STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE ASSUMED DURATION OF THE WAR OF THE ILIAD By John. A. Scott Professor J. Van Leeuwen (Mnemosyne, XXXIV (1906), 193 ff.; XXXVIII, 396 ff.; and republished as part of chap. I in his Com- mentationes Homericae, Leiden, 1911) advanced with convincing arguments and great assurance the theory that the Iliad describes not the end of a long war, but a campaign embracing only a single summer. The Greeks, he believes, having ravaged the islands which lay along their course, and having sacked the allied towns in the Troad and adjacent regions, prepared to storm the walled city itself. The Trojans, as soon as they learned of the landing and intended assault, formed an army and advanced to meet the Greeks; the action described in the Iliad immediately follows, and in a few weeks the war is at an end. The purpose of the present investigation is to offer a new study of the Iliad with reference to the theory just stated. It must be said in advance that definite chronological references in the Iliad are surprisingly few, and that most of the scenes of the poem are as undatable on internal evidence as the soliloquies of Hamlet, or the Sermon on the Mount. The definite references are practically all confined to the action or speeches just before the preparations for fighting begin. These references are not dragged in, but we learn as if by accident that the army has already been at Troy for many years, and we know that the action which is to follow is the culmination of a long struggle. The artistic effect of giving this definite information just in advance of the fighting is very great. The only such references are the following: Agamemnon in the speech in which he attempts to arouse his men to action by pretend- ing to discourage them says: B 134: ivvfa Si) fttftdaai Aids fi€yd\ov ivtavrol Kal Si) Sovpa aearpre vtutv ko.1 (nrapra XiKwraf The fact that the war has been a long one and that it would be a shame to have waited so many years and then return home with [Classical Philology VIII, October, 1913] 445 446 John A. Scott their task not yet accomplished is the burden of the speech of Odysseus: B 295: ypZv 8' eivaTos sort irtpirpowimv cwauros ivdddt /u/jofovrta-a-i. also his arguments in the same speech based on the omen of the bird and her young destroyed by the serpent : B 313: 6ktu>, arap p.rfn\p Ivarr) ty, rj T*Kt riicm. [repeated in 326]. 327 : pd^ovrai- 115: [Agamemnon says:] iirtl iroXvv 3>\vra AaoV 120: /xai/r o«to> TOiwSe roo-ovSe Tt Xaov 'A^aiSf atrpr/KTov w6X.tfi.ov iro\ep.i£tiv r/Sk /m^ea-Oat Avopacri iravpoTtpoun, TtXos 8' ov irto ti 7re<£avTai- 161 : 'Apyttrjv 'HJX.£vt)v, fjs tivaca iroAAoi 'A^oiSv iv Tpoig okoXovto kt\- 272 : (o jroirot, rj Sr) p.vpC 'O8v<70"evs eo-6\a topyi jSovAas T i£dp)(u>v ayaOas iro\.€p.6v re Kopvcpov jroAvoaxpuv 'Apjya .... ot 8t) vvv eaTai l yvvaud n-oAw \p6vov aAyea iraxr^av After the fighting has once begun the chronological references are few and vague, since each act is represented as taking place for the first time. To refer to an act as habitual, well-known, or customary would rob the poet of the chance to describe it. Unless the war has lasted long, these following verses would be without meaning: E 788 : opa p.iv «s jroAep-ov iriaXio-Ktro Sure 'A^iAAeus, o£8e TroTt TpSts irpo irvXamv Aap8WiaW €purrt, KaTa&vtjrSiv avOpunrotv; ov p,ev yap ttot oirunra (W.XV * vt f "Siavetpg to irpCv [Words of Diomede.] Z419: Andromache tells how her father was slain by Achilles, his dead body treated with honor, a mound erected in his memory, and elms encircled this mound: wepl Se wreKias epa 8' eya> p-er' 'A^atoio-iv 7roAep.i£ov, ovk iO(kt(TKe pa)(rfv airo rectos 6pvvp.iv 'ExTaip, AAA ocrov es Siauas re TrvAas ko.1 x?/s dvraftov ovS* ocra (paalv IXiov iKTTJcrOai., evvaiop.evov irroXUBpov, to izpiv eV tlpyjvrfi, irplv e\6ttv utas 'Aj(aubv This depletion of Trojan resources can hardly be explained except on the assumption that the city has undergone a long siege. In N 95 ff. Poseidon tries to arouse the Greeks by contrasting the present aggressive attitude of the Trojans with their former policy of avoiding a struggle. When Meriones starts for his tent to get fresh arms he meets Idomeneus who says (N 259) : " You will find an abundance of spears 450 John A. Scott here in my tent, spears I have seized from fallen Trojans, for since 1 joined in the combat there has come to my hand an abundance of arms of every sort." To whom Meriones replies: N 267 : Kai Tot ipxu. irapd T« xXurig Kal vrji /xsXatvrj ttoXX evapa Tpuxav He adds that his bravery has been seen by Idomeneus on many an occasion. As neither of these warriors has thus far more than fleshed his sword in the action of the Iliad, where did they capture all this armor and in what battles did they perform these mighty exploits ? When Polydamas urges the Trojans to return to the city and endure the siege, Hector shows that already they are so impoverished that their only hope is in driving the invaders out of the Troad; a changed policy is thus obligatory: 2 287 : 5 °" lro> K£Kopij<70£ teA.ficj'oi ivSo6i irvpymv; ■jrplv /xkv yap Hpidpoto irokai p.tpoires avOpumoi TravTcs /xv6fs, irpmrov xnrrjv^Trj, rov trip ya.ptvna.Tt) ij/8»7 - Hermes, then, assumed the character of a youth of hardly more than eighteen years. He assures Priam that he is the son of Polyctor and a soldier of Achilles, also that he was selected among seven brothers to follow with the Greeks to Troy. "How," asks Van Leeuwen, "can a soldier who has been nearly ten years in the field give the impression that he is a lad in his early young manhood?" Ineptus fere mihi ipse videor talia rogans (Mnem., XXXIV, 202). Even worse is the case of Helen who says of herself that she is now in her twentieth year at Troy (0 765). Paris, however, had told her but a few days previously that he had never had stronger passion for her than at that moment (r 442 ff.). The veteran Hellenist and critic can never restrain his mirth when he thinks of her years and his passion. Quis sine risu legal fi 765 collatis F U2-446 (Mnem., XXXIV, 194). These two illustrations show an utter failure to grasp one of the fundamental laws of Homeric poetry, namely, when once an actor is given or supposed to have a definite age or form he maintains each unchanged throughout. Telemachus is introduced in the first book of the Odyssey as a young man just reaching his majority, ready and anxious to assume the duties of manhood; but nine years previous to the time assumed as the setting for this first book Odys- seus meets his own mother, Anticleia, in his visit to Hades; Tele- machus by actual counting is at that time not over twelve years of 454 John A. Scott age, yet he is just as old as he was when introduced in the early scenes of the poem: \ 185: Tj/Ac/miX 05 rip-evea. vep-erai (cat oturas eicras ScuWrat, as iireoiK€ SucaoTrdAov avSp' aXeyvvav In this same scene in Hades, Agamemnon refers to Telemachus as a man among men: A. 449: os tov vw ye hit avSpmv i£a apid/x<2- These evident contradictions in the age of Telemachus are no proof of independent authorship or interpolations, but show strict adher- ence to epic usage. 1 A striking example of chronological inconsist- ency is furnished by Elpenor, the companion of Odysseus, who, heavy with wine, forgot to go down from the roof on the ladder and so lost his life, and who is spoken of as immature and "very young" (ve&Taros, i 552). Yet he must have been an old and seasoned vet- eran, since he has seen ten years' service at Troy, as is implied in all parts of the narration of Odysseus, and more than a year has elapsed since the departure of the Greeks. Hermes appeared to Priam in exactly the same form as he appeared to Odysseus in k 279. When Hermes came to Priam he came in the form he was wont to assume when appearing to mortals, and when he left he did not assume some other appearance. The poet had no intention of giving the god the form and attributes of the son of Polyctor; his attention was fixed only on describing Hermes. The poet of the Odyssey regards Penelope as the mother of an adult son; the father and husband has been gone for nearly twenty years, hence he has been as long from Penelope as Helen has been at Troy, when she laments for fallen Hector. In the case of Penelope the twenty years cannot be called in question, and she is surrounded by youthful suitors, while in the Iliad Paris must have aged along with Helen, yet the passions of the suitors seem like the emotions of Paris: a 365: iravres ff ^pj/cavro irapal Aex«crcri ic\i0rjvai- v 8* avTow Xvto yovvwr, ipio 8* apa Ov/wv t0f\x$ew 1 Altendorf, Aesthetischer Kommentar zur Odyssee, p. 41, has an unusually good discussion of the character of Telemachus in Books one and eleven. Assumed Duration of the War of the "Iliad" 455 The chronology of the Iliad may be wrenched by the excision of a few verses, but no amount of excision in the Odyssey can make a young woman out of Penelope, when a grown son stands at her side. If the age of Helen makes the passion of Paris a subject of mirth to Professor Van Leeuwen, what hilarity he must find in the story of Penelope and the suitors! The poet of the Odyssey builds on the chronology of the Iliad in determining the years of Nestor. In the Iliad he is now ruling in the third generation, in the Odyssey the rule of the third generation is completed (A 252; y 245). Nestor has added to his years, but has grown no older. The repeated references in the Iliad to the feebleness of Nestor because of his age presume that the end of his strength if not of his life is near, yet he shows no decline in the story of the Odyssey. Nestor is there the wise and intelligent host, he plans the sacrifice, begins the rites with water for the hands, makes use of the ceremonial grains, cooks the meat on spits, pours out the offering of wine, and arranges the journey which Telemachus is about to make to Sparta. The Nestor of the Iliad remains unchanged in body and mind. How does Helen appear in the Odyssey f Is the charm all gone ? Here she cannot hide her age, since we have seen the marriage of Hermione and Hermione's younger paternal brother, Megapenthes. Hermione's wedding has been long delayed, so that we hardly dare to estimate the years of her mother. Whom does Helen resemble when she appears in the Odyssey, Hecuba or Tithonus ? 8 121 : ck 8' EX.€vrj OaXdfioio OvwStos vxjjop6oio fjXvOev, 'Aprt/juSi xpv incvui- This is the very goddess to whom the maiden, Nausicaa, is likened both by the poet and by Odysseus (f 102, 150). It never occurred to the poet that she was growing old, or could grow old. Just as she first appears in the Iliad hard at work with her needle, so here she comes in as the industrious wife busy with her wool and her spinning. This little trait of industry common to both poems is a neat indica- tion of a single conception and a single author. Helen had not aged; she was still in the poet's vision the youthful beauty whose charms 456 John A. Scott had brought to Sparta a Trojan prince, and for whose recovery a race dared risk a foreign war. To sit down with paper and pencil for the purpose of auditing her charms by her years is to fail to appre- ciate the very essence of Homeric poetry. These illustrations are taken from the Odyssey, since the few days involved in the action of the Iliad give no space for testing the lapse of time. The Iliad and Odyssey were recited before the same audience and observed the same poetic proprieties, so we cannot assume that anything which would have been absurd in the Iliad would be acceptable in the Odyssey. Many events, such as the muster of the troops, the report of Iris- Polites as to the multitude of the Greeks, the duel between Paris and Menelaus, the Teichoshopia, and the advice of Nestor in regard to military tactics, do not strictly belong to the tenth year of a siege, but the poet must give some impression of the appearance of the army, of the tactics to be employed, of the regal bearing of Agamem- non, of the beauty of Helen and her mental attitude regarding her present and former husband, 1 and also the contrast between Paris and Menelaus, but since he did not describe the earlier years of the war he must insert them in the only part he did describe. The change in the character of the war was due to the success of the Greeks in intercepting the Trojan supplies and it was the genius of the poet which substituted the "Wrath" with its personal hero for the impersonal causes which forced the Trojans to assume the offensive. Northwestern University 1 Professor Rossner, Beitrdge zur Losung der homeriscfie Frage, Magdeburg, 1913, p. 54, shows that the purpose of the Teichoshopia is to picture the mental attitude of Helen when she sees the leaders of the Greeks, and also that the duel is not to settle an issue, but to show us Menelaus and Paris; hence these character-sketches are timeless and are not out of place in the tenth year of the war.