STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 466 Notes and Discussions Mr. Dennison wrongly analyses this «am-clause; the words magno acciditcasu .... mortem do indeed contain a reference to the escape of Ambiorix, but after all the dominant thought is that of his peril : note that mortem, the last word of this part, repeats the thought of magno .... adferretur. In this way Caesar makes one thought, that of peril, run from first to last through this part of his illustrative example. Quite naturally the account of Ambiorix's escape from peril takes a little more space than is allotted to the account of his peril. Now, if w« were asked to sum up this whole «a?»-clause in terms of a noun, we should use the noun periculum. Part (a) has to do with peril faced, part (b) with peril avoided. Finally, in sic . . . . et ad subetmdum periculum et ad vitandum multum fortuna valuit we have a summing-up: "in this marvelous way, alike in the matter of incurring and in the matter of escaping peril, great was fortune's power." What has been said makes it clear why we have but a single noun in the gerundival group; where should that single noun,periculum, be placed save between the balanced gerundival phrases ? The balance that Mr. Dennison so sorely desiderates is here. Horace's words to Bullatius, quod petis hie est, apply. The balanced gerundival phrases correspond exactly, in anaphoric arrangement, to the two parts of the nam .... texerunt description. Further, multum here is not feeble. It repeats, as Caesar meant it to repeat, multum at the beginning of § 2; so far there is anaphora again, fortuna valuit was meant to recall potest fortuna, in chiastic fashion; there is also artistic variation of the verb. In conclusion let us take once more a survey of the whole chapter. For four lines we deal with Basilus; we see him on his way to kill or capture Ambiorix. Then Ambiorix becomes the theme. A general account of the tremendous influence that fortune always wields in human affairs and a specific account of the great role she played in one case incircle a description of a man 's terrible peril and his incredible escape from that peril. The chapter, then, is not weak at any point; no one but a consummate master of style could have written it. It may serve to remind us that in spite of its apparent simplicity the Bellum Gallicum is often highly elaborate and artistic in form. Chables Knapp Barnard College, Columbia University SIMIUS 7Sr^ = FANNIUS? Porphyrio ad Hor. Sat. i . 10. 18 notes that simius is used for simia, that the reference is to Demetrius, linked with Hermogenes in 90, and that the poet has chosen this word for Demetrius propter maciem ac Notes and Discussions 467 parvitatem corporis. As the word is probably used like simius in Seneca Controvers. viiii. 3. 12, Cesti simius est. solebat et Graece dicere, 6 TnOrjKo^ /ton, and like simia in Plin. Ep. i. 5, where Arulenus Rusticus is dubbed by Eegulus Stoicorum simia, with no reference to his appearance (Vitelliana cicatrice stigmosum), Porphyrio's explanation propter maciem, etc., may probably be regarded as based on his own inferences from the Latin text, or at least representing a tradition of like origin; and it is not impossible that, believing the reference to be to Demetrius, he has confused him with a later and more celebrated namesake, the actor Demetrius, mentioned in Juvenal iii. 99, whose stage mannerisms are described by Quintilian xi. 3. 178-80. The obvious reason for the reference in simius would seem to be the habit of some one who has been thought to sing slavishly after the manner of another, perhaps to ape Hermogenes himself. Now in 79, 80 of this satire, where Horace is replying to the strictures made on his Fourth Satire by various obtrectatores, Fannius is named in closer relation to Hermogenes than is Demetrius in 90: vellioet nosentem Demetrius aut quod ineptus Fannius Hermogenis laedat conviva Tigellif ineptus conviva implies almost as complete a characterization of tasteless servility as simius iste doctus cantare in 18, 19. In fact conviva, in order to have point, should connote a continued relation perhaps as constant guest and host, or parasite and patron. simius is also a metrical equivalent of Fannius and so to those familiar with the intimacy existing between Hermogenes and his ineptus conviva would come irapa ■KpoaBoKiav. Again, the juxtaposition of the words Her- mogenes and simius may have received point from the association together of the names of two of Socrates' disciples, Hermogenes, speaker in the Cratylus, and Simias of Thebes, speaker in the Phaedo. They are men- tioned together in Phaed. 59 b and c and especially in Xenophon Me^n. i. 2. 48 (ed. Marchant) in a series of names, koI 'Ep/x.oyo'r;? koI St/iuas. Horace like his cultivated contemporaries was familiar with the libri Socratici (Od. i. 29. 14; iii. 21. 9; A. P. 310; Sat. ii. 3. 11, 4. 3) and we may have here allusion to some jest of the Roman schoolboy. Lastly, Her- mogenes and Fannius are the only persons in Satire x who are also named in iv (21 ff. and 71 flp.). Without discussing the details of these allusions in the Fourth Satire, let us note the double contrast (1) vulgo (cuiquam, ubivis, quibuslibet) over against amicis and (2) Hermogenes over against Horace himself, vulgi Hermogenisque is perhaps like tS>v irepl 'Ep/xoyevr/v, Hermogenes and his coterie, which would include Fannius, who finger the latest popular literature instead of the Old Comedy. Geoege Dwight Kellogg Princeton University