STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE LOT ORACLE AT DELPHI By Frank Egleston Robbins The inquiry 1 begins with a graceful painting on the inside surface of a fifth-century Attic cylix now in the museum at Berlin (Fig. I). 2 Aegeus is seen in the very act of consulting the oracle about his child- lessness, and is about to receive the obscure answer which, according to the story preserved by the Greek authors, puzzled him so much.* The column which divides the scene shows that the consultation takes place within the sanctuary; Aegeus, at the right, awaits the answer of the prophetess seated to the left on a tripod, and the names of the two, Aegeus and Themis, are given above them. For the rest, Furtwangler's comment may be quoted: "Die Priesterin, durch deren Mund Apollon spricht, sitzt, genau so wie es die Pythia zur Zeit des Malers auch tat, auf dem Dreifuss, um gottliche Eingebung zu erhalten. Sie wird hier Themis (Qifus) genannt, mit einem mytho- logisch nicht gerechtfertigten Namen. Denn unter Themis ver- standen die Griechen eine Doppelgangerin der Erdgottin, die ihrerseits einst allerdings auch in Delphi Spriiche erteilte, aber schon vor Apollon, sogar vor Phoebe, welche dieser abloste. Dem schlan- ken, zvichtigen Madchen, das wir hier sehen, fehlt ja auch vollig die matronale Erscheinung welche sich vom Bild der Erdgottin nicht trennen lasst. Aigeus konnte nur eine Pythia befragen. Dichterischer Sprachgebrauch, welcher Orakelspriiche mit Oiniarts bezeichnet, verfiihrte wohl dazu, der Sprecherin Apollons den Namen Themis zu verleihen. Das Madchen auf dem Prophetenstuhl sinnt in sich gekehrt, in der Rechten Apollons heiligen Lorbeer, in der 1 The author wishes hereby to acknowledge the great help he has derived from his colleague, Professor Campbell Bonner of the University of Michigan. Many of the essential arguments of this paper are due to Professor Bonner's suggestion. 2 Furtwangler-Reichhold, Griechische Vasenmalerei, Taf. 140; Arch. Anzeiger (1854), p. 427; Winter, Jiingere altische Vasen, p. 52; Gerhard, Auserlesene Vasen- bilder, 4, pp. 103-4, Taf. 327-28; Muller-Wieseler, Denkmaler der alien Kunst, II, 947; Welcker, AUe Denkmaler, II, 237; Decharme, Mythologie, p. 107, Fig. 65; J. E. Harri- son, Themis, p. 481. 3 Euripides Medea 678 ff.; Plutarch Vit. Thes. 3 ff. [Classical Philology XI, July, 1916] 278 The Lot Oracle at Delphi 279 Linken eine Schale, wie wir annehmen miissen, angefiillt mit dem Wasser der kastalischen Quelle, welches sie zum Weissagen begeis- tert " Fig. 1 Furtwangler devotes most of his attention to the name given to the prophetess: does the painter intend her really to be the Themis, who, according to one account, took over the ancient oracle at Delphi from the earth-goddess Gaia, her mother, and in turn was succeeded by Apollo, or, according to another, receiving the oracle from Gaia turned it over to Phoebe, who in her turn gave it to Apollo; 1 or is she simply a priestess of Apollo, a Pythia, named Themis perhaps because the responses of the god were sometimes called Oifiurres? Fortu- nately the present investigation does not require a definite solution 1 Paus. x. 5. 6; Aesch. Eum. 1 ff. 280 Frank Egleston Robbins of this difficulty; but at the same time Furtwangler's conclusions are not, to me at least, entirely satisfactory. It is, in the first place, a very striking coincidence that the painter should have chosen to assign to a mortal prophetess the name Themis, when the tradition that the goddess Themis once ruled the Delphic shrine was so well known; this is a prima facie improbability; and it may be doubted, furthermore, whether the purchaser of this vase would appreciate such a reason as Furtwangler gives for the assignment of the name. Nor is it agreed among archaeologists that Themis should be repre- sented, as he says, by a matronly type; 1 and, with regard to the vase under discussion, other critics are content to believe that our Themis is really the goddess. 2 As for the undoubted fact that all the accessories of the scene are Delphic — the laurel, 8 the tripod, and, we may add, the phials — this need cause no great concern. The vase-painter has taken them from the Delphi he knew; if he tried to represent some more obscure form of consultation, his public would probably fail to understand the narrative he is trying to tell, and would certainly fail to locate the scene at Delphi; and, in fine, he is no archaeologist, but only an artisan of moderate education and attainments, and we may expect of him inconsistency and even inaccuracy. Surely to such a man it would be natural enough to show Themis, the predecessor of Apollo, in the surroundings of Apollo's priestess, and giving oracles in the already time-honored manner. 4 'Welcker, Alte Denkm., II, 32S (and Taf. XVI, 31), in his essay "Themis als Schlafprophetin," endeavors to show that the figure of a maiden sleeping in front of the Delphic tripod is Themis; the sleeping figure by no means agrees with Furt- wangler's notion of the type. Themis as Justitia (see «.»., ap. Daremberg-Saglio, Diet., Ill, 1, p.777,with the citation of Aulus Gellius xiv. 4) was represented as a maiden, the Astraea virgo. 'Welcker, op. cit., 237: "Dass anachronistisch Themis anstatt des Apollons ihm wahrsagt schmeichelt in lockrer Weise der attischen Stammeseitelkeit" ; also Decharme, loc. cit.; Miss Harrison, op. cit., p. 480: "seated on it is not any one par- ticular Pythia but Themis herself." 5 Of the laurel Miss Harrison, loc. cit., remarks, "she is thallophoros." But the laurel must be indicative of Delphi as well as the other attributes. 4 It is to be noted that Euripides speaks of a tripod of Themis, to which Apollo has succeeded: ASiKot ASiKa rbr' &p\ $\aicev KNoxex 0{. or Opiaif the latter word is not well understood, but may perhaps originally have meant "fig leaves," and may give a clue as to the earliest form of the oracle. 7 1 On kleromancy in general Halliday, op. tit., chap, x, may be consulted. The author has collected most of the pertinent passages from the literature. J. G. Frazer's annotations to Paus. vii. 25. 10 set forth an important variety of kleromancy practiced in Greek temples in later times. * Halliday, p. 211, with citations in n. 1; Farnell, IV, 191. Cf. too the use of ttbtcTv with xpic>ta » Op. tit., p. 247, n. 15. * Iambi. De myst. iii. 11 (Parthey). 5 Cf. Bouche-Leclerq, I, 194. "Suidas, s.iw. Bpial, 8p?a; Hesychius, s.vv. dpiai, Spuifciv; Etym. Moon. a.m. 0plcu, 6pla; Bekker, Anecd., I, 265, s.v. 0piii\\a- koX Spii^eiv rb (pvWoSoyttv. Suidas s.v. 8pta has a similar statement; and cf. Hesychius s.v. tfptifetc. For another mean- ing (probably not original) see Lobeck, Aglaophamus 1345. The Lot Oracle at Delphi 287 According to the legends these mantic lots derived their name from the Thriae, three nymphs, and popular etymology connected their name in turn with the numerals rpeis or rpuraai. The lexi- cographers and mythologists, together with the Homeric hymn to Hermes, 1 afford considerable information about them and Apollo's use of them. According to the lexicographers the three nymphs, daughters of Zeus, were the nurses of Apollo and dwelt on Parnassus; they discovered the three mantic counters and offered them to Athena; she, however, disclaimed them as a thing that did not belong to her (for this was in the province of Apollo) and threw them into the Thriasian Plain, which thus received its name. According to this form of the legend the Thriae were the originators of klero- mancy, and they may be supposed to have taught it to their ward. Since Apollodorus, in relating the story of Apollo's cattle, represents Apollo as practicing kleromancy, we may infer that this was actually the case. Here Apollo is said to have learned "from his divining art" who stole the cattle; he exchanged the herd for the lyre of Hermes, and later, when Hermes made his flute, he bought this for the staff he had formerly used in tending his cattle, together with a lesson in divination by lot (5iA twv if/ri, pMVTeirjs awdvtvOe SiSaavraAoi, rpr hri fiovoi nous ct' e Srj eiraTa jroTW/uevai oWore cLXkr/ Krjpla fioaKovrai koJl t£ Kpaivovai acaora. al 8' ore p.ev Ovintaw iSrjSvicu p.(\i ^Apoves lOiXowriv aAjj&ijjv ayopevuv •qv 8' airovoo-i dcmv fjSclav eSwSrjv, ij/tvSovTai. Si) hra.ro. 8V aXXrjXmv Soveovaai. Tas tch. tireiTa 8t8a)/u, piva rtpirt, koI et /Sporov avSpa Satir/s woWaKi crf/s 6p,ri<; iwaKovcrcTai, at kc TV)Q)i&\r) ^ raj fiavTUcas elx« if/ii4>ovs, airives lpop,ivoiv p,kv t&v fxavrevonivav tfXSovro Koi i) Hvdia lp4>opovp.ivr} $\eyev a 0-eepei> 6 'AiroKkuv. So it seems certain that the counters were in existence in historic times and were kept in a phiale\ Suidas' passage, however, gives rise to some further questions; for example, just what was the significance of the "jumping" of the counters ? Farnell 1 speaks of this as being "in response to the questions of the consultants; and the functions of the Pythoness would seem to be entirely dispensed with in this process"; and in a note he says that Suidas seems to contaminate two distinct methods. He apparently understands that the two methods existed together, which may well have been the case. BoucheVLeclerq 2 too admits that Apollo's arrival at Delphi did not wholly exile kleromancy, which was certainly there in earliest times, but that it was used in conjunction with other methods, for example, to determine the order of consultation (a fact generally admitted) or to decide which of two meanings was to be adopted, in the case of an ambiguous oracle; perhaps, too, in cases resembling that of the Thessalians already mentioned. Undoubtedly, it is due to the con- servatism of religion that this earlier and half-superseded form of divination retained through the centuries a place in the ritual, and that the mantic counters kept in the sacred place still showed by their "jumping" — managed we know not how — that the memory of their former importance must not fade out of the traditions of the shrine. The painted and engraved scenes which have already been adduced show, I think, that the Greeks did in fact preserve the memory of the old lot oracle at Delphi, perhaps even that it did not lose its importance until a time much later than usually imagined, for artists seldom archaeologize. 3 I suggest, therefore, that the 1 Op. tit., IV, 191. 2 Op. dt., I, 194. Halliday, pp. 211-12, suggests that "the consultation of the pebbles was a preliminary rite to discover whether Apollo would vouchsafe an answer." 3 There is evidence in Euripides, of uncertain value to be sure, that the Athenian of the fifth century turned as naturally to a kleromantic oracle as to any other, when necessity arose. I refer especially to Hipp. 1057 f.; ii SAtos ijSe, xhijpov o<5 8e8eyn4rr), KarriyopeT aov rrtard, kt\. k\t)pos here is usually interpreted (e.g., by Wecklein, Paley, Mahaffy and Bury, and Murray in his translation) on the basis of 290 Frank Egleston Robbins Themis vase, the Praenestine cista, and perhaps the other vase whereon Apollo appears are satisfactorily explained by the assump- tion, in each case, that the phiale" is that mentioned by Suidas, the receptacle for the sacred divining counters. In the absence of information about the kind of lots used, and about the method of interpretation, it would be better perhaps to refrain from a fuller explanation of these scenes, and especially of the last-mentioned, the subject of which is so doubtful. But the Praenestine cista seems to show Apollo and Oedipus after the drawing has been made, and it is the result of the drawing which causes Oedipus so much surprise, while Themis is shown in a moment of deliberation just before "taking up" the lot. It may be well at this point to consider an obvious objection to the explanation proposed for the Themis vase. Will this form of divination fit the story of Aegeus handed down in literature ? The Euripidean version — which is substantially that of Plutarch — is found in the Medea, 11. 678-81. Aegeus has told Medea that he has returned from the ancient oracle of Phoebus — observe that in the literary form of the legend it is not Themis — and Medea has been informed that she may ask of him what the god said. Then follows (11. 678 ff.): MH. tl Siyr' ?xpi7