STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Classical Philology Vol. vi yanuary, ign No. i THE LAW OF BREVES BREVIANTES IN THE LIGHT OF PHONETICS By E. A. Sonnenschein It is my object in this paper to discuss a question which is probably troubling the minds of a good many students of old Latin verse, and if possible to suggest a solution. But I want to avoid going into a multitude of details which would probably only confuse the main issue. I will write briefly, as to fellow-students who are well acquainted with the phenomena to which I refer and who will themselves supply the gaps in my exposition and correct it, if it falls at some points into overstatement. For criticism I shall be grateful. If I am on altogether wrong lines, the sooner I am put right the better for me. 1 1 In a former paper ( Classical Review XX [1906] , 168 f . ) I said that the phenomena coming under the head of the "Breves Breviantes" law may require to be reinter- preted if Plautine verse is to be regarded as "semi-quantitative" rather than fully quantitative. I will not attempt here to justify the use of the term " semi-quantita- tive"; for that would lead me into a discussion of the important part played by accent (word-accent and sentence-accent) in Plautine verse, and for that I have not room. — I note that my general position has been challenged by Professor Harkness (Classical Philology II, 63) ; in reply I would beg him to note the difference between " inner falls" and " outer falls" (see p. 9 below). Quantitative rhythm of the iambic or trochaic order depends on the shortness of the inner falls (i.e., those which come between the two rises of the iambic or trochaic dipody) just as much as on the length of the rises. But a long syllable may be used at either end of the series - - - with- out disturbing the quantitative rhythm. This is shown by Greek verse, in which the outer, but not the inner, falls can be formed by a long syllable. The Greek comedians, no doubt, often form their inner falls of two short syllables ; but not, I think, without some sacrifice of the true iambic rhythm. When the step is taken of admitting a long syllable to the inner fall I maintain that the verse can no longer be described as fully quantitative. [Classical Philology VI, January, 1911] 1 2 E. A. SONNENSCHEIN The existence of a law of Breves Breviantes — or something which corresponds to what is commonly described by that name — in the sphere of Latin morphology is indisputable. We are face to face with such shortenings as bene, male, am&t, lubet, monltus (by analogy of monUfirus, from monSturus, cf. Moneta), etc. — shortenings the evidence for which may be seen in any classical writer of Latin verse. 1 It seems unfortunate, however, that this law should be described by a term which ignores an essential factor of the shortening. So far as I have observed, at any rate, all writers on the subject make the presence of a stress on the Brevis or on the syllable which follows the Brevianda an element in the case, without which the law would be inoperative: bine, male", etc.; pudicitiam, iuventutis, etc. (these latter being found only in OL verse, Amph. 930, 154, etc.). The term "shortening shorts," however, suggests that a short syllable has in itself the power of shortening the syllable which follows, by a pro- cess which some writers have described as "assimilation of quantity," apart from stress of voice. 2 Another point that I notice in the current statements of this law is the inadequacy of the phonetic explanation which is offered. Victor Henry defends the doctrine of assimilation of quantity as follows: Iambic words like duo show a curious peculiarity. It is physically possible to pronounce successively an accented short vowel and an unac- cented long vowel; but, especially if the accent is strongly marked, it will be noticed that the long vowel then tends scarcely to exceed in length the preceding short vowel. Hence, in versification previous to the Augustan age, all words of this kind were treated, at the option of the writer, either 1 The fact that mater and frdter have a short final syllable in the earliest Latin, just as much as pdter, has been recently accounted for by Skutsch (OMta II, 151 f.) by the supposition that all these forms are properly vocatives, which have taken over the function of nominatives. In many exceptions to the law the long quantity may be explained as restored by analogy. 2 "The term 'Breves Breviantes' originated as an explanation of certain facts of OL verse structure: and if the facts in question admit of a better explanation, some new term will be called for in morphology also. In most cases the reduction of a vowel is due to weakness of stress ; but it may also be due to increase of speed on the part of the speaker, when he is conscious that he has to utter a good many sounds in one breath-group." (I take this statement from a letter by my friend Professor Rippmann, whom I am glad to find in general sympathy with the contention of this paper. ) The Law op Breves Breviantes 3 as iambics or as pyrrhics, and we find the scansion rdg&~rdga, pUtd, tilde", ddml, udld, rdgd, hdmd, etc. 1 The appeal is to the experience and ear of the reader. Similarly Lindsay remarks, "We ourselves, if we pronounce a phrase of this kind, feel that the short syllable c&- exercises a short- ening influence in this position upon the following long syllable -ve." 2 I know of no such law of phonology as is here implied. In an English word like "echo" the second syllable is to my ear longer than the first; indeed such words as "echo," "shadow," "never" tend to become fully iambic before a pause, the second syllable being lengthened as a kind of balance to the accented first syllable. Thus the ordinary prose pronunciation of "shadow" seems to me not very different from that which it has in Tennyson's verse (The Last Tournament) — And friends and foes were shadows (■ — ) in the mist. Distrusting my own ear I appealed to Mr. Henry Sweet, and he gave me welcome and unequivocal confirmation. There can be no doubt that in such words as echo the second vowel is longer than the first. When such words are drawled the lengthening falls entirely on the unaccented vowel, as in "what a pityyy!" That there is no necessity for shortening