STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Notes and Discussions 457 THE ARCHON PHILOCRATES Philodemus relates that the philosopher Polemo died in the archonship of Philocrates. 1 The entry "Polemo filosofus moritur post quern Archesilas et Crates clari habentur" is found in Eusebius under ol. 126, 3 or 126, 4; in Hieronymus in M under 127, 2; in APF, under 127, 3; in R, under 127,4; in the remainder of the manuscripts, under 128, l. 2 If we combine these two sources we may date the archon Philocrates in 274/3, 273/2, 271/0, 270/69, 269/8, or 268/7 B.C. We cannot allow Polemo so much latitude in the choice of the year of his death, but it is a difficult matter to decide which, if any, of these dates is correct. So little confidence has been put in the chronicles of Eusebius-Hieronymus in matters of chronology that their statements have not been accepted as evidence unless confirmed by other sources. For example, the death of Zeno in all the manuscripts of Hieronymus is placed in 264/3, though it is now established that he died in 262/1 . 3 In the Armenian version of Eusebius the discrepancy is even greater, for this item is recorded under 270/69 or 269/8 B.C. Some of the manu- scripts agree in placing the death of Polemo and Zeno four years apart, 4 and if they are correct in the relative position of these events, we may establish the year 266/5 as another possibility for the death of Polemo. Such a method of reasoning must not be accepted unless it can be proved that all the items in this period vary in the same proportion. Unfortunately the history of the reign of Antigonus Gonatas still offers many chronological problems and very few of the items recorded in Eusebius for that reign can be checked. We shall have to find other evidence to help us determine the correct date of the death of Polemo. The date of Philocrates may also be determined by means of the secre- tary-cycle, for inscriptions are preserved which show that the secretary in his archonship came from Demetrias or the second tribe in the official order. 5 Unfortunately the cycles for the first half of the third century are almost as numerous as the manuscripts of Hieronymus and vary quite as much, or perhaps we should say, they are equally corrupt — so much so that 1 Acad. Phil. Ind., col. Q 4 ff., Mekler, p. 58. 2 Jacoby, Apollodors Chronik, 343. 3 On the date of Arrheneides in whose archonship Zeno died see Kolbe, Abhand- lungen der konigl. Gesellsch. der Wiss. zu. Gbttingen, Band X, No. 4, p. 40 ; Kirchner, BPW (1909), 844 ff.; Mayer, Philologus, LXXI, 226 ff.; cf. AJP (1913), 381 ff. Ferguson followed by Tarn (Antigonos Gonatas, 306) dates Arrheneides in 262/1 (Priests of Asklepios, 154). 4 In Eusebius, NZ; in Hieronymus, all but MAPFR (Jacoby, op. cit.). The arrangement of the items in the edition of Eusebius by Schoene led me to make the incorrect statement in CP (1914), 262, that the death of Zeno was ascribed to 266/5 B.C. The statements concerning the evidence for the date of Philocrates should be corrected and brought into conformity with that given in the text above. s IG. ii. 2 684, 685. 458 Notes and Discussions scholars have as yet given unqualified approval to no one of them. Fergu- son, Beloch, Kolbe, Pomtow, Tarn, and myself have constructed different cycles. In dating Philocrates, Ferguson, Kirchner, and Tarn follow one group of the manuscripts of Hieronymus, 1 Kolbe and Pomtow another, 2 choosing always the date which suits their arrangement of the cycle. Beloch could not make his theory fit any manuscript tradition and so had the courage to disregard it. 3 I have been guilty of doing the same thing, though there is some warrant for dating Philocrates in 266/5 B.C. if we consider the relative dates of the deaths of Zeno and Polemo as recorded in the majority of the manuscripts. 4 A new combination of two Attic inscrip- tions (IG. ii. 2 684 and 7526) gives welcome confirmation of this theory. 5 Unfortunately the two stones are so badly broken that the body of the decree is almost completely lost. We learn, however, that ambassadors came to Athens from Tenedos in the archonship of Philocrates and they were praised by public decree. Now Tenedos, as all the Aegean Islands, was under the jurisdiction of Ptolemy in 268 B.C., and Athens was subject to Antigonus. 6 An official embassy from Tenedos could not be welcomed in Athens without giving mortal offense to Antigonus, and in 268 Athens was not prepared to do that. The decree must therefore belong to some period when Athens was independent of Macedon and friendly to Ptolemy. In other words, we must date the archon Philocrates at some time after the outbreak of the Chremonidean War or between 267 and 262 b.c. 7 A closer approximation may be obtained from the evidence of IG. ii. 2 685. In this decree the taxiarchs received the official thanks of the state. We must conclude from this that Athens was at war, and since she could praise her captains the campaign for that year could not have been wholly unsuccessful. This can only be said of the first year of the Chremonidean War when Athens was supported by Egypt and her other allies, and the offensive campaign of Antigonus was temporarily paralyzed by the revolt of his Gallic merce- naries at Megara. 8 The mutineers were finally cut to pieces by the Mace- donian troops, but the campaign for that year was ended. Next year the Spartans suffered a crushing defeat at Corinth and their king Areus was killed. 9 The Peloponnesian allies gave no further support to Athens, and since Egypt had 'already withdrawn her fleet she was left to carry on the unequal contest alone. In the remaining years of the war Athens was 1 Ferguson, "Priests of Asklepios," University of California Publications, I, No. 5; Kirchner, Ins. Or. II and III, ed. min. Tarn. op. cit., 415 ff. 2 Klio (1914), 267-69. Apparently Kolbe has abandoned his original position where he dated Philocrates in 268/7 b.c. See note 3, p. 457. = Gr. Oesch., Ill, 2, 32-61. • Tarn, op. cit., 105, 106, 290. * CP (1914), 248 ff. ' CP (1914), 276. « Wilhelm, AM, XXXIX, 315. » Justin, xxvi. 2. ' Trogus, xxvi. The date of Areus' death (Diodorus xx. 29) is determined by Eduard Meyer by inclusive reckoning and placed in 266/5 B.C. {Forschungen, II, 510). Notes and Discussions 459 practically in a state of siege, and had no occasion to honor her commanders for their success in the field. Only the priests who performed sacrifices for safety now received the praise of the state. 1 Philocrates must therefore be dated within the period of the Chremoni- dean War and preferably in the first year's campaign. The evidence of Hieronymus and the inscriptions support the date 266/5 B.C., and if our secretary-cycle places Philocrates in that year, it is reasonable to suppose that both cycle and date are correct. Any cycle which places Philocrates before the alliance of Athens and Ptolemy, or before the beginning of the Chremonidean War must now be rejected as impossible. Allan Chestee Johnson Princeton, N.J. » IG. II. 2 670, 674, 676, 689.