he gives further proof that his source was most comprehensive. Cf. Lydus, p. 35, 2 ff ., with Philo De mundi opif. 41 and Anatolius, p. 36, 15; Lydus, p. 36, 5 ff ., with Anatolius, p. 36, 24. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 109 addition to the many parallels which can only be referred to here, it can be shown that very probably the arithmological block, ii. 4-12, preserves one characteristic feature of arrangement from the original S. The argument is based on comparing such expressions as r) kolt' aiadr] vorirots (cf . c. 34) ; followed by a group of topics. IV. Transition again, and the powers of 7 h> aiadrjTots, with topics. V. Transition, "though it shows so many forms in both bodiless and conceptual things, the nature of 7 extends also over all visible creation. For what is not faXeffSonov ? " Topics follow. VI. Etymology — hrra, o-e(3a/iaVots Kal vorjTOK iiriStiKw- oparrjv airaoav ovoxav, ovpavov Kal yijv rat. Stareivei Si avTrjs i) o'6ai kvkXok, ktX. Kal yfjv, ra iripara tov iravros fyOaxraoa. Anatolius, p. 36, 25 ti yap ov tpiXifSSopov; .... avriKa ^ivra (piXipBofua. tov ovpavov (paaiv tsra SicfcuxrOai kv- Philo Leg. all. i. 4 KAOtf, kt\. ^atpci Sk r) v apidfiup, which matches Capella's omniumque numerorum solam seminarium esse, and that in all three occurs the notion expressed by Favonius pereuntibus aliis quae id recipere possunt immutabile persevered. In this passage Chalcidius cannot be following Adrastus, for the latter, as a Peripatetic, would be likely to state the theme about as Capella has done; in fact, the Aristotelian form adopted here by Capella is quite as much an argument for Adrastean influence as the likeness with Chalcidius noted above. A further characteristic of Capella is to identify each number with some divinity, just as Nicomachus is known to have done, judging from Photius, cod. 187, and the Theologumena Arithmeticae of Iamblichus. Perhaps Capella owes this trait to Nicomachus, for some of the instances are quite remarkable; for example, his identifi- cation of the triad with the Fates, Graces, and quaedam uirgo, quam dicunt caeloque ereboque potentem is matched, as far as the Fates are concerned, by Theol. Arith., page 16, and 'Ek&tti is one of the epithets applied by Nicomachus according to Photius. But these agreements, after all, may be due only to the influence of S, for we have seen above that Capella's identification of 6 with Aphrodite, which might otherwise be regarded as Nicomachean, is proved by the agreement of Lydus to have been part of S. Though Capella himself or his Latin sources have modified them somewhat, more of these identifications may have been in the original S than are generally preserved outside of Capella's own line. Capella, then, seems to be descended from an S document of the Theonian group, more voluminous than Theon, and probably influ- enced by a Latin translation of Adrastus. It cannot be positively 122 Frank Eglbston Robbins shown that Adrastean influence affected more than the parts men- tioned above, and furthermore it is impossible, from Chalcidius, to tell whether Adrastus' commentary on the Timaeus contained a whole arithmology, such as the source of Capella must have been; I am inclined, therefore, to explain the situation by Adrastean influence rather than actual copying of Adrastus. Favonius, too, has the marks of the Theonian branch of the family, but to judge from his account of the birth and ages of man, which is unlike Capella and Chalcidius in phrasing but adds some details to which the name of Hippocrates is affixed, he did not come under Adrastean influence, though his original authority must have been fairly comprehensive. In spite of this some of his chapters are decidedly thin, and seem to have been padded with arithmetical detail, as in the fourth and sixth, or astronomical matter, as in the fourth, fifth, and eighth, foreign to the original S. It is probable, too, that in some details he was influenced by Capella, but further about his sources can hardly be ventured here. I do not intend at this time to add anything about the slighter arithmological sources, such as Plutarch, Vindicianus, and scattered references in the Aristotelian commentaries; but a word may be added concerning Isidore's Liber numerorum. The Scriptural arith- mology which forms a large part of this work is of course outside the field of this discussion; some of it was original, but much more modeled after the quasi-Philonic attempts to apply numerical symbolism to the Bible which were attractive to many early church- men. 1 The non- scriptural part seems to come either from Capella or the latter's source, for sometimes Isidore adds to the topics of Capella. This, however, is outweighed by the fact that Isidore employs whole sentences in the very words of Capella, and the latter's style is unmistakable. To make clearer the general con- clusions of this investigation a diagram showing the descent of the most important members of the S family is appended. 1 Examples are the Expositio in Psallerum of Cassiodorius; Augustine in parts of De civ. Dei, De div. quaest. Ixxxiii, and De musica; Ambrose in De Noe et area 12. 39, De Abr. 2. 9. 65, 2. 11. 80, Exp. in Ev. sec. Luc. vii. 95, 139, 173, and Exp. in Psal. cxviii, pp. 1198A, 1280B Migne. The Tradition of Greek Arithmology 123 Neo-fyitvagofean -JI.S10-350 (com>tl«A Ait's TWit.ftW-n.. •?) ISlOOBE «■ StVlliB 4 616 Fig. 1. — Solid lines represent derivation of documents one from another through either one or several steps. Some lines of descent, about which there is doubt, are marked with a "1". Broken lines are used to show influences which do not amount to incorporation or reproduction. University of Michigan