STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. ISOCRATES AND THE EPICUREANS By Habbt M. Htxbbeia Any study of ancient rhetoric has sooner or later to take account of Isocrates and the influence exerted by him, not only on the tech- nical study of rhetoric, but also on the style of much of later Greek literature. This influence is most noticeable in the first century before our era in the revival of Atticism. The theorists of that period were not content to study the style of Isocrates in the attempt to restore the classic purity to the debased Greek tongue, but found in him a model teacher of rhetoric, one who combined with instruc- tion in the technicalities of speaking a study of the social and political relations of man, the whole being infused with a breadth of view and seriousness of purpose which made it not unworthy the name "philosophy." Thus the principles of education expressed by Isocrates became a natural rallying-point for those who were dis- satisfied with both the philosophical sects and the rhetorical schools. To a restatement of this Isocratean ideal in education, long obscured by the predominance of the philosophical sects, Cicero addressed him- self in the De Oratore. Briefly stated, the idea which he unfolds is that before the time of Socrates the philosopher and orator were united in one person to form the perfect statesman; that Socrates and all his successors had made an unnatural division between philosophy and rhetoric, and that the time had come to reunite the two disci- plines, with philosophy serving as the handmaid of rhetoric in the training of the ideal statesman. That Cicero was closely following the ideas of Isocrates in formulating his doctrine is proved, not only by the general similarity of their educational systems, but also by the large number of passages in the De Oratore which so closely parallel passages in Isocrates as to preclude the possibility of their being mere coincidences. Cicero was followed a generation later by Dionysius with his treatise on the Attic orators. The ideal of the movement is well summed up in the introduction; it is to restore 17 apxala teal <£iA6vaiKrjs evKKrjpias Seirai, nadairep evfiiXeta 4>o)vr\s ko.1 fieyedrj nai tovoi kclI irvevfia, ical ISOCRATES AND THE EPICUREANS 407 irpcxroyirov Kal x eL P& v K0 ^ T °v XomtoO crckpcwos d£tcopd re Kal pv6fwl, Kal r6X/*a kcu touwt 1 ctXXa, St' a /cat rd? 'laoKparriv einbrus 0acrt tiJj iroXtretas airoaTrjvai.. 1 With this compare Isoc. Panath. 10, PftiZ. 81, .Ep. 8, 7; Dion. Hal., 7soc. 1; Pseudo-Plut. Decern Orat. Vit. 837A, 838E; Photius 260. ii. 178, frag. i&: [ItroKpar-qt jrapd] rod Kvirpio[v ritKavra e]Xa/3£v ei/c[o &X]Xa 5e/ca k Sudhaus' restoration of 'laoKpartis may be regarded as certain in view of the confirmation of the gift of twenty talents from the Cyprian Nicocles afforded by Pseudo-Plut. Decern Orat. Vit. 838A: Kal wapa NikokX&ws tov Kinrpiov jSacrtXewj, 6s r\v vlos Eiiaydpov, eiKoat. raXavra XajScbv. Philodemus' words: 7rapd Ttfiodiov .... ekafiev dXXa Se/ca do not square with the statement in Pseudo-Plutarch that he received one talent from Timotheus after the capture of Samos. The latter statement is probably derived from Caecilius, and so represents a tradition which is inherently more trustworthy than Philodemus. The smaller sum, too, seems more probable, for the booty of Samos must have been very much reduced after paying the expenses of the ten months' campaign (Isoc. Ant. 111). ii. 50. 21 : NOj' 5' «r' iKelvo /3ct5tf u/xev, 6 irepl 'AptoroTeXous avay- yeKSovatv, 6tl ttjs deiXrjs iyvp.va£ei> iiri4>uviiv irap' abrq> ra prjTopiKa KaTap,a06vTO)v ovk Ibbvar' ovSels b> ovderipq Karevrvxwikolav, airox^peiv. As Sudhaus has 1 The references to Philodemus are to volume, page, and line of Sudhaus' edition. 408 Harry M. Hubbell shown, 1 this statement does not imply that Philodemus considered Isocrates' teaching as philosophy because of a few superficial resem- blances to Epicureanism, nor can it mean that he misunderstood Isocrates' use of the terms 4>CKocrola and (frthoawfreiv, but it is a deliberate misrepresentation designed to belittle Aristotle by making him inferior to Isocrates. For Philodemus, as we shall see later, was not in doubt as to the real content of Isocrates' "philosophy." In the same article Sudhaus has pointed out that we learn from Philodemus for the first time of political differences between Isocrates and Aristotle. Isocrates, as his Philippus shows, was strongly in favor of a union of Greece under Macedonian leadership for a war with Persia. From Philodemus (ii. 61. 15) we learn that Aristotle opposed the Persian expedition: Ik /8aivs. ISOCRATES AND THE EPICUREANS 409 in the strict sense including forensic and deliberative oratory, and irokiTini) or political science (ii. 245. 6). Of these three only i- iv X67wj» hiaB&otis, o'iwv avrol ypav rolvvv t6 (itBobinbv W-eiv avrrjp, 01) waikv 5e Kadairep ovSe Tr\v iroir)Ti.Kr)v. To the other two branches, p-qropiKi] in the narrow sense, and vokiTiKi], he denies the position of an art. They lack the essential characteristic, namely a definite set of principles which can be imparted from teacher to pupil. Quite the contrary, rhetorical and political ability is the result of practice and experience. The suc- cessful public speaker may be compared to a good merchant, a hunter, or even a successful thief (i. 74). All succeed, however, as a result of their own skill based on experience, and their occupations cannot be called arts in the sense in which we speak of music as an art. Similarly i(rrr]s means an epideictic orator, and by a natural enlargement of its semantic area, a teacher of epideictic oratory; and iuTTr)s is, of course, quite different from that current down to the fourth century. The development of meaning has been worked out by Brandstaetter (Leipziger Studien, 1894), and need not be repeated here except so far as it affects our immediate discussion. Brand- staetter infers from the fragments of Philodemus that Epicurus was the first to use (nxpurrris and related words in this sense, and that it became a part of the technical vocabulary of the school in the writings of Hermarchus and Metrodorus. But an examination of the pas- sages on which he based his conclusion (i. 78. 2-19; 78. 19-85. 19; 85. 27-89. 10; 120. 10; 120. 22) will show that Philodemus nowhere quotes from Epicurus an example of this use of the word. The pas- sages are in some parts hopelessly corrupt, but the general sense is clear enough. It seems that Epicurus recognized epideictic oratory as an art, and made the distinction between this and practical 410 Harry M. Hubbell oratory which Philodemus makes. That he applied the term vkxtik§ ov p.r)8' elvai Tavr-qv Kal iroki.Tudjv, p,r]8' 8Aws ebrd t£>v prjropiK&v 8i8aapev irdht.Ti.K6v evO&iis rdv piiropa, dXXa Kal oi)8' dSXcos elvai ttoKitikov rdv prjropa, oiide Kadawep Kara o-iravucrepav avvi\B&.av irapa tois apxaiois iras 6 Xeyuv ev Srjpoj prjroip iKaXeiro. To this summary of Philodemus' position we may add one more statement which shows still more clearly the nature of the pretensions of the rhetorical schools: i. 222. 4: 'AiroTedewpripivwv roiyapovv, w r&i'e 7rauTrevoveTT)pioi> rqv ptjTOpucfiv Kal juSXXw Iri. p.tra ttjs irei0ovs ~Kap.0avop.ivqv. After this extended digression, which, I hope, has made clear the point that Philodemus uses uTTi}s of the professional writer of epideictic orations and teacher of rhetoric, let us return to the passages in which Isocrates is classed with the sophists. The first is a short fragment which evidently belongs to a passage discussing whether or not rhetoric is an art. ii. 122, frag, iv: . . . . iKoovs, Kal Xeyowri rbv '\o-0Kparr\v Kal rbv Topylav Kal rbv Kvcriav bpoXoyeiv ovk txtiv lino'rqp.nv. 'Airt- 8avus 8i \eyerai. Kal aSvvarus, eweiSri rexvtrai re eirrjyy eKkovro elvai Kal SiSat-eiv SXiKovs, Kadawep Kal wapa JlKariovi. Topyias. '0 8e 'Ir\ \byov tov 'laoKparovs rj rbv HavaOnva'iKbv fj rbv Bowripw Kal rr\v x \W\ivr\v aptdbSus Cf. i. 99. 5&=Suppl. 48. 15: Tov 8k ev 777 4>i\o(Tocj)la rrj Kad' ripas avearpappivov Kal twv riyovpivuv tovs 'IffOKparelovs ~kbyovs Kal tovs bpoiovs ovk apedbSas Kal ikoiav rfiv iavrcHv 8vvapiv Kai Thyyqv elvai. El 5' iPovkovro p,ev rexvrjv elvcu, rfiv 8' avri)v elirov § \shm\v rj juAXktt' h> XPV°~*<- v bp.oi.iov iicaXow. Hw(fia£ov yovv iKtivqv t<£ SKca yivet, Kai oixl t6 XLepiirarriTucdv tj 'Zrauciiv [p6vov a'lpev 8e ao^urruv 'laoKparris .... ii. 233. 11: '6rav to'ivvv Qeiua- el 8' 'laoKpaTijv Kai Marpus il^jj, ixtpos ti TepuoraTCU.' ktX. Further, in support of his theory that sophistical training does not produce political ability, he comments on the weakness of the Isocrateans in practical politics: ii. 250. 23: iroXKol 8k t&v iv tjj urTi.KiJ rfjv Kar' 'lcroKpar-qv irepiweKOL^p.evusv Siadeaiv ovt' evireipiav exoucri 7roXiTiK)jf ovre \6yovs a> 8r] p.(a Swavrai iroieladai, Kai 8t.Ka ktSv^CKew .... A general criticism is aimed at the sophists that their speeches are not suitable for public delivery. Specific criticism of Isocrates is quoted from Demetrius, who found his long periods hard to deliver, 414 Harry M. Hubbkll and from Hieronymus in a passage which is also quoted by Dionysius of Halicarnassus, De Isoc. 13 (i. 197. 5 ff.). 1 In a passage discussing Ae'£is the Kakbs \6yos of Isocrates is con- trasted with the rbv koKov fj rbv errfpiov tt\v pt\ropiKr\v Kal paKkov en pera rfjs ireiBovs \apfiavo- pivrjv . . . . ri pevroi papTVpeicrdat. Sia tuv aTOTekecrparuv, us ol rrj prjTopuqj irpoSi.aTpel\j/avT€s apelvovs yivovrai tuv bpoytvuv, SiaoreX- \bptda, aiK ax6«Xe rovvo/xa ridivat roi$ ttoXitmkhs dXXd reus hi daripov us Kav priropas roiis repi b.t}px>a6£vt\v ical KaXXiarpaTcv, ot Xiyovrai rifv iro\iTiKt}v tceKTrjadat. dOvafiiv, a^iucraifiev eiwelv uv /ecu Iv etXXc«) fiipei iirep;vriv i. Isocrates' course of instruction undoubtedly contained some study of the theory of government, and these N6juot and noXtreuu look like a continuation by the rhetoricians of the practice of Isocrates of broadening the scope of his instruction. Of imitators of his style we hear more. " Some imitate the style of Isocrates, others that of Thucydides," we read in i. 151. 19, which seems to refer to the Atticist revival of the first century. Philodemus mentions no names, and our information from other sources (e.g., Dionysius) is almost as meager; we may point to Crates of Tralles (Diog. Laert. IV. 23; cf. Blass, Griech. Bered., 101), who appears to be the only direct imitator of Isocrates of whom we know in this period. To this may be added the passage already quoted above, that there were at the most only two or three who imitated his style, and that it was doubtful whether there was a distinct Isocratean style. We must understand Philodemus to refer here to the lack of imitators among the orators. Of examples of his influence on historiography there could be no lack. Philodemus' estimate of Isocrates is distinctly unfavorable. His main thesis — that epideictic rhetoric, and that only, is subject to the rules of art — concedes, it is true, something to Isocrates; more 418 Harry M. Httbbell perhaps than we might expect from an Epicurean; he acknowledges the position of Isocrates as a master of encomium and, by implication, his influence on the historiography of Greece. But to grant this and nothing more is to deny the essential characteristics of Isocrates' teaching. For if eloquence is robbed of the privilege of guiding the destinies of nations the kernel is gone, and nothing but the empty shell remains. We may wonder why the Epicureans did not reject the rhetorical schools in their entirety instead of making a distinction between the art of writing and practical eloquence. The solution of this problem was indicated by Usener (Epicurea, XLII) and has been supplemented by Sudhaus. In all the philosophical schools there was a stylistic difference between esoteric and exoteric works, and even the Epicureans recognized the importance of literary form in works designed for the general public. So far, then, as study in the rhetorical schools tended to improve one's style it met with the approval of Epicurus, and no farther (cf. his words, Diog. Laert. x. 119: Kal avyypaufxaTa KaraKeiif/eiv ov iravriyvptlv 8i) . That he was attracted by the style of Isocrates we may safely conclude from the striking reminiscences of the orator's style in the Epistle to Menoeceus (cf. Sudhaus in Rh. Mus. XLVIII [1893], p. 337). His reason for adopt- ing Isocrates as his model may be found in the quotation from the Hepl faTOpucrjs in Diog. Laert. x. 13: acufy^s 5' fjv [Epicurus] ovtws ws net! ev rep Hepl prjropiKrjs a^ioi p.t]8kv fiXXo fj T)veiav acrKetv. This clearness which Epicurus considered the sole virtue of style was the quality in which Isocrates surpassed all others: Dion. Hal. De Dem. 18 : Kadapevei re (17 'IcroKparovs X&jts) yap ei tis Kal aXKi), rots bvbp.acn Kal tt\v di&Keicrdv Igtiv d/cpi/^s, avepa r' icrri Kal Kourij Kal ras tiiXkas aperas awdcras irepie'iX^ev, £1- Siv av p.a\irjs. Here we have a satisfactory explanation of the interest in Isocrates as a stylist. This is sufficient to account for the slight degree of favor accorded him by Philodemus. The main claims of Isocrates, however, whether put forward by himself or renewed by the rhetoricians of the first century, are vigorously combated. Yale University