STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 116 Book Reviews Latinitas and eXXj;wo-/iio'?. The influence of the Stoic theory of style as shown in the writings of Dionysius, Quintilian, Pliny the Younger, Tacitus, Pronto, Aulus Grellius and Sextus Empiricus. By Chables Newton Smiley. Wiscon- sin dissertation. University of Wisconsin Bulletin, Philology and Literature Series III (1906). Pp. 205-72. $0.30. The scope of Dr. Smiley's careful dissertation is defined in the title- Following in the steps of Professor Hendrickson, in whose penetrating studies of ancient rhetorical theory much emphasis is laid on the contri- butions made by the Stoics, Dr. Smiley traces this Stoic influence in Greek and Roman literary criticism from the reign of Augustus through that of Marcus Aurelius. He finds more Stoicism in Dionysius than has ever been suspected before, disposing somewhat too easily of the influence of Theophrastus and of Eademacher's views on this matter. Quintilian is rightly characterized as a vigorous opponent of Atticism, and one wonders why he was "compelled to give a larger place in his treatise to Stoic principles than Cicero" does (p. 232). Cicero accepts the principles of Latinitas as rudimentary if not axiomatic {Brutus 140) and gives an appreciative description of the genus humile {Orator 75-90) as one, but not the only, constituent of eloquence. Quintilian, whose purpose is more pedagogic, sets forth the rules of good use at greater length (i. 5 ff), but does not differ from Cicero in his fundamental estimate of style. So with Pliny. His occasional commendations of pressus sermo purusque are not different in purport from Cicero's eulogy of Caesar's Commentaries {Brutus 262): they are hardly evidence of new and special influence of "Stoic" theory. Pliny might well, after the delivery of his Panegyricus feel inclined to less florid diction {Ep. iii. 18. 10) and yet remain leagues away from Stoicism. But though Pliny and Quintilian are Ciceronians, their own criticisms give evidence — and this is Dr. Smiley's point— of the survival of "Attic" tendencies in their day. Tacitus, too, in his Dialogus, comes out for the simpler style, though we must make some allowance in such a work for dramatic imputation. We should welcome a study of the difference between Tacitus' later manner and Atticism. Distinctly the most skilful and interesting chapter in the dissertation is that on Fronto. To him, both Cicero and Cato are fountain-heads of eloquence; Stoicism and rhetorical embellishment are no longer at odds. The "theory of style which was formulated by those who sought simply docere has in the age of Fronto been appropriated by those whose chief object is deZectore" (p. 259). This same fusion of tendencies, with a plentiful admixture of pedantry, appears also in Aulus Gellius. Sextus Empiricus, the last writer treated, shows in his attack on grammar that there are still Atticists to demolish. It would be interesting to determine, if one could with any certainty, how much of the later criticism of Stoic principles was called forth by contemporary Book Reviews 117 movements and how much was traditional — an echo of the discussions of Cicero's day. We hope Dr. Smiley may find occasion to follow the fortunes of Stoicism in still later periods of the empire, and to round out his present treatment by a chapter on the philosopher Seneca. E. K. Rand Harvard University The Golden Days of the Renaissance in Borne from the Pontifi- cate of Julius II to that of Paul III. By Rodolfo Lanciani. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Pp. xii+340. $5.00. This sumptuous volume is similar in style to the author's earlier English books. Like them it is profusely and beautifully illustrated, and furnishes very entertaining reading. The titles of its seven chapters are, "The City," "Life in the City," "Paul III," "Michelangelo," "Vit- toria Colonna," "Raphael," and "Agostino Chigi," but these titles serve as convenient pegs on which to hang a great variety of topics. About all that is of any value for the classical student is scattered through the first three chapters, in which the author deals with the improvements of various kinds that were carried on during the two hundred years after the return of Gregory XI in 1377, and describes the condition of the city itself and of the monuments of antiquity, and their treatment by popes and cardinals. For instance, he gleans from a bull of Martin V the in- formation that in 1425 the butchers had established themselves in the forum of Nerva and in the theater of Marcellus, the fishmongers in the portico of Octavia, the tanners in the stadium of Domitian, the glass- blowers in the baths of Agrippa, etc. Attention is rightly called to one fact which is usually overlooked, that is that only "scanty vestiges of mediaeval Rome are left standing. If we except a few churches which have been spared the heinous transformations of the seventeenth century, a few baronial towers not yet whitewashed or turned into tenements, and a few private houses which have not yet fallen into the hands of specu- lators, Rome oifers no connecting link between the classic and the modem age" (p. 47). The explanation of this condition of things (p. 49), however, is hardly adequate. As in all Lanciani's books, many things are stated as facts that are not universally accepted as such. E. g., on p. 37, n., on the "received notion " about the Tarpeian Rock; the "notion "has not yet been disproved. The identification (pp. 122, 145) of the ruins in the Colonna gardens with Aurelian's Temple of the Sun is more than doubtful. No such accuracy of measurement of the ancient water supply as is found on p. 77 is pos- sible. The statement p. 140 about the origin of the university of Rome is amazing. The book is interesting to the general reader, for whom it is plainly intended, but is otherwise unimportant. Samuel Ball Plainer