STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 479 tion in some cases. While most of the epichoric alphabets are illustrated, eight inscriptions from Thera and a small portion only of the Gortynian law code are given. Delphi has been omitted while nine stones from Tegea have been included. Lemnos is represented by a document which is not certainly known to be Greek. The various classes of inscriptions from Attica are well represented in a series of forty-eight photographs, though unfortunately the retrograde and boustrophedon methods of writing are not included, nor any inscription of the Christian era. Coins have been excluded as in the IG, but pottery has been used to illustrate the alphabets of Megara and Corinth. The Hekatompedon inscription (No. 13) shows very clearly some of the problems of the epigraphist in assembling scattered fragments preparatory to the more difficult task of restoration. Very few scholars would agree with Kern in dating this inscription in the middle of the sixth century. The ravages inflicted by man and time are well seen on Nos. 20 and 26. The cuttings for the door-post in the latter serve to show what must have been the fate of many Greek inscriptions. Kern's excellent book cannot be used as a textbook because of its limited range, nor can it in any sense displace the works of Roehl, Roberts, or Dittenberger. It does serve to supplement these, however, and in the class- room it will undoubtedly be found useful in promoting the students' interest in epigraphical studies. Allan Chester Johnson Princeton University Griechische Epigraphik. Mailers Handbuch der klassischen Alter- tumswissenschaft. By W. Larfeld. Erster Band, 5. Abteil., 3. Aufl. Miinchen: Beck, 1914. The third edition of the section on Greek epigraphy in Miiller's Hand- bucher by Larfeld is an abridgment of the latter' s Handbuch der griechischen Epigraphik which appeared in two volumes in 1902 and 1907. Much of the huge mass of formulae and the detailed plates of letter-forms which com- prised the bulk of Vol. II, published in 1902, have been eliminated in the new edition, which has also been brought abreast of the advance in this department of language in recent years. Larfeld still insists that the typed facsimiles in Inscriptiones Graecae are quite satisfactory as a means of studying the development of the Attic alphabet. One might as well write a dissertation on the characteristics of handwriting based on a study of the type in our daily papers. The student of epigraphy who has no opportunity of seeing the original documents can gain an intimate and accurate knowledge of the development of letter-forms only by a study of squeezes or photographs. Kern's excellent little book will do much in this direction. Better still, Kirchner promises to issue in 480 Book Reviews convenient form photographic reproductions of the documents in the Epi- graphical Museum at Athens. These plates will be the ultimate resource for those of us who cannot study inscriptions from the original texts. Larfeld gives a sketch of the history of Greek epigraphy from the earliest times down to the present day. A comparison of this with the same section in the second edition shows to some extent the great activity in this branch of classical study during the last twenty-two years. Certainly no other field, with the possible exception of papyrology, has been so productive, not only in itself, but also in the closely allied department of history. In the second part Larfeld discusses the material, cost, officials in charge of publication, place of dedication, etc. The question might be raised as to the location of all the documents found on the Acropolis at Athens. The cuttings in the native rock could have accommodated only a tithe of the total number. Most of the decrees show the back of the stone roughly finished, and they must have been placed where only the front could be seen. Possibly many were set up along the walls of the Acropolis. The chapter dealing with the fate of inscriptions is most interesting. In some cases the Athenians destroyed or erased portions of decrees by legislative enactment. The ravages of war by Greeks, Romans, Goths, Slavs, Bulgarians, Normans, Franks, Venetians, and Turks destroyed in turn the ancient monuments and records. Early Christianity was equally culpable with fanatical Mohammedanism in the work of destruction. When the glory of Greece was in eclipse and forgotten, the peasant found that the Attic decrees were very convenient for doorsteps or pavement blocks, or, if mortar were needed, the state archives yielded excellent material for the lime-kiln. Even at the present day not a few inscriptions are broken into pieces by the peasant who, in his ignorance, believes that the mystic letters indicate treasure hidden within. On the other hand, the fact that these stones make good building material has been the means of saving hundreds of documents which might otherwise have perished. Many are still imbed- ded in the walls of the Acropolis and dwellings of Athens. In 1911 ten were found in a small foundation wall near the Propylaea. The history of some of the documents cannot be charged as uninteresting. A fragment of the Erechtheum building-inscription was used to fortify Athens in the Greek struggle for independence. The fragment has long since disappeared from view but the impression in the mortar remains and is legible. Another fragment was found by the English traveler, Chandler, and purchased from the owner. In order to make the stone more portable, he intrusted it to a stonecutter to chip away the back, which was still covered with cement. Mr. Dinsmoor has recently discovered that the stone was opistho- graphic, and that the distinguished traveler was thus guilty of unconscious vandalism. The secretary-cycle is not mentioned as a means of dating Attic inscrip- tions, though Larfeld is apparently aware of Ferguson's researches. Whatever Book Reviews 481 may be the differences between the cycles constructed by Ferguson or his critics, all are fully agreed upon the existence of some form of tribal rotation in the third and second centuries. Secondly, in his directions for publishing a newly discovered text Larfeld fails to mention the best and most accurate way of reproducing the inscription, namely, by photography. A full account of the alphabets is given in the third section with a good resume of all the theories concerning origins and variations. While dis- carding the Greek tradition that Boeotia was the original home of the alpha- bet on Greek soil, Larfeld believes that the Phoenician letters were first adopted at Delphi about the tenth century and thence spread over Greece so rapidly that the complete form was not developed, but that additions were made in each separate locality. This presupposes that Delphi was an important trade and literary center as early as the Trojan War. The evidence does not bear out such a theory. The traditional account is as satisfactory as the one which Larfeld seeks to establish. If the Delphian priesthood had first adopted the Phoenician symbols they would have taken care that the tradition would be established giving the credit to Apollo. It is much more likely that Phoenician colonists adapted their native char- acters to the language of the subject people, which in turn imposed itself on the conquerors. The rapid spread of the new idea is more likely due to merchantmen than to the work of the priesthood. Various districts have different characters for certain sounds, usually non-Phoenician. In these cases the symbols were not transmitted by Greeks who were familiar with the sounds, but more likely by foreign traders. If the Phoenician merchants divided their Greek territory into spheres of influence in commercial rela- tions we can readily understand how errors in transmission might have remained uncorrected in particular districts. No single theory, however, can explain all the divergences, some of which must have developed between the tenth and eighth centuries, when the art of writing seems to have been confined to a few who, writing on parchment, gradually developed certain characteristics in separate localities just as different styles of writing devel- oped in the different monasteries of Europe. More than a third of the book was taken up with formulas of Greek inscriptions. Here Larfeld's adaptation of his previous work is not only useless but senseless . To the general reader the formulas are without interest ; to the specialist the abridgment is valueless for he must always consult the larger work to which Larfeld himself constantly refers the reader. There are also many meaningless abbreviations, the key to which can be found only in the main collection. It would have been better if this entire section had been omitted. The usefulness of the book would not have been diminished and the cost would have been materially reduced. Apart from this defect Professor Larfeld has carried out the abridgment of his larger work most satisfactorily. Allan Chester Johnson Princeton Univeksity