STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. REPRESENTATIVE GOVERNMENT IN THE MACEDONIAN REPUBLICS By Tbnney Frank We are told 1 that the Romans after deposing Perseus, in 167 B.C., "liberated" the Macedonians, divided the territory into four repub- lics, devised charters for the cities and a definite constitution for the states, laid down certain general regulations concerning revenues, armament, and coinage, and then withdrew. In general we know that the national constitution of the four states provided for an executive of each to be elected annually, that the power to elect these magistrates was vested in primary assemblies which gathered at the respective capitals, and that there was a senate to which very impor- tant, if not all, legislative functions were given. The literary evidence bearing most directly upon the three depart- ments of government can be briefly stated. 1. The magistrates. — Livyxlv. 29: " annuos creantes magistratus . . . . ibi magistratus creari iussit;" Diod. xxxi. 8. 9: h> raiirais apxyyoi r&raapes [i.e., one for each state] Ka.rmrbBi\ao.v 2. The senate or synedrion. — Polybius xxxi. 12. 12: SrjiiOKpariKrjs Kal e8p(.aicrjs irokireias; Livy xlv. 18: "commune consilium 2 gentis esset ne improbum 3 vulgus .... libertatem .... ad licentiam traheret" (explained by the phrase "ut suum quaeque consilium 4 haberet"); Livy xlv. 32: (from Polybius) "senatores quos synedros vocant legendos esse quorum consilio res publica administraretur . ' ' 1 See Livy xlv. 18, 29, 32; Diod. xxxi. 8. 9; Niese, Griech. und Maked. Slaaten, III, 180 ff.; Colin, Rome et la Grece, 438 ff. 2 The MS reading is concilium, but the correctness of the regularly adopted reading is not doubted since the context demands it and Polybius' word a-vveSpiaiajs (xxxi. 12) supports it. The MSS constantly confuse concilium and consilium: see Thes. L. L., s.v. "concilium," col. 45, 1. 14. 3 The MSS read esset improbum vulgi. The end of the sentence proves that this emendation (of Sigonius) is substantially correct. 4 The MS V reads consilium correctly, other MSS concilium. The context leaves no doubt that V is correct. [Classical Philology IX, January, 1914] 49 50 Tenney Frank 3. The popular assembly. — Livy xlv. 29: "capita regionum ubi concilia 1 fierent." The passages which refer to the executives and to the elective assembly are clear enough and need not detain us. Our interest centers in the synedrion or senate, for in its constitution and powers lies the peculiar character of this government. The evidence does not amount to proof but it points with a high degree of probability to the conclusion (a) that the senate was a representative body, 2 (6) that it was the real legislative body of the state, and (c) that its ordinances, being the ordinances of a territorial state, resembled in their binding force the laws of modern states. If this be true, the Macedonian state had a republican form of government which was not very different from that of more advanced republics of today. Our first question is whether the new Macedonian senate can rightly be called a representative body. Of this there can be little doubt. Although the Greeks never, so far as we know, intrusted sovereign power to a representative body, the principle of representa- tion was well known and widely practiced in certain religious and political bodies. In fact, the most obvious method of forming synedria in the numerous leagues and religious unions of Greece was to require each participating state to delegate some degree of power to one or more deputies who might speak for the state at large. This was surely the practice in the Amphictyonic league, the famous Delian league, and the league of the islands, whose representatives were empowered to pass certain ordinances which were intended to be binding upon the members of each league. It does not derogate from the principle as such that these unions had but little real power or significance. Many of the political leagues also delegated power of representation to deputies. We are still in doubt whether the i The reading concilia is proved correct by the words that follow: ibi magistratus creari iussit. 2 The proposal to give each Latin municipality a representation of two members in the senate at Rome (Livy xxiii. 22) was made during the Punic War. The constitution which the seceding Italians established at Corfinium in 90 B.C. seems also to have been representative with a unicameral legislature remarkably like that which Paullus created for the Macedonian republics. In this I follow Diodorus (xxxvii. 2) in preference to Strabo (v. 241), since Diodorus here seems to be following the careful historian Posi- donius (see Schwartz, s.v. "Diodorus" in Pauly-Wissowa). Repeesentative Government in Macedonian Republics 51 synod of the Achaean league was a primary assembly. 1 I am in- clined to think that it was, in spite of the contention of Dubois, Lipsius, Beloch, and Swoboda, who believe it a representative body. However, the evidence is more clearly in favor of regarding the old Boeotian, 2 the Aetolian, and the Lycian synechia as representative bodies, and most authorities would be inclined to add to this list the senates of the Thessalian, Locrian, Acarnanian, and Magnesian leagues. Now, when Paullus shaped the governments of Macedonia he could hardly draw upon Roman ideas for the form of a national senate, since in Macedonia a number of cities had to be equably represented, and Rome had devised no method of government in Italy which did not contemplate the supremacy of the metropolis. Obviously the system of representation in vogue in many of the Greek leagues would better serve the needs of such a state. We may feel sure, furthermore, that if the synod of the Achaean league was actually a primary assembly consisting of such citizens as chose to attend, Paullus, and any other Roman, would have rejected that form in favor of one in which strict order and more clearly defined responsibility prevailed. How the deputies of the Macedonian states were actually chosen we do not know, nor is this an essential point. The deputies who attended the meetings of the Amphictyonic league were not all appointed in the same way. For example, the hieromnemone^ from Athens were assigned by lot while the pylagorae were elected by show of hands. The deputies from Aetolia were doubtless elected by acclamation in the general assembly, whereas those from the Macedonian monarchy must have been selected personally by the Macedonian king. And yet all of these deputies were representatives of their various states. The new historical fragment, usually attri- buted to Theopompus, makes it seem likely that the members of the 1 Dubois, Les ligues Stolienne et acMenne, 124; Lipsius, Verhandl. d. s&chs. Gesell. d. Wiss. (1898); Beloch, Griech. Gesch., Ill, 2, 183; Swoboda, Klio (1911), 458. However, I think Francotte, Mus4e Beige (1906), 5, is nearer the truth in considering the body a primary assembly. 2 See Bonner, "The Boeotian Federal Constitution," Class. Phil. (1910), 405 ff., Swoboda, Klio (1910), 319 ff., and Sokoloff, Klio, VII, 67. 3 See Demosthenes xviii. 144; Arist. Clouds 623, and Cauer, s.v. "Amphiktyones," Pauly-Wissowa, I, 1923. Trajan ordered the selection of a municipal boule by popular election (Dio Chrys. ii. 74, ed. von Arnim), but this was probably unusual. 52 Tenney Frank Boeotian senate of the fourth century were drawn by lot from among the principal senates of the various cities. 1 Just what method Paullus prescribed for the new Macedonian republics we do not know. It does not seem probable that the members were chosen by lot; for that method little accords with Roman practice and was discouraged even at Athens when the Romans became influential there. 8 Neither is there any reason to think that Paullus would have introduced such un-Greek methods as selection by censors or by co-optation. If we may hazard a conjecture from a weighing of probabilities we should suggest as most likely that the municipal senates of each district were required to select a given number subject to certain qualifications regarding age, occupation, and wealth. It is entirely likely, then, that the Macedonian senate was a representative body. A far more important question is whether this body was the real legislative department of the state; otherwise the new constitution would have differed little from that of a large number of already existing Greek leagues. In the ordinary league it was the primary assembly of the populace which had the power of deciding all important questions of war, peace, and membership. The synedrion was usually a counseling body only, which shaped the ordinances and recommended them to the populace. But if one examines the three passages we have quoted above regarding the nature and purpose of the new Macedonian senate one discovers at once that this body was devised for a more important task than merely to give advice. The phrase of Polybius, SrjuoKpaTinrjs nal (TweSpKwcrJs, is unfortunately rather noncommittal, but it tells some- thing. When one remembers that Polybius calls the Achaean con- stitution out and out democratic, 3 his addition of o-weSpta/afc with reference to Macedonia becomes significant. Apparently the principle of popular government did not hold in Macedonia in the same way as in the Achaean league. Polybius' phrase implies that the new senate had real governmental powers, and the natural iSwoboda, KKo (1910), 322. 2 Kohler, CIA, II, 481; cf. Ferguson, KKo, IV, 1-17. 3 Polybius ii. 38: iea96\ov Sr)iioKparlas dXrjSivijs ai