STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 227 Spo/miov of the Alcestis, is very far from constituting substantial evidence. A few obvious slips like the statement that the Protagoras of Plato was earlier than the Birds (p. 148, note 1), that Polycrates wrote a defense of Socrates rather than an accusation (p. 237), or the assumption that the Kaivov in the Wasps, vs. 120, was a center of Corybantic worship instead of a law court (p. 171), while not seriously affecting the argument, do never- theless, in conjunction with the astonishingly numerous misprints in citations from Greek texts, mar somewhat the appearance of the book, at least for the fastidious. W. A. Oldfather University of Illinois Poetae Latini Minores. Post Aemilium Baehrens iterum recensuit Fbidebicus Vollmeb. Vol. II, fasc. 3. Homerus Latinus. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1913. Pp. x+65. M. 2. Zum Homerus Latinus. Kritischer Apparat mit Commentar und Uberlieferungsgeschichte. Von F. Vollmeb. Sitzungsberichte der koniglich bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, philo- sophisch-philologische und historische Klasse. Jahrgung 1913, 3. Abhandlung. Pp. 152. M. 3. We have in these two publications the mature fruit of collections and studies that extend over some fifteen years. Briefly to summarize the formal contributions to the text criticism of the Homerus Latinus, all eight manuscripts used by Baehrens have been recollated, and, as one familiar with this side of his work might readily believe, numerous corrections made; six hitherto unused manuscripts of the tenth to the twelfth century have been added, one of which, discovered by Vollmer himself at Antwerp, together with a manuscript of Valenciennes, constitutes a wholly independent arm of the tradition; seven of the earliest editions between 1477 and 1513 have been examined, and selected readings from them reported; a full list has been drawn up of all recorded codices from the time of the oldest catalogues to the present day, including more than sixty now in existence, a dozen or so of which have been examined and reported upon, and a few, notably the Helm- stadtiensis 384 and the Vindobonensis 3509, laid under contribution for important results; and finally, a restatement has been made, with occasional corrections and elaborations, of the manuscript classification set up in part in the Festschrift Joh. Vahlen (1900), and in greater detail, under Vollmer's supervision, by his pupil Remme in a Munich dissertation (1906). All this has been done, it need scarcely be added, with that mastery of technique and critical acumen which is characteristic of Vollmer's work as an editor, and constitutes the most notable addition yet made to our knowledge of this text. 228 Book Reviews Even more important is the contribution to the understanding of the author, but unfortunately this cannot be summarized. Numerous passages have received their definitive interpretation, and it would be tempting to give examples, did space permit. And yet the dagger-mark of despair appears frequently enough, for Vollmer is conservative in the constitution of the text, and few editors have exercised more self-restraint in printing their own suggestions. The principal emendations I have noted are in vss. 246, 286, 601, 751, 891, 983, and 1010, all quite convincing, except possibly vs. 983, where a brief statement of reasons would have been helpful. In vs. 286 the rare regemet has been restored with certainty from regent et of the archetype- To the instances cited in the commentary may now be added Avianus 42. 8, where some manuscripts preserve the correct regemens and errors in the others point clearly to the same form. There should also be noted an important change in punctuation in vs. 489, the establishment of a lacuna after vss. 385 and 696, and the determination of the correct position of vs. 790, i.e., after 793. Of course not everyone will agree with each conclusion reached by the editor. I should be inclined to dissent, for example, in two instances where the reading of the archetype has been changed, as it appears to me, with scarcely sufficient warrant. In vs. 900, instead of laetis in arvis (so Barth for the impossible armis), Vollmer accepts Bondam's Latiis. The phrase may not be wholly perspicuous or satisfactory, yet Vergil's laeta arva of Elysium (A. 6. 744), and illic res laetae of Latium (A. 2. 783), both cited by Vollmer, give it some support, while just such a word as laetis serves to con- trast the present scenes of war and peril with the felicity of Aeneas' future destinies, and to foreshadow the peace and prosperity of the Augustum genus which the poet would honor. Again in vs. 216 Schrader's emendation Oileos has been accepted in place of the archetype's Oileus. Hyginus, Dares, and Dictys may be but bruised reeds on which to support our manuscripts at this point, but surely Seneca's use of Oileus = the son of Oileus (Medea 661), followed and so supported by Sidonius 5. 196 f ., makes this reading to say the least possible. The peculiar AIAX OILIOS (or ILIOS ?) of a cista Praenes- tina (CIL, XIV, 4108) may perhaps point in the same direction. The most general interest, however, of these studies, and indeed perhaps their greatest value, lies in the elaborate critical commentary where thousands of variants are once for all carefully recorded and in the many elaborate discussions of text history and manuscript classification. Numerous typical cases of errors in tradition are discussed, with rich illustrative material, glosses, simplifications of word order and of construction, mistakes in initial letters, emendations both learned and impudent, interpolations of familiar parallels — in a word the countless pitfalls to which the text tradition of a popular classical author, especially one read widely in the schools, was subject. The method is detailed, severe, and objective; it succeeds, as far perhaps as that end can ever be reached, in elevating text criticism to the rank of a science. It Book Reviews 229 would be hard to find a critical commentary better adapted as a model for philological exercises in a pro-seminar, where it would furnish an excellent addition and supplement to Lindsay's brilliant Introduction. Among minor points of interest might be noted Vollmer's acceptance of the name Baebius Italicus for the author, as given in the late Vindob. 3509, together with convincing arguments for its correctness (pp. 16, 142 f .) ; the suggestion that the mediaeval ascription to Pindarus is due solely to a mis- understanding of Bishop Benzo's Pindarus sew Homerus, by which really the Greek authors were meant (p. 143, nn. 1 and 2) ; and that the well-known vss. 900 f . point rather to the period of the Flavian emperors than to that of the Claudian. An interesting separate report upon the early printed editions, from 1477 to 1541, has been made by the skilled hand of Dr. Fr. Bock, of Erlangen. The printer has unfortunately marred somewhat the appearance of the Greek citations by the almost uniform use of a Latin italic c for uncial sigma, and of three separate fonts for minuscule theta. W. A. Oldfathee University of Illinois Aegyptisches Vereinswesen zur Zeit der Ptolemaer und Romer. Von Dr. Jub. Mariano San Nicolo. Erster Band. Mtinchen: Beck, 1913. Pp. viii+225. Three very different legal and economic systems successively influenced the development of the "Vereinswesen" of Egypt; in none of them was a clear distinction drawn between public and private corporations and associa- tions. Dr. San Nicold, therefore, well aware of the complications and rami- fications of his subject, very wisely defines the scope of his study by a few specific exclusions, and arranges his material according to the aims and activities of the organizations which it represents. The clubs and societies found in Egypt during the period dealt with are grouped in five chapters, which deal respectively with "Kultvereine," "Vereine von Altersgenossen," "Agonistische Vereine," "Berufsvereine," "Private und sonstige Vereine." Of the great mass of facts presented, only a few of the most interesting and important can be mentioned here. Cult societies first made their appearance in Egypt in the Hellenistic period, but were speedily adapted to the worship of the native divinities and seem to have played an important part in the struggle of paganism against Christianity. With Hellenism came also the institution of the gymnasia and ephebic service, which were the source of numerous organizations, both large and small, composed of age-fellows. Agonistic societies, too, are found, among them the Dionysiac players. Perhaps the most striking array is that of the " Berufsvereine," which range from gilds of brewers and bartenders (if I may so translate fvToirfiXai), bakers and beekeepers, gravediggers and