STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 421 tary agent), with passive verbs; (c) dependent on the verbal force in nouns; (d) dependent on adjectives and adverbs; (e) adverbial phrases, expressing distance from point to point (corresponding to ad, usque ad, etc.); if) denoting location or domicile; (g) in functions, public and private; (h) adverbial formulas, etc. ; miscellaneous; (B) Temporal. The classification is thus parallel to that of the great Thesaurus. Many interesting facts develop from a study of the material already collected. Fox instance, the Eoman grammarians (Charisius i. 232. 24 K) lay down the rule that a should be used only before consonants, and ab only before vowels and h. As a matter of fact, we see that in the inscriptions ab occurs before every consonant in the alphabet. This, then, is another "grammarians rule " (see Classical Philology I, pp. 47 ff .) which did not represent the actual speech. The question of assimi- lation or non-assimilation in prepositional compounds is another matter on which this work will throw light. Thus, we find adclamo, adcubo, adcresco, adficio, adflgo, adgredior, adquiro, but accubitio, accumbo, and both adflictus and afflictus. The Dictionary is issued in fascicles of twenty-four pages each. Five of these, reaching the word ADTRIBVO, have already appeared. Three more are ready for printing this summer, and it is the intention of the editor to publish at least four fascicles each year. Two years more, perhaps three, will be necessary to finish A. The whole, when completed, will fill eight or ten volumes of about 500 pages each. The speed with which the work will proceed depends somewhat upon the number of subscribers. The mechanical labor necessary first to collect this material, inscrip- tion by inscription, and then to sift and classify it, is immense, and its completion by one man must require many years of incessant toil. Since so important a work has been begun and so well, it may be a question whether it would not be wise for Dr. Olcott to associate with himself a corps of collaborators and so hasten the lexicon to completion. Walter Dennison University op Michigan Studi italiani di filologia classica. Vol. XII, 1904. The longest article in this volume, that in which, on pp. 11-120, E. Lattes discusses fascicles IX and X of the new Corpus inscriptio- num Etruscarum, can only be named as lying beyond the competence of the reviewer. A. Solari, pp. 1-9, gives a list, containing little of interest to the classical student, of Latin MSS anterior to the seventeenth century, found in the communal library at Leghorn. 422 Book Reviews C. Marchesi, pp. 121-38, gives (in Latin) an account and partial colla- tion of three Verona MSS (oddly described as adhuc non comperti), viz.: a Persius, saec. xiii, Ovid. Epp., saec. xiv (ending with Her. xx. 12), and Valerius Maximus, saec. xiv or xv. This last M. makes the mistake of regarding as important, having collated it only with Kempf's second edition; most of the readings which he supposes to be new are recorded in the first edition from the inferior MSS which, on the discovery of cod. L, Kempf largely disregarded. The Veronensis, which has some interesting correspondences with B, is evidently no less interpolated than the other recentiores (cf. Kempf 2 , praef. p. xxix). Interesting, and for the text of Persius indispensable, is F. Ramorino's article, pp. 229-60, "De duobus Persii codicibus": Laur. 37, 19= A, and Laur. 33, 31 =A', a copy of A made by Boccaccio. In contradiction of Bandini, R. assigns A to saec. x extr. or saec. xi in.; he collates it with Montepess. A and Vat. B, representing the Sabinian recension, and with Montepess. C, Buecheler's P, representing what R. calls the Pithoean recension, and sums up thus: "cum cod. Laur. A recensionem praecipue Sabinianam praebeat, perpaucis tantum locis cum pithoeana commixtam, cum longe emendatior sit quam A et B . . . . hunc codicem ex archetypo multo meliore fluxisse quam o (= AB), fortasse etiam nonnihil antiquiore, vel unciali vel semiunciali scriptura exarato." There are a few misprints: pp. 235, 255 "Prol. 4 pirenem," whereas the remark on p. 259 indicates that the correct pirenen is the reading of A as well as of A' ; p. 255 " S. I 22 turn" should be tun, as on p. 236; ibid. "1 131 ababaci," but p. 238 " ababati ;" it does not appear which is correct. C. Pascal, pp. 219-27, discusses the composition of Catull. lxiv. That it is a translation is shown by the singularities nutricum 18, frigidulos singultus 132, sevens euros 173, flexerunt artus 305. But it is not trans- lated from a single source; for an original poet, introducing the Ariadne episode as a series of pictures displayed before the guests, would have maintained its pictorial character and accompanied his description with references to the spectators such as we find in Verg. Aen. i. 466 ff. Catullus develops the episode in narrative form; we must conclude that he introduced the device of the drapery only to dovetail one original narrative into another. And the two parts are different in tone: the Peleus and Thetis " has a certain sobriety and moderation of coloring and a cer- tain simplicity of development which contrast vividly with the impas- sioned character of the" Ariadne. As to the source of the latter, P. can suggest nothing ; that of the former he would find in a pseudo-Hesiodic poem on the same theme, from which Tzetzes Prol. ad Lycophr. 261 cites two lines (fr. 94 Marckscheffel); with these P. compares vss. 26-28 of Catullus, and with fr. 218 M., which he thinks may belong to the same epithalamium, vss. 386-88. The suggestion as to source is plausible; as for the contamination, there is another possibility, a modification of P.'s Book Reviews 423 view. He does not remark on vs. 251, parte ex alia (cf . Verg. Aen. i. 474) or on the distinctly pictorial, or sculptural, character of the Bacchic rout introduced by this phrase. The same character belongs, in the main, to vss. 52-70; we may then suppose that Catullus followed in the first place a Greek original containing a brief pictorial description of Ariadne in Naxos, and that into this he inserted a narrative (vss. 71-250), perhaps from a second Greek source. P. suggests that the absence of Apollo and Diana (vss. 299 ff., contrast 12 62 f. and Aesch. fr. 350 Nauck) may be a primitive element of the myth ; Sun and Moon could not be present at a festival which took place by torchlight at nightfall. It may be added that Hes. fr. 94 is the only parallel passage that has escaped Ellis' notice; for the comparison of Apol. Khod. iii. 968-71 with vss. 106 ff. is false. The "Analecta" of L. Castiglioni, pp. 279-318 (in Italian despite the title), are varied in contents and full of interest. Using a cod. Neap. saec. xv, and having regard also to other MSS, C. gives collations of the Achilleis of Statius, the Remedia amoris of Ovid, and the pseudo- Ovidian Nux; for the last-named also a new collation of cod. Flor. in cor- rection of Baehrens. He treats of the relations between the MSS of the Achilleis, discusses the character and authorship of the Nux and the blending of erotic with idyllic poetry in the Remedia amoris and Tibul- lus, and defends or emends the text in various passages of Tibullus and the Nux. The elaborate and suggestive essay is well worth reading as a whole, and students concerned with this or that portion will find it always desirable to reckon with C's observations. C. O. Zuretti, p. 319, on Auson. Cent. nupt. praef. 5, explains unus et sequens cum medio as = u. (medius versus) et s. (medius versus) cum ■medio (versu). But could medius versus be understood from a following medio sc. versu ? N. Terzaghi, "Ad Hes. Th. 535 ss.," pp. 139-44, advances the theory that Theog. 535-64 belonged originally between Op. 48 and 50, Op. 49 having been inserted as a stop-gap after the passage had been transferred to the Theogony. The arguments drawn from mythical considerations are neither clearly stated nor convincing; linguistically T. errs, both in supposing that aXXd could be used to introduce vs. 565 as a continuation of vs. 534, and in translating epi^cro /3ot)Aa9 534 by "thwarted the will" of Zeus. Syntactically this phrase must mean "matched wits" with Zeus, and it is evidently an amplification of the epithets ttoikiXov 511, and iroiKiX6^ov\ov 521, just as imepKvBavra 510 is further developed in 514 ff . and d/uipTivoov 511 in 512 f. T. notes that Hyginus says that Zeus did not perceive the deceit practiced on him, and infers that Hyginus' copy of Hesiod did not contain Theog. 550-52, "probably a later addition by someone who did not wish that Zeus should cut a poor figure despite his omniscience." Here T. goes too far or not far enough; the question is one, not of textual criticism, but of comparative folklore. 424 Book Reviews Terzaghi has also, pp. 181-217, an article on the commentary of Nicephorus to Synesius irepl iwtrvimv. On a not uninteresting discussion of ancient theories concerning dreams, of Chaldaic oracles, and the sources of Nicephorus, there follow an account of the MSS of the commentary with critical notes and "Adnotationis crit. in Syn. n. t. lib. specimen." Two articles by E. L. De Stefani exhibit the sound fruit of long labor. Regarding the Excerpta ex Aeliani H. A., of which he has at command five unpublished collections besides the printed Excerpta Constantini, De St. states, pp. 145-80, that "all the MSS of the excerpts depend on the archetype of the complete MSS," and that all are valueless for the text of Aelian, save perhaps the parts of the Excerpta Constantini derived from the 7tAotos. Discussing, pp. 421-45, the Epitome Aristotelis de Animalibus by Aristophanes of Byzantium, De St. arrives at the fol- lowing results: (1) Ael. H. A. iv. 55 = Aristoph. ii. 458, 459; (2) the con- tents of lost portions of the epitome may be inferred from passages of the H. A. ; (3) Aristot. 7rcpi £ Herodian II. 613. 9 L., refer not to Herodian, as Lentz supposed, but to Theodosius. A. Olivieri, pp. 261-77, gives the readings of cod. Laur. 75. 5 for the "Ophthalmology" in Aetius' 'Iarpixa, lib. vii, and observes that Laur. justifies many of Hirschberg's emendations. T. Tosi, p. 278, proposes to read ovyyevctas of*pi in Eur. Or. 1046. (rrji d8eA.<£>7s, a gloss on