STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE COMPOSITION OF THE DE OBATORIBUS ANTIQUIS OP DIONYSIUS By Ralph Hermon Tukey In his introduction to the De oratoribus antiquis, Dionysius declares that his ultimate purpose in writing the work is to assist in the grand movement of expelling the meretricious Asianism and restoring the true Attic style. To this end he promises to select from the Attic writers such authors as are best suited for the reader to copy, and to point out what elements in each are most worthy of imitation. The present work is to be devoted to orators : at another time, if opportunity is afforded, he will discuss the historians. Accordingly he selects from the field of oratory six representative men, and divides them into two groups according to the period in which they lived, the earlier group, comprising Lysias, Isocrates, and Isaeus to be treated in the first division (owraf t? ) of the work, and the later group, including Demosthenes, Hyperides, and Aeschines, in the second. The first division with its essays on Lysias, Isocrates, and Isaeus has been preserved intact. We also have an essay on Demosthenes, which has come down to us under the title of irepi Trjs At] fioaOevoix; \e£e&>?, and which in all the important manuscripts is separated from the group of essays on Lysias, Isaeus, and Iso- crates by one or more of the other works of Dionysius. The scope and method of this essay differ materially from the plan that was outlined in the introduction to the De oratoribus antiquis and which was followed in the first division of that work. This wide divergence in treatment plainly separates it from the essays on Lysias, Isocrates, and Isaeus, and points to an independent origin. But on the other hand we have two undoubted references to this essay in other works of Dionysius which assign it to the De oratori- bus antiquis. It is the purpose of the paper to present a hypoth- esis which reconciles these two facts and suggests a solution for certain other difficulties that are found in the extant essay on [Classical Philology IV, October, 1909] 390 The De Oratoribus Antiquis of Dionysius 391 Demosthenes. Briefly stated it is this, that Dionysius completed the De oratoribus antiquis according to his original plan and that afterward, for reasons which will appear later in the discussion, he wrote another essay on Demosthenes and incorporated it into the De oratoribus antiquis. The first avvTagv;, which follows closely the plan outlined in the introduction, in its closing sentences renews the promise of a second part in which Demosthenes, Hyperides, and Aeschines should be discussed. 1 That this second part was actually com- pleted and contained essays on the three later orators is made evident by the opening sentences of the essay on Dinarchus, 2 where Dionysius says that he did not include Dinarchus in his work on the Attic orators because he was "neither an inventor of a special type of style, as was Lysias, Isocrates, and Isaeus, nor was he a perfecter of the discoveries of others like Demosthenes, Aeschines, and Hyperides." 3 If for any reason we assume that the second part was never written, or that it was left incomplete and did not include Aeschines and Hyperides, we take away the occasion for any explanation on the part of Dionysius with regard to his failure to treat Dinarchus in that work and leave this sentence without point or meaning. Furthermore, the detailed statements (quoted below) about the style of Hyperides which are found in the De Dinarcho indicate that Dionysius had worked out a systematic treatment of that author at least ; and the manner in which they 1 De Isaeo 124. 8. 629, hrtpav Si ipxV lroifyropai tov \6yov irepl re Ai)fu>s iv rots irepl t&v ipxaloiv ypacpeunv Sta tA /uiJtc eipcrtjr ISlov yeyovivai x"'P al ' T VP os tAk &"Spa, &v'\l Kal t&v 'TirepelSriv 392 Ralph Heemon Tukey are introduced presupposes an acqaintance with such a treatment on the part of the reader. 1 From an examination of the references to these three orators in De Dinarcho and elsewhere in the works of Dionysius, we may hope to gain some idea of the contents of the second part. We may infer from the passage already quoted from De Dinarcho, that, as Lysias, Isocrates, and Isaeus each represented a particular style, so Demosthenes, Aeschines, and Hyperides were regarded as perfecters of three separate styles, or rather that the new elements introduced by each of the earlier orators were regarded as more highly developed or more skilfully combined with other qualities in the corresponding later orators. Such a correspondence is obvious in the case of Isaeus and Demosthenes, where the nascent SeivoTt)? of Isaeus finds its perfect development in the more finished eloquence of Demosthenes. 2 x^P^ i s * ne common element in Lysias and Hyperides and the advance is made in the case of Hyperides by combining this quality with effectiveness (^a/an-o? fiearfc iarr ical Bok&v airXovs ovk airtjWaiCTcu BeivoTVTOS, De imitatione 213. 8. 435). That the two men were associated in the mind of Dionysius is shown by the following references: rod 8' "TTrepeiBeiov rat? re oltcovo/iiais a/cpi^earepov ical rah tcaTacnceval 1 ; yevpaiorepov ttw? ovtos t&v Avcnatcwv, De Dinarcho 304. 12. 640; 6 8' 'TTrepetSj)? Kara fiev ttjv eicXoyfjv t&v 6vofiaTa>v rjTTaTcu Avcriov, Kara Be top irpayfianicbv tottov oiaepet,, ibid., 305. 11. 641; 6 Be 'T7T€/oetSij9 euo-TO^o? fiev, airdviov 8' av% t)Tiic&' ical ry fiev ttj? (f>pd<; Ktnacritevy Avcriav wreptjpicdK , Tjj Be t?j? evpecreax; •wavovpyia, irdvra<;, De imit. 213. 3. 435. There is less material for establishing a similar relationship between Isocrates and Aeschines. No other mention is made of Aeschines in the essay on Dinarchus, and elsewhere in the works of Dionysius no comparison between the two men is found. But in the summary criticism of the more important Greek authors which appears in the epitome of the work on Imitation, the style of each is said to be irofiiriicos [De imit. 1 Further evidence for the existence of an essay on Hyperides is found in the state- ment of a scholiast on Hermogenes (Walz Rh. Or. VII. 1048) : Aiovtiaiov, Ssrcpl %apa)t- rijpos SUXafle AvirLov Atjiaoj)p irapai «cal iir&yyehim tou \A70u, KparteTy X^f « «oi wp&s diraffav avdpdnrov tpfoip iip/xoa^ini /ieTpi(braTa Aijfwv SXhwv pifrbpuv re Kal i\oo)i> X^|«s T&5 Kp6.Ti.aTa Soicofoas ex""- 396 Ralph Heemon Tukey De Demosthene his only concern is to establish the pre-eminence of Demosthenes — especially over Plato. There is now no refer- ence to imitation and the work takes the form of argument rather than of exposition. Furthermore, the scope of his treat- ment is extended beyond the boundaries which were observed in the De oratoribus antiquis. There the discussion was confined strictly to the orators; but in this essay orators, historians, and philosophers are treated without apparent distinction, so far as it is a question of their relation to the subject under discussion. Even more striking evidence of the independent origin of the De Dem. is found in the treatment of Isaeus in this essay. In the De Isaeo he was represented as having introduced the element, SeivoTt]?, which was the most characteristic feature of the oratory of Demosthenes, and frequent references were made to Demosthenes' indebtedness to him in other respects. But in the De Dem. he is mentioned but once and then as one of six writers who exhibit "nothing new or unusual."' It is highly improbable, to say the least, that such a statement would be found in this essay, if it had immediately followed De Isaeo as a part of the same series. The underlying motive of the essay, as may be inferred from the controversial tone of some of its passages, is the refutation of what Dionysius regarded as extravagant claims of the advocates of Plato. 2 After the second part of the De oratoribus antiquis had been completed, the attention of Dionysius, we may suppose, was called to the fact that, while he had shown in that work that Demos- thenes stood first among the orators, such pre-eminence did not preclude a representative of history or philosophy from being awarded the primacy in the whole field of prose literature. It was to refute the claims of the advocates of Plato that he then prepared this second essay on Demosthenes. Apparently we have here another chapter in that never-ending controversy between the 1 De Dem. 143. 6. 974: * AvT«ptov 7&p 5t? koX Qe68o>pos ical T\o\vKpdrTjs 'Iv ijiJiiTe- \tj3v irepl \670us, 0? rijv etiyevyj KaTcurtcevijp oiiK tvaffivifi rls Tror" 1 karlv oi)5£ MvavTax, wa&av elptaveiav &els, 10s W0uffa, Sia\4^0fiai. The De Obatobibus Antiquis of Dionysius 397 partisans of rhetoric and those of philosophy. In the Epistle to Ammaeus he has already refuted the assertion that Demosthenes derived his skill in oratory from his study of the precepts of Aristotle. Now he is aroused by the renewal of the old claim 1 of the philosophers that Plato had surpassed all others in writing and speaking and should be taken as the standard for the simple style of the dialogue and also for the more vigorous style of public address, 2 in fact, that he not only stood first among the philoso- phers, but as an orator outshone even Demosthenes in his own field. For Plato's simpler style in the colloquial parts of the dia- logues Dionysius has only words of commendation, 3 but his criti- cisms of Plato's supposed attempts at oratory are severe and in some instances betray a lack of appreciation of the spirit in which Plato composed them. 4 To speak in his own terminology, Dio- nysius is sometimes guilty of condemning Plato's Bvva/xK before he has gained an adequate conception of his irpoaipeo-R. But in spite of the occasional thrust, it is evident that Diony- sius tried to avoid giving to the essay a polemical cast and endeav- ored to present the appearance of studied impartiality. 5 In order to give to the work the form of a logical demonstration, he had recourse to the doctrine of the three types of style. His method of proof is that of elimination. If the prose authors be divided into three groups according to style, and the best author, or authors, in each group be selected, it is then necessary merely to show that a given author is superior to each of these foremost representatives in order to demonstrate his superiority over them and all others in the given groups. Accordingly he endeavors to show that Demosthenes is superior to Thucydides, the representative of the elevated style, to Lysias, the representative of the plain style, and 'Of. Cicero Orator 62; Brutus 121. 2 De Dem. 178. 8. 1024 : ml p.&\urra iirel rives a£iova>v yap Br) Kal SedBmpo 1 ; Kal IIo\v«:paT»;s 'Icrato's re Kal Z&h'\o? Kal ' Avaj;tfievr)<; Kal oi Kara tov? avrovs yevofievot, tovtok xpovovs ovOev ovTe Kaivbv ovre irepiTTOv e-rrerr)heva , av, aXka airb tovtcov tS>v %apaK- Trjpcov Kal irapa tovtovs tou? Kavovas to? eavT&v \ef et? KareaKevaaav [De Dem. 143. 2. 974). The historical point of view has been abandoned, and in the whole field of prose literature Dionysius sees three types of style (xapaKTrjpe 1 ; tt)? \e'fea>?), each with its own representatives. Among these leaders, Isaeus has no claim to prominence and may be disregarded in the demonstration of the primacy of Demosthenes. The expression ovOev ovre Kaivbv ovre irepiTTov is not to be taken absolutely, but is to be interpreted in the light of the context and of the underlying purpose of the essay. So far as it was a question of the three styles without regard to their development, Isaeus presented nothing novel. His histori- cal relation to Demosthenes is neither affirmed nor denied. What has been said up to this point with reference to this essay on Demosthenes applies only to the first part, which ends with chap, xxxiv. This section of the essay has a certain completeness in itself, as is indicated by the last sentence in chap, xxxii [De Dem. 202. 5.1058): fiovKopai Be Br) KalcrvWoyiaaadai raelptjfieva i% apxfjs Kal Bell;ai 7rdv0\ ocra irrrecrxdfiriv apxpnevos tt)? deapias tov XeKTiKOV toVov, ireiroirjKOTa e/A,avr6v. The opening sentence of chap, xxxiv 1 shows that this treatment of Demosthenes from the standpoint of style (Xe/m/ed? totto?) was to be followed immedi- l De Dem. 203. 22. 1060: 6\lya roirois in irpo5 inrop.vriiMTuriu>bs rifi&y \apwv, oOj irepl tjjj ovvdiaews TcirpayiMTeiiieBa; ibid. 239. 14. 1111 : irhrreis iv rots irepl tijs Kal irepm^y Kal (yKariaKevov SiwK-y tpp&aiv, ivip S>v iripwBl pjoi SijXoCtoi i ipfuivtav iireTrfSewcv i Aripu>< ratha \4yV, ixeiva ■/jmy- K&*r$i}v irpoeiireTv, £ireira, tva pot pij iwv&kwXos jj p.TjSe afoTTjpbs 6 X670S, dXX' e2v 'Attik&v pr)Topa>v alternates with irepl t5>v ap%aia>v prjTopcov. Such freedom in the use of titles is not strange in view of the general nature of the subject of the work, nor is it a matter for surprise that such a work 'Rabe, "Die rhetorischen Schriften des Diortys von Halicarrtass," Rheinisches Museum XLVIII (1893). 149, maintained that Dionysius always used the word (riiirafis in the sense of a work that is composed of parts. "Also riirajis ist immer eine Art ' Sammelband,' mag derselbe nun in Bticher getheilt sein, wie bei Deinias (Schol. Eur. Or. 872 .... Aeivlas iv 8' rijs irpdrris ffvirdfews), oder in solche Theile, wie bei Dionys (hier je 3 Kapitel?)." Among the passages which he cites is De Dem. 231. 19. 1099, iro\i y&p iv i) v, the word ypatprj is to be taken as referring to the collection of six essays rather than to the first three, for which Dionysius uses the term