STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE AINH IN ANAXIMENES AND ANAXIMANDER By W. a. Heidel It has sometimes been doubted that Anaximenes believed in a hivT}. Zeller (I. 242. 4) controverts the contention of Teichmttller that the primordial motion of the Air was rotary. We might be content to accept Zeller's conclusion, if we could assume that Anaximenes distinguished between the primordial motion of the infinite Air and the original motion in the cosmos. But this assumption, made without definite evidence, would be extremely hazardous in the case of so early a thinker. Within the cosmos Zeller, though not without misgivings, is willing to accept the hiirq, regarding Anaximenes as the first to advance this view. In support of a hivrj in the system of Anaximenes we may offer the following considerations. 1. When Simplic. Phys. 24. 26 [Box. 477. 4), following Theophrastus, says, Kivrjcriv Be koX o?jto<; (as well as Anaximander) alSiov irotel, Bi' f)v Koi Tr)v fjLera^oXTjv yive(rOai, he doubtless referred to rotary motion; cf. Arist. Cael. 286 a. 9, ffeov 8' ivepyeia a6avaa-(a- TOVTO B' icrrl ^cor) aiBio<;. war avwyK-q tu> delm Kivrjaiv VTrdpxeiv. eVel S' o ovpavb<; TOtowro? (crw/Lta yap n delov) , Bca tovto e'x^ei to eyKVKXiov awfia, o ^vaei Kivelrai kvkXw aei. This conception was ancient; cf. Alcmaeon, fr. 2 (Diels) and Diels Parmenides Lehr- gedicht, p. 67. 2. [Plut. ] Strom. 3 and Hippol. i. 7. 3 use the verb eiroxeladai of the earth supported by the air, clearly implying that it is home by air in motion.^ The earth and the stars so borne are thin disks (Hippol. ibid, and Arist. Cael. 294 b. 13). These phenom- ena we are doubtless to conceive as analogous to that of leaves caught up by a whirlwind, cf. Arist. Cael. 295 a. 11. 3. Hippol. i. 7. 6 ov Kiveladai Be inro yrjv to, aarpa \eyec, Kadw erepoi vTrei\ijaaiv, aWa irepl yfjv, ma-Trepel irepl rrjv rj/jLerepav Ke(})a\7)v (TTpe^erai to inXCov. Here it is clearly assumed that there is a 'Cf. Diog. Laert. ix. 30 (speaking of Leueippus) : riiv yrjv dx^ufSai wepl ri iiiirov SivoviUv-qv ■ irxvi^ i"' aiTrjs TV/iiravuSes efpoi. Cf. also Diels Dox., pp. 46, 329 test. 6 3. LCLAS8ICAL Philology I, July, 1906] 279 280 W. A. Heidel general rotary motion in a horizontal plane, the circling diurnal movement of the heavens centering in the earth. Our ancient sources appear to confound two things in themselves sufficiently distinct: (a) position at the center of a circle (due to rotation in a plane) and (6) position at the center of a sphere. In spite of the allusions to Anaximander's cr^alpa and the spheres of the stars, I incline to think that the introduction of the scientific conception of the cosmos as a sphere was due chiefly to the Pythagoreans. The rotary motion in a plane accounts only for the position of the earth at the center of the Bivt], and not for the failure of the earth to fall in space. The latter problem does not seem to have troubled Anaximenes ; he might equally well have inquired why the cosmos does not fall. The remarks of Arist. Cael. 294 b. 13 ff. must therefore be taken as applying chiefly to Anaxagoras. 4. Diog. Laert. ii. 9 says of Anaxagoras: ra Be darpa kut' a/3%a? fiev doXoeiBoK ive')(6rjvai, axyre Kara Kopvr)v ttj'; yrj^ rbv aei (f>aiv6fievov elvai TToXov, vcrrepov Be rr/v eyKXicriv Xa^elv. In the first of these positions Anaxagoras, as we see, agreed with Anaximenes. The latter can not well be thought ignorant of the inclination of the ecliptic, the discovery of which is variously assigned to Anaximan- der or to Pythagoras. It is possible, therefore, that Anaximenes, like Anaxagoras, referred to the original motion of the stars. The mistake, if mistake there was, may have been due to the explana- tion he offered of the setting of sun and stars. But clearly such an explanation was possible even if he accepted a present inclination of the earth, since the phenomena to be explained are the same in any case. At all events, it is not without interest to note the close connection of two opinions — the inclination and the disk-shape of the earth. All of those philosophers — Empedocles, Anaxagoras,' Diogenes, Leucippus, Democritus — whom the doxographers quote on the first head were likewise agreed on the second. The infer- ence would seem to be clear. The disk-shape of the earth was supposed to be due to the action of a rotary cosmic motion oper- 1 Archelaus also should be included ; for according to him the earth is a disk, raised at the circumference and hollowed at the center. Cf . Hippol. i. 9. i (Dox. 563. 27) . His view of the inclination is particularly interesting and suggestive ; cf . Hippol ibid.: ^iriicXt^^pai 5^ rbv oipavbv yj<^t., Kal oiJrws rbv ^\uiv iwi ttjs 7^s iroi^trat ^wj Ka. rbv iipa woirjirai Stac^ar^ (to! rr/v yrjv ir)pdv. M/xvrjv yip ehai rb irpwTov. The Ati^ in Anaximenes and Anaximandee 281 ating in a plane and collecting the sediment (so to speak) of the eKKpicri^ at the center. See Philosophical Review XIV, p. 71. 1 have taken Anaximenes first because his case is comparatively strong. Zeller, as we have seen, inclines to accept the Bivt] as the discovery of Anaximenes, thus denying the notion to his prede- cessor Anaximander. We may now enumerate several considera- tions which lend support to the contrary view. 1. Simplic. Phys. 24. 13 {Dox. 476. 13): oI>to<; Se ovk aXXoiov- fxevov Tov aroi^eiov ttjv yeveaiv iroiei, aX)C uTTOKpivofievcov tS>v ivamitov Bm tj)? aiSlov Kivrj(T€(o<; . As was said above, Kivr}fft<; aiSio'; implies rotary motion. And, besides, the whole range of Greek philosophy connects aTroKpLo-Li and eKxpicri^ with the Bivrj.^ 2. The earth has the disk-shape ; cf . Hippol. i. 6 {Dox. 559. 28 f .). 3. Arist. Cael. 295 6. 10 : ela-l Be rti/e? oi Bia ttjv o/ioidTrjTo, aaiv avTTjv {sc. Trjv yrjv^ fieveiv, wuirep tmv ap')(^al(ov ' Ava^ifiavBpo<;. It is evident that Anaximander couched his explanation of the posi- tion of the earth in rather vague terms. This is proved by the interpretations offered by Aristotle and Theophrastus. The former in attempting to illustrate the thought alludes to the argument familiarly known as "Buridan's ass." This is hardly more absurd than the phrase used by Theophrastus [apud Hippol. i. 6. 3) Bia rrjv oiioCav ir-avrmv air-oaTacnv. It may be taken for granted that Anaximander was placing the earth in a circle rather than in a sphere. Assuming the Bivt) as established, it would seem most natural to understand him as attributing the central position of the earth to the uniformity of the surrounding strata — water all around, air next, and fire at the periphery, each in a uniform circle.^ 'Theodoretus iv. 16: ol Si rpbxov SUrfv repiSivetaSai (sc. tov kImimv). Diels Dox., p. 46 refers this to Anaximander. 2 This interpretation receives some support from two passages in Plato, namely Tim. 62 e ff . and Phaedo 109 a, although the argument here relates to position at the center of a sphere. In Plato the earth is of course a globe, and as such lubppowoi or t