STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE FORM OF THE CHLAMYS By F. B. Tarbell The question of the form of the chlamys is one of the most perplexing that meet us in the study of Greek costume. Every one of the numerous modern statements on the subject with which I am acquainted is either indistinct or, in my judgment, erro- neous. And yet the evidence is abundant, consisting not only of numerous representations of the garment in vase-painting and sculpture, but also of several more or less specific indications in our literary sources. 1 Under these circumstances it would seem as if a convincing solution must be attainable. We are in the habit of applying the name "chlamys" with a great deal of confidence to all small brooch-fastened outer gar- ments represented in Greek art. But for our present purpose it is better to take nothing for granted. For identifying, then, the chlamys in art we have chiefly the following data: it was fast- ened by a fibula (Isidore Orig. 19. 24. 2: chlamys est, quae ex una parte induitur, neque consuitur, sed fibula infrenatur; Ovid Met. 14. 393, 394; Suetonius Tib. 6); it was associated with the petasus (Philemon, quoted by Pollux 10. 164; Anthol. Or. xii. 78); it was worn by Hermes (Ovid Met. 2. 733; Lucian Tim. 30; Pausanias v. 27. 8). Accordingly, the chlamys may be recognized in such vase-paintings as Figs. 8, 463, 524 of Baumeister's Denk- maler; Arch. Zeitung, 1854, PI. 67 ; Jahrbuch d, arch. Instituts, 1891, PI. I, and Anzeiger, p. 23. From these and similarly well- attested examples we may go on to identify the chlamys, with more or less of certainty, in numerous other cases; but the question whether every small brooch-fastened garment may safely be called a chlamys is one which I should like to leave open till the end. The vase-paintings just cited have been chosen because they clearly show that, if the chlamys had one definite shape, it was 1 Acknowledgment for reference to these sources is due to Bltlmner Oriechische Privatalterthilmer, p. 178, and to Amelung in Pauly-Wissowa Real-Encyclopadie, s. v. "Chlamys." [Classical Philology I, July, 1906] 283 284 F. B. Taebell four-cornered. Numerous other representations, both in sculp- ture and vase-painting, confirm this statement. Others, while not clearly betraying the existence of four corners, afford no evidence to the contrary. So far as I can see, there are no cases of prob- able chlamydes which refuse to be interpreted as four-cornered. If, then, we could rely upon the accuracy of Greek renderings of costume in art, it would be our next duty to determine, by actual experiment, what particular four-cornered form the chlamys assumed. But, considering the liberties which the Greek artists took with the form and disposition of drapery, it is advisable to look to our literary authorities for further guidance. I shall attempt to show that, in connection with the monumental evi- dence, these authorities indicate this shape: or this: Pig. 2 A chlamys of the pattern shown in Fig. 1 would be fastened about the neck at the points marked x, and would display four corners; one of the pattern shown in Fig. 2 would be fastened at The Form of the Chlamys 285 A and B, and would display two corners. There would naturally be other variations, both in size and in proportions, but these do not call for special comment. For the circular form of the lower edge the evidence is abundant. Thus Ammonius De differentia vocabulorum 147 quotes Didymus to this effect: r) p.ev yap , )(\alva Terpdyavov ifidnov 17 8& x\a/iv<; et? reXeiov rrepl to, icarm (rvvrjKTai. The words efc reXeiov avv?\K.Tai defy interpretation, but the contrast with rerpdymvov shows that a curvi- linear form is intended. Valckenaer in a note on the above passage cites the parallel language of Ptolemy of Ascalon, 90 : r) Se %Xa/tt>? .... e%et KV/cXoreprj ra, Kara), and from the lexicon of Cyril: ■)(\afiv<; to irepicfrepes, to ev rfj crvvrjdeia Xeyojievov KV/cXofiavriov. Still more instructive is the stock comparison, variously expressed by various writers, of the site of Alexandria to a chlamys. It will be convenient to begin with Plutarch's version {Life of Alexander 26): icvie\oTeprj koKttov fjyov, ox> ttjv ivrb<; irepufrepeiav evdelat ySao-et? mairep airb Kpacnrehwv et? a^rnia j^Xa/Mv- 805 irrrekdiifiavov ef ierov avvdyovaai to fieyedoi. 1 Here we meet again the circular lower edge (ttjv iprb 1 ; Trepuf>epeiav) , and learn further that the two adjacent edges were straight (evdelat /Sacret?) and inclined symmetrically so that the top was narrower than the bottom (e£ icrov crvvdyovaai to /Meye0o<;), as in the diagrams given above. Pliny N. H. v. 62, puts the same comparison thus: earn [i. e., Alexandriam] . ... ad effigiem Macedonicae chlamydis orbe gyrato laciniosam, dextra laevaque anguloso procursu. Here the words orbe gyrato laciniosam must refer to the circular con- tour of the chlamys below, while the two angulosi procursus (called at kicaTepmdev ymviai" in Hesychius, Photius, and Suidas, s. v. ©eTTa\i«a TTTepd) are the ends conceived as extending to right and left of the breadth given by the upper edge, AB. Strabo's The passage is difficult. Taking it in connection with other evidence bearing upon the form of the chlamys, I understand it somewhat as follows : " They described a rounded area, to whose inner arc straight lines succeeded, starting from what might be called the skirts of the area and narrowing the breadth uniformly, so as to produce the figure of a chlamys." The word kcSXttos, which I have loosely translated by " area," may have been suggested by its use for that portion of a chiton which falls over the girdle. I understand ttjj' ivrhs ircpupipeiav as the circular contour on the landward side. Strictly speaking, the words ought to imply a circular contour on the outer or seaward side, but I doubt whether this was intended by Plutarch ; see below, p. 287. 2 This point is borrowed from Wachsmuth Rhein. Mus. XXXV (1880), p. 454. 286 P. B. Tabbell way of putting the same facts (C. 793) deserves also to be quoted, though it conveys no new information: ecrn Be xkafivBoeiBes to °~X*if ia T0 ^ eSdcfyois t?)? 7rdXe<»?, ov ra, p,ev eiri p,r)K0<; rrXevpd iari ra afiiic\viK\va-Ta because washed, the former by the Mediterranean, the latter by Lake Mareotis. The curvature of CDE accounts for the fact that these sides are spoken of as having a "diameter," by which I understand a straight line drawn from C to E. ra eirl TrXaTo? (irXevpd) are the short sides, AC and BE, called oi lo-dfioi as being the narrowest places between two bodies of water. Diodorus xvii. 52 does not go into particulars, simply saying: rbv Be tvttov kiroreXovo-a xXafivBi irapcnr\r)0-t,ov. There remains to be considered Strabo's repeated comparison of the inhabited portion of the earth to a chlamys. The most important passage for the present purpose is in C. 118, 119. According to this, the oUovfievr) may be conceived as a chlamys inscribed in a parallelogram. The greatest length of the chlamys is indicated in terms which correspond to a straight line con- necting C and E in our diagrams; its greatest breadth, to a straight line connecting H and D. The ends taper ( nvovpt&iv ; cf. C. 113: o-vvaepeiav be thought to imply a curve at the top as well as at the bottom, we may conceive the upper edge as forming a more shallow curve than the lower edge, as is suggested by the dotted line of Fig. 1. In conclusion, some possible objections to the foregoing views must be considered: 1. It has been assumed that, while the chlamys varied in size and proportions, it was cut on an essentially uniform pattern. Some may be inclined to assume, on the contrary, that there were distinct types of chlamys native to different regions, as a Mace- donian chlamys, a Thessalian chlamys, and possibly others. This view is clearly contradicted by our literary authorities. Strabo, Diodorus, and Plutarch, in the passages cited above, speak of the chlamys as if it had a fairly definite and well-known shape. Pliny's account of the site of Alexandria must be derived from the same source as the other similar accounts; and, if he speaks of a Macedonian chlamys, this can mean only that he regards the chlamys as of Macedonian origin. Similarly with the state- ment about the Thessalian chlamys in Hesychius, Photius, and Suidas, s. v. ®erra\iKa tnepd, and in Pollux vii. 46. That the Thessalian chlamys was not a special type of chlamys is evident from Pollux's assertion of the equivalence between ivrederTaXicr- fi.e$a and xKap,vho^>opovfi.ev. These lexical notes go back to some authority who regarded the chlamys as of Thessalian origin. 288 F. B. Takbell 2. It might be imagined that some essential change in the form of the chlamys took place between the fifth century b. c, to which most of our monumental evidence belongs, and the time of Strabo. This notion is possible enough a priori, but it receives no support from the evidence. The fact that the best- attested representations can be easily interpreted in accordance with the literary evidence, provided reasonable allowance be made for the absence of photographic accuracy in the rendering of drapery by Greek artists, is sufficient ground for believing that no essential change took place. 3. It may be objected that neither the inhabited world as known to Strabo nor the site of Alexandria had the form advocated for the chlamys in the foregoing discussion. This seems to be true. But it is not the facts, but certain writers' conceptions of the facts, that are relevant. In the absence of scientific surveys, topography was to a considerable extent a matter of fancy. The fancies with which we are now concerned are, I think, sufficiently clear. 4. The last objection which occurs to me is of a different sort. No representation of a chlamys, so far as I am aware, gives any suggestion of a seam, as if the garment were sewed together out of two or more pieces. This, to be sure, is not decisive, inasmuch as a seam is very rarely indicated in Greek art, even where it must have existed. 1 Nevertheless, although positive evidence is lacking, I am disposed to assume that the chlamys was of one piece. Now the ordinary web of cloth is of uniform breadth, and a chlamys of the shape advocated above, if cut out of such a web, could not have selvages at both ends, AC and BE, nor would it be likely to have a selvage even at one end, as that would involve unnecessary waste of cloth in cutting. But in the best example of the Orpheus relief, the one in Naples, the outer garment of Hermes, presumptively a chlamys, has the edge corresponding to BE of Fig. 2 characterized as a selvage. The Parthenon Frieze 1 For an indication of a seam in vase-painting see the interior of a cylix decorated by Aeson (Antike Denkmdler II, PI. 1). As for the statue published in the Bullettino delta commissione archeologica comunale di Roma XXV (1897) , PI. XII B and p. 175, and in the Brunn-Bruckmann Denkmdler, no. 357, where Helbig (Filhrer durch die Offent- Uchen Sammlungen klassischer Alterturner in Rom, 2" Auflage, no. 934) sees the indi- cation of a seam, I am inclined to think that, while the meeting edges of the Doric chiton are marked as selvages, the seam itself is not expressed. The Form of the Chlamys 289 affords still more troublesome cases. The youthful figure on the west side, numbered 12 by Michaelis, wears a supposed chlamys, each end of which shows the puckered selvage; and the same is probably true of No. 15 in the same series. These selvages, then, of which perhaps other instances might be found, constitute the difficulty with which this paragraph deals. As has been partly indicated already, there is no lack of ways of escape. For one thing, I am assured by one who ought to know that there is no impos- sibility in weaving on a hand-loom a web with its edges inclined inward, like AC and BE of the diagrams. Perhaps this was done, and, if so, there is nothing more to be said. If, however, we assume the ordinary rectangular web, there is always the pos- sibility that the chlamys was sewed together out of two or more pieces, in which case the difficulty again disappears. And if we do not wish to avail ourselves of this possibility, we may suppose, in the case of the Orpheus relief, either that the sculptor indi- cated the selvage arbitrarily and incorrectly or that he had in mind cases where the chlamys actually was cut with one end a selvage. In the case of the Parthenon sculptures, on the other hand, the selvages appear to be truthfully rendered, 1 and we are thus led to a query as to whether the two brooch-fastened gar- ments cited from the West Frieze are really chlamydes at all. May not they and with them others of similar appearance on the Frieze and elsewhere be examples of a rectangular garment, of which the Greek name was perhaps xkavfc or xkaviaicos ? So far as I can see, there is nothing decisive to be said against this. If this supposition, which I do not urge, be entertained as a pos- sibility, it would follow that in many cases of brooch-fastened garments represented in art it can not be certainly decided whether the name "chlamys" is applicable or not. 1 The only exception which I have di8covered i8 in the folded piece of stuff held by the priest in the East Frieze. In this piece two adjacent edges meeting at a right angle appear to be marked as selvages, where in any actual garment one of the edges would show a hem.