STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE IN THE AGE OF HESIOD By Robert J. Bonner Voluntary arbitration was the first step in the direction of a systematic administration of justice in Greece. The Homeric Greeks took a second step by devising a system of challenge and wager to induce an unwilling opponent to submit to arbitration. 1 The third step was the development of compulsory processes of law by making arbitration obligatory in case either party to a dispute desired it. As the petty kings and chieftains were the natural arbitrators of the people, it was a simple matter for them to change a custom into a law. In all probability the change was effected by the aristocracies which succeeded the Homeric kings. The nobles would be quick to perceive the advantages of a step which so materially increased their political power. There are several indications that by the time of Hesiod a plaintiff could compel an unwilling opponent to submit to the judgment of a regular court. It is only on this assumption that we can understand Hesiod's bitter denunciations of the nobles who oppressed the people by means of unjust judgments. 2 For the nobles could not have con- tinued to render corrupt decisions had they acted as arbitrators to whom recourse was had by litigants only as the result of a voluntary agreement. The remedy would have been in the hands of the people. Neither is the appeal of Hesiod to his brother to settle their disputes amicably instead of resorting to the court of "bribe-devouring kings" intelligible unless Hesiod was obliged to submit to their adjudication. 8 1 For details see my paper on "Administration of Justice in the Age of Homer," Classical Philology VI, pp. 12 ff . The results obtained in that investigation are constantly used in the present paper, which constitutes a second chapter in the judicial history of Greece. In the main my conclusions are based upon the Works and Days. The case of Amphitryon in the Shield of Hercules and the case of Apollo versus Hermes in the Hymn to Hermes have been used chiefly for purposes of illustration. The proemium of the Shield of Hercules which contains the story of Alcmene and Amphitryon is taken from Hesiod's Catalogue of Women (cf. Hypothesis A). The Hymn to Hermes is not earlier than 536 B.C., the year in which Terpander is sup- posed to have invented the seven-stringed lyre. The age of Hesiod in all probability falls between 750 and 650 B.C. ' Works and Days (edited by Ezach) 220-21, 248 ff. f 262-64. > Ibid. 35-36. [Classical Philology VII, January, 1912] 17 18 Robert J. Bonner Evidently a uniform system for the administration of justice was established throughout Boeotia. Within each district the petty chiefs composing the dominant aristocracy met with some regularity in the chief city and adjudicated disputes. Thither nocked the country people from the villages either as litigants or as listeners; and a city agora on court day must have presented a scene strikingly similar to that pictured on the shield of Achilles. 1 Some machinery must have been available for summoning parties and witnesses, and for enforcing judgments, but it is nowhere men- tioned. Thonissen 2 suggests that heralds were used for this purpose. In any event a judgment rendered by the men who controlled the government could not easily be evaded. It is interesting to note that the processes of law were open to strangers as well as citizens. 3 Access to the courts of a foreign city was in all likelihood regulated by special treaties. Litigants commonly substantiated their claims by the evidence of witnesses. "Even when dealing with your brother," says Hesiod, "summon a witness; but do it with a smile." 4 The smile was to cover the insistence on what might under the circumstances be regarded as a useless formality. Hesiod had learned this lesson from his experience with his own brother. That witnesses might give their testimony under oath is made plain by the poet's denunciation of the witness who knowingly commits perjury and thereby does an injury to justice, 6 os Si k« fmpTvpir/cri e*o)V iiriopKOv o/*oWa« ^ctxrerai, ev 8e hUrfV pXaipas vrJK€ Works and Days 27 ff . ■ he droit pe~nal de la rgpublique athfnienne 31. • Works and Days 225 ff., 327; cf. Glotz La solidarity de la famille dans le droit criminel en Grece 220 ff. < Ibid. 371. '■Ibid. 282-84. « Ibid. 219. ' Ibid. 193-94; cf. 322. Justice in the Age of Hesiod 19 ftXaij/u 8' 6 Ka/cos tov apeiova ra pvOounv ctkoAioTs iveirmv, iirl 8 ' opuov djueiTai. Tzetzes explains this passage as meaning that a man deprives another of some property and when called to account, swears that he is innocent just as Hermes offered to swear that he did not steal the cattle of Apollo. Even if the Hymn to Hermes, in which the dis- pute between Hermes and Apollo is described, is considerably later than the poems of Hesiod, it may be safely used to add some details to the picture of legal procedure in the age of Hesiod. For it no doubt reflects in the main the practice in vogue down to the period of written codes. Apollo on discovering the loss of the cattle, at once set out to trace them and secure witnesses to establish the identity of the culprit. 1 So important was testimonial evidence that rewards for information leading to the finding of the thief were sometimes offered. 2 If witnesses could be produced the accused had the option of returning the booty with suitable damages or of facing almost certain defeat in court. Apollo, though he was unable to secure a witness, confidently charged Hermes with the theft. Irritated by the accusations, Hermes threatened to bring the matter before Zeus, and offered to swear that he was innocent. It is not stated that Apollo agreed to accept the oath as decisive, as did Menelaus when he challenged Antilochus to swear that he had not won the race by a foul. At any rate the case was taken before Zeus for adjudication. 3 alif/a. 8' ikovto Kaprjva #va>Seos OiXvp-iroio es irarepa KpovtWa Aios irepiKaAAea TtKva. KeiOi yap dja<£oT€poi