STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. CICERO AND BITHYNICUS By Elmer Truesdell Merrill In the collection of Cicero's miscellaneous correspondence (Ad Familiar es) stand in immediate conjunction two undated letters (vi. 16, 17) of which the former is addressed simply Bithynicus Ciceroni S., and the latter Cicero Bithynico S. The somewhat formal tone of the letter from Bithynicus suggests that perhaps the address is not preserved in its original shape; but this point is not of value for the present discussion. In Fam. xvi. 23. 1 Cicero remarks to Tiro, ad Bithynicum scripsi, but as an isolated sentence, and without anything in the context to suggest the theme of his letter. These three are the only places in the entire body of Cicero's corre- spondence where the name Bithynicus is to be found. The placing of the two letters vi. 16 and 17 in this order suggests, in the absence of any other extant correspondence between the two men, that the ancient editor of Cicero's epistles in the form in which we now have them took the second to be an answer to the first, and that has been the judgment also of recent scholars in con- siderable numbers, including such men as Professors Tyrrell and Purser and O. E. Schmidt. The collocation of the two Bithynicus letters immediately after the brief letter to Basilus (vi. 15), which I have discussed already in this journal (Class. Phil., VIII, 48 ff.), further suggests that the ancient editor may have believed the Bithynicus concerned to be the man of that name probably nomi- nated by Julius Caesar before his death to be governor of Sicily in 44 B.C., and the (undated) letters to have been written by and to Bithynicus in that province not long after the fatal Ides of March, to which day the editor doubtless referred the Basilus letter. This also has been a common opinion in recent times, though some critics have hesitated to make any definite affirmation about the date, even when they were certain that the second letter was in answer to the first. Two men called Bithynicus are the only persons of that surname known to us who may or must have been known to Cicero. One of [Classical Philology X, October, 1915] 432 Cicero and Bithynicus 433 these is mentioned by Cicero himself (Brut. 240) as a somewhat older friend of his student days. His full name is given by Cicero as Q. Pompeius A.f., qui Bithynicus dictus est. The cognomen, which Cicero's phrase would imply was a new one, he appears to have acquired by services in connection with the organization of the province of Bithynia in 75 B.C. 1 He took the side of Pompey in the civil war, fled with him to Egypt, and was there killed in the year 48. 2 That is practically all that is known about him. Of the second Bithynicus even less is told. In 43-42 a Pompeius Bithynicus was governor of Sicily, where he was put to death by Sextus Pompey. 3 It is justifiably enough assumed that he was the son of the other Pompeius Bithynicus, dead six years earlier. It is less surely, but with some degree of plausibility, assumed that his governorship began in 44 by the ante mortem appointment of Caesar and that accordingly he was in Sicily either from some little time before Caesar's death, or, at any rate, from a time shortly thereafter. This, to be sure, corresponds with a longer term of office than the single year then allowed by law for praetorian provinces; but (1) no other incumbent or claimant of the post for the year 44 is known, (2) the selection of provincial governors for 43 (M. Cusinius for Sicily) presided over by Antony was a month later (December, 44) declared null and void by the senate and the present incumbents ordered to remain in command; and therefore, as Bithynicus was at least locum tenens at the end of 43 and the beginning of 42, it is but reasonable to suppose him a hold-over appointee of Caesar for 44 (cf. W. Sternkopf in Hermes, XLVII, 328). Even this is much grist for little meal. The circumstances are favorable to the view that Cicero might have had correspondence with either of these two men. For further determinations we must turn to the letters themselves. Bithynicus in addressing Cicero claims an interest in his friendship based upon Cicero's intimacy with his father. Of his own previous relations to Cicero he speaks with an indefiniteness that appears to be the expression of modest politeness. All this does not seem natural 1 Liv. Per. xciii; Eutrop. vi. 6; Fest. 320 L. s. u. rutrum ten. iun. 'Otos. vi. 15. 28. » Dio xlviii. 17. 4; 19. 1; App. iv. 84; v. 70; Liv. Per. cxxiii. 434 Elmer Truesdell Merrill if addressed to a somewhat younger former schoolmate. But it is perfectly proper from a younger man to his father's old friend. Surely no one reading the two letters independently, the one of the other, and without prejudice, could fail to perceive that the tone of the first is that of a junior recommending himself to a senior, that of the second, of a senior meeting with reminiscent kindness the advances of a junior. Thus the elder of the two Bithynici appears to be eliminated. It is the younger who writes to Cicero, and is answered by him. But in spite of the view generally taken (and taken, I suspect, by the ancient editor), Cicero's letter is very evidently not an answer to the extant letter from Bithynicus. Suppose we had preserved to us only the letter of Cicero : what could we reasonably infer from it concerning the utterances of the letter from Bithynicus to which it is evidently a reply ? Bithynicus must have expressed sorrow over the unsettled political conditions of the time, and hope that they might speedily be happily adjusted, so that when he was able to return to Rome he might cultivate more fully those relations of inti- mate friendship with Cicero which he had to some extent previously enjoyed. And as to the circumstances of the letter, Cicero recog- nizes that the political friends of Bithynicus, and not his own, are in power, and from them Bithynicus may confidently look for favors, while Cicero himself can only assure him of the continuance of his warm personal regard, for his father's sake and his own. At one point we might be sure that Cicero is quoting the actual words of his cor- respondent, promissum tuum, quo in litteris uteris; scribis enim, si ita sit, te mecum esse uicturum. It is not certain, on the other hand, that Bithynicus made reference to his father's friendship with Cicero. That remark may as naturally have originated with Cicero himself. Now when we turn to the extant letter of Bithynicus, it is evident at first sight that it in no way corresponds in sentiment to the outline reconstructed above, except that the writer refers to his father's friendship with Cicero. That is actually the only point of apparent connection between the two epistles textually before us (for me tueare of the first letter can have no possible reference to a state of things when the friends of Bithynicus, as the second letter indicates, are in power). I have no doubt that this point alone prompted the Cicero and Bithynicus 435 thought that Cicero's single letter to Bithynicus must have been an answer to the single letter from him. But notice especially that there is nothing at all in the actual phrases of Bithynicus pointing to the phrase quoted verbally by Cicero from him (scribis enim, si ita sit [that is, if political troubles should subside], te mecum esse uicturum). Cicero's letter clearly indicates that this was the main point in the missive that he was answering. For it the letter of Bithynicus must have been written. But his extant letter makes no such proffer of desire for more perfect intimacy: it merely refers modestly to the friendship for Cicero of the writer and his father as the basis for asking Cicero ut absentem me, quibuscumque in rebus opus fuerit, tueare. That is evidently the purpose for which this letter was written. It appears by its tone and manner of expression to be addressed to a person who had not been previously a correspondent and was not even on terms of active present friendship with the writer. But the second letter assumes a certain familiarity already established, which Bithynicus could, with the proper deference to an older and more distinguished man, express a desire to increase (cf. inter alia Cicero in answer to Fadius Gallus — Fam. vii. 23. 4: est mihi gratissimum . . . . ut earn domum sumeres, ut non modo prope me, sed plane mecum habitare posses; and of the Stoic Diodotus — Brut. 309: qui cum habitauisset apud me mecumque uixisset, nuper est domi meae mortuus). Again, at the time the first letter is written, Cicero may be regarded as having influence with the powers that be : at the date of the second letter he has none at all, but the friends of Bithynicus, who are not his, are in the saddle. There is accordingly no good reason for connecting the two letters intimately, but on the contrary quite unsurmountable obstacles in the way of that disposition of them. They must be considered as quite distinct in time and setting. To what period, then, are we to assign each ? The letter of Bithynicus appears to have been written when he had no standing of especial intimacy with Cicero, but would commend himself to his kind consideration. What the officia were which Bithynicus pleads as a basis for claiming (though he does it with great deference) the exercise of Cicero's friendship in the future, we cannot tell. Outside of these two letters and the three words in 436 Elmer Tetjesdell Meekill Fam. xvi. 23. 1 nothing is known concerning the relations between Cicero and the younger Bithynicus. The tone of the letter suggests that their friendship must earlier have been of the slightest, and there had been a considerable period of cessation of all intercourse, so that Bithynicus appears to feel that he almost needs to introduce himself to Cicero's memory. The elder Bithynicus, Cicero's boy- hood friend, had accompanied Pompey on his disastrous Thessalian campaign, and it is quite reasonable to guess that the officio, now recalled to Cicero's mind may have been performed when Cicero was in Pompey's camp at Dyrrachium. The younger Bithynicus would certainly be of military age, his father, on Cicero's estimate, being about sixty years old in 48, and the son competent to hold a praetorian province in 44. I imagine that the letter was written after the father's tragic death, and some considerable time afterward, when Caesar had returned to Italy, Cicero had concluded those long months of anxious waiting at Brundisium and was established at home in a dignified and not unhonored retirement, and the younger Bithynicus, who had prolonged the conflict against Caesar, was lingering outside of Italy, but ready and desirous to return and take up the thread of life under the new ruler. I am therefore inclined to think that his words ut absentem me, quibuscumque in rebus opus fuerit, tueare have a more specific meaning here than they would elsewhere necessarily carry. Bithynicus may very well have in mind the possibility of securing from his father's friend, with whom he had held no communication since they parted at Dyr- rachium two years before, an effective word in his behalf with Caesar, who had shown himself considerate and generous toward Cicero. The letter of Bithynicus might with considerable probability be assigned to the second half of the year 46, when Caesar was back in Rome between the African and Spanish campaigns, and was setting on foot the new administration, besides pardoning his former enemies right and left. That the younger Bithynicus, who I assume had been a Pompeian like his father, appears in 44 as Caesar's nominee for the governorship of Sicily, and so had presumably been praetor in 45, or perhaps several years earlier, is of course not surprising. Some other Pompeians fared as well from Caesar's magnanimity. At any rate Bithynicus did not murder his benefactor. Cicero and Bithtnicus 437 The circumstances of Cicero's letter to Bithynicus are, as I have pointed out above, distinctly different. The state is in a parlous condition, being in the hands of people who are ambitiously exploit- ing it for their own advantage. They are the political friends of Bithynicus, and hence Cicero speaks with some reserve about the condition of things, but intimates his own powerlessness. This fits only the period after Antony had succeeded in establishing himself at the helm of affairs, and Cicero, following the lead of his friends, M. Brutus and Cassius, had, at least for the time, given up the une- qual struggle. I am inclined to assign the letter to the end of May or the month of June in the year 44. And I further think it quite likely, though it is by no means certain, that the remark ad Bithyn- icum scripsi in Fam. xvi. 23. 1 refers to this particular letter. The letter itself sounds as if Cicero and Bithynicus had not recently been in active correspondence, and that, if a fact, would readily explain why Cicero in a letter to Tiro interpolates a brief remark that he has answered the (no longer extant) letter just received from the governor of Sicily. I would attempt to date Cicero's answer to Bithynicus more precisely, but that would involve, according to my view, the necessity of discussing the controverted date of the letter to Tiro mentioned above, and upon that question I am disinclined to enter at the present moment. Univeesitt of Chicago November, 1914