STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE DEATH OF MENANDEK By William Scott Fbeguson The excellent article of Dr. Clark in Classical Philology I, pp. 313 ff., has convinced me that the archonship of Philippos, and hence the death of Menander, do really belong to 292/1 B. c. His proof, which is grounded on the sound maxim that the birth- years of celebrities were often ascertained in antiquity by calcu- lation, while the years of their death rested upon contemporary records, starts with the pretty demonstration that Menander and Epicurus became ephebes, the former in 325/4, the latter in 324/3. Dr. Clark is thus enabled to maintain the report of Strabo that the philosopher and the comedian were a-vve(f>ri^oi, while he discards the false combination that, for this reason, they were both born in 342/1. 342/1 was the well-established birth- year of Epicurus ; the birth-year of Menander, on the other hand, was 343/2, and since he lived 52 years his death occurred in 292/1, or, as is otherwise recorded, in the thirty-second year of Ptolemy Soter's reign (323/2-285). There are still some weak places in this argument, but it is doubtless the best solution of the problem thus far reached,' and it is not invalidated by Wilhelm's new doctrine of the /SacriXeia {Urk., pp. 215 ff.), or by his redating of IG. II 2. 975 f. {ibid., pp. 63 ff. ). In my Priests of Asklepios (p. 150) I rashly affirmed that the location of Philippos in 293/2 was now beyond doubt. This I should like to emend. What I should have said is that the sequence Philippos-Kimon is indubitable ; for that the words used to characterize the activity of Phaidros, hoplite-general in Kimon's year (/tai rriv iroKiv ekevOepav koI 8riiJ,OKparov/jLevrjv avro- vofiov irapeScoKev Kal tov? vofxoxK KvpioxK toI<; fied' eavrov IG. II 331 ) , presuppose the presence in the city of the oligarchic leaders, iWilhelm Urkunden dramatischer Auffuhrungen, pp. 249 f., uses the same argu- ments as Clark, but he is apparently afraid of the logical conclusion. Menander, he says, "Konnte als Mann von (freilich noch nicht erreichten) 52 Jahren bezeichnet werden " in the end of 293/2. In other words he was 52 in 292/1. [Classical Philology II, July, 1907J 305 306 William Soott Ferguson exiled in 307/6 and recalled in Philippos' archonship, should be manifest to anyone who has studied the party struggles of Athens at this period. Beloch, indeed, asserts the contrary {Griech. Gesch. Ill 2, p. 36). But apart from the improbability of a dangerous revolutionary activity being displayed by a small band of dispersed and discredited exiles, we have the authority of Philochoros, who states expressly that no constitutional crisis preceded the return of the oligarchs.' On the other hand, if the danger referred to in the decree was the disposition of Demetrius to re-establish the exiles, Phaidros could have had no share as hoplite-general in averting it, since the pleasure of the king was not revealed till the year of Philippos. At its beginning it lay in the province of prophecy to foretell the recall of the oligarchs.^ It may accordingly be taken as demonstrated that Philippos preceded Kimon directly. But so far as this datum is concerned, Philippos-Kimon may be placed in either 293/2-292/1 or 292/1- 291/0. Phaidros, however, as hoplite-general in Kimon's year, irepi- aiv6fi€vo<; ael ra Kparicrra, Kal top alrov e/c t?j? %<«>/>a? Kot T0V9 aXKow KapTTois aiTio'; iyevero elaKo/jLtadrlvai, avp,^ovXevcra'i TOit Bi]fi(oi (Tvinekea-ai .... (erasure of about 38 letters because of some reference to Demetrius) . The country was thus in danger, but the threatened invasion did not ensue, and the crops were harvested in safety. The attack was expected in harvest time, that is, in March- April of 291 or 290. This peril of Attica can be brought into connection with two events only — with the second revolt of Boeotia, and the appearance of the Aetolians on the frontier. The first of these occurrences is not dated strictly, but from the general account of Plutarch [Demetrius 39 f. ) it is possible, indeed, that the siege of Thebes lasted as late as March- April 291, but it is improbable that the prospects of the revolters were at that time so good that the democrats in Athens were iDlonysius of Halicarnassus (Beiske), p. 637. ^Ibid., ToC S' ivmiTov rovSe SieKBimos, iripov S' fUnbvTos. Then follows the omen of a dog on the Aeroiiolia, and its application by the seer, Philochoros himself, to the recall of the exiles. The annalistic arrangement of Philochoros' ' PltBU makes it clear that we have to do with the beginning of the year in which the main incident occurred. The Death of Menandee 307 tempted to secede also, or that it was feasible for the Boeotians or Aetolians to break through the Macedonian lines and menace Attica in their rear. Still, this contingency cannot be excluded altogether. On the other hand, the Aetolians hung upon the Attic frontier in the early half of 290. This we know from the celebrated Ithyphallos, sung when Demetrius came to Athens later on, in Boedromion (September) of this same year.' His point of departure on this occasion was Corcyra, where he had been dallying with Lanassa, Pyrrhus' runaway wife, instead of attending to his proper business. The Aetolians took the oppor- tunity of his absence to plunder his possessions far and near. They even seized the Delphic sanctuary (290/89, i. e., before Boedromion, 10. II 309). The Athenians were obliged to fight in their own defense. Hence the appeal made to the king in the Ithyphallos to take the Aetolians in hand himself. Another course was open to Athens in this emergency. It might have joined the Aetolians and Pyrrhus, and thus have taken sides against its overlord, and this was, in fact, what the people wished to do; but a revolt at this time would have been most unwise, as the events of the next few months showed. Hence Phaidros took credit to himself at a later date, not for preventing the revolt — he was too shrewd a man to jeopardize the honors he was soliciting by appearing as the opponent of so desirable an issue — but for forestalling its consequences. Secession, he claimed, and with good reason, would have resulted in Demetrius' taking the control of affairs from the democrats and giving it to the extreme oligarchs, who, embittered by a long exile, would have instituted a reign of terror in the city. The temptation to break away from Demetrius was at this time all the greater in that, in the very last days of Phaidros' generalship (supposing Kimon to have been archon in 291/0), or in the very first week of that of his successor, a Ptolemaic fleet under the command of Zenon appeared in Attic waters. It conveyed a gift of corn to Athens, 1 Athenaeus vi. 253 c. The last doubt as to the connection of the Ithyphallos with the coming of Demetrius to Athens in September of 290 has been set aside by the recent discovery of Bourguet (i' administration flnandire du sanctuaire pythique au i»« siicle avant J.C., pp. 141 if. ; of. Pomtow Klio VI, pp. 92 f.) that the Pythia, which the king celebrated in Athens after his arrival, came in October, not in August. 308 William Scott Ferguson doubtless from Philadelphus, though significantly enough its donor is not named in the Athenian decree from which we learn of the incident [IG. II 5. 3096). Zenon was probably commis- sioned to incite sedition in Athens, but, as we have seen, Phaidros and other moderates induced the Athenians to wait. In summary it must be reiterated that, while the evidence thus far presented favors iJ91/0 for Kimon, nothing decisive has been made out. No one knew better than Phaidros the state of Philadelphus' preparations for a war with Demetrius, since he had been in Alexandria in one of the years between 296/5 and Kimon's archon- ship. This we learn from the following passage of IG. II. 331: Ktti «7ri NiKiov fjikv apxovTos a-Tparrjyoi viro tov 8^/aov x'^p°^ovrjOel<; im. r^v Trapa(rK£vr]V Sis iravTwv S)fx, irpoarrJKev iTre.iJ.eX.TJ9r) KaX.w's Kal (jsiXori/jiox;- Kot eiri. Trjv Xmpav j(£ipoTovj;0£is irXtovaicis Kal em. toiis ^ci/ovs yevo/MVO's Tpis T^v iracrav eiro-q- (Taro CTTTOvS^v oirios av ol (rTpariioTai. d)s apurra KaT{e)pav several times and had charge of the mercenaries three times. Struck by this seeming impossibility, I suggested {Klio V, p. 161), that TrXeovuKK carried us back of 296/5, and Beloch {Griech. Gesch. III. 2, p. 377) concluded that the order of events was dis- regarded in that the embassy to Egypt belonged four years later than 291/0. This was, beyond doubt, harsh treatment of the text; for elsewhere in the document the chronological sequence is strictly adhered to, and it can, I think, be shown now that both of us were wrong. For to my contention the objection is fatal that Phaidros must then have held the generalship iirl rrjv xmpav before that iirl t^v -jrapaaKev/jv, or the praetorship before the aedile- ship. But this is unprecedented and quite unlikely ; for the for- mer office involved serious military duties, while the latter, so far The Death of Menandee 309 as we can judge, was a purely civil post. Against Beloch, on the other hand, it can be urged that it is clear from IG. II 5. 3096 that Athens had already opened negotiations with Egypt in 291/0 or earlier. Hence if the embassy of Phaidros is taken out of its context in IG. II. 331 (295/4-292/1), and placed later than his chief generalship, we are obliged to replace it by another quite similar embassy. In other words the embassy of Phaidros is needed before 290/89 to explain the relations existent between Egypt and Athens on the eleventh of Hekatombaion of that year. It would be equally erroneous to date any of Phaidros' general- ships cttI Tf]v x^P"'^ after 291/0; for in that year, at the latest, he was commander-in-chief, and had thus reached the summit of his military career. Subsequently he held no lower military oflBce. We conclude then, that, since Phaidros was general iin ttjv Xoipav several times and commandant of the mercenaries thrice in the four (or three) years between 296/5 and Kimon's archonship, he must have held these offices simultaneously. On the other hand, we contend that from the moment it is shown that the gen- eralship eVi Tr)v x^P"-^ ^^/3ay for four years in succession (295/4-292/1) {icaX enl ttjv %«/3ai' x^tpoTovrjdeh TrXeom/ct?), and he was put in charge of the mercenaries three times [kuI eVl roi)? feVow ryevo/xevo'; rpk). In this dual capacity he exerted himself stoutly that the mercenaries should be properly equipped and do their duty (Trjv Traaav iiro'qcraTO aTrovSfjv OTrax; dv ot crrpaTiaiTai,