STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Notes and Discussions 505 as found in either Greece proper or such Greek lands as the coasts of Asia Minor, Cyprus, the Ionian Islands, etc., are so marked. There can be no doubt that some, if not most or all of these, represent varieties known to the ancients. The classical writers have a fair number of references to the lizard, but little in the way of a description of its personal appearance. Dioscorides (2. 70) tells us that some call the also o-avpa. xa^KtSuoy. Aristotle (Hist. Anim. 8. 24, 3) says of it : ko! r) KaXovfian/i ^aXxis vn-6 tivw, vtto 8' mW £tyvts. The Scholiast on Nicander's Theriaca, 817, explains this name: koXutoli 8i Kal ^aXiiiS' %X a V"P **"' Ta *> viirov xv the emphasis is on the indefinite continuity of the circular movement or on the return to the starting point, the identity of re'Xos and dpxv- I n alrta St.' aXXrjXwv it is on reciprocal action and cumulative effect. Por- phyry's example is the corruption of the wise by public opinion, and the corroboration of public opinion by the concessions of the wise. The Platonic passage taken as a whole is precisely similar. Commentators strangely overlook the yap and the av in the words that follow those already cited: Tpor) yap Kal im(8coo~is \p-qo-Trj vwreis xprjO-Tal Totavrijs iratSctas avTiAa/*j8dvotxrai tri fiekriovs tS>v irporeptav tpvovTat as re TaXXa Kal eh to ytwav. I have found only a few examples of this force of kvkXos; but they are sufficient to establish the usage, and further search would doubtless discover others. In [Plato] Epist. 8. 353 D the suggestion of the geometrical circle is more explicit, but otherwise the meaning is the same, to o-pjtKpbv tovto peydXtov Kal pvpttov kcucSv alriov e/caoroTe i^vpfSalvu yt.yv6p.evov, Kal wipas oihiv TTOTt TiXetTai, £wdirTa 8e da 7raAaia TtXtvrrj Sokovou dp\y v KaKwv yiyverai, Kal dvTairoSaxns Ik StaSox^s to>v 8avG>v o-vp/Sawa, to t« yap etc. That is, the evils of faction are cumulative and interminable, for every defeat stimulates the desire for revenge in the worsted party. Note the dvTaVo&ocris, the paying back with interest or "tit for tat" of comedy. In like manner Iamblichus de Myster. p. 177. 10 Parthey, says that evil men attract evil spirits and are in turn made worse by them : o-waii- £ovrai tc vtr' dXXi/jXmv ovtuis KadaTrzp tis kvkXos dp\r)V TtXevTrj crwdirTuyv Kal dvTavoSiSovs ttjv tarrjv aprnft-qv <5>a-avra>s. Here as in the 8th Platonic Epistle there is conscious reference to the mathematical circle, and the language resembles that used by Aris- totelian commentators in explanation of reasoning in a circle. Cf. Eustratius in Analyt. Post. p. 177. 1, Themist. in Analyt. Post B 12. p. 54. 23. But the difference noted above holds. If these parallels are pertinent, those cited by W. G. Headlam in E. J. Phil. XXX. 291 ff . are not to the point. He quotes Soph. fr. 787 on the phases of the moon: Notes and Discussions 507 dAA' oip.os aid irorpios iv miKvif 6cov rpo\iS KVKXcirai Kal /teraAAacrcrei xxnv uxrirep (Ttkyvrp oi//is .... dAA' l£ dS^Xov irpwrov (p\erai. vea ****** jf&Tavirtp avTrjs tKirpe.TrtcrTa.Tr) avj} 7raA.1v oiappd koitI p.r)8kv «fpx £Tal - Evidently the Platonic kvkXos of cumulative effect has nothing to do either with the waxing and waning moon or with the distinct image of a wheel that precedes it in Sophocles. The same may be said of the passage which Headlam cites from Hippodamus the Pythagorean apud Stob. Flor. 98. 71. It is merely a statement of the commonplace that all human things move in a cycle of growth and decay. That idea is familiar to Plato, but he is not dwelling upon it here. His point is that, given a good start, iavrrep anal; opp^a-y ev (cf . dp^r/v re Kal 6pp.rjv kt\. in Polit. 305 D) prosperous growth will be spontaneous and progressive. It would have been singularly inept to weaken this thought by an allu- sion to the truism that everything must wane as well as wax. This consideration is fatal also to Adam's interpretation, which agrees with Headlam's on this point though otherwise differing. Adam does not look for a "wheel" or a "hoop," but he says: "The fact is that the growth of a natural {koto. v kpyiav «rriv, to. 8k kvk\

iyra toiovtov tlvai. Is it not barely possible that to. 8k kuk\