STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 483 OTi TO. a/JM yiyvofntva ov Swarat a/M, i^ayyiXXav. iv o(76pov^ yap wpdia^ ev evl Oavai KoipiS dSwoTov, and this would surely seem to imply, not that Homer lacked die sprachliche Mittel to do it, but that the thing itself was impos- sible. The inadequacy of Homer's powers of expression is not an idea which an ancient critic would be likely to entertain. Paul Shobey Nemesios von Emesa: Quellenforschungen zum Newplatonismus und seinen Anfdngen bei Posidonius. By Werner Wilhelm Jaeger. Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1914. Pp. xi+148. M. 5. Neo-Platonism in one sense began with the first pupil of Plato, who hypostatized the symbolism of the Timaeus, the Parmenides, and the idea of good. In another sense it originated with the teachers of Plotinus. Its "beginnings" at any intermediate stage can be traced only by a Quellen- forschung whose methods and postulates are still open to debate. Such inquiries rest largely upon two tacit assumptions: (1) later Platonists could not, or did not, consult the Platonic texts, but took their quotations always, as modem philologians do sometimes, at second hand; (2) each of them relied mainly on some one secondary source which, in spite of the enormous gaps in the literary record, we can discover by parallels in rhetorical, phil- osophical or Platonic commonplace. They followed their authority slavishly and were rarely capable of any intelligent interpolation or modification. These postulates make wild work in the study of Cicero's, Plutarch's, and Philo's relations to their sources. They are of course much more plausible in the case of a late and less significant writer such as Nemesios. But even here, I think, their systematic and uncompromising apphcation may mislead. Dr. Jaeger begins his investigation with the account of the psychology of avTacria, etc., in Nemesios, pp. 171-73. The text and meaning of Nemesios here are in my opinion quite simple and present no serious problem. He gives first in his own terminology his own Platonizing eclectic view. The mind has three faculties, <^ovraaTiKov, SuavotfriKov, and /ivij/iovcvtikov. This broad use of ^avraa-TtKov for the generalized faculty of sense-perception and imagination is found also at the close of the preceding chapter. It can be traced back to Aristotle's De anima 432A, 31, and appears, I think, in the "Epicurean" psychology of Cassius in Plutarch's Brutus, chap. 37. Modem psychology would ratify it for many purposes. The words ^v- Toaia and avTaa-T6v Nemesios appropriates for a particular imagination and the object corresponding to it. An "empty" affection, without objective correlate, he designates as (jxivTaa-im. All this is commonplace of post- classical philosophic culture colored by Stoicism. But for a further Stoic 484 Book Rkviews refinement Nemesios has no use. The Stoics' love of terminological sym- metry led them sometimes to distinguish, not only the ^avTao-/ua and the avTa(TT6v, but also their supposed subjective correlates. Corresponding to the unreal (^avrao-jmi they assumed an unreal or "inane" mental state or faculty, the ^vtocttikov, a shade of meaning suggested in part by general usage and passages of Plato's Sophist, but taken as a rigid distinction, prac- tically superfluous from the point of view both of science and of linguistic convenience. It is the same faculty of the mind that is excited from within in the case of the tfyavTaafia and from without in the case of the (^ovrao-Tov. In hallucination, as in Aristotelian pure thought, the object and the mental state coincide. Usage may confound the two, or it may objectify the hal- lucination, but does not then really need a second term to designate its subjective aspect. Lucretius' dog waking from dreams pursues inania cenorum simulacra. This naive confusion of subjective and objective works no practical inconvenience. And the appropriation of <^vTaavTaa-T6v, avTadvTa(TiJux. He adds dryly in the tone of Plutarch's and Cicero's criticisms of Stoicism that the difference is only a matter of terminology: 57 8e Bui(ovia tovtois rrtpi Trjv ivaXXayrjV fwvriv yiyove. tSv ovd/tiaTov. This apparently refers to their use of <^vt(uttik6v nearly in the sense of his a.vTadvTaa.vTa(TiM in the subjective sense of the irdOo's, he instinctively felt that £A.Kucr/ios was inappropriate to the objective coloring of the word in ordi- nary and in Stoic usage. At any rate, he does not use it of ^avTaxrim, as Dr. Jaeger's hasty sentence seems to imply that he does. In the attempted solution of the problems he has thus raised. Dr. Jaeger proceeds to quote Chrysippus' definition of ijiavracriia from Diodes of Magnesia in Diogenes Laertius 7. 50-51, SoVrjo-ts Stavoias ola yivtrai Kara Toiis vTTvovi. His comment on this is: "Die Sokt/o-is allein kann man beschreiben als wdOoi Simkcvov ott' oiSevos avTadvTadvTaavTaavTa<7TiKov Si Tov SuxKevov SieXKycr/iov avev avTacTTOv. It is the third, not as in Jaeger's table the first, in a series of four sentences, in every one of which the corresponding word is a noun. It is obviously a noun, as Dr. Jaeger, if I have understood him rightly, admits in the corre- sponding nominative sentence of "Actios," von Arnim, Stoicorum fragmenta, II, p. 22, quoted by Jaeger. Both are developments of the statement Xpwri-Tr- iros 5to<^epav dAA-)fXa)v <^7;tri TcTTapa TaCra; and the other three members of the group are clearly nouns. As I explained in the beginning, the Stoic fondness for terminological symmetry would naturally make a noun of it to balance on the subjective side the objective <^avTatr/xa, and so make finer or more explicit distinctions than the ordinary man requires. There is no basis, then, for the structure of hypothesis which Dr. Jaeger builds on this sentence. It is clearly impossible to give to the entire book the kind of scrutiny I have bestowed on these three obscure and subtle pages. I have read it with interest, though with a growing sense of insecurity as I moved on from conjecture to conjecture up to the final apotheosis of Posidonius as the one transmitter to later antiquity and the Renaissance of the high authentic gospel of poetic and scientific monism latent in Plato's Timaeus. I suspect Dr. Jaeger of overestimating the influence of Posidonius, whom he celebrates with an eloquence that recalls the comment of Strabo on Posidonius' own style: (Twev6ov