STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 106 Book Reviews and to the description and classification of the manuscripts. The dis- cussion of these matters is full and clear. In his zeal to demonstrate that Haase and others attached too much importance to E, the editor is inclined to go to the opposite extreme. The text is accompanied by references to the ancient authors who made use of the Naturales Quaestiones and by a critical apparatus, which shows good judgment in what it gives and omits. An Index Nominum and an Index Testimoniorum close the volume. Increased knowledge of the manuscripts and the labors of scholars since Haase have made it possible to improve upon his text in many details. On the other hand, in numerous changes, especially in many of the emendations proposed by the editor himself, there is no improvement over the recension of Haase, which is not yet by any means made super- fluous. A large amount of work still remains to be done on the Naturales Quaestiones. Frank Ivan Merchant Iowa State Normal School Roman Economic Conditions to the Close of the Republic. By Edmund Henry Oliver. University of Toronto Library, 1907. Pp. xv+200. 11.50. This study forms an extra volume in the "University of Toronto Studies in History and Economics." It is a welcome addition to the comparatively few English works on Roman economy and finance. The main division, pp. 41-192, treats of the period from Rome's first Mediter- ranean expansion to the close of the republic, under four heads: general economic conditions, agriculture, etc., industries, trade and commerce, administration and finance. In general, the author seems to overrate Roman agriculture and finance and to underestimate the importance of Roman commerce and manufactures. He occasionally combines in one description the state- ments, e. g., of Cato and Pliny the elder. This seems to be a somewhat questionable mode of procedure. He would have increased the useful- ness of the book if he had given modern equivalents for all ancient coins, weights, and measures. He follows the quite common usage of rating the sesterce at about four cents (cf. pp. 159, 160, 165). The Latinists who now make use of the obsolete ratio of 16:1 might be con- sidered belated populists in disguise. So far as the reviewer can see, it is necessary to adopt either the ancient ratio of ca. 12:1 or the present market ratio. The former is to be preferred. A few matters of detail may be noted. On p. 43 the author follows Plutarch's version of the anecdote about the chlamydes of Lucullus in preference to that of Horace. On p. 45, 12,000,000 sesterces should be Book Reviews 107 changed to 12,000, and 40,000,000 to 4,000,000. The MS reading duo milia might be preferred to the old reading, sex milia. At this point and elsewhere several words are omitted within the quotation marks, and the fact is not indicated. Farther down "Peacocks" should be changed to "eggs," and "easily" should modify the next statement. On p. 49, 133,000 lbs., the reading of Weissenborn-Mliller, may be substi- tuted for the old reading of 123,000 pounds. P. 52: "which you even remove": "which" is not foimd in Horace and should be outside the quotation marks; wsgwe probably does not signify "even," and "house- hold goods" a little farther down is a misprint for "household gods." "No colony was founded after 157 B.C.," is quite incorrect. "Borian" is presumably a misprint for "Thorian." The language on p. 70: "The diminution in Rome's population is contemporaneous with the expansion of Eoman power," is a somewhat misleading assertion and should be modified. Pp. 74, 75: the reference to Plautus should be Merc. 396-98; master (Demipho) should take the place of mistress, and "crush grain" (pensum faciat) ought to be corrected to "spin," "perform a spinner's task," or the like. P. 81: gwadrawtes appears here and elsewhere. The author seems to have misunderstood the abbreviation Q, which stands for quadrantal, a measiu-e of about 5.77 imperial gallons. "Telam" is probably not a web, but a loom. P. 82: "eight hundred jars with a capacity of five sacks of grapes." Culleus here and below is apparently a measure of capacity = ca. 119 gallons. The passage may be rendered: "jars with a (total) capacity of 800 cullei (ca. 95,200 gals.) in which five vintages can be (stored)." Quid multaf Mistakes are easy to find in most books. A word may be added concerning the bibliography, which is apparently an after- thought. Some commissions and omissions are etwas entfremdend. Adams Roman Antiquities, 1792, Hiillmann Romische Grundverfas- sung, 1832, Preston and Dodge The Private Life of the Romans, 1894, and various magazine articles are included, the histories of Niebuhr, Schwegler, Ranke, Mommsen's Geschichte des rOmischen Milnzwesens, Iwan von Milller's Handbueh, etc., and all the works of Herzog, Madvig, and Willems are excluded. As a rule, the number of the edition and of the volimies of a work is not stated. The dates of publication are in several instances incorrect or misleading. For example, the Handbueh, etc., of Marquardt and Mommsen is said to have been published in 1876. The third edition of Vols. I and II appeared in 1887, and the first edition of Vol. Ill in 1887-88, etc. Pauly-Wissowa Real-encyclopddie, etc., is said to have been issued in 1894. Apart from the bibliography, the study is a careful and fairly accu- rate piece of work, and, as a first effort, it is very promising. J. E. Gbanbcd University of Minnesota