STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. ETHNOLOGY AND THE GOLDEN AGE By George Norun It is the common habit of civilized peoples to assume that the fabric of their customs and institutions represents a departure from a primitive condition or state of nature, and to estimate the value and direction of their mode of life by the contrasts which it presents to the days of long ago. But the picture which is drawn of this state of nature is itself colored in no small degree by the prejudices of the moment either for or against present conditions and tendencies. Those who are intoxicated by the wine of their achievements are prone to think of the natural state as the negation of all the good things which man has won for himself in the course of an ever-forward march, while those who have grown oversensitive to the evils of civilization dream of a lost paradise or a golden age. But in seeking to understand these antithetical points of view, we have to reckon with something more than subjective mood or fancy. Culture theorists of the more sober sort have usually sought some basis of historical reality, some solid ground of fact; assuming that in distant parts of the world, far removed from the currents of civiliza- tion, people remain very much now as they were in the beginning, 1 they have commonly taken as their point of departure, in tracing the course of human development, facts or reported facts about far-away primitive tribes. Professor J. L. Myers in a recent pamphlet 2 has presented a careful study of the influence of ethnology on modern political science, proving, especially for the seventeenth and eight- eenth centuries, that there is a very close relation between the shifting ideas of that period as to the origin and growth of society and the ever-increasing store of information about uncivilized peoples which was opened up by exploration of remote regions of the earth, especially 1 Ae Vilhjalmur Stefanson assumes that he found among the Dolphin and Union Straits Eskimos the conditions of the Stone Age; " My Quest in the Arctic," Harper's Magazine, CXXVI, 512. ' The Influence of Anthropology on the Course of Political Science, University of California Press, February, 1916. [Classical Phtlologtt XII, October, 1917] 351 352 George Norlin the Americas. The first accounts of primitive life, derived from discoverers who brought to these aborigines "not peace but a sword," 1 led to the view of man in his natural state which we see in Shake- speare's Caliban and Hobbes's wretched creature "poor, nasty, and brutish, in continual feare and danger of violent death" — a concep- tion which held the boards until the Jesuit Fathers, approaching the Indians as human beings like themselves, and not seldom meet- ing with response of docile affection and loyalty, began in their letters home to contrast the simple virtues of these children of nature with the vices of European civilization, and so prepared the way for the ideal savage of Pope and Rousseau. 2 We have here, if I am not mistaken, an instructive parallel to the influences which determined the course of Culturgeschichte in ancient' Greece. When the Hellenes established the outposts of their civiliza- tion among the hostile tribes which bordered the Mediterranean, and especially on the coasts of what they at first called the Unfriendly Sea, they must have seen in the savage life which opposed and threatened them mainly the dark obverse of their own brighter culture. 3 Their tales of cave-dwelling, man-eating monsters reflect something of this early experience ; 4 and as late as Herodotus we find the tendency to dwell, by way of contrast, on the savage customs of the un-Greek world, 5 notably of the northern barbarians. 6 It was inevitable that the Greeks should think of such revolting practices as human sacrifice and cannibalism which they found still existing among uncivilized peoples 7 as survivals from a primitive condition which they in their forward progress had left behind them, and that they should look on Hellenism, especially in the years before the 1 Myers, p. 2. 2 Lavisse, Hist, de France, VIII, 2 Partie, p. 308: "Avant lui [Rousseau], les mis- sionaires Jesuits du Paraguay avaient ecrit des Lettrea ou ils opposaient les vertus de leurs catechumenes aux vices des civilises, et repandu en Europe des prejuges sur la superiority de l'homme sauvage." 3 See arguments drawn by geographers like Apollodorus from the term A|e»o5, in Strabo vii. 3. 7; and Gilbert Murray's "Greece and the Progress of Man" in The Rise of the Greek Epic. < Berard, Les Phiniciens et VOdyssee, II, 175, 245; Maine, Ancient Law, p. 120. " See especially iii. 38; and Bury, Ancient Greek Historians, p. 44. • Book iv. ' Herod, iv. 103, 106; Pseudo-Platonic Minos 315 B. Ethnology and the Golden Age 353 first flush of their triumph in the Persian "Wars had faded, as embody- ing all that was best in human achievement. 1 The issue of that con- flict was, indeed, the final vindication of a mode of life which had been till then by no means unprecarious. In Athens, above all, the past misgivings and hesitations to which the pages of Herodotus bear ample witness now gave way to that exaltation of spirit and confident pressing forward to the future which ushered in her Golden Age; 2 and so, perhaps, it is no accident that Aeschylus, who fought at Marathon and wrote the Persae, was, so far as we know, the first Greek to bring into clear relief the idea of human progress from a helpless, brutish existence to the arts, of life, 3 or that Sophocles, who as a boy had led the victory chant after Salamis, was inspired to hymn the marvelous conquests of man over the blind forces of a reluctant world. 4 Henceforth the deliverance of man from savagery to civilization by the grace of Prometheus, or Palamedes, or by his own upward striving becomes a recurring theme of the Athenian drama. 5 The latest example of it in the tragic poets is a fragment of Moschion 6 where we are well on the way to the organic development theory 7 of the fifth book of Lucretius : Time was when mortals lived the life of beasts And dwelt in mountain grots and sunless caves; For sheltering houses they had none as yet Nor spacious city strong with masoned towers. 1 So in Euripides, Orestes, Koivit 'EW^vaiv v6pos (495), saves the world from the brutish violence of barbarism, to BrfpLwSet tovto KaX juaup6pot/ icaiuv, $ xal 77j!» xal ]ri\6is SXXuir' 'ael (523, 524) Cf . Dummler, Prolegomena zu Platan's Stoat, pp. 47-49. •For the psychological effects of the defeat of Persia, see Arist. Pol. 1341a. 30; Diodorus 12. 1. 3, 4. 3 Prom. Bound, 462 ff . Xenophanes anticipates Aeschylus in a brief couplet : oiStoi dir ipxv s rriyra. BtoX Bvrrrour tiir^Seifax dXXd xp6"V tfrounrts iipevpttrKowiv &/j.eivoi> Frag. 18 in Diels Frag, der VorSokratiker. The idea of improvement in human con- ditions was, of course, implicit in culture-hero myths; it may possibly have been a part of epic tradition, but the dating of the Homeric Hymn to Hephaestus is pure guesswork. < Antigone 332-64. •Nauck, Trag. Graec. Frag., pp.59, 236, 542, 771, 931; Eur. Suppl. 201 ff.; Meineke, Poet. Com. Graec., pp. 706, 707. • Nauck, p. 813. 7 Benn, Greek Philosophers, II, 99. 354 George Nohlin No curving plows then broke the swarthy glebe, The nurse of corn, nor pruning iron bestowed Its care on teeming rows of vines; but Earth Was waste and barren, yielding up no fruit. 1 Men fed on human flesh by slaughtering men; And Law lay prostrate; Violence sat the throne With Zeus; the strong devoured the helpless weak. But soon as Time, which brings all things to birth And fosters all, had wrought again a change In human life, whether by lending them Prometheus' wit or sheer Necessity Or Nature's self, through long experience, To be their guide, divine Demeter's gift Was found, a gentle sustenance; and found Was also Bacchus' pleasant spring; the land, Unsown before, was plowed by spans of oxen; Cities now they girt with walls and houses built, And changed their savage life to gentle ways. Thenceforth the law enjoined to hide the dead In tombs and give to the unsepulchered Their due of dust, and not to leave exposed Reminders of their former ghastly feast. 2 Moschion's sketch dates probably from the fourth century, but, although the notion of progress upward from savagery recurs in this period and later, 3 it is especially characteristic of the pride of achieve- ment and buoyant optimism which followed the Persian Wars.* 1 Reading noi Tpot\v ipipovaa. * It is significant that every detail of this picture of primitive savagery may be supplied from the wild tribes described by Herodotus in his fourth book : the Troglo- dytes dwell in caves and are in other ways little removed from animality (183) ; the Scythians have no walled cities or fixed abodes (46); nor do they plow (19); the Androphagoi are the most savage of human creatures; they are without restraint of any principle of right or law, and feed on men (106). It is, of course, not necessary to assume that Moschion took his colors directly from Herodotus; the essential point is that such details of ethnology were available in the fifth century and probably earlier. Gomperz, Griechische Denker, I, 312 (also Dummler, op. tit., p. 28), derives Moschion's sketch directly from Protagoras' Tlepl tt)s 4v <£/>XB KfraoTdaeas, but Protagoras may have been indebted to Herodotus, perhaps "talked with him about ethnology at Thurii" as Gomperz fancies (I, 353); cf. also, Nestle, Herodot's Verhdltnis zur Philosophic und Sophistik, pp. 17, 18. •See Isocrates Panegyricus 28; Aristotle Pol. 1269 A 5; Diodorus i. 8; Delphic Inscription in Bulletin de Corr. Hellenique, 1900, p. 96; and Rohde, Der griechische Roman, p. 217. • Gomperz, I, 311, 312. Ethnology and the Golden Age 355 Toward the end of the fifth century there is a marked cooling down of enthusiasm for things as they are 1 and, from this time on, in increasing disenchantment, a growing conviction, indeed, that civili- zation has lost the way; that it represents an aberration, a xapln- fiaais, from the right path; and that, after all that may be said for the present mode of life, its outstanding facts are greed, luxury, and man's inhumanity to man. This reaction of feeling is strikingly instanced in the disposition of the. philosophers, beginning with Socrates, to hold aloof from political life and to live more and more in the realm of the ideal, 2 and, above all, in the cry, "Back to Nature," which became the dominating idea of the Cynics and, after them, of the Stoic school for centuries. Nature is now no longer "red in tooth and claw with ravin," but is the wise teacher and sure guide which erratic society has ignored or contemned ; and the natural man is no longer the savage "nasty and brutish," but a simple and kindly being, having but little and that little in common with others, and with that little content; and he is to be found only in a far-away past, a Hesi- odic Golden Age, or in a far-away present which civilization has not touched and spoiled. Such reversions to Hesiodic pessimism were evidently in the air before the fifth century closed! 3 Perhaps they start with the Sophist Hippias whom Gomperz regards as the precursor of the Cynics and Stoics. 4 At any rate, they are reflected in Plato, 5 who, in certain moods, associates the virtues of temperance and justice with primi- tive conditions of a bygone age. In the Laws* he pictures the early state of society as one of pastoral simplicity where all have enough to satisfy their necessary wants, but none is rich or poor, and so there is no occasion for envy or insolence or injustice to arise. In another passage of the same dialogue 7 he refers to the view that, of old, men 'The after-glow of the triumph over Persia lingers fifty years, according to Diodorus xii. 1. 3, 4. » Plato Rep. 496 D, E. 3 Pherecretes' Ayptot seems to have been a burlesque on already current idealiza- tions of uncivilized life. Plato Prolog, 327 D; see Nestle, op. tit,, p. 27. • Gri&hiscke Denher, I, 348. 'Barker, The Political Thought of Plato and Aristotle, pp. 151, 190. • 679 A-E; cf. Laws 713. ' 782 A-D. 356 George Norlin lived on the fruits of the earth, abstaining from flesh in Orphic fashion; and in the Republic, in which Socrates sketches the origin of a city in a state of health, he prescribes a diet exclusively vege- tarian — bread and cakes and fruit spread out on the grass; .the people reclining on boughs of myrtle and yew, wholesomely enjoying the frugal fare and each other's pleasant company, sound of limb and long of life and transmitting to their children an idyllic existence like their own. To this Glaucon objects that Socrates would not do differently if he were prescribing for a community of swine, and insists that people should live in a civilized manner with couches and tables and the dishes and desserts of a modern bill of fare. "Very good," says Socrates, "we are considering, it seems, not the growth of a healthy city merely, but of a city luxurious and inflamed. I dare say it is not a bad idea for thus we shall discover the rise of justice and injustice." 1 This notion that the fever of modern life sets in with the departure from the simple diet of the fruits of the earth is the basis of the CuUurgeschichie of the geographer Dicaearchus, if we may trust Porphyry's brief summary of his History of Greek Civilization. Men lived in the beginning like Hesiod's Golden Race; they possessed none of the arts, not even that of tilling the soil; they subsisted on nature's food, fruits and herbs, without want and without surfeit, and therefore in a state of health, leisure, peace, and amity. There was no struggle for existence, no ground for strife, no cause for war. Then came the pastoral stage when people began to own property, to eat flesh, and to live luxuriously. Then arose envy, dissension, wars, which increased in the more elaborate life of the agricultural stage.* Dicaearchus was known to Rousseau and perhaps influenced him,* but the exact analogue to the "Back to Nature" cult in the eighteenth century is to be found in the teaching, and apparently in the practice, of the Cynics, notably Antisthenes and Diogenes. l Bep. 372 B-E; and Adam's Commentary; cf. Myers, Herodotus and Anthro- pology, p. 163. But Plato does not commit himself to this point of view; his sympathy with it in this passage is playful, not to say ironical (j"Mimmler, op. tit., pp. 61, 62); here, as elsewhere, the dramatist-philosopher eludes classification. See Paul Shorey "Plato, Lucretius, and Epicurus," Harvard Studies in Clots. Philology, XII, 208. » Miiller, Frag. Hist. Grace., II, 233. * Pohlmann, GeschichU des anliken Kommunismus und Sozialismus. I. 113. Ethnology and the Golden Age 357 Like Rousseau they condemned Prometheus as the great enemy of mankind. 1 The gods had withheld fire because they desired that men should continue in the ideal state of the Golden Age. The arts and institutions of civilization have enslaved us to effeminacy, luxury, and injustice. Hardiness, self-sufficiency, and spontaneous kindness are to be found only in the natural state or among the lower animals.' For the Cynics drew lessons, not only from uncivilized people, but from the animal world; like Walt Whitman, they — Could turn and live with animals, they are so placid and self-contained. They do not sweat and whine about their condition. They do not lie awake in the dark and weep for their sins. Not one is dissatisfied, not one is demented with the mania of owning things. Not one kneels to another nor to his kind that lived thousands of years ago. Not one is respectable or unhappy over the whole earth.* From the Cynics the doctrine is taken over by the Stoics. Zeno, the founder of the school, defined the ideal society as a state of nature where the characteristic features of the modern city are conspicu- ously absent: it has no temples, no gymnasiums, no law courts, no money, no slaves, no private property even in women and chil- dren; 4 and it becomes a commonplace of Stoic thought that the course of civilization has been steadily away from the natural kind- ness and contentment of the Golden Age. Aratus, for example, draws a pretty picture of the good old days when men had not yet sailed the sea in search of gain, but were satisfied to till the soil and to subsist on the produce of their fields. The spirit of Justice then lived on earth, ever present with men and ever heeded by them, and there was no strife, no lawsuits, no slaughter. In the less righteous Silver Age Justice retired to the mountains, whence she came down at evening to chide the people for their sins and to warn them of evils to come. When the cruel race of bronze was born, which was the first to forge the sword and slay oxen for food, 8 she withdrew 1 Gompers, op. cii., II, 117; Dio Chrya. Or. vi. 25, 30. * Dio Chrys. Or. vi. 21-34. » Ibid., xl. 32. * Diog. Lacrt. vii. 33. ' See Plutarch's use of these lines in his sketch of the progress of cruelty from the killing of animals to the wholesale slaughter of men in war, Htpl 2apicoTr(av vopl/xuiv. > Nauck, 196. Ethnology and the Golden Age 361 kindly to strangers, who do not stir the soil with plow or hoe, but live on the natural produce of the earth. 1 Even Herodotus, who sees in the northern tribes mainly unre- generate savages, 2 makes exceptions of the Argippaeans, whose food is the fruit of trees, who wrong no man, and are wronged by none; 3 and of the Issedonians, who, save for one savage custom, are said to be just, and to treat their women as equals. 4 The geographer Ephorus, who was apparently the first to describe the Scythian tribes at any length, contrasted two types of these northern barbarians, the savage 'kvdpwTroayoi and a sequestered tribe of nomads whom he identifies with Homer's ra\aKra<£d7ot.. The latter he describes as dwelling in wagons, abstaining from animal food, harming no living thing, having all things in common, even wives and children, waging no war against others, and free from attack because they possessed nothing to tempt aggression. 5 The philosopher Posidonius, whose interests embraced also geography and ethnology, devoted much attention to the Mysians, their pious scruples against taking life, their diet of milk and honey and cheese, their moral simplicity and innocence, 8 and appears to have drawn from them arguments for his theory of the original state of man in the Golden Age. 7 There were not wanting those who, as Apollodorus, took a con- sistent view of savagery and dismissed such accounts as poetic moon- shine. 8 Against these skeptics Strabo takes up the cudgels and challenges them to explain the fact that some of the nomad Scythians of his own day still preserved very much the same manner of life as that ascribed to them by earlier authorities, notwithstanding that by this time Greek civilization had spread its degenerative influence i It is tempting to take Eumenides, 706, 061-' iv XxiSauriy oirre TOKovot tv rArois to mean that Soythia and Sparta are the traditional homes of justice, as do Riese (Die Idealisirung der NaturtSlker des Nordens in dear griechischen und rBmischen Literatur, p. 11) and Pohlmann (op. tit., I, 134), but surely the. significance of these places is here purely geographical ; cf . Soph. Oed. Col., 694. *iv. 127. »iv. 23. «iv. 26. « Mulle'r, Ft. Hist. Grace., I, 257, p. 257; frags. 76, 78. 'Strabo vii. 3. 3. ' Sehmekel, Die Phil. d. Mita. Stoa., pp. 287-88. s nXdiriiara, Strabo vii. 3. 7, 10. 362 George Norlin to almost all peoples of the world and infected them, especially where they had come into contact with the sea, with the poison of greed and inhumanity. 1 It is easy to read both in and between the lines of Strabo's extended discussion of this question that his interest in it is not merely that of a dispassionate ethnographer, but almost that of a zealot who is defending an important article of faith. 2 His earnest- ness and heat betray as evidently as if he had said it in so many words that he is here the spokesman of a sect who cherished the nomad Scythians as a pure type of man in the natural state and derived from them the principal argument for their belief in the degenerative influence of civilization.* If, furthermore, we take the outstanding features in the descrip- tion of these northern tribes — a pastoral or prepastoral life; a frugal, mainly a vegetarian, diet; community of property or no property at all; community of wives and children; a peaceful, orderly, and kindly existence — and compare them with the characteristics ascribed by the philosophers to the original state of man in the Golden Age, the correspondence is too exact to be accidental. But to what extent the facts suggested theory or theory supplied the facts is, perhaps, open to discussion. The historicity of the milk-eating, peace-loving nomads is commonly doubted; Rohde, for example, apparently treats them as a product of the idealizing imagination and thinks them as unreal as the Hyperboreans; 4 and our « vii. 3. 7. » vii. 3. 7,11: arXovvrdrovs re yip afrrais yv/d^ofity gal tJ/ko-tb KaxiyrptxtU tirrtKtcripovt T« iroKb i)/iQr Kal avrapKtartpovs. » i SoK€i fiir tit THitpbrrrra avrrtlvtiy oia((>6tlpii Si to IjSr) Kal vouuXlav ami rijt A*\&ri)Tos . . tle-aytt (vii. 3. 7, 22) reveals the Stoic. * Der oriech. Roman., p. 217. Rhode follows Riese, who contends that the tradi- tion of .the nomad Scythians begins with Homer, whose fancy sketched the first outline of a milk-eating, just-dealing, northern race, and that henceforth the Greek imagination filled in the sketch with various ideals, mainly Pythagorean and Platonics (op. cit., pp. 20, 21). Riese dismisses the researches' of Ephorus as bookish and second-band. Neumann, however, regards Ephorus as a trustworthy authority, who may idealize the customs of the Scythians, but always does so on a basis of fact (op cit I, 315 ff.). The crux of the problem is the community of wives and children. This according to Riese is read into the institutions of the Scythians from Plato. But, in the first place, the limited communism of Plato is not the communism attributed to the Scythians; and, in the next place, Plato cannot be held responsible for the sexual Ethnology and the Golden Age 363 own view is likely to be determined by a more or less a priori assump- tion of how the Stone Man and his later representatives should have behaved in order not to disturb a consistent plan of evolution. But we can at any rate be sure of these points : that the nomad Scythians of Ephorus were regarded by the Greeks generally as historical; 1 that the preponderance of ancient authority is in favor of this view; and that there is ethnologically no improbability in attributing to uncivilized tribes of that time the unspoiled simplicity and the sub- stantial virtues which Stefanson found in the Eskimos, who had never seen a white man, and which led him to infer that "the hand of evolution had written the Golden Rule in the hearts otthe contempor- aries of the mammoth millenniums before the Pyramids were built." 2 We are, then, in accord with the testimony of antiquity as well as with modern experience in concluding that the Greeks in their contact with uncivilized peoples found two sets of facts — one which supported the view that primeval man existed in a slough of brutish promiscuity, more or less idealized, ascribed by Herodotus to the Auseans (iv. 180) ; to the Agathyrsians (iv. 104); and to the Massagetae (i. 216). Furthermore, it is quite clear from the last reference that the common Greek view, from which Herodotus here dissents, attributed this custom to the Scythians as did Ephorus and later writers generally (see, fr. ex., Nicolaus Damascenus, 123; Muller, III, 460). Indeed, such contrasts to their own marriage customs the Greeks found in many parts of the world ; other examples are reported by Aristotle, Pol. 1262 A 19; Xanthus, frag. 28; Theo- pompus, frag. 222; Nicolaus, frags. Ill, 135, in Muller, Frag. Hist. Graec; and Diodorus ii. 58 — enough to give plausibility to the dramatic exaggeration in Eur. Andromache, 173 ff . toioutoi" Tar rb fiippapov yhot tar-ftp rt Svyarpl Tats re iirirpl piyrvrai KbpT) r' adc\