STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE CHRONOLOGY OF THE YEARS 432 AND 431 B.C. 1 By Allen B. West The chronology of the years 432 and 431 is involved in difficulties. As given by Thucydides it is as follows: The battle of Sybota was fought in September, 433. 2 The Potidaean trouble commenced eWvs after this battle. 3 It was then that Athens made her per- emptory demands. The Potidaeans spent the winter, e/c xoXXoO Trpaaaowes, in sending embassies and making preparations, and in the following year Archestratos was sent out to enforce the Athenian demands. 4 He found Potidaea already in revolt 5 and turned his attention to Macedon. The revolt occurred eight months before the attack on Plataea. 6 Forty days after the revolt, Aristeus entered Potidaea. 7 While Aristeus was collecting his forces from the Pelopon- nese, Callias joined Archestratos 8 in Macedon, where they remained until the arrival of Aristeus. Then they marched leisurely to Potidaea and the battle followed. Six months later occurred the attack on Plataea, when the archonship of Pythodoros still had two months to run. 9 The attack was made, ana rjpi. kpxo^vw, at the 1 The purpose of this paper is to combine the hypothesis of Busolt, that the battle of Potidaea was fought in the tenth month before the attack on Plataea, with the one defended by E. Meyer, which gives the date of the attack on Plataea as March 5 rather than April 4. For the sake of completeness I shall restate many of their arguments, and to avoid cumbering the body of the paper with repeated acknowledg- ments, I shall content myself with a general acknowledgment of indebtedness in this place. The justification for a paper of this sort, on a subject so much discussed, is not so much in the combination of these two views as in the fact that I shall bring forward some new bits of evidence. For the presentation of Busolt's views and for a bibliography see Busolt, Griech. Gesch., Ill, 2, 799, note, and 907, n. 2; also, Hermes, 35, 573 ff. 2 Thuc. i. 45-51; IG, I, 179. * Ibid. 58. ' Thuc. i. 56-57. 6 Ibid. 6 Thuc. ii. 2, /mjk! Unrip ; i. 60-62. Here we have an interval of forty days between the arrival of Aristeus and the revolt and another interval up to the day of the battle. Thus we get a total of about eight months in all between the revolt and the affair at Plataea. ■> Thuc. i. 60-62. 8 Ibid. 61. The reading of the MSS, ivivap6prat, is plainly a mistake for iiriirapiivras. See below. » Ibid. ii. 2. [Classical Philoloov X, January, 1915] 34 Chronology of the Years 432 and 431 b.c. 35 very last of the month, in the dark of the moon. About eighty days later the Peloponnesians invaded Attica, dipovs ical rod airov &kh6.£ovtos. 1 The invasion lasted more than fifteen days and less than forty. 2 Shortly before the Peloponnesians left Attica the Athenians sent a fleet of a hundred ships to ravage the Peloponnesian coasts. 3 With the aid of inscriptions, we are able to supplement and correct this information which we get from Thucydides. 4 The discussion centers about two points. Is the reading pijvl ?ktw correct or should it be emended to benkry ? Secondly, is the Svo of Thuc. ii. 2 to be changed to T&Toapas or werre ? In the course of this paper I shall show that the battle of Potidaea took place in the tenth month before the attack on Plataea and that the archonship of Pythodoros still had five months to run when the attack on Plataea took place. As a result of these two changes the chronology will be as follows: Potidaea revolted shortly before the greater Dionysia, i.e., late in March, 432. Then the Athenian expeditions of Archestratos and Callias and the Corinthian expedi- tion of Aristeus are to be dated in the interval between the revolt and the battle of Potidaea, which was fought in Thargelion, May 15 — June 13, the tenth month before the attack on Plataea. The expedition of Phormio was then sent out, not in the year 432-31 as is generally believed, but late in the year 433-32. Plataea was attacked March 5, 431, and the Peloponnesians invaded Attica May 25-27, remaining until about the first of July. Toward the end of the invasion, June 27, in the ninth prytany, probably that of Hippothontis, the Athenian fleet sailed on its voyage about the Peloponnese. I In the first place we must consider the inscriptions mentioned above, which not only give us the following definite information, but also present the following questions for settlement. For the year 432-31 the first payment for an expedition to Macedon was made in the second prytany. 5 This payment was made directly to Eucrates, the general in charge of the expedition, of whom Thucydides tells 1 Ibid. 19. s Ibid , u. 23. 2 Ibid. 57; iv. 6. * IG, I, 179 06. 6 The second prytany extended from August 27 to October 4. 36 Allen B. West us nothing. That other payments, made during the course of the year for the army besieging Potidaea, went through the hands of the Hellenotamiai is evidence that the expedition under Eucrates was the only one sent out to the north during that year. During the course of this paper I shall attempt to show that Thucydides completely failed to mention this expedition of Eucrates. Nine payments were made to the Hellenotamiai for the army at Potidaea, approximately one for each of the eight following prytanies. Pay- ment seven was made in the prytany of Hippothontis, on the sixth or the sixteenth day. Payment eight was made during the same prytany. The ninth payment, which was for the cavalry, was made on the seventeenth day of an unknown prytany. In order to determine when the Athenian fleet sailed on its Peloponnesian ex- pedition in the summer of 431 it is necessary to decide whether Hippothontis held the ninth or the tenth prytany. We also have fragmentary accounts of the money spent for this fleet, in which the prytany of Hippothontis is again mentioned. In these accounts the first payment was made to the generals Socrates, Proteas, and Carcinos on the eighth day from the end of a prytany. Was this prytany the eighth or the ninth? The other payments for the expedition were made through the Hellenotamiai after the fleet had sailed. The first was made in the prytany of Hippothontis. The second was made in the prytany of ntis. Traces of two other payments follow. For a full understanding of the chronology of this year it will be necessary to compare the evidence of these inscriptions with the account given by Thucydides. First, a glance at the official calendar for the year in question will be necessary. 1 The year of the archonship of Pythodoros ended July 31. The official year of the Boule" ended August 12. The eighth prytany extended from April 18 to May 26; the ninth from May 27 to July 4; and the tenth from July 5 to August 12. I shall now attempt to show that Hippothontis held the ninth prytany. Let us assume for the moment that this was the case. We have seen that two payments for the army at Potidaea were made 1 See Keil, Hermes, 29, 321 ff. I wish to make a correction in the table opposite p. 358 for the year 431. Hek. 1 is given as August 1. The date for Hek. 13, however, is given as August 14. This is obviously a mistake for August 13. Chronology of thk Years 432 and 431 b.c. 37 in that prytany, the first on the sixth or the sixteenth day. The following payment to the cavalry was made on the seventeenth day of an unknown prytany, and it is hardly likely that three payments were made in the short space of twelve days. In that case we must assign the last payment to the tenth prytany. For the Pelopon- nesian expedition the first payment to the Hellenotamiai was made in the prytany of Hippothontis. Three payments followed this. It is of course possible that four payments were made in one prytany, but not probable. Thus, taking into consideration the two sets of accounts, it would seem that Hippothontis did not hold the last prytany. The question remains: Was the payment to the generals of the fleet made in the prytany of Hippothontis or in the one that preceded ? If it was made on the eighth day from the end of the ninth prytany, we must date it June 27. If, however, it came in the eighth, the date is May 19, but that is altogether too early, for we shall see that the earliest possible time for the beginning of the Peloponnesian invasion is May 25. We have no alternative. The payment to the generals was made June 27 in the ninth prytany, which, as we have shown, was probably Hippothontis. Another payment was made in this prytany to the Hellenotamiai. This happened after the fleet had put to sea, for otherwise the payment would have been made to the generals in command of the expedition. 1 II I shall now discuss the date of the attack on Plataea, showing that it took place March 5, and also that the Peloponnesians invaded Attica May 25-27, about eighty days later. Thucydides says that the archonship of Pythodoros had two months to run at the time of the attack on Plataea, but this is a mistake. We must emend either to a five or a four. Although it is a simple matter to explain the 8vo as a mistake for 8', the matter is not so simple as it seems. If we assume for the moment that 8' is the correct reading, the 1 Thuc. ii. 23. The account given by Thucydides is in agreement with that given above. He tells us only this, that the fleet sailed while the Peloponnesians were still in Attica, and that lack of provisions forced them to leave soon afterward. We may infer, however, that by far the greater part of the invasion preceded the departure of the fleet. The end of the invasion probably fell early in July. I shall discuss this point more in detail later. 38 Allen B. West attack on Plataea took place April 4. Eighty days afterward the Peloponnesians entered Attica, Bipovt mi rod airov aKiia^ovros. The number eighty is merely an approximation and gives us a limit of two or three days either way. Reckoning thus, the invasion com- menced some time between June 20 and June 25. It lasted more than fifteen days and less than forty. Thus the Peloponnesians left Attica, at the earliest, sixteen days after their arrival, or July 5, at the latest, thirty-nine days afterward or between July 29 and August 3. It is evident from our inscription that the fleet sailed about June 27, and we know that this was shortly before the departure of the invading army. Thus the Peloponnesians probably left Attica about the first of July. On the face of it, everything seems to fit in with our hypothesis that the attack on Plataea took place April 4, but we have been figuring more closely than the account of Thucydides warrants. The first invasion was not exceptionally short nor has any historian, so far as I know, made that assumption. We gather from Thucydides that it was at least of average duration, for he gives no sign that the Peloponnesians were in Attica only little more than two weeks. On the contrary, his account of the Peloponnesian stay, of the skirmishes, and of the discontent in Athens would lead one to assume that the invasion lasted longer than sixteen days. Busolt has suggested twenty-five days as its probable duration. 1 A further point is to be mentioned. Thucydides tells of nothing that happened after the departure of the fleet. The Peloponnesians remained only until their provisions were exhausted and then retired by a new route. Thus it would seem that this period must have been by far the shortest part of their stay, certainly not more than a third of the total, and it is impossible to assume that the departure of the fleet divided the invasion into two parts, approxi- mately equal, as would be the case if we assume that the Pelopon- nesians were in Attica only from June 20 to July 5, and that the Athenian expedition sailed about June 27. Now if we assume a stay longer than sixteen days, we are in greater straits than before. Let us accept Busolt's hypothesis that the invasion lasted twenty-five days. Then the Peloponnesians J Hermes, 35, 573 ff. Chronology of the Years 432 and 431 b.c. 39 must have departed from Attica about July 15. Busolt also reckons the period between the sailing of the fleet and the end of the invasion at about eight days. That is approximately one-third of twenty- five. I should agree with him on this point, but when he attempts to reconcile a payment made June 27 with the sailing of the fleet July 7, I cannot see the cogency of his arguments. According to Busolt the first payment cannot have been for the purpose of defray- ing the expenses incidental to the preparation, as has been suggested, for then there would be no payment to the generals immediately before their departure. Such a payment was usual and necessary. He goes on to say that the Athenians, whenever possible, preferred to pay out small sums at frequent intervals rather than to draw large sums from the sacred treasuries for the purpose of paying the expenses of an expedition far in advance. This was done in order to save interest on the money borrowed from the treasuries of the gods. Busolt's arguments are valid, but they cannot be used to prove his hypothesis. In fact, if rightly used they will disprove it. If the Athenians were as careful as Busolt suggests — and we have reason to believe that they were — they would not have paid out, as early as June 27, money which was not to be used until after the departure of the fleet ten days later. For proof of this we have the accounts for the rest of the year. The fact that of the four payments made during the remainder of the year three were made in the last prytany shows that in this case the interval between payments was thirteen days at most. It is scarcely probable, therefore, that the Athenians would have allowed this payment to the generals to be made ten days before the fleet sailed. Busolt also states that the payment to the generals was made shortly before their departure during the embarkation. Now the expression "kurz vor der Ab- fahrt" seems to be definite enough and to refer to an interval of at most two or three days, not one of nine. On the whole, Busolt's hypothesis has no great degree of proba- bility in its favor. In fairness to his argument, however, I must state that he bases his conclusions only in part upon the evidence given above. Perhaps his chief arguments come from the two phrases used by Thucydides, apa ?ipi apxofitvcp and dipovs teal rod a'vrov aK/xa^ovTos. In the first place, although he thinks that the 40 Allen B. West summer of Thucydides is not an artificial summer but one dependent upon natural phenomena for its limits, he says that a spring begin- ning early in March and a harvest in full swing in the latter part of May are impossible. It is evident, however, that an early spring will naturally be followed by an early harvest. It follows that if we can prove the Peloponnesian invasion to have taken place late in May, we have evidence that Athens enjoyed an early spring in 431 and likewise an early harvest. E. Meyer has shown that a harvest in May is not impossible; 1 and Busolt himself admits that in ancient times under favorable conditions the harvest began in May. The question remains as to the precise meaning of depovs /cat tov would be removed, but even this is not sufficient to invalidate our previous argument against that reading. If iwurap6vTas is the cor- rect reading and if the battle was fought September 15, Callias might have sailed on the first day of the second prytany, and his expedition might then be identical with that of Eucrates. Fifty or sixty days before his departure Archestratos sailed. Thus Archestratos left Athens shortly before the new year. Meyer accepts the MSS- reading evidently with these things in mind (G.d.A., IV, 287). This reckoning, however, does not avoid the difficulty that only one expedition was sent out to the 50 Allen B. West We can now take up the question of the expedition of Phormio in connection with our hypothesis that an interval of ten months elapsed between the battle of Potidaea and the attack on Plataea. After the battle the Athenian forces began the investment of Potidaea from the north only. When Athens heard that on the side toward Pallene the city was not invested, an expedition under Phormio was sent out. 1 A month's time is amply sufficient for all preparations. Even if we should date the battle early in June, Phormio 2 sailed before the beginning of the new year, and Eucrates some two or three months afterward. Things are now quite clear and we are free from all chronological difficulties, for the three expeditions mentioned by Thucydides no longer fall in the year 432-31. To continue, Phormio completed the investment of Potidaea and ravaged the Chalcidian and Bottiaean territories. About the month of September Eucrates was sent out against Perdiccas. This expedition is not mentioned by Thucydides, but the reason for the expedition is quite obvious. Perdiccas had deserted the Athenian cause just before the battle at Potidaea and was probably giving assistance to the Chalcidians, or perhaps merely threatening to do so. In any case the Athenians still had their interrupted spring campaign to finish and Therme, an excellent base of operations, was still in their possession. Athens probably had two objects in view: to punish Perdiccas and to prevent him from giving assistance to the besieged Potidaea. Thus this campaign was parallel with that of Phormio, and Eucrates was to keep Perdiccas busy while Phormio conquered the Chalcidians. In this way Athens tried to divide the forces of the enemy. Now that we have dated the revolt early in the spring of 432, we have plenty of time for Corinth to call together the dissatisfied Peloponnesian allies at Sparta before October 20. This they did immediately after Phormio completed the investment of Potidaea north in the year 432-31, and as a consequence we have no place for Phormio in the inscription, IG, I, 179a. The other difficulties discussed above are not affected by a change of reading. ' Thuc. i. 64. 2 1 can see no reason for assuming that the expedition of Phormio did not sail until September, as Busolt does. In fact, everything points to the conclusion that his expedition was sent out during the year 433-32. Chronology of the Years 432 and 431 b.c. 51 and soon after the passage of the Megarian decree, early in the year 432-31. 1 August is not too early for this meeting, and the Corin- thians could then demand an immediate invasion of Attica with some hopes of success. A month later the Peloponnesian synod met, and again the Corinthians insisted upon the necessity of doing some- thing for the relief of Potidaea before it was too late. An invasion of Attica might even then have been made and perhaps have been effective. Nothing was done, however, and nearly a year passed before the Peloponnesians crossed the Attic borders. The period of nearly nine months between September 1 and May 25 is much more in accord with the expression used by Thucydides than the six months between November and May. We have now about three months more time for the repeated embassies that passed between Athens and Sparta. Taking everything into consideration, we can be almost certain that the 'ticrc? of the MSS is a mistake for Senary. The one reading presents many difficulties; the other makes all go smoothly. VI Let us consider again the date of the attack on Plataea in the light of the preceding discussion. In the first place, I may say for the benefit of those who are still inclined to defend the April date, that such a hypothesis makes the reading eKTy more impossible than before unless they accept Busolt's reckoning 2 by which Boedromion becomes the sixth month. It will be well to consider the question briefly. The battle of Potidaea must have been fought in Pyanepsion, which extended from October 10 to November 7. It is now quite impossible for Phormio to complete the investment of Potidaea and for the first meeting to be held before October 20. The revolt of Potidaea, even if we accept the rejected eirnrap6vras, must have taken place after the first of August, and that puts three expeditions in the year 432-31, one of them certainly in the first prytany, and another in the third. All of this is quite impossible. VII Turning aside from chronology, I shall conclude the discussion with a few words upon the Athenian strategoi of the years 433-32 1 Thuc. i. 66 f. 2 See above. 52 Allen B. West Thucydides Busolt* Meyer Revised Revolt of Potidaea and sailing of Archestratos After battle of Sybota, (IIot«i- SettTCLl) *K TToWoit 7TpOIO, I, 179; cf. Thuc. i. 45, 51. In Thuoydides Andocides is named in place of Dracontides, evidently by mistake. 4 Thuc. i. 57. The MSS-reading is ner' 1 SKKay Sixa. This is of course impossible. The number cannot be greater than two. 6 Ibid,. 61. « Ibid. 63 f. 7 Kirchner, Prosop. Att., No. 13099.