STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 106 Book Reviews more vigorous but jealous colleague, Castellanus, perhaps as deservedly, has none. Everything that experience in making books can suggest has been employed to make this work easy of reference. There are excellent summaries — which might have been multiplied to advantage — useful tables, e. g., of the editiones principes of Greek and Latin authors, and elaborate tables of chronology and of bibliography. The illustrations, gathered with characteristic industry, from multifarious sources, are in general well executed, most of them presenting interesting portraits. Few errors occur in the excellently printed work. The Dutch name of Wowerius (or Woverius), it may be noted, was apparently Jan van den Wouwere, not van der Wouwer. But though the biographical method has the advantage of including in their proper place many interesting and instructive personal details, these are sometimes so disconnected that one is apt to miss the perspec- tive. We should have liked to have a clearer account of the tendencies of thought that marked each important epoch; a larger view of what the study of Greek and Latin has meant to different generations; the relation of that study to the civilization of each age, whereby the modern clas- sical student, for example, by apprehending better the lessons that Greek life and letters have had to offer at different times, might have deduced a stronger argument for the cause of Greek at the present time than this book can afford. Moreover, a separate survey of the progress of learning in the several departments of classical philology and archaeology would have been welcome. These fields are, of course, touched on in connection with the lives of men who were prominent in them; but a retrospect of the study of epigraphy, for example, or of rhetoric — not noticed as a special tend- ency in the Netherlands at the beginning of the seventeenth century — or of archaeology in general, would have been helpful. Here and there we get incidentally sections on the rise of the English colleges, on the pronunciation of Greek, on the founding of the national academies, and the like. By means of the index a student may piece together an account of the study of Homer or of Lucretius; but it will be piecework. Nevertheless, it is ungenerous to carp at these generous volumes, with their wealth of material soundly presented, affording the reader safe means for making his own generalizations. Charles Burton Gulick Harvard University Syntax des Nominativs und Accusativs im Lateinischen. By C. F. W. M0LLER. Leipzig und Berlin: Teubner, 1908. 175 pp. The veteran Ciceronian critic had undertaken the preparation of the " Kasuslehre " for the Historische Grammatik der lateinischen Sprache Book Eeviews 107 now in course of publication under the editorial supervision of Landgraf , and early in 1903 had already sent to the printer the portion of the work covering the nominative, vocative, and accusative cases. His death fol- lowed soon after, before he had begun the correction of the proofs, and the volume, issued as a Supplement to the Historische Grammatik, was put through the press by his colleague Skutsch, assisted by Witte und Kroll. 1 Three pages are devoted to the nominative and vocative; the remain- der of the book deals with the accusative, and is an exhaustive presenta- tion of the history of that case from the beginnings of the literature down to the latest grammarians and Church Fathers. The first and fullest chapter treats of the " Accusativ des Inhalts," covering not only the com- moner manifestations of that use, but in great detail the instances of the cognate accusative and of neuter pronouns and adjectives. Subsequent topics are the " Accusative of Extent," " Greek Accusative " (distinguished naturally from the use with passives used as middles), the various types of the "Accusativ des Effekts," the "Double Accusative," " Accusative with Compounded Intransitives," "Accusatives with Substantives," and the various idiomatic uses, such as magnam partem, id genus, etc. I have noted no discussion of the " Accusative of Limit of Motion." Though a very full repository of pertinent illustrations classified with great accuracy, the work is much more than that. The virtually com- plete material which Miiller's industry had accumulated enables him to discuss many problems with a more adequate basis for judgment than was possible for any previous writer on the subject. Kritz and Kraner, for example, had maintained that multum in its abverbial use denoted only " Maas " or " Grad." Dietsch on Sallust Jugurtha i. 5, suggests "in adverbio multum inest aut rei saepius factae aut modi maioris, inter- dum ambae vix distingui possunt." What had been an inadequately supported impression on Dietsch's part, becomes in the light of Miiller's copious illustrations an established fact. Only the context can determine whether multum in a given case means "often" or "to a high degree." Often, too, we receive from Miiller important corrections of the statements of earlier scholars as to the frequency or range of a construction. Thus WOlfflin Comparation, p. 29, tells us that, apart from Plaut. Aul. 420, plus miser, the comparative of adjectives formed with plus does not occur before Tertullian. But Miiller cites some fifteen instances of the formation from Ennius, Horace, Livy, Ovid, Gellius, Quintilian, and other writers. Hand, iv, p. 474, had said: " pauca sunt verba, veluti diligendi, credendi, nocendi, quae cum adverbio plurimum componi solent," and cited but four verbs with which plurimum occurred. Miil- ler's material shows conclusively that Hand was ignorant both of the 1 Mttller had also begun work upon the dative, but had not proceeded far when death overtook him. The few pages of his manuscript treating of this case have recently been published in Olotta, II, pp. 169 ff. 108 Book Reviews frequency of the use and its range. It is found with no fewer than six- teen different verbs of a considerable variety of meanings in Cicero alone, to say nothing of its far from infrequent use in Sallust, Caesar, Livy, and other writers. In dealing with textual problems Miiller naturally exhibits the same conservatism as characterizes his own textual labors, and is inclined to support MS tradition as against the acceptance of conjectures. Thus in Caesar B. G. ii. 35, he holds to xv dies supplicatio decreta est (where editors write in dies or dierum), citing in support Cato Agr. 112. 2, in sole ponito biduum; 162. 3, suspendito in vento biduum; as well as Livy xxvii. 4. 15, supplicatio diem indicia, where again in has been gratuitously inserted by editors. Despite the wealth of material presented in Mtiller's volume, there are topics where fuller illustration is desirable. One misses citations of passages showing two accusatives with transduco, particularly as bear- ing on the text in Caesar B. O. ii. 10. 1, funditores pontem traducit, where Meusel, followed by many recent editors, reads ponte. Similarly under celo, and particularly in the case of verbs of making, calling, regarding, and the like with two accusatives. But omissions of this sort are rare and relatively trivial. The value and importance of the work will be at once apparent to all who desire to learn the ultimate facts of usage from an authoritative source, and will assure its title to be regarded, as Skutsch in his Preface himself denominates it, " ein dauernder Besitz unserer Wissenschaf t." Charles E. Bennett Cornbll University C. Suetoni Tranquilli opera. Vol. I: De vita Caesarum libri viii. Recensuit Maximilianus Ihm. Editio minor. Leip- zig: Teubner, 1908. Pp. 359. M. 2.40. The first volume of Ihm's new recension of Suetonius, which was published by Teubner in 1907, is now added to the "Bibliotheca Scrip- torum Graecorum et Romanorum Teubneriana," with such omissions as the scope of this series rendered necessary. The text is naturally the same as that of the editio maior, and the critical apparatus, which in accordance with the usage in the more recent volumes of this series is at the foot of the page, although considerably reduced, contains all of the most important variant readings. The testimonia, however, are omitted, as well as the illustrations. The Preface gives the history of the text and the relations of the MSS, together with the lists of editions and special works dealing with the author, but considerations of space have compelled the omission of the valuable list of mendorum genera, which is found in the larger edition.