STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 232 Book Reviews Kenrd Aristoteles die sogenanrde tragische Katharsis f Von Heinbich Otte. Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1912. Pp. 59. M. 1.60. The tardiness of this review was partly unavoidable and partly due to a desire to weigh again carefully the argument of Margoliouth, whom Otte dismisses very curtly. Otte follows and enlarges upon Joseph Egger in his destructive criticism of Bernays and he is not more successful than was Knoke. It is a beaten road, beginning with attacks upon details, such as Bernays' effort to distinguish trddri from iraOrj/juxTa and ending in much ridicule of a theory that reduces the theater to a psychiatric asylum. It is a relief to know from Margoliouth that at least Bernays' "personal character .... is pleasing." But a metaphor is not an enunciation of Euclid and the essential consideration is whether Bernays was right or wrong in assuming that Aris- totle coined a metaphor from the treatment of religious ecstasy. The fact that Aristotle uses the word xoflapcris for the first time without the article and without comment (Pol. 1341a23), as Otte notes, may simply mean that the reference to such treatment is too obvious to require emphasis. If Aristotle prefixes the article to Kddapaw in the famous locus following (1341639), it is only what we should expect; and here no juggling of words can destroy the conviction that he was as conscious of difficulty in the idea to be conveyed as of novelty in his use of the word. He can pause only to explain it dirAuis, but he will explain it later on more clearly iv to« irtpl iroo/i-uojs. Now Otte finds it necessary for his argument to adopt the theory that Aristotle's reference is to a later discussion which he made or intended to make in the Politics of the use of poetry for irarfkia, Svayoyytj (Unterhaltung) , avecris «oi ■nji (TWTovlas avdnava-K. He goes even farther and supplies for us this missing doctrine of the social function of tragedy. The udda/xTis of tragedy intended in the Politics is summed up, in short, in the verse of Timocles, rcdvrjKt tiKt. In the Poetics no explanation occurs, simply because Aristotle is using KaOapa-is in a sense understood by all Greeks and requiring no comment. What then does the definition of tragedy come to be ? Mt/wjo-is is the owracris tS>v trpaypArmv, irepaivoviX.dv6pu>wov (1453a3) are not enough; indeed, the playwright must sift out Book Reviews 233 all fuapd from his material, and this sifting out is the KaBapcrm of the Poetics, and would be so understood by any Greek reader. Why not, we ask, add to, akoya to the matter which requires to be sifted out ? Because by reference to a passage in the Odyssey, another in the Oedipus Tyrannus, another in the Phaedo you shall see that /xiapos suggests itself to the mind as the opposite of Kadapos, and in the light of this possibility compare oi 6f$ov Sto fufirjcreais rjhovrjv (1453612) by a reference to the Rhetoric 137164 ff.: irav o av ev /UfirtfLtvov fj k&v rj fit] iJ8i> avrb to p4.1x.rjp.ivov. ov yap an tovtib yaipei, aXka. o-vWoyurfios icrrtv on tovto iicavo (Lore pja.v6d.vuv ti o-vp.pa.lvu (note particularly the next sentence)! So that the oIkoo, ySovr) of the drama lies simply in a "convincing" presentation of a terrible and pitiful theme. Indeed, this is putting it more than fairly. It would be truer to say that it lies in mere vraisemblance. In short, if one submits Otte's main position to the same torture that he applies to Bernays', he might ask how impressing pity and fear upon the incidents may be said to sift out fuapd. By squeezing them out ? It is now in order for some victim of this greatest literary crux to work out an ingenious thesis from this pavOdvecv ti o-vpfiatva by starting with Poetics 1448616 and comparing Politics 1339a35-36, 1341a23-24, 134166. But, before setting out in pursuit of this will-o'-the-wisp, let anyone so tempted examine Politics 1340al-14 and ask himself whether this is not a preliminary sketch of Ka.8apo-K. To this great chapter of the Politics all argument must return. One line is sufficient to upset the whole argument of Margoliouth, i.e., bpav el in; 234 Book Reviews Kol irpos to rflos owraVa (^ iwvcriKrj) koi irpos T^v ifru^v. The iraBr] of the melanchohc men of genius, and of all of us in minor or occasional degree, as described in the Problems, § 30, are o-a>/uaruca. When Kadapms is resumed in the seventh chapter of Politics v, the language is metaphorical throughout. Now if Problems, § 30, suggests any treatment of these iraOrj, it is a bottle of good wine, the fiedy of Politics 1339a20. Why turn to passages in Hippocrates for treatment which when examined contain no idea of homeopathy ? As in the Problems, it is a matter of "feeding up" the element in defect, except in cases where, as a modern would put it, the vitality is too much depleted. The truth is that these irdOri on this higher plane are not to be extinguished, or purged away, or even purged themselves, but to be given their proper rpotp-q, which produces a high and legitimate delight, something very different from the v