STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE INSTITUTION OF ATHENIAN ARBITRATORS By Robert J. Bonner Written evidence is inferior to the testimony of witnesses liable to cross-examination. No satisfactory explanation of the reason for the change from oral to written evidence has ever been advanced. 1 The plaintiff in Apollodorus v. Stephanas, a perjury case, remarks that the law required written evidence: ha fify-' ae\e2p ii-jj pipe irpoaOtiviu rols yeypappivois ptfHv. 2 This statement does not neces- sarily mean that the sole purpose of the provision was to facilitate the punishment of perjury, for the practice was never extended to the Blutgerichte, where the consequences of perjury were likely to be more serious than in the other courts. 3 In modern practice evi- dence is reduced to writing mainly for purposes of appeal. In Athens also appeals were based almost entirely on the affidavits presented at the arbitration. 4 It seems quite plausible, therefore, to suppose that the real motive for requiring affidavits was to insure that the appeal should be taken substantially on the evidence as originally presented. Written evidence is fundamental in arbitra- tion proceedings as described by Aristotle. 5 Consequently the law instituting arbitration was either first enacted or radically revised when written evidence was introduced." 1 Both arbitration and perjury had occurred to me as probable reasons (Evi- dence in Athenian Courts [1905], p. 47). Leisi, Der Zeuge im Attischen Becht (1908), p. 87, does not suggest any special reason for the innovation but thinks it was intro- ducted by litigants: " Allmahlich mochte es sich fur die Parteien als praktisch erweisen, den Worlaut der Zeugnisse schriftlich zu fixieren, um das Pladoyer ganz genau auf sie einrichten zu konnen und vor nachteiligen Auszerungen besser geschiitzt zu sein . . . . ob zuerst noch beide Modalitaten nebeneinander bestanden, oder ob das schriftliche Verfahren sogleich gesetzlich vorgeschrieben wurde, iat nicht zu ent- scheiden." 2 Demosthenes xlv. 44. * Bonner, "Evidence in the Areopagus," Class. Phil., VII (1912), 450; cf. Lipsius, Das attische Hecht (1915), p. 883. * For exceptions see Evidence in Athenian Courts, p. 55. « Const, of Athens 53. * Leisi, op. cit., pp. 85 ff.; Lipsius, op. cit., p. 883; "Evidence in the Areopagus," Class. Phil., VII (1912), 450, n.l. [Classical Philolog* XI, April, 1916] 191 192 Robert J. Bonner According to the older view, public arbitration was introduced in the archonship of Euclides. 1 More recently the date has been pushed back into the fifth century because of the mention of arbi- tration by Andocides 2 : ras pkv 5«aj & 8.v8pes ical tAj Siairas hrovi)- ffare Kvplas tlvai, ordeai iv dijuoKpaTov^epy ry iro\ei iylvovro. It is assumed that both public and private arbitral awards were reaffirmed by this enactment. But why should the awards of public arbitrators be reaffirmed ? They were not final; the defeated party had the right of appeal. If he failed to exercise this right it was because he acquiesced in the decision. Accordingly there was no reason for expecting that there would be any general disposition to reopen cases settled by public arbitration. But private arbitra- tions were final; appeals were not allowed. Naturally the defeated party would welcome an opportunity for reopening the case. Thus the Andocides passage furnishes no proof of the existence of public arbitration before the archonship of Euclides. Furthermore, it is entirely improbable that arbitration was introduced under the demo- cratic regime of the fifth century, though it was never more needed, for it would have materially lessened the amount of litigation and relieved the congestion of the courts. But one may very well doubt whether the ecclesia would have passed a measure that tended to lessen the activities of the popular courts even if a reformer was bold enough to propose it. 3 The popular jealousy of any interference with the courts is seen in the success of Themistocles' charge that Aristides by his activity as a private arbitrator was subverting the popular courts as a step toward tyranny. 4 The earliest certain references to public arbitration are subse- quent to the Peloponnesian War. A law dealing with arbitration 1 Pischinger, De Arbilris Atheniensium Publicis (1893), pp. 45 ff.; cf. Lipsius, op. cit., p. 220. » i. 88. In reference to the view that this passage proves the existence of public arbitrators before the time of the Thirty, Caillemer (Daremburg and Saglio, Diction- naire des Antiquites, s.v. "DiaitStai") inquires: "Mais l'argument tirfe de ce texte est-il bien probant ? " » It is worth noting that Aristophanes, who has much to say about litigation, makes no mention of arbitration. 4 tQ S' otV 'Aptareldji irvvifiTi ri> vp&rov iyairapJvif Sti. tj)p iirwvvfUav ttrrepov 6- ptfrov iavrif KareffKevafffUvos (Plutarch Aristides vii). The Institution op Athenian Arbitrators 193 is mentioned in a fragment of Lysias. In a suit to recover a sum of money (irepl rod xp««s) the defendant claims that he exhausted every means to effect a settlement without litigation, but in vain. The plaintiff constantly refused either to effect a friendly settlement or diairav bnTptyai, &os i>p.eis rbv vbpov t6v irepl tu>v Sicuttjtuv Meade. 1 Schoemann, 2 contrary to the generally accepted view, argued that this law did not establish arbitration but merely extended its scope by increasing the amount that could be referred to arbitration. But why should the law have placed an upward limit on claims subject to arbitration? Amounts up to ten drachmas were exempt, not because it was not deemed desirable to have such claims settled by arbitration, but to prevent them from finding their way into court on appeal. 3 But no consideration could justify the exemption of a case from arbitration on account of the largeness of the sum involved. Indeed, the larger the amount in dispute the more desir- able it was to afford an opportunity for a compromise. There is even less reason for the view that this law was an amendment to the original law, extending it so as to include the kind of claim in question. The claim was for a sum of money (irepl xP^ws) and was based on a epofiivovs did precisely what the Thirty did. Regarding the functions of the Thirty rural justices instituted in 453 no information is available, but it may be safely assumed that they were essentially the same as those of the itinerant judges of Pisistratus. 2 When the board was reorganized under the restored democracy and increased to Forty, its duties were fundamentally changed. The arbitral functions of the original board were assigned to the arbitrators, a board instituted for this purpose. Hence the close connection between them and the Forty. 3 Written evidence came into general use about 390, more than a decade after arbitration. But there is no objection to assuming that 6 t&v SiaiTTjTwv vbytos* contained a provision requiring affidavits for all arbitration cases. The words /cat avh^re robrwv n&prvpes in the earliest case involving arbitration do not necessarily imply oral evidence, as expressions of similar import are found in speeches delivered long after all evidence was required to be reduced to writing. 5 The other alternative is to assume a thorough revision of rbv t&v 1 Aristotle Constitution of Athens 16. 4. 'Ibid. 26.3; 53. 1. » In a paper entitled, "The Jurisdiction of Athenian Arbitrators," Class. Phil., II (1907), 407 ff., I pointed out that, so far as citizens were concerned, only the cases that came under the jurisdiction of the Forty were subject to arbitration. Conse- quently neither the archon nor the thesmothetae sent cases to the arbitrators. Lipsius, Das attische Recht (1905), p. 228, reached the conclusion that the only cases involving property rights that were exempt from arbitration were the monthly suits (««"?>■<>' SIkcu) which came within the jurisdiction of the cteayaiyett. In Nachtrage und Berichtigungen (1915), p. 981, he accepts my view so far as concerns the SiaSitcaatai v6ftov in 390. The former alternative is to be preferred. In either case it is clear that the purpose in introducing written evi- dence was to facilitate appeals from the awards of arbitrators. The extension of the practice to cases not subject to arbitration need occasion no difficulty. 1 Testimonial evidence was not of para- mount importance in an Athenian trial. The facts of the case were developed by the speakers with or without corroboration of the details. Corroboration was always desirable but never essential. In modern practice the facts in the case must be presented entirely through the medium of evidence. Thus the disadvantages resulting from the presentation of evidence in an inferior form were outweighed by the accruing advantages, among which uniformity in practice, saving of time, and greater certainty in dealing with perjury are obvious. University of Chicago 1 The words MvnetaS' Srt 5