STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE DATE OF THE LATERCULUS VERONENSIS By Clinton Walker Keyes The list of the Roman provinces usually called the Laterculus Veronensis was printed in 1742 in Maffei's Opuscoli Ecclesiastici, but remained entirely neglected by classical scholars until it was rediscovered and edited from the original manuscript by Mommsen in 1862. 1 Since that time the question of the trustworthiness of the document and the problems in regard to the mysterious province Arabia Augusta Libanensis mentioned in it have frequently been treated, but the question of the date of its composition has not been investigated since Mommsen's original article. It seems very gen- erally to have been thought that Mommsen had proved that 297 a.d. was the exact date of composition, and this year has sometimes been so far taken for granted as the proved date of the document that the mention of a province in it has been accepted as conclusive evidence that this province existed in 297. 2 In actual fact, however, Mommsen does not claim to be able to fix definitely the year of com- position. After proving that the document must be dated between 296 and 342, he continues: Es ist nichts im Wege und vieles spricht dafiir, dass es unmittelbar nach der Einrichtung der neuen Diocesen, im J. 297 oder bald nachher, aufgesetzt und eben nichts anderes ist als das nach dieser wichtigen administrativen Umgestaltung officiell in Umlauf gesetzte neue Diocesen- und Provinzen- verzeichniss Auf jeden Fall ist das Veroneser Verzeichniss das alteste, das wir besitzen. 3 Kuhn, in his attack on the trustworthiness of the Laterculus, 4 did not question Mommsen's dating of the original document, but 1 Mommsen, Abhandl. d. Berl. Akad. d. Wiss., phil.-hist. EL, 1862, pp. 419-518 = Histor. Schriften, II, 561-88. My references below will be to the Histor. Schriflen. 2 See, for example, R. Cagnat in Melanges .... Havet, 1909, p. 70: "Entre 295 et 303 les documents nous fait defaut. Hereusement la liste de Verone nous fournit une date moins reculee: 297 La division de la Numidie se placerait done entre 295 et 297." ' Mommsen, op. cit., p. 587. « E. Kuhn, "Uber das Verzeichnis der r5m. Prov. aufgesetzt um 297," Neue Jahrbb. f. Philol. u. Paedag., CXV (1877), 697-719. [Classical Philology XI, April, 1916] 196 The Date of the Laterculus Veronensis 197 asserted "dass das Verzeichnis .... die Aenderungen in der Provinz- einteilung von 297 bis gegen 380 zum grossten Teil in sich aufgenom- men hat," and "dass das Veroneser Verzeichnis als ganzes betrachtet fur irgend eine bestimmte Zeit als zutreffend nicht erachtet werden kann." 1 As far as I know the first expression of doubt as to the accuracy of Mommsen's estimate of the date was made by Mispoulet, who stated the opinion 2 that the document could not be dated before the end of Constantine's reign. He added that he was preparing an article in which he intended to uphold this view; but it seems never to have appeared. More recently G. Costa 8 expressed the opinion that Mommsen's date was too early and Mispoulet's too late. He did not discuss the question further, but said that his treatment of the epigraphical evidence for the provincial government of Diocletian might throw some light on the subject. In this I believe he was right, as will appear below. What I wish to do in this paper is to attempt to fix the date of the Laterculus as closely as possible by the use of evidence which has become available since the time of Mommsen's article. Mommsen found indications in the document itself which seemed to him to point to the reign of Diocletian. His most convincing arguments were drawn from the names of Egyptian, Pontic, and Numidian provinces, and these are the only parts of the empire which we need to consider here, as they give us our only good evidence as to the date of the Laterculus. EGYPT The former imperial domain of Egypt was divided into three provinces at the time of the Laterculus: Thebais, Aegyptus Iovia, and Aegyptus Herculia. 4 The names of two of these provinces obviously refer to the titles Iovius and Herculius assumed by Dio- cletian and Maximian. At the time of Mommsen's article the names 'Op. tit., p. 701. Kuhn's theory has been refuted by C. Czwalina, "Uber das Verzeichnis der rom. Prov. vom J. 297," Progr. Wesel, 1881, and W. Ohnesorge, "Die rom. Provinzliste von 297," Teil I, Progr. Duisburg, 1889. Mommsen's view that the only interpolations are the obvious ones mentioned by him, op. cit., p. 576, seems now to be generally accepted. 1 Acad, des Inscr. et Belles-Lettres, Comptea rendua, 1908, p. 255. ' De Ruggiero, Diz. Epigr., II, 1833. « Cf. Mommsen, op. cit., pp. 571-72. 198 Clinton Walker Keyes of these two provinces were found only in the Veronese list. Now we have evidence from the papyri for governors of Aegyptus Herculia in 316 and 322. 1 Our earliest evidence for the province Thebais seems to be the governorship of Satrius Arrianus in 307. 2 The first change from the arrangement of the Egyptian provinces given in the Laterculus, as far as we know, was the formation of the province of Augustamnica, which occurred in 341. s Thus the evidence from Egypt shows us merely that the Laterculus cannot be dated after 341. In fact, there is no actual evidence that any of these three Egyptian provinces existed in the reign of Diocletian at all; it is perfectly possible that they were formed after his abdication, and that two of them were then named after the two retired Augusti. PONTUS The name of the province Diospontus may also refer to Diocle- tian's title Iovius. The province was later named Helenopontus after Constantine's mother. 4 The epigraphical evidence in regard to the matter is as follows: Date Reference Governor's Name and Title I 293/305 CIL, III, 307, 13643, 14184», 14184n, 14184"; AJA, IX (1905), p. 328 = L'An. Epigr., 1906, N. 2. Aur. Priscianus v.p. praes. prov. Pontl II 317/23 CIL, III, 14184" = JHS, XX (1900), p. 164 Val. CIIPVS— VR v.p. praes. provlnc. Diospont[i] Ill 333/37 CIL, III, 14187", 14187" Fl. Iul. Leontius praes. pr. {g^}(-H«M«|K»itl> I shows that Pontus was not divided before 293. How much later in the reign of Diocletian this governor comes we cannot tell. There is no evidence whatever for the division of the province or the exist- ence of the name Diospontus during Diocletian's reign. > Pap. Oxyr., VI, 896, 28; Pap. Theadelph. (ed. Jouguet), 13, 11. Cf. Pap. Thea- delph. 19, 1. t Grenfell and Hunt, Or. Pap., II (1897), 78, 1; cf. Pap. Flor., I, 33, 9. •E. Schwartz, "Zur Geach. des Athanasius," Nachrickten d. Ges. d. Wiss. zu GBttingen, phil.-hist. Kl., 1904, p. 354; cf. M. Gelzer, Stud, zur byzant. Verw. Agyptena. Diss. Leipzig, 1909, pp. 5 f. « Cf. Mommsen, op. tit., pp. 575, 586, 587. The Date of the Latercultjs Veronensis 199 II, which mentions Diospontus, shows that the name Heleno- pontus was not given to the province before 317 at the earliest, for it was called Diospontus at least up to that date. Ill shows the existence of the title Helenopontus in the last years of Constantine. The province would hardly have been named after Constantine's mother before she became Augusta, which prob- ably occurred in 325. Perhaps this change of name is to be connected with the foundation of Helenopolis (=Drepana) in Bithynia in 327 - 1 The evidence from Pontus, then, gives us no reason for connecting the Veronese list with the reign of Diocletian rather than with that of Constantine. It merely proves that the list must have been drawn up before the end of Constantine's reign in 337. NUMIDIA In the large number of inscriptions containing the names of governors of Numidia we find evidence which enables us to date the Veronese list more closely. A list of the governors of that province from 303 to 314 follows: Date Reference Governor's Name and Title I November 20, 303 CIL, VIII, 4764- 18698 — regente p. N. vestra. Aurel. Quintiano v.p. II 304 CIL, VIII, 2345, 2346. Of. 4334 Valerius Floras v.p. p.p. N.M. CIL, VIII, 6700 = 19353 — marturum qui sunt passi sub preside Floro in civi- tate Milevitana in diebus turincationis Ill 305-6 CIL, VIII, 4766 = 18700 (Diocletian) Val Ant[oninus v.p. p.p. N.C.] CIL, VIII, 5526 = 18860 (a. 306) P Val [A]nton[inus p.p.] N.C. CIL, VIII, 7965 Valerius Antoninus v.p. p. N.O. CIL, VIII. 7067 Valerius Antonilnus v.p. [p.p. Numi]diar[um] IV 308/11 CIL, VIII, 7004 = 19419 Scironius Pasicrates v.p. [p.p. Numi)diar[uml V 314 CIL, VIII. 18905 Val. Paulus v.p. p.p. N. Pallu de Lessert 2 puts Valerius Florus (II) before Aurelius Quintianus (I). The persecution of the Christians at this time • Pauly-Wiss., a.v. "Helena," VII, 2, 2821. « Faatea dea prov. Afr., II, 311-14. 200 Clinton Walker Keyes consisted of two periods, the dies traditionis and the dies turificationis, with an interval between them. Diocletian's first edict ordering the persecution was issued at Nicomedia, February 23, 303, and was put into effect in Numidia, May 19, 303. According to the inscription cited above (II), Floras was governor of Numidia during the dies turificationis, and Pallu de Lessert, believing that he was succeeded by Quintianus (I) before November 20, 303, is puzzled to find time for the two periods of persecution between May 19 and November 20. It seems to me that Costa 1 is undoubtedly right in placing these governors in the order in which I have put them above. He argues plausibly that the "edict of amnesty" which came between the two periods of persecution was issued at the time of the celebration of Diocletian's vicennalia (November 20, 303) ? But whether this is true or not, Eusebius tells us that the emperor's edict ordering the second period of persecution, the dies turificationis, was received in Palestine in the second year of the persecution; i. e., in 304. 3 That this is the right chronological order of the two governors is also clearly shown by the fact that Quintianus (I) is the last of a con- tinuous line of governors of the simple provincia Numidia, while the governorship of Floras (II) marks the beginning of a series of governors of one or both of the two provinces into which Numidia was divided. Also, we have definite evidence that this division took place while Florus was governor. 4 During the dies turificationis he superin- tended the persecution at Milev, which is very near Cirta, and in the part of the province which became Numidia Cirtensis. But in the other inscriptions he is called p (raeses) N{umidiae) M(ilitianae) . The natural inference is that during the persecution he was governor of the undivided province (as was Quintianus, his immediate prede- cessor), and that, after the division, he became governor of Numidia Militiana. And since one of the inscriptions 6 in which he holds this title also mentions Diocletian as emperor, the division was made 1 Op. cit., pp. 1833 f. The arguments I give below for this arrangement of the governors and for the division of Numidia in 304 are for the most part Costa's. » Op. cit., p. 1860. • De Mart. Palaest. 3. 1; cf. A. Maranesi, L'Imp. Rom. e il Cristianesimo (Torino, 1914), p. 450 f. Cf. also Costa's argument from St. August. Contra Cresc. III. 27 (op. cit., p. 1861). « Cf. Costa, op. cit., p. 1834. > CIL, VIII, 2345. The Date of the Laterculus Veronensis 201 before his abdication. 1 We can therefore fix this division of Numidia definitely in 304 or very early in 305. Valerius Antoninus (III) governed Numidia Cirtensis under both Diocletian and Constantine; he was probably its first governor. Later he seems to have governed both of the provinces, though they were still formally separate, as did also Pasicrates (IV), whose gov- ernorship comes under the pretender Domitius Alexander. The earliest governor of the reunited province whose date can definitely be fixed is Paulus (V), who held the province in 314. After that we find no further reference to a division of the province. The reunion of its two parts is doubtless to be connected with the rebuilding of Cirta, which was renamed Constantina, 2 after the over- throw of Alexander, which occurred in 311. Since Numidia was not divided before 304, and the division did not last after 314, the Laterculus Veronensis, which lists the two provinces Numidia Cirtensis and Numidia Militiana, must have been drawn up between these two dates. I do not see how we can fix its date more closely. Of course the theory that it was drawn up about the time of Diocletian's retirement and represents his final arrange- ment of the provinces is a very plausible one, but we must remember that it is quite possible that the document dates from the time of Constantine and contains the names of provinces which were formed by him or some of his colleagues. As mentioned above, we have no proof whatever of the existence of the new Egyptian prov- inces or of Diospontus under Diocletian, and this statement applies to many other provinces. We can no longer accept the appearance of a province in the Veronese list as definite evidence that it existed in Diocletian's reign. Pbinceton University 1 This is also proved by the inscriptions of Valerius Antoninus (III). 2 Aurel. Victor De Caess. 40. 28.