STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Notes and Discussions 365 Je connais le sort, il peut de'mentir: De la nuit du silence un secret peut sortir; Et des dieux quelque fois la longue patience Fait sur nous a pas lent descendre la vengeance. It will be observed now that the obligation of the Irish borrowing rests between von Logau and Longfellow. From the lack of more exact knowledge of the source whence the editor of the Irish collection obtained the verse, however, I can render no further judgment than that, in my opinion, the probabilities of origin point to Longfellow. 1 Edwaed Godfrey Cox Cornell University GREEK LAW IN ROMAN COMEDY In every discussion of Plautus or Terence, the fundamental question always is the degree of fidelity to their originals which we must assume for them. In the pages of the principal periodicals dealing with the history of Roman law, we meet at every point with a very intelligible distrust of Roman comedy as a fons iuris, which, however, is based much more on the non-Roman character of the subject-matter than on the peculiarities of the literary genre in which it is found. If the point which the following observations seek to establish is valid, there are numerous cases in which the suspicion is unfounded. Two passages of Plautus, Stichus, vss. 446 ff ., and Casina, vss. 68 f., are referred to by Kriiger, Geschichte der Quellen des rom. Rechts, p. 77. Stichus, vss 446-48: atque ne id vos miremini homines servolos potare amare atque ad cenam condicere licet haec Athenis nobis. The purpose of these lines is explicitly stated. They are meant to explain a situation which would otherwise excite surprise, even though taking the audience into one's confidence in the very course of the action is a somewhat primitive device. The same effect is better produced in the Casina passage because it is there done in the prologue, the natural place for explanations of this sort. Casina, vss. 68 f.: sunt hie inter se quos nunc credo dicere: quaeso hercle quid istuc est?serviles nuptiae? It is immaterial whether this passage together with the first part of the prologue is non-Plautine or not. Audiences had not appreciably changed in Rome between Plautus and the succeeding generation. With these, a number of other passages may be compared. 1 Since writing the above article I have come upon, in an Irish newspaper, a word- ing of the proverb in question which sounds less literary than the verse quoted at the beginning : Is mall meilid muilte D6 — The mills of God grind slowly. 366 Notes and Discussions Rudens, vss. 723, 724: Labbax: mihi non liceat meas ancillas Veneris de ara abducere! Dabm.: non licet: ita est lex apud nos. Palaestra and Ampelisca have taken asylum at the altar of Venus. To a Greek, the inviolate character of such sanctuary was a commonplace. But Roman law knew no such limitation of the owner's dominium. "What's this? " bawls the leno, echoing the indignant astonishment of every slave- holder in the audience, "Am I not to be permitted to take my chattels where I find them?" " Not in Cyrene," is the answer. "That's our law." It is quite unnecessary to point out that these lines are not at all needed for the dialogue, and that their purpose is the same as that of the other passages. Oaptivi, vss. 449 ff.: Heg.: sequere me, viaticum ut dem a tarpezita tibi eadem opera a praetore sumam syngraphum. Tyn.: quern syngraphum? Heg.: quern hie ferat secum ad legionem hinc ire huic ut liceat domum. Tyndarus' question brings an answer which makes clear to the audi- ence the purpose of the Greek syngraphus. The somewhat similar ovufioXov in Aristophanes (Birds, vs. 1205) requires no such explanation. Pseudolus, vss. 55-58: ea caussa miles hie reliquit symbolum expressam in cera ex anulo suo imaginem ut qui hue adferret eius similem symbolum cum eo simul me mitteret. Again vss. 648 f. nam istic sumbolust inter erum meum et tuom de muliere — Ps. scio equidem: ut qui argentum adferret atque expressam imaginem suam hue ad nos, cum eo aiebat velle mitti mulierem. Twice, therefore, purpose and value of the symbolus are explained in full. A Greek audience could hardly have failed to be bored by this painstaking setting-forth of a well-known Greek custom. In Herodotus (vi. 86) in a very similar case, it is simply said owroSaKviWes to. o-vufioXa drrairtov to. xprj/AaTa. Compare with all these a passage in the Phormio of Terence. In spite of his closer adherence to his originals, Terence, no more than Plautus, forgets that he is speaking to Romans in Rome. Vss. 125, 126: lex est ut orbae qui sunt genere proximi eis nubant et illos ducere eadem haec lex iubet. Vss. 295-97: verum si cognatast maxume non fuit necesse habere: sed id quod lex iubet dotem daretis: quaereret alium virum. Vss. 415, 416. an ut nequid turpe civis in se admitteret propter egestatem, proximo iussast dari? Notes and Discussions 367 Taking these together we have a clear and complete statement of the Attic iirtBiKcuTux. We can hardly assume that such an explanation was found in Terence's original. The Athenian for the reasons advanced in vss. 415, 416 was not a little proud of this custom and surely would not need to be told in detail of what it consisted. The original of the Phormio, the Epidikazomenos of Apollodoros, contained in its very title the technically exact name of the procedure. We may notice, however, that Terence exhibits much the greater skill. The explanation is not patched into the story, nor set forth didactically in a single speech, but unfolds itself gradually in the course of the dialogue. Besides that, it is the young rake Antipho who receives it, a gentleman who may have been ignorant of more things than the rudiments of law. In the Mostellaria of Plautus, vs. 1034, we have again the matter of asylum, and, this time, without explanation. But when we compare this with the Rudens passage, the reason becomes at once apparent. In the Budens, the asylum is a matter of the utmost consequence. It produces that intertwining of the Daemones and the Palaestra story, without which there could, of course, be no denouement, no untwining. If the legal implications of an asylum are not fully apprehended, the connec- tion between the two stories becomes, for a Roman audience, purely mechanical. On the other hand, the altar-scene in the Mostellaria is merely a farcical interlude, and the attention of the audience is engrossed, even here, by a situation which always delighted them, the mock-reversal of the master and slave relation. With the passages from the Pseudolus, we may compare Bacchides, vss. 263, 264: eo praesente homini extemplo oBtendit Bymbolum quem tute dederas, ad eum ut ferret, Alio. Here the self -same symbolus is mentioned without a syllable of the explanation so profusely offered in the other play. But in the Pseudolus, the whole knavery of the slave depends upon the peculiarities of the symbolus and cannot be understood unless these are known, while in the Bacchides, the symbolus is simply incidental and is only casually alluded to. We may draw the conclusion that Plautus, and Terence as well, accept Greek legal situations only where they are dramatically indifferent. In other cases, their law must be assumed to be Roman law, since when it is Greek law, it is rendered intelligible by some form of explanation. The care displayed in such matter may furnish an additional confirma- tion of the dictum of Emilio Costa, who found in his studies of Plautus and Terence an intima penetrazione del diritto nella vita. Max Radin Newtown High School New York City