STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Vol. I October, igo6 No. 4 MENANDER: A STUDY OF THE CHRONOLOGY OF HIS LIFE By Walter Eugene Clakk The commonly received date for the birth of Menander of Athens, the poet of the New Comedy, is the year 342-41 b. c, which was also the birth-year of Epicurus. The length of Menander's life is given as fifty-two years; so that, by reckoning inclusively both terminal years of his life-period, his death would fall in the year 291-90 b. c. 1 The only express statement as to the poet's birth and death is contained in I. G. Sic. et Ital. 1184 (to be cited in the sequel as "the inscription"), which says that Menander was born in the archonship of Sosigenes (which is fixed beyond question in the year 342-41), that he lived fifty-two years, and died in the archonship of Philippus and the thirty- second year of Ptolemy Soter's reign. The words are: MeravSpos Ai07rei'#ovs K.r]i(Tuvi iytwrjdr) iirl apxovros "Syixnyivovr fTt\ev- T7)v v kou /3 lirl ap\ovro% Qiktrrrrov, Kara to f} ko.1 \ eros tt}s HtoXc/jmiov tov 2t»?/oos /8ai\jdaooi eyva>pt£ovTo\ t yet the Armenian version under this same year of Abraham 1701 has the notice, Menander et Speusippos philosophi cognoscebantur. Be- fore the discovery of the new fragment of the Parian Chronicle it was natural to regard the word Menander as a corruption of Menedemus, but it now seems probable that there was originally under the year 321-20 a notice of Menander's first appearance at the City Dionysia, with the words irp&Tov eSiSa^e, while under 316-15 was a notice of his first victory— for Eusebius would surely not have passed over this important event in silence. Capps in Am. Jour. Phil. XXI (1900), p. 61, restores this sec- ond notice as follows: Me'i>ai>fy>o? ^kw/wko? irpSrrov, Bpafia StSalfa? 'Opyrfv, eviica, /cal M.€veS7]fioi\6(rohiarj/3o<; mv eirl Aio- «Xeow (sic) dpj(ovTO'i. Since there is no archon Diocles during this period, Clinton (F. H* II, p. 181 [1841]) emended to <3>t\o/ic\eov?, who was in fact archon in the year 322-21, and Clinton's conjecture has long been accepted without demur. The two considerations which appear to have induced Clinton to make the change would seem to be as follows: In the first place, the consideration that our versions of Eusebius ascribe to Menander a victory in 321-20, according to Hieronymus, or, according to the Armenian version, in 322-21 ; and that Philocles was archon in the year 322-21. The change was plausible and brought the statement of Anon. De com. into partial agreement with those of our versions of Eusebius. 2 The second consideration would appear to be that, as Clinton thought, a closely analogous confusion of the names Diocles (archon in 409) and Philocles (archon in 392) was to be found in a scholium to Aristophanes Plutus 179. The scholium reads: tort 8e «os AiokAcovs €Tt) u^, uxttc aXoyov Sia ovo/mitos avTtjv inaipav. ifiaivei oe kou IIXaTtov iv tiS acovt «7rTaK era vcrrepov SiSa^devri iirl Aionktovs (sic), tXo«Xeoy?, as corrected by Hemsterhuys. Clinton (F. H. 3 II, p. 106) bids us look to the year 322-21 for a like erroneous interchange of names; but, as a matter of fact, the cases are by no means analogous. In copying the scholium, the eye of the copyist, after he had written ScSaxOevn eirl, caught the ending -xXeow of the next word, and, since the name Ato/cXe'ou? (occurring just above) had but just passed through his mind and been written by him, he very naturally wrote it again, thus making a Ato-/c\eov? out of <£t\o- 1 So Bekker emends the irpwTos of the MSS, 2 Kirchner, accepting the year under which he finds the notice placed by the Arme- nian version (because it agrees with the emended notice of Clinton), gives, in his Prosopographia Attica II, p. 67, as the date of Menander's first victory the year 322-21. In so doing he tacitly ignores the date under which the notice is found in Hieronymus. The discrepancy of a year between Clinton's emended notice and the date 321-20 as given by Hieronymus troubles Bethe Hermes XXXVII (1902), p. 281, and he refuses to pass over it lightly. Yet so many are the dislocations of notices in Hieronymus that this discrepancy could hardly of itself invalidate Clinton's emendation. 318 Walter Eugene Clark icXeovs of his original. This is no substitution at all, but one of the most common kind of scribal errors and easily to be corrected. The only reason, then, for emending Ato«\eov? to i\o/c\eov9 in the notice of Anon. De com., is that the notice is thus brought into partial agreement with the data of our versions of Eusebius under the years 322-21 and 321-20. If we can show that the notice of Anon. De com. can not refer to a year as late as 322-21, then Clinton's conjecture must be abandoned. We have already seen that some scholars have found reason to suspect the data given by the inscription. It must therefore be used with great caution, and we must beware of using any part of it as a basis for conclusions until we have made certain whether it contains an error or not, and wherein the error, if any there be, may lie. Yet even if we admit the correctness of the inscription in assigning Menander's birth to the archonship of Sosigenes 342-41 b. c. (and, for our present argument, such a proceeding is permissible, because, since no one accepts a date posterior to 291-90 for Philippus, the birth date can not be later than 342-41), there is a grave objection to Clinton's emendation of Aio/eXe'ou? to QikoicXeow;. If the poet was born in 342-41, and if it was in the archonship of Philocles (322-21) that he won his first victory, he must then have been in his twenty-first year, or, assuming that he was born during the concluding months of 342-41, in his twentieth year. But to call him e<£?7/So? at that age involves a contradiction of terms, since the period of ii]/3eia, properly speaking, was limited to the eighteenth and nineteenth years of a young man's life. Assuming that the inscription is right in giving 342-41 as the date of Menander's birth, he would have become er)/3o<; in 324, and could no longer be properly called tyvfa in 322-21.' 1 The age at which the enrolment of the ^ij/Soi took place has long been disputed. Since the discovery of the ' kBriraXuv IloXtrela of Aristotle, the locus classicus for the enrolment of the %(j>-rj§oi is chap. 42 of that work. There occur the words: iyypi- ifiovTai 5' els robs SripJnas dKraKalSexa %ti\ yeyovbres. It is still, however, a matter of dispute among scholars whether by this statement is intended the completion of the seventeenth year of a young man's life, or of his eighteenth year ; but to my mind it seems certain that the statement of Aristotle and our other evidence lead to the con- clusion that the enrolment took place at the, end of the seventeenth year. For dis- cussion, and for corroboration of my view, see Schaefer Demosthenes unci seine Zeit Menandeb 319 Further, Strabo tells us at xiv. 638 that Menander and Epi- curus were crwecprjfioi. These are his words: 'AOrjvaXoi n\r]pov)(ovs tirc/xij/av 8mt^iA.iovs i£ eavrwv, u>v rjv nol NeoxXiJs 6 *EiriKOvpov tov a] ko.1 ev Tea> ko.1 itprjftevo-ai. 'Adyvrjcrr yevttrOai 8' avnS /uk6v. 1 Now, the Chronica of Apollodorus 2 gives the birth-date of Epi- curus with great precision, to wit, the seventh of Gamelion of 01. 109 3 = 342-41 b. c, or January of 341. The seventeenth life- year, accordingly, would have been completed in Gamelion of 325-24 b. c.= January 324, and it must have been during that year that he became e^>i?/3o?. 3 At this time the ecpvfieia, presumably, still lasted for two years 4 and, unless the word avvecprjfio'; here has its most restricted sense, Menander must have become e]j0ij 5^, i)fioi had been employed as evidence. Much more likely is it that the source of Strabo (perhaps a record of the ty-qfiela of Epicurus, like the record of a certain Herodotus mentioned by Diogenes Laertius x. 4) based its statement on some sentence in the works of Epicurus himself where Epicurus referred to his famous con- temporary Menander. The explanation of the discrepancy, accordingly, is not far to seek. The author of our inscription, knowing that Menander and Epicurus were called crvvtyrifioi, interpreted the word in the sense which it had in his own later day, when the ei)/3oi served only one year; and, knowing that Epicurus was born in the year of the archon Sosigenes, he ascribed the birth of Menander to the same 1 It is not yet fully agreed as to the time of year at which the Soni/iao-la of the £0ij/3oi took place. It is certain that all of our known ephebic inscriptions are dated in the third prytany, in the month Boedromion ; cf . Dumont Essai I, p. 134. But this fact by no means leads to the conclusion that the doKt/jaaia and enrolment took place at that time, and it is much more likely that the Somimala and enrolment took place at the beginning of the official year ; cf . Wilamowitz Arist. u. Athen I, p. 191 ; Busolt Griech. Staatsalt?, p. 213. If the Sou/mala is to be placed at the beginning of the official year in Hecatombaeon, or at any time prior thereto, then the birth of Menander must be ascribed to the year 343-42. Kaibel in his comments on the inscription suspects the year 342-41 as an error, but believes that it was reached by a computation based on the date of Menander's first appearance in 322-21 (which date he accepts on the authority of the emended notice of Clinton), and that twenty years (the "half dK/«j") were added. Menandeb 321 year. Having thus been led to substitute the name of Sosigenes for the name of the archon which he found given, and which he considered as an error, he naturally enough retained fifty-two years as the length of Menander's life, without discovering to himself the discrepancy by laboriously counting down a list of archons. 1 One more objection yet remains to the correction of Ato«\eow to 'Ax>TMcXeov? in Anon. De com., to wit, the notices (as restored by Capps) in our versions of Eusebius which place the first appearance of Menander at the City Dionysia in 01. 114 3 = 321-20 (in the Armenian version 01. 114 s = Abraham 1595 = 322-21). This notice, I believe, belonged originally to 01. 113 3 = 325-24, the year of the archonship of Anticles, and has been lowered by just one Olympiad. For similar dislo- cations, see Jacoby Apollodors Chronik, pp. 129, 132, 139, 287, 308, 313. This kind of error occurs several times in the portions of the Canon which come under Jacoby's survey, and in places where there is other evidence to make the true date certain. In this particular case we have no evidence which can make it sure that the notice has suffered a dislocation; but, if we are right in correcting to 'AirweXeov? in Anon. De com., the assumption of a dislocation of the notice in our versions of Eusebius becomes necessary. We must then suppose that Menander's first appearance at the City Dionysia took place in the year 324, and that his first City victory was in 315. This is just what we should expect from all that we know of his career. The apparent tradition that he was victorious with his first play in the year 321-20, or 322-21 and yet won the first prize so seldom, has always been a troublesome point to critics. He won only eight victories in all, of which four, or possibly five, were won at the City Dionysia. 2 It now 1 The theory just proposed necessitates the assumption that the compiler of the inscription knew the birth-date of Epicurus, and that he was aware of the fact that Menander and Epicurus were called avvir)(Soi. As we know nothing of the sources from which the compiler of the inscriptionidrew, and can merely state that he used great care in the selection of his data, such an assumption can not be made into a cer- tainty ; but it seems to be the most natural explanation of the error of the inscription. 2 See Aul. Gell. xvii. 4 : ex istis tamen centum et quinque omnibus eum octo vicisse, idem Apollodorus eodem in libro scripsit. Gellius here gives the total for both festivals, while Apollodorus gave the number of victories for each festival separately : cf. Jacoby Apollodors Chronik, p. 359. 322 Walter Eugene Clark seems certain that it was only after repeated attempts that he won a coveted City victory ; nor is it likely, in view of the small num- ber of victories, that it was with his first play that he won a victory at the Lenaea in 322-21 or 321-20. Bethe Hermes XXXVII (1902), p. 278, by an examination of two places in the Heauton Timorumenos of Terence, finds a new and valuable clue to the date of its prototype, Menander's play of like name; but, under the influence of older views, he does not venture to date the production of the 'Eavrbv TifMopov/ievos earlier than 321, and gives back in his conclusions all the ground which he had gained. Line 117 of the play of Terence reads: in Asiam ad regem militatum abiit Chremes, and Alexander is the only person who could be spoken of par excellence as "the king" at this period. In 1. 194, moreover, occur the words patriam incolumem. After the ravages of the Lamian war this phrase would be altogether out of place. Bethe believes, therefore, that this play was written by Menander before the year 323, but that, in accordance with the notices of our versions of Eusebius, it was not produced until 321 or 320. His arguments for a date of composition prior to the death of Alexan- der are cogent and convincing, but we can not suppose for a moment that Menander postponed the production of his play for two years out of a desire to polish it off carefully. In view of the fact that he wrote some hundred and five plays in about thirty-three years, he must soon have learned to work much more rapidly. Or, if Bethe means to imply that the play was not produced until 321 because of the extreme youth of the poet, there are the cases of Alexis and of Eupolis and of Aristophanes, each of whom brought out a drama at as early an age as seventeen. If Terence's 11. 117 and 194 are a true reflex of the Menandrian original, we must assuredly suppose that Menander brought out the play before the year 321 ; for, had the production been as late as that, the references to "Alexander" and to "a fatherland still safe and unimpaired" would no longer be pertinent. Clearly, if Bethe's arguments are of any weight, we must assume that the 'JLavrbv TifMopovnevos was brought out as early as 323. This conclusion Menandee 323 affords strong corroboration of the correctness of the change to ' AvTifc\eov<; in the notice of Anon. De com. Legrand Revue des 6tudes grecques XVI (1903), p. 357, per- ceiving the error of Bethe, carries back the production of the play to the period of its composition (that is, to a time prior to the death of Alexander) by endeavoring to show that it was pro- duced at the festival of the Attic deme Aixone by the youthful Menander at eighteen years of age, who thus started his career before venturing on a more ambitious attempt at the Lenaea or the City Dionysia in Athens. But new plays were not, in general, presented at demotic festivals; at these the performances were confined to the reproduction of old pieces, and there are but two instances known to us of new plays having been brought out at demotic festivals. Once, indeed, we find a record 1 of a new play at Salamis, if the inscription, which dates in the Christian era, has been correctly restored; and there is a second record 2 which tells us that Euripides brought out a new tragedy at the Pei- raeeus. At Aixone, to be sure, we know 3 that there was a theater in which plays were produced — all comedies apparently; but we are not warranted in assuming that this deme formed an excep- tion to the general rule. Moreover, if Legrand follows out the suggestion which he tentatively makes, that is to emend to 'Apti- icXeow in the notice of Anon. De com., he can not connect this notice with an assumed production of a play at the deme Aixone; for it would be absolutely without parallel for the chronographers to record a first victory or any victory at a demotic festival. Legrand's hypothesis is based on the fact that the scene of the play is laid in the deme Aixone; but even if the scene is laid at Aixone, it is not safe to conclude that it was produced there. For such a conclusion there is as little warrant as there would be for concluding that Menander's play the 'AXaefc was brought out at the deme 'AXal ' Apar)vi8e<; because, as we know, its action takes place in that deme. Legrand's arguments relating to the inconsistencies of the play, however, have weight; and, together with Bethe's suggestion, afford convincing proof of the early date of Menander's drama. * CIA. II. 470. *See Haigh Attic Theatre*, p. 43. "CIA. II. 585. 324 Waltek Eugene Clabk Jacoby would solve the problem by attacking the death -date given in the inscription, namely the year of the archonship of Philippus and the thirty-second year of Ptolemy Soter's reign, and by arguing for the year 291-90 as the date of Menander's death. He believes that there has been a corruption from 8 ical X to /3 teal X, that is to say, from 34 to 32. The year of Ptolemy Soter's accession is variously given by the Greek chronographers 1 as 324-23 or 323-22, of which the latter year is the one gener- ally accepted. Jacoby, arbitrarily assuming that the author of our inscription reckoned from the year 324-23, arrives at the year 291-90 as the thirty-fourth year of Ptolemy, and thinks that the name of the archon as originally given was that of this year, 291-90. He further claims that when, through the cor- ruption of S to /3, the statement was taken as referring to the year 293-92, the name of the archon was changed and the name Philippus substituted. If, however, the compiler of the inscription was careful enough to do this, he would have been much more likely, I conceive, to change the numeral than the name of the archon. Jacoby's conclusions are reached only by extreme means. The birth -date he feels must be right ; and he accepts the number of years given as the length of Menander's life, because it agrees with a passage of the Chronica of Apollodorus as cited by Gellius xvii. 4, where the metre preserves the number. Therefore the error must be in the death-date, and he is willing to employ any means to bring the date given by the inscription into agreement with his theory that Philippus was archon in the year 293-92. Yet such arbitrary treatment of the inscription can not be a posi- tive argument for placing Philippus in the year 293-92. If, on other grounds, it could be proved beyond the shadow of a doubt, as has not yet been done, that Philippus was archon in 293-92, then it would be allowable to apply to our inscription a critique like that of Jacoby. Our chief difficulty lies in the fact that there is no general agreement as to the archonship of Philippus. Older scholars 2 1 See Beloeh Bettr. zur alt. Oesch. Ill, p. 313 ; Jacoby Das marmor Parium, p. 195. Beloch in his Geschichte III. 2, p. 33, claims that even the year 322-21 may be probable. 2 So Droysen Hellen. II. 2, p. 397. Menandeb 325 placed it in the year 292-91, and this is the date which Beloch 1 once accepted; but Unger, 2 Kirchner, 3 Ferguson, 4 Jacoby, 5 and Kolbe 6 insist upon assigning it to the year 293-92. Very recently, however, Beloch has abandoned his former position and maintains 7 the date as 291-90. Inasmuch as our conclusion that the birth of Menander is to be ascribed to the year 343-42 b. o. makes it necessary to assign the archonship of Philippus to the year 292-91, it is necessary to consider here certain points in the arguments of Kolbe and of Bethe, the most recent exponents of the dates 293-92 and 291-90, and to determine whether their methods of procedure are fully justified. Kolbe seeks to show that Dionysius of Halicarnassus, in his account of the life of Deinarchus, must have reckoned the two fifteen-year periods which he mentions, as running from 322-21 to 308-7 and from 307-6 to 293-92. By thus reckoning inclusively he arrives at the year 293-92 as the archonship of Philippus. The passage De Dein. 2 reads as follows: Kat StartreXeKtv IrStv trevrtKaiStKa xpovov Aoyous tav rots ySouAo- (itvois Io)s Kao-travSpos rqv it6X.lv KixTt' ov KartXvcrav rrjv iv rrj Mowv\ia povpav iuro KacrcravSpov KaTa- ara&ttaav ol Trepl ' ' Xvriyovov km. Arjfiyjrpiov .... tWtXBav p.kv £is SiKacmjpiov ov\ virip.uvav .... l$eX6a>v 8k rrjs iroXtios ko.1 iXOwv £ts XaAia8a .... tov aw' 'Ava£ucpa.Tovs xpovov fa>s "StAtWov irtvT£Kai8tK€Tt) ytvoptvov lutt SieTpuj/tv. But this statement of Dionysius is not specific enough to make this conclusion of Kolbe's the only possible one, and it seems to me not at all improbable that by the words tov air' ' Ava^iKpaTOW %p6vov ea>? <£>i\farirov TrevreicaiSeiceTr) yev6ftevov Dionysius meant the period from 306-5 to 292-91 reckoned inclusively ; especially in view of the data found in De Dein. 9. Here occur the words tov? 'AOtfvrjo-iv ap^avras .... yevofievovs eftSofiijicovTa irpoOrjcrofiev ; but our manu- 111 Die attischen Archonten im dritten Jahrhundert," Beitr. zur alt. Gesch. (1902), and in Hermes XXXVII (1903), p. 130. tPhilol. XXXVIII (1879), p. 447. ^Hermes XXXVII (1902), p. 438. * The Athenian Archons, pp. 11 ff. — Ferguson's latest discussion, The Priests of Asklepios, was received after this article was in pages and his results unfortunately can not be referred to here. ^Apollodors Chronik, p. 360. QAth. Mitth. XXX (1905), pp. 78-84. So too Sehoeffer in P.-W. II, p. 588; Ditten- berger Syll. 2 , p. 192, n. 18. Wilamowitz Antigonos, p. 240, gives a doubting assent. i Griechische Geschiehte III. 2, p. 33 (1904). 326 Waltee Eugene Clark scripts contain only sixty-eight names. Inasmuch as Dionysius states distinctly that he is going to give the names of seventy archons, we can not do otherwise than accept his statement at pre- cisely its face value; and, in the absence of any statement to the contrary, we must assume that they cover a period of seventy years. We have from other sources proof for Hegesias, archon in 324-23, whose name is missing from the list. It is not therefore unreason- able, in view of the explicit statement of the number seventy, to assume that the list originally contained yet another name, now lost; and, since the list is complete through Olympiodorus (294-93), and it follows from De Dein. 2 that Philippus is the last archon during this period of seventy years, it must be the archon of 293-92 whose name has been lost. By looking at the matter from a slightly different point of view we arrive at this same conclusion; and, in addition, we are forced to admit that Dionysius must have reckoned the second fifteen-year period as extending from 306-5 to 292-91. For, after an enumeration of the names of forty archons and a sentence in explanation, Diony- sius gives the names of fifteen archons, beginning with Archippus and ending with Anaxicrates (307-6) ; then occur the following words: en-l tovtov r/ KaTacrraOelcra vtto Kao-crdvSpov 6\tyapxia icare- \v6t], Kal oi elo-ayyeXOevre; ej)j3oi, and so must be rejected. Beloch 2 has taken the other horn of the dilemma in his argu- ments for the year 291-90 as the date of the archonship of Philippus. Assuming that the birth-date given by the inscrip- tion is correct, he counts down fifty-two years and arrives at the year 291-90 as the year of Philippus, which year he proceeds to defend by the use of CIA. II. 5. 614= b. But there are weighty reasons for believing that the Cimon there mentioned does not belong to this period, 3 but to a much later date; and there is no sufficient reason for supposing that the name to be supplied is that of Philippus. Besides, in order to make room for two archons, Cimon and Lysias, between Olympiodorus and Philippus, he is obliged to treat the text of Dionysius De Dein. 9 in a most arbitrary manner. For either Dionysius deliberately falsified in his statement as to the number of archons, or he himself, by an omission in the list which he obtained from his sources, believed that Philippus was archon in the year 292-91. For inasmuch as he gives the archon for 261-60 as the first and Philippus as the last in the list and states that he is going to give seventy names, if Philippus is to be placed in the year 291-90, there must have been seventy-one names in the original list. We are not in a position to impeach the sincerity of Dionysius in this matter and his language precludes any theory of exclusive reckoning by years, as suggested by Beloch. The only possibility to support Beloch's view is that one name may have dropped out of the original list, that Dionysius may have had only seventy names, and placed Philippus in 292-91. Such a possibility has no i See Beloch Gr. Gesch. III. 2, pp. 33, 34. *Gr. Gesch. III. 2, p. 33. 3 See Kolbe Ath. Mitth. XXX (1905), pp. 76, 103 ff. 328 Walter Eugene Claek authority except the doubtful and fragmentary inscription ad- duced and emended by Beloch. Therefore, as the case now stands, any conservative criticism must needs maintain that Dionysius is historically correct in stating that there were sev- enty archons from Nicophemus through Philippus, and conclude that the name of the archon for the year 293-92 has been lost. 1 It seems to me that argumentation based on the inscription I. G. Sic. et Ital. 1184 is bound to be faulty ; we must work from other facts to the inscription, and not vice versa. My line of argument is briefly as follows: We know that Menander and Epicurus were r)fioi. Epicurus must have become e$??/3o? at the beginning of the year 324-23. Menander must have become e^ij/Sos in 325-24 (archonship of Anticles) or 324-23 (archonship of Hegesias and year of Alexander's death) or 323-22 (archonship of Cephisodorus). Prom Anon. De com. we know that Menander as e^jj^os won a victory in the archon- ship "of Diocles" — a name which we know to be corrupt. Bethe has shown that Menander must have composed a play before the death of Alexander. There is thus a double reason for rejecting Clinton's emendation to Philocles (322-21) and for emending to Anticles (325-24). If Menander became e<£j?/8os at the beginning of 325-24, his birth must fall in the year 343-42. The most natural explanation of the error of the inscription is that it is due to a synchronism with Epicurus. Reckoning from 343-42, we arrive at the year 292-91 as the date of Menander's death and of the archonship of Philippus and of the thirty -second year of the reign of Ptolemy. Harvard University 1 Perhaps we shall never find the material to determine what was the full name of the missing archon of the year 293-92. That it ended in -oos (or perhaps -oos) would seem to have been established by Capps Am. Jour. Arch. IV (1900), pp. 89, 90. The fragment on which Capps bases this partial determination certainly refers to a year prior to Menander's death and subsequent to the introduction of the contest of comic actors at the City Dionysia — an innovation which, in all probability, took place between 307 b. c. and Menander's death. But, in the period extending from the poet's death back as far as 307, we know of no archon-name ending in -oos or -pos. There seems, therefore, to be good reason for assuming a gap of a year in the list between Philippus and his next known predecessor, Olympiodorus, archon for the year 294-93. — Wilhelm Urkunden dramatischer Auffiihrungen, pp. 63 ff ., argues against so early a date for the inscription under consideration.