STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Volume IX October IOI4 Number 4 PLATO'S LAWS AND THE UNITY OF PLATO'S THOUGHT. I By Paul Shorey In spite of Lucian's sneer, "colder than Plato's Laws," the masterpiece of Plato's old age was more closely studied and intelli- gently appreciated in antiquity than it is today. It has happened to eminent modern scholars to deal with verbatim quotations or obvious reminiscences of the Laws with no recognition of their source. It has been a commonplace of criticism to contrast its prosy preach- ments and tediously minute prescriptions with the fresh, dramatic charm of the minor dialogues and the large poetic idealism of the Republic. Critics who have lost their way between the comprehen- sive design and the labyrinthine detail have pressed a few confused or corrupt passages, 1 a few awkward periods, a few abrupt or strained transitions 2 into the service of the thesis that it is an incoherent aggregation of fragments put together by some Philip of Opus out of Plato's Nachlass. Deviations from the Republic required by the very design of the work, its inr6deai.s, as -Isocrates, 3 Plato, 4 and Aristotle 6 would put it, are exploited as evidences of a fundamental revolution in Plato's social and political opinions. The custom, in 1 E.g., 934C. 1 Chiefly in Book xi and in Book xii as far as 958C. Plato himself apologizes, 922B: ravra di di) fieri, ri vvv elpri/Uva avayxaiov anus y4 ircos rdi;atrOai. * Panegyr. passim. *Rep. 550C; Laws 743C, 812A, etc. 6 Politics passim; of. 1269a 32. [Classical Philology IX, October, 1914] 345 346 Paul Shokey systematic expositions of the Platonic philosophy, of relegating the Laws to an appendix, as it were, and the neglect of countless definite coincidences of thought and formula with the more dramatic dia- logues have confirmed the impression that the fullest and most explicit enunciation of Plato's teaching is of interest only to pro- fessional philologists. Its noble and stately, if sometimes monoto- nous, pijropeia has been confounded with the flat, unraised style of the epistles or the solemn and cumbrous preciosity of the Epinomis for the maintenance of the genuineness of those plausible imitations. A few petulant Carlylean declamations, a few wilful Ruskinian boutades, 1 have completely blinded liberals of the school of Grote and Gomperz to the true historical significance of this unique com- bination of an Aristotelian wealth of good sense, political wisdom, and discriminating observation with a divinatory insight and a depth of Hellenic feeling that forever elude the dialectical net and the would-be exhaustive categories of the semi-alien encyclopedist. The repetitions, 2 the apologies for digressions, 3 the allusions to the weakness of old age, 4 the self-checks, 6 and the self-praise 6 have provoked comparisons with the senile maunderings and self- complacency of Isocrates' latest work. Deprecation of this injustice does not commit us to the paradox that the Laws portrays persons with the dramatic poignancy of the Protagoras and Gorgias, or embodies abstractions with the high imaginative vision of the Republic. There are tedious tracts. There is something of the didacticism, the repetitiousness, the self- complacency and at the same time the hopelessness, if not the moroseness, of old age. The years have altered not only the emphasis of Plato's moods but perhaps some of his minor opinions. The style, with some gains, has lost flexibility, simplicity, and colloquial charm. Little tricks of manner have passed into mannerisms. 7 It is a question of degree, of the weight to be attributed to these things in the interpretation of Plato's philosophy and the history » 704, 742C, 769B, 908-9, 929D, 937-38, 952D, 829D. *659D, 688B, 699C, 733 = 662-63, 740E, 743E, 754C, 770C, 774C, 812A, 822E, 876D, 887B. » 642A, 682E, 701D, 864C. 5 701C, 722D, 803BC, 857B. * 752A, 770A, 846C, 855D, 957A. 6 683C, 699D, 811CD. 7 t&x *" tr"ti ^ KO 'i &M">' ft 1ra "i TU, & rpbirov o5; tj irws; t6 ye TOffovrov. Plato's "Laws" and the Unity of Plato's Thought 347 of his personal development. I think that recent criticism has overemphasized them, and I shall endeavor to show in this study: (1) that the Laws is in Plato's conception essentially finished, and is on the whole as well composed as is any equally long and fact- laden treatise in ancient — or in modern — literature; (2) that the slight and easily explicable divergencies from the thought of the Republic are completely outweighed by all-pervading correspondences in principle and in detail; (3) that allusions to methods and ideas of the dialectical dialogues, and explicit solutions of problems dramatically presented in the minor dialogues, make the work almost a complete compendium of the Platonic philosophy; (4) that the precision, the stately rhythm, the religious unction of the style deserve to be studied for themselves and not merely as foils to the more obvious charms of the earlier dialogues. I cannot, of course, hope to present many facts that have not been singly observed by others. But the collections, though mak- ing no claim to exhaustiveness, may be of some interest even to those who do not accept my main theses. The existence of the Republic prescribed for an artist of Plato's versatility a different design for any subsequent treatise on politics and sociology. He was no Isocrates to spend forty years redevelop- ing the topics and diluting the ideas of the prize composition that "had beggared him." Fundamental truth must, of course, be repeated. But many things he had said once for all, and could thenceforth take for granted by implication and allusion. The formal demonstration of the thesis of the Gorgias that virtue and happiness coincide, the censure of Homeric theology, 1 the definition of the virtues in partial resolution of the airoplat of the minor dia- logues, the psychology and pedagogy of the scientific studies of the Academy as a propaedeutic to dialectics, the embodiment in a series of poetical allegories of the regulative concept of the idea of good — • these topics, occupying more than half of the Republic, are, as we shall see, presupposed and, when required by the argument, repeated in the Laws. But an explicit rediscussion of them was not called for except on the assumption that Plato had changed his opinions, l Laws 886C briefly dismisses this topic. But cf. 636D and 941B with Rep. 378B. 348 Paul Shorey which is begging the very question at issue. Nor can we expect him to rewrite such a masterpiece of art as the evolution of democracy and tyranny out of the ideal state in the eighth book, 1 or to recast the eschatological myth that crowns the whole. In the Gorgias and the Phaedo Plato had already preluded to this incomparable Vision of Judgment. And after the Story of Er anything that even he could have composed on this theme as a conclusion to the Laws would have been an anti-climax. He therefore incorporates the "sanction" of the idea of immortality in his main argument by a few explicit references, 2 fills the space which its fuller exposition would have occupied with the theodicy of the tenth book, and con- cludes his latest work, not on a high poetic and religious climax, but with an almost pathetically patient and lucid summary of the simple principles of his lifelong teaching and his political philosophy. The Republic was the definitive poetic embodiment of the parallel and antithesis between the ethical and political ideal which is an object of seemingly vain quest in the minor dialogues and that of the Athenian democracy and the sophists and demagogues who exploited it for their own ends. To this exhausted theme Plato could not well return for many years, and then only on a more prosaic and matter-of-fact level. The Politicus is in the main a study of method — a contribution both to general logic 3 and the special logic of politics. 4 Taking up the old postulate of a royal or political art 5 and the old parallel or antithesis between the true art or science and the arts of flattery of the demagogue, the rhetorician, and the sophist, 6 it defines the statesman by successive eliminations of all rivals and pretenders to his function. 7 A myth presents and regretfully dis- 1 Macaulay, who had little appreciation of Plato's higher flights, says: "I remem- ber nothing in Greek philosophy superior to this in profundity, ingenuity, and elo- quence." * 727D, 870D, 828D, 881A, 927A, 959B. ' 286D: To\i Si /j.i\iv vvv t^v SiawepavSeurav irai&elav. 6 It is not, as sometimes affirmed, the reconciliation of the two temperaments by the marriage of unlikes. Plato distinctly assigns the second and inferior place to this measure: 309C, 310A: toi>s p£v XomtoiJs, Svras drdpuirlvovs Ser/wis, inrdpxovTos roirov tov ffelov (rxeSbv oiSev x ^ e ' r * , ' " T < irpotiy oire ivvo^iravTa dwoTeKetv. 6 773B. 7 It may be vaguely covered by 458E: elev 5' 4k Upol [sc. yd/tot] oi , f) irXdrrav KaOdirep Ik Ktjpov riva vrb\iv ical woXlras; Rep. 588D: ireiSri eiTrXavrbrepov K^pov .... Xiyos. 10 Rep. 473A: k&v el p.^ ri? Sonet 12 636A; Polit. 294B. » 636A, 736B, 778B. " 766A, 808D; Polit. 292D. " 684DE, 752B, 779E, 781B, 788A-90A, 839B, 922D, 925D: & luipla iv dv0ptirois 4p.w6Sia ytyvertu rois rotoirots iirirdypturir tov n-fyriva Idfkeiv Trel8t$t)s tux"' ircudelas, fjrts tot4 iariv; Laws 788C: riju ye ipBiv. TGorg. 509A; Rep. 360B; 618A. 8 Crito 49D. » Rep. 527E. Plato's "Laws" and the Unity op Plato's Thought 353 and its compromises of the good with the necessary 1 to the dis- appointments of Plato's Sicilian experiences and the failure of his idealistic faith and hope. The suggestion can do no harm provided the texts are not distorted in its support. But it remains for sober criticism a superfluous hypothesis. The inevitable decay of the imagination in old age, and the literary motives already glanced at, the avayiai ^oyoypafaicf), amply account for all significant differ- ences between the Republic and the Laws. The ideal principles of social reform having been once adequately expounded, it remained to portray their plausible application to a conceivable Greek city. Such a hypothesis necessitated an immense mass of superadded detail, 2 and a more matter-of-fact treatment. Old age doubtless diminished Plato's elasticity of feeling, and his mood may have been permanently saddened by the death of Dion. But all the notable pessimistic utterances of the Laws can be closely matched from the Republic. 3 It is the height of naivete" to suppose that Plato really expected to establish the kingdom of philosophy in Sicily. The most rudimentary literary art would forbid the explicit admission within the Republic that the heavenly city was a mere Nephelo- coccygia. But the argument that his ideal is not wholly chimerical 4 is so hedged about with qualifications and reserves 6 that the intelli- gent reader has little difficulty in apprehending, as Kant apprehended it, the true meaning of the final sentence: 6 "It makes no difference whether it anywhere now exists or ever is to be. The philosopher will concern himself with the politics of this city and no other." Here, as often, the unscholarly divination of Emerson comes plump upon the truth: "He did not, like Pythagoras, break himself with an institution. All his painting in the Republic must be esteemed »739, 740A, 8S3C, 875CD, 948CD; ef. 628D, 758E, 858A; Rep. 347C, 358A, 493C, 520E, S27A. s See the list of omissions in Rep. 42SCD, 412B. The polity of the Laws, too, as we shall see, dispenses with much that ordinary states require. Cf. 842CD. '379C, 496DE, 516D, 486A, 500BC, 604B: oilre ti rdv i.v8purtvuv &%u>v Iv HeyiXys erjrovSijs =Laws 803B; cf. Laws 644D and 803C. *499C: SXXus evxaU S/iOia; cf. 540D; cf. Laws 839D: as 8' odv owe %anv \nrkp &v0pairov. *450C ff., 4S7D, 4S8AB, 466D, 472A, 520A-C. • 592B. 354 Paul Shorey mythical, with intent to bring out, sometimes in violent colors, his thought. You cannot institute, without peril of charlatanism." 1 But though Plato's sober judgment was subject to no illusions, the exigencies of his literary design and the impatience inseparable from the world-bettering temper led him in both the Republic and the Laws to the affirmation of two dangerous Utopian principles, the abuse of which by the disciples of Rousseau and Carlyle has reflected some discredit on the author. The historical spirit rejects his assumption of the unlimited plasticity of actual and secularly evolved human nature. And modern liberals condemn his invoca- tion of the benevolent autocrat as the deus ex machina of reform. Our present concern is not to apologize for either of these ideas, but to point out the relative justification of Plato's literary use of them, and to show that the Republic and the Laws do not appreciably differ in their statement. The Greek x6\is was in fact far more plastic to a dominating personality than the huge modern Wvos ever can be. Isocrates, like Plato, dwells with complacency on the power of the mere example of the Prince to transform the fashion of life and conduct in the citizens. 2 And with the mythical or real cases of Lycurgus and Solon 3 in mind, Plato found abundant confirmation for the postulates that the "Lawgiver" can mold human nature to his pattern, 4 that the second generation if not the first can be made to accept any teaching that it is desirable for them to believe, 6 and that a unanimous public opinion created by education 6 and preserved by laws that forbid its contradiction 7 can subdue instinct 8 and hold in check the desire for innovation. 9 1 Plato: New Readings. 2 Isoc. Or. ii. 31 ; iii. 37; vii. 22; Plato Laws 711B. 3 Polit. 295BC obviously alludes to Solon. i Rep. 501A, 500D: a ixel 6pf . . . . eU &vdpt&Tuv tfiti Tt$4mt .... Sri/uovpydv T1J5 3l7|UOT!K))S &p€Tijs; cf . 377C. ^ Rep. 541A, 41SCD; Laws 752C, 663E: XiSuvtov fiv$o\6yrifM .... irap&Seiypa rod irelaeiv & ti i.v {tix*'PV t ' s ir«Weu> ris twv viwv \f/vx&s =*Rep. 414C. In 781-83 there is a hint of the argument which modern reformers draw from evolution and the changes which it has wrought in human nature. Cf. 676C. « 665C, 643D, 653A-C; Rep. 367A, 378D, 463D, 464A. '838CD, 798B, 660E; cf. Rep. 392A. 8 838B : apiMpbv pijiM mTaafiivwai tr&aas t&s toioi/tos ijSovis. a 657B, 797CD. Plato's "Laws" and the Unity of Plato's Thought 355 From this it is but a step to the doctrine of the all-wise autocrat that has given so great offense to liberal critics who make no allow- ance for its function in the literary economy of Plato's romances, 1 and who fail to distinguish the different forms which it assumes, and the qualifications by which it is limited. In the form of the famous dictum that either philosophers must become kings or kings phi- losophers, 2 it is merely the demand that the state be governed by the highest available intelligence, 3 which is of necessity the possession of a few, however democratically selected and trained. 4 This, though Plato is not always careful to mark the distinction, should not be confused with the invocation of a converted autocrat to bring about the revolution and inaugurate reform. That thought, too, appears in Republic 502B: els luavos yevofievos woXtv exw irei- doidvrjv.^ It assumes the form of wilful paradox in Laws 709E: rvpavvovnivrjv (wl dore rf/v ir6\iv. This outrages the liberal senti- ments of Grote and Mill as much as it surprises the natural Greek feeling of the interlocutors Megillus and Cleinias. 6 They overlook the fact that the virtuous youthful tyrant is simply an ideal postu- late of method, an evxtf with which Plato pleases his imagination even while recognizing its impracticability as a continuing form of government so long as human nature remains what it is. 8 All apparent inconsistencies are due to the fact that Plato cannot for- bear to oppose to the liberal politician's conception of government by plausible palaver, under the forms of law, 9 the old Socratic ideal of government as an art and science, the autocratic discretion of the 1 Cf . the Demiourgos of the Timaeus and the Lawgiver of language in the Cratylus. 2 Rep. 473C. But in 540D the idea of the revolution that establishes the reformed state is more prominent. With £/>ws i/nriffn, 499C, cf. Laws 711D. 3 714A: rijv tov vov dtavofiijv e'irovo/j.dfrvTas vdfiov; cf. 645B f 890D, 957C; Polit. 297B. *Rep. 428E, 491B, 494A, 503B; Laws 818A; Polit. 292E, 297BC, 300E. 5 By implication also in rims &v ff/xiKpoTdrov yueTa/3aX6>Tos, 473B. • 711A; cf. Polit. 293E. ' 709D. « 691C, 692B, 713C, 854A, 875B, 947E; Polit. 274E, 301C, 301D. The Republic differs, if at all, only in the assertion, required by the ir60evairiv yiyveadca Kara v6i,\opovoiiwvos; Rep. 395C, 607 A. 7 797, 799, 656, 819A; Rep. 380, 424C. 8 846D ff.; cf. Rep. 370B, 374A, 394E, 395, 423D, 433A, 553E. 360 Paul Shobey subjection of all life and action to austere discipline and regulation, 1 the anticipation of the Aristotelian doctrine of the mean, 2 and its application to the theory of a mixed government, 3 the denunciation of the unlimited love of money, 4 the distinction between the self and the things of self, between the three kinds of "goods," 5 between the two kinds of equality, 6 between the good and the necessary. 7 But for our present purpose, the better understanding of the plot, we need now consider only the three interrelated ideas, that politics is an ethical science, that the true statesman subordinates everything to a conscious unitary moral end, that the prohibitions and penalities of positive law ought to be accompanied by explanatory or hortatory preambles. 1. In what, if any, sense politics is subject to the moral law is still hotly debated, with arguments that have not changed much since Frederick the Great undertook the refutation of Machiavelli. The crucial instance is still as it was for the Callicles of the Gorgias? the bare-faced avowal of the right of the stronger in all international relations, and the acceptance of the victory of the bigger battalions as the survival of the fittest. 9 All Europe still judges by the prin- ciples of Callicles the endeavors of English or American statesmen to deny or extenuate this ugly fact. On this aspect of the question Plato has little more to say. In the Republic he proposes to mitigate the cruelties of war between Greeks, but, like Isocrates and Aristotle, he regards the barbarian as the natural enemy. 10 The root of war he finds, with St. Francis, in human greed and cupidity. 11 With the reluctant abandonment of the ideal of the state of nature 12 he tacitly accepts war as an unalterable condition of life, even in Utopia. 13 In the world as it is we must be armed against injustice, he tells us, 14 1 942D (cf. Rep. 563C), 762, 758, 760A, 807. 2 Even in respect to health, 728D, 719, 729, 792C. * 712-13, 757-59. *Rep. 373E: airapov 591D; Laws 870A; Ar. Pol. 12566 32. * 717C, 728D, 743E. ' Supra, p. 353, n. 1. « Rep. 558C; Laws 757, 744C. 8 483D. 9 Laws 638B: vlxas Si ml ^ttoj i/crbs \iyov rk vvv 6Cb)u=v; cf. 890A. io 470C. " Rep. 373DE. n Supra, pp. 348 ff. 13 Laws 626A: %v yap mXovaiv ol xXefo-roi tuiv &t>$piiir kKvScovi t&v aXkcov irb\eoiV* only through a valor, a discipline, and a vigilance based on perfect virtue. 10 Within the state the general problem has two aspects, the morality of the means by which power is attained and the ends for which it is used. Plato is not careful to distinguish the two ques- tions. For his fantastic literary hypothesis of a benevolent tyrant has no effect on his healthy Greek abhorrence of the tyrant of experi- ence. 11 He finds no occasion for the casuistic psychology of Brown- ing's "Saviour of Society" or of the modern historian's rehabilitation of Sulla. He takes it for granted that power unscrupulously achieved I Menex. 246E; Polit. 307E; Laws 626B, 829A. * Laws 628D. • Maneuvers: Laws 829; German student duels and American football: 830E- 31A. *Bep. 374, 395BC, 404A, 416D, 453B, 467, 522E, 525BC, 526D, 537A, 543A; Laws 758B, 760-62, 795BC, 796, 813D, 829, 833A, 942BC. 6 626A: tovto ml (r elp^ng Spaariov. 6 660E. The "inconsistency" with 630D and 712E hardly requires explanation for an intelligent reader. 7 630B, 963E. » 758A. 8 Laws 638B. io 829A. II Cf . closely the language of Rep. 502B with that of 565E. 362 Paul Shobey will be selfishly used. He assumes that the politicians and dema- gogues who disdain no means of winning office will govern the state in the interest of self or party. All existing states are condemned in his eyes by the fact that not the common weal but to benefit friends and injure enemies is their conception of the end of govern- ment and their definition of justice. 1 They are not polities but factions, 2 and, precisely because for such politicians politics is the art of seizing the helm of the ship of state, they scorn the philosopher who gives his mind solely to the science of navigating the ship. 3 Deeper goes the question, What, for the ends of government, is the common weal? Is it victory in war, wealth, luxury, power, personal liberty, character, or the moral betterment of the citizens ? 4 Here Plato parts company from the modern liberal who, proclaiming that it is impossible to make men virtuous by act of parliament, would limit the functions of the state to the protection of the citizen at home and abroad, the enforcement of contracts, and the administra- tion of justice in the external 5 and vulgar 6 sense of the word. For Plato the end is to produce good men absolutely, 7 not, except in a reformed state, good citizens relatively to the government and the party in power. 8 On this issue in his idealistic moods he admits no compromise. "Watch me," says the Athenian, "if I propose a single law that looks to any other end." 9 The imperialistic statesmen of the Athenian prime were more efficient and perhaps more honest 1 Supra, p. 358, n. 3. * Laws 712E: oix eUrlv iroXtT«toi; 832B; t4j oi woX«-efas; Rep. 497B: oW i]rTtvovi/. * Cf. in Class. Rev., June, 1906, 247, my interpretation of the allegory of the ship, Rep. 488. Polit. 499B repeats Rep. 488E. In his own state Plato punishes with death unauthorized vo\virpaynovetp vepl rois v6p.ovs. Cf. Laws 952D. But the suppression of free inquiry by the mob of Athens is a very different matter. As against the ordinary Athenian Philistine or politician Plato almost sympathizes with the Sophists. See his treatment of Anytus in Meno 92BC. Sophistry is after all more akin to philosophy than is mere rhetoric. Gorg. 520B : r% Si dX?;0e£p K&\\t6t> iariv poaivr\s re KaX huauwrinrp koX i,vp.rc& ipeis oi vior, Laws 881 A; Theaetet. 180D and passim. 12 In patriotic moods (Menex. 238-39), or in criticism of Sparta (Laws 634A), he himself does not disdain the topics of the Periclean Funeral Oration. 13 631B, 661, 716, 721B, 726-34E, 783C, 806E, 854A-C, 903-906, 916D ff ., 923A ff., 937A. 366 Paul Shobey But it is hardly possible to exaggerate their influence on the later ethical literature of the Greeks which found in them endless texts for edifying paraphrase. We have lost that innocent Stoic and neo-Pythagorean faith in precepts which would make invincible the heart that cons them. But Plato anticipates our irony with the apology that in an age of transition and disintegration of all tradi- tional restraints even the slightest reinforcement of the moral sense by good words is worth the hazard of the skeptic's scorn. 1 2. These little sermons are woven into the design of the Laws by virtue of the two principles, that the lawgiver must always keep in view his conscious moral purpose and that every law should have a persuasive preamble. The first we have in large measure anticipated. The idea of the ao-ii>, evpeviaTtpov yiyvbpevov ev/j.adi airepy&aeTai. 10 Compare fur- 1 Rep. 424D, xapovo/iia; Laws 700D, 701A. *857D, 891D: vo/u>0ecrfas i/cris .... fialveiv. 3 723A: t^v irrlTa^iv, 8 5i) iariv o vbiws. * 857E, 880E, 788A, 770A, 730B, 724B. "811D; cf. 957C. 6 891A; cf. Phaedr. 258 ff. Being written they may be studied till even the dullest understands. The apparent "contradiction" between this and the stand- point of Phaedr. 275D need not disturb us. It is enough, however, to prove the spuri- ousness of the silly exaggeration of the Phaedrus passage in Epistles vii. 344. » 941C, 858D, 964C, 817C. 8 304CD. 9 The Socrates of the Gorgias says: aW ov xc6jtot« ai rairriv efSej rijv pTjTopiK-f/v. 10 I have emended a