STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 84 Notes and Discussions Cf. Hippolytus 164 and 966 where to fiMpov is a S5Tion3nn. To this train of associations Platonism adds the depreciatory significance of "material." In Timaeus 86 D the erotic sensualist is described as apova t(r)((ov \mo rav a-io/juiTOi Ttjv tlnix^v, and in Phaedo 66 C the body infects the soul with ipu>- Tiav .... Kal \vapuii. Cf. 67 A, t^s tov (Tw/juiTOi d^pocrwijs. Later writers use vXt/cds or iXnuo's to express the idea: Proclus in Rempvb. ii. 276. 8 Croll., BovXtva yap (sc. i) t/f^x^) Ovfu/ii, iTnOvfUcwi .... haiijxxnv vAaiots ; Agathias Hist., p. 151 C, t5v t^s vXtjs diMpTrjixdriav ; Synes. hymn. 3, Bvotpav vXa^ KriXiSa 4>ipiO .... Xaimpas vAas tjuepos ay^ci ; and p. 1077 A, Twi TOV <7poavvrii he would have admitted that he ought to have done so. Palseographically the change is very shght. See Meineke Analecta Alex- andrina, p. 230, n. 1: "Litterae iv et a simillimo compendio exarabantur. Apud Artemidor. Onirocr. ii. 37 pro dSiyXos leg. eS&jXos, et apud Arcad., p. 82, 15, apoTO% pro evpoTos." Paul Shobey THE ACCENTUATION OF WORDS OF THE TYPE COMMEMORARE In Class. Phil. VI, p. 414, Professor F. W. Shipley suggests that com- pound verbs of the type commemorare received a secondary accent on the second syllable. Professor Shipley does not seem to have observed, and may be interested to learn, that this suggestion had already been made by myself in Class. Rev. XX, p. 33, and Class. Phil. II, p. 344. To be exact, I went somewhat farther than Professor Shipley, and suggested that all words of that measure, whether compound verbs or not, were accented in that way if they had been increased from quadrisyllables by inflection. If the point is to be cleared up, it is desirable that all the evidence should be put together. Professor Shipley bases his conclusion on the evidence afforded by the clausulae of Cicero and Quintilian, and on the history of compound verbs of this type in Old French; my own conclusion was based on the metrical treatment of all words of this type in Plautus. The Plautine evidence may be summarized as follows: (1) Whenever we know with certainty the position of the accent, we find that in iambic and trochaic verse (except in the first foot) the first syllable of a metrical resolution, whether arsis or thesis, is a syllable that would be accented in prose. (2) Words of the type commoditatem bear the ictus on the second and fifth — commdditaMm — or on the first and fourth — commoditdtem. Neither of these Plautine stressings would be consistent with any other prose accentuation than commdditdtem. Examples of the stressing commoditatem will be found in: Am. 296, 739; As. 201; Bacch. 298, 426, 538, 769; Cap. 131, 1004; Cure. 467; Mil. 644; Rud. 957, 1236; Stick. 422, 740; Trin. 313, 1138. Notes and Discussions 85 It is probable that not only in Old French but in all the Romance lan- guages there is evidence of this pronunciation. Italian incollerirsi can only- come from incdlerire. Spanish Saragassa, which can only come from Caes&r- auffAsta, is evidence that this accentuation was so firmly established as to be capable of analogical extension. Chaeles Exon University College, Galwat VARIA SOCRATICA ONCE MORE May I take the opportunity, kindly offered me by Professor Shorey, of making a brief reply on some of the main points of his criticism in the July number ? In several cases I think I can show that his objections have been already met by anticipation in my book itself. And in any case, whatever m ay be the fate of my own views, there is a real problem to be solved by anyone who believes Aristotle's famous account of the genesis of Platonism in Meta- physics A and M. As throughout the metaphysical and philosophical books, Aristotle's main thesis is obviously to show that Platonism was a refined and qualified Pjrthagoreanism; yet the well-known passage of A about the influ- ence of Cratylus and Socrates seems to account for the Trpay/mTua nXariavo^ without any reference to the lythagorean theories. If Aristotle is relating the facts correctly, as I believe he is, there must be some way of accounting for this seeming incoherence. My proposed solution {V.S., p. 38, 68) is that the way in which early Pythagoreanism came to influence Plato was through Socrates himself; my critics who reject this solution ought at least to propose a rival one and moreover to weaken by actual counter-evidence the cumulative argument for the Pythagorean character of Socrates' beUefs based on the concurrent testimony of Plato, Xenophon, and Aristophanes. Dr. Shorey seems to find a special absurdity in my having detected the (Tujua — (TrjiJM theory in the Frogs as a "crowning proof" of the impiety of Euripides. If he means that Aristophanes is not really serious in his attack on Euripides I agree with him, but neither do I beUeve him to be serious in the Clouds. The charges in both cases are made mainly in fun, as the author of the Symposium knew, but still they are there, and it is true, as I said, that the professed indictment of Euripides as impious culminates in the charge of his having made a heroine say Tts 8' o'Sev ei to ^rjv /xw ion. KarOaveiv ; The point is even made a second time at vs. 1477 where the whole line in question is flung in the author's teeth. Now it is quite certain (o) that the doctrine that our true life hes beyond the grave is of Orphic provenance, (b) that it is exactly what was meant by those who derived trS/ui from trrjfm, and (c) that it is this behef which is the basis of the ixtkirr) Oavdrov of the Phaedo. Hence I am quite entitled to argue from the use made of the famous line in the Frogs that the doctrine would appear "impious" to the ordinary Athenian of ca., 400 B.C. Whether Aristophanes peTsonally thought the impiety a serious one is immaterial to my reasoning.