STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE CHRONOLOGY OF EARLY ROME By Henry A. Sanders It has come to be second nature with most of us to date the founding of Rome in 753 B. c, and the first year of the Republic in 509 B. o. We recognize, to be sure, that much of the early history is mythical, but to what extent and in what manner that may affect the dates is seldom considered. How erroneous it is blindly to fasten these dates upon all Roman writers and to interpret their years ah urbe condita after this generally accepted era, I have shown, taking Livy as an example, in a couple of notes in the Classical Journal I, p. 156; II, p. 82. But to discuss the whole subject and even to attempt to distinguish between the historical and the mythical in the chronology of early Rome is to venture on much more dangerous ground. Already in 1855 Sir George Oornewall Lewis in his Inquiry into the Credibility of Early Roman History, II, p. 556, came to the conclusion that, "All historical labor bestowed on the early centuries of Rome will, in general, be wasted." Succeeding historians have reaffirmed or even strengthened this assertion, and the failure of many attempted chronologies of Rome illustrate it. Most radical of all is doubtless Pais Storia di Roma and Ancient Legends of Roman History, who absolutely rejects all the legends as well as the chronology. The time of the founding of Rome was, both to Greeks and Romans, a matter of pure guesswork. Its date according to the Varronian Era, now interpreted as 753 b. c, was merely one of many guesses, and was not universally adopted till much later. Under these circumstances it is apparent that the determination of this mythical date is as impossible for us as it was for the ancients. But the Romans made use of later dates in trying to approximate to the time of the founding, and this date, when once established by any author, had, in turn, a paramount influence on his manner of stating later dates. It is for the light that may [Classical Philoloqy III, July, 1908] 316 The Chbonology of Eably Rome 317 be thrown on these later dates and their historical basis, that I have attempted this investigation. I. In the first class I place those myths which refer to a time before the destruction of Troy or which, though timeless, mani- festly imply a very ancient origin: 1) Antiochusof Syracuse (424 b. c.) 1 wrote that "Sicelus, an exile from Rome, came to the Oenotrians before the emigration of a portion of them to Sicily" (Dion. Hal. i. 73. 4). 2) Antigonus, in the Historia Italica (200 b. a), said that "Rhomus, sprung from Jupiter, founded a city on the Palatine, and gave his name to it" (Festus, p. 266 M). 3) Festus, p. 266 M, cites from a Historia Cumana that "colo- nists from Athens, Sicyon, and Thespiae, called Aborigines from their wanderings, first settled on the Palatine and called their city Valentia, a name which was changed to Rhome on the arrival of Evander, Aeneas, and many Greek-speaking followers" (Servius ad Aen. i. 273 refers this to [£.] Ateius [Praetextatus]) . 4) Plutarch Bom. 1 states on unknown authority that "the Pelasgians founded the city and called it Rhome from their strength." 5) Plutarch Bom. 2 names Rome, daughter of Italus and Lucaria, the founder (cf. Syncellus I, p. 363 in Corp. Scrip. Hist. Byz.). 6) Dionysius of Halicarnassus i. 72. 6 and Plutarch Bom. 2 had found the statement that Rome was founded and named by an ancient Latin hero, Romis or Romus, son of Italus. II. In the second class I place those myths, which make the founding of Rome the direct result of the capture of Troy: 1) Heraclides Lembus (150 b. o.) wrote that "Greeks, return- ing from Troy, were driven to the Tiber by a storm and settled there, when a captive girl named Rhome set fire to their ships. The city prospered and was named Rome in honor of the girl" (Festus, p. 269 M, Solinus i. 2, Servius ad Aen. i. 273). 2) Aristotle (f 322 B. o.) gives the same without naming Rome (Dion. Hal. i. 72. 3). 3) Plutarch Bom. 1 applies this story to wandering Trojans. 1 Only those authors are dated whose time seems reasonably certain. 318 Henby A. Sandebs 4) The writer, probably Hellanicus, of the History of the Priestesses of Argos (400 b. o.) combined the two versions, mak- ing Ulysses and Aeneas the leaders of the expedition. Cf. also Damastes of Sigeum (400 b. c.) for the same (Dion. Hal. i. 72. 2). 5) Clinias related that "Home, daughter of Telemachus, mar- ried Aeneas and gave her name to the city" (Servius ad Aen. i. 273, cf. Plutarch Bom. 2). 6) Oephalon of Gergithes (200 b. o.) wrote that "Aeneas founded Rome and named it from a companion" (Festus, p. 266). 7) Sallust Cat. 6 claimed to have heard an old story that "Aeneas with Trojans and Aborigines founded Rome" (cf. Dion. Hal. i. 72. 1). III. In the third class I place those writers who had Rome founded by a descendant of Aeneas or other Trojan in the second or third generation after Troy. The variations are so slight, I merely enumerate authorities: 1) Dionysius of Chalcis (250 B. o.) ; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 72. 6. 2) Demagoras, Agathyllus, and Cephalon of Gergithes (200 B. a); cf. Dion. Hal. i. 72. 1; Syncellus i. 363. 3) Eratosthenes (195 b. o.) ; cf. Servius ad Aen. i. 273. 4) Alcimus in the Italica; cf. Festus, p. 266. 5) Agathocles of Cyzicus (250 b. c), two versions; cf. Festus, p. 269; Solinusi. 3. 6) Apollodorus in Euxenide (250 b. o. ) ; cf. Festus, p. 266. 7) Naevius, Ennius, and other Romans; cf. Servius ad Aen. i. 273; vi. 777; Dion. Hal. i. 73. 2. 8) Callias (300 B. 0.) made Romulus the son of Rome, a Trojan woman, and of Latinus; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 72. 5; Festus, p. 269; Syncellus i. 363. 9) Plutarch Rom. 2 and Dionysius of Halicarnassus i. 73 have several other versions making a son of Aeneas the founder; cf. also Etymologicon Magnum s. v. 'Pw/jltj. IV. In the fourth class I place the myths, which represent Rome as founded by a descendant of Ulysses or some other Greek, and in the second or third generation after Troy. The forms vary little. The authorities are as follows: The Chronology of Eably Rome 319 1) Xenagoras; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 72. 5; Stephanus Byz. s. v. "Avreia and 'ApSea. 2) Clinias; cf. Pestus, p. 269; Servius ad Aen. i. 273; Plu- tarch Bom. 2. 3) An unknown author in Plutarch Bom. i. 4) An unknown author in Servius ad Aen. i. 273. V. In the fifth class belong the myths, which make Rome a colony of Alba Longa. The only important variations are as to dates, which I will give with authorities: 1) Timaeus (300 B. o.) dates Rome in the thirty-eighth year before the first Olympiad = 814 b. c., 1 contemporaneous with Carthage; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 1. 2) The date Olympiad 1, 1,= 776 B. c. is also found; cf. Syn- cellus 1. 365, who cites Laas (=Kallias?) and also wrongly Timaeus for this date. 3) Q. Fabius Pictor (190 b. c), in Olympiad 8, 1 = 748 b. c. ; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 1; Solinus i. 27. 4) L. Cincius Alimentus (190 b. c), in Olympiad 12, 4 = 729 B. o. ; cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 1 ; Solinus i. 27. 5) Eratosthenes (195 b. a), Apollodorus (143 B. a), Lutatius (100 b. c), Nepos (cf. Solinus i. 27), Polybius (cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 3), Cicero De re pub. ii. 10, in Olympiad 7, 2 = 751 or 750 b. c. 6) Cato (170 b. c.) places date 432 years after Troy = 752 (751) b. o. ; 2 cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 2; also Eusebius, a. Abr. 1264 = Olym. 7, 1. 7) Eusebius a. Abr. 1263 gives Olympiad 6, 4 = 753 or 752 b. o. 8) Syncellus i. 361 gives Olympiad 7, 4 = 749 b. o. 9) Tarutius, Atticus, Varro give Olympiad 6, 3 = 753 B. o. ;* cf. Censorinus De die natali 21. 5 ; Solinus i. 27. 1 Trieber Hermes XXVII, p. 334, shows that 814 not 813 b. c. is the right inter- pretation. 2 Cf . ibid. ; the discussion in Dionysius shows that 752 not 751 b. c. is meant. 8 The question whether the comparative or actual Olympiad year was given in the various historians is a perplexing one. The Olympiad year was from July to July. The founding of Borne occurred traditionally on April 21, Thus the Olympiad years and the years a. u. c. coincided during ten months, and it was natural in dating Roman events to give the comparative Olympiad year. Therefore, if such Olympiad dates be 320 Heney A. Sanders We may now sum up the results of our classification and so eliminate worthless material. Of the five classes of foundation myths, the second, third, and fourth are plainly under the influence of the Homeric tradition, and so can teach us only that, when the western Greeks became curious about the origin of Rome, the in- fluence of the Homeric poems was the chief literary one among them. The origin through Greek heroes seems to have been at least as early as the story of the Trojan origin, and the two myths were very early combined. Furthermore there was during that period no widely known native myth concerning Rome's founda- tion, though its origin confessedly antedated tradition. The myths of the first class indicate the same condition in even stronger terms. To be exact, from the fifth century B. o. on, the western Greeks had no definite knowledge regarding the date of Rome, though they thought of it as antedating the earliest of their own colonies, some of which belonged to the eighth century. It is a fair assumption, therefore, that Rome was older than the tradi- tional date (753 b. c.) rather than younger, a conclusion confirmed by prehistoric graves found within the limits of the city. It remains for us to consider the myth which interposed the Alban kings between Troy and Rome. This was generally combined with dates ranging from 814 to 729 b. c. Not only is it younger than the other classes of myths, but it appears regularly as a com- bined Trojan-Alban myth. It is possible, though not probable, that a popular myth once existed at Rome, independent of the Trojan myth and stating merely that Rome was a colony of Alba; but it seems more likely that the growth of the Trojan myth, when its chronological discrepancies had been noted, was guided or influenced by the few public rites and customs, pointing to a former religious or political supremacy of Alba and Lavinium. Such being the case it is evident, as Mommsen ROm. Chron., pp. 152-54, has pointed out, that these dates are pure combina- interpreted exactly, they would be one year late for events between April 21 and July 1 ; ef. Mommsen Rom. Chron., p. 135, n. Yet when we come to the later and more exact writers, there were doubtless many cases of correct dating. The earlier historians and the Greeks regularly used the comparative date ; thus in Pabius Pictor Olym. 8, 1 = 748 not 747 b. c. On the other hand there can be no doubt that in the exact reckonings of the astrologer Tarutius and of Varro Olym. 6, 3 = 753 not 754 B. c. The Chronology of Eably Rome 321 tions, either being reckoned after the fall of Troy or back from the establishment of the republic. As regards fixing even an approximate date for the founding these dates are absolutely worth- less, but they do prove the presence of the line of Alban kings in the traditional history of Rome long before the time of Sulla, when Mommsen Rdm. Chron., p. 156, claimed that they first appeared. 1 It is certain that the earliest lists of Alban kings did not give the number of years of each reign, but the length of the whole period could, nevertheless, be determined by the regular method of the early chronologists of reckoning three generations to the century. Yet Livy i. 3, gives 15 Alban kings ( = 14 generations) besides Aeneas, a period far too long to agree with the accepted eras of Troy and Rome, though it agrees fairly well with the date of Troy's fall according to Timaeus and Clitarchus, viz., 1234 b. c. ; cf. Clemens Alex. Strom, i. 21. 139. The 484 intervening years allow for 14 generations with an ample balance for Aeneas and Numitor. Diodorus vii. 3 a, and Dionysius of Halicarnassus i. 70 ff . also give 15 kings besides Aeneas, though only 13 generations. The lengths of the individual reigns are given shortened to agree with the accepted eras. It is manifest that these lists do not represent the original form ; an older one must have given just 13 generations from Troy to Rome: 1183— 750 = 433 = 13 X33|. It is true that we can reduce the 16 names of Diodorus and Dionysius to 13 generations by omitting Aeneas, since Ascanius was born at Troy, and also omitting one each from the pairs of brothers Remulus and Agrippa, 2 Amulius and Numitor. Such additions and interpre- tations can hardly have appeared in the original list, in which the number of kings and generations doubtless agreed. Thus in Ovid Fasti iv. 41 ff. there are but 13 kings besides Aeneas 3 and in the Metamorphoses xiv. 609 ff .* only 13 including Aeneas. The same lr rrieber Hermes XXIX, p. 124 agrees that their names were not older than Alexander Polyhistor (80 b. a). 2 Or Ascanius and SiMus. 3 Cf. also Servius adAen. vi. 767, that Numitor was the thirteenth Alban king. < The name Alba is commonly corrected into the text, making 14. 322 Henry A. Sanders number appears also in Appian Bas. i. 1. Both the interval of 433 years and the 13 kings between Troy and Rome must have been quite commonly accepted. In Timaeus the period was 420 years, for he placed the found- ing of Rome in 814 B. c, while the correct interpretation of Clemens Alex. Strom, i. 21. 139, refers the date 1234 b. o. 1 for Troy's fall to Timaeus. But 420 years allows for 12 generations and 20 years to spare, a period that can be covered by giving 10 years to the wanderings (cf. Ulysses) and 8 to the rule of Aeneas, as in the late writer Thrasyllus, and placing the founding of Rome in the second year of Numitor. The period of 420 years between Troy and Rome according to Timaeus makes it certain that he admitted the rule of Alban kings, probably 12 in number. There must also have been a shorter list of Alban kings to agree with the 300 years' rule according to Virgil Aen. i. 272 fp. and Justinus xliii. 1. 13. This presupposes a list of 9 Alban kings, which can be obtained from Cassius Dio, frg. 4 (Zonaras 7. 1) by excluding both Aeneas and Numitor. It is possible that this represents an ancient form of the myth, as Trieber Hermes XXIX, p. 125, and Pais Storia di Roma II. i, p. 187, suppose, but it is quite as likely that both the 9 kings and the 300 years represent a late adaptation to the magic number three. It is hardly necessary to discuss the relation of the other dates of Troy and Rome. As Timaeus, who dated Rome the earliest of those giving definite dates, plainly allows for the period of Alban kings, the other early historians, both Greek and Roman, must have done the same, as soon as they attempted to give dates to the ^nger Hermes XXXV, p. 24, and Trieber H ermes XXVII, p. 332, make the date of Troy 1334 b. c, according to Timaeus. They seem to have been led astray by the incomplete citation of the passage in Mflller F. H. G. The absurdity of this reckon- ing is evident from the fact, that, if they interpreted the whole sentence of Clemens in the same fashion, they would find that Troy fell in 1287 b. c, according to Eratosthenes instead of 1183 b. o., the accepted date, based on another passage in the same chapter of Clemens. Besides, Clemens assigns the date 1334 b. c. for the fall of Troy to Duris only a few lines farther on. Censorinus De die nat. 21. 3 cites Timaeus for the fall of Troy in 1193 b. c, but this is certainly due either to an interchange of names or an omission. This is the date given by Thrasyllus; cf. Clemens Strom, i. 21. 137. Mommsen Rfrm. Chron., p. 136, erred in the other direction by assuming that Timaeus (frg. 23 Mtiller) represented Aeneas as contemporary with Dido. The fragment in question leaves no place for Aeneas in the myth of Dido, who kills herself to escape marriage with Iarbas. The Chronology of Eakly Rome 323 period. This renders it fairly certain that, from the fourth century on, the Alban kings had a place in the history of Rome. Pais op. cit. I. i, pp. 201 and 224, holds that the Alban myth arose soon after the subjugation of Latium (340-338 b. o.) and from political reasons. As regards the time of origin he must be about right, but both the chronology and the presence of the Greek names in the list indicate a Greek origin rather than a native Latin one. Par more frequently the traditional seven kings of Rome were used to date the city, by reckoning back from the establishment of the Republic. Mommsen Bom. Chron., pp. 134 f., has explained the variations in the dates of the founding by a very free use of the interregnum year after Romulus, which he made into two years and twice added to the reign of Numa, though still retaining it as an interregnum year, a rather forced explanation even though the length of Numa's reign is variously given as 39, 41, or 43 years. 1 Mommsen thus reached the conclusion that the different dates of founding were due merely to varying lengths of royal rule and pointed to a single accepted date for the establishment of the Republic. He took no account of such divergent dates as those of Cincius Alimentus, whom he considered an antiquarian of the Augustan age, or of Timaeus or Ennius. Moreover, the inference which he drew from this and from a similar reduction to unity of the many apparent variations in the consular lists, as given in the Fasti and in the various historians, has been fatal to progress in investigations into the chronology of Rome. Briefly stated, his position is (op. cit., p. 133) that "the various Fasti and historians show practically the same numbers and names of consuls for the Republic, thus pointing to the existence before the literary period of a single, well-established tradition, an officially corrected edition of the Fasti ; but instead of the historical trustworthiness of the lists and dates being assured thereby, in fact these would be much more certain, if there were two or more original versions, now agreeing, now disagreeing." The unanimity discovered by Mommsen seemed to him to prove that all divergent forms and dates had been corrected and unified 1 Unger Rh. Mus. XXXV, p. 11, sees the fallacy of this explanation, but his own method of inserting interregnum years after four of the kings is even worse. 324 Henky A. Sanders in the pontifical tablets before the literary period. In other words, the pontiffs possessed a single, authoritative consular list, couched in literary form and accommodated to the prevalent chronological ideas, even before the time of Fabius. With the exception of Pais op. cit., p 226, 1 who goes to the other extreme by refusing all credence to the early consular lists because of their divergences and inconsistencies, this view of Mommsen's has in general been held down to the present, notably by Unger op. cit., though the facts he gathered were against it. Yet this interpretation demands that the seven kings of Rome be reckoned in round numbers at 240 years, even in the earliest version, instead of at the natural three per century; neither does it explain all the different found- ing dates, and, as above stated, sadly overworks the interregnum year after Romulus. Not only must we explain the increase in the regal period from 233 to 240 years, but we cannot lightly deny authority to 729 b. c. as the date of founding according to Cincius Alimentus. Dionysius surely knew whether he was using a historian or a contemporary antiquarian, so that this date must also be explained. 2 In spite of the length of time it has stood, the theory of Mommsen rests on a most insecure footing. Yet on this hangs all the learned investigation, reaching down to the present, which has attempted to reconstruct and date the literary version, or collection of extracts of the pontifical tablets, supposed to be the only original source of all the early annalists. That there are variations in the Roman consular lists is unquestioned (cf. CIL I, Fasti consulares). Mommsen even did not try to correct them out of the texts, but rather belittled them and asserted that they were of late origin. So far is this from being true, that the discrepancies are both decided and numerous, and go back to the earliest sources. And besides, instead of having arisen through careless omissions, judging from internal evidence, the briefest list seems to be the oldest and most trustworthy. Let us turn our attention first to Livy. As I pointed out in the Classical Journal I, p. 156, he omits the four dictatorial years, 'Of. Anc. Leg. of Rom. Hist., pp. 6 ff. 2 Thue Unger op. cit., p. 25. The Chbonology of Eably Home 325 421, 430, 445, 453 a.u.o., three consular years, 247, 264, and 265 A.U.O., and one military tribune year, 378 a. u.c, a total of eight. That should have given him the year 501 B. 0. for the founding of the Republic, and doubtless one of his sources had that date, though Livy himself reckons in his chronology four of the years he, in fact, omits, and besides adds an extra decemviral year, so as to arrive at 506 b. o. for the establishment of the Republic. It seems clear that, of the sources of Livy, one, which we may style 0, omitted eight years from the full consular Fasti, while another, which I call D, omitted four. It is not determinable which, if either, of these sources inserted the extra decemviral year. But this is not the worst. Even the above-mentioned more abbreviated consular list was somewhat padded. If we turn to Livy vi. 35. 10, we learn that owing to dissentions between plebe- ians and patricians, there were no curule magistrates for five suc- cessive years. This statement is on its face suspicious, yes impos- sible. Now turning to Diodorus xv. 75, who regularly represents an earlier source than Livy, we find that the period of anarchy is confined to a single year. 1 Furthermore, Diodorus omits the four decemviral years as does Livy (one falls in a lacuna) and likewise one military tribune year, 387 a. u. 0. ; this is not the same one as in Livy, but it falls in the same period, so that the chronological balance was preserved. The omissions of Livy or an equivalent all occur in Diodorus and more besides. So we have a right to assume that Diodorus omitted the three consular years, 247, 264, 265 A.u.o., which fall in a lacuna. This is all the more certain as Diodorus also omits the year 272 A.u.o., making here also a group of four years omitted. This makes a total of 13 years omitted by Diodorus. Nor is this all; between books xii and xiii he omits five years, 331 to 335 a. u. o. inclusive, though he later reinserts five years by repeating 'Mommsen Hermes XIII, pp. 306 and 553, refers the one year of anarchy to Polybius and Fabius, holding that the four years as also the four decemviral years were inserted to make up for omitted interregna, etc. ITnger Bayer. Akad. XV (1879), pp. 88 ft., has overthrown this view by showing that if much time was lost at the begin- ning of the year through interregna, the consular year was so much shorter. The slight variations in the length of the consular years owing to priestly influence on the calen- dar, abdications, dictatorships overrunning the consular years, interregna, etc., have had no effect that can be reckoned. 326 Henby A. Sanders xv. 2 — xv. 20, the five years just given in the passage xiv. 97 to xiv. 110. These five sets of names are plainly from different sources in the two passages, as almost all the names in the second set differ somewhat in form from the first set. It is also noteworthy, that the Roman events are joined to the first set, leaving the sec- ond set without Roman historical allusions. The conclusion is unavoidable, that the Roman chronology of Diodorus was influ- enced by two sources. The one, which we may style Source A, omitted 18 years from the most complete Fasti, the other, Source B, omitted 13. What cause can there have been for such extensive omissions or insertions ? We may note first, that the military tribune year, 378 A.u. c, omitted by Livy and his sources, was the year before the period of anarchy, while the military tribune year, 387 A.u. c, omitted by Diodorus and his sources, was the last one in the same group of military tribune years. The conclusion is obvious; not even the one year of anarchy according to Diodorus was in the original consular lists, but was manufactured out of some refer- ence to a brief period of anarchy, and when it became a full year, it crowded out a military tribune year near it, so as to keep in accord with accepted chronology. That we find two separate years omitted in the different sources proves that two independent authors corrected the list to agree with the accepted chronology. The omission of five successive years in Source A of Diodorus seems to have been later than this and to have been arbitrarily made to balance a previous insertion of the five anarchy years. Source C of Livy is closely related to Source B of Diodorus, having inserted merely one consular and four anarchy years addi- tional. The two must be referred back to a common source, as X, which lacked four consular years between 247 and 272 A.u.c, the whole five years of anarchy, and the four decemviral years. We have just shown how the one anarchy year crept in by crowding out a military tribune year. In like manner this one year of anarchy must have grown to five from chronological reasons, viz., to keep pace chronologically with some other consular list which had inserted the four extra-consular years or the four extra- decemviral years. The Chronology of Eaely Rome 327 Let us see if we can determine the age and author of any of these sources or consular lists. For Sources X and B the date of establishment of the Eepublic was 509—13=496 b. c. 1 I have noted above that the seven kings must originally have been reckoned at 33J years each, or at a total of 233 years. Now a historian, who was earnest and exact enough to search out a con- sular list containing the least number of interpolations, would surely have reckoned the seven traditional kings as seven genera- tions at a total of 233 years, and not accepted the pure inventions, which gave a definite length to each reign. If, however, we add these 233 royal years to 496 b. o. of Sources X and B, we get 729 b. o. for the founding of the city, precisely the date given by Cincius Alimentus, 2 which Mommsen tried to call in question. Cincius was, therefore, either Source B or X. We have also the right to infer that Cincius and his sources mentioned the Alban kings, for the 420 years between 729 B. o. and 1149 b. c, the date of Troy's fall according to Ephorus (Clemens Strom, i. 21. 139), is the same as Timaeus and Thrasyllus gave to the Alban period. This whole chronology is so simple and honest, that the ques- tion may well be asked, why Fabius Pictor and all his followers gave a different one. The answer cannot be doubtful. The variations in the consular list, the changes, interpolations, and chronological adjustments go back to the pontifical and other lists, even before the time of Fabius. The variations in these current lists, extracted from priestly or official sources, by comparison brought about the increase of the regal period from 233 to 240 and perhaps to 244 years, in an attempt to preserve approximately some accepted date for the founding. Now in a partial list of the kings, Cicero De re pub. ii. 10 fl\, indicates a total of 238 years for royal rule, though he expressly states a total of 240 years, probably by including a two-year interregnum after Romulus; cf. Mommsen Rom. Chron., p. 138. We should therefore accept lUnger Bh. Mus. XXXV, p. 2, by a different reckoning gets 498 b. c. as the true date. 2 The adjusting of later dates, as the capture of Rome by the Gauls, to this chronol- ogy of Oincius presents some interesting results, which I must, however, reserve for another paper. 328 Henry A. Sandebs 238 years as the second stage in the increase of the regal period. But we have seen that Sources A and B differed from each other by five years, as also Sources B and C. Then Source A must have placed the establishment of the Republic in 491 b. a, i. e., 509-18 ; but if that author gave 729 B. 0. as the founding date, he would have 238 years in the regal period. Source C implies the establishment of the Republic in 501 b. c. (509-8), Source D in 505 b. c, but none of these can be defi- nitely connected with the briefer period of royal rule and the customary dates of founding. Yet they may well have had some influence on the growth of the regal period. Thus 505 + 243 = 748 B. 0., an accepted date for the founding and a common era for the kings. After a regal period of 238 years had been obtained, the next inventions were the interregnum year and two years after Romulus (100 senators at five days each gives 500 days), thus giving 239 and 240 years respectively; these two were in turn increased by four years each (to 243 and 244) by a confusion arising out of the use or omission of one of the groups of four interpolated years. It is hardly worth while to show how all the dates of founding grew out of this confusion. The important fact is that the con- fusion in the consular list and in the regal period existed before 200 B. c. and had not been entirely eradicated in the Augustan Age. We may also surmise that not even the tradition of seven kings was always unquestioned. Remus at times seems more important than Romulus and Tatius is made a ruler with Romulus, if not alone. Doubtless by inserting one or the other of these, Laas (Kallias?) secured eight kings, so as to agree with the founding in the first Olympiad 1 : 8X33^=267, and 267+509=776 b. a, i. e., Olym. 1, 1. Timaeus, however, must have inserted both extra kings, making a total of nine, and padded the consular list by an extra four years in order to agree with the founding date 814 b. c, for 510 B. c. seems the earliest date for the Republic indicated elsewhere. 2 To sum up, I find that there were two or more consular lists l Of. p. 319 above. 2 Auother possibility for Timaeus is eight kings at 40 years, i. e., 320 years; for 814-320=494, a reasonable date for the founding of the Republic. The Chronology of Early Rome 329 existent in Rome long before 200 b. c. One at least of these seems to have been interpolated early, perhaps before 300 b. o. ; cf. Timaeus and Kallias. It cannot be due to chance that these interpolations in the different Fasti seem to go mostly by fours. Doubtless the first four, the consuls 247, 264, 265, and 272 a. u. c, were introduced through family influence or carelessness, but the other insertions were mostly due to the existence of two or more varying lists, mutually influencing each other. This is the natural explanation for the introduction of the four dictatorial years and for the increase of the period of anarchy from one to five years. According to the above we may date the establishment of the Republic in Rome between 510 and 491 b. a, or more exactly, as some of the interpolations and omissions seem certain, between 500 and 496 b. o. with the preference for the later date. Cincius, who requires the date 496 B. c, must have used a different consular list from Fabius, whose list had to reach back to 508 or 509 b. c. in order to get 748 b. o. for the founding, as he seems to have assigned but 239 l or 240 years to the kings. Polybius iii. 22, as also Cato and the Fasti, gave 243 years to the regal period, hence 509 b. o. for the Republic. We know that Polybius used the pontifical tablets to determine the date of Rome (cf. Dion. Hal. i. 74. 3); therefore both Cato and Pabius, who require the same date for the Republic, used them also. Cincius surely had a different source, perhaps the libri lintei; but there may well have been, and probably were, other priestly or official Fasti, as well as numerous consular lists extracted from these and in the hands of the public. 2 Furthermore, the confusion in the lists would arise more easily if there were several to influ- ence each other, than if there were only two. There were, doubt- less, consular lists current pointing toward many of the dates from 514 to 491 b. o. for the establishment of the Republic. In conclusion let me emphasize once more, that the proof that there were parallel Roman consular lists as early as the third or fourth century b. c. is the strongest proof of the general accuracy and historical reliability of that list. University of Michigan lOf. linger Rh. Mus. XXXV, p. 4. 2 0f. Dion. Hal. i. 73. 1, 74. 5 ; Livy iv. 7. 10.