STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. CONCERNING THE ORATORY OF BRUTUS By Edwaed J. FlLBET Did Cicero in his Brutus sive de claris oratoribus attribute to Marcus Junius Brutus the views which the latter actually held regard- ing oratory ? The testimony to be obtained from various sources — including other works of Cicero — relative to the general opinion held by Roman critics in regard to Brutus' oratorical style would seem to be somewhat at variance with Cicero's representation of Brutus in this treatise. Evidence external to the Brutus is first offered: § 1. Cicero and Brutus differed in their respective views of what constituted the best oratorical style. Each felt free to criticize the oratory of the other. Quintilian says that Brutus thought Cicero's composition somewhat unfinished: 12. 1. 22: "Quamquam neque ipsi Ciceroni Demosthenes videatur satis esse perfectus .... nee Cicero Bruto Calvoque, qui certe compositionem illius etiam apud ipsum reprehendunt." Tacitus represents Aper as saying, Dial. 18: "Legistis utique et Calvi et Bruti ad Ciceronem missas epistulas, ex quibus facile est deprehendere .... Ciceroni visum .... Brutum otiosum atque diiunctum; rursusque Ciceronem .... male audisse a Bruto . . . . ut ipsius verbis utar, tamquam fractum atque elumbem." Although Aper is here openly assailing these orators, his statement is apparently confirmed by an allusion to these letters in Quint. 9. 4. 1: " .... nisi et eiusdem aetatis homines scriptis ad ipsum [Ciceronem] etiam litteris reprehendere id collo- candi genus aussi fuissent." Quintilian makes mention also (3. 6. 93) of a difference between Cicero's and Brutus' manner of defending a case. But the difference seems to have consisted not in the style of oratory so much as in the principle to be followed in the pleading. In the concluding sections of the Orator Cicero gives unmistakable evidence of the fact that Brutus' views and his own are not in har- mony: Or. 237, 238: "Habes meum de oratore, Brute, iudicium; quod aut sequere si probaveris, aut tuo stabis si aliud quoddam est [Classical, Philology VI, July, 1911] 325 326 Edward J. Filbey tuum. In quo neque pugnabo tecum neque hoc meum de quo tanto- pere hoc libro asseveravi umquam affirmabo esse verius quam tuum." In the year 44 b.c, Cicero, in a letter to Atticus, shows not only that a general difference existed between his own style and that of Brutus, but also that his anticipation of Brutus' disapproval of his views as expressed in the Orator was realized: Att. 14. 20. 3: "Quid tu Bruto putas et ingenioso et erudito ? De quo etiam experti sumus nuper in edicto. Scripseram rogatu tuo. Meum mihi placebat, illi suum. Quin etiam, cum ipsius precibus paene adductus scripsissem ad eum 'de optimo genere dicendi,' non modo mihi sed etiam tibi scripsit sibi illud quod mihi placeret non probari." § 2. This difference of view was fundamental. Brutus' style was dull, serious, and blunt, and was lacking in ornament, variety, and spirit. In Tac. Dial. 21, Aper says: "Brutum philosophiae relinquamus; nam in orationibus minorem esse fama sua etiam admi- ratores eius fatentur." In the sentence following he speaks of Brutus' speech for Deiotarus as characterized by "lentitudinis ac teporis." He had already said (§ 18, supra) that to Cicero, Brutus seemed "otiosum atque diiunctum." In 25 Tacitus has Messalla say in the course of his defense of Cicero and the other orators of his period, Brutus included: "iure et prioribus et sequentibus anteponuntur. Nee refert quod inter se specie different cum genere consentiant .... gravior Brutus, vehementior et plenior et valentior Cicero; omnes tamen eandem sanitatem eloquentiae prae se ferunt Solum inter hos arbitror Brutum non malignitate nee invidia, sed simpliciter et ingenue iudicium animi sui detexisse." Quintilian intimates that Brutus' style was suited to philosophy, but was not eminently oratori- cal: 10. 1. 123: "Supersunt qui de philosophia scripserint Egregius vero multoque quam in orationibus praestantior Brutus suffecit pondere rerum; scias eum sentire quae dicit." Again Quintilian says, 12. 10. 11: "efflorescat .... oratorum ingens proventus. Hie .... sanctitatem Calvi, gravitatem Bruti .... reperiemus." In the Silvae of Statius, the recipient of a present com- plains of the poor taste exhibited in sending him the "dull speeches" of Brutus: 4. 9. 20: "Bruti senis oscitationes." Plutarch, Brutus 2, speaks of the sententious and laconic brevity noticeable in the Greek letters of Brutus: 6 BpoCro? 'EWtjvuttI .... ttjv awo^dey- Concerning the Oratory of Brutus 327 lxaTiKr)v Kal AaKCOviKrjv kiriTqhevwv fipwyvkoiyiav iv rat? e7rwTo\ai? eviaxov Trapdcrrjfjios iariv. Cicero complains of the brevity of Brutus' letters: Ad Brut. 1. 14. 1: "Breves litterae tuae, breves dico? Immo nullae: tribusne versiculis his temporibus Brutus ad me ? Nihil scripsissem potius." Brutus seems also to have incurred the charge of petulance and want of tact in his manner of writing to Cicero: Att. 6. 1. 7: "Ad me autem etiam cum rogat aliquid, con- tumaciter, adroganter, cucoivovorjTOK solet scribere." Seneca hints at something of the same sort: Suas. 6. 14: "Ferendam esse .... aut Bruti superbiam." When Cicero praises the elaborate Isocrates, Brutus demurs: Or. 40: "Horum aetati successit Isocrates, qui praeter ceteros eiusdem generis laudatus semper a nobis, non nun- quam, Brute, leniter et erudite repugnante te." In the same treatise there is an implied criticism by Cicero of the constant sameness of Brutus' style: Or. 110: "Tu autem eodem modo omnis causas ages? Aut aliquod causarum genus repudiabis ? Aut in isdem causis perpe- tuum et eundem spiritum sine ulla commutatione obtinebis ? " In his letters, also, Cicero shows that Brutus' style was less ornate and less impassioned than his own: Att. 13. 46. 2: "Legi epistolam: multa de meo Catone, quern saepissime legendo se dicit copiosiorem factum, Bruti Catone lecto se sibi visum disertum." And again: Att. 15. 16. 2: "Brutus noster misit ad me orationem suam habitam in con- tione Capitolina, petivitque a me ut earn ne ambitiose corrigerem ante quam ederet. Est autem oratio scripta elegantissime sententiis, verbis ut nihil possit ultra. Ego tamen, si illam causam habuissem, scripsissem ardentius .... corrigere non potui. Quo enim in genere Brutus noster vult et quod iudicium habet de optimo genere dicendi, id ita consecutus est in ea oratione, ut elegantius esse nihil possit. Sed ego secutus aliud sum, sive hoc recte sive non recte." § 3. There is some testimony tending to show that Brutus' style was not wholly without vigor, and that he at least recognized the value of ornament, as also of a careful selection of one's language. In Tac. Ann. 4. 34, Cremutius Cordus, the historian, is represented as saying: "Bruti contiones falsa quidem in Augustum proba, sed multa cum acerbitate habent." The natural intensity of character which Cicero seems to have attributed to Brutus is indicated in two letters to Atticus: Att. 14. 1. 2: "DeBruto .... Caesarem solitum 328 Edward J. Filbey dicere: 'magni refert hie quid velit, sed quidquid vult valde vult': idque eum animadvertisse, cum pro Deiotaro Nicaeae diceret: valde vehementer eum visum et libere dicere." Att. 14. 20. 3: "Quod errare me putas, qui rem publicam putem pendere e Bruto, sic se res habet; aut nulla erit aut ab isto istisve servabitur." In the Orator, after emphasizing Demosthenes' "figures of thought," and declaring that the essence of oratory is found in the ornamenting of one's sentiments with a kind of brilliancy, Cicero says that of this Brutus is as thoroughly aware as anyone: Or. 136: "Nee quicquam est aliud dicere nisi omnis aut certe plerasque aliqua specie illuminare sententias: quas cum tu optime, Brute, teneas " A little later, Cicero adds, Or. 227: "Nihil enim est aliud, Brute, quod quidem tu minime ignoras, pulchre et oratorie dicere nisi optimis sententiis verbisque lectissimis dicere." In Att. 15. 16. 2 (quoted in § 2, supra) Cicero testifies that Brutus employed appropriate sentiments and carefully selected words in his address to the people immediately after the death of Caesar. So few fragments of Brutus' oratory remain that no reliable conclusions can. be based upon the evidence they offer as to Brutus' usual style. It may be noted, however, that the letter of Brutus and Cassius to Antony, preserved in the cor- respondence of Cicero as F am. 11.3, exhibits plainly the qualities of severity, dignity, boldness, and great care in the selection of words. That Brutus strove to avoid a rhythmical style seems certain. Quintilian testifies however that his efforts were frequently unsuccess- ful: 9. 4. 76: "Itaque et versus hi fere excidunt, quos Brutus ipso componendi durius studio saepissime facit." § 4. A summary of the main facts presented by external evidence shows that (a) Brutus and Cicero favored different styles of oratory; 1 (b) Brutus blamed Cicero's composition; 2 (c) Brutus ranked higher as a philosopher than as an orator; in oratory he fell below his repu- tation; 3 (d) Brutus was grave, 4 dull and spiritless, 5 brief and blunt, 6 plain, 7 and monotonous. 8 !Oic. Or. 237, 238; Att. 14. 20. 3; Att. 15. 16. 2; Quint. 3. 6. 93. 2 Quint. 12. 1. 22; 9. 4. 1; Tac. Dial. 18. 3 Tac. Dial. 21 ; Quint. 10. 1. 123. 4 Quint. 12. 10. 11 ; Tac. Dial . 25. 6 Tac. Dial. 18; 21; Stat. Silv. 4. 9. 20; Cic. Att. 15. 16. 2. epiut. Brut. 2; Cic. ad Brut. 1. 14. 1; Att. 6. 1. 7; Tac. Dial. 25. 'Cic. Or. 40; Att. 13. 46. 2. scic. Or. 110. Concerning the Oeatoey of Brutus 329 The evidence introduced in § 3 offers no serious contradiction to this characterization. The severity attributed to Brutus in Tac. Ann. 4. 34 is what might properly be expected when a cold and unex- citable nature was impelled to act with firmness. Brutus seems to have been a man who felt strongly when important interests were at stake. Hence Caesar's opinion of Brutus need occasion no sur- prise when he says 1 that Brutus insists upon his wishes being carried out. Brutus' speech for Deiotarus, mentioned in the same passage, may have seemed to Caesar, as he says, earnest and bold. But it has been seen that Aper considered the speech dull and languid. 2 When Cicero writes to Brutus in the Orator 3 that Brutus is well aware how necessary an element of oratory ornament is to be judged, it can hardly be considered that Cicero intended to say more than that Brutus knew what emphasis Cicero himself felt should be laid upon ornament. That Brutus scarcely shared this view, Cicero sug- gests in the same treatise, 4 when he asks Brutus whether he intends to persist in using one style of oratory in causes of every sort. A careful selection of the sentiments to be expressed, as also of the words to be employed, seems to have been a characteristic feature of Brutus' style. 5 In brief, it becomes apparent that Brutus was one of that numerous class of Roman orators who strove laboriously to acquire a true Attic style, but who took as their model for this style not Demosthenes, but the plainest and most austere of his predeces- sors. Simplicity of thought, of composition, and of diction; the employment of only such expressions as were in strict accord with propriety; and an air of passionless dignity — these seem to have been striven for by Brutus as conscientiously as by any other of the would- be Atticists of his day. § 5. In certain passages from the Brutus, Cicero represents Brutus as holding views not greatly at variance with his own. Before the discussion proper, Cicero says that he has heard that Brutus' speech for Deiotarus was characterized by especial ornament and richness: 21: "causam Deiotari .... ornatissume et copiosissume a Bruto .... defensam"; also that on Brutus' account he lamented the loss of opportunities for public oratory, for which Brutus seemed so l Oic. Aft. 14. 1.2. 2 Tac. Dial. 21. 3 Cic. Or. 136. * Cic. Or. 110. 5 Cic. Att. 15. 16. 2; Fam. 11. 3; Or. 227; Tac. Dial. 25; Quint. 9. 4. 76. 330 Edward J. Filbey well fitted: 22: "tua et natura admirabilis et exquisita doctrina et singularis industria." In 118 Cicero represents Brutus as saying: "Quam hoc idem in nostris contingere intellego quod in Graecis, ut omnes fere Stoici prudentissumi in disserendo sint et id arte f aciant sintque architecti paene verborum, idem traducti a disputando ad dicendum inopes reperiantur." Cicero replies: 120: "Quo magis tuum, Brute, iudicium probo, qui eorum philosophorum sectam secutus es quorum in doctrina atque praeceptis disserendi ratio con- iungitur cum suavitate dicendi et copia." In 125, after Cicero has said, "Sed ecce in manibus vir et praestantissimo ingenio et flagranti studio et doctus a puero C. Gracchus; noli enim putare quemquam, Brute, pleniorem aut uberiorem ad dicendum fuisse," Brutus replies "Sic prorsus .... existumo atque istum de superioribus paene solum lego." In 204, Cicero has said that Cotta lacked fire, and Sulpicius humor. "O magnam inquit artem! Brutus: si quidem istis, cum summi essent oratores, duae res maximae altera alteri defuit." In 249 Brutus says that Marcellus' oratory is very like that of Cicero; further, that he, Brutus, is exceedingly pleased with Marcellus. In enumerating the latter's excellences as an orator Brutus declares that in consequence of Marcellus' careful selection of words, his brilliancy of speech and dignity of gesture, all that he says seems beautiful and splendid; that in fact he lacks none of the qualities necessary to an orator: 250: ". ... fit speciosum et inlustre quod dicit, omniaque sic suppetunt ut ei nullam deesse virtutem oratoris putem." Again, Cicero represents Brutus as enthusiastic over the praise given Cicero by Caesar, and as placing a high estimate upon what Cicero has accomplished in making the Latin language rich and fertile: 254: "Amice hercule, inquit, et magnifice te laudatum puto, quern .... principem atque invento- rem copiae dixerit Quo enim uno vincebamur a victa Graecia, id aut ereptum illis est aut certe nobis cum illis communicatum. Hanc .... gloriam testimoniumque Caesaris .... triumphis multorum antepono." When Cicero tells how he used the calm delivery of Calidius as an argument against the latter and suggests that there is a question as to whether such calmness is wise or unwise, Brutus is supposed to say: 279: "Atque dubitamus .... utrum ista sanitas fuerit an vitium? Quis enim non fateatur, cum ex Concerning the Oratory of Brutus 331 omnibus oratoris laudibus longe ista sit maxuma, inflammare animos audientium et quocumque res postulet modo flectere, qui hac virtute caruerit, id ei quod maxumum fuerit defuisse?" After Cicero has said that when Brutus heard Hortensius speak the latter was no longer in his prime, and was lacking in the ornaments that had characterized his oratory, he adds: 327: "Hoc tibi ille, Brute, minus fortasse placuit quam placuisset si ilium flagrantem studio et floren- tem facultate audire potuisses." At the close of the treatise, in an appeal to Brutus, Cicero says: 332: "Tu . . . . Brute .... effice id quod iam propemodum vel plane potius effeceras, ut te eripias ex ea quam ego congessi in hunc sermonem turba patronorum. Nee enim decet te ornatum uberrumis artibus .... numerari in vulgo patronorum. Nam quid te exercuit Pammenes .... si quidem similes maioris partis oratorum futuri sumus?" § 6. Somewhat opposed to the general tenor of these passages is a statement of Cicero contained in 309: "dialectica .... sine qua etiam tu, Brute, iudicavisti te illam iustam eloquentiam, quam dialecticam esse dilatatam putant, consequi non posse." It may be noticed also that in 250 1 Brutus names as one of the excellences of Marcellus the latter's use of carefully chosen words. His dignity of gesture is likewise emphasized. § 7. Summary of the characterization of Brutus' opinions and style, in the treatise, and conclusion: Cicero says that Brutus' speech for Deiotarus was ornate and rich; 2 that Brutus had been taught sweetness and richness of speech; 3 that Brutus would have been pleased with Hortensius could he have heard the latter when his ornateness and vigor were undiminished; 4 that Brutus is already the foremost orator at Rome, and possessed of all the ornaments the richest arts can offer. 5 Brutus is represented as saying that the Stoics while good at debate prove dry and meager in a speech; 6 that of the early orators he reads Gracchus most, whose style he considers the fullest and richest; 7 that fire and humor are two of the chief requirements of an orator; 8 that he considers Marcellus — and therefore Cicero — 1 Of. § 5, supra. * § 327. 1 § 125. 2 § 21. 6 § 332. 8 § 204. a § 120. 6 § us. 332 Edward J. Filbey a model orator, and thinks it desirable that one's oratory seem beauti- ful and splendid; 1 that it is a high honor to be the originator of a fulness of style, and that with this richness the eloquence of Rome rivals that of Athens; 2 that a calm delivery is a serious defect, for the chief function of an orator is to inflame his auditors. 3 On the other hand, Cicero says that Brutus has judged logic to be the foundation of true eloquence. 4 And Brutus lays emphasis upon a careful selection of words and a dignified delivery. 5 Cicero's statement 6 that Brutus' speech for Deiotarus was ornate and rich was quite certainly no more than a compliment, 7 in spite of the apparent support found in the letter to Atticus already quoted. 8 But the other statements both of Cicero and of Brutus considered in § 5 cannot be reconciled with the external evidence bearing upon Brutus' style and views. If it be accepted from external sources that the oratorical style and the ideals of Brutus were distinctly opposed to those of Cicero; that Brutus was, as an orator, "grave, dull, spiritless, brief, blunt, plain, and monotonous" — the conclusion reached in § 4 — it is impossible to believe that he had been taught sweetness and richness of speech, that he would have been pleased with Hortensius' ornateness, or that he was possessed of all the orna- ments offered by the richest arts. Nor is it credible that he would declare that the Stoics, whose style was so like his own, failed in a public speech; that Gracchus with his full and rich style was his favorite early orator; that humor was essential to the orator; that the listeners ought to be impressed with the beauty of an oration; that Cicero was for him the model orator; that the greatness of Roman eloquence was attributable to the originating by Cicero of a fulness of style; that a calm delivery was a serious defect; or that the chief function of an orator was to inflame his auditors. On the other hand, the statement of Cicero that Brutus has judged logic to be the foundation of true eloquence; and Brutus' emphasis upon a careful selection of words and upon dignity in delivery, are each in accord with his gravity, dulness, want of spirit, brevity, i g§ 249, 250. J §254. 8 §279. <§309. 5 §250. <> §21. 7 Cf. also Tyrrell and Purser Correspondence of Cicero VI, note, p. c: "Terms which it is impossible to regard as anything more than expressions of effusive polite- ness." »Cic. Att. 14. 1. 2 ; supra, § 3. Concerning the Oratory of Brutus 333 distaste for ornament, and monotony. It is quite credible that Brutus would have expressed just this opinion. How much of what Cicero says is to be attributed to politeness and considered but as complimentary to Brutus, cannot be determined. One conspicuous instance of such urbanity has already been noted. 1 It is possible that some of the other apparent inconsistencies are to be accounted for in the same way. However, Cicero took consider- able liberty in the handling of the characters in his dialogues, 2 and it is probable that he felt that to give the necessary weight to the expression of the views which he held regarding oratory and which he was endeavoring to emphasize in the treatise, he must represent Brutus' views as in accord with his own, rather than — more truth- fully — as at variance with them. A comparison of the evidence, external and internal, bearing upon the question under consideration seems to point quite definitely to the conclusion that, except in two instances, Cicero's representation in this treatise of Brutus' oratorical style and views does not coincide with the testimony from other sources; and that he does not, there- fore, represent correctly the point of view of Brutus. University op Nashville Peabody College fob Teachers 1 Cf . de 21, supra. 2 Cf. article on "The Literary Sources in Cicero's Brutus," byG.L. Hendrickson, AJP XXVII, 184.