STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Eeviews 187 "Gracchus," he says, "could tell a tale, like that of the cruel wrongs inflicted on the allies, which could arouse a thrill of horror without also awakening the reflection that the speaker was a man of gi'eat sensibility and had a wonderful command of commiserative terminology." We have dealt with the early, and to our mind, the more important, part of the book so fully that we cannot discuss in detail the author's treatment of the early career of Marius. Contrary to tradition, he assumes (cf. p. 301) that Marius was not a man of low origin. By way of conclusion, a few points may be noted in connection with the style and language of the book. The narrative portions are particu- larly well done. The stories of the struggle between Tiberius and Octavius (pp. 119-25) and of the death of Gains (pp. 139-43) are very effectively told. At many points, however, the book is not an easy one to read. Sentences frequently require a second perusal before their exact meaning is grasped. Of minor matters we should prefer "vocations" to "avocations" on p. 41; the phrase "relationship of clientship" (p. 803) is kakophonous; "revealed" on p. 72 seems to be a typographical error for "rivaled," and Marius can hardly have been said to "identify" himself with a cause (p. 306). There are some admirable political maxims in the book, one or two of which we cannot refrain from quoting: "The truth that a suzerain can not treat her subjects as badly as she treats her citi- zens may be morally, but is not legally, a paradox" (p. 154); "Of all political temperaments that of the moderate is the least forgiving, just because it is the most timorous;" "intellect which unconsciously used emotion as its mask." To the bibliography on pp. 487-89 may now be added the important article by Kornemann, Zw Geschichte d. Gracchen- zeit, in the first Beiheft of Beitr. zur alt. Gesch. and Warde Fowler's Notes on C. Gracchus in the current and forthcoming numbers of the English Historical Review. Taken all in all, the book is the most interesting, as well as the most scholarly and judicious, history which we have of the closing years of the second century, and will make the reader eager for the volumes which are to follow. Frank Frost Abbott The Speeches of Isaeus. With Critical and Explanatory Notes. By William Wyse. Cambridge: University Press. 1905. Pp. Ixiv -I- 735. 18s. net. The Introduction contains a full, readable, and precise accoimt of the manuscripts and editions of Isaeus, and a list of subsidia. The text, handsomely printed, with critical notes, occupies pp. 1-174. The closely printed commentary occupies pp. 175-723. Three indexes cover eleven pages. The text seems a trifle less conservative than that of Thalheim (published by Teubner), which was passing through the printer's hands 188 Book Reviews at the same time. Attic forms are restored, on the basis of inscriptions — not only vo? for vios, ^/i^eo-ySj/Tow for ^/x<^icr;8j;Toi)v, and the like, but also aiToSti^avTiov for diroSuidToxmv. The commentary is a thesaurus of ma- terial for the illustration of the speeches. New light is brought from the papyrus documents of Egypt. Most difficult points are discussed with much learning. The illustrative matter is so abundant that the commentary is entertaining as well as instructive reading. In so exten- sive a work a scholar who is familiar with Isaeus may expect to light upon details in which he does not agree with the editor. E. g., on v. 17, where the litigants agree to a mixing (a-vyxeai.) of the votes before the announcement of the result was made. "It is plain (our editor says) that, when, as at this trial, 500 ^5^01 lay unsorted on the abacus, it was hard to tell at a glance whether the prosecutor had triumphed, unless perforated i/r^^oi were in an immense majority .... The words a-vyxiat Tcts il/rjipovi are intelligible, if the compromise was not reached until the work of arranging and ordering the votes was completed." But if the work was completed, then the time was past for a compromise. We may suppose the abacus to have had twenty-five rows of holes, with twenty in each row. Naturally the perforated i/^^oi were set in rows at one side and the unperforated at the other side, in such a manner that a glance of the eye could determine whether a ^<^os had been set in the wrong column, and also which of the two battalions was the more numerous. Before one hundred 1/^(^01 had been set in place, unless the judges were very evenly divided in opinion, anyone who saw the abacus could tell what the general result was likely to be, and long before "the work of arranging and ordering the votes was completed," the litigant who saw that he was defeated would be ready for a compromise, and well might seek to avoid a formal decision. The time was not then past for a friendly settlement. This was the situation in v. 17. The most serious criticism of this edition of Isaeus, however, does not rest on details, but on the plan. Often, when a critic desires more than is given, a reply is ready at hand: "This would have been pro- vided but for limitations of space." But where an editor finds room for an incidental note of four pages on horses in Attica, and for half a dozen pages on "The Descendants of A" (the Codex Crippsianus), manuscripts which can have no critical value, the critic is justified in observing the lack of what is necessary for the fullest understanding of our author. The editor's Introduction is devoted exclusively to manuscripts and edi- tions. He gives no general statement with regard to Isaeus as an orator, and his relations to Lysias and Demosthenes, although Isaeus' chief interest on the rhetorical side lies in his being the leader of the one and the follower of the other, nor does the editor speak with regard to the relation between the Xoyoypdcfioi and his client. Much excellent infor- mation is given about court procedure, but no systematic presentation of Book Reviews 189 the matter is made. Very likely space might actually have been saved by putting together facts and principles. Certainly space would have been saved if the editor had stated clearly and once for all his criticisms on the tricks and fallacies of Isaeus. The reader wearies of the repeti- tion of sentences like the following: "In vituperation Greek pleaders are absolutely reckless, and Isaeus is a man who would stick at nothing." The editor, indeed, is so constant in his endeavors to show that the orator is dealing falsely, and assumes so confidently that the orator in every case must be on the side of injustice, that the reader involuntarily takes the side of the orator, with some irritation. The editor might fairly have called attention to the statement in the -ye'vos 'laatov, which he prints, that Aucrtas /J-iv koi vircp aBiKwv iirtiOc Xeymv, 'lo-aios St koI vvip dyaOiSv Xiyiov vironToi ijv. But he might have reminded his reader, on the other hand, that Athenian laws in general were brief and vague, and that large liberty of interpretation was left to the courts; that the 400 or 500 judges felt themselves to be a sort of executive committee of the Ecclesia — they had made the laws and they might interpret or even change them; that justice was regarded less than equity, so that no liti- gant was satisfied with showing that the letter of the law was on his side, and not infrequently a litigant would urge his cause, although the letter of the law was clearly against him; that no previous decision of a court was to be cited as determining the meaning or the scope of a law, and that no officer, corresponding to our judge, was present at the trial with authority to rebuke the speaker if he misstated or misinterpreted the law, or to charge the jury as to the relation of the law to the evi- dence; that the writer of the speech did not appear before the court in any way; and that a speaker could not be held accountable legally for any misstatement of facts in his speech, although the witnesses were responsible for any damage caused by their false testimony. The order of intestate succession to an inheritance, and the limitations of time set for speeches, are fturther matters which call for systematic exposition in such a book. Would such statements and discussions be too elementary for our editor? His commentary contains much matter that is equally elementary and not so fundamental. Some of these subjects, but not all, are set forth in the editor's chapter on Law in Whibley's Companion to Greek Studies. The editor's treatment of elision and hiatus seems a trifle indolent. Since for most of the orations we have only a single manuscript, it is simple to follow this in this matter. But why should not the editor of Isaeus be as exact as the editor of Homer in indicating ehsion, that the reader may know what is regarded as hiatus? Why should anyone care to follow the manuscript in printing