STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. LAND RECLAMATION IN THE FAYUM UNDER PTOLE- MIES PHILADELPHIA AND EUERGETES I By W. L. Westbbmann CHBONOLOGY The ancient irrigation system of the Nile Valley which Ptolemy Soter found in operation when he took control of Egypt had been developed by a gradual process of evolution which had already covered a period of more than three thousand years before Alexander entered the country. No data remain to us from the Pharaonic period which can give us an insight into the details of canal and embankment construction. Fortune has been kinder to us in the Ptolemaic period. In 1889-90 Mr. Flinders Petrie made an impor- tant discovery of paper coffins at Tell-Gurob, a mound lying south and west of the Bahr-Yusuf (Canal of Joseph) in the angle where it turns sharply northwestward to enter the Fayum. These coffins were found to be manufactured of old papyri glued together. The difficulty encountered in detaching the separate papyri explains the shattered condition of this group of documents, which was published as the famous Petrie Papyri. 1 For our present purpose the important documents are a series of letters from the official correspondence of Cleon and his successor Theodorus, engineers in charge of state building projects, including irrigation, in the Fayum. 2 The private letters which passed between Cleon and various members of his family are among the most appealing documents which have come down to us from antiquity. 3 No one endowed with an imagination and a kindly heart could read the intimate letters of this family 1 Flinders Petrie Papyri. Vols. I and II edited by J. P. Mahaffy; Vol. Ill, by J. P. Mahaffy and J. G. Smyly. Royal Irish Academy, Cunningham Memoirs VIII (1891), IX (1893), XI (1905). Dublin. * P. Pet. II, III. 3 The private letters will be found in best form in S. Witkowski, Epistulae Privatae Graecae, 2d ed. (Leipzig, 1911). The career of Cleon has been sketched sym- pathetically by Wilamowitz, Reden und Vortr&ge (Berlin, 1902), pp. 246-53. A. Bouchfi-Leclercq has reconstructed the whole career of Cleon in an attractive article, "LTngenieur Cleon," Revue des etudes grecques, XXI (1908), 121-52. [Classical Philolooy XII, October, 1917] 426 Land Reclamation in the Fatum 427 without a feeling of deep sympathy for Cleon in the hour of his disgrace and retirement from his high position. Unfortunately the private letters do not concern us here, excepting as we may trace in them the outlines of the public career of Cleon. The official activity of Cleon as engineer {LpxiTeicruv) in the Arsinoite Nome (the Fayum) may be traced, in the correspondence saved to us, from the twenty-seventh year to the thirty-third year of Ptolemy Philadelphus, 258-252 b.c. x The date of the appointment of Theodorus as successor to Cleon is uncertain, although we have an official announcement (date lost) addressed to the oeconomi, nomarchs, royal scribes of the nomes, police officials, comarchs, and village scribes, of the advancement of Theodorus (P. Pet. II, 42 (a), p. 138) from the position of sub- engineer (inrapxireKTuv) to that of full guardianship of the dykes and the control of the irrigation waters. In the year 30 of Philadelphus, 255 B.C., Petechonsis was virapxireiCTUv. Presumably, then, Theod- orus came into that position after the year 255. He appears for the first time as architecton in the year 2 of Euergetes, 245 B.C., 2 is holding that office in the years 241 and 240 B.C., 3 and appears for the last time as architecton, so far as the papyri show, in the year 10, or 237 B.C. 4 The extant papyri falling later than 237 B.C. do not mention the ipxiriKTcav or the inra.pxi-T6K.Tuv. This may, of course, be chance, and the office may have continued for a long time. But the proba- bilities are that it ceased to exist thereafter, because the work was completed. 5 The official activity of Cleon and Theodorus was 1 The memorial addressed by Cleon to Diotimus, P. Pet. II, 13, (17), p. 42, mentions official activities of the year 27 of Philadelphus. I agree with Wilamowitz, Reden und Vortr&ge, p. 249, note 3, as against Wiloken, in identifying this Cleon with the engineer of the entire correspondence. P. Pet. II, 13, (11), p. 39, is of the twenty- eighth year. In P. Pet. Ill, 42, F a, the date must be restored [\]y, the thirty-third year, and in it Cleon still has the official title ipxtriKruv. In the unsettled condition of the dating of regnal years in the third century B.C. I am arbitrarily accepting the later date of the two possibilities offered by Grenfell and Hunt in their table in P. Hib. Appendix III. *P. Pet. 111,43, (2), p. 119. 3 P. Pet. II, 9, (2), (3), (4), pp. 22, 23, and 24. « P. Pet. II, 15, (2), p. 52. For the date, els rb iL, see P. Pet. Ill, 42, (7), p. 131. As a result of the dating els t4 il the dioecetes Eutyches in H. Maspero's list, in Les Finances d'Egypte sous les Lagides, p. 245, is to be definitely placed in the year 10 of Ptolemy III, or 237 B.C. 6 Ulrich Wilcken, GrundzOge und Chrestomathie der Papyruskunde, I, 1, p. 332. 428 W. L. Westebmann apparently confined to the Fayum. We have, as yet, no information about any architecton attached to any other nome than the Arsinoite, nor have we any knowledge of any other original reclamation project from any other nome or period, on any similar scale. 1 The results of the reclamation work accomplished under Cleon and Theodorus are still discernible to the eyes of the archaeologists who have worked in the Fayum. 2 For no remains or articles have been found on the third, or next to the lowest, plateau of the Fayum and none on the lower half of the second plateau, which antedate the reign of Ptolemy Philadelphus. In other words, these portions of the Fayum had no villages upon them before Philadelphus' time, but were still under water. Geographic and archaeological evidence, therefore, prove that these plateaus were laid bare in the third century b.c. The Petrie Papyri have given us the names of the two engineers who directed the important project, with some details as to the methods of work employed in carrying it out. Table I may help to visualize our present knowledge of the chronology of the work as shown in the names of the officials in charge as engineers and sub-engineers. Wherever the official title appears along with the name in the correspondence of any year, that fact is indicated in the table. TABLE I Year Engineer Sub-Engineer B.C. 258 Cleon Cleon Cleon Cleon, title apxtriKruv given Cleon Cleon Cleon, title apxireKTiav given Theodorus Theodorus, title apxtTetcrtav given Theodorus Theodorus, title apxtrdKrwv given Theodorus* Theodorus, title af>x' T *' eT °>i' given 257 256 255 Petechonsis, title vxapxireKratv given 254 253 252 251 ( date in- ) 247 ( definite j 245 TheOdorUS, title iirapxirilcTiay given 241 240 239 237 * In this year Theodorus combined in his person the office of ipxiriKTar and o£«ox6»io5. -P. Pet. II, 9, (5), p. 24. 1 The project described in P. Lille, 1, is for the recovery of waste lands formerly under cultivation, but now unproductive. 2 Grenfell, Hunt, Hogarth, Fayum Towns and Their Papyri (P. Fay.) (London, 1900), pp. 2, 14, 15. Land Reclamation in the Fatum 429 The work of reclamation in the Fayum certainly, therefore, ex- tended over a period of twenty-one years, 258-237 B.C. Witkowski 1 seems to put the beginning of the task about 260 b.c. Bouche- Leclercq ascribes the whole reclamation scheme to Ptolemy Soter and indicates a much earlier date in the reign of Philadelphus 2 for the actual beginning of operations. I have little hesitation in agree- ing with the latter and find several reasons for suggesting 270 B.C. as the latest date which can be considered. In the year 255 B.C. a "Canal of Cleon," named after the engineer, is nearing completion. 3 One must presuppose that several seasons' work had already been done upon this canal, which is a new one, and that the activities of Cleon had been so important in connection with it as to attract his sovereign's attention to the extent of naming the canal in honor of the chief engineer. This would carry the engineering work of Cleon earlier than 260 B.C. Secondly, P. Pet. II, 16, is undoubtedly a letter out of the correspondence of Cleon's family. 4 It mentions events which occurred in the years 265 and 264 and was evidently written in the period 263-260 b.c Even that early Cleon is already close to the king. A more convincing consideration is this. The correspondence of the year 28, or 257 b.c, 6 shows that a certain village in the reclaimed area, named Philoteris, had long since been established, and the land around it brought under cultivation. For even in that year the dykes are distinguished as "new" and "old" dykes. Throughout the Cleon correspondence it is evident that the canals in the reclaimed area were already being used for purposes of irrigation in the years 258-252 b.c. As soon as the size of the lake had been diminished, the reclaimed land was settled with agri- cultural colonists and brought under cultivation as rapidly as the canals could be extended. As a result of this occupation and use, the further extension of canals and dykes must have progressed slowly. New construction and repairs were carried on usually during '"Circa a. 260 magnam Moeridis laous partem sicca vit" — Witkowski, Epist. Privatae Graecae, 2d ed., p. 1. 2 In Revue des Etudes grecqu.es, XXI, 122; cf. P. Fay., p. IS. 3 P. Pet. II, 6, p. 17 : koX trvvreKfoat. rb XoiTrdp ttjs KX&aros 5«fy>vyos. 4 Witkowski, loc. tit., No. 4. 6 P. Pet. Ill, 37. This village has been identified by Grenfell and Hunt, P. Fay., p. 63, and located at the site of the modern village of Wadfa (see map at end of P. Fay.). 430 W. L. Westermann the months Epiph to Athyr, or July to November inclusive. For this was the flood period, and the labor of the farms would then be available for other than agricultural work. Furthermore, as several of the extant contracts for construction work clearly show, work upon dykes and canals in the remaining months of the year tended to impede the regular process of irrigating the land. 1 These are the reasons which make it seem reasonable to stretch the period of this reclamation work backward from 237 to 270 B.C., or perhaps earlier. The work could not have been completed under Philadelphus, nor could it have been carried out speedily, as Grenfell assumed. 2 University op Wisconsin ' P. Pet. II, 9, (4), p. 24: %pyov tva pi) iinepov irl tov iroTioyjoS Tcp&ynaTa initv rapixv 1 - Cf. P. Pet. Ill, 43, Col. II, p. 119, a contract for construction work with the stipulation oi$iv irriKtoXiovres /3p^x el " T V I'h"- * P. Fay., p. 15.