STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE OLYMPIC VICTOEY OF AGIAS OF THESSALY By Kbndall K. Smith Inscribed upon a long pedestal' at Delphi, beneath one of the nine cavities cut in the top to receive the plinths of statues, are these elegiac verses: IIpSTos 0A.v/i9rta TrayKpdnov, ^aparaXu, viKas Ayta Akvoviov, y^s "^""o ©tccaXtas, irevraKis cv Ne/te^, rpts Tlvdia, TrevraKW IctO/jloi- Kai croiv ovSeis irco OTTJare rpcnraia )(iptav.^ According to this inscription we have in Agias the first Thessalian to win the pancratium at Olympia. My object in this paper is to propose a date for that victory, the importance of which is not limited merely to the field of historical research but has also its bearing upon the history of Greek literature. For as long as the victory of Timodemus, the Athenian pancratiast, is left undated, so long will the dating of Pindar's second Nemean ode^ and its position among his works remain in doubt. Any narrowing of the field brings nearer the solution of that literary problem, and may ultimately decide the disputes of Fraccaroli, Schmidt, Christ, and others.* Since Agias was the first Thessalian to win the pancratium at Olympia, his victory must come before 408 b. c, for another Thessalian, Polydamas, won in that year.'* Therefore, he belongs in the fifth century at the latest. If the date proposed in this paper be accepted, Christ's dating of the second Nemean ode in the years 459-51 b. c. will have to be given up, and choice made between the extremes, either before 480 b. c, or after 448 b. c* ^Am. Jour. Arch. XIII (1909), pp. 447 ff. ^Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), pp. 592, 593. sSchol. Nem. 2, 4: nerii, yip t^v Ne/teaxJ)!' vlK-qv i(TTe(pavovTo tA '0Xv when still a boy, or, supposing him to have been ^Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), pp. 595, 596. 2 E. Preuner Ein delphisches Weihgeschenk, p. 17. ^Herme.-) XXXV (1900), pp. 141-95. 4 The victors in the other years are : 432 B. c. ) 428 y Dorieus of Rhodes (Foerster, Nos. 258, 260, 262). 424 ( 420 Androsthenes (Poerster, No. 267). 416 or 412 Androsthenes, 2d victory (Foerster, No. 272). — H. Poerster, Die Sieger in den olympischen Spielen, pp. 19, 20. ^Bull. Cor. Hell., loc. cit. ^ Preuner op. cit., p. 16. 'R. G. Kent A History of Thessaly from the Earliest Historical Times to the Accession of Philip V of Macedonia, pp. 9-10, 18, 19. Cf. E. Meyer Theopomps Hellenika, pp. 247 fE. He gives as dates ca. 445-415 B. c. The Olympic Viotoby op Agias of Thessaly 171 no more than twenty at that time, that Agias, his father, had been married some eight years and was about thirty-eight years old when he won his victory. Then, as we raise the son's age, the father's increases as well. However nominal this office of apx<>>v may have been, an age of thirty seems none too young at which to take it up. If, indeed, he was thirty in 431 b. c, his father must have been mar- ried in 462 B. c. (or earlier, since we cannot say that Daochus was the oldest son. He is certainly not named for his grandfather). And if Agias married in 462 b. c, even supposing him to have been only twenty-two, then a victory in 444 b. c, eighteen years later, would bring him into his fortieth year. For these reasons, the placing of the rule of Daochus between 431 and 404 b. c. seems bound to carry his father's victory back before 444 b. c, hence to 460 b. c. The authority for this extraordinarily long rule of twenty-seven years, unrecorded elsewhere in history, comes from an inscription' on the same long pedestal at Delphi on which Agias is commemorated. The details given of a rule over all Thessaly "not by force but legally," together with what is otherwise known about Thessalian affairs, suggest that this was an elective office with few real powers. Now, after Lycophron's victory in 404 b. c.,^ there was no peaceful stretch of twenty-seven years in Thessalian history until the days of Macedonian dominion. In 431 b. c.,^ Thessalian contingents came to Athens not from any central government but by cities. Into the intervening period the rule of Daochus just fits. One slight fact points to the location of supreme authority in the year 424 b. c. at Pharsalus, the home of Daochus.' Brasidas in that year attempted to pass through Thessaly and sent a messenger to friends of his in Pharsalus, by whose help, or rather, by rapid march- ing, he succeeded in getting through the country.^ Thessaly during this period was a neutral, and the peace and plenty recorded in the inscription may reflect this attitude. Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), p. 593: Adoxos ' Ayla elfii, irarph 4»(£/?(ra\o5, dir(£(r7;5 BcaaoKiai dp^as oi ^ig. dXXA ySfxCf) einb, Kal etKoiTL sttj- ttoXX^ 5^ Kal dyXaoKdpwif} elp'^vri TrXoiVy re e^pve OeffiraKla. ^Xen. Hell. 2,3, i. 3Thuc. 2, 22, 3. < Brought forward by R. G. Kent op. cit., pp. 10, 18, 19. 6 Thuc. 4, 78, 1. 172 Kendall K. Smith The chief support, however, for this date must come from the dates of the son and grandson of Daochus, both of whom are com- memorated by inscriptions on the family pedestal at Delphi.' Sisyphus,^ the son, was a brave warrior; Daochus II, the grandson, was tetrarch of Thessaly and hieromnemon of the Amphictyons at the time when he dedicated this monument to his family.' In the case of Daochus II it has been shown by HomoUe* and Preuner^ that he must have held these offices between 339 and 332 b. c, and that he was active politically as early as 352 b. c. If we take 338 b. c. as a working date and compute each generation at 33 years — the number found most workable by Kirchner in his Prosopographia Attica — the time between 404 and 338 b. c. is seen to cover exactly the required span of two generations, sixty-six years. In other words, the known date of the grandson harmonizes with the assumed final date of the grandfather. By the same method of calculation we secure as the correspondi'ng date in the life of Sisyphus 371 b. c. (338+33). Is it possible that this is the same Sisyphus mentioned in the history of Theopompus,'* 1 For reference a family tree is given liere : Flor. Aparus 518 b. c. Acnoniug 485 B. c. I I I I Telemachus Agias Agelaus 452 b. c. Daochus I (431-404) 419 b. c. Sisyphus I 388 b. c. Daochus II (339-332) 353 b. c. Sisyphus II 320 B. c. ^Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), pp. 593, 594: O^K e^evai 7J 67JK€V inrot-KTv6v(i}v. *Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), p. 595. ''Preuner op. alt., pp. 7-12. « Theopomp. ap. Athen. 6, 252F. The Olympic Victory of Agias of Thessaly 173 and so necessarily active in or before 394 b. c, the year with which the history concludes? To have been a prominent figure in 394 b. c, or earlier, he must have been born not far from- 425 b. c. Then in 371 B. c. he would have been about fifty-five years old. If, then, for purposes of computation, we consider that one generation or 33 years later (i.e., 338 b. c), Daochus II was also flfty-five, he must have been fifty when appointed tetrarch and have worked in Philip's interest at the age of forty-one; none of which are unreason- able ages. Then, turning to Daochus I, if we assume that in 404 b. c. he also was fifty-five, we obtain the not improbable age of twenty- eight for his election(?) as ruler of Thessaly.' Or, if we apply the test of generations to the date of Agias himself, quite apart from the twenty-seven years of his son's rule, we obtain fresh support for the year 460 b. c. as opposed to 444 b. c. For, the calculation by intervals of thirty-three years gives to Agias the year 437 B. c, as the date toward the end of his career corresponding with the age fifty-five computed for his descendants. If, now, we consider him to have been fifty-five years old in 437 b. c, it is impossible that his great Olympic victory came in 444 b. c, when he would have been forty-eight years old. Even if we assume that there was a variation of ten years from the iron-clad succession of generations that we have been using, he remains thirty-eight at the time of his victory. On the other hand, the date 460 b. c. allows us to retain the full length of the generations and makes his age when he won, thirty-two.^ Thus the calculation by generations is not only in complete accord with the supposition that Agias' son was ruler of Thessaly in 431-404 B. c, which carries with it a preference for the date 460 b. c, but independently favors that date itself. The foundations of such an argument as this are admittedly weak. Hypothesis rests on hypoth- esis. But the resultant date is certainly reasonable. I have no doubt that the correct date is either 460 or 444 b. c. The facts at 1 Indeed, if any change is desired, it would be towards adding to his age, therewith increasing the probability that the Sisyphus of 371 b. c. was the Sisyphus of 394 b. c. 2 Whether his other victories — 3 Pythian, 5 Netnean, 5 Isthmian — were grouped around, preceded, or came after his Olympic victory, we cannot say. They cover a period of at least nine years. But even if they all preceded it and it was the culmina- tion of his athletic career, he can have won his first victory in 470 b, c, at the age of twenty-two. 174 KEND.iLL K. Smith present ascertainable seem to point rather to the former year. In this I have the support of Preuner, who looked for a date before the middle of the century. This can only be 460 b. c. If we place his victory in that year, we can fill the lacuna in the Oxyrhynchus papyrus and complete the list of winners in the pancratium between 480 and 448 b. c. Then the victory of Timodemus, which Robert wanted to place in 460 b. c' and which must have come there to maintain Christ's dating of the second Nemean ode, will have to fall outside this period, and be dated either before 480 or after 448 B. c. There is one uncomfortable doubt still left undecided. Did Telemachus, the brother of Agias, also win an Olympic victory? The inscription^ on the pedestal states that on the same days he won the same number of crowns at wrestling as his brother did in the pancratium. If one of them was won at Olympia, we shall be obliged either to move to 464 b. c. (which is vacant) Amesinas of Cyrene, whose victory in wrestling is placed in 460 b. c. by Julius Africanus,' or else transfer Ag'as to 444 b. c. The indefiniteness of the inscription, however, and its omission to speak of an Olympic victory by name, lead me to believe that while Telemachus may have won as many times as his brother, he did not win at Olympia, and that rjfiaa-i tok ainoh cannot be pressed too literally. I have not allowed this point to enter into the argument because of its uncertainty. And if it is felt that the inscription does intend to attribute to him an Olympic victory in the same year with Agias, I should be inclined to question the accuracy of the dating of Amesinas rather than to remove Agias from 460 to 444 b. c. Harvard University 1 Vermes XXXV (1900), p. 183. ^Bull. Cor. Hell. XXI (1897), p. 593: K(l7(Ij TovSe &iMi8e\tpo[s €](pvv, &pi6^v 5^ t6v avrbv vikGjv )itovi'07rd\[7;s], ^\yD\ff'riviav Si &vSpa KpiruTTOv KTetva, iBi\ovTo[s iov 1]ri\4iiaxos 8' iTO/iia. SEuseb. Chron. I, 203; H. Foerster op. dt., p. 16, no. 225.