STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE COST OF LIVING IN ROMAN EGYPT By Louis C. West The material here presented has been gathered in a search after evidence relating to the exchange of commercial products between the different provinces of the Roman Empire, a work still uncompleted. While having little, if any, direct connection with the larger problem, the facts gathered together in the accompanying tables are interesting and valuable, for they show clearly the conditions under which one part of the Empire lived and worked; they also show the nature of the objects which entered most largely into the internal trade of Egypt. The lists of articles with their prices are in large part self- explanatory, and accordingly no attempt will be made here to do more than emphasize in a general way the main points of interest. This will be done by considering the material from two different points of view; in the first place by dividing it into chronological periods, so that the relationship of prices within each period and in com- parison with other periods may be seen; in the second place by select- ing some commodity other than money as the standard of value, and on this basis considering the relation of prices to the wages of labor. Finally, an attempt will be made to compare the prices in the papyri of the early fourth century with those in Diocletian's edict and to point out how far our opinion of that edict is affected by the comparison. In the way of a thorough understanding of all the information offered by these prices there is at present one great difficulty: i.e., the impossibility of determining the exact value of the coins men- tioned in the papyri. But despite this, many interesting facts are clear, and there is always the hope that new discoveries will lead to a more exact determination of the money values. It is tempting to draw comparisons between the ancient Egyptian workman and our own American workman, but as such comparisons are usually misleading, none will be made here. A workman in this country earning $2.00 per day when wheat is $1.00 per bushel is [Classical Philology XI, July, 1916] 293 294 Louis C. West not five times better off than the ancient workman earning 20 cents a day when wheat was 50 cents a bushel. The difference in social standards and in climate compels our workman to spend more on his food, both in quality and quantity, on his clothing, on protection against the weather, on amusements, education, medicine, insurance. In fact it is probably not an exaggeration to say that the Egyptian fellah earning 20 cents a day at the present time can bring up a family with less worry and trouble than one of our own workman earning $2 . 00 per day. The most evident feature in any list of prices current during the Empire is the fall in the value of money, a movement that began early in the first century and that never ceased. It becomes notice- able first in the revolutionary period of the third century, when the fifty years of internal strife permanently disorganized the industrial and commercial life of the entire Empire. But great as was the decline in that period, it was nothing in comparison with the fall in the fourth century, when the old money terms lose all meaning, being partially displaced by the new coins of Constantine, and to a greater extent being replaced by barter. This is a phenomenon in no way peculiar to Egypt, but one general to the entire Empire. In dealing with a people like the Egyptians, whether it be the Egyptians of today or of any older period, we are chiefly concerned with the subsidiary coinage rather than with the gold coinage. The small wages earned by the common laborer made his possession of a gold piece a matter of very rare occurrence. Just as today in Egypt business is transacted in terms of the piaster (a coin equiva- lent to five cents), so in ancient Egypt business was transacted in terms of the drachma or denarius. This fact becomes more impor- tant when we remember that the debasement of the subsidiary coinage was far greater than the debasement of the gold pieces. Thus the solidus of Constantine was worth five-ninths of the aureus of Julius Caesar, but the denarius of Constantine was worth only one four-hundred-and-twentieth part of the denarius of Julius Caesar. Among the prices in our table which may be assigned to the period before Nero, there is one of great interest: the wage of 3j, 4, and 6 asses paid to weavers in the time of Augustus. With this may be compared the wage of 12 asses paid in Rome to day laborers The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt 295 in the time of Cicero, some fifty years earlier (see Pro. Q. Rose. x. 28). As both these workmen were among the more poorly paid classes, we may say that the difference between 3J asses and 12 asses represents the relative difference of the cost of sustaining life in the two coun- tries — a difference made necessary by the greater amount of clothing, of food, of protection against the weather, required in Italy. This difference is further increased by the fact that these Egyptian weavers were probably earning wages slightly higher than those paid ordinary laborers. The 3§, 4, and 6 asses of the papyrus are equiva- lent to 5|, 6, and 9 obols which may be compared with the 3, 4, and 5 obols paid farm laborers in the year 78/79 a.d., when money was worth roughly 5 per cent less than in the time of Augustus. For the second period into which our material may be divided — that between Nero and Trajan — we have one extremely important document, i.e., the account book kept on a large estate at Hermopolis in the year 78/79 a.d. From the prices given there we find that a farm laborer would earn from 13 to 21| drachmae (91 to 150f obols) per month. This would enable him to buy If to 2 artabae of wheat; from 5 to 9 artabae of vegetables; from f to 1 artaba of lentils. If we take prices found in other documents of the same period, we find this laborer would need approximately one year's earnings to purchase a donkey, or the entire earnings of 2\ to 4 years' labor to purchase the eight-year-old slave girl mentioned in the table. With a superabundance of labor forced to work at such wages, it is easy to see why slave owning was not profitable in Egypt. As a matter of fact, the slaves mentioned in the papyri are, almost without exception, women kept as concubines or persons kept as domestic servants. Needless to say, neither class was ever owned by the ordinary fellah. The prices in the document just mentioned (P.B.M., 131) present an interesting problem. The wages paid farm laborers, 3 to 5 obols per day, are less than those paid weavers in the time of Augustus and also less than those paid farm laborers in the year 105 a.d. Both of these ratios are such as we should expect. In the case of wheat and other produce the ratios with prices at other periods are not what one would expect. For example, the price of wheat is actually higher than in the documents of the years 125, 149, and 183 a.d., 296 Louis C. West while vegetables are higher than in the year 191/92 a.d. Both of these differences are greatly increased when we take into account the fall in the value of money by the end of the second century. There seems only one obvious explanation for these facts, and that is a deficiency in the Nile flood of the year 78 a.d. and a correspond- ing decrease in the amount of arable land and in the quantity of grain that was harvested. Under such conditions wages either remain constant or actually decrease, while prices of food supplies always advance. In the period of approximately 35 years after the date of the docu- ment which has just been discussed (78/79 a.d.) we find wages of farm laborers have approximately doubled. In 105 a.d. wages were from 6 to 9 obols per day in place of the 3 to 5 paid in the earlier period. Eight years later, in 113 a.d., laborers on the canal banks at Hermopolis were paid 40 drachmae per month, or approximately 9 obols per day. Ox drivers were paid less than half this amount, but as far as I know, the reason for this difference is unknown. Despite the rise in wages, the price of wheat, judging from the one document of the period, is actually lower than in 78/79 a.d. This price, however, is in close agreement with prices in the years 149 and 183 a.d., and so is undoubtedly a normal one. It is an interesting fact that in spite of a further fall in the value of money elsewhere, both wages and prices remained approximately the same until the end of the second century. For this period of seventy-five or eighty years, 8 or 9 obols per day was a fair wage and 8 drachmae (56 obols) per artaba a fair price for wheat. At this wage and price a workman could earn between 4J and 5 artabae per month, an extremely large sum, as will be shown later. From documents of the middle of the second century we have much interesting material on the value of farm animals. It is clear that their value was so great that the purchase of one was nearly, if not altogether, impossible for the common laborer. Averaging the value of nine camels sold between 144 a.d. and 160 a.d., we find that they represented an investment of about nine months' labor. Compared with modern prices this is extremely interesting. An ordinary camel today is worth about $75.00 and represents about seventeen months' labor at the usual wage (3 piasters, or 15 cents The Cost op Living in Roman Egypt 297 per day). It is often said that the position of the common man was more favorable during the second century of our era than at any other period in Roman history. This seems to be borne out by the evi- dence of our tables. If we are justified in estimating the laborer's pay at about 4| artabae per month, we find him earning twice the amount the papyri show he earned in the first century or in the fourth and later centuries. Compared with conditions today, his lot was equally favorable. We have just seen that he could earn a camel in about one-half the time necessary today, while for every bushel of wheat earned today, he could earn a bushel and a half. For the period between the death of Septimius Severus and the accession of Diocletian, we are singularly devoid of information on which to base inferences of value. At the earlier period the denarius seems to have had a value of about seven cents. In the edict of Diocletian the value of the denarius is stated to be about four-tenths of a cent, but as will be pointed out shortly, there seem to be reasons for believing this value is somewhat inflated. In terms of money, the wages of this period have increased greatly over those of the pre- ceding century, but the increase was far from proportional to the decline in the value of money. In 215 a.d. we find a bricklayer's assistant earning 2 drachmae per day; an amount that is paid to an ordinary laborer in 258/59 a.d. Compared with the wage at 9 obols paid in the preceding century, this wage of 2 drachmae represents an increase of 5 obols per day or of 55 per cent. Wheat likewise advanced. In place of the 8 drachmae per artaba of the Antonine period we find prices of 16, 18, 19, 20 drachmae, representing an advance of 100 to 150 per cent, or two or three times the advance in wages. In other words, wages had been greatly decreased. It is impossible to compare accurately the wages of labor as given in the edict of Diocletian with those paid in Egypt. Those of Diocletian are naturally much higher, as they seem to be based on conditions found in Eastern Europe and in Asia Minor, rather than along the Nile. If we take the wage paid unskilled labor — 25 denarii per day and keep — we have a wage equivalent to 1\ artabae of wheat per month, leaving the "keep" altogether out of the calcu- lation. If we consider the amount of wheat in a contract of the year 605 a.d. in which a man agrees to work for two years at a total 298 Louis C. West wage of 19 artabae, as the least amount necessary to support life, and add this to the 7§ artabae, we have a wage equivalent to 8| artabae per month. This is about four times the amount earned by contemporary labor in Egypt. It is interesting to recall that this ratio is in close accord with the ratio of the wages of 3§ and 12 asses earned in Egypt and Italy respectively at the beginning of our era. When we reach the period beyond Constantine, the old money terms almost cease to have any meaning. During the fourth cen- tury we find wheat selling at 26, 30, and 50 talents an artaba; barley at 25 and 30 talents an artaba; aracus at 1,800,000 denarii an artaba; dates at 15 talents an artaba; a pound of meat at 330,000 denarii; chickens at 5 talents apiece; eggs at 2,500 denarii each; two slaves at 2,400 talents; 1,800 pounds of straw at 144 talents; a cowhide at 75,000,000 denarii. Laborers' pay had risen to 200 talents a month. It is when we compare these values with those of the earlier centuries that we realize most forcibly the enormous depreciation of the currency. Thus the rise of wheat from 10 drachmae in 78/79 a.d. to 50 talents in 350 a.d. is equivalent to a fall in the value of the denarius from 1 to TSTnnnr- This decline may be shown in another way: in 134 a.d. a cow was sold for 44 drachmae; in360A.D. a pound of meat was sold for 145,000 denarii. This means that for the price of a pound of meat at the middle of the fourth century, over 1,300 cattle could have been purchased at the middle of the second century. Other similar examples may be found in the tables; for example, the rise of an artaba of lentils from 2| to 800 drachmae in the period from 78/79 a.d. to the fourth century. New terms gradually took the place of the denarius and talent. Thus, in the literary sources we find wheat, wine, and other commodities sold at so many measures per solidus. For smaller transactions the follis was used, but these terms are comparatively rare in the papyri, neither of them, apparently, coming into general use in Egypt until shortly before the Arab conquest. In the papyri from the fourth century onward one new term, the myriad of denarii in place of the single denarius, comes into rather general use, but as in all other parts of the Empire the common people were coming more and more to disregard money and were exchanging their produce by The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt 299 barter. One of our papyri is of particular interest as belonging to what may be called an intermediate stage between exchange by means of money and exchange by means of barter. In this docu- ment of the year 360 a.d. 40 artabae of aracus are said to equal in value 72,000,000 denarii or 500 pounds of meat. Here, it is safe to assume, the bargaining was conducted in terms of the produce, and the money value was written in the papyrus merely as a formality. The uncertainty as to the value of money was responsible in part for the growing custom of paying wages and taxes in kind. For the collection of taxes there were two sets of officials, one for payments in kind, the other for payments in money. In the payment of wages in kind the government perhaps followed the lead of private employers. Two private documents mentioning such payments are quoted in the tables. Other documents combine payments in money and in produce, as does a contract of the year 569 a.d. Here a man binds himself to act as house servant at a yearly wage of 10 artabae of wheat, 4 artabae of barley, 12 xestae of oil, 24 cnidia of wine, and 95 talents of money. The careful enumeration of the articles of food and drink in this document makes it apparent that the money was the least important part of the transaction. In such contracts, entered into, as we may believe, chiefly from a desire to escape the crushing oppression of the tax collector, every advan- tage was on the side of the rich man. Having once entered into service, the employee lost his freedom of action, and to all intents and purposes he became the serf of the employer. From such con- tracts the great feudal estates in Egypt and in other parts of the Empire, in large part, took their rise. If we attempt to draw from our tables any general conclusions as to the relation of wages and the prices of commodities, it is neces- sary, owing to our ignorance of the value of the coins, to use some standard other than money. Wheat is eminently suited for this purpose, both because there can be no great variation due to differ- ences in quality, and, secondly, because it formed the chief item of food among the common people. If we consider, therefore, the papyri in which both the price of wheat and the wage of labor are mentioned, we are enabled to figure the amount of wheat earned per 300 Louis C. West month by the common laborer, and so obtain an effective basis for comparison. This information may be tabulated as follows: 78/79 a.d 2 artabae per month (P.B.M., 131) 314 a.d 1 i artabae per month (Pap. Rainer, E, 2000) Fourth century. . .2-1% artabae per month (Pap. Rainer, AN, 295) Fourth century. . .2 artabae per month (Pap. Rainer, AN, 289) Averaging 2 artabae per month This amount is in exact agreement with P.B.M., 125, where 2 artabae of wheat are given as a month's wage. Although such an amount looks extremely small to us, it was sufficient to maintain the laborer and the non-productive part of his family, namely the children under five or six years of age. Under the Ptolemies an artaba of dura per month was considered a sufficient amount for the proper maintenance of a soldier (see Kenyon, P.B.M., I, 168). This grain was slightly cheaper than wheat, but if we disregard the difference and consider one artaba of wheat per month as a bare living wage, we have a safe basis on which to compare earnings at other periods. Even at a wage of one artaba per month, there was undoubtedly a small surplus available for needs other than food. This is made evident by a contract of the year 605 a.d., already referred to, where a worker in purple agrees to serve two years at a total wage of 19 artabae of wheat — an amount that must have been sufficient to sustain life if nothing else. Even lower than this wage is that provided for in earlier contracts governing apprenticeships. Here we find that 4 or 5 drachmae per day were paid as the equivalent of a boy's food (see Oxyrhyn. Pap. 275 of 66 a.d. and Tebt. Pap. 385 of 117 a.d.). At the contemporary prices of wheat these amount approximately to \ artaba per month. If we average all the wages of unskilled labor and all the prices of wheat available for the first two centuries, we obtain an average wage of about 2f artabae per month. Despite the elements of uncertainty which enter into such a calculation, the result is in rather close agreement with that shown in the preceding table. If, how- ever, we take each value of wheat separately and compare it with the nearest available wage we obtain results widely at variance with those given above, but as we are altogether uncertain whether the local conditions which governed the price and the wage are identical or not, the result is not trustworthy. The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt 301 Today in Egypt one gains the impression that the common people are working for the mere right to exist, their wages permitting nothing but the bare necessities of life. That conditions in Egypt under the Romans and probably in every other period were not different for the bulk of the population is clearly shown by the com- parison of wages and prices that has just been made. No attempt has been made here to estimate the earnings of skilled labor. So many things enter into the question of such wage, as for example, the degree of skill in a weaver or an acrobat, the reputation of a race-track manager, that it seems impossible to deduce any conclusions of value from our evidence. In a general way, the articles in our list of prices may be divided into two classes: luxuries and necessities. We have just seen that the peasant could buy nothing but the necessities. In all probabil- ity, to judge from modern conditions, his buying power was limited to grain, a few vegetables, herbs for sauces and relishes, a little cloth- ing, a covering under which to lie at night, and two or three coarse household pots. All other objects were for the richer classes. In Table I an effort has been made to show the modern equiva- lents of certain coins at different dates in the period under considera- tion. It would be idle to claim that the figures represent anything but a rough approximation of the truth. There seems no more bewildering problem in the whole field of papyrus studies than the valuation of the money in use in Roman Egypt. Diocletian in his edict tells us the number of denarii, 50,000, in a pound of gold, thus furnishing an exact valuation. In certain other reigns we are told the weight of the aureus or solidus, but even then we cannot be sure that the coin mentioned in the papyrus contains the legal weight of gold. Thus in P.B.M., 483 of 616 a.d. the solidus there used was said to be one-twelfth below the proper weight. At one time three gold standards seem to have been in use in Egypt. In Oxyrhyn. Pap. 154 of the seventh century a sale of 482f artabae, 1 choenix of wheat was made for 48 7 V solidi less 193 ceratia on the private standard, or for 36^V solidi on the public standard, or for 36|4 solidi on the Alexandrine standard. One of the edicts of Jus- tinian is directed against the Egyptian custom of making a distinc- tion between pure and impure gold, but the document just quoted as well as others (i.e., O.P., 126 of 572 a.d.) show it had little effect. 302 Louis C. West Even if we knew the weight of the gold coin we could not be sure of its relation to the subsidiary coinage, for the extent to which the smaller coins were debased makes it impossible to place any reliance on their legal or theoretical values. A comparison of the value of the denarius as given by Diocletian with its value in the next few years makes it possible that Diocletian's evaluation is not altogether trustworthy. A few years after the abdication of Diocletian, Constantine reformed the currency, making the solidus T V of a pound and the denarius Tinnr °f * ne solidus or yj-gVinr °f a pound of gold. This is less than one-eighth the value of the denarius as given in the edict of Diocletian. Such a drop in the course of ten or eleven years is almost unthinkable. The effect of such a depreciation in Egypt where business was conducted largely in terms of the sub- sidiary coinage may be surmised from the relative depreciation of the gold and other coinage. Thus, the solidus of Constantine was worth about 16 per cent less than the corresponding gold coin of Diocletian, but the denarius of Constantine shows a decrease of 1200 per cent from the denarius of Diocletian as given in the edict. Great as are these decreases in the value of the coinage, the advances made in the price of commodities are even greater. According to Diocletian, wheat was to sell no higher than 100 denarii a modius; in 314 a.d. it was sold for 10,000 drachmae an artaba, an increase of 57 times. In the same way barley in 314 a.d. shows an increase of 95 times the price in 301 a.d. Wine sold in 301 a.d. for 8 denarii a sextarius; in 314 a.d. for 1,800 drachmae a cnidium or 360 drachmae a sextarius, an increase of 45 times. Lentils increased about 8 times, a Baby- lonian hide, 2,400 times, shoes 20 times. Differences such as these are difficult to explain if we regard the denarius in 301 a.d. as actually worth what Diocletian said it should be worth. All our facts, how- ever, tempt us to believe that Diocletian in his efforts to systematize the value of money was endeavoring to give a totally fictitious value to the denarius. This hypothesis has been put forward by Bucher in a publication so far inaccessible to me. It is supported by the familiar quotation from Lactantius who says in reference to the edict: "then much blood was shed for the veriest trifles; men were afraid to offer anything for sale, and the scarcity became more excessive and grievous than ever." The only condition under which men ordinarily refuse to sell is when they are unable to obtain a fair The Cost op Living in Roman Egypt 303 return for their produce. In 301 a.d., therefore, producers must have felt that in selling wheat at 100 denarii they were obtaining in return far less than they should. On the other hand, it seems natural to assume that Constantine, in reforming the currency, gave the denarius a legal value approxi- mating its true value at the time. From later edicts of the years 396 a.d. and 445 a.d. we learn that the government at those periods was unable to enforce a fictitious value of the denarius and in each year promulgated a new legal value in close agreement with the actual value of the coin. That the subsidiary coinage which was, in reality, nothing but a fiat coinage, varied in value from day to day is self-evident from modern analogies. It is also supported by an interesting statement in a private letter of the late fourth century: "the solidus now stands at 2,020 myriads (of denarii) ; it has gone down" (see O.P., 1223). In conclusion, it should be stated that all references to the papyri of the Rainer Collection have been taken from various publications by Wessely. All other references have been verified. TABLE I Roughly Approximate Values op the Coihs Mentioned in the Text Date Coin Value Remarks J. Caesar aureus $5.4335 denarius 0.2173 Augustus aureus 5.1765 denarius 0.2071 Nero aureus 4.9170 denarius 0.1975 Trajan denarius 0.1214 S. Severus denarius 0.0714 M. Aurelius denarius 0.0976 Caracalla aureus 4.348 Gordian denarius 0.0717 Diocletian aureus 3.6224 follis 0.0087 denarius 0.00435 Constantine 312 a.d. solidus 3.018 siliq.ua (orceratium) 0.12575 talent 0.02515 follis 0.01214 of 323 a.d. nummus 0.01049 denarius 0.000503 Middle fourth century talent 0.00988 End fourth century follis 0.01238 myriad of denarii 0.001494 cf. O.P. 1223 denarius 0.000443 445 a.d. follis 0.013566 denarius 0.000419 Sixth century follis 0.01428 early Justinian " 0.014994 in 538 a.d. " 0.01666 in 558 a.d. denarius 0.000345 early in century Sixth to seventh century myriad of denarii 0.000483 304 Louis C. West table II A. Wages of Workmen Date Employment Term Wage Authority 1 A.D. weaver per day 3} asses O.P. 737 u « hired man 1 « It 4 asses O.P. 737 N It foremen of weavers a a 6 asses O.P. 737 8/9 A.D. performer or artiste' farm laborers' « « 1 dr., 4J ob. O.P. 731 78/79 a.d. It It 3-5 ob. P.B.M. 131 « u donkey boys it it 2Job. P.B.M. 131 92 A.D. guard per month 40 dr. P.B.M. 701 First century guard laborers per day 1 dr., 5 ob. O.P. 390 « i « « 4 ob. O.P. 985 105 A.D. laborers, men* « « 6ob. Fayum Towns 102 * «i " , young men u u 5 ob. Fayum Towns 102 41 * laborers, boys it u 1-4 ob. Fayum Towns 102 a u men for yonoi and SpayfiaTo. n it 7-8 ob. Fayum Towns 102 113 A.D. contractor in charge of water works per month 40 dr. P.B.M. 1177 " " laborers on water works 6 it a 40 dr. P.B.M. 1177 it a contractor for ox drivers a a 32 dr. P.B.M. 1177 u « ox drivers it it 16 dr. P.B.M. 1177 125 A.D. laborers per day 9ob. Fayum Towns 331 143 A.D. u " ** 8ob. B.G.U. 99 154 A.D. u u u 8ob. B.G.U. 391 160 A.D. * u u 8ob. P.B.M. 296 162 A.D. « It u 8ob. B.G.U. 704 165 A.D. contractor with three camel drivers and four boys to carry grain 40 dr. P.B.M. 331 168 A.D. laborers It It 8ob. P.B.M. 337 172 A.D. bricklayer* per 10,000 bricks per day 40 dr. Tebt. Pap. 402 178/9 a.d. laborers 8ob. B.G.U. 359 183 A.D. wages of weaver's apprentice.' Nothing for 2 yrs. 7 mos., then rest of third year per month 12 dr. O.P. 725 fourth " It u 16 dr. fifth It It 24 dr. 1 This is the rather unsatisfactory translation of the conductei of the papyrus. 2 This performer contracted to serve 30 days at 1 dr., 2 ob. per day, plus a bakshish, or tip, of 13 dr., 2 ob., on the completion of his contract. • In a Pompeian inscription (C.I.L., 4, 4,000), the sum of 5 asses is allowed for diaria. • Frontinus De Aq. 116 gives the sum of 250,000 sesterces as that paid to a familia of 240 slaves engaged on the aqueducts. The sum includes both the maintenance of the slaves and the cost of the supplies needed in their work. We may perhaps estimate the wage alone as 2 or 3 sesterces per man per day. » Why the laborer should in this instance be paid as much as his foreman is not clear to me. • In Tebt. Pap. 402 of 172 a.d. the laying of 2,200 bricks is shown to be a fair day's work. At the rate of 40 drachmae for 10,000 this amounts to a wage of 8f drachmae per day. It is unfortunate that the number of men necessary to lay 2,200 bricks is unknown. ' In addition to these payments, the teacher was to give the boy a tunic each year costing 16, 20, 24, 28, 32 drachmae respectively. The Cost of Living in Eoman Egypt 305 TABLE II — Continued Date Employment Term "Wage Authority 187 A.D. nurse for 2 years 400 dr. O.P. 91 190/1 A.D. sitologos per year 400 dr. O.P. 514 Second century stevedores 1 per day 1 dr., 3 ob. O.P. 522 u a " It u 4ob. O.P. 522 u a stone cutter with keep donkey driver It u 4 dr. O.P. 498 a it u n 1 dr., 5 ob. O.P. 1049 it a u a It u 2 dr., 4 ob. O.P. 1049 a it workman tying bundles It It 1 dr., 5 ob. O.P. 1049 215 A.D. bricklayer u u 2} dr. B.G.IT. 362 U. U " , as- sistant U It 2 dr. B.G.U. 362 255 a.d. u a it 6-9 dr. B.G.U. 14 258/59 a.d. laborers it it 2 dr. P.B.M. 1170 301 a.d. manual laborer with keep it it 25 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 7.1 « u bricklayer it « 50 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 7.2 a u stone mason a it 50 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 7.7 314 A.D. laborers it « 400 dr. Pap. Rainer E 2000 *c a u it it 500 dr. Pap. Rainer E 2000 it It u It u 650 dr. Pap. Rainer E 2000 340 a.d. II per month 12 tal. B.G.U. 21 u it " U It 15 tal. B.G.U. 21 it u u It It 25 tal. B.G.U. 21 Fourth century cobblers per month(?) 60 tal. Pap. Rainer NN94 Pap. Rainer 37 « u oil workers (?) 130 tal. it it tarsicarius per day 8 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 a u weaver per month 136 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 a a groom n u 3,500 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 299 It u mulio it it 6,000 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 299 it a shipmaster per day 100 tal. Pap. RainerE 1014 M U laborer per month 200 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 It It " , assistant U It 60 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 It It « it It It 60 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 It It u it a 2 art. of wheat P.B.M. 125 It It lanarius It u 2 art. of wheat P.B.M. 125 It u mechanic a it 4 art. of wheat P.B.M. 125 U It cook It u 25 art. of wheat P.B.M. 125 Anastasius laborer without per day 4 ceratia Zach. of Mitylene donkey 7. 6 it laborer with donkey 2 a it 8 ceratia Zach. of Mitylene 7. 6 590 a.d. laborer it it 4/9 cnidium of wine 19 art. of wheat O.P. 207 605 a.d. purple worker for 2 years Erman u. Krebs, Aus d. Pap. d. k6n. mus., p. 219 610/11 A.D. man in charge of race track and stable per year 72 solidi O.P. 138 618 A.D. starter in the hip- podrome per month 5ft ceratia O.P. 152 1 This is perhaps the foreman of the stevedores. 2 These were wages paid in the construction of Dara in Mesopotamia and are said to be extremely high. 306 Louis C. West TABLE II — Continued B. Pood and Drink Article Date Measure Price Authority Wine 8 B.C. 300 cotylae 18 dr. P.B.M. 1171 u 1 A.D. 1 jar 6 dr. O.P. 745 a 78/9 a.d. 1 " 10 dr. P.B.M. 131 «f 130 A.D.I 1 « 7J dr. O.P. 472 M 191/2 A.D.» 1 « 15 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 19. 2 m M U 1 « 16 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 3. 10 M M It 1 cnidiumi 24 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 35. 21 a second century 1 jar 8 dr., 1 ob. O.P. 522 u u a 1 " 8 dr., 4 ob. Wilcken, G.O., I, 356 a « a 1 « 3 denar. Glessen Pap. 79 M 254 a.d. 1 monochorum 8 dr. P.B.M. 1226 « 267 a.d. 101 jars 1,100 dr. O.P. 1055 « third century 1 chus 16 dr. Grenfell, Gk. Pap. II, 77 Grenfell, Gk. tt a u 1 " 20 dr. Pap. II, 77 « 301 A.D. 1 sextarius 8 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 2. 10 « 314 A.D. 1 cnldium 1,800 dr. Pap. Bainer E2000 M 340 a.d. 1 34tal. B.G.U. 21 M «f u 1 xestes 3 tal. B.G.U. 21 M 350 a.d. 1 cnldium 2 tal. P.B.M. 429 « m u 1 spathium 25 tal. P.B.M. 249 K fourth century 1 jar 2 tal., 2,000 dr. O.P. 1288 « a u 1 spathium 7 tal. O.P. 1298 M u u 1 xestes 330,000 denar. P.B.M. 984 « a it 1 • 4 tal., 2,000 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 289 « u a 1 cnidium 1 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 « a a 1 3 tal., 2,000 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 295 « a u 1 20 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 u a u 1 spathium 5 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 It u u 1 20 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 cc u u 1 xestes' 2 tal. Pap. Rainer 37 B.G.U. 14 Vinegar 255 a.d.« 1 jar 12 dr. u 340 a.d. 1 xestes 1,060 dr. B.G.U. 21 Beer Tiberius 1 chus 2ob. Tebt. Pap. 401 a 78/79 a.d. 1 measure Hob. P.B.M. 131 a 301 a.d. 1 sextarius 2 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 2. 12 1 In this document 150 jars of wine are pledged for the interest on 1$ talents of money. At the usual rate of 12 per cent, this means each jar was pledged for 7£ dr., which ia probably a little less than the real value. •This price is only approximate. In the papyrus 38 jars are sold for 542 dr., 1 chalcus. Goodspeed, op. tit., p. 33 translates the "Xj;" of the papyrus as "four dozen" thus obtaining a price of 111 dr. per jar. 3 Goodspeed, op. cit., p. 63 favors considering the kviSIo of the papyrus as a diminutive of kvISi) (nettle) rather than from kvISmv as here in the table. 4 In Mesopotamia in ordinary times 25 measures of wine could be purchased for one aureus ; in times of famine, the price rose until 2 measures only could be purchased for the same amount (see Joshua the Stylite, Chron. 43, 87 for the years 501/2 and 503/4 a.d.). In the reign of Theodoric wine could be purchased in Italy at the rate of 30 amphorae for one solidus (see Frag. Anon. Vales. 73) . « In Dacia in the year 166 a.d. vinegar was sold at the rate of J denarius for 1 sextarius; see C.I.L., 3, p. 953. The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt 307 TABLE II — Continued Article Date Measure Price Authority Raphanus oil 255 A.D. 1 cotyla 2 dr. B.G.U. 14 Oil 18 B.C. 1 choenix 5 dr. Fayum Towns 101 U 1 A.D. 1 chus 4 dr. 2 ob. O.P. 739 * a It 1 a 4 dr. 3 ob. O.P. 739 It a it 1 " 4 dr. 4 ob. O.P. 736 U it it 1 * 5 dr. O.P. 819 m 191/2 A.D.I 1 * 16 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 24. 16 it 255 a.d. 1 cotyla 4 dr. B.G.U. 14 « (first quality) 301 A.D. 1 sectar. 40 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 3. 1 * (second qual- ity) u U l * 24 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 3. 2 " (coarse qual- ity) u u 1 * 12 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 3 3 Gre'nfell, Gk. N third century 1 chus 6 dr. Pap. II, 77 Wheat 69/79 a.d.» 1 artaba 20 dr. P.B.M. 896 u 78/79 a.d. i " 11 dr. P.B.M. 131 u U It l * 10 dr. P.B.M. 131 u 125 A.D. l * 7 dr., 1 ob. B.G.U. 834 It 149 A.D. l * 7 dr. Tebt. Pap. 394 u 183 A.D. l * 8 dr. B.G.U. 200 1 191/92 a.d. l * 18 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 13. 11 Goodspeed, Gk. M It It l * 20 dr. Pap. 30. 15. 24 M 255 a.d. l " 16 dr. B.G.U. 14 u 250-300 a.d. i * 19 dr. Grenfell, Gk. Pap. I, 51 M 301 A.D.« 1 cast, modlus 100 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 1. 1 « 314 A.D. 1 artaba 1 tal. 4,000 dr. Pap. Rainer E2000 H 350 a.d. l " 50 tal. P.B.M. 427 H fourth century l * 30 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 « « « i ■ 26 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 295 « a u. 13 " 1 aureus Palladius, Asceti- kum 11 " u u. 5i« " 1 aureus Palladius, Asceti- kum 11 O.P. 154 « seventh century 5 1 " 2 ceratia Barley 191/92 A.D.« 1 " 10 dr., 1 ob. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 33. 31 « 301 A.D.7 1 cast, modius 100 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 1. 2 1 The measure here is not expressed in the papyrus. 1 As it is doubtful whether this price refers to wheat or some other commodity, this item has been disregarded in all calculations. > This isequivalent to 74} cents per bushel. In 1912 the average price was $1 . 06 per bushel. 4 This is a famine price, the preceding price being the usual one. 'Joshua the Stylite (Chron. 26) gives the usual price of wheat in Mesopotamia as 30 modii for one aureus. During the Persian Wars at the end of the fifth century the price rose until it reached the rate of 13 choenices for one aureus. At Antioch in the middle of the fourth century the ordinary price was 10 modii for one aureus; see Julian, Opera, p. 369 B. •This price is only approximate. In the papyrus 3 artabae are sold for 30 dr., 2 ob., 1 chalcus. ' This price is equivalent to 74} cents per bushel. In 1912 the average price of barley was $1.01 per bushel. 308 Louis C. West TABLE II — Continued Article Date Measure Price Authority Barley 314 A.D. 1 artaba 1 tal., 4,000 dr. Pap. Rainer E 2000 « 346 a.d. 1 30 tal. P.B.M. 248 u third to fourth century 1 1 14 dr. Payum Towns 131 u third to fourth century* 1 20 dr. Grenfell, Gk. Pap. II, 77 " fourth century 1 25 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 Vitelli, Pap. d. it sixth «• 12J " 1 solidus Soc. Ital. 88 'Pure" bread 1 A.D.S each 4 ob. O.P. 736 Cake a u u i ob. O.P. 736 Aracus 360 A.D.4 1 artaba 1,800,000 denar. O.P. 1056 fifth century 1 1,700 tal. Giessen Pap. 105 a it tt 1 1,800 tal. Giessen Pap. 105 Cummin 18 B.C. 1 " 7 dr. Fayum Towns 101 " fourth or ftf t)h century 5 1 xestes 1 tal. 4,000 dr. Pap. Rainer NN74 Cnecus 18 B.C. 1 artaba 4 dr. Fayum Towns 101 Lotus 95/96 a.d. 1 18 dr. Fayum Towns 111 P.B.M. 248 Dates 346 a.d. 1 15 tal. Date palms 348 a.d. 2 trees 124 tal. B.G.U. 458 Vegetables 78/79 a.d. 1 artaba 20-21 dr. P.B.M. 131 " 191/92 a.d. 1 16 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 24. 17 Vetches u a 1 18 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 16. 21 Lentils 78/79 a.d. 1 " 2} dr. P.B.M. 131 " 301 A.D. 1 " 100 denar. Edict. Dioclet. 1. 11 Pap. Rainer E 206 a fourth century 1 " 800 dr. Onions u it 1 xestes 500 tal. Pap. Rainer E 1014 Cabbage 1 A.D. each iob. O.P. 736 Coriander a it 1 artaba 6 dr., 3 ob. O.P. 819 Pease 255 a.d. 1 16 dr. B.G.U. 14 Fruit of jujube second to third 1 * 20 dr., 2 ob. O.P. 920 tree century Meat 360 a.d.« lib. 145,000 denar. O.P. 1056 it fourth century 1 " 330,000 denar. P.B.M. 984 « " 1 " 1 tal., 2,000 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 295 a it u 1 " 4 tal., 2,000 dr. Pap. Rainer AN 289 a u u 1 " 3,200 dr. P.B.M. 1289 Liver u u 1 " 3,200 dr. P.B.M. 1259 Pigeons 1 A.D.' each 1 ob. O.P. 736 1 These prices are in close accord with those of the second century and make it possible that the documents belong to that period. * In Mesopotamia at the very beginning of this century the usual price of barley was 50 modii for one aureus; see Joshua the Stylite, Chron. 26. The 12 J artabae of the papyrus equal 432 modii, so the agreement between the two prices is fairly close. 3 In the English translation of Cassian (Instil., 4, 14) the price of bread is given as "three pence" for 2 loaves. The original has been inaccessible to me. In Oxyrhyn. Pap. 522 one loaf with relish is the amount given per day to a workman for his "keep." * In this instance 40 artabae of aracus valued at 72,000,000 denarii were given in exchange for 500 pounds of meat. This seems a case of barter. « In Diocletian's edict (i. 32) the price is given as 200 denarii for one castrensis modius. « In Diocletian's edict (iv. 2) beef is worth 8 denarii a pound; an enormous differ- ence from the prices given in our table. 7 In Diocletian's edict (iv. 29) pigeons are worth 24 denarii a pair. The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt 309 TABLE II — Continued Article Date Measure Price Authority Birds fourth century 1 each 5tal. Pap. Hainer AN 295 U u a « 1 tal., 2,000 dr. P.B.M. 1259 u fourth to fifth « 4 tal., 2,000 dr. Pap. Rainer NN 74 century Eggs fourth to fifth century 1 2,500 dr. Pap. Hainer NN74 Fish fourth to fifth century' It 60,000 dr. Pap. Rainer NN74 Garum 143 A.D.' double jar 2 dr. O.P. 520 u fourth to fifth jar 150,000 dr. Pap. Rainer NN 74 century 5 Breakfast 1 A.D. 1 ob. O.P. 736 Grinding wheat u u per artaba 3 to 4 ob. O.P. 736 O. Wearing Apparel Article Date Number Price Authority Linen cloths 21 A.D. each 3 dr. O.P. 1281 M « 266 a.d. a 8 dr. Tebt. Pap. 406 « U third to fourth century 20 dr. Grenfell, Gk. Pap. II, 77 Vitelli, Pap. d. Soc. Ital. 64 Chiton, linen first century' it 4,600 dr. « 50 A.D. u 8 dr. O.P. 285 u 183 A.D. a 16 dr. O.P. 725 u It 20 dr. O.P. 725 « u u « 24 dr. O.P. 725 K U It a 28 dr. O.P. 725 W « 32 dr. O.P. 725 second century 7 « 8 dr. O.P. 1269 " , white-tasseled 260 a.d. « 100 dr. O.P. 1273 and striped « third century 40 dr. Tebt. Pap. 423 Paenula 1 A.D. 10 dr. O.P. 736 Robe, milk white 36 A.D. 12 dr. O.P. 267 Chlamys and sticharium fourth century 17 tal. O.P. 1288 Sticharium 346 a.d. it 154 myriads of denar. P.B.M. 247 Delmatica, silvery- striped Delmatica, turquoise 260 a.d. it 260 dr. O.P. 1273 U M « 100 dr. O.P. 1273 color 1 In Diocletian's edict (iv. 23) fowls are worth 60 denarii a pair. 1 During the Persian invasion of Mesopotamia in the year 500/501 a.d., eggs were sold at 40 nummi apiece, a famine price ; see Joshua the Stylite, Chron. 43. * In Diocletian's edict (v. 3, 4) river fish are worth 12 and 8 denarii a pound. 4 Garum or fish pickle was made in the Fayum, and this is undoubtedly the native product. » In Diocletian's edict (iii. 6, 7) the price is given as 16 and 12 denarii per sextarius. • A comparison of this price with others from the first century makes it evident that there is a mistake here either in the date of the document or in the price. Two or three slaves at the contemporary prices could be bought for this amount. ' The price here given is that at which the garment was pawned and is, accordingly, something less than the real value. In another second-century papyrus (P.B.M. , 193) various garments are pawned at the following prices: white chiton, 11 dr.; green chiton, 16 dr. ; scarlet chiton, 20 dr. 310 Louis C. West TABLE II — Continued Article Date Number Price Authority Delmatica, white, pur- ple border Delmatica Vest, Dalmatian, onyx color Vest, Xolte Kerchief Towel and linen cloth Himatium Babylonian hide Shoes, women's " with hobnails Weaving loom, 3 cubits less 2 palms in width Needle and thread " , sewing, first quality Needle, sewing, second quality Weaving a paenula 260 a.d. fourth century fifth century first century' 301 A.D. 346 a.d. fourth century 301 A.D. fourth century 54 A.D. 1 A.D. 301 A.D. w 1 A.D. each 100 dr. 2 tal. plus 1 cnidium of wine 33,850,000 denar. 30,000,000 denar. 7.500.000 denar. 15,000,000 denar. 5 copper tal. 500 denar. 1,200,000 denar. 1,200 dr. 60 denar. 3 tal., 2,000 dr. 20 dr. 1 ob. 5 denar. 2j denar. 1 dr.. 2 ob. O.P. 1273 Pap. Rainer AN 299 O.P. 1026 O.P. 1026 O.P. 1026 O.P. 1026 Vitelli, Pap.d. Soc. Ital. 64 Edict. Dioclet. 8. 1 P.B.M. 247 O.P. 1288 Edict. Dioclet. 9. 10 Pap. Rainer AN 289 O.P. 264 O.P. 736 Edict. Dioclet. 16. 8a Edict. Dioclet. 16. 9 O.P. 736 D. Household Utensils Article Date Number Price Authority Tin lecythus Ladles Curved knives , large Scissors u Knife Cups " , large Triclinium with linen cover and four cushions, embroid- ered Basket " , for fish " , small " , large " , small second century 2 fifth century Wicks 255 a.d. 1 A.D. 143 A.D. 191/92 a.d. 314 A.D. 314 A.D. 143 A.D. each for 4 for 3 for 5 for 2 each for 24 for 13 each for 8 each for 50 4 470 of 120 of 250 of 150 of 30 of 1,200 of 1,054 of 500 dr. myriads denar. myriads denar. myriads denar. myriads denar. myriads denar. myriads denar. myriads denar. dr. 11 ob. 1 dr., 1 ob. 4 dr. 300 dr. 200 dr. 1 ob. O.P. 1269 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1289 O.P. 1277 O.P. 739 O.P. 520 Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 22. 13 Pap. Rainer E2000 Pap. Rainer E 2000 O.P. 520 1 One copper talent here is worth 36 silver drachmae. •The price here given is that at which the article was pawned; the real value would be somewhat higher. The Cost op Living in Roman Egypt 311 TABLE II— Continued E. Objects of Pebsonal Adornment Object Date Price Authority Pair of gold earrings Pair of unstamped silver bracelets 36 A.D. 114 A.D.» 20 dr. 40 dr. O.P. 267 B.G.U. 22 F. Animals Animal Date Price Authority Cow, with calf 124 A.D. 62 dr. P.B.M. 839 « 134 A.D. 44 dr. Fayum Towns 62 " 337-350 a.d. 600 tal. P.B.M. II, 304 Donkey 8 101 A.D. 306 dr. Vitelli, Pap. d. Soc. Ital. 38 M Ill A.D. 208 dr. Tebt. Pap. 474 " , young female 126 A.D. 56 dr. Fayum Towns 93 * 142 A.D. 148 dr. P.B.M. 303 « 143 A.D. 160 dr. P.B.M. 466 " 148 A.D. 64 dr. P.B.M. 313 * , female with foal 179 A.D. 160 dr. P.B.M. 339 m 197 A.D. 300 dr. B.G.U. 527 « second to third cen- tury 216/17 a.d. 260 dr. B.G.U. 228 u 1,500 dr. Vitelli, Pap. d. Soc. Ital. 79 " 219 A.D. 500 dr. B.G.U. 413 « fourth century 20 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 289 M sixth to seventh century' 2i solidl O.P. 922 Camel 144 A.D. 500 dr. B.G.U. 87 * 147 A.D. 800 dr. B.G.U. 88 " 150 A.D. 670 dr. B.G.U. 416 * 152 A.D. 800 dr. B.G.U. 153 * 154 A.D. 580 dr. B.G.U. 453 u 157/8 a.d. 800 dr. P.B.M. 320 * 159 A.D. 780 dr. B.G.U. 100 * 159/60 A.D. 680 dr. B.G.U. 469 u 160 A.D. 600 dr. P.B.M. 323 " and 2 foals 177-79 a.d. 900 +dr. P.B.M. 1100 * , male Arabian 289 a.d. 16 tal., 3,000 dr. B.G.U. 13 " ■ female 302 a.d. 9 tal. Grenfell, Gr. Pap. 11,74 M , " 302 a.d. 9 tal. P.B.M. 714 " , male 9 tal. Grenfell, Gr. Pap. II, 74 Pig, young 191/2 A.D. 20 dr. Goodspeed, Gk. Pap. 30. 23. 8 u second century 1 40 dr. O.P. 1269 " , young u u 2 dr. 3 ob. P.B.M. 928 fourth century 50 denar. Wessely, Ein Alter- sindiz., p. 8 1 The bracelets were valued, as in modern Egyptian usage, according to the weight of the coin silver they contained. 1 At Pompeii the price of a mule is given at 520 sesterces; see C.I.L., 4, 3340, 1. Apuleius records the sale of a donkey at three different prices: 17 denarii, 50 sesterces, 11 denarii; see Metam. 8. 25; 9. 31; 10. 13. • The price here mentioned is the average at which ten animals in the papyrus were sold. * In the Dacian wax tablets (C.I.L.. young pig is given as 5 denarii. 3, p. 953, of the year 166 a.d.) the price of a 312 Louis C. West TABLE II — Continued Animal Date Price Authority Pig * , young Horse « " , from* Constanti- nople Horse Sheep fourth century 1 fifth century seventh century 148 A.D.* sixth to seventh century sixth to seventh century 618 A.D. second to third century 8 tal. 3 ceratia 3 ceratia less 36 folles 188 dr. 2 solid! 3 solidi 3 solidi 18 dr., 2 ob. P.B.M. 1259 Pap. Eainer E 420 Pap. Ralner AN 432 Vitelli, Pap. d. Soc. Ital. 39 O.P. 922 O.P. 922 O.P. 153 O.P. 184 G. Slaves Kind of Slave Date Price Authority Girl, 8 years old 77 A.D. 640 dr. O.P. 263 Woman, with two('l) children Slave child 79 A.D. 1,800 dr. (?) O.P. 375 85/86 a.d. 140 dr. O.P. 336 Woman, 35 years old 86 A.D. 10 dr. of silver plus 10 tal., 3,000 dr. of copper O.P. 48 Man 100 A.D. 10 dr. of silver plus 2 tal., 600 dr. of O.P. 49 Woman, 25 years old 129 A.D.» 1,200 dr. O.P. 95 Boy 166 A.D.« 200 denar. P.B.M. 229 Woman, 25 years old 178 A.D. 900 dr.. O.P. 485 Man 180 A.D.* 520 dr. O.P. 96 Girl, with infant boy 251-53 a.d. 2,000 dr. O.P. 1209 Woman, with 2 children 291 A.D. 14 tal. O.P. 1205 Slaves, two 337-350 a.d. 2,400 tal. for two P.B.M. 251 Gallic boy 359 a.d.« 18 solidi B.G.U. 316 H. Building Material Article Date Price Authority Outer squared stones Inner " " Antlblemata " second century « « tt u 16 for 4 dr. 30 for 4 dr. 100 for 3 dr. O.P. 498 O.P. 498 O.P. 498 1 The prices given in this papyrus are confusing; i.e., pig or pork, 2,400 drachmae; pig, 8 talents; young pig, 10 talents. * The price of this horse is so low when compared with the prices of contemporary donkeys and camels that we must infer it was a very poor specimen. » In the Dacian wax tablets the sales of three slaves are recorded : 139 a.d. six-year old girl 205 denar. C.I.L., 3, p. 937 142 a.d. boy 600 denar. C.I.L., 3, p. 941 160 a.d. girl 420 denar. C.I.L., 3, p. 959 ' This sale took place in Italy, the purchaser being an Egyptian attached to the fleet at Misenum. ' This price is obtained by considering the tax of 52 drachmae paid on the sale as equal to 10 per cent of the value of the slave. • This sale was made in Ascalon to a soldier from Arsinoe who was temporarily in Syria. The Cost of Living in Roman Egypt TABLE II — Continued 313 Article Date Price Authority Outer oblong corner stone Inner oblong corner stone Chipped, squared stone Chipped, oblong corner stone Brick, laying 10,000 second century « « « a u u 172 A.D. 16 for 8 dr. 30 for 8 dr. 50 for 4 dr. 50 for 8 dr. 40 dr. O.P. 498 O.P. 498 O.P. 498 O.P. 498 Tebt. Pap. 402 I. Transpobtation Date Nature of Transportation Price Authority Second century Donkey hire per day* 2 dr. O.P. 1049 215 A.D. « u u u 4 dr. B.G.U. 362 191/2 A.D. Five donkeys going from 10 dr., 2 ob. Goodspeed, Gk. Karanis to Memphis Pap. 30. 36. 10 Baggage wagon per day H dr. Wilcken, G.O. 1180 Second century Boatload of wheat from Oxyrhyn. to Alexan- dria 21 dr. per 100 art. O.P. 522 236 a.d. Freight on 250 artabae of 100 dr. plus 1 Jar P.B.M. 948 vegetable seed carried of wine plus 16 from Arsinoe to Oxy- dr., if boat held rhynchus over 4 days at Oxyrhyn. Fourth century Boatload of grain from 9 tal. Mitteis, Pap. Leip- Fayum to Alexandria zig 5 534 a.d. Freight on 1485 J artabae of wheat from Oxy- rhyn. to Alexandria 11 solidi, 3J ceratia O.P. 142 Third to fourth Carrying corpse from 340 dr. Grenfell, Gk. Pap. century Great Oasis to Mle( ?) II, 77 Second century Traveling allowance to soldier for trip from Egypt to Misenum To boatmen for going 3 aurei B.G.U. 423 612 A.D. 3 solidi less 12 O.P. 151 from Oxyrhyn. to ceratia Alexandria to bring back an advocate J. Miscellaneous Items Items Date Price Authority Hide, cowhide, unworked Hay, per donkey load " , crop on 3 arurae of land 301 A.D.* 362 a.d. 100 A.D.» 142 A.D. 500 denar. 75,000,000 denar. 12 dr. 276 dr. Edict. Dioclet. 8. 6o O.P. 1057 Fayum Towns 119 O.P. 728 1 Today a donkey may be hired for 30 to 50 cents a day, the owner paying for the feed. For a donkey worth $40.00, this is at the rate of about 1 per cent of its value per day. If we average all the second-century prices of donkeys, this rent is at a rate of a trifle over 1 per cent per day. In Diocletian's edict the rent of a laden donkey is 4 denarii per mile and of a baggage wagon 12 denarii per mile. 2 In B.G. U. 655 of 215 a.d. we find a taxpayer giving 8 drachmae in money instead of furnishing one or more hides to the army. • In Diocletian's edict (xvii. 7) the price of hay and straw is fixed at 2 denarii for 3 pounds. In ibid., xvii. 8 the price of pabulum is fixed at 1 denarius for 6 pounds. 314 Louis C. West TABLE II— Continued Items Date Price Authority Straw, lor 1,800 pounds Manure, per artaba 340 a.d.i 144 tal. B.G.U. 21 third century" 4 dr. O.P. 934 Tow, per pound lourth century 4 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 310 mm « « u 1 tal., 2,000 dr. O.P. 1288 Bed pigment (sandyx) ' "I 160 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 310 P.B.M. 928 Colors lor painting, per second century 7 dr. to 9 dr., 1 ob. xestes Aromatic oil fourth century 4 tal. Pap. Rainer AN 310 O.P. 1188 Acacia trees, 2 fallen 13 A.D. 8 dr. " , each 188 A.D. 13 dr. O.P. 1112 " , lor 14 225 a.d. 1,200 dr. O.P. 909 Persea tree, 1 small dried 13 A.D. 6 dr. O.P. 1188 branch Persea tree, branch ol K u 1 dr. O.P. 1188 living tree Persea tree, 1 branch ol u u 1 dr. O.P. 1188 dried tree Eeeds, lor 1,000 bundles 2 B.C. 15 dr. O.P. 742 Wax tablet and stylus 1 A.D. 1 ob. O.P. 736 Water jars, per 100 113 A.D. 6 dr. P.B.M. 1177 Purse second to third century 1 dr. Tebt. Pap. 337 Nails, per mina 255 a.d. 12 dr. B.G.U. 14 Malleable bronze, lor 6 lbs. Wrought iron, lor 100 lbs. 338 a.d. 1,000 denar. O.P. 85 316 A.D. 6 tal. O.P. 84 Perfume, dry precipitate, third century 32 dr. O.P. 1142 1 cotyla 1 In Pompeii the price of straw was 5 asses per pound; see C.I.L., 4, 4000. * Pliny H.N., xviii. 53 gives the price of manure as 1 denarius per cartload. • Pliny H.N., xxxv. 23 gives the price of sandyx as 2\ asses per pound.