STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. THE SEPTIMONTIUM AND THE SEVEN HILLS By Samuel Ball Platkeb In 1896 Wissowa published an article in Satura Viadrina (Breslau), entitled "Septimontium und Subura," in which he discussed the so-called Septimontium or second stage in the growth of the city of Rome, and gave a new explanation of the meaning and position of Subura at that early date. His views have been generally accepted by topographers, although of late dissenting voices have been heard. I have therefore thought it worth while to review briefly the history of the septem monies of Rome, and to present and discuss Wissowa's theory of the Septi- montium and Subura. In the literature of the Ciceronian and Augustan periods there are not infrequent references to the seven hills {septem montes) of the city of Rome, such as the following from Vergil (Aen. vi. 783) : septemque una sibi muro circumdabit arces felix prole virum, and (Georg. ii. 534): scilicet et rerum factast pulcher- rima Roma septemque una sibi muro circumdedit arces. Cicero (Ad Att. vi. 5. 2) speaks of the aarv eTrrakofyov, and Tibullus (ii. 5. 55) writes: carpite nunc tauri de septem montibus herbas, dum licet hie magnae iam locus urbis erit. Varro (De lingua Latina v. 41) says: Septimontium nominatum ab tot montibus quos postea urbs comprehendit, and (ibid. vi. 24) : dies Septi- montium nominatus ab his septem montibus in quis sita urbs est. Aulus Gellius (xiii. 14), where he is quoting the opinions of M. Valerius Messala Corvinus, consul in 53 B. c, speaks of the septem urbis montes in such a way as to show that Messala used the term as an ordinary designation for Rome in his day. We may there- fore assume without reservation that in the periods under review men spoke regularly of the septem montes of the city, and the question presents itself: Which were these seven hills? A comparison of the notices found in the historians, Diony- sius, Strabo, Livy, Varro, Tacitus, etc., makes it clear that these [Classical Philology I, January, 1906] 69 70 Samuel Ball Platnee septem montes were the hills of the city inclosed by the Servian wall, although there is nowhere an exact catalogue of all these hills in one passage. Tradition varied more or less in assigning the addition of some of the hills to this or that king, but its oldest form represented Servius as having incorporated the last two, the Esquiline and the Viminal. The chief variation in the traditional account concerned the Quirinal and the Caelian ; but be this as it may, there is little doubt that under septem montes in the Ciceronian epoch were included normally the Palatine, Capito- line, Aventine, Caelian, Esquiline, Viminal, and Quirinal — five montes and two colles. In later imperial times, however, with the growth of the city, it is evident that considerable confusion was introduced into this list, as is shown by Servius' note on the passage from Vergil (Aen. vi. 783) already quoted: bene urbem Komam dicit septem inclusisse montes et medium tenuit. nam grandis est inde dubitatio. et alii dicunt breves septem colliculos a Romulo inclusos qui tamen aliis nominibus appellabantur, alii volunt hos ipsos qui nunc sunt a Eomulo inclusos, id est Palatinum Quirinalem Aventinum Caelium Viminalem Aesquilinum et Ianicularem. In this passage the list is that of the Servian hills, except that the Janiculum has been substituted for the Capitoline; a substitu- tion easily explained by the fact that the Janiculum had become an important part of the city in Augustus' reorganization, and that the Transtiberine region could not be entirely omitted. Servius assumes that even in Vergil's time this must have been the ordinary view of the content of septem montes, for the expres- sion breves septem colliculos .... qui tamen aliis nominibus appellabantur, whatever this may mean, certainly does not refer to the seven hills of the Servian city as ordinarily understood. So also the Bern. Scholiast on this same passage says: septem id est septem montes JRomae Aventinus Tarpeius Caelius Ianiculus Quirinalis Viminalis Esquilinus. Tarpeius being only another common name for Capitolinus, we have here the list of the hills in the Servian city, with the substitution of the Janiculum for the Palatine. A comparison of such notes shows that the later com- mentators felt bound to admit the Janiculum into the list, and therefore eliminated one or another of the original names. The Septimontium and the Seven Hills 71 In the Regionary Catalogue of the fourth century the list of hills includes the following: Caelius Aventinus Tarpeius Palati- nus Exquilinus Vaticanus et Ianiculensis; and in the Mirabilia of the twelfth century we find Ianiculus Aventinus qui et Quiri- nalis dicitur Tarpeius Palatinus Exquilinus Vaticanus et Iani- culensis, showing an increasing uncertainty of tradition. Occurring first in Varro we find another term, Septimontium, used in a double signification. In the De lingua Latina (v. 41) Varro writes: ubi nunc est Soma Septimontium nominatum ab tot montibus quos postea urbs muris comprehendit, e quis, etc. There can be no doubt that Varro means by this to state categori- cally that the settlement which has now become the city of Rome was once called Septimontium, because it extended over seven hills, the same which the Servian wall afterward inclosed. Momm- sen has explained the passage to mean that there were as many hills in the Septimontium as in Rome, but not necessarily the same. This would involve the change of quos to quot, and even then it would be somewhat difficult to reconcile the text with the fact that Varro proceeds after e quis with a description of the seven Servian hills. Another reference to Septimontium in this sense is found in Festus (321), where we read: Sacrani appellati sunt JReate orti qui ex Septimontio Ligures Siculosque exegerunt. The other meaning of the word is the festival celebrated on December 11, which occurs in the following passages: Varro L.L. vi. 24: dies Septimontium nominatus ab his septem montibus in quis sita urbs est feriae non populi sed mon- tanorum modo ut Paganalia qui sunt alicuius pagi. Here it is perfectly clear that Varro believes that the festival of the Septi- montium derived its name from the seven Servian hills, and that it was a festival which was celebrated by the montani in their local organization, as distinguished from the populus as a whole. Comparison of this passage with that previously cited from Varro makes it certain that there too the writer is thinking only of the Servian hills, and not of any different list. This Septimontium was evidently one of the more important rural festivals in imperial times. Suetonius Dom. 4, says: septi- montiali sacro quidem senatui equitique panariis plebei sportellis 72 Samuel Ball Platnee cum obsonio distributis initium vescendi primus fecit. Columella (ii. 10. 8) speaks of the Septimontialis satio; and Palladius (xiii. 1) writes: faba circa septimontium seri potest. Tertullian [De idol. 10), in speaking of the temptations to idolatry to which teachers are exposed, says: etiam strenuae captandae et septimontium et brumae et carae cognationis honoraria exigenda omnia. Other references to the origin of the festival are : Schol. Veron. ad Aen. ii. 635: septem monies unde etiam dies sacer septimontii consti- tutus est, and Plut. Qu. Rom. 69: to Be aeirri/jLovvriov ayovaiv eVl tw top efiSofiov \6ov Tj7 iroXei Trpoo-KaTave/MTjdrjvac teal rr)v 'Pdy/xrjv eirraXo^iov yeveOVS TOL TtLXt] Trja>s ovriaf 'A/JevfVJivos K«A.tos ['EctkJvAios Kos BeA.ii>»;a]A.ios IIaA.a- [tii/osJ. The uncertainties and possibilities of the text of Lydus are numerous, but it appears probable that he is attempting to repro- duce the view contained in the passage from Servius previously cited, and that in his first list he intends to give the names of the seven hills of the republican city, Tt/3o[t5jOTtoi>] standing for Caelian and Jlpa^iv^eo-^Tiov for Quirinal, although this is very problematical. In the second list he has, as a matter of fact, given the Servian hills over again, except that Be\ivrj/^? e/CTeVarat) ; (2) that there had been almost always two interpretations of the application of the term Septimontium; and (3) that any defi- niteness of distinction in the names of the two sets of hills had long since died out. We are left, therefore, to the testimony of Labeo alone for the names of the earlier list. There are in this list three difficulties — one purely formal, namely the presence of eight instead of seven names, and two questions of topographical fact, namely the explanation of Subura and Fagutal. It is now generally admitted that Fagutal was the name applied to the slope of the Oppius toward the Velia, the present situation of the well-known church of S. Pietro in Vincoli. In earlier times it was sometimes regarded as the valley between the Oppius and the Cispius, but that was when the valley of the Subura was also thought to have had a place among the monies. This identification of the Fagutal may be regarded as an accepted fact, and Labeo's list contains, therefore, the three parts of the Palatine — Palatium, Cermalus, and Velia — which are thoroughly vouched for by manifold evidence, the three parts of the Esquiline — Oppius, Cispius, and Fagutal — and the Caelius and the Subura. The Subura in historical times was one of the best-known 78 Samuel Ball Platnek districts of Rome, not altogether to its credit. It was the valley stretching from the Forum up between the Oppius and the Cis- pius, and can not by any subterfuge have been called a mons. Another suggested explanation is that Subura was first part of one of the hills, and then became the designation of the valley at its foot ; but this would be an unexampled and unnatural transfer. Not to linger over less probable hypotheses, Wissowa argues as follows: Niebuhr's method of simply striking out Subura is wrong, for the mention of Caelius is irregular; that is, in the Festus citation it is inserted between Oppio and Cispio, thus breaking the order Oppio monti Cispio monti, in which it seems to be quite clear that after the five substantive forms the two adjectives Oppius and Cispius are used with mons, while in the epitome Caelius is the only word that has changed its place. Caelius is also the only name that has the same form in the early list and in that of the hills of Servius, for Palatium becomes mons Palatinus, so that the suggestion of the interpolation of Caelius lies near at hand. On the other hand, there seems to be no possible reason for the inter- polation of Subura, and even if Subura is dropped from the Septimon- tium, the regio Suburana of the next stage of Rome's growth remains still an unsolved mystery, if it is supposed to refer to the historical Subura, inasmuch as we have ample evidence that it (the regio) lay principally on the Caelian! Everyone will remember the very peculiar shape that earlier maps gave to the regio Suburana in order to make it include all that seemed to belong to it. Careful examination shows with sufficient clearness that this regio must have included only the Caelian district, and there seems to be no other explanation possible except to admit that the topographical unit, from which the regio was named, lay on the Caelian, and was quite different from the Subura of later times. This unit must have been a hill, to correspond with the usage in other cases, and therefore one of the parts of the Caelian, as the adjacent hills are excluded by the limits of the other three regions, as Varro enumerates them. The conclusion, therefore, is that the mention of the Caelian in the series of the seven hills of the Septimontium is incorrect, but that it is by no means a mere interpolation; for no one who had intentionally inserted an eighth hill would have omitted to drop one of the other names that had become almost obsolete, so that the number might cor- respond. Caelius belongs in Labeo's text, but as an explanation of Subura, which Labeo knew was not the Subura of his time, but a part of the Caelian. This theory gives us four natural and symmetrical regions, and leaves the valley of the later Subura outside of the city until the union of the earlier Roman settlement with that on the Quirinal and Viminal — a topographical necessity. While it is not certain to which part of the Caelian we should attach the name Subura, whether to the western part (with Rich- ter) or to the eastern part (with Wissowa), so far as his explana- tion of Caelio-Subura goes the latter's argument seems probable, The Septimontium and the Seven Hills 79 well supported by evidence, and altogether acceptable, provided we may believe that there was a difference between the name Subura in historical times and earlier. He says: Aside from Labeo, there is no evidence to be got from literature, nor has any etymology of the word been found. Varro and Verrius derive the name Suburana tribus or regio from a pagus Succusanus, and we know that the official abbreviation of this word was Sue. Plainly, there- fore, the original form was Sucusa or Succusa, the name of the part of the Caelius. The ancients regarded these two names as identical, but this does not prove that they were so by any means, especially as, ety- mologically, Subura can not have been derived from Sucusa, and the way out is to assume that they were originally separate things, and that the names became confounded in later times when the earlier names of parts of hills gradually dropped out of use. Verrius says that the pagus Succusanus derived its name "a stativo praesidio quod solitum sit suc- currere Esquilis infestantibus earn partem urbis Gabinis," and, so far as this goes, it is additional evidence for a district on the Caelian, rather than in the valley of the later Subura — a most irrational place for a gar- rison to be stationed to defend the city from the attacks of the Gabinians. On the whole, this theory seems to me the only one that can lay any claim to probability, or to being a reasonably satisfactory explanation of the situation. The principal difficulties — and the only ones that are of special importance — are, first, the discrep- ancy between Varro and Labeo, and the apparent ignorance on the part of the former of the original content of Septimontium as given by the latter. If Varro was not ignorant of this, he must have deliberately refused to admit its truth, in which case we should, I suppose, be bound to accept his view as against that of Labeo in a matter of Roman antiquities. To be taken in con- nection with this objection, however, is the increasing confusion in regard to the whole matter of the names and number of the hills, so that a difference in the first century B. C. does not seem quite so strange as it otherwise might. Anyone who had accepted the canonical account of the founding of Rome, as it had taken shape in the time of Cicero, would probably find it hard to divert his thoughts from the history of the addition of the seven Servian hills, as we find it given in Livy. The silence of other Roman writers about the Septimontium does not seem a valid objection in the face of reasonable evidence, no matter how confined in com- pass. I see no other way, therefore, than to admit that Varro was mistaken in this instance — or else to throw out the whole theory. 80 Samuel Ball Platneb The second objection is that of the confusion in the meaning of Subura, and the transfer of the name in historical times to the valley. This difficulty can be explained, apparently, in no other way than that which Wissowa has worked out; and here again, if one rejects the possibility of this explanation, he must perforce reject the whole theory. Personally, I think that the weight of present evidence is strongly in favor of this view, and that it is the only working hypothesis as yet advanced which enables us to correlate the known facts of early Roman topography. This it does so well that there is not sufficient ground for refusing to accept it. The history of the "Seven Hills" is therefore this: After the city had extended its limits beyond the Palatine, it included seven hills, or separate points of hills, the three of the Palatine, Palatium, Cermalus, and Velia, the three of the Esquiline, Oppius, Cispius and Fagutal, and the eastern or western point of the Caelius, Suc- cusa (Subura). A festival, the Septimontium, was established in honor of the existing city, celebrated by the montani separately. The same name was given to the city itself, probably before the institution of the festival. After the Servian wall was built, in historical times, the old Septimontium was explained as referring to the seven hills now inclosed within this wall, viz.: Palatine, Capitoline, Aventine, Caelian, Esquiline, Viminal, and Quirinal. This became the canonical content of the term, recognized by the people in general and even by historians, the only exceptions being a few anti- quarians like Labeo ; although it seems that a dim idea was float- ing about that originally some other hills had been meant. But the septem montes of Latin literature were those just enumerated. After Augustus had reorganized Rome and divided it into fourteen regions, of which the Transtiberine district formed one, and a very important one, it seemed manifestly improper to omit the Janiculum from the list of the seven hills, and therefore, as time went on, we find this hill substituted for one of the Servian, as, e. g., for the Capitoline in the note of Servius. In the earlier Middle Ages the Vaticanus also appears. Western Reserve University.