STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 97 Augustus, not, as has been believed, between 68 and 71-72 a.d. The epistrategoi were purely civil officials — equestrian procurators in fact — the military power being once more concentrated in Alexandria, where the prefect resided. Their relation to the strategoi, or chief nome officials, M. Martin discusses carefully. The former were primarily inspectors, without native authority either to collect taxes or to settle disputes. They simply received protests against the exactions of the fiscal agents and the judgments of the competent magistrates. They could render judicial decisions only when deputed to do so for and by the prefect. Their positive functions, apart from the allotting of those liable for the village liturgies— & duty which they lost in the third century a.d. — were trifling in character. The Greek cities in Egypt were not under their direct control, as has been surmised, but were under the nome authorities, like the Egyptian villages. For the support of the epistrategoi the yield of certain imposts was set aside — «rc- Keifitva imo-Tparriyui.. That they received and did not levy these taxes, is shown by M. Martin in one of the most detailed arguments in his careful, well-ordered, and promising thesis. William Scott Ferguson Roman History and Mythology. Edited by Henry A. Sanders. New York: Macmillan, 1910. Pp. 427. In this attractive book we have Vol. IV of the University of Michigan Studies, Humanistic Series. It is issued under the generous patronage of a score of friends of the University of Michigan and contains four Doctors' dissertations by graduate students who successfully pursued their work under the supervision of the general editor. They are: I. "Studies in the Life of Heliogabalus," by Orma Fitch Butler. II. "The Myth of Hercules at Rome," by John Garrett Winter. III. "Roman Law Studies in Livy," by Alvin E. Evans. IV. "Reminiscences of Ennius in Silius Italicus," by Laura Bayne Woodruff. I. The first of the four is far the largest (pp. 169). It is a minutely detailed study of the life of Heliogabalus, or rather of the biographies of that emperor. The writer follows the method of Heer in Der historische Wert der Vita Commodi in the Sammlung der Scriptores Historiae Augustae. So likewise she has gone into an elaborate critical study of the records in the Vita, Victor, and Eutropius. Her purpose is to solve, if possible, (1) the question of the identity of the sources for the different lives, and (2) the problem of the reliability of the manuscripts in attributing the lives to one and the same author — namely, Lampridius. The dissertation develops, accordingly, into a twofold work: (1) a biography of Heliogabalus drawn from all sources other than the Vita; and (2) a critical study of the Vita itself, with a view to determining the 98 Book Reviews historical worth of the component elements. This naturally, and perhaps unavoidably, leads to much repetition. The conclusion confirms not only a plurality of sources but also a plurality of authors for the Vita. The different authors have recklessly used various sources with naturally result- ing inconsistencies and contradictions. These Miss Butler has carefully sifted. Numerous misprints and even errors of English mar the otherwise fine appearance of this part of the volume: e.g., Had-rian (p. 31); Studnizka, followed by Cumont, think (p. 81); different than (p. 140); beside for besides (passim; notably p. 119). II. In the second thesis Dr. Winter presents a discussion of peculiar interest to the student of Roman mythology and religion. There were in Rome two groups of Hercules sanctuaries, that of the Tiburtine Hercules in the Circus Maximus and that of the Greek Heracles in the Circus Flaminius, though the latter never acquired any deep religious significance. To clear up the confusion of Greek and native elements in Roman mythology is always an interesting and attractive task. The mythological study becomes also a source study. Winter's aim is "to determine the sources and the relation of the various parts of the myth to one another and to determine, if possible, the earliest form and content of the literary form of the myth at Rome." The evidence of Heraclides, Agathocles, Diodorus Siculus, Gellius, Varro, and others, together with the versions given by Strabo, Festus, and Solinus, is carefully weighed; from these we are led back to Timaeus and the older annalists; Livy gives the story of Hercules-Cacus to explain the institution of the Ara Maxima, and his picturesque version is traced back to Tubero, one of the later Roman annalists; while the accounts of Hercules and Cacus in the Roman poets seem to be inspired by Hesiod's giganto- machia. Dr. Winter holds that Heracles, and so by implication Hercules, was a purely Greek god. Certain elements in his worship, as the offering of tithes to him at the Ara Maxima, may have come through Semitic influences. The worship of this Greek god Heracles was brought to Rome by way of Cumae, though this cannot have been the only route by which he came. Etruria, as well as the Greek cities of southern Italy, performed an important part in his Italian adoption; and this happened at an early date, for Heracles is a perfectly familiar figure in Etruscan art in the sixth century B.C., when commerce between Greece and Etruria achieved importance. The myth of Cacus as a belligerent shepherd must for a long time have existed wholly apart from that of Hercules. Cacus became associated with Heracles in the third century, as may be inferred from Diodorus ( = Timaeus) . His appearance in the r61e of a robber-giant was familiar to the annalists of the next century. But there is no evidence that the complete blending of the two antedates Vergil himself. The Hercules-Cacus story is but little Book Reviews 99 more than a remodeling of the Geryon and Typhoeus myths familiar to Vergil in the Greek poets. III. Dr. Evans in his "Roman Law Studies in Livy" has rendered a distinct service in the investigation of early Roman law as handed down to us in one of our chief est sources of knowledge of that subject. It is his purpose to show that it was not private but public law that interested Livy. Private law concerned him only as it was involved in political history. Dr. Evans has with patient care collected and classified all the passages in his author that have any direct or indirect legal bearing. His work falls into a discussion of three topics: (1) ius; (2) precedent and custom; (3) criminal procedure. Ius, he finds, denotes "a power of control of a person over an object" (or person) — (o) right, authority, law, justice; (6) right, authority, law, court, government. Ius gentium and ius belli include what we term international law. Cicero may look upon the ius gentium as a "philosophi- cal ideal"— law of nature, held sacred by all nations in common; but in Livy the ius gentium embodies much of general international law, even as the ius fetiale covers specifically that part of international law which has to do with the diplomatic service. The careful distinction is made between ius, fas, lex — human law, divine law, civil statute. Mos and exemplum, custom and precedent, as in our modern systems of legal procedure, give rise to various kinds of ius, both statutory and consti- tutional. Many passages from Livy are cited showing how strong was the influence of precedent upon the Roman legal mind. Custom becomes crystallized into ius. This dissertation is everywhere excellent; but the chapter devoted to criminal procedure is particularly strong. We are surprised by the mass of material brought together from Livy touching Roman criminal law at almost every stage of its historical development in the Roman courts. Mr. Evans gives full citations from his author, clearing up many vexed questions of procedure as to (1) the trial comitia, (2) the amending of an original indictment, (3) the nature of a trial as to charge, (4) the penalty, death or fine, (5) the frequent avoidance of trial by suicide or voluntary exile, (6) nolle pros, proceedings, (7) procedure against non-Romans, against women and slaves. "There developed in Rome," as he proves, "two jurisdictions for criminal prosecutions. The one was a public prosecution by the people under the leadership of the tribunes. The preliminary steps of pronouncing a penalty and of appeal to the people were probably lost, as far as actual practice was concerned, and cases came directly before the assembly. The other jurisdiction was the quaestio extraordinaria." It was one of the two weapons that the nobilitas used to offset the power of the commons. This quaestio was regularly decreed by the senate, and the senatus consultum ultimum was a direct descendant of it. Mr. Evans did excellent proofreading amid many difficulties; but toward the end he seems to have grown weary, and errors abound: e.g., 100 Book Reviews anniiellment (p. 341), Amstbewerbung (p. 342), Perhaebia (p. 348), Fluvius (p. 350). We welcome his work as a distinct contribution to historical study — of value both to the student of Roman history and to the student of ancient law. IV. The last of the four dissertations is literary in character. Miss Woodruff has industriously gathered together from the Punica of Silius Italicus every possible passage or phrase that may seem to have any possible similarity in sound or sense to anything in the extant fragments of Ennius or to anything in Vergil or Livy that may possibly hark back to the great annalist. She realizes that she is on slippery ground and she proceeds with great care; for how much of occasional resemblances in diction or even in imagery may be due to direct influence of one author upon another is a question on which the fewest critics can ever agree, especially when our acquaintance with one of those authors is so very fragmentary. But when we consider the potent influence of Ennius upon all subsequent Latin writers and recall the notorious lack of originality on the part of Silius writing upon the same subject as Ennius, we realize at once the difficulty of Miss Woodruff's task and the skill with which she meets it. And yet, when all is done, there can be little that is satisfying in her work. Her results are at best problem- atical or negative, as she herself says at the end: "That any one source can be found for any particular portion of the Punica is, I think, impossible. Everything seems to be the result of a combination and blending of many elements taken from many different sources. Not to Ennius or to Livy alone was Silius indebted, but to these authors combined with numerous others. Thus brief phrases and general pictures, as well as those larger conceptions that underlie the structure of the poem as a whole, are traceable now to one predecessor, now to another, and all are so interwoven and confused as to render a separation impossible." Non liquet. Walter Miller University op Missouri De Veterum Imprimis Romanorum Studiis Etymologicis, scripsit Feed. Mulleb. Pars Prior. Traiecti ad Rhenum: A. Oosthoek, 1910. The purpose of this Utrecht dissertation, the subject of which was sug- gested by Bechtel and Wissowa, is to determine to what extent the etymologi- cal studies of the Romans depended on those of the Greeks. The first 98 pages are devoted to a consideration of the theories and practice of the Greeks, from Protagoras to Philoxenus, with a discussion of the origin of the Poema Etymologicum of Johannes Mauropus. Among the Romans the four prede- cessors and successors of L. Aelius Stilo who are deemed worthy of notice (Lucilius, Aurelius Opillus, Hypsicrates, and Nigidius Figulus) are dismissed