STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. CICERO'S AMALTHEUM By Prank Gardner Moore Cicero's desire to imitate the Amaltheum of Atticus first appears in 61 B. 0., in the well-known letter on the acquittal of Clodius (1. 16). Atticus had sent him certain epigrammata of his own production : Epigrammatis tuts, quae in Amaltheo posu- isti, contenti erimus, praesertim cum et Thyillus nos reliquerit, et Archias nihil de me scripserit (§ 15). The mention of Thyillus and Archias is sufficient evidence that the verses were in Greek. Clearly the statues or busts placed by Atticus in his Amaltheum were to be provided with suitable inscriptions in metrical form. The comparison with those men- tioned by Nepos is inevitable. The latter were, of course, in Latin, and Nepos found much to praise in their terseness (Nepos Att. 18. 5, 6). He does not imply that Atticus honored any others than statesmen and generals with his elogia in four or five verses. 1 It was certainly in this class, rather than as an orator, that Cicero received his place among the statuary of his friend. There is no positive evidence that Atticus' collection of sculptured heroes of Roman history was limited to the Amaltheum, rather than variously disposed about the villa. But, with the certainty that he would place his friend's portrait in a position of honor, it is difficult to resist the conclusion that the essential feature of the Amaltheum was an out-of-door gallery of Romans eminent in public life or in warfare. At all events, Cicero was not merely curious to learn what this feature of Atticus' Epirote estate was. He knows enough of its nature already to desire to reproduce it upon his paternal Arpi- nas: Velim ad me scribas, cuius modi sit 'A/MiXdeZov tuum, quo ornatu, qua TO-rroOeaCa, et, quae po&mata quasque historias de 'That Atticus' metrical elogia were at least in circulation among his friends, if not formally published, is the only reasonable inference from the context in which Nepos mentions them, although the reference to imagines leaves us in doubt whether the biographer has in mind the original busts or statues, or drawings of some kind in an idition de luxe. [Classical Philology I, April, 1906] 121 122 Frank Gardner Moore ' AfxaXQela habes, ad me mittas. Lubet mihi facere in Arpinati (§18). In view of the strange conflict of legends gathered about the name of Amalthea, it is not strange that he should ask to know Atticus' literary authorities, whether as a guide in the purchase of statues or reliefs, or merely for his own enlightenment as to what an Amaltheum was, as distinguished from an Academy, a Lyceum, and the other features prescribed by landscape archi- tects for the correct villa — much as the new-fledged country gen- tleman of today must needs discover pleached walks and all the other lore of the colonial garden. As for the first motive, the question of the sculptures is fully provided for under quo ornatu, and we are forced to conclude that the second motive prevailed, but may well assume that something more than mere novelty attracted him to the idea; and the problem does not lose in interest on account of the uncertainty as to just what the Amal- theum of Atticus was. It has been held, 1 and is still maintained in Pauly-Wissowa, that the name was also given to the entire estate of Atticus near Buthrotum. Certainly it is a striking fact that there is no name for the estate corresponding to Formianum, Arpinas, and the like. The practice for extra-Italian estates, to be sure, may have differed from the familiar custom, and one must regret the lack of accessible information as to how the Greeks named their coun- try places. Little light is thrown upon the name of Atticus' estate by the commentators on Cicero's Letters. Thus Tyrrell: Amalthea was a villa of Atticus in Epirus, so called from the neigh- bouring shrine of the nymph Amalthea. It is sometimes called Amal- theum. The adjectival form is generally used as in Tusculanum, but cf . Caieta, above: Att. i. 4. 3. 2 Caietam .... ornabo, however, is an inconclusive example, for the name of the town might be used in lieu of the name of the estate, just as Att. 2. 20. 2; ab Amalthea tenon commovebo, does not prove that Atticus or Cicero would have thought of calling the estate itself Amalthea. Nothing more is involved than a graceful metonymy, as in Caieta above. 3 That the same figure would give •Orelli (Mom., after Ernesti; Pape Eigennamen; Wernicke in Pauly-Wissowa. *On Att. 1. 13. 1. 3 0f., in 1. 13. 1, the playful, and purely figurative, caesis apud Amaltheam tuam victimis. Cicero's Amaltheum 123 Amaltheum a wider range than "shrine of Amalthea" is obvious, but the single occurrence in Cicero (Leg. 2. 7) does not justify the assumption that the entire estate bore that name, and there is no other tangible evidence. All the support to be found for that theory comes from association of the name with 'AfiaXffeuvs icepa<; as applied to rich and well-watered estates or parks. But the passage 1 which is chiefly relied upon makes the 'A/xa\0eia<; icepa<; a toVo? in an aX<70?; in other words, plainly a limited spot, not the grove or park as a whole. Hence, conceding that the prover- bial significance of the term was amply satisfied by the plane groves of Atticus on the banks of the Thyamis, 2 proof that Amal- theum was equivalent to Villa Abbondanza, or meant to its owner anything more comprehensive than Cicero's Academy at his Tus- culanutn, is entirely lacking. There can be small doubt that it was but one feature, like the Tusculan example just cited, or Hadrian's Canopus at Tivoli. To the question what the Amaltheum was, various answers have been given — a library, 3 a gymnasium,* a museum, 5 a sanctuary, 6 a building or room containing the library and portraits of famous Romans with pertinent inscriptions,' the estate itself. 8 The only detailed discussion of the Amaltheum known to the writer is that of O. E. Schmidt, 9 who sees in it a garden-house, in form perhaps resembling a small basilica, with a fountain, and wall-paintings depicting scenes from the legends of Amalthea, interpreted by inscribed verses, while busts or statues of distinguished men with elogia completed the scheme of decoration. That it was a library rests upon no securer ground than the common fashion of adorn- ing libraries with the busts of eminent men of letters. The only literary man "whom we know to have had a place in the 1 Duris ap. Athen. 12. 542: Kal T\ri 'ItttuvIov ir6Xews 4\opov koX KardfifrvTov HSa