STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 373 tabulation and renders a real service. (5) The many translations of Latin passages are invariably accurate, as one would expect. That they did not always strike the present reviewer as being felicitous, is only a proof that a former student may some day presumptuously differ from an honored master. Typographical slips are creditably rare, although bletat (p. 102) is rather startling. One must regret the printing of words and phrases from various languages in the same type as English words, the few exceptions in the text only serving to emphasize the confusion. Feed B. R. Hellems Sophokles. Erklart von F. W. Schneidewin und A. Nauck. Zwei- tes Bandchen: Konig Oedipus. Elfte Auflage besorgt von EwaldBruhn. Berlin: Weidmann, 1910. Pp.239. M. 2.20. Sixty years ago Schneidewin first published his school edition of the Oedipus Tyrannus. At his death in 1856 the work of revising his Sophocles passed into the hands of the great conjectural critic, August Nauck, who issued one edition of the plays after another, the ninth of the Oedipus Tyran- nus appearing in 1886. Bruhn published the tenth in 1897. In text and commentary the present edition is an improvement on its predecessor. This manifests itself in some cases, viz., vss. 667, 840, 1182, 1309, 1461, in the rejection of conjectures adopted in the tenth edition, in favor of the reading of the MSS. But in 463 and 806 also the reading of L and other codices should have been kept, as in the previous edition. Bruhn now reads eJSe in 463, but, in support of tine and the participle, cf. Soph. El. 676, O.C. 1580, Plat. Gorg. 481c, etc.; and he adopts Robert's conjecture riys rpoxoXdrov in 806 in preference to the MS reading tov Tpo^Xarijv, which occurs in the same story in Eur. Phoen. 39. Vs. 13. Bruhn would omit ov. This is wrong; cf. Dem. 19, 123, Philem. 213, Herod. 2, 110, Plat. Lys. 212d, etc. pi) ovk l x «>v in 221 illus- trates the same principle, but here the editor without warrant gives to each negative a separate negative force. Vs. 31. opai in the sense of "advice contributed (p.<£epav) by others." For a better interpretation in which ^ovAcv^twv is made to depend on £a>cras jaaAiora, cf . Classical Philology II 94 f . Vs. 360. The reading adopted in the text rj Tripa \iyew is inferior to ij 'KirapcT \6ymv, which is implied in L and supported by a scholium. Vs. 586. There is nothing "indefinite" about the protasis d . . . . avu Aoyw is to be preferred. Vs. 659. Clearness and symmetry demand vyr]v rather than tftvyeiv. Vss. 702 f. M. Seyffert's 374 Book Reviews iyKaXctv !x e 's an< l Bruhn's conjecture riic/jap (709), which are adopted in the text, are both unnecessary. Vs. 917. If, as seems likely, the original reading of L was d . . . . Xeyoi, this should be adopted in preference to yjv . . . . Xeyrj, since it is amply supported by Ai. 521, 1159, 1344, O.C. 352, Ant. 666, 1032, O.T. 314, 979, etc. Vs. 1021. ^vopa^tro is an affectionate middle, " he called me his own child." Emendation is not needed. Vs. 1064. The imperative Spa suits Jocasta's excited state of mind (cf . 1056, 1057, 1061) better than the infinitive Spav (so Bruhn), and it is not necessary that 1064 should conform in structure to 1065. Vss. 1462 f . In adopting the fern. dual forms raXv 1462, alv 1463, 1466, Tavraiv 1504, Bruhn accepts the evidence of the MSS (see Kuhner-Blass I 604; II 584) in preference to that of the inscriptions (Meisterhans 3 123). Cf. toiv iXoiv SaKpvppoovvroiv 1472. In the Critical Appendix wo a-rpacpel's 728, Kar^XO' 117, and oXtOpov 1343 are attributed as conjectures to Ed. Schwartz, but the first comes from the MSS, the others had been made by previous scholars, F. Ascherson and Turnebus, and all are found in one or more texts. It goes without saying that in spite of criticism this is an excellent edition of the play, improved through a long series of revisions. Charles W. Peppler Emory College De poetarum Atticorum arte scaenica quaestiones quinque. Scripsit Paulus Gbaebee. Gottingen: Dieterich, 1911. Pp. 60. M. 1.50. The more important conclusions advanced in this dissertation are as follows: "In Aeschylus and twice in Sophocles, when a new character enters the scene, he converses first with the chorus (or coryphaeus), even if another actor is already present; especially striking instances are Persae 249 and 681. Of course, this practice arose in the one-actor period and lapsed after the addition of a third actor. Incidentally, it has a bearing on the stage question, for it is inconceivable that an actor should regularly ignore another actor on the stage beside him in favor of the chorus in the orchestra below" (chap. i). The second chapter, "De choro et histrionibus," contains little that is new except the hypothesis that the number of choreutae in the early chorus was fifteen, which was reduced to fourteen, thirteen, and twelve as the first, second, and third actors were added by the successive promotion of coryphaei. There is no use pointing out that this ignores the traditional derivation of tragedy from a dithyrambic chorus of fifty, for Aristotle and his statements on this subject are utterly de trop nowadays and it is popular to trample them under foot; in fact, Graeber is himself a convert to Dieterich's theory that the histrionic element in Greek drama came from Eleusis. But Grae- ber's hypothesis also runs afoul of comedy; for, since the formal recognition