STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 462 Notes and Discussions STRABO i. 4. 6 6. Uapafj.vdovfi.evoi &' eirl irXeov, on Kara vo-iv earl to otto ovotoAt}? em Swriv b\ao-T7]fja /xei^ov Aeyeiv, koto v eXdrTunv eo-rlv eiKoo-i p.vptdoW, oVov Treiroi.rifi.eBa tov elpr/fievov o~Ta8iao~fX.6v Sorb tijs 'IvSikiJs eh Tr)v 'Iftr/piav. oiSe tovto ow ev Aeyei. ovtos yap 6 Aoyos irepl fiev Trjvy Kal ovo oucov/xevai elvai rf koX irXeiovs. koi fiaXurTa eyyiis tov Si' 'A6r)v£>v kvkXov tov Bia tov 'AtXxlvtikov weXdyovs ypas av rvy)(dvoi. vr)v fnaKpoTepav elvai kcu avr^v Kat ; Groskurd conjectures the following before KaOdirep elprfKafiev: p.epos yap elvai rrjs evKparov, y irtpirpi^ei dirao-av Tr)v yrjv, to Xoiirbv 8ie rr)v e£o> 0dAaTTav koi ravrrfv crvppow elvai. and he adopts the koi of Corais; Forbiger, Miiller-Dubner, Tardieu, and Meineke assume a lacuna before is, as did Kramer. Corais and the others read o-rrep ow oXrj rj evKpaTOs Kara fAtJKOs dirb Trjs eu> Trpos T^v eo-irepav iroXv p.ei£v tov rrXarovs eon", owtco koto vo-iv Kal rr/v olKovp.evrjv, Tr]v re KaO' Tjp-Ss Kal el Tive7 paKporepa eo~Ti, twnv; and theoretically he was right (compare Aristotle's dis- cussion of the point, Meteorologica ii. 5. 13) in making the natural limits of the breadth of the inhabited world the frigid and torrid zones, and in making the natural limits of the length of it lie in a parallel of latitude. The dimensions of the known inhabited world were, to Eratosthenes, 38,000 by 77,800 stadia; but theoretically, 38,000 by about 200,000 stadia. There is one other moot point in our passage — in the clause tmtp .... ixvpidZoiv. Groskurd inserts ovk before eXdrraiv and emends tiirtp to Kaxirtp; Forbiger retains tlirtp but accepts ovk, and so Meineke. If we assume that Eratosthenes' distance from the equator to the southern limit of the inhabited world is 8,300 stadia — and this is obviously the assump- tion of C. Muller, Groskurd, and Forbiger when they place the parallel of 464 Notes and Discussions Athens at 25,450 stadia north of the equator — then, by trigonometry, the text here contains an inaccurate statement. Counting Eratosthenes' degree at 700 stadia, the parallel in question would thus lie at 36° 21' 25J" latitude, and the circumference of the parallel would figure out to be 202,945 stadia. But among the many meridian distances ascribed by Strabo to Eratosthenes, there is no reference to Eratosthenes' distance from the equator to the southern limit of the inhabited world; and none of the ancient astro- nomical writers, I believe, quote Eratosthenes on this point, though Ptolemy makes a statement from which one might compute that Eratosthenes' dis- tance in this case was 8,300. Ptolemy says: " [The arc between the tropics is between 47J° and 47 }°], 8i ov awayerai a-^eSov 6 airos Xoyos t kcu "lrnrap^oi crwexpTjcraro. yiverai yap toiovtiov rj /jl£To£v rtov TpoiriKuiv ux eyyiara, ol