STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. HORACE AN ATTICIST By M. B. Ogle There have appeared within the past year two articles 1 dealing with the stylistic doctrines of Horace as they are set forth in his Sermones, which are written from the same point of view, follow the same line of argument, and agree, with slight differences, in their conclusions. According to the one, Vergil and Horace, in their earlier poetry, at least, adopted the plain style because they were Atticists, members of the circle of Asinius Pollio, and exponents, therefore, of the stylistic theories of that circle. According to the other, Horace wrote the tenth satire of the first book with definite reference to the dispute between the Atticists, whose stylistic theories he upholds in this satire, and the Asiatics, including Lucilius, whose stylistic theories he combats, although Horace was not an extreme Atticist, but modified "the extreme views of the Atticistic school to which he belonged." Furthermore, Calvus and Catullus are men- tioned in vs. 19 of this satire because "they are leading Atticists" with whose views on the points treated in this satire Horace was in complete accord, whereas Hermogenes and the simius, mentioned in vs. 18, represent the Asiatics; hence, the word cantare, vs. 19, cannot have the meaning usually given to it, but must be equivalent to "satirize," as in S. 2. 1. 46. These views, supported as they are by the auctoritas of two such scholars as Professor Jackson and Professor Ullman, must receive, as they deserve, serious attention, but I am not, I must confess, Atticist enough, in spite of the auctoritas, to accept their conclusions without at least important modifications. That Horace in S. 1. 10 sets forth his conception of satire and the difference between his conception and that of Lucilius, that he makes clear, also, his ideas of the style in which such productions 'Jackson, "Molle atque facetum," Harvard Studies, XXV, 117 ft.; Ullman, "Horace, Catullus, and Tigellius," Class. Phil., X (1915) , 270 ff. I have expressed my doubts about the validity of the conclusions of the former in a paper which will appear in AJP. [Classical Philology XI, April, 1916] 156 Hokace AN Atticist 157 should be written, no one will question. The satirist, he says in effect (vs. 10 ff.), needs wit, which Lucilius had, but he needs brevitas, which he did not have; he needs invective, which Lucilius had, and geniality, which Lucilius did not have; he must sometimes play the part of the orator and the poet, which Lucilius did, sometimes that of the self-restrained gentleman, which Lucilius did not do. It does not follow, however, that, because Horace employs in this passage terms which are applied by the writers on oratorical theory to the bombastic style of the Asiatics on the one hand and the simple style of the Atticists on the other, he is expressly contrasting the two and explicitly stating his preference for the latter, or that he is on this account an Atticist and the critic of Lucilius because he, " compared with the higher standards of Horace's day," was an Asiatic. An argument based on the use of words is of doubtful value in any case, but especially so here, since Horace in his other discussion of the nature and aim of his work (S. 1. 4) uses these very same terms where they cannot have reference to the stylistic theories of any school; comis et urbanus, 1. 4. 90, iocosius, 1. 4. 104. It is a question, more- over, to my mind, at least, whether we ought not to confine the terms "Atticist" and "Asiatic," as we find them employed in the literature of the last century of the Republic, to the advocates only of cer- tain stylistic theories which were formulated in connection with grammatical-rhetorical (oratorical) studies. 1 However this may be, Horace in this tenth satire makes it perfectly clear that he is not writing as the mouthpiece of any particular literary group, for in vss. 81 ff. he mentions among the real docti, who he hopes will approve of his work, Varius and Maecenas, who certainly, from the point of view of style, cannot be classed as Atticists. That his satires should be marked by the qualities of the plain style is certainly not surprising, since he takes pains to tell us (S. 1. 4. 40 ff.) that he is not writing poetry but prose in verse form, sermoni propiora, and sermo is, accord- ing to Auc. ad Her. 3. 13. 23, "oratio remissa et finitima cottidianae locutioni." 2 That this was the style which Lucilius employed Horace also makes clear; cf. S. 1. 4. 56: "His, ego quae nunc, / ohm quae scripsit Lucilius, eripias si / tempora certa modosque, et quod prius » Cf. Hendrickson, Class. Phil., I (1906), 98. 2 Cf. Morris' note on 1. 4. 42, and UUman, Class. Phil, VI (1911), 286 and notes. 158 M. B. Ogle ordine verbum est / posterius facias, .... non .... invenias etiam disiecti membra poetae"; 2. 1. 28: "me pedibus delectat claudere verba / Lucili ritu"; cf. 2. 1. 63. These words tell us, as plainly as words can, that Lucilius, in the judgment of Horace, employed the style of ordinary conversation — the plain style, if we must call it so — and they should be sufficient evidence to refute the argument that Horace criticized Lucilius because his style was essentially that of the so-called Asiatics of Horace's day. Without this testimony of Horace, however, we should be in no doubt as to the position of Lucilius in the history of Latin style. We find applied to him, in the first place, in a work on style where we have a right to expect stylistic terms to be employed in their technical sense, the adjective urbanus, that shibboleth of the Atticists, a stock epithet of the plain style; 1 Cic. De Or. 1. 72: "C. Lucilius .... homo .... doctus et perurbanus"; cf. De Fin. 1. 7. If we say, as some 2 do, that Cicero, in using this term, is allowing his admiration to warp his judgment, and that in reality Lucilius was not urbanus — I am using the word in its technical, stylistic sense — then I fail to see how we can place any dependence whatever on ancient literary criticism; rather must we conclude, it seems to me, that if Lucilius' style had not been essentially that described by the rhetoricians as the plain style, Cicero, on whose testimony chiefly we have to rely for the definition of urbanus as a quality of this style, would not have employed the term. Cicero, however, is not alone in ascribing this quality to the style of Lucilius. According to Porphyr. ad. Hor. S. 1. 10. 53, "comis autem Lucilius dicitur propter urbanitatem," and again, ad S. 1. 3. 40: "Luciliana urbanitate usus in transitu amaritudinem aspersit." Furthermore, no less an authority than Varro, as we learn from Gell. 6. 14. 6, made Lucilius the representative of gracilitas, meaning thereby XapoKTi)p lCf. the remarks of Hendrickson, AJP, XXI, 122. So pus in 1. 7.1 recalls Lucilius cited above. * In view of Professor Ullman's suggestion, p. 276, that another point at issue between Horace and Hermogenes may have been the fact that the latter was a Stoic, it may not be amiss to note that as a Stoic he probably shared with his fellows their fondness "suo quamque rem nomine appellare," Cic. Ad. Fam. 9. 22. 1; he would, therefore, have found the poetry of these three men all the more to his liking. This practice was distasteful to both Cicero and Horace, and there is striking similarity between the former's advice to an orator concerning the use of the ridiculum. Or. 88, and the passage under discussion from Horace. Horace an Atticist 167 interpretation of cantare which is used in its ordinary sense as the frequentative from cano, just as it is used in S. 2. 1. 46, "insignis tota cantabitur urbe." There is, however, no unfavorable conno- tation, as Professor Ullman maintains, in the latter passage; it means simply, as Professor Morris puts it, that everyone will be repeating the satirical verses which Horace will write about him. It is exactly the same use which we have in Ovid, Am. 1. 15. 13: "Battiades semper toto cantabitur orbe." From this point of view, also, it makes no difference whether or not we identify the Hermogenes of vs. 18 with the Tigellius of S. 1. 2. 3, and 1. 3. 3, although personally I cannot see why Horace is so careful to call the former Hermogenes unless he wished to distinguish them or, at least, to make their identity less marked. Let it be granted, however, that the two are, as Professor Ullman asserts, identical. Tigellius, then, was dead some years before this tenth satire was written, and since Hermogenes is clearly spoken of as living in this satire — there can be no doubt about vs. 90, hence no doubt about vss. 18, 80 — the reference is not specific; Hermogenes, like most of the names in Horace, is not an individual but a type, and neither the friendship of the specific Tigellius for Octavius, nor his enmity with Calvus, need enter into the discussion at all. The tenth satire, therefore, to sum up, was not written with definite reference to the dispute between the Atticists and the Asiatics, nor is it an attack upon the latter because they combated certain theories, concerning chiefly, if not solely, the style of oratory advo- cated by the former. Rather is it like the fourth, a statement first of all of Horace's idea of satire and of his relations to Lucilius. The latter was his master, and like him Horace wrote sermoni propiora, and in an easy conversational style suitable to the subject-matter and differing from prose only in its form. Lucilius, however, had two great faults: he was too diffuse, too careless of the artistic effect, and too brutal, too personal in his attacks on individuals; these two faults Horace made it his aim to avoid. These two satires serve, also, as replies to those who criticized Horace's idea of satire; in the fourth he answers those who charged him, or satirists as a class, with being too bitter in his attacks on individuals; in the tenth he replies 168 M. B. Ogle to those who complained that he was not bitter enough. To the latter, satire meant an unsparing arraignment of conditions and of men, and this they found in the open and often brutal invective of Lucilius, Calvus, and Catullus. They would not or could not realize that Horace was not writing saturae but sermones, and that he pur- posely avoided that feature which, owing to Lucilius, had become a marked characteristic of the old literary form known as satura. University of Vermont