STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. MARON: A MYTHOLOGICAL STUDY 1 By Charles B. Newcomer In the ninth book of the Odyssey Homer makes Odysseus describe at some length that wonderful wine with which he sub- dued the Cyclops Polyphemus. It had such strength and sweet- ness that it was drunk mixed with twenty parts of water. Soon after setting out homeward from Troy, Odysseus and his men landed on the coast of Thrace and plundered the Ciconian city Ismarus (later called Maronea). 3 As a reward for sparing the shrine of Apollo, Odysseus received twelve jars of this wine from his priest Maron, Euanthes' son. Odysseus says Od. ix. 196 ff. : arap alycov oktkov €X ov /n«Aavos oivoio fjScos, ov fioi ISoHce M.apmv Evav#eos vlos, ipevs AiroWwvos, os "la/xapov a./i.i(Sef$iqKei.v. The scholiasts thought it strange that Homer did not connect Dionysus, the wine-god, with this passage, which treats especially of wine, and that he did not make Maron the priest of Dionysus rather than of Apollo. This perplexity was caused, as I believe, by their misunderstanding the word evavdife, originally an epithet of Dionysus. Now, evavdifc, "blooming," might easily become, with changed accent, Evowtfj??, the "Blooming One," a fitting name for Dionysus, the god of vegetation. Athenaeus, quoting from Phanodemus, gives evidence in favor of this view. He says, xi. 465 a, that the Athenians rjcrdemes ovv ry icpdcrei iv pSat? epekirov tov Aiovvcrov, %opevovTe; leal avaKaXovvrei evavdrj teal SiOv- paftfiov Kal fia/cxevrav teal flpo/uov. Here evavO^i is manifestly an epithet of Dionysus. But not all the ancients misunderstood the name "Euanthes." Euripides in the Cyclops makes Maron a son of Dionysus, fol- lowing, as I think, the '08vvXov, h.drpap,vv, TLvdvOr], TavpoiroXiv. From this series of old traditions we learn that Maron was the son or grandson of Dionysus. But how might Maron, son of the wine-god, become priest of Apollo, the god of soothsaying, at this ancient shrine of Ismarus ? Let us consider the association of Dionysus with Apollo at other shrines. In Greek religion the gods were largely made after the image of the worshipers. While they were anthropomorphic, they were also superhuman — mightier than men, whom they might benefit or harm according to their pleasure. Men courted their good- will and invoked their assistance, feared their wrath and sought to appease it. Thus many men of various needs and in various circumstances and places prayed to one god, who then came into Maeon: A Mythological Study 195 the possession of many attributes. Witness the numerous epi- thets and by-names applied to any popular divinity. Apollo. — The attributes and characteristics of Apollo are especially manifold. He appears as sea-god, sky-god, and earth- god. The meaning of the word "Apollo" is uncertain; hence we get no light as to the origin of the god from its derivation. There is a tradition that sailors carried the worship of their pro- tecting sea-god to Crisa and Delphi; cf. Preller-Robert Griech. Myth., pp. 257 f. Possibly they came from Crete, where Apollo Delphinius was worshiped; CIG. 255. 4: iv Kvcoaa) iv ra> UpS> to> ' Att6XX(opo^ tS Ae\ivico. At Delphi the cult of Apollo super- seded that of the chthonic oracle god Pytho. Poetically expressed, Apollo slew the python. But as god of oracles he only expressed the will of Zeus, and that too through the priestess Pythia. Much missionary work was done from Delphi. Wherever the worship of Apollo was introduced into other parts of Greece, he was said to kill the native god or hero and take his place. But in each case he would assume some of the functions of the native god. Thus Apollo appears as the god of farming, vegetation, spring; of cattle-raising, the chase, growing youth; of the palaestra, strife, and battle; of oracles, oaths, treaties; of expi- ation, healing, as dispeller of all evil; of music, dancing; of death ; of sea-faring, capes and mountains, colonization, commerce ; of light, the sun. Dionysus. — More is known of the origin of Dionysus. Kretschmer derives the name from Ato? and vvcro';, the Thracian word for "son." See Aus der Anomia, pp. 22 f. ; cf. vvad — vv/u,T), Koprj, and Nvcmt, the "Maidens" on the Sophilus vase, Ath. Mitth., XIV (1889), Taf. I; also the inscription Ato? v (^a/iat, j£0a/j.aXo?), Lat. humus (humilis), "earth," homo (humdnus), A.-S. and Goth, guma, "man." 196 Charles B. Newcomer There is manifold evidence that Dionysus came comparatively late into Greek religion, and that he immigrated from Thrace. He is pre-eminently a nature-god and, like Demeter and Cora, comes and goes with the seasons — has his epiphanies and reces- sions. Homer mentions Dionysus in but one passage, the Glaucus episode in the sixth book of the Iliad, considered by some critics as a late addition. Here he is not yet an Olympian, but may be frightened by the wrath of the mortal Lycurgus, and flees to Thetis for refuge. Later we find him represented among the Olympian gods — e. g., on the frieze of the Parthenon. Vase- painters of the sixth century B. C. picture his triumphal entry into the assembly of the Olympians; cf. Miss Harrison, Pro- legomena, pp. 366 f. The historians all ascribe to Dionysus a Thracian origin, while the poets — influenced, no doubt, by the patriotism and vanity of the Greeks, who were averse to acknowledging a barbarian origin for so popular a divinity — make him a native of Thebes who returns in triumph after wandering to the far East. Herodotus (v. 7) says of the Thracians: 6eoiK Be creftovrai fiovovs rovcrBe- "Apea Kal Aiovvcrov /cal "Aprefiiv. In another passage (viii. Ill) he gives an account of a famous oracle shrine of Dionysus situated upon the mountain heights of the unconquered Satrae. The priests were chosen from the tribe called Bessi. As at Delphi, it was a priestess that pronounced the oracles. Since this people remained unconquered for hundreds of years, we may believe that Dionysus was their native god. His oracle, which remained famous till Roman times, is referred to by Euripides in Hecuba 1267: o ®pyi;l fidvTR ei7re AtoWcro? TciSe. Pausanias (ix. 30. 9) says that the people of Libethra, a city on the Macedonian side of Mount Olympus, received an oracle sent from Dionysus in Thrace. This must be the famous Thracian Dionysus just considered. Amphiclea was an ancient city lying to the north of Mount Parnassus. In x. 33. 11 Pau- sanias tells of an oracle shrine situated there, nrp6ixavTi<; Be 6 lepevs ecrrt, %pa 8e e« tov deov «aro^o?. The fact should be noted that Dionysus advances southward upon Grecian territory, and that he still preserves his prophetic gift. We find him next on Mabon: A Mythological Study 197 Mount Parnassus sharing with his brother Apollo the temple at Delphi. The worship of Dionysus greatly fascinated the Greek mind, and soon spread over all Greece. The ruins of theaters in every considerable Greek city are witness to the spread of his religion; for the performances of dramas in his honor were acts of public worship. In Attica Dionysus was more especially the god of intoxicating wine and the accompanying joys; while in the Delphic cult-myth he was still considered rather as a nature-god, the god of vegetation and animal life; and as such he died and had to be called back to life every second year by the thyads. Pausanias says (x. 4. 3) : al Se dvidZes oiTa>crai 8e e? rov Tlapvacrov irapa eVo? avTai re Kal al yvvalices Ae\cj>a>v ayovcriv opyia At,ovva Aiovvacp teal T(p 'AttoWcovi fiaivovrai. Note the words "rave in honor of Dionysus and Apollo.'''' The worship of Apollo is not only partly super- seded by that of Dionysus, but is contaminated as well. At Delphi the three winter months (Dadophorius, Poetropius, Amalius) were sacred to Dionysus. During this time Apollo was said to be banished among the Hyperboreans, and the Del- phians invoked Dionysus back to life, especially under the name Zagreus. Cf . Plutarch De el apud Delphos 9 : ^Aiwvcros^ v &(\G>v ovSiv t/ttov rj t 6ea> (names of actors, musicians, and other performers). It is to be noted that here again the Apollonia, always mentioned first, correspond to the older lyric portion of the Athenian state festival, and the Dionysia to the later dramatic portion. An inscription (JGr. II. 570) giving an account of disburse- ments of the Attic deme Plothea contains the items: "for the Apollonia 1,100 drachmas, for the Pandia 600 drachmas." The Pandia at Athens were the last act in the City Dionysia; Mommsen Feste d. Stadt Athen, p. 433, n. 1. If the same may be inferred for Plothea, we have here again the same order of Maeon: A Mythological Study 199 development as at Athens: first the lyric, then the dramatic part of the celebration. Phlya was a rich Attic deme situated some five miles northeast of Athens in a fertile district capable of supporting a large popu- lation. This was the birthplace of Euripides, and, I think, the home of the old Attic family of the Lycomids, who performed mystic rites here. The orgies of the Great Goddess, Earth, with Bacchic mysteries, were said to have been celebrated here even before the mysteries were instituted at Eleusis. Here were altars and temples of many gods and goddesses. Pausanias (i. 31. 4) mentions altars of "Flowery" ("Ai'&o?) Dionysus and of "Dionysus- given" (Aiowvr]6pos) Apollo at Phlya mentioned by other writers; cf. Plut. Them. 15; Herod, viii. 11. Just what relationship this Dionysus-given Apollo had to Dionysus himself may not be evident, but the epithet proves some association of the two gods. The Homeric instance of the union of Dionysus and Apollo is too early either to explain their connection in Greece or to be explained as the result of missionary influence from Delphi. For Rohde (Psyche, pp. 295 ff.) gives much ancient testimony and cogent arguments showing how the orgiastic worship of the Thracian god was introduced comparatively late into Greece ; and how it contaminated the cult of Apollo. But at Ismarus it is not at once evident which god first pos- sessed the shrine. If Ismarus was originally a Greek colony with pure Apollo-worship, Dionysus doubtless won his claims as he did later in Greece. But if Dionysus was the original possessor of the shrine at Ismarus, the Apollo-worship must have been introduced by Greeks. This might have been a slow and peace- ful conquest, a matter of education. If so, the partisans of Dionysus had sufficient influence to retain their priest Maron, the reputed son or grandson of Dionysus (Euanthes), while Apollo became the god of both parties. But conquest also might bring about a similar result; for conquerors often reverently spared the shrines of peoples they subjugated. Thus Apollo, the god of the victorious invaders, 200 Charles B. Newcomee might take up his abode in the old Dionysus temple, retaining the old servants and even the priest. At any rate, such a cus- tom prevailed in the middle of the fifth century b. c, for the Athenian decree establishing a colony at Brea in Thrace expressly commands the colonists: ra 8e re/tew) ra i^rjprjfieva eav icaOdirep ea-Ti, Kal dWa /j.t) re/ievi&iv ; IG. I. 31; Hicks 2 41; Dittenberger 2 19; Roberts-Gardner Inscriptions of Attica 8. We have seen that Apollo and Dionysus were brothers, and as such possessed many attributes in common. They might share a common temple or receive the homage of the same worshipers at religious functions. The shrine at Ismarus presents us the most ancient instance of their union. University of Michigan