STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. NOTES AND DISCUSSIONS A NOTE ON THE AUGMENT An article recently published in this Journal (VII, 4) has drawn atten- tion to some difficulties of the augment. Of the points raised not all can be profitably discussed here. In some questions it would be unseemly for me to meddle. For instance, anyone who is dissatisfied with the augment in similes must revise the work of Professor Piatt; or if he has his doubts about the iterative, he can correct the grammar of the late Dr. Monro. In other cases, such as the augmentation of the main body of aorists and imperfects, the dispute is beyond the compass of a short paper, where it is impossible to enumerate the examples. Dr. Shewan will agree that in such matters there is no need for haste or alarm. If there are more augments than I made out, they will not run away; if there are fewer, no false examples can now be foisted into the text — that possibility has been past for some centuries. But there are some uses so comparatively rare that their occurrences can be enumerated; where this is so, it will be possible to debate the facts. Some- times the facts themselves are conceded by Dr. Shewan; here we can reason- ably argue the interpretation. In this way discussion may be restricted to four points. a) The extreme rarity of the temporal augments like that in ffi, || Toptrov iroSds, etc.); so too, scansions like || tov Se, || tov 8«, etc., seem quite normal. If then the augment in narrative was from the first felt as part of the sense, it is not easy to understand the taboo of mpovo-e. But let this pass, and in spite of forms like Z£fjyt, yyiiTo, f£«rjce etc., 1 let us suppose that spondees of the type rJKovcre were especially offensive. Is it not inter- esting that these offensive spondees are relatively much commoner in the 1 The forms are (Iliad, narr.) aliretvd, dfup' airbv, i.p\> iJ/Saiij', ^7«to, fjyov 54, ^vr-qae, r/paro, ijpwa^e, i)us re, tSpvae, ?f«rice, tfoirro, ipiuri, Iptprbv, iirireiov, (tpiaffi), tffravTO, t; 8' (if3av 8' Spa, ISv 8' Spa fuv etc.) after the weak caesura, none of types iirdytj 8', eiroptv 8', Ikiov 8' apa, etc., after the strong. Now look at k 397 and at ir 230. Odd little facts, these. Odd too the chance that type tKektvo-t Sc standing after the heph- themimeral will always scan the other way about — r 259 (tTapows Si K&cvac) A 584, P 596 (Aavaote Si 82, X15? J2 35, 685, 8 817, 829, p456, 567? m 259 ? (cf. A 391). P) * 406, £28. y) A 507, B 240, A 179, © 370 ? N 78 ? 772, S 95, P 173, X 18, a 182, 241, 8 727, 330, t 495, £371, *-223, p 524, t 369 (cf. A 663, 013). 2) uncertain— r 405, 415, E 423, Z 338, 1 118, 519, S 267, 293? *333, O401, a 43, 194, k 43, o 268, 270, ir 66, p 568, t 484 ? x 29. II) unaug. 1) certain —A 445, B 114=1 21, T 367, K (117), 406, N 453, X 252, * 604, O 641, a 36 ? f 172, 1 516, v 303=tt233. (cf. v 181). 2) uncertain— B 82, I 700, K 124, Y 350, * 80, 8 209. The following are ignored— I), 1), a) E 823, Z 126, 2 292, 406, X 236, Q 642, a 235, c 304; I), 1), y) 1,344, A 279, X 104, P 319,