STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. GENS, FAMILIA, STIRPS By Max Radin To advance a new theory of the Roman gens is, in effect, to attempt a reconstruction of early Roman history, and scholars may be forgiven if they show scant patience with those who undertake to darken counsel on this subject. It is, indeed, rather unlikely that newer conjectures will be markedly more convincing than the many that have been offered to the choice of the investigator. But it may very properly be questioned whether all the facts on which these conjectures ought to be based have been ascertained. If we seek to discover what the gens was in the days of Roma Quadrata — if such a city existed — or even at the time of the Struggle of the Orders, we shall be hopelessly handicapped by lack of docu- ments. Our only resource is to attempt to find out what the gens was at a period when documents are fairly numerous, and to reason back with progressive uncertainty as far as we care to go. The most common view of the gens is the one recently set forth by Kubler in Pauly-Wissowa-KroU, Realencyclopddie, VII, 1176-98. Briefly, it may be said to be the following. The gentes as such were originally patrician solely. After the virtual surrender of the patriciate, plebeians also constituted themselves into gentes or quasi-gentes} The right to call these new organizations gentes was at first contested by the patricians but ultimately acquiesced in and legally acknowledged. Gentes were officially divided into familiae or stirpes.^ Against this view. Professor Botsford in his article "Problems Connected with the Roman Gens" (Political Science Quarterly, XXII [1907], 665) maintains that the gens was at all times both patrician and plebeian, i.e., contained both patrician and plebeian members. Both scholars, however, take for granted that, at the close of the Republic, the term gens was unhesitatingly applied to ' Cf L^crivain, s.v. gens; Daremberg-Saglio, Dictionnaire des antiquitis. ' Both Kubler and Botsford (cf. infra) reject the asaertion made by Lfecrivain (op. cit., p. 1515) that atirps waa the official title of the plebeian group. [Classical Philology IX, July, 1914] 235 236 Max Radin either patrician or plebeian super-families, and that familiae or stirpes were the divisions of these gentes. Kiibler notices that familia is seemingly a variant for gens in many passages and believes that the " confusion" of these terms begins with Cicero.' When, however, we read (p. 1180): "es gab sowohl patrizische wie plebeische gentes. Von plebeischen finden wir erwahnt," etc., the impression must not be obtained that, in most of these cases, the families in question are characterized as gentes in the passages from which they are quoted. In almost every instance — the exceptions will be noted later — the term is familia or genus? Besides the enumerated plebeian gentes Kiibler lays stress on the expression, "patricia gens," from which he infers the existence and recognition of plebeiae gentes.^ If we leave aside all consideration of the orginal nature of the gens, and confine ourselves to a period definitely historical, for which relatively numerous documents are extant, it will be well to consider first the one writer who ex professo sets forth the development of the Roman state, and whose statements, qualified, interpreted, or inverted, are none the less the basis of all that is soUd in our knowledge of Roman history, Livy. It is quite true that modern critics will not accept any statement of Livy about a condition or a fact for which his evidence is not obvious. But he is surely excellent author- ity about what he himself believes. And it is solely with the view of determining Livy's own idea of the gens that the following material has been collected. gens Gens is used in a number of quite distinct cases in Livy. o) The commonest meaning is that of "tribe," "race," "people."* In the plural, gentes, especially in the phrase ins gentium (iii. 4. 7, and passim), it denotes "the human race." ■Op. cit., p. 1177: "Schon zu Ciceros Zeit aber beginnt sich der Unterschied zwischen gens und familia zu verwischen." ^ In one instance the citation has evidently been made inadvertently. Cicero De har. res. 32 does not refer either to the gens or the familia Calpurnia. The phrase is, muUi sunt in hoc &rdine [i. e., in senatu] qui sacrificia geniilicia faciitareni. •If Kubler's words "die gleichfalls vorkommen" indicate his belief that such a phrase as gens plebeia occurs, other instances must be cited than the two offered here, viz., Cic. De legg. ii. 55 and Suet. Nero 50. Neither contains the phrase. * I suppose I may be spared the necessity of citing instances of this use. It occurs on practically every page of Livy. Gens, Familia, Stirps 237 There seems to be no trace in Livy of the distinction which Tacitus' sought to make {Germania ii, xxvii, xxxviii) by which natio is made a sub- division of gens. In Livy, natio has its technical legal designation of "birth" and is used particularly to denote the origin of slaves (xxi. 46. 10). Gens means any national or racial group, large or small, as indeed it does through^ out Latin .^ 6) Gens is used to designate a Roman clan or super-family, i.e., a group of men believing themselves to be descended from a common ancestor, but unable to trace that descent in detail. In this sense, which more especially interests us, the following, as far as I can find, are all the instances in Livy: Claudia gens iii. 58. 5; vi. 20. 3; 40. 3; iv. 3. 14; Cornelia gens viii. 18. 8; XXXV. 10. 9; xxxviii. 58. 3; xlv. 41; Fabia gens ii. 43. 11; 45. 16; 48. 8 {his); 49.2; 49.3; 49.4; 50.2; 50.11; iii. 1. 1; v. 46. 2; 52.3; 52.4; viii. 32. 15; xlv.- 41; Furia gens xxxi. 48. 12; Horatia gens i. 26. 13; lulia gens i. 3. 2; Manila gens vi. 11. 2; 20. 14 {his); Potitia gens ix. 29. 9; 34. 19; Quinctia gens iii. 11. 6; 12. 3; vii. 39. 12; Sergia gens viii. 18. 8; Sestia gens iii. 33. 9; Silvia gens i. 3. 10; Tarquinia gens ii. 2. 3; 2. 7; 2. 11; Tarquitia gens iii. 27. 1. c) The plural is used in the same sense, referring expressly to patrician clans: minores gentes i. 35. 6; 47. 7; maiestas earum gentium vi. 40. 4; stMrum gentium {Furiae Quinctiae Corneliae) viris vii. 1. 2; patridae gentes x. 15. 9. d) Again, without such specific reference, confundere iura gentium iv. 1. 2; conluvio gentium iv. 2. 5; nova iura gentium iv. 4. 4; discrimina gen- tium V. 14.4; lurhato gentium iure vii. 6. 11. e) The legal phrases gentem habere x. 8. 9; gentis enuptio xxxix. 19. /) Rarely it is used of similar clans or super-families outside of Rome: ob antiqua gente Aequicolis i. 32. 5; certae gentis sacerdos v. 22. 5; gens Bar- cina xxiii. 41. 2. g) Derivative adjectives and nouns are rare: gentilicia sacra {Fabiorum) v. 52. 4; gentiles {Glaudii) iii. 58. 1. familia Familia, too, is used in several wholly different ways: a) In the undoubtedly original sense of a group oi famuli, i.e., all those living chattels that were not pecunia. This is chiefly, but not wholly, in legal phrases: familia armata iii. 14. 9; ut familia venum iret iii. 55. 7; famil- iam in potestate habere viii. 15. 9; ipsi familiaeque eorum xxvi. 27. 8; familia arcessita xxxix. 14; familiae heredes xlv. 40. To this we may add the adjec- tive in the phrase res familiaris iv. 60. 2. ' Cf. the note on chap, ii in the Church and Brodribb edition of the Germania, p. 32; cf. also Velleius ii. 98. ' The doublet gentes ac nalionea is intended to cover every variety of loosely organ- ized tribes (Ulpian on the Census, Dig. 50. 15. 1. 5). 238 Max Radin 6) As equivalent to "family" in the narrow sense, i.e., that group of men descended from the same known ancestor, who could be contemporaries of one another — the Greek ayxia-Toa.^ Besides the technical term familia funesta ii. 8. 9; 47. 10; xxvi. 18. 11, we have duae familiae iv. 61. 10; dtw- decim familiae Potitiorum ix. 29. 10; execratio familiae x. 38. 10; 41. 3; per familias xxi. 54. 2; comploratus familiarum xxii. 55. 7; in singulas familias xxvi. 34. 2; familia nostra xxvi. 41. 8; familiae aliquot xxix. 31. 8; cum familiis xxxix. 53; xl. 3; xli. 8; xliii. 17. There are further phrases con- taining adjectives: familiare ostentum xxvi. 6. 14; familiaris orbitas xxvi. 41. 9; familiaris luctus xxvii. 51. 12; familiaris amicitia xxxii. 22. 11. c) In the sense of super-family, i.e. = gens: Aelia iv. 54. 3; xxii. 35. 2; Atilia xxii. 35. 2; Cassia ii. 41. 10; iv. 15. 5; Claudia ii. 56. 7; iv. 15. 5; vi. 40. 6; ix. 29. 8; 33. 3; 34. 3; 34. 15. familiare consilium iv. 48. 6; Claudia Marcellorum xxv. 29. 6; Cornelia Scipionum xxviii. 41. 15; xxxviii. 55. 2; 58. 3; 59. 11; Decia, familiare fatum x. 28. 13; Fabia ii. 42. 8; ii. 49. 4; familiare bellum ii. 48. 9; Icilia iv. 52. 2; iv. 54. 4; Licinia v. 22. 2; vii. 9. 5; ManUa vii. 10. 13; Papiria x. 39. 14; Pinaria i. 7. 12; Popillia xlii. 22; Potitia i. 7. 12; 7. 14; familiare sacerdotium ix. 29. 9; Pupia iv. 54. 3; Quinctia iii. 12. 2; 25. 3; Silia iv. 54. 3; Trebonia v. 10. 11; Valeria i. 20. 2; ii. 18. 7; 30. 6; iii. 17. 8; vii. 32. 13; 32. 15; x. 9. 3; Vibia xl. 44.2 d) The plural is likewise used in the sense of c) : splendor familiarum iv. 15. 5; patricii pleheiique nobilissimarum familiarum xxxix. 53; dum famil- iae ad sefamam mendacio trahunt viii. 40. 4; multas familias xxiii. 4. 7. e) As in the case of gens, the word may be used of corresponding non- Roman clans: familia Mopsiorum xxiii. 1. 2; familia Barcina xxiii. 13. 6; familia inimica (Numidian) xxiv. 29. 8; familia Blossiorum xxvii. 3. 5; familiaria iura xxiv. 5. 9. Livy has still other ways of referring to the family or super-family. domus domus lunia ii. 5. 7. Frequently of families proper (i.e., in the restricted sense): i. 40. 3; iii. 37. 2; 58. 11; iv. 13. 8; 31. 5; 40. 3; xxvi. 18. 11; xxviii. 41. 14; xxx. 20. 4; 30. 13; xl. 4. 8; xlv. 41. genus Pinarium genus i. 7. 13; genus Potitiorum i. 7. 14; genus Fabium ii. 46. 4; plebei generis iv. 9. 4; memor generis (Corneli) iv. 19. 1; Cilnium genus X. 3. 2; 5. 13. nomen Fabium nomen ii. 42. 2; 42. 8; 45. 16; nomen Potitiorum ix. 29. 11; nomen Marcellorum xxv. 29. 6. ' This will cover at most four generations. Cf. Festus 221 M. 2 In some instances, notably in those of the Decii and the Scipios, it ia not clear whether familia is used in the sense of 6) or c) . Gens, Familia, Stirps 239 Gentile Name in Plural Fabii ii. 47. 12; 48. 8; 48. 10; 49. 1; 49. 2; 50. 1; 51. 5; Valerii Horatii iii. 39. 3; Claudii Cassii iv. 15. 5; lunii, Valerii, Fabii, Quinctii, Cornelii ix. 17. 11; Calavii xxvi. 27. 7. If we examine these facts without preformed hypotheses, we should never infer that Livy's views of gens and familia were those of Kiibler. Considering the instances cited under gens b), we find that in every case the reference is to a patrician clan, or, at any rate, to a clan, expressly designated as such by Livy. In the correspond- ing group, familia c), we meet with very many instances of patrician clans, and also with plebeian clans.' That this holds throughout the entire extant work of Livy, viz., thirty-five books, can scarcely be an accident. We may, therefore, legitimately infer that Livy considered the word familia to be the term of larger extension, covering all family groups of any size or character, but believed that the term gens denoted a family group of patrician lineage and could properly be used of no other. The term patricia gens (cf. supra) does not presume the existence of a corresponding term gens plebeia; nor is a similar implication contained in suarum gentium (vii. 1. 2). In the first place, the term plebeia gens, as far as I know, does not exist in the Latin of this period, or of any period near it in time. In the second place, the adjective can be descriptive as well as limiting.^ Again, the plural use of gens, in gens d), especially discrimina gentium v. 14. 4, is equally indefinite. It will be noted that all the in- stances but one deal with the agitation about the lex Canuleia. They can all be interpreted in perfect accordance with the usage of Livy indicated above, and, at any rate, do not necessarily conflict with it. Only in gens f) does Livy permit himself a certain freedom in the use of the word gens. Even here, the reference is to certain families that may properly be called illustrious. Besides, the distinction would be wholly pointless anywhere except at Rome.' • The Claudii, Cornelii, Fabii, Manlii, Potitii, Quinctii appear in both lists. The undoubtedly patrician Pinarii and Valerii are referred to only as familiae. ' One may, it is submitted, speak of "the patrician interrex" and "the plebeian tribunes" without of necessity implying the existence of plebeian inierreges and patrician tribunes. » In his valuable study of words of relationship in early Latin, J. Kohm (Altla- teinische Forschungen [1905], pp. 16-18) finds no instance of gena except in meaning a) (except one corrupt passage from Accius [Ribbeck, Trag. Frag, Accius 580] ) . Familia is generally used in meaning o) (pp. 1-5), and in the sense of 6) (p. 6). 240 Max Radin Of the plebeian "gerdes" cited by Kiibler from Cicero (cf. supra) only a few are actually so denominated. Of these the Minucii (Cicero Verr. i. 115) at least maintained that they were patrician originally (Livy iv. 16. 3). The Fonteii are mentioned (Z>e domo 35, and 116, contaminatis gentibus et guam deseruisti et guam polluisti; and non suae genii Fonteiae sed Clodiae; cf. further, De har. resp. 57) only in immediate juxtaposition with the Clodii, so that the latter name may have exercised a sort of assimilation on the former. But in De legg. ii. 55 the gens Popilia is referred to without such qualification.* However, gens in this sense is rare in Cicero. Besides those men- tioned, the Cornelii are so designated {De legg. ii. 56), the Tarquinii (Rep. ii. 46), the Claudii {passim and De domo 35), the Manlii {Phil. i. 32), the Valerii {Place. 12). In general, it is the word familia^ that is used whether the reference is to patrician or plebeian. Besides that, there are a number of phrases or rather paraphrases, which seem especially designed to cover the idea contained in gens, e.g., genus ac nomen {Verr. iv. 79), genus etfamilia {Ldg. 12; Muren. 90), familia genus nomen {Muren. 12), genus nomen familia {Dig. 20), genus familiaque {Plane. 18). Speaking of Clodia, Cicero says {Gael. 33) that she had married ex amplissimo genere in familiam noMlis- simam. It is plain from what has been said that Cicero does not syste- matically observe the distinction carefully made by Livy. If he had wished to do so, there could have been no better opportunity than in the Caeliana, where the pretensions of the patrician Claudii and plebeian Caecilii are contrasted. But the relative infrequency of gens, and the preponderance of patricians, or of particularly illus- trious plebeians (Minucii, Popilii) in the instances that do occur, render it at least probable that Cicero did not feel the terms gens and familia to be quite interchangeable. Other writers of that time do not offer sufficient instances to permit safe inferences about their usage. One instance from Varro ' It will, however, be noted that the Popilii are among the first plebeians to hold curule offices. Cf. M. Popilius Laenas, consul 358 B.C. (Livy vii. 12. 1). In the same way, the Licinii, the %'ery oldest of all plebeian nobiles, are called gena (Varro R. R. i. 2. 9). ' Cf. particularly the Pro Murena and Pro Plancio, where there is constant occa- sion to mention the claims of families and clans. Gens, Familia, Stirps 241 has already been cited. Caesar uses gentes of the German clans' and again of his own family in the funeral laudation of his aunt Julia: A Venere lulii, ewius gentis familia est nostra? Sallust speaks of Corneliorum gens (Cat. 55) and gens Aemilia {Phil. 6).^ In the passages from Caesar and in Sail. Jug. 95 we find gens and familia used side by side in the sense which makes familia a subdivision of gens. As has been seen, that is distinctly not the rule for Cicero and Livy. Familia is the more extensive word and may mean either the family proper or the super-family or clan, and is by far the com- moner word in both senses. Gens is rarer, and, where it does not mean "race" or "tribe," means "clan" only.* What is true of the nouns gens and familia does not, of necessity, hold true of the derivatives gentilis and familiaris. As adjectives they probably followed the fortunes of the words from which they come.* But the commonest use of these words is substantive. As a substantive familiaris is common in all Latin in the meaning of "friend." Festus (86 M.) states that members of the same familia, either familia a) or familia b) (cf. supra) may be so designated. However that may be, the first meaning is undoubtedly the more general. The others have only slight literary currency, if any.* For gentiles we have the much quoted definition of Q. Scaevola preserved by Cicero in Tojnca 6. 29: Gentiles sunt inter se qui eodem nomine sunt, qui ab ingenuis oriundi sunt, quorum maiorum nemo servitutem servivit, qui capite non sunt deminuti. In substance this is repeated by L. Cincius, Cicero's contemporary, gentiles mihi sunt qui meo nomine appellantur.'' This definition can scarcely have been offered otherwise than to decide a concrete dispute. By the Twelve Tables, certain substan- tial rights of inheritance and guardianship are given to the gentiles. It is obviously of very great moment to know who may and who ' Combined with cognationes (B. G. vi. 22. 2). 2 Suet. Div. lul. 6. ' Cf. the constant reference to the Aemilii as familia in the Scauriana, e.g., 45. ' Cf., however, infra the instances from Livy (xl. 21), Sallust (Jug. 108), Trog. Pomp, (xxviii. 3. 4). ' Cf. gentile monimentum (Domitii, Suet. Nero 53) and familiare sejmlchrum (Gaius Dig. 11. 7. 5). • Cf. the instances in Kohm, AUlateinigche Forschungen, p. 11. ' Festua, s.v. gentilis, 94 M. 242 Max Radin may not be considered gentiles. Now, by a quite apparent etymology, gentiles were blood kinsmen, and yet it was equally apparent that the kinship of many undoubted gentiles was not demonstrable by ordi- nary evidence. The general principle of Roman law in such cases was that stated by Papinian {Dig. 22. 3. 1) : quotiens quaereretur genus vel gentem quis haberet necne, eum probare oportet.^ Scaevola, then, sought to establish that the proof of a common nomen was itself presumptive evidence of community of descent. There were, how- ever, in Rome two very large classes of men bearing any specified nomen who were demonstrably not of the same descent as others of that nomen. These were, first, emancipated slaves and, secondly, men adopted from other gentes.^ These were accordingly expressly excepted. The fact that no others were expressly excepted may be taken to indicate that in the time of Scaevola, i.e., about 100 B.C., there were no other Romans bearing a certain nomen and demonstrably of different actual origin from other Romans bearing that nomsn.^ If that is so, certain rather far-reaching inferences may be per- mitted. CUents in Rome sometimes bore the gentile names of their patron and sometimes did not. It would follow from what has gone before (since clients are not excepted in Scaevola's definition) that where they did bear that name they were of libertine origin, and that where the cHentela arose in any other way, e.g., by voluntary commendation of one free man to another, the client did not assume his patron's name.* In the generation almost immediately after Scaevola we meet with many men, neither libertini nor libertini ' This formulation is late, but gentem habei'e, in view of the fact that gentile law was obsolete in Papinian's time, shows that it must go back much earlier. ' By Roman law, adopted children suffered capitis deminutio minima. To be sure, this applied to those adopted from one family into another of the same gens, as Botsford points out {loc. dt.), so that the adopted child, although capite deminuius, might nevertheless be of the same actual blood as the others of his name. But these instances seem to have been very rare. In general, it is not at all strange that the individual's right to create claimants to the substantial rights of a gens should be denied by Scaevola. ' The definition is not quite accurate in another respect. Taken literally it would exclude even Romans captured in war and later restored to their country. Cf. the senator C. Terentius CuUeo (Livyix. 45. 5), and especially the consul Servilius (Livy xxvii. 21. 10; xxx. 19. 8-9). Cf. my note on this point, "The Case of the Marcelli, " Class. Phil., VII, 481. • Cf. the instances given by Botsford, Political Science Quarterly, XXII, 673, and quoted by Kilbler, op. cit., p. 1179. Gens, Familia, Stirps 243 generis, nor yet, strictly, clientes, who bore well-known gentile names. The most notable instances are such men as the Antiochene Archias and the Spaniard Balbus. We may speak of them as natural- ized foreigners. If cases of this kind had been known to Scaevola, it is scarcely conceivable that he would not have specifically excluded them. Since he did not, and since it cannot be supposed that he would have permitted Archias to share in all the gentile prerogatives of the Crassi, or Balbus in all those of the Scipios, we may conclude that instances of such names did not exist in his time. We know of many cases, long before Scaevola, where either indi- vidual foreigners or the citizens of any entire community received Roman citizenship. The Libyphoenician Muttines (Livy xxvi. 7. 8) and the poet Ennius may serve as examples. But we do not know of a single case where such a naturalized foreigner adopted an already existing Roman name. Biicheler makes the nomen of the Umbrian Plautus a Romanization of his role of Maccus.' We have no evi- dence of Maccii in Rome before Plautus or of Ennii before Ennius. The procedure presumably adopted by Plautus, or something like it, may well have been the rule. The condition of affairs in Cicero's time, when such foreigners upon naturalization did not hesitate to adopt the most illustrious names, is so decidedly different, that we must look for a fixed point at which the change took place. Such a point may be found in the lex Plautia-Papiria of 89 B.C. which opened Roman citizenship in wholesale fashion to thousands of foreigners. The practical necessities of immediate registration — the law allowed only sixty days — probably compelled the hasty assumption of praenomen and nomen, and it is to be assumed that the clerks of the various praetors were not over particular.^ One thing in general may be noted in connection with the defini- tion of Scaevola. It is made by a plebeian. If, according to the traditional view, the right of belonging to a gens, properly so called, was a moot point between patricians and plebeians, it is highly ' Rhein. Mus., 41, 12; cf., however, W. Sohultze, Zur Oeach. der lat. Eigennamen, pp. 298 ff. ' The arbitrary assumption of any name would not of itself render the offender liable to the penalties of the lex Cornelia de falsis (81 B.C.) (cf. Kilbler, op. cil., p. 1177). That was the case only if the adoption of the name was coupled with specific fraudulent intent. Cf. the passage there quoted (Paul. Sent. v. 25. 11). One may also compare a late rescript, of Diocletian, of 293 a.d. (SJod. lust. 9. 25). 244 Max Radin probable that a plebeian iuris prvdens would consciously make his decision cover the claims of his order. How authoritative such a decision would be depended, certainly till Augustus, upon the personal views of the single iudex or of the majority of the iudicium, which considered any given case. There is no doubt, however, that ultimately the decision became generally accepted. The definition appealed particularly to Cicero. He had more than one occasion to combat the pretensions of the patricians to exclusive nobility,' and of the nobility as a whole.^ It pleased him to consider himself a gentilis of Servius TuUius (Tusc. i. 38).' The reference, of course, is half-jesting, but it depends upon the defini- tion of Scaevola for its point, as does the statement (Verr. ii. 190) that Verrucius was paene gentilis to Verres. The passage from Cicero's translation of the Timaeus, to which Kilbler (p. 1177) attaches great importance, does not seem to me more than a direct appHcation of the Scaevolan doctrine. It is merely the expansion of the bfioivvnov of the original. What the con- text is which in Kiibler's view contradicts this simple explanation is not apparent. Kiibler is surely wrong when (p. 1180) he seeks to establish that Cicero conceived men to bear to the gods the rela- tion of clients. There is no such statement in the Platonic passage {Tim. 41 C) which Cicero is translating. On the contrary, as to that part of man which is Betov, men are equated with the gods and not inferior to them. In every other respect gods and men stand in no relation whatever. There is nothing in Cicero to indicate that he understood Plato differently. The word quasi need have no legal significance. It is simply the apology for an unexpected word, getvLilis. This can be seen more clearly from two other passages of Cicero — De legg. i. 23 : id homines deorum agnatione et gente teneantur 1 Cf . Pro Murena 15 : si tibi hoc eumis nisi qui patricius sit, neminem bono esse genere natum, etc. 2 Cf. Pro Plancio 17-18. » With this statement, we may compare the following from Brutus 62 : MuUa enim scripta sunt in eis {sc. laudationibus) guae fada nan tunl, falsi triumphi, plures consu- latus, genera etiam falsa et ad plebem transitiones, cum homines humiliores in alienum eiusdem notninis infunderentur genus; ut si ego me a M* Tullio esse dicerem, qui patricius cum Ser. Sulpicio consul anno decimo post exactos reges fuit. We find, therefore, that Cicero regarded himself as an undoubted gentilis of Servius TuUius, but expressly dis- claimed any pretension to blood relationship with the patrician Tullii. Gens, Familia, Stibps 245 and i. 24: ex quo vere vel agnatio nobis cum caelestibus vel genus vel stirps appellari potest. The same idea is present here as in the Timaeus. Men are not dients of the gods, but actual kinsmen. In discussing the various uses of the word gens in Livy, two instances, marked e) gentem habere (x. 8. 9) and gentis enuptio (xxxix. 19) were reserved for separate treatment. As far as gentem habere is concerned, Kiibler's view seems better than Botsford's. The latter's objection was based upon the citation of this phrase to demonstrate the exclusively patrician character of the original gens. The phrase, however, can be legitimately adduced only as evidence of Livy's own conception of the gens, and for that, as I have tried to show, there is other and better evidence. Gens can indeed be used with the meaning of "birth,"' but the phrase gentem habere is established in the sense demanded by Kiibler, not only by the passage from Papinian (Dig. 22. 3. 1), but also by the fact that similar phrases are Ukewise known to the law. So collegium habere (CIL, III, 2924; I, 20; Bruns, Pontes', p. 351), from the Dacian wax tablets, means the right of belonging to the corporation, and tribum habere (Cic. Phil. vi. 12) means legal membership in a tribe. The other term, gentis enuptio, has been made the subject of a discussion in which the context seems to have been lost sight of. As a reward for her services in the Bacchanalian investigation, Fecen- nia Hispala (Livy xxxix. 19) received officially the datio deminutio gentis enuptio tutoris optio quasi ei vir testamento dedisset. It is self- evident that the phrase is part of a legal formula, a formula by which the senate attempted to confer upon Fecennia the most nearly com- plete disposal of her person and property which the law made possible for women. To do this, the senate consciously strove to put her in the position of a widow without male kinsmen, who has received from her husband by will the right of choosing her guardian — a purely formal guardian, it may be remembered, who could not refuse his auctoritas in any transaction. That is about what was effected in the law of the empire when a woman received as a special privilege the ius III liber orum. It is as idle to seek to determine just what the gens was from which Fecennia received enuptio, as to attempt to ' Hardly however in the sense of "illustrious" birth (Botsford, op. cit., 067). 246 Max Radin demonstrate that every woman in the second case actually had borne three children. The privilege in both instances could be conferred honoris causa, and need have no basis whatever in the actual circum- stances of Fecennia's case.' The phrase does not occur elsewhere. Enubere e patribus (Livy X. 23) is not at all the same thing. The full meaning of the expres- sion, as well as of the words familia[e] gens and eiusdem gentis of the Laudatio Turiae {CIL, VI, 1527; Supp. 31670; Bruns, Pontes'', 321), can be determined only when we have reached quite certain conclu- sions as to the existence of a legitima tutela gentilium for women. In one or two passages, finally, gens is used in a way that can clearly be distinguished from all the instances already cited. These are, first, Livy xl. 21 : non posse ohlivisci se in talibus rebus Antigoni qui .... praecepisse liberis diceretur, ne quis cum tola gente simul in rebus dubiis periclitari auderet. As this is Philip's pretext for not taking both Demetrius and Perseus with him, it is plain that gens means no more here than "offspring," as we shall see stirps means (cf. infra). ^ The second is the phrase of Sallust, Jug. 108, Dabar, ex gente Masinissae. Dabar was Masinissa's grandson. The word gens here again has the sense we shall find generally expressed by stirps. Cf. also ex gente regia (Trog. Pomp, xxviii. 3. 4). However isolated, these instances compel us to assume that gens could be intelligibly used in the general sense of "relationship" or "hne," a meaning, of course, easily obtained from its etymology. stirps The only purpose of the classification of the various meanings of stirps is to eliminate one meaning that is frequently attached to it. Kubler, fol- lowing nearly all his predecessors, makes stirps or familia the division of a gens (op. cU., p. 1177).' This meaning of stirps is used in discussing the case of the MarcelU (Kubler, op. cit., p. 1190) and determines the interpre- tation there suggested. In Livy, stirps is used as follows: (o) as equivalent to "offspring": stirps virilis (i. 1. 11; 3. 11; 40. 3 and passim); (jb) as equivalent to "line," "descent," "origin": regia stirps (i. 5. 5); Itatica stirps (i. 40. 2); peregrina 'Botsford takes the phrase literally. Kubler {op. cit., 1179) seems to hold that it is purely formal here. ' This proverbial expression seems to me to account quite adequately for the cum tota gente of Catullus 79. 2 =" You and all your kith and kin." ' All the citations there are concerned with familia and do not mention stirps. Gens, Familia, Stibps 247 stirps (5. 34. 1); ab stirpe Clavdia (iv. 48. 10); (c) as equivalent to "gener- ation": ad tertiam stirpem (xxxiii. 21. 5); cf. the frequent in stirpes in legal discussions (Gains iii. 8. 16); {d) in the figurative sense drawn from the literal meaning of stirps: a stirpe tollere (xxxiv. 2. 3); ab stirpe extingmre (ix. 34. 19) ; ad stirpem devolvere (i. 47. 5) ; (e) in such combined phrases as stirps genti (ii. 50. 11) ; stirps gentis (xxxvii. 8. 4) ; where one of the meanings already indicated may be applied. Besides the literal meaning — also found in Livy (xxvi. 41. 22) — the instances cover practically all the meanings found for stirps throughout Latin. Nowhere is a clear example adduced of stirps as a division of a gens. The term retains, at all times, something of the abstract sense of "origin," "line."^ Under these circumstances the constantly recurring statement that stirps as well as familia is an ordinary term denoting the division of the gens should be rejected, as well as all interpretations based upon that use of the word. Newtown High School New York City ' Cf. especially the instances from early Latin brought together by Kohm (op. cit., p. 21).