STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 433 brack and others. Meyer's arguments that the account in Herodotus is colored by Athenian perversion of the facts has been rather generally accepted. On the basis of the pre-Periclean evidence and the evident admiration expressed for Pausanias by Thucydides, Wright supports and furthers this view. But the only new elements which he brings into the discussion in attempting a reconstruction of the detailed movements of the battle have not gained my credence. Induced by a statement in the Laches of Plato, he explains the final movement of the Greek forces which brings on the battle as a " feigned retreat with the deliberate pur- pose of drawing the Persians" into a depression disadvantageous to them. The victory is due to this feigned retreat, an evidence of the " consummate strategy " of Pausanias. I can not but doubt the wisdom of basing Pausanias' claim to strategic ability upon a movement which exposed a somewhat inferior Greek force to attack, when it was separated into three distinct divisions, one of which did not seem to get into the fighting at all. For these are the actual facts of the battle as they appear in Herodotus — and after all is said and done we must still rely upon him alone for the general outline of the engagment. Wright's dissertation furnishes an excellent starting-point for any future discussion of the campaign, because of the completeness of the evidence here collected. It would have been advisable to insert Grundy's map of the battlefield, to which Wright continually refers, instead of the complicated tabulation of the evidence which appears at the end. W. L. Westeemann University of Minnesota History of U-Stems in Greek. By William Cybus Gunnebson. Chicago dissertation. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1905. Pp. 72. $0.75. That the border-line is an unfavorable locality for the development of pronounced character is a patent and potent fact in political geography as it is in philological geography, and vice versa. Hence the clamoring need of patient, self-sacrificing investigation into the facts concerning the half-consonant vowel-stems. We therefore gladly welcome this thesis, bristling with facts and theories; though the interpretation of these facts is often — one might almost fear too often — left to the reader. If the author errs in this matter, it is in the rare direction of modesty, which prevents him from determining what as yet no one can determine. After the preliminary discussion of w-stems in other Indo-European languages, the author plunges at once into the theme, distinguishing between stems in w and stems in u. These give each two sub-heads, 434 Book Reviews according as the u- or w-stems develop into a noun or an adjective, these finally being differentiated according as their genitive is constructed by the ending -eos (resp. -«a>s), or -«os. The author's practice does not seem consistent in the matter of bring- ing etymological cognates down to the latest development; e. g., on p. 13 Skt. daru is not brought down to Eng. " tree," although, just before, Skt. janu — Eng. "knee." On p. 14 we are told: "Greek nouns in -rus are feminine, with one exception;" but this exception is not given us until we reach p. 44. A cross-reference would have helped. One questions the value of many or prolonged quotations from the Etym. Mag. or Choeroboscus (cf ., e. g., p. 28), whose statements are often mere guesses, nor even especially happy guesses at that. One longs often to see the more rigid application of the chronological antecedence to aid in deter- mining which of variant or duplicate forms may be the older and probably the original one. When the material is scant, as often, this is of course impossible; but citing a sole example from the Middle Ages (p. 28) can scarcely lend much aid to an investigation into the origins of forms. We still think that a careful sifting and chronological arranging of the Belegstellen for forms like -n-oktms as vs. Tr6\.rjos, etc. (pp. 23, 28, etc.), would do more toward proving to be a fact what is otherwise only a prob- lematic theory. On p. 33 we read that " in Homer the o-stem forms, nom. sg. vtds, ace. sg. vlov, voc. sg. v'U, are frequent." With the excellent material at hand in these days for studying the Homeric Sprachge- brauch, we should have expected and gladly welcomed statistics here. Such statistics the author does give most acceptably on pp. 36 ff., while opening up the subject of nouus in -Ss, gen. -vos. As the reviewer has devoted no little study to the formation of the verbals in -tos and the differing verb-stems on which these verbals are built (cf. articles on the Sophoclean use of verbals, in Am. Jour. Phil. XIII), he would fain have known to what extent the nouns in -rvs (p. 46) follow the usus of the verbals in -tos in the matter of their formation from this or that tense- stem of the verb; but we are not enlightened. No accent is placed on TptTTvs, p. 48. The thesis closes with an alphabetical list and grouping of the ca. 453 words which in all available MSS and inscriptions present themselves as the material from which to develop the above theories. One is familiar with the dictum: a poor poet should be criticized not at all, a medium poet leniently, an excellent poet mercilessly. Judged by this dictim, the valuable thesis before us deserves a vastly severer criticism than the reviewer has accorded it. In the immediate future no one will be able to accomplish aught in this especial and especially diffi- cult field without using it. Charles Edward Bishop College op William and Mary