[
{
"id": "jstor-261354",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Companion to Greek Studies",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to sum up clearly the main results of explorations in fields to which he has devoted less attention",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Handbook review; deficiencies of references and cross-references.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261355",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kaiser Hadrian und der letzte grosse Historiker von Rom (Kornemann)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Both works deal with the sources and reliability of the Scriptores Historiae Augustae, particularly of the life of Hadrian",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "he is inclined to reject more as later forgery or interpolation",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Quellenkritik of SHA; single Anonymous source detected by tendency across lives; D2 for interpolation judgments.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261356",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Progress of Hellenism in Alexander's Empire (Mahaffy)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he moves about with perfect mastery in this most difficult and most unsatisfactory, perhaps, of all great historical periods",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261357",
"kind": "review",
"title": "University of California Publications, Classical Philology, Vol. I",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This paper shows the certain though vanishing use of the digamma in melic poetry.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261358"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261359",
"kind": "review",
"title": "On the Influence of Lucretius on Horace (Merrill)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "that Horace was influenced by Lucretius in early life (Sermones), only slightly in the Odes i-iii, again in Epp. i",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261360"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261361",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Archiloque, sa vie et ses poésies (Hauvette)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The time is opportune for a re-examination of his life and art.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261362",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Reden und Aufsätze von Theodor Mommsen",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Otto Hirschfeld issues this selection from the addresses and other writings of the master",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261363",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Index Phaedrianus",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Good indices of the ancient writers are, as the author of this work maintains, greatly to be desired.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261364",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Handlexikon zu Cicero (Merguet)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it gives his complete vocabulary, hitherto available only in the Thesaurus Ciceronianus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261365",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Criticisms and Elucidations of Catullus (Munro)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The first, on Cat. 63. 18 (p. 143), proposes to read hilarate procitatis for hilarate erocitatis of cod. O",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The emendation will hardly find acceptance.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer rejects Munro's conjectures and defends the transmitted text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261366",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Evidence in Athenian Courts (Bonner)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to deal with the whole subject of evidence in the courts of ancient Athens from the stand- point of English law",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262264",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A History of Rome during the Later Republic and Early Principate (Greenidge)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to cover the history of Rome from the beginning of the Gracchan period to the accession of Vespasian",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262266",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, Vol. XVI",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "A Preliminary Study of Certain Manuscripts of Suetonius' Lives of the Caesars",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "He has shown con- clusively that these late MSS may not safely be ignored.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Volume review; lead article brings late MSS into Suetonius recension.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262267",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Brygos: His Characteristics (Tonks)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "an attempt to determine the characteristics by which the vases of Brygos may be distinguished from those of other vase-painters",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Vase-painter attribution: not D3 per rules.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262268",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cours d'épigraphie latine, Supplément (Cagnat)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This small brochure presents Addenda et Corrigenda to the author's third edition of his Cours d'ipigraphie latine",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262269",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Inscriptiones Graecae ad res Romanas pertinentes",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "this collection of inscriptions, most of them scat- tered in jotirnals and monographs inaccessible to most students",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "A goodly number of improved readings and restorations have been introduced into the text; but much remains to be done",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262270",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Attraction of Mood in Early Latin (Frank)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This paper discusses the origin of the so-called",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262271",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Primer of Classical and English Philology (Skeat)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "for all the topics chosen for exposition have to do with the relations of Greek, Latin, and English sounds",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262272"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262273",
"kind": "review",
"title": "On the Syntax of Some Prepositions in the Greek Dialects (Kellerman)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This dissertation discusses the syntax of certain prepositions of allied meaning as found in the Greek dialects.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262274",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De sermone Ennodiano (Trahey)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "While the style of Ennodius is on the whole less elegant than that of Hieronymus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-3286898",
"kind": "article",
"title": "Philology and Classical Philology",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The professor of Greek is appropriately put forward as the talk- ing delegate of classical philology",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-05-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262018",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Greek Thinkers, Vols. II and III (Gomperz)",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "not to hunt for flaws and self-contradictions which in at least nine cases out of ten prove to be misapprehensions of the interpreter",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey resolves alleged contradictions in Plato by the unity of his thought.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262019",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Untersuchungen zur Geschichte von Iran (Marquart)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dealing exhaustively with numerous details of Iranian chronology and topography",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262020",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Papers of the British School at Rome, Vols. I-II",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "to determine the course of each of the three main roads (with their branches) which traverse the district under consideration",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262021",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Study of the Case Construction of Words of Time (Brown)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the accusative case is usually aided in the expression of duration by the meaning of the noun denoting time",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262022",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Poetic Element in the Satires and Epistles of Horace (Edwards)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The author has collected carefully the passages of Horace's satirical writings which reveal in any way a more manifest poetical treatment.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262023",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Metaphor and Comparison in the Dialogues of Plato (Berg)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "will serve as a convenient tabulation of the more important tropes em- ployed by Plato",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262024",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch as a Source of Information on the Greek Theater (Flickinger)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Plutarch modernizes most of his allusions to all matters pertaining to the theater to fit the theater of his own day",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262026",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roman Historical Sources and Institutions (Michigan Studies I)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the custom of punishing traitors by hurling them from the cliff gave rise to an aetiological story",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262027",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der illustrierte lateinische Aesop in der Handschrift des Ademar (Thiele)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "presents a new text of these fables and discusses in considerable detail their relation to Phaedrus and Romulus",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the Romulus fables of Ademar represent a text-recension, not so far removed as has been supposed from the other Romulus collections",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262077",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sprache als Schöpfung und Entwicklung (Vossler)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Vossler rightly insists that all linguistic investigation should start with the indi- vidual's concrete utterance",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262078",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristophanis Ecclesiazusae (van Leeuwen)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "In the matter of the constitution of the text van Leeuwen's attitude toward the tradition of the MSS certainly does not appear to be chan- ging sensibly in",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "we find prac- tically three dozen brand-new emendations all told admitted into the text",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; editor departs freely from MSS; reviewer reports and judges.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262079",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thesaurus linguae Latinae epigraphicae (Olcott)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the Herculean task of compiling a well-ordered, complete lexicon of the more than -200,000 Latin inscriptions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262081",
"kind": "review",
"title": "L'administration financière du sanctuaire pythique (Bourguet)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The methods of administration and control adopted for the discharge of this task, and the constitution, responsibilities, and conduct of the various boards",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262082",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Holzsarkophage aus der Zeit Alexanders des Grossen (Watzinger)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The present monograph gives an account of this cemetery and its contents",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262083",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Forum Romanum, seine Geschichte und seine Denkmäler (Hülsen)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the history of the development of the Forum in antiquity, in its various relations to Roman life",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262084",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Roman Forum, its History and its Monuments (Hülsen, tr. Carter)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author has made the few changes necessary to bring the book down to date",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262085",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Quellen und Untersuchungen zur lateinischen Philologie des Mittelalters I.1: Sedulius Scottus (Hellmann)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "that fusion of the sciences of history, paleography, and the transmission of texts which gives an indispensable clue to the investigator of the early Middle Ages",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "pointing out that the title, formerly given to Sedulius' work — De regimine principum — is unauthentic",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Medieval Latin; new text from all MSS, MS classification, title judged unauthentic.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262086",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Campaign of Plataea (Wright)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Wright has reopened the difficult question of the detailed movements of the battle of Plataea",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The writer first establishes the theory that Herodotus' account of the campaign took its final form during the opening years of the Peloponnesian War",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 for a Periclean redaction in the composition of Herodotus' account.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262088",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Meaning of ΓΑΡ (Misener)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "all of (sic) the meanings of yap are derivatives, more or less remote, of the reason-idea which it primarily conveyed",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262089",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Athener Nationalmuseum (Svoronos)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The scheme of the entire publication includes marble sculptures, bronzes, vases, gems, and other small objects",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262090",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Case Constructions with Similis and its Compounds (Jones)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "marks not a logical distinction, but one partly of time, partly of style. He holds that the genitive was originally characteristic",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262091",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Priests of Asklepios: A New Method of Dating Athenian Archons (Ferguson)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the fixed official order of the tribes was followed in the selection of certain annually elected officers at Athens",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262092",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aischylos' Choephoren (Blass)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In the commentary exegesis, though not neglected, is subordinated to the critical recension of the text.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Professor Blass himself probably does not believe that it is possible to restore with certainty the hand of Aeschylus in the corrupt choruses",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Blass's recension emends freely; Shorey defends transmitted readings at several loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1906-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-3292089",
"kind": "article",
"title": "The Progress of Classical Philology",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The startling discoveries of new material, resulting from the systematic exploration of the Mediterranean countries",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Survey of the field 1875-1900 based on Kroll.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1906-12-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261667",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Evidence of Greek Papyri with regard to Textual Criticism (Kenyon)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "review of the principal results obtained by the help of the papyri concerning the text of extant Greek authors",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Byzantine copyists have not done any great harm to these texts",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Papyri largely confirm medieval tradition; early Homer papyri add spurious verses; counsels distrust of conjecture.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261668",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Topographie von Athen (Judeich)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it has enabled the author to give us a complete and scientific guide to the monuments of Athens",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261669",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grundriss der römischen Geschichte, nebst Quellenkunde (Niese)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a simple sketch of the external history of Rome from the foundation of the city to the beginning of the Middle Ages",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261670",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aesthetischer Kommentar zur Odyssee (Altendorf)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Altendorf tries to re-establish belief in the unity of the Odyssey by arguments applying to it as a whole and in detail",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Hence the Odyssey is one single creation, each part related closely with the whole, and all the work of a single poet.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Unity of one poem against analysts (D2, not D3); whole-poem unity then used to defend suspected passages.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261672",
"kind": "review",
"title": "On the Language of Vitruvius (Morgan)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Ussing attempted to show that the De architectura of Vitruvius was written about the middle of the third century by an amateur",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "nearly all the peculiarities in language and style which are cited by Ussing as characteristic of late Latin may be paralleled in Republican, Augustan, or Silver Latin",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Date of a work argued from language; late dating refuted feature by feature.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261673",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grundzüge der Sprachpsychologie I (Dittrich)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "what promises to be the most exhaust- ive treatise on the psychology of language yet undertaken",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261674",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De tragoediarum Graecarum conformatione scaenica ac dramatica (Detscheff)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a study of the changes produced in Greek tragedy by the addition of the second and third actor",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261675",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Heinrich Brunn's Kleine Schriften II",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "It is, furthermore, an advantage to be able to study Brunn's method, to observe his development",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Collected essays of a modern archaeologist; review dwells on his method.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261676",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Prometheus of Aeschylus (Harry)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the ample space for notes is occupied for the most part with a vast number of illustrative quotations",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261678",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Four Plays of Euripides (Verrall)",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Mr. Verrall's guiding principle is that Euripides, being a great poet, cannot possibly be guilty of the artistic sins which sober criticism discovers in his plays.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Mr. Verrall proves that the Helena could not have been originally written for the Attic stage.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Verrall resolves artistic faults by rationalist readings; D2 for occasion of the Helena; reviewer satirizes.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261679",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Romanorum iuris publici sacrique vocabulis solemnibus in Graecum sermonem conversis (Magie)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "a practically exhaustive tabular list (pp. 43-154) of the Greek expressions used, from the beginning of the second century b.c. to the reign of Diocletian",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261680",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Index etymologicus dictionis Homericae (Mendes da Costa)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "consists of an etymological grouping of the Homeric vocabulary",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261681",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studien zur Ilias (Wecklein)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "presents a view of the composition of the Iliad which is based upon Grote's theory of an original Iliad and an Achilleid",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "This Iliad was a comparatively commonplace and ordinary poem, and may have been composed by several popular poets",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Wecklein assigns Urilias to several popular poets, Achilleid to a master-poet (D3 secondary); reviewer finds it unconvincing in detail.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261682",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Index verborum Propertianus (Phillimore)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The new index is practically a register of the words found in the Oxford edition",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261683",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Supplementary Papers of the American School of Classical Studies in Rome, Vol. I",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "the scientific study, by Messrs. Pfeiffer, Van Buren, and Armstrong, of all the brick- stamps",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261684",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Metaphorical Terminology of Greek Rhetoric and Literary Criticism (Van Hook)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Pp. 12-44 are devoted to a classification and definition of terms.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261685",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Selections from the Greek Lyric Poets (Tyler)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "will make a convenient textbook for those American college students who are appalled by the erudition of Smyth",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262137",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Religion of Numa, and Other Essays (Carter)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Carter ascribes the religious development from the beginning of the republic to the Second Punic War, to the direct influence of the Sibylline books",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262138",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roman Society from Nero to Marcus Aurelius (Dill)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "has given us a graphic pic- ture of the more important elements in Roman society in the Antonine age",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262139",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Papyri medizinischen und naturwissenschaftlichen Inhalts (Kalbfleisch and Schöne)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The third part of the Berlin Classical Texts contains nine rather fragmentary papyri and one parchment",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262140",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Idle Actor in Aeschylus (Dignan)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The most frequent cause for the idleness of an actor was the primitive theater.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262141",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Glossemata de Prudentio (Burnham)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "both come from a common archetype, of Celtic origin, of the period of 650-750 a. d.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "is corroborated by the lemma of the Glossemata.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition of medieval glosses from two MSS traced to one archetype; a disputed Prudentius reading supported.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262143",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bacchylides, The Poems and Fragments (Jebb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "It is neither desirable nor possible in our space to discuss the endless questions of text and interpretation suggested by Jebb's Bacchylides",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "His astonishing virtuosity fills long lacunae with verse which, if not what Bacchylides actually wrote, is what he would gladly have signed",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "both",
"note": "Shorey discusses renderings of single phrases; D1 for conjectural supplements of lacunae.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262144",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in Roman History (Hardy)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The first ten essays are a reprint of the author's book on Christianity and the Roman Government.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262145"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262146",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Romanization of Roman Britain (Haverfield)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "presents in simple form the sum of our knowledge of the extent and character of the Roman civilization in the island",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262148",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Syntax of the Boeotian Dialect Inscriptions (Claflin)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "a general view of the syntax of the dialect as a whole, rather than a mere summary of pecul- iarities",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262149",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Signacula medicorum oculariorum (Espérandieu)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This is the formal publication of the interesting epigraphic monu- ments known as oculists' seals",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262236",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das attische Recht und Rechtsverfahren I (Lipsius)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "opens with a historical sketch of the administration of justice in Greece",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262237",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der Blitz in der orientalischen und griechischen Kunst (Jacobsthal)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Babylonian and Assyrian art invented certain closely related symbols for the thunderbolt",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262238",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ancient Legends of Roman History (Pais)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "not only can no confidence be placed in any portion of the canonical version of the history of Rome before the Gallic invasion",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262239",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, Vol. XVII",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Professor Morgan's observations on Vitruvius confirm his previous study in the conclusion that the author's language is thoroughly in keeping with the traditional date",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the author's language is thoroughly in keeping with the traditional date which makes him an Augustan",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Volume review; D2 for Vitruvius date; Howard on Livy and Valerius Antias (E) also judged.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262240",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De epigrammatis Simonideis I (Boas)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "How do we come by our collection of poems, which we ascribe to this author?",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "How do we come by our collection of poems, which we ascribe to this author?",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Tradition of the Simonidean sylloge; few epigrams under Simonides' name held genuinely his (corpus partition, D3 secondary).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262241",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Erichthonius and the Three Daughters of Cecrops (Powell)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "This thesis contains a good statement of the story of Erichthonius and the Cecropides in literature and art.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262242",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Prellwitz, Etymologisches Worterbuch der griechischen Sprache",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A lamentable number of incorrect Germanic forms have crept in, most of them no doubt due to the printer.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262243",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rostowzew, Romische Bleitesserae",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "with important conclusions as to the vari- ous uses for which they were employed, and their significance.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262244",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Baumann, Sprachpsychologie und Sprachunterricht",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Baumann warns against the exaggerated importance attached by many adherents of the reform movement to the spoken language",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262245",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Decharme, Euripides and the Spirit of His Dramas, tr. Loeb",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He enlarges upon the influence which Euripides has exercised on the moderns. But that test would put Seneca above Aeschylus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262246",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Foster, Dio's Rome",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "shows that Professor Poster has made a very accurate rendering of the History into smooth, idiomatic English.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an English translation; translation as transmission.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262247",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Angus, The Sources of the First Ten Books of Augustine's De civitate Dei",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "For his survey of Roman history in the early books Augustine is shown to have used Florus and Eutropius, as well as Sallust and Livy.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262248",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sanders, The Cynegeticus",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The aim of Dr. Sanders is to throw light upon the problem of the authorship of the Cynegeticus",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The thesis cannot be said to make any real contribution to the settlement of the problem discussed.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Sanders argues Xenophontine date/locality from allusions and topography; reviewer rejects, leaving authorship unsettled.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262249",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Leage, Roman Private Law",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a systematic treatise which presents in an un- usually clear and analytical form the subject-matter of the institutional writings.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262250",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Postgate, Tibulli aliorumque carminum libri tres",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "This convenient little edition will at once take its place as the most useful text of Tibullus in the market.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "text quite where he found it, and the compact little appa- ratus contributes a goodly number of suggestions",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of a conservative Oxford text whose apparatus adds conjectures.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262251",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Martini and Bassi, Catalogus codicum Graecorum bibliothecae Ambrosianae",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a trustworthy account of the contents of the 1,098 Greek manuscripts, com- prehending about 2,500 works",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "No errors of scribes are corrected, but all are scrupulously indicated.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Manuscript catalogue: describes the tradition's holdings; no standing questioned.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262252",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Endt, Studien zum Commentator Cruquianus",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "The object of these studies, a product, apparently, of the Horatian school of O. Keller, is to prove the worthlessness of the Commentator Cruquianus",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "until such demonstration is made Horatian scholars may be pardoned for using, though with great reserve and caution, matter derived from the Commentator Cruquianus.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Endt impugns the scholia source; reviewer keeps its cautious standing.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262253",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dieterich, Mutter Erde",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He deals therefore with the mysteries of birth, death, and a second birth from the common mother Earth.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262342",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Leo, Der saturnische Vers; Thulin, Italische sakrale Poesie und Prosa; DuBois, The Stress Accent in Latin Poetry",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The appearance within a period of twelve months of three books devoted mainly to a study of the Saturnian verse",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262343",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ryan, Lowe, Friedlander, Petronius: Cena Trimalchionis",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "His rendering is often vigorous and happy, but it is disfigured by numerous errors.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Review judging translations and notes on the sense of passages.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262344",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Goodwin, Demosthenes against Meidias",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Demosthenes against Meidias. With Critical and Explanatory Notes and an Appendix. By W. W. Goodwin.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "In § 35 he reads with Schafer",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; one adopted supplement noted.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262345",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Croiset, Aristophane et les partis a Athenes",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he is nowhere at enmity with the democratic principle.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262346",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wagner, Symbolarum ad comicorum Graecorum historiam criticam capita quattuor",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "In approaching the complex and difficult problem as to the nature, authorship, and authority of these biographical notices",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Eight lemmata, however (pp. 44 ff.), are shown to be due to an interpolator of Suidas, who made use of Athenaeus and is detected by his blunders.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: proves the tragic and comic Timocles distinct makers; formula criterion decides attribution of Suidas lemmata.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262347",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Helbig, Sur les attributs des Saliens",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "endeavors to prove that it was identical with that of the Koman patrician warrior down to the seventh century",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262348",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Blass, Die Rhythmen der asianischen und romischen Kunstprosa",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author proceeds to trace the origin of the Asian rhythmic in the Hellenistic age, as a development out of the Attic rhythm",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262349",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fraenkel, Griechische Denominativa",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The author rejects the current view that verbs in -ovv owe their origin to adjectives in -wros (pp. 104 ff.)",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262350",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Papers of the British School at Rome, Vol. III",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The most interesting part of the investigation is the determination of the lines of the roads",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262351",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Pascal, Seneca",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "He shows that Tacitus is quite in contradiction with himself in his varying references to Seneca",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Inconsistency in Tacitus resolved by appeal to unharmonized sources.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262354",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Baden, The Principal Figures of Language and Figures of Thought in Isaeus and the Guardianship-Speeches of Demosthenes",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The author's purpose in this dissertation is to determine the extent to which Demosthenes was influenced by Isaeus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262356",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Canter, The Infinitive Constructions in Livy",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The dissertation of Dr. Canter presents a collection of all the infini- tives found in Livy",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262357",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Conybeare and Stock, Selections from the Septuagint",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Sect. 54 of the Grammar quotes Ps. 51. 6 as a certain instance of accusative for vocative",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School reader with grammar of Septuagint Greek; review dwells on grammar and diction.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262358",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Solmsen, Inscriptiones Graecae ad inlustrandas dialectos selectae",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "It is to be regretted that the author has retained the Doric accent even within the limitations explained in the Preface, p. iv.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262359",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rand, Johannes Scotus",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "He has prepared a critical edition of a ninth- century commentary on Boethius' Opuscula sacra, and by careful and cogent reasoning ascribes it with every probability to Johannes Scotus himself.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the phraseology and imagery are so similar as to compel the assumption of a common origin.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review accepts Rand's ascription of the Boethius commentary to Scotus against Usener's earlier dating; style convergence decides attribution.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262360",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dreyer, History of the Planetary Systems from Thales to Kepler",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The history of Greek astronomy has a twofold interest.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262361",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hirschfeld, Die kaiserlichen Verwaltungsbeamten bis auf Diocletian",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "which has been so useful to students of Koman imperial history since its publica- tion a generation ago.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262362",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Scherling, De vocis skene quantum ad theatrum Graecum pertinet significatione et usu",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Although much has been written on the terminology of the Greek theater, no one term has received thoroughgoing attention.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1907-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262044",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hoffmann, Die Makedonen, ihre Sprache und ihr Volkstum",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The question is, as admitted on all sides, really the linguistic one, Was the speech of the Macedonians a dialect of Greek?",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262045",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Breal, Pour mieux connaitre Homere",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "composed neither by a single author nor by a crowd, but by an organized group of poets who were charged with the celebration of religious festivals in Asia Minor",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "The homo- geneity of the epic verse, by itself, would disprove the views of Lachmann.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: Breal assigns the Homeric poems to an organized group of poets, against both single author and Lachmannian layers; verse homogeneity decides.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262047",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Beare, Greek Theories of Elementary Cognition from Alcmaeon to Aristotle",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The 'higher' reaches of philosophy, or metaphysic, are purposely disregarded by the author in order to limit the inquiry to the problems of empirical psychology.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262048",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hahn, Rom und Romanismus im griechisch-romischen Osten",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Each chapter contains a brief historical sketch, followed by a considera- tion of the Latin elements in the writers and in the inscriptions of the period.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262050",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kunze, Die Germanen in der antiken Literatur",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a series of selections from Latin writers illustrating early German history from Augustus to the conquest of Italy by Theodoric the Great.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School source-reader; reviewed for its selection of sources.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262051",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Elderkin, Aspects of the Speech in the Later Greek Epic",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The author proposes to compare the speech in the later Greek epics, particularly in Quintus of Smyrna, with that in Homer.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262052",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Legras, Etude sur la Thebaide de Stace",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The twenty-six subdivisions or episodes of the Thebaid are discussed in detail, and referred to their origin",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262054",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lanciani, The Golden Days of the Renaissance in Rome",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "describes the condition of the city itself and of the monuments of antiquity, and their treatment by popes and cardinals.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262055",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mahaffy, The Silver Age of the Greek World",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The work belongs, in fact, to 1890, not to 1906.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262056",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Otto, Priester und Tempel im hellenistischen Aegypten",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "he passes to an exhaustive treatment of the organization of the priesthood.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262057",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Drumann, Geschichte Roms, 2nd ed. Groebe, Bd. III",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a review of Caesar's exploits, with which it is almost exclusively concerned, supplemented by the necessary study of the movements of his rival, Pompey",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262058",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Clark, Asconius; Fisher, Tacitus Annales (Oxford texts)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The transmission of Asconius is through a manuscript found by Poggio at St. Gall in 1416, which has since disappeared.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "has given a conservative text, following the codd. Medicei in a number of places where the other editors have departed from them.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of two editions; Clark identifies the Matritensis as Poggio's lost copy and reconstructs it; Fisher conservative.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262059",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Crumley, On the Social Standing of Freedmen as Indicated in the Latin Writers",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "comes to the conclusion that libertus always means 'one who has been freed from slavery,'",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262061",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plenkers, Untersuchungen zur Ueberlieferungsgeschichte der altesten lateinischen Monchsregeln",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "Traube showed that the older extant MSS of the Benedictine rule represent a later and interpolated edition",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Plenkers' minute investigations confirm Traube's general results decis- ively.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Manuscript tradition of the Regula Benedicti; new Spanish and Treves MSS corroborate Traube.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262062",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ross, Aristotle, De Sensu and De Memoria",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Dr. Ross's edition of the De sensu and De memoria is a revision of a doctoral dissertation",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "The text is that of Biehl, with slight changes which are noted.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition follows Biehl; reviewer corrects readings at particular loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262063",
"kind": "review",
"title": "von Garnier, Die Praposition als sinnverstarkendes Prafix",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "are found to have an intensive force in composition. This always bears some relation to the original local sense",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262064",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Richardson, Horace's Alcaic Strophe",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This paper answers statistically the question, How did Horace arrange words, regarded pmely as groups of syllables",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261748",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mackail, Select Epigrams from the Greek Anthology, 2nd ed.",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In I. 39. 4. ov <jy66vo<s KaroTTTcvav is now rendered, may look down ungrudgingly, which surely perverts the meaning",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Review weighs revised translations and selection; text changes few.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261749",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Barker, The Political Thought of Plato and Aristotle",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "it gradually grew into what is virtvially a history of Greek political thought to the death of Aristotle",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "These lecture notes pre- served in the Peripatetic school and the Alexandrian library were put together from the private copy of Theophrastus",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: the Politics reported as three lecture courses assembled by Roman editors, not a continuous treatise.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261750",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bondurant, Decimus Junius Brutus Albinus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "gives in detail the life, character and influence of Decimus Brutus, estab- lishing the various facts by full citation of authorities.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261751",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hope, The Language of Parody; a Study of the Diction of Aristophanes",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "there has been no systematic treatment of the language of parody with a collection of the words by which parodic effects were secured.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261752",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tucker, The Frogs of Aristophanes",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Whoever henceforth shall teach the Frogs in English, ignorant of this edition",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "marking the sentence as unfinished and obviating emendation.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; readings kept with the MSS at several loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261753",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wright, A Short History of Greek Literature from Homer to Julian",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In a small book which contains the history of the rich literature of more than a thousand years much must necessarily be omitted",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Handbook of literary history; review judges proportion and coverage.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261754",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wecklein, Ausgewahlte Tragodien des Euripides: Elektra; Orestes",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The general characteristics of Wecklein's annotated editions of the plays of Euripides are too familiar to readers of this journal",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the usual date 413 (or 414) is accepted as most probable in view of the historical allusions",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School editions; review reports the received date accepted.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261755",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Adams, Lysias, Selected Speeches",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Many of the notes are models of terse expression, especially on points of syntax and the use of particles.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition; review weighs its commentary on syntax and the style of Lysias.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261756"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261757",
"kind": "review",
"title": "DeWitt, The Dido Episode in the Aeneid of Virgil",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "In a word, \"Aeneas did not love Dido.\" Is this conclusion correct?",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261758",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Behn, Die ficoronische Cista",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "On epigraphical grounds the author assigns the cista to the period 400-380 b. c.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261760",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Altmann, Die romischen Grabaltare der Kaiserzeit; Olcott, Thesaurus Linguae Latinae Epigraphicae",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "These Dr. Altmann has classified into groups according to the leading motives of their sculptured decoration.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261801",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Radermacher, M. Fabi Quintiliani Institutionis Oratoriae Libri xii, Pars Prior",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Complete editions of Quintilian recur in cycles, it would seem, of about twenty years.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He holds fast (Praef., p. vi) to the established division of the MSS into three main families",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of a critical edition; reviewer urges the Harleianus for readings at loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261802",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Renkema, Observationes criticae et exegeticae ad C. Valerii Flacci Argonautica",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Renkema adds several new emenda- tions to the already large collection",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "not open to any real doubt in the passage of Valerius.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261804",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ausfeld, Der griechische Alexanderroman, ed. Kroll",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The book contains a statement of the manuscript relations which make it possible to establish the third-century a. d. text",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Single brackets are used in the translation to segregate what, in Ausfeld's judgment, is the story proper from the accretions",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Composition analysis: a self-consistent original history separated from later accretions and interpolations.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261805",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ihm, C. Suetoni Tranquilli de Vita Caesarum Libri VIII",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Ihm follows Traube in regarding as the archetype of the existing MSS the lost Fuldensis",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "many though not all of them showing a return to the readings of the archetype",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Recension of Suetonius; reviewer faults the editor for discounting late MSS readings.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261806",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grenfell and Hunt, The Hibeh Papyri, Part I",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Texts of nearly one hundred documents of the third century b. c, together with descriptions of half as many more, constitute the bulk of the volume.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "instead of being representatives of an equal or earlier type of text.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: eccentric Ptolemaic Homer papyri against Ludwich's vulgate-priority view.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261807",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schroeder, Sophoclis Cantica",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Professor Schroeder follows up his Aeschyli Cantica by a similar metrical analysis of the choruses of Sophocles.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261808",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Jordan, Topographie der Stadt Rom im Alterthum, I.3, ed. Hulsen",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It contains the detailed description and discussion of the topography and monuments of Rome",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261810",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Nitsche, Demosthenes und Anaximenes",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "that Anaximenes is the real author of some of the works now included among the writings of the great orator.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Nitsche seems to prove that Anaximenes is the author of the fourth Philippic",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: partition of the Demosthenic corpus, with speeches, prooemia and letters assigned to Anaximenes; Didymus find plus common-author recognition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261811",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Shawyer, The Menexenus of Plato",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This little book reproduces Burnet's Oxford text of the Menexenus, adding a brightly written Introduction",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This little book reproduces Burnet's Oxford text of the Menexenus",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition reproducing the received Oxford text; introduction touches authenticity without reported verdict.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261812",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Herkenrath, Der Enoplios",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dr. Herkenrath analyzes the entire body of extant Greek lyric and choric verse in order to establish two con- clusions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261813",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mayser, Grammatik der griechischen Papyri aus der Ptolemaerzeit",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "It furnishes an exhaustive and orderly exhibit of the facts so far as they fall under the heads of Lautlehre and Wortlehre",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261814",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Meillet, De quelques innovations de la declinaison latine",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the contention that the -em of hostem, etc., is not due to the analogy of consonant stems, but comes from -im by phonetic change.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261815"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261817",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Miller, The Tragedies of Seneca, translated into English verse",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "It is not the gods that Pyrrhus is advised to fear, but the excessive prosperity which they have bestowed on him",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Where he differs from Leo, he has almost always taken the conservative position.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review; the opening page also carries Nairn's De Sacerdotio. D1 secondary covers the translator's readings against Leo.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261818",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lermann, Altgriechische Plastik",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "the series of twenty colored plates giving in actual size the painted patterns on the dresses of the archaic female statues of the Athenian acropolis.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261819",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Collignon, Scopas et Praxitele",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "it deals not only with Scopas and Praxiteles, but with Greek sculpture generally from the beginning of the fourth century",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261820",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Emerson, The Art Institute of Chicago: Illustrated Catalogue of the Antiquities and Casts of Ancient Sculpture",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the greater part of the two volumes (pp. 33-237) being devoted to casts of early Greek sculpture",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261424",
"kind": "article",
"title": "Is There a Science of Classical Philology?",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "The aim of this science is understood to be the ideal reconstruction of Greek and Roman culture",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Presidential address on the discipline, its history from Wolf and its aims.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261434",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Weber, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte des Kaisers Hadrianus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Weber makes extensive use of coins for the purpose of settling the order in which the various provinces were visited.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261435",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Pais, Ancient Italy, tr. Curtis",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he rejects the first secession as a mere anticipation of the second, which he considers genuine",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261436",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Seymour, Life in the Homeric Age",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It is, however, too much in the form of a manual of Homeric antiquities to be readable as a whole",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261437",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Life in the Homeric Age (Seymour); Inscriptiones Graecae ad res Romanas pertinentes",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Recent interest in the discussion of Homeric \"War and Arms\" may justify a hundred and twenty-four pages devoted to them",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261438",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ancient Britain and the Invasions of Julius Caesar (Holmes)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "upon most of the vexed questions connected with the two expeditions of Caesar into Britain this book is a final and authoritative publication",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261439",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Modificirung der Maske in der griechischen Tragodie (Hense)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he has gathered all the instances in the texts of the extant plays where there is indication of a change of expression",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261440",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Il concetto della vita nella Filosofia greca (Modugno)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This is a pleasantly written survey of the history of Greek thought from the point of view apparently of scientific positivism.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the close of the Hense review; Modugno is a general survey of Greek thought.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261441"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261442",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Platon und die Aristotelische Poetik (Finsler)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "He shows how its ideas are develop- ments or supplements, or conscious contradictions of the ideas of Plato",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261443",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Xenophon's Hellenica (Marchant, Underhill); Ancient Sinope (Robinson)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The text utilizes papyri fragments, published in 1898, containing portions of i. 2, 2-5, 8 and iii. 1, 3-7.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "It is exceedingly conservative, and the critical notes are scanty, though well enough selected.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reissued edition; papyri variants reported as unimportant, text conservative.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261444"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261445",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Les religions orientales dans le paganisme romain (Cumont)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Its purpose is to put the world at large in possession of the vital facts and conclusions drawn from the study of the oriental reli- gions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261446",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die italischen Rundbauten (Altmann)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author undertakes to show that the circular structure was originally the prevailing form throughout Europe",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the close of the Cumont review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1908-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262433",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Religionsphilosophie Kaiser Julians (Mau)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Mau's monograph is the first systematic attempt to trace in the emperor's two",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262434",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grundriss der Geschichte der klassischen Philologie (Gudeman)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Every American philologian who loves the history of his subject is well acquainted veith Dr. Gudeman's \"Outlines\" of that history",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262435",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lexicon Plautinum (Lodge)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In other words, it is very doubtful if contra should ever be taken as a preposition in Plautus.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262436",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Singular und Plural (Witte)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "as a study of language and the development in syntax the book is of unusual merit",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "is a clever and interesting piece of linguistic dexterity, but will convince no one inclined to doubt",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Witte stratifies Homer and dates verses (e.g. W. and D. 753 interpolated) by number usage; reviewer rejects the stratification.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262437",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Tebtunis Papyri, Part II (Grenfell, Hunt, Goodspeed)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "found great quantities of papyri at the site of the ancient Teb- tunis, in the Fayum",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "suffices to show that these lines represent a tradition dif- ferent from that of other MSS",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262438",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Greatness and Decline of Rome (Ferrero)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the Roman world-conquest was the effect of an internal transformation which is continually being re-enacted in the history of societies",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262439",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Feste (Nilsson); Leges Graecorum sacrae (Ziehen)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Students of Greek religion have long felt the need of a comprehensive treatment of the religious festivals outside of Athens.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262440",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Prophetarum Vitae Fabulosae (Schermann)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Of the six recensions of the Greek text which he distinguishes, the oldest is an anonymous work derived ultimately from Origen.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Others are falsely ascribed to Epiphanius, Dorotheus, Hip- polytus, and Symeon Logothetes.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Recensions and false ascriptions of late texts; not a partition of an authorial corpus, so not D3.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262441"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262444",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Loeb Collection of Arretine Pottery (Chase)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "the signatures of the pro- prietors of factories and of the slaves in their employ",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262445"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262446",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristophanis Pax (van Leeuwen), continued; Plutarch MSS (Ziegler)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the rejection of vss. 417, 831, 1002; the insertion of an entire verse after 1243",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "in a large number of instances he defends the traditional text against the attacks of various critics",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page carries the end of the Pax review (emendations and defences of the text) and the end of Ziegler on the Plutarch MSS.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262447",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De inventione Iuvenalis capita tria (Hartmann)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The author of the dissertation is concerned primarily with a compara- tive study of Juvenal and earlier satirists.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-4385989",
"kind": "article",
"title": "The New Classical Philology",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "we must investigate the development of clas- sical studies, in order fully to appreciate their pres- ent status",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-03-20",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261832",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hegemonius: Acta Archelai (Beeson)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dr. Beeson's edition has the distinction of being the first that is really complete",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Dr. Beeson holds Hegemonius to be the author of the work",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition from a newly used complete MS (Traube); attribution to Hegemonius upheld.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261833",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vorgriechische Ortsnamen (Fick)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "He has attempted to distinguish in detail between genuine Greek and originally foreign",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261834",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die altesten Kalendarien aus Monte Cassino (Loew)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "he set himself to ascertain their exact relation- ship and history",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Now that Dr. Loew has shown us that 779 is a wrong dating and that the MS may have been written at any time between 779 and 787",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Redates MSS (Isidore, Keil grammarians) by palaeography; received dating overturned.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261835",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Attica of Pausanias (Carroll)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the comparative unimportance of the topography of Megara and of Attica outside of Athens might have made it seem justifiable to omit these entirely",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the close of the Loew review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261836",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der neue Menander (Robert)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "show how mistaken was the attempt to reconstruct the pagination of the Cairo MS",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "a non intellegitur is more helpful to other scholars than an unsupported conjecture",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Robert fills gaps from plot presuppositions; reviewer, with Korte's new inspection of the papyrus, rejects this.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261837",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Catulli Veronensis Liber (Friedrich)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "He believes, with K. P. Schulze, that O and G are both direct copies of the lost Veronensis",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "But his treatment of critical prob- lems is too often characterized by unsafe methods.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer defends MS readings (e.g. 47. 2 mundi) against Friedrich's emendations.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261838",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Q. Horati Flacci Carmina (Vollmer); Aristotelis de Animalibus Historia (Dittmeyer)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Many important conclusions are based on hypotheses which are not adequately supported by the evidence",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The seventh and ninth books, with the last ten chapters of the eighth, which had been called in question by Aubert and Wimmer, are also rejected",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Vollmer's stemma rests on order of poems, errors, scholia; reviewer rejects it. Dittmeyer rejects books VII, IX, X as spurious.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261840",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Carl Otfried Muller: Lebensbild in Briefen (Kern)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Most readers of Classical Philology are familiar with the important contributions made by Carl Otfried Mtiller to the cause of classical studies.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the end of the Dittmeyer review (emendations).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261841",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die meteorologischen Theorien des griechischen Altertums (Gilbert)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Die meteorologischen Theorien des griechischen Altertums. Von Otto Gilbert.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract shows only the title of the Gilbert review; the rest is the Muller letters and Misch.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261842",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Geschichte der Autobiographie, I (Misch)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The nearest approach to formal autobiography in what the author calls the Hellenic and Attic periods of literature is found in the oratorical apologia pro vita sua",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261843",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Anthropology and the Classics (Marett, ed.)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "discoursing with great wealth of illustration on \"the European diffusion of pictography and its bearings on the origin of Script.\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "His essential unity is sufficiently demonstrated by the typical truth of his description of loose early feudalism",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Lang's lecture: consistent sub-Minoan picture excludes archaizing poets or a committee; one maker for Homer (D3).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261845",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Athenian Lekythoi (Fairbanks)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "This book is a careful classification and discussion of Athenian lecythi from about 475-430 b. c.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261846",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grammaticae Romanae Fragmenta (Funaioli)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "This is a collection of all extant fragments that have to do with grammatical questions",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Ordi- narily reference to modern literature is given only in matters of textual criticism, or in questions of genuineness.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition of fragments; no standing put in question; direction weak.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261847",
"kind": "review",
"title": "METANOEO and METAMELEI in Greek Literature (Thompson)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A distinction of meaning between the two groups of words is maintained fairly well in classic writers, the Septuagint, and the New Testament",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261848",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Horazstudien (Beck)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "This pamphlet contains an elaborate criticism of Vollmer's views of the interrelation of the Horatian MSS.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "insists that in many cases the alleged error is the right reading",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Beck defends MS readings; denies alleged common errors can build a stemma.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261850",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Johannis Vahleni opuscula academica II; Diogenes von Apollonia (Krause)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "they were intended not only to vindicate or amend or interpret the texts of classical authors, but also to serve as examples of critical method",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262403",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cicero, Divinatio in Q. Caecilium, in C. Verrem IV (Nohl)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Nohl follows Eberhard in reading, without any MS authority, illigabant",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The editor seems to be wrong in eliminating item in §5, against the evidence of all the codices",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262404",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Libanii Opera (Foerster)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Foerster, like other Teubner editors of this type of literature, has limited himself to pointing out the more obvious sources",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Libanianus on which he has certainly earned the right to dogmatize.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the end of the Nohl review (MS readings restored).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262405",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Greek Historical Writing and Apollo (Wilamowitz)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Historical science, the historical imagination, and critical methods of research are hardly a hundred years old",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262406",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Briefwechsel zwischen August Bockh und Ludolph Dissen (Hoffmann)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "it is particularly interesting for the picture it gives of the golden age of German classical scholarship",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the close of the Wilamowitz review (Shorey on Il. xxii. 15).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262407",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Athenian Family (Savage)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Athenian Family. A Sociological and Legal Study, Based Chiefly on the Works of Attic Orators.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262408",
"kind": "review",
"title": "On the Interpretation of Empedocles (Millerd)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The evidence for this interpretation Miss Millerd reviews somewhat more fully than previous writers",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262409",
"kind": "review",
"title": "La metrica di Orazio (Stampini)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "seldom since their day has Latin meter been so rigorously made to conform with the Greek as in Stampini's work",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the end of the Millerd review (sense of physis).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262410",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Helladian Vistas (Quinn)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He is obviously writing for the cultured reader or prospective traveler, rather than for the student",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262412",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Riddle of the Bacchae (Norwood)",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "the chorus have been \"hypnotized\" by the Lydian enchanter and are so completely under his power that they imagine what they describe!",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Palace-miracle difficulty resolved from staging: characters later exit by the doors, so the fall is the chorus's illusion.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262413",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in Greek Allegorical Interpretation (Hersman)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Part I gives a sketch of allegorical interpretation before Plutarch; Part II deals with Plutarch, more especially with his treatment of the Isis myth.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262414",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kurzgefasste griechische Schulgrammatik (Weigel); Eugraphius (Wessner)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Great prominence is given to the stem in all inflections, and thereby apparent irregularities are explained.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "We may well believe that this will be the final edition of the commentary",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Eugraphius dated from language and relation to Donatus and Servius.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262416",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Life in Ancient Athens (Tucker)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "an uninterrupted narrative dealing with facts about classical Athens which every younger student of ancient history should know",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262417",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plato: The Apology and Crito (Flagg)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The notes on each paragraph begin with a helpful summary of the thought in lucid and picturesque English.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262374",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kritisch-historische Syntax des griechischen Verbums (Stahl)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Stahl's book belongs, in my judgment, to the syntax of the past, not to the syntax of the future",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262376",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Populare Aufsatze (Krumbacher); end of Sontheimer on Vitruvius",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "his unique efforts in behalf of a quickening of interest in Greek and Graeco-Roman culture during the middle and later ages",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Fatal, however, to this idea is the immediately following feminine relative quae, which must refer to aedis, not to pronai.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Sontheimer would date Vitruvius before 27 B.C. by reading augusti as adjective; reviewer refutes at the locus.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262377",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Les dialectes indo-europeens (Meillet)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the question of the grouping of the Indo-European languages as reflecting dialectic differences already existing in the parent speech",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262379",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Oppien d'Apamee, La chasse (Boudreaux)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The editor thinks he discovers two families (x and z) in the MSS tra- dition.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the x family represents the \"traditional\" text : if the readings of the two families are intrinsically equivalent, the x family is to be preferred",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Editor lets the theory of MS tradition decide readings; reviewer doubts that this should decide the text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262380",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fragments from Graeco-Jewish Writers (Stearns)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Professor Stearns has done a real service to students of Hellenistic Greek by collecting from early Christian writers these curious Greek fragments",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Most of these fragments are preserved in the Praeparatio Evangelica of Eusebius",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Collection of fragments; no standing in question. Shear on Plato and Basil (E) follows.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262381"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262382",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Priester und Tempel im hellenistischen Agypten (Otto)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the relations of a great ecclesiastical organization to the life of the time",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with the end of the Shear review (Plato and Basil parallels).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262383",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Article with Names of Persons and Gods in Thucydides and Herodotus (Pfeifauf)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a systematic comparison of instances occurring under like conditions leads to almost exceptionless guiding principles",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262384",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Platonuv Ion (Nedopil)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "gives a historical resum6 of the various views held by scholars as to the funda- mental idea of the dialogue and Plato's purpose",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Surveys arguments on authenticity and date of the Ion without a stated verdict; no D code assigned.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262385"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262386",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Platons ausgewahlte Schriften: Gorgias (Nestle); Characters of Theophrastus (Jebb, Sandys)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He does not cite Robin TMorie platonicienne de Vamour, who argues for a late date of the Phaedrus",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "that a large proportion of scholars would reverse this argument",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey disputes Nestle's relative dating of Phaedrus and Gorgias from a developmental reading.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262387",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Pindari carmina cum fragmentis selectis (Schroeder)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "It must long remain the standard critical edition of Pindar.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the readings of the best MSS being restored in many places where they had been given up by all modern editors",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Metrical schemes decide readings at loci (restorations and conjectures such as N. 9. 13).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262388",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fragments of Empedocles (Leonard)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "the rendering \"green\" for OeXv/iva, Fr. 21. 6, seems singularly ill considered",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Page opens with Clapp joining Pindar Fr. 227 and 172 as one poem.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262389",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Year's Work in Classical Studies, 1908 (Rouse)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The eighteen departments into which the vast field of philology is divided are systematically treated as wholes and kept up to date year by year.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1909-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261895",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A History of Classical Scholarship II-III (Sandys)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These later volumes fulfil the author's hope, expressed six years ago, of continuing the story from the time of Petrarch to the present day.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261897",
"kind": "review",
"title": "C. Suetoni Tranquilli opera I (Ihm); end of Muller, Syntax des Nominativs und Accusativs",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The Preface gives the history of the text and the relations of the MSS, together with the lists of editions",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "is inclined to support MS tradition as against the acceptance of conjectures",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261898",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Untersuchungen zu Lucilius (Cichorius)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In the chapter on the life of Lucilius the stemma of the poet's family is reconstructed from his father M. Lucilius to Pompey the Great",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261899",
"kind": "review",
"title": "P. Papini Stati Thebais (Klotz)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These are reduced by the editor to two classes, one of which consists of Parisinus 8051 with its corrections by three hands",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "we have in this edition a standard critical text of the Thebais",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261900"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261902",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Deification of Abstract Ideas in Roman Literature and Inscriptions (Axtell)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In the first Dr. Axtell con- siders the deified abstracts as individual cults under the following heads",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261903",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Notes on Stahl's Syntax of the Greek Verb (Gildersleeve)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Professor Gildersleeve's three papers reviewing Professor J. M. Stahl's Kritisch-Historische Syntax des griechischen Verbums",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261904",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mathematik und Philosophie bei Plato (Ebeling)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "B",
"span": "it endeavors to trace the evolution of Plato's thought in relation to mathematics",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey explains away alleged contradictions (Theaetetus vs Republic) passage by passage against developmental readings.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261905",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The General Civil and Military Administration of Noricum and Raetia (Peaks)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Miss Peaks discusses first in a general way the officials who figured in the administration of the provinces, their ranks, titles, and functions.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261906",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Phoinix von Kolophon (Gerhard)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "By his patience and skill the editor has succeeded in patching together fragments of papyri now described as Papyrus Heid. 310.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261907",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thukydides fur den Schulgebrauch, Buch VI (Boehme, Widmann)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In the matter of interpretation, text, history, and geography the recent literature is always cited.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261908",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Rhetoric of Aristotle, translated by Jebb (Sandys)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "But occasionally it is so free as to be rather interpretation than translation",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261909",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Seven Against Thebes of Aeschylus (Tucker)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "his emendations are for the most part supported by sound argument; all are possible; but some to say the least are improbable.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Professor Tucker has hardly been as conservative as the statement in his preface would lead us to expect.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261910",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Greek Architecture (Marquand)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A full and trustworthy account in English of Greek architecture has been greatly needed",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261911",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Index to the Fragments of the Greek Elegiac and Iambic Poets (Lane)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Miss Lane's Index will be serviceable and we should therefore thank her for it",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261912"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261913",
"kind": "review",
"title": "C. Plini Caecili Secundi epistularum libri (Kukula)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the most fundamental thing of all is to know what the MSS say, and that only after this is determined can we properly proceed to classification",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Professor Kukula has been reasonably con- servative and self-restrained.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261914",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Philologie et linguistique: Melanges offerts a Louis Havet",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The thirty-seven contributors to this complimentary volume are apparently all of the nationality of their friend and teacher",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261915",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hellas and Hesperia (Gildersleeve)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These lectures do not present themselves at the bar of a \"journal devoted to research,\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-3286842",
"kind": "notice",
"title": "The \"Classical Journal\" and \"Classical Philology\"",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "But in practice there is a natural tendency to confine articles of a purely technical character to Classical Philology",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-03-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262198",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kaerst, Geschichte des hellenistischen Zeitalters II.1",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "Then follows in five chapters a detailed treatment of Hellenistic culture, and in four chapters a similar treatment of the Hellenistic state.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer also criticizes Kaerst's conceptual method of history.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262199",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Drerup, [Herodes] Peri Politeias",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Since Kfihler in 1893 discovered that the oration Ilepi iroXiTetas, which is attributed to Herodes Atticus in the thirteenth-century parchment from",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Clearly, the speech belongs to 400-399 b. c, not to 404 b.c; it deals seriously with Larisa, not obscurely with Athens",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review: attribution to Herodes rejected; style and composition date the speech to the late fifth century.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262200",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Postgate, Flaws in Classical Research",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Professor Postgate has written a most entertaining paper \"drenched in matter,\" and full of suggestions from which even dissenters will learn.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262201",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Poland, Geschichte des griechischen Vereinswesens",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The term thiasos in Attic use meant technically, Poland remarks, a subdivision of a phratry.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262202",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Abbott, Society and Politics in Ancient Rome",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the sympathetic sketch of the life of Cicero's son, under the title of \" The Career of a Roman Student.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262203",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schwartz, Eusebius Kirchengeschichte, kleine Ausgabe",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It was a happy idea to make Schwartz' edition of Eusebius' Church History accessible to a larger circle of readers",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The readings of the Rufinus text and of the Syrian translation are in- cluded when important.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an editio minor; reports the edition without contesting the text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262204",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fowler and Wheeler, Greek Archaeology",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "This handbook belongs to a class already represented by Murray's Handbook of Greek Archaeology (1892)",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262206",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fowler, Social Life at Rome in the Age of Cicero",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "there is no book in our language which supplies a picture of life and manners, of education, morals, and religion in that intensely interesting period.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262207",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Basore, The Scholia on Hypokrisis in the Commentary of Donatus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The author first faces the problem whether the scenic Scholia, found in so late an author, are of any value in reference to the stage customs of the Terentian age",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262208",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thackeray, A Grammar of the Old Testament Greek",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Three important studies have recently appeared in the hitherto rather neglected field of Septuagint grammar.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262209",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Olcott, Thesaurus Linguae Latinae Epigraphicae",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The word annus occurs more frequently than any other in inscriptions, and its treatment requires thirty-two columns",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262210"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262211",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Denison, A Mexican-Aryan Comparative Vocabulary",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The great majority of the comparisons are so far-fetched that they fail even to excite \"hostile surprise\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262212"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262213",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tarbell, Catalogue of Bronzes in Field Museum",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Field Museum possesses a collection of about three hundred reproductions of objects, almost exclusively bronze",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262214",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Diels, Herakleitos von Ephesos, 2nd ed.",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "I may be permitted instead to offer comments and suggestions on a few texts.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "However, the text is intelligible as it stands.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer proposes and weighs readings passage by passage; some conjectures accepted, some MSS readings defended.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262215",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ball, Selected Essays of Seneca",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The principle of choice is the illus- tration of Seneca's \"personal connection with the history of his time.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition; review concerns selection and pedagogy, no text question.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262216",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Reiley, Philosophical Terminology of Lucretius and Cicero",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Lucretius used eleven terms, Cicero four; and there was a subtle dis- tinction in meaning",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262217",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Gelzer, Ausgewahlte kleine Schriften",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "But the richest mine of interest to the classical scholar is opened up in Gelzer's sketches of those two giants of our department",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Essays on Byzantine church history and on Curtius and Burckhardt as scholars.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262218",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sihler, Testimonium animae",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "To him the primary significance of classical paganism is not harmony, or love of truth, or love of beauty",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262219",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ullman, Identification of the MSS of Catullus cited in Statius",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "to discover what manuscripts were used by Statius in his edi- tion of 1566, and to examine the accuracy and critical judgment of that editor of Catullus",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Three of the MSS cited- by Statius have disappeared",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "MS tradition; reviewer questions the identification of Maffei liber with R.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262220",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wilhelm, Beitrage zur griechischen Inschriftenkunde",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it falls into 227 little opera, each centering in the deciphering or restoration of an inscription or name",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262221",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ofenloch, Caecilii Calactini fragmenta",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Ofenloch includes in his Corpus not only those fragments containing Caecilius' name",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Those of most doubtful origin are marked by an asterisk.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Fragment collection including attributed fragments; doubtful attributions marked.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262167",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roberts, Dionysius of Halicarnassus on Literary Composition",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Dionysius possessed a receptive mind and a graceful but gar- rulous pen.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "he has given us a careful text based upon Usener's",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition with translation; review weighs Dionysius as critic.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262168",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Walden, The Universities of Ancient Greece",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "sketches, by way of introduction, the history of education, especially of higher education, in Greece in the Athenian and Macedo- nian periods.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262171",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Legrand, Daos",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "will welcome it as the first competent attempt to reveal the content, the form, and the spirit of the New Comedy",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262172",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vollmer, Poetae Latini Minores I; Birt, Jugendverse und Heimatpoesie Vergils",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "In the interpretation of the Vergilian Appendix there is a perceptible drift toward granting the authenticity of many of the poems.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "To his view that the poems are the early work of Vergil we are altogether willing to assent",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Catalepton accepted as Vergil's; Birt's rejection of IX and his emendations opposed. Single-author authenticity, not D3.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262173",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dieterich, Eine Mithrasliturgie, 2nd ed.",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "for the study of the liturgy itself and of Dieterich's evidence of its essential harmony in cosmology, theology, and ritual with the syncretistic Egyptian Mithraism",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262174",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Calderini, La manomissione e la condizione dei liberti in Grecia",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "In his hasty historical sketch of the manumission of slaves, he begins with the Homeric Age.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262177",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Scheer, Lycophronis Alexandra II: scholia",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "With the publication of Vol. II containing the scholia, Professor Eduard Scheer completes his edition of Lycophron",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "We are fortunate in having so excellent an edition of the scholia to Lycophron",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262178",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ritter, Neue Untersuchungen uber Platon",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "inconsistency, more or less dis- guised by metaphor, is to be expected in relation to ultimate metaphysical problems",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey reads apparent inconsistencies in Plato through the unity of his thought.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262179",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Walker, Antimia: An Essay in Isometry",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "He finds in the received text of Pindar fifty-six cases of the forbidden equivalence",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This plainly does not justify the wholesale emenda- tion attempted here.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "A metrical rule across the corpus is made to decide emendation; reviewer rejects it for the received text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262180",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Juthner, Philostratos uber Gymnastik",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "make of this edition almost a complete history of ancient gymnastic",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Juthner acquits Mynas of bad faith and does ample justice to his occasional good suggestions.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262181",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Werner, Aristote et l'idealisme platonicien",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The chief novelty of Dr. Werner's book is his affirmation that Aristotle's God is identical with the soul of the world.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262183",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Knoellinger, M. Tulli Ciceronis de virtutibus libri fragmenta",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "Knoellinger's work is an exhaustive discussion of the question whether we have here a reference to a lost work of Cicero entitled De virtutibus.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This being answered in the afiirmative, a restoration of the Latin fragments from the French text is attempted.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Convergence of indications (name, doctrine, dates) assigns De la Sale's source to Cicero.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262184",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ogden, De infinitivi finalis vel consecutivi constructione",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "proposes to give a complete and correlated view of the use of the final and consecutive infinitives in the earliest Greek poetry.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262185",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thomas, Apulei De Philosophia Libri",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "It is upon this MS that M. Thomas has relied most of all in constituting his text.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "If M. Thomas has erred at all it is on the side of caution.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262186",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Byrne, The Syntax of High School Latin",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "Mr. Byrne with fifty collaborators has arranged a very interesting table of statistics of the grammatical constructions used in these three authors.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262187",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Preble and Jackson, The Source of \"Jerusalem the Golden\" (Bernard of Cluny)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "This work was undertaken by Professor Jackson to correct what he felt to be a common misapprehension as to the nature of Bernard of Cluny's poem De Contemptu Mundi",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "but their authenticity seems very doubtful and some of them are per- haps more correctly assigned to the better-known Bernard of Clairvaux.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer doubts attributions of minor pieces to Bernard of Cluny; no argument given.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261271",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fick, Hattiden und Danubier in Griechenland (with Meister)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Fick undertook to distinguish in the pre-Hellenic names of Greek localities the languages of various ancient tribes and races",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261272",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ritter, Platon I",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "For the dating of the dialogues, he recognizes the following methods",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "rejecting the second, the thirteenth, and others accepted by Eduard Meyer and Christ. I doubt the genuineness even of the seventh and eighth epistles",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Genuineness of epistles and dialogues, dating by style and thought; Ritter and Shorey reject different items.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261273",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schroeder, Aristophanis Cantica",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "With the Aristophanes, Professor Schroeder completes his rewriting, in terms of the \"new metric,\" of virtually the entire body of extant Greek lyric verse.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261274",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Robert, Pausanias als Schriftsteller",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the author's endeavor to show that the world of scholars has made a mistake in regarding the Description of Greece as a guide-book",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Purpose and literary method of the Periegesis; reviewer holds to the guide-book view.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261276",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Brauchitsch, Die panathenaischen Preisamphoren",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "an arrangement which depends largely upon an analysis of the changes that take place in the figure of Athena",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261277",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kroll, Vettii Valentis Anthologiarum Libri",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "although it was used by Scaliger, Salmasius, and others, it has remained unedited until the present day.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "who has now given us an admirable editio princeps, such as only a sound classical philologist, well versed in ancient astrology, could prepare.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261278",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Curcio, Poeti Latini Minori II.2: Dirae, Lydia, Ciris",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "It is difficult to see on what principle Curcio selected his MSS, other than their convenient location in Italy.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "that the \"Dirae\" and \"Lydia\" are the work of a single author, who is not Vergil",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "MS stemma judged; D3 secondary: poems of the Appendix under Vergil's name assigned to another single author.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261279",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dombart and Kalb, Augustine De Civitate Dei I, 3rd ed.",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "is devoted to a study of the numerous manuscripts of the De Civitate Dei",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "In ii. 27, the baffling philosophaster still remains, a term of reproach that Augustine would scarcely have applied to Cicero.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261280",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Abele, Der Senat unter Augustus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Abele has undertaken to collect and examine the data bearing on the relations of the senate and Augustus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261281"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261282",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dyer and Seymour, Plato Apology and Crito",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "except the bracketing of TrdXai Apol. Sid which removes an effective reijetition",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "The following readings, adopted by Seymour, are open to criticism",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition; reviewer judges readings one by one, partly for MSS, partly for conjectures.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1910-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261297",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Clark, Ammiani Marcellini Rerum Gestarum Libri I",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "The problem of the relation of the MSS, a subject with which he dealt in his dissertation",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "As all the later MSS are descended directly from V, the editor rightly bases his text on V alone",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Text on V alone, but about 500 new emendations; cursus rhythm used to emend final words.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261298",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mulder, Die Ilias und ihre Quellen",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "8. Such a task could not have been performed by chance, by organic development, nor by a compiler (Bearbeiter), but demanded the creative poet.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "1. The Iliad is a unity, composed according to a single plan.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Unity of the Iliad against analysts; one work, so D2 not D3.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261299",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bywater, Aristotle on the Art of Poetry",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Of course what Aristotle really did mean is what we want to know",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "we have an edition which was much needed and which pretty well exhausts what antiquity can do to explain its own remains",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "both",
"note": "Reviewer presses the sense of katharsis against Bywater's parallels.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261300",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Capps, Four Plays of Menander",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the editor's liberal employment of his own supple- ments in the filling of lacunae, his independence in the distribution of",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "The deviations from the papyrus, when it is legible, are fewer than in KQrte's text.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Plot theory decides placement of the St. Petersburg fragment; supplements fill lacunae.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261301",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Baikie, The Sea Kings of Crete",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "This admirable summary of recent discoveries in Crete will doubtless prove the most popular handbook on the subject.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261302",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ziebarth, Aus dem griechischen Schulwesen",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The basis of this extremely interesting and instructive study is a Milesian public document of the end of the third or the beginning of the second century B.C.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261304",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Zervos, Marcellus of Side on Pulses",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is per- forming the welcome task of publishing in a series of monographs the uned- ited fragments of ancient Greek physicians.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Only a few pages are preserved to us in two codices, discovered recently in prose",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Editio princeps of recently found fragments.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261305",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Postgate, Dead Language and Dead Languages",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It is a new and novel presentation of the claims of classical education for its time- honored place in the training of modern men.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261306",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hinneberg ed., Kultur der Gegenwart: Allgemeine Geschichte der Philosophie",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "There is a good account of Stoicism, and an admirable chapter on Plotinus, with which the sketch closes.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261307",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Suss, Ethos",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Dr. Suss rehandles the old prob- lem of the historical relation of Plato, Isocrates, and Alcidamas",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Shorey reads psychagogia in its passages against a bare word-parallel.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261308",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Croiset, Aristophanes and the Political Parties at Athens",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Prior to the Peloponnesian war, the \"rural democracy\" constituted an actual majority of the citizen body.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261309",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sonnenschein, The Unity of the Latin Subjunctive",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "To discover this common strain is the object of the \"quest,\" an investigation which proceeds along rather unusual lines.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261310",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Birt, Die Buchrolle in der Kunst",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Birt proceeds to distinguish and characterize seven types of gesture and posture assumed in holding the papyrus roll.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261311",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Prou, Manuel de paleographie latine et francaise",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "The extensive changes in this new edition of Prou's manual make it a much more useful handbook on Latin paleography",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Paleography handbook; scripts read as documents.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261314",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schissel von Fleschenberg, Dares-Studien",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Schissel comes to the conclusion that the Latin writer was unques- tionably using freely a Greek original, and that this was identical with the source employed by Malalas.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "From this dependence he coins a terminus post quern of ca. 510 a.d. for the date of the Latin Dares",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261315",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bruton ed., The Roman Fort at Manchester",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "is a scholarly treatment of all the available evidence, literary and monumental, for the reconstruction of the Roman fort at Manchester",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261316",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Leisi, Der Zeuge im attischen Recht",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The important and difficult subject of the Attic law of evidence, after remaining practically untouched for many years",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261317",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Burnam, Commentaire anonyme sur Prudence",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "prints a hitherto unpublished commentary on that author from a MS in the municipal library at Valenciennes.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "and that the work itself is to be assigned to Remi d'Auxerre",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Carolingian commentary; anonymous work assigned to Remi.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261318",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Helmreich, Galeni de Usu Partium",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "In a brief preface the editor gives account of the relation of his edi- tion to manuscripts and previous editions.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "we cannot assume to have even approximately a definitive text",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261319",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Arvanitopoullos, Thessalika Mnemeia I",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dr. Arvanitopoullos discovered on the site of ancient Pagasae in Thessaly a large number of grave-stelae",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261320",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Zippelius, Priene (reconstruction)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It shows, in bird's-eye view, the city of Priene, as it looked about 150 b.c.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261925",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Murray, The Iphigenia in Tauris of Euripides (translation)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It would be interesting to secure, if we could, the opinion of Euripides on the question of rhymed verse as his English vehicle.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261926",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rodenwaldt, Die Komposition der pompejanischen Wandgemalde",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "an interesting attempt to solve the much-debated problem how much is Greek and how much Roman in the Pompeian wall paintings",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261927",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Drachmann, Scholia Vetera in Pindari Carmina II",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Drachmann complains that he has not been so successful in emending the text of the scholia in this second volume as in the first.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Drachmann's ol ko.t£<txov cavrovs is far better than any reading in the manuscripts",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261928",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rees, The So-called Rule of Three Actors",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "has caused modern scholars to formulate the rule that ancient playwrights had only three actors at their disposal.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261929",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Weichert, Demetrii et Libanii qui feruntur Typoi",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The brief tract which has come down to us under the name of Demetrius of Phalerum discusses 21 types of letters.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Weichert decides that the Demetrius who composed the riiiroi was not he of Phalerum",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Attributions of two tracts; style of Libanius' letters decides the second.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261930",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Gragg, A Study of the Greek Epigram before 300 B.C.",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "The material of Miss Gragg's essay includes 324 epigrams from monu- ments and from the literary tradition.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "nor are we disposed to object to the charity of the author in recognizing the authenticity of epigrams ascribed to early poets in MSS",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261931",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ballentine, Terence Hauton Timorumenos",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "In 83 he declines to emend meruisti to commeruisti.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He rightly retains suum in Per. 7, keeps the MSS verse-order in 3 ff.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261932",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Foerster, Libanii Opera V",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "He has forsaken the order followed by Reiske, and arranges, according to the subject-matter",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Foerster rejects from the corpus and assigns to Choricius on the grounds of style",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Pieces removed from Libanius and given to Choricius by style; treated as work authenticity, not corpus partition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261933",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fick, Die Entstehung der Odyssee",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "According to Fick the Odyssey consists of four original poems put together by botchers and blockheads.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The existing texts cannot be accounted for on the hypothesis of one great poet working either near the beginning or near the end of the process.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Odyssey partitioned among several poets and an interpolator; page also carries Murray's 'Homeros' as imaginary ancestor.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261934",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Murray, The Rise of the Greek Epic",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The existing texts cannot be accounted for on the hypothesis of one great poet working either near the beginning or near the end of the process.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "permits him- self an ingenuity of caviling hypercriticism that even Robert might envy",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of Murray's many-bard thesis on Iliad/Odyssey; Shorey rejects the disintegrating analysis, so the item settles toward one poet.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261935",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Drerup, Omero (Italian edition)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it presents a better and fuller picture of the most ancient civili- zation of Greece than any other one book",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261936"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261937",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mood, Some Figurative Uses of Venire and Ire",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "deals with types like ad (in) spem venire (ire)",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261938",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ihm, Palaeographia Latina",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A booklet accompanying the plates contains a brief history, written in Latin, of the manuscripts, with a selected bibUography.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Palaeographic facsimile plates; manuscripts presented as documents of script.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261939",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plasberg, Cicero philosophical works, Fasc. I",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The task of preparing a new (and much needed) edition of this group of Cicero's philosophical works",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The text is the most conservative that has yet appeared",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Critical edition reviewed; conjectures replaced by MSS readings.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261940",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wachtler, Die Bluetezeit der griechischen Kunst",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to comment incisively upon each member of a series of illustrative monuments",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261941"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261943",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wilcken, Zum Alexandrinischen Antisemitismus",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Wilcken has collected and discussed a number of documents relating to anti-Jewish feeling and demonstrations in the first and second centuries.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261944"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261945",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Svoronos, Athens National Museum selections",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "They comprise illuminating discussions, in the author's brilliant style, of half a dozen votive reliefs",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261946"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261948",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Endt, Adnotationes super Lucanum",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The source of these, at least for the recension W U C, the editor refers (p. xi) to the grammarian Vacca",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "it is clear from the citation (vii. 471) from Livy's narrative",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition of Lucan scholia; source and date of the commentary argued from a citation.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261949",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Nicole, Textes grecs inedits (Geneva)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Of the eight Greek texts which Professor Nicole publishes, six are from papyri, one from a parchment fragment, and one from a wax tablet.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The papyrus is in generalagree- ment with the better class of Aeschines manuscripts.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261951",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dahnhardt, Natursagen II",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "That widespread popular tendency, half faith, half fancy, to interpret the everyday phenomena of nature in terms of religion and religious history",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261952",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Eger, Zum aegyptischen Grundbuchwesen",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Eger has examined a wide range of published papyri in the effort to elicit their testimony as to this land system",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262319",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Gildersleeve-Miller, Syntax of Classical Greek, Part II",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Syntax of the Simple Sentence Continued, Embracing the Doctrine of the Article.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262320",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Taylor, Varia Socratica",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "The central aim that unifies the volume is the attempt to prove that much more of Platonism than is commonly supposed is Socratic",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "I also note with regret that he apparently accepts the letters as genuine, dating the Republic by them",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Secondary D2: Shorey disputes Taylor's acceptance of the Platonic letters.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262321",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Duhain, Jacques de Tourreil",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A minor chapter of the history of the national literature and the national tradition of classical scholarship, thoroughly and intelligently studied",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262323",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bennett, Syntax of Early Latin I",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Professor Bennett's book deals with a field which has long been crying for cultivation.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262324",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wetmore, Index Verborum Vergilianus",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Despite Merguet's publication, Wetmore's Index fills an important gap.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "further investigation of the matter might profitably be applied to the question of the genuineness and the chronology of the Minor Poems",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Rand proposes word-use across the corpus to test Appendix Vergiliana genuineness and readings (pariter, Cul. 3).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262325",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Papers of the British School at Rome V",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the continuation of Dr. Ashby's work on the \"Classical Topog- raphy of the Roman Campagna\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262326",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Summers, Select Letters of Seneca",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Many of the conjectural readings are bold, but they have the merit of at least being reasonable.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Many of the conjectural readings are bold, but they have the merit of at least being reasonable.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract mostly carries the preceding BSR review; Seneca edition seen in window only.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262327",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dragatsis, To Themistokleion",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "topographers have usually located the tomb in the bend (dy/cuiv) of the shore outside the entrance to the Piraeus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262328",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Leutner, The Article in Theocritus",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "this examination of Theocritus' use of one part of speech throws much light upon many interesting passages",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "both",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261612",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Post, Selected Epigrams of Martial",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "While the editor's conclusions are for the most part sound, there are some passages in which his interpretation seems open to question.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261613",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cumont, Die orientalischen Religionen (German ed.)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The translator has made numerous additions to the notes, bringing the bibliog- raphy up to date",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page also carries Nicole, Proces de Phidias (papyrus reconstruction).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261614"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261615",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Arnold, Roman Stoicism",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Professor Arnold has constructed the history of Stoicism as far as possible from the writings of Cicero and Seneca",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261616",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Zander, Eurythmia Demosthenis",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "feel much confidence in the new science of rhythmical prose",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261617",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Billeter, Die Anschauungen vom Wesen des Griechentums",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "quotations from an immense but somewhat indiscriminatingly selected literature, both philological and general",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261618",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Krause, Diogenes von Apollonia",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "The main subjects treated are the formation of the world, the generation, growth, and structure of living beings.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261619",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Barbagallo, Lo Stato e l'Istruzione Pubblica",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Barbagallo has undertaken in the present work to explain the connection of the central government with public instruction in the period from Augustus to Justinian",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261620",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Keep, Separation of the Attributive Adjective in Plautus",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The earliest Latin prose is said to exhibit the close juxtaposition of the attributive adjective and its substantive",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261621",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Shorey-Laing, Horace: Odes and Epodes (rev.)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "many long, involved phrases of the odes have been elucidated more fully by translation or explanation of the construction",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261622",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Domaszewski, Abhandlungen zur roemischen Religion",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Domaszewski to gather into a volume his most important articles on Roman rehgion.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261623",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Stengel, Opferbraeuche der Griechen",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "adding to our precise knowledge of Greek ritual by a series of special studies",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261624",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Reitzenstein, Die hellenistischen Mysterienreligionen",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "their words and ideas must be interpreted with due regard to their Hellenistic as well as their Jewish environment.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261625",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bell, The Aphrodito Papyri",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The 315 papyri described and printed in the fourth volume of the British Museum catalogue are without exception late and documentary",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1911-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261521",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sandys, A Companion to Latin Studies",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "such information (apart from that contained in histories and grammars) as would be most useful to the student of Latin literature.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261522",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Foerster, Libanii Opera VI",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Foerster defended the genuineness of xv and xvi against Cobet, but his faith has weakened",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "he now hesitates in ascrib- ing to Libanius these declamations, always unpopular",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Open on declamations xv-xvi; confirms xxvi-xxviii against Gasda (illiteracy explained as ethos).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261523",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Martin, Les epistrateges",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The epistrategos was an official set over Upper Egypt by the Ptolemies in the early part of the second century b.c.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261525",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mueller, De Veterum Imprimis Romanorum Studiis Etymologicis",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "is to determine to what extent the etymologi- cal studies of the Romans depended on those of the Greeks.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261526",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schweikert, Cruquius und der Codex Divaei des Horaz",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "makes a careful study of the conclusions which have been drawn from his readings of the Codex Carrionis seu Divaei",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "His conclusion is, that while the dicta of Cruquius must be carefully weighed in each case, the judgment of Bentley is sound",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Credibility of Cruquius as witness to a lost Horace codex, tested passage by passage.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261528",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Goelzer, Le Latin de Saint Avit",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "As a contribution to the historical syntax of the Latin language the work is of great importance",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261529",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hildebrandt, Scholia in Ciceronis Orationes Bobiensia",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A new edition of the Scholia is decidedly welcome.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "we have before us a work that is practically final as far as the MS source is concerned",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261531",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lawson, Modern Greek Folklore and Ancient Greek Religion",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "this book is the most important attempt to deal in a large way with the survivals of ancient religion among the modern Greeks",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261532",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rehdantz-Blass-Fuhr, Demosthenes Ausgewaehlte Reden",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a number of innovations, made by Blass on rhythmical and other grounds, have been rejected in favor of stricter conformity to Codex 5",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "have been rejected in favor of stricter conformity to Codex 5. This change will meet with approval.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Rhythm-based readings dropped for manuscript S; reviewer approves.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261533"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261534",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Faesi-Sitzler, Homers Odyssee II",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Two attractive emendations are made by Sitzler in 6 559",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Sitzler is not a conservative in his treatment of the text.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Editor brackets many verses; reviewer restores several MS readings; a late interpolation (103-31) explains a reading.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261535",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lemercier, Les Pensees de Marc-Aurele (translation)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "make it unsafe for the student of philosophy to base conclusions on its pre- cise phrasing",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261536",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Peck, A History of Classical Philology",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He is trying to put into brief compass and readable form the information with regard to the history and significance of his subject",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261538",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Meyer, Griechische Papyrusurkunden der Hamburger Stadtbibliothek",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Meyer devotes his first to twenty-three Roman and Byzan- tine documents, mostly from the Fayum",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261539",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Jones, The Poetic Plural of Greek Tragedy",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The purpose of this treatise is to give a categorical statement of the use of the poetic plural in the Greek tragedians",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261540",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Solmsen, Inscriptiones Graecae ad inlustrandas dialectos",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The excellence of this brief collection of Greek dialect inscriptions has already been pointed out",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261542",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Adam, The Vitality of Platonism",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the essential characteristic assigned to the Logos by the Stoics are already present in the writings of Heraclitus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261543",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Greenwood, Nicomachean Ethics Book Six",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the editor discusses the author- ship of the sixth book, lucidly and convincingly refuting the arguments of those who would assign it to the Eudemian Ethics",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "well calculated in form and temper to confirm the natural presumption in favor of the authenticity of the book",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Assignment of a common book between two works of one author; not a partition among persons, so D2.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261544",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rossbach, T. Livi Periochae",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This new critical edition of the three epitomes of Livy is a welcome addition to the Teubner Library.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "leaves the reader completely in the dark as to his present view upon the subject",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authorship of Oxyrhynchus epitome and date of Periochae left unresolved; linguistic evidence criticized.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261545",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Samter, Geburt, Hochzeit und Tod",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "whose origin he finds in the fear of spirits and the desire of man to placate or avert them",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261546",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schulze, B. G. Teubner 1811-1911",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The centennial history of the firm contains much more interesting matter than the mere name would suggest",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261547",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Florilegium Latinum",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These little volumes contain well-chosen excerpts in their respective fields",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Same page as Teubner history; coded for the school excerpt volumes.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261549",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plasberg, Cicero philosophical works, Fasc. II",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The text, like that of the works contained in the first fascicle, is very conservative.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "I have noted more than fifty passages where the editor fol- lows the best MSS against the readings of inferior MSS or conjectures",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Page opens with Brillant, Les secretaires atheniens; windows show Plasberg II.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261550",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ludwich, Nonni Panopolitani Dionysiaca",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to undertake the drudgery of a new edition in which the results of his studies should be readily accessible to scholars",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "they were sufBcient to establish the essential correctness of the editor's conjectures made with the aid of L.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261551",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kiessling-Heinze, Horaz Satiren (4th ed.)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "There is less dogmatism on p. x concerning Livy's account (7.2) of the Italian forms of the drama",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Commentary revision; extract reports changes on the history of satura and Lucilius' birth year.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261553",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Baehrens, XII Panegyrici Latini",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he emphasizes the high value of the Harleian codex as well as that of Upsala for the reconstitution of the lost archetype",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "to amend an otherwise faultless text in the face of unanimous MS authority in order to make it conform to a postulated rule",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition uses clausulae; reviewer refuses to let the rhythm rule override unanimous MSS.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261554",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Murray, Aratus and Theocritus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The chief value of Wilamowitz' discussion of the identity of Aratus in Theocritus is in its destructive rather than constructive conclusions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Identity of a person addressed in Theocritus, not corpus partition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261964",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Partsch, Griechisches Buergschaftsrecht",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "This is an exhaustive and scholarly treatment of suretyship in Greek law.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261965",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Nicole, Catalogue des vases peints, Supplement",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It includes the vases acquired by the National Museum of Athens subsequently to 1897",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261966"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261967",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Nachmanson, Beitraege zur Kenntnis der altgriechischen Volkssprache",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "mostly belonging to the general phenomena of assimilation and dissimilation between non-contiguous sounds",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261968"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261969",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Olmstead et al., Hittite Inscriptions",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "what will undoubtedly be for many years the standard edition of the Hittite hieroglyphic inscriptions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261971",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wecklein, Euripides Cyclops (2nd ed.)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he went back and revised Prinz's three plays and is now similarly engaged upon his own earlier editions",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The second edition is more conservative than the first",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261972",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Teuffel-Kroll-Skutsch, Geschichte der roemischen Literatur II",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it will be reviewed simply as an attempt to bring the work up to date",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Handbook revision judged on bibliography and index.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261974",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vonach, Die Berichte des Photios ueber die fuenf aeltern attischen Redner",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The article of Photius on Antiphon is based entirely on the Pseudo-Plutarch Vita",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261975",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Maccari, Stichomythica",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "that Latin stichomythia is a merely formal and rhetorical imitation of the Greek as Menander's is of Euripides'.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262103",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Harrison, Themis",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "She would attribute his origin to the social action of the Kouretes, who represent a tribal group whose unity the Kouros reflects",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262104",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ridgeway, The Origin of Tragedy",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In this book Mr. Ridgeway rejects the generally accepted view which associates the origin of Greek tragedy with the worship of Dionysus.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262105",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Klotzsch, Epirotische Geschichte",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Klotzsch has tried to make real history out of the meager records of Epirus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262106",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Seager, Excavations in the Island of Mochlos",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The Mochlos gold work is superior to the Hissarlik treasure, refuting the charge that Dr. Schliemann was mistaken",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262107",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Heinze, Tertullians Apologeticum",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "gives in the present volume an admirable interpretation of Tertullian's Apologeticum",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Reading of the work as a whole; secondary on priority over Minucius Felix.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262108",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roscher, Die Zahl 40 / Die Tessarakontaden",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Every such study properly conducted, as are those of Dr. Roscher, contributes substantially to the stock of primi- tive ideas",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262109",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Abbott, The Common People of Ancient Rome",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The Common People of Ancient Rome. Studies of Roman Life and Literature.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262111",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Graeber, De poetarum Atticorum arte scaenica",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "when a new character enters the scene, he converses first with the chorus (or coryphaeus), even if another actor is already present",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262112",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Braunstein, Die politische Wirksamkeit der griechischen Frau",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The conclusion reached in the first chapter, which deals with the citizenship of women",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262113",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Wright, Comparative Grammar of the Greek Language",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "For the study of the comparative grammar of Greek our classical stu- dents have had no such suitable handbooks",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262114",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Homerische Probleme I (Belzner)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the alleged evidence for different stages of civilization within the Homeric poems",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He begins by rejecting Cauer's and Lang's a-priori assumption that Homer could not have archaized",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of Belzner on cultural strata as evidence for composition of the Odyssey; rejection of archaizing objection tends to unity.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262115",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Enchiridion patristicum (Rouet de Journel)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This volume is a collection of excerpts from the patristic writings, compiled for the definite purpose of illustrating the doctrine of the several Fathers",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262116",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Isocrates, Cyprian Orations (Forster)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Mr. Forster has given much attention to the text, and that which he presents agrees rather with Drerup in most cases than with Blass.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He has not made any conjectural emendations, and has in most cases followed very closely the readings of Codex Urbinas (F).",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of a school edition; text follows one codex without conjecture.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262117",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Q. Horati Flacci Satirae (Lejay)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "It is therefore a critical edition, with a brief though adequate apparatus, in which the impor- tant variants are noted",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The text is on the whole conservative, and more weight is given to the readings of the Blandinian manuscripts",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; secondary E for Old Comedy and satire.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262118",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Auli Persii Flacci Saturae (Van Wageningen)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "This scholarly edition based upon the text of Leo's recent revision of the standard Jahn-Biicheler text will be welcomed by all students of Persius.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Van Wageningen turns too readily to conjectural emendation",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer accepts MS-supported deviations, rejects conjectures where the MSS reading stands.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262119",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De C. Maecenatis Fragmentis (Lunderstedt)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Herr Lunderstedt lists so many who have collected and commented on the fragments of Mae- cenas that he finds it necessary to justify himself",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Herr Lunderstedt lists so many who have collected and commented on the fragments of Mae- cenas",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Fragment collection; extract shows little of its argument (windows belong to the next Statius review); direction weakly inferred.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262120",
"kind": "review",
"title": "P. Papini Stati Silvae (Klotz, 2nd ed.)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it was his chief purpose, in the preface to his first edition, to show that the Matritensis was the source of all other known codices of the Silvae",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In general the editor has performed the task of revision with commend- able caution and moderation.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Stemmatic argument that Politian used the Poggian codex decides the report on verse i. 4, 86a.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262121",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tales of a Greek Island (Dragoumis)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The stories deal with the modern peasants of the little island of Poros",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262122",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Einleitung in die Sprachwissenschaft (Porzezinski)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "one chapter is devoted to a history of the scientific study of language, two to a classification of the world's chief languages, one to phonetics",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262123"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262124",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Epigraphie (Jalabert)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The first deals with the elements of Christian epigraphy, such as the dating, diffusion, formulas, etc., of the inscriptions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262125"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261480",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Platonische Aufsatze (Apelt)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "That on \"Die beiden Hippias\" maintains the genuineness of both dialogues.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "there is little if anything un-Platonic in the greater Hippias, and the burden of proof rests upon its impugners",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review mostly on Plato's doctrine (A); D2 for the Hippias authenticity essay, which the reviewer endorses.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261481",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sprachliche Forschungen zur Chronologie der platonischen Dialoge (v. Arnim)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "It is not enough to establish stylistic coincidences between a group of dialogues suspected to belong to the same period.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The position assigned to the Phaedrus is in accord with the argument in my Unity of Plato's Thought that it is a mature work",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Stylometric dating of dialogues; reviewer asks that each passage be weighed in context.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261482",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Menandrea (Koerte, 2nd ed.)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The present edition adds the Heidelberg fragment of the Periceiromene, the Oxyrhynchus fragment of the Misoumenos",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Now more con- servative, he rarely omits to note in his commentary the few restorations that do not conform to reported gaps or traces.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Papyrus edition review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261483",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studia Catulliana (Grebe)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "About 85 passages are treated, in connection with most of which the author finds fault with one of Friedrich's interpretations or emendations.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Grebe easily refutes this by pointing out that defututa modifies puella",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Defends MS readings against Friedrich, but also offers new conjectures.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261484",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Fabulis Terenti in Actus Dividendis (Keym)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "It was inevitable that the next step would be the reopening of the whole question of act divisions in Plautus and Terence.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The traditional division violates (a) at nine different points",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Criteria from Menander's practice decide act endings at particular verses.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261485",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristophanis Pax (Zacher)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The praefatio deals with the manuscripts, of which there are eight",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "V and R (Rav. 137) are the oldest and best manuscripts and the only ones to present this play without lacunae.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; manuscript dependence.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261486",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Greek Inscriptions from Sardes I (Buckler and Robinson)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The document is a mortgage or rather a conveyance with right of redemption reserved.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261487",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aurelius Victor, Liber de Caesaribus (Pichlmayr)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the first complete text of this corpus that has appeared since the publication of",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "His attitude toward the manu- script tradition is characterized by wise conservatism",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "A general principle (errors in names are the author's) decides readings at several loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261488",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lexicon Plautinum fasc. 6 (Lodge)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the treat- ment of enim whose Plautine meaning and position in a sentence seem to have been fixed once for all",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261489",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Textgeschichte der Bibliotheke des Photios (Martini)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The first part of the investigation is devoted to a description of the MSS.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "all the MSS of later date are directly, or indirectly, descended from A and M",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Manuscript tradition; upholds the A tradition used by Bekker.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261490",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der Trug des Nektanebos (Weinreich); Das Marchen von Amor und Psyche (Reitzenstein)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "These two essays are studies of Hellenistic Novellen and agree in finding oriental myths as the nucleus of the Greek narratives.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261491",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Homer in der Neuzeit von Dante bis Goethe (Finsler)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These cross-section books, as they may be called, follow the history and influence of one of the great classic authors through the Middle Ages, the Renaissance",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261492",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cicero im Wandel der Jahrhunderte (Zielinski)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The last edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica (s.v. \"Cicero\") has no reference to this book and practically ignores the great field of inquiry which it opens up.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261494",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Bellum Civile of Petronius (Baldwin)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "where exaggeration on the part of Petronius may be claimed the intent is apparently not humorous",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The aim has been to produce a text that would read throughout, with a sparing use of actual emendation.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Primary: Petronius' relation to Lucan (parody theory rejected); edition text eclectic.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261495",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Notes on the Text of the Corpus Tibullianum (Deutsch)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The author attempts, chiefly by conjecture, to throw light on a dozen passages of the Corpus Tibullianum",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "A similar dearth of the best support blights all the rest of the conjectures.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Book proposes conjectures; the review rejects them and keeps the received text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261496",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Disputatio Critica de Carminibus Horatii Sex Quae Dicuntur Odae Romanae (Slijpen)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Slijpen agrees with most scholars that the six poems form a cycle.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Slijpen agrees with most scholars that the six poems form a cycle.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Unity of the Roman Odes as a cycle.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261497",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Clausula in Ammianus Marcellinus (Harmon)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author has presented the results of a study of the accentual clausula of Ammianus Marcellinus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261498",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ptolemaische Homerfragmente (Gerhard)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The two Heidelberg texts edited in this volume are Iliad papyri of Ptolemaic times",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "their variant readings can no longer be brushed aside as mere wild aberrations",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Ptolemaic papyri bearing on the pre-Alexandrian text against the Vulgate.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261499",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Excavations in Thessaly 1910 (Arvanitopoullos)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "gives us a preliminary account of his excavations and investigations in Thessaly for the year 1910",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261500",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Antike Fluchtafeln; Aus einem griechischen Zauberpapyrus (Wunsch)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "and sixty consecutive lines from a Paris papy- rus (Suppl. gr. 574), which is the best representative of the works of this class",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261501",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Charakteristik der lateinischen Sprache (Weise)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Charakteristik der lateinischen Sprache. Von Dh. F. Oskak Weise. 4te Aufl.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261502",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ad Propertii Carmina Commentarius Criticus (Enk)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "re-examining the literature on Propertius with a view to establishing the text at every point where there may be said to be a question of reading",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Cautus (for captus) at ii. 23. 10 is plausible, though I do not feel certain that the MSS are wrong.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Conjectures and transpositions; secondary D2 for the argued unity of ii. 33.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261503",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Latin and Greek in American Education (Kelsey)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "they are all agreed that the classics offer a most valuable preliminary train- ing alike for practical affairs or a professional career",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261504",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sex. Propertii elegiarum libri IV (Hosius)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This edition at once takes its place as the standard text edition of Proper- tius.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Extreme conservatism is shown in the text.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer lets agreement of manuscript classes (NA, NF) decide readings, e.g. iii. 11. 24.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261505",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cacus der Rinderdieb (Munzer)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "by a careful comparison of the three poets Munzer deduces the common \"mythic formula.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1912-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261410",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Verse of Greek Comedy (White)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "Professor White's im- mense collections of closely analyzed and consistently interpreted metrical facts",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261411",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Einleitung in die Altertumswissenschaft (Gercke and Norden)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the search for manuscripts, their collation, the establishment of relationships, the construction of a stemma with its attendant difficulties and dangers",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261412",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Terence (Sargeaunt), Loeb Classical Library",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he decided to issue a text-and-translation series that should contain \"all that is of value in Greek and Latin literature",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261413",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Philostratus, Life of Apollonius (Phillimore; Conybeare)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "there is nothing funnier even in Tredwell than the rendering which our two scholars have given of the words",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261414",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Euripides (Way), Loeb Classical Library",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Its faithfulness makes it much the most suitable rendering for confrontation with the original text.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261415",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Centaurs in Ancient Art: The Archaic Period (Baur)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "provides us with far more copious materials for studying the early art history of the centaur",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261416",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Luciani quae fertur Demosthenis Laudatio (Albers)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Anticipating his con- clusion that the Encomium was not written by Lucian, Albers examines as criteria the evidences of the rhetorician's art",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Albers makes out a case for the possibility of authorship by some rhetorician of the period other than Lucian",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Convergence of rhetorical, stylistic and dialect criteria decides attribution and date.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261419",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristotle on the Athenian Constitution (Kenyon, trans.)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "means rather \"powerful citizens\" than \"those in high office\" (22. 3)",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review; Thalheim edition follows in the extract.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261420",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Donarem Pateras (Elter)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Elter lays great emphasis upon the flaws of logic which, under the usual interpretation of the ode, are inherent",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261421",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Introduction a l'etude comparative des langues indo-europeennes (Meillet)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the newly discovered Indo-European lan- guage from Chinese Turkestan, beginning to take its place",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261422",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studia palaeographica (Loew)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "A contribution to the history of early Latin minuscule and to the dating of Visigothic MSS",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "supplies us with a new criterion for dating Spanish MSS that will force a revision of the date in many cases",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Ligature practice across the mass of MSS decides the date of individual manuscripts.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262461",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lucian, Vol. I (Harmon), Loeb Classical Library",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "not \"kept his face to the front,\" but \"did not change color or countenance.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262462",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studien zur Entstehungsgeschichte der Metaphysik des Aristoteles (Jaeger)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "We do not know how much of it Aristotle intended to make part of a consecutive treatise, how much he may have interpolated or added",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Dr. Jaeger's twenty-page refutation of Natorp's theory that K 1-8 is spurious and Platonic is the best piece of reasoning in his entire book.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Composition of the Metaphysics by philological analysis; defends K 1-8 against athetesis.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262463",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sophistik und Rhetorik (H. Gomperz)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The main thesis of the present volume is that sophistic was in its essence rhetoric",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262464",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Luciani quae feruntur Podagra et Ocypus (Zimmermann)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "These two short pieces in verse have led a shifting existence, now accepted by some editors as legitimate Lucianic offspring",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "He dissociates the two, claiming that the Tragopodagra is genuine and the Ocypus spurious",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Style, vocabulary and metre decide each piece's attribution; Ocypus assigned to Acacius. D2, single works, not a corpus partition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262465",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Dioskuren als Retter zur See (Jaisle)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "a good collection chrono- logically arranged of the references in Greek and Latin literature and inscrip- tions to the Dioscuri as protectors on the sea",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262466",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Xenophontis Scripta minora, fasc. posterior (Ruehl)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This is due to the rediscovery by Ruehl of the Codex Vaticanus Graecus 989 (V)",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "In the Respvblica Atheniensium Ruehl has gone farther than Kalinka in inserting emendations in the text.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "New codices; emendations inserted, while conservative on authorship.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262468",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plautus, Captivi (Brix, rev. Niemeyer)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In 911 ff. Niemeyer inserts two whole verses; in 912 (912 B in his numbering) he inserts several words",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The insertion of verses to fill up the gap in A in this part of the play is an entertaining exercise for those who like that sort of thing",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer rejects the editor's insertions and emendations and keeps the manuscript reading.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262469",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Etudes sur le style des Discours de Ciceron (Laurand)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is easily the best introduction to the study of clausulae that we have",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262470",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Plagiat in der griechischen Literatur (Stemplinger)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Part III treats (1) of the manner of indicating authorship or sources, (2) verbatim quota- tions, (3) free rendering, (4) unconscious borrowing.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262471",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kleine Schriften I (Usener)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the first of a series of four destined to contain Usener's opuscula",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262472",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Le Credenze d'Oltretomba (Pascal)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Non-literary sources are excluded from consideration; but the data of literature, primary and secondary, are well digested.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262473"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262474",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Technologie und Terminologie der Gewerbe und Kunste (Blumner, 2nd ed.)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "his authoritative work on the arts and trades of the Greeks and Romans",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262475",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Conditional Statement in Livy (Steele)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "most of those who use the book will value it chiefly as presenting a broad panorama of Livy's usage of conditional sentences",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262476",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Latin Terms of Endearment and of Family Relationship (Harrod)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "to gain from a study of the Latin inscriptions additional information in regard to the use and meaning of two groups of words",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261698",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grundzuge und Chrestomathie der Papyruskunde (Mitteis and Wilcken)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the first work to do for the non-literary papyri what Dittenberger's Sylloge did for the Greek inscrip- tions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Opening carries the end of a Wilamowitz review (three Stesichori), not this item.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261699",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Les institutions militaires de l'Egypte sous les Lagides (Lesquier)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Les institutions militaires de I' Egypte sous les Lagides. Par Jean Lesquier.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261700",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius (Mooney)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "his text rests on no independent collations, but is apparently his own",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Porson's emendation in iii. 745 (which Mr. Mooney rejects) now has MS authority",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer brings papyri against the edition's choices at several loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261701",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die sogenannten Sententiae Varronis (Germann)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "There was, then, room for a definitive discussion of the sententiae with a view to determining, if possible, the authorship of the collection.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the belief of Ger- mann's more immediate predecessors in the Varronian authorship of the collection is disproved",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Parallels in thought and language with Seneca decide against the MS ascription to Varro.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261702",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studi Graccani (Cardinali)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "there are three distinct Latin sources — the original Latin source of Appian, a pre-Ciceronian, and Livy",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261703",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thucydides, Book iv (Spratt)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Below the text at the foot of the page are noted important variants, corrections, and conjectures",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "although a complete apparatus criticus for the book has not been attempted",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition; direction not argued, taken as conservative.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261704",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristarchs Athetesen in der Homerkritik (Roemer)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author has devoted himself with peculiar enthusiasm to the attempted dis- covery of the true Aristarchus",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the supposedly valuable scholia in Ven. A are to be ignored as entirely worthless",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Standing of the Venetus A scholia as witness to Aristarchus' recension.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261705",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Golden Latin Gospels (Hoskier)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "This is a sumptuous and elaborate edition of the beautiful Gospels, written in golden letters on purple vellum",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "with a view to clearing up, if possible, the disputed points in con- nection with its origin",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "First edition of a MS; reviewer offers a conjectural history of its text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261707",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Nebensatze in den griechischen Dialektinschriften (Hermann)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Here are collected examples of every kind of subordinate clause found in the inscrip- tions of all the dialects except Attic",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261708",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Itinerarstudien (Elter)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "an attempt to establish the thesis that the Antonine Itinerary in the form in which it has come down to us is a pilgrims' itinerary",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Elter does not establish his thesis.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Form and purpose of a document's extant redaction; reviewer keeps the received view.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261709",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der erste platonische Brief (Immisch)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He wastes no time in proving that the Letters in their present form could not have been written by Plato.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Whatever genuine paragraphs or sentences they may contain, the Letters as they stand are the work of a compiler.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authenticity of the Letters as a collection; considered D3 but it is a compiler, not a partition among makers.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262538",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Untersuchungen uber die Natur der griechischen Betonung (Ehrlich)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "shall we take a skeptical attitude toward the utilization of the facts of Greek accent for the explanation of sound changes",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262540",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Study of Augustine's Versions of Genesis (McIntosh)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The study falls into three main divisions: (1) a reconstruc- tion of the text",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Tested by a random examination of the indices locorum of several volumes of the Vienna Corpus",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reconstruction of an Old Latin text from quotations; direction not argued in extract.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262542",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Commentationes Aenipontanae IV (Kalinka and Zingerle)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "is a study based on a careful comparison of the",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "contains a brief summary of the philological manuscripts or fragments of manuscripts",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Collection: MSS of the Tyrol, Polyaenus compared with Frontinus, a codex study.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262543",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lateinische Palaographie (Bretholz, 2nd ed.)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Bretholz traces the evolution of the script from stage to stage, describes the different scripts",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262545",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Governors of Moesia (Stout)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "he discusses the evidence for identifying and dating the governors of Moesia",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262546",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Menschenart und Heldentum in Homers Ilias (Spiess)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the task of presenting a series of descriptions or pictures of life and character as represented in the Iliad",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The unity of character and personality thus shown is a striking and effective answer to the statement made by Wilamowitz",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Character study; reviewer reads it as answering analysis of the Iliad.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262547",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Student's Edition of the Odes of Horace I-III (Garnsey)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This \"real subject,\" Garnsey thinks, is the career of Murena.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262548",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Horace, Odes (Garnsey); Studies in Fronto and His Age",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Through Murena he believes that he can solve all the old puzzles of the Odes and give a new and profound significance to innumerable passages",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Reviewer rejects reading Murena allusions into passages throughout the Odes.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262549",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in Fronto and His Age (Brock); The Religious Experience of the Roman People",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The theory of a peculiar literary language indigenous to Africa hardly requires further reputation, since it has been abandoned and exploded by its chief apostle.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262550",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Religious Experience of the Roman People (Fowler); The Works of the Emperor Julian I",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "As a solution of the vexed problem of the original function of Mars the author suggests (pp. 132 ff.) that the god was not a spirit",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "A number of plausible emendations due to Mrs. Wright herself, or communi- cated by friends, improve corrupt passages of the text",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262551",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Julian (Wright); The Old Testament in Greek, Part III (Brooke and McLean)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Without undertaking to construct a text, it prints that of Vaticanus where it is preserved, falling back where it fails upon Alexandrinus",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "In this particular, therefore, the printed text of Parts II and III is an improvement upon that of Swete.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Septuagint edition (confirming apparatus, Freer MS used) plus Shorey's emendation of Julian 12D.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262552",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Antike Portrats (Delbruck)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Then follow on Plates 13-57 Greek and Roman portraits, beginning with the Pericles in the British Museum",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Plates of portraits as objects; page opens with end of Septuagint review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1913-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261589",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Handbook of the Modern Greek Vernacular (Thumb)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It is the especial merit and distinction of Thumb's book that it furnishes a practical and at the same time scientific account of the vernacular",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261590",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Arte e Artifizio nel Dramma Greco (Guglielmino)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the first on the conventions of Greek dramatic art and the devices for preserving verisimilitude under those require- ments",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "tragic fragments he holds to be undoubtedly Sophoclean and refers them to a tragedy Eurypylos already divined by Tyrwhitt",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from the following Wilamowitz review: authorship and date inferred from style.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261591",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Spurhunde des Sophokles (Wilamowitz)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "From the style he infers that the play belongs to the earlier period of Sophocles' irocpov kol Kardrexvov manner.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The tragic fragments he holds to be undoubtedly Sophoclean and refers them to a tragedy Eurypylos already divined by Tyrwhitt.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review: Sophoclean authorship and early date from style; reviewer defends a line rejected as spurious and offers supplements.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261592",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Spurhunde des Sophokles (Wilamowitz); Der Orient und die fruhgriechische Kunst",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The latter part of the essay gives Wilamowitz' present views of the origin of the Greek drama.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261593",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Apollonius Rhodius: The Argonautica (Seaton)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "While this is a faint render- ing of the Greek, one cannot question its correctness.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "iii. 290 and 1131 are so much alike that one wonders why Ov/jlov of the former passage should not be emended to Ov/im.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261594",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kleine Schriften (Dieterich)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "These two elements Dieterich regards as the chief factors in the destruction of genuine Greek religion.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261567",
"kind": "review",
"title": "English Literature and the Classics (Gordon)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Mr. Gordon, after a sufficient account of the Characters of Theophrastus, shows how a similar literary form was developed in England",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261568",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Demosthenes' On the Crown (Humphreys)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dr. Humphreys' notes are generally in substantial agreement with the inter- pretation of the earlier edition",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261569",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Zur Biographie Martials (Lieben)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "He holds that the epigrammatist, thanks perhaps to Quintilian, had won the favor of Titus",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Now, once the biographer is granted freedom to cull from a book epigrams that confound his chronology and redate them with no other compelling cause",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review rejects redating of Martial ix. 97 and other epigrams to earlier years.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261570",
"kind": "review",
"title": "M. Manilii Astronomicon Liber Secundus (Housman)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "When will the harder lesson be generally learned, of the necessity of collations personally made and reviewed with painstaking accuracy",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "It is quite possible to see that Mr. Ellis' observation and recorded note in the case of several of the variants referred to above may not have been at fault",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review: manuscript tradition of Manilius; photographs of M and L newly used.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261571",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Manilius II (Housman); A Commentary on Herodotus (How and Wells)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "His new stemma accordingly includes only GLL 2 M, and shows no such troublesome serpentine lines of intertwining as Mr. Garrod's.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In the case of M the photographs apparently confirm the acute inferences he drew in 1907 about certain of the excerpts published by Mr. Ellis.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Housman stemma; closing begins Drerup on unity of the Iliad by rhapsode structure.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261572",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das funfte Buch der Ilias (Drerup)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "No rhapsodist could recite at a single effort a poem of 15,000 verses; hence there must be a division into smaller unities",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This book is the most complete and thorough argument for unity with which I am familiar, since no well-attested verse is excluded",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Responsion of scenes rules out interpolation; unity of a work. Opens with Laird on Herodotus pedestal.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261573",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Lucretiani libri primi condicione ac retradatione (Mussehl)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "The author's general position is that the poem is far nearer completion than has hitherto been considered.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Lacunae and trans- positions Mussehl generally rejects ; many stop-gaps he shows are inadequate",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3 from Drerup tail: dividing Homer among poets by treatment of the gods declared absurd.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261574",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Hieronymo Donati Discipulo (Lammert)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Lammert proceeds to a search in Jerome's works for parallels in thought and expression to the Artes grammaticae, the commentary on Terence",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "must have been responsible for readings not intended by the authors",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Herzog on transcription into the Ionic alphabet as source of corruption.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261575",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Umschrift der alteren griechischen Literatur in das ionische Alphabet (Herzog)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the corruptions which the transcription of our texts from the epichoric or the Old-Attic alphabets into the Ionic alphabet of the fourth century has caused",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The result has been that up to the present time general uncertainty has pre- vailed about the testimony of the MSS on many critical points",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Herzog (tradition) and opening of Sjogren review (new collations against Baiter).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261576",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Epistularum ad Brutum Liber Nonus (Sjogren)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Fortunately Mr. Sjogren has not disdained the long, strenuous, and often dull labor of making new collations of a considerable number of MSS",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "which would uphold as Ciceronian many MS readings that have been censured by previous critics",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; new collations, conservative text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261577",
"kind": "review",
"title": "La phrase a verbe 'etre' en latin (Marouzeau)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "We have in this book an exhaustive study of the position of the forms of the verb esse in the comedians, especially in attributive phrases.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "He has been bolder than his predecessors in that he has placed the five letters we owe to Cratander ahead of the eighteen",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Sjogren tail: letter order reset, MS readings upheld.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261578",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Epiktet und das Neue Testament (Bonhoffer)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Their conclusions to the effect that Epictetus was familiar with the New Testament are refuted in detail.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261579",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Notes sur la fixation du latin classique (Marouzeau)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "It is the linguistic phenomena due to this conflict, down to about the time of Augustus, that M. Marouzeau portrays in this treatise.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261717",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Antigonus Gonatas (Tarn)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "His long struggle with Ptolemy Philadelphus for the hegemony in Greece and supremacy in the eastern Mediterranean",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261718",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Antigonus Gonatas (Tarn); Principles of Greek Art (Gardner)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "A man no longer felt himself a part of his own city state, with his life bound up in the corporate life within those city walls",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261719",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ovid and the Renascence in Spain (Schevill)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "examines in the present volume an important epoch in the posthumous career of Ovid",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261720",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Lysis ek tou prosopou (Dachs)",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "The slighting words are not those of the poet, but of a speaker who intentionally belittled Menelaus in order to spur Hector",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Does this show two different con- ceptions of Menelaus and hence diverse authorship ?",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: apparent contradictions used by analysts to divide Homer among poets are resolved by speaker; opens with Schevill tail.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261721",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Washington Manuscript of the Four Gospels (Sanders)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "B",
"span": "He has provided an elaborate monograph on the paleography and text of the manuscript, concluding with a detailed collation of its text",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "In estimating the text, Professor Sanders abandons the positions of Westcott and Hort and adopts in part those of von Soden",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Freer MS W newly published; opens with end of Dachs (Homer to be grasped as unity before partition).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261722",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Washington Manuscript (Sanders); Kleine Schriften II (Usener)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The heading fvayytkiov Kara uaawrjv is not by a second hand, but by that which wrote the quire",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "But on the whole Professor Sanders has produced a careful and trustworthy collation of his very notable manuscript.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer corrects readings of the first hand at many passages.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261723",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Polybius (Laqueur)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Professor Laqueur attempts to prove that Polybius rewrote his history in ever-expanding form until it reached the fifth revised and enlarged edition.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the arguments so often throw the facts into an incorrect setting, and so often reach conclusions not remotely justified by the premises",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review rejects Laqueur's five-stratum composition of Polybius.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261724"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261725",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cretan Elements in the Cults and Ritual of Apollo (Swindler); Gli Idilli di Teocrito",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Miss Swindler is to be congratulated upon the skill with which she has presented, and in the main established, the case for the Cretan elements in the cult of Apollo.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "general conservatism, and occasionally— as so often in Germany — the tendency to follow the lure of prose logic in rewriting a poet's text",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D1 from Wecklein commentary notice in window and closing.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261727",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Apulejus von Madaura und das romische Privatrecht (Norden)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Dr. Norden's plan is somewhat different from that of his predecessors; their purpose was to treat the texts as sources and tabulate the passages",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "And he deserves the special thanks of all students of the pastoral for his spirited defense of the eighth.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Taccone: authenticity of Theocritus Idyll 8 defended on its architecture.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261728",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Castrogiovanni, das alte Henna in Sizilien (Rossbach)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Greeks and the Italic peoples had a larger number of war gods than is commonly supposed",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261729",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Juvenalis Declamans (de Decker)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "In this work M. de Decker seeks to show that the rhetorical element in Juvenal is due to the poet's previous practice of oratory.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261730",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Juvenalis Declamans (de Decker)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Fortunately, the author maintains, we possess such documents in the Suasoriae et controversiae of the elder Seneca",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261731",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Athenian Clubs in Politics and Litigation (Calhoun)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "In fact, a large part of Dr. Cal- houn's book is taken up with describing the political and judicial situations in which the influence of clubs may have been effective.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261456",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roman Farm Management: The Treatises of Cato and Varro",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "It is rather a free rendering of the Latin text than a close translation of it",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; closing is Reid's Municipalities.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261457",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Municipalities of the Roman Empire (Reid)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "detaining the reader for a few moments at each of several hundred munici- palities",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261458",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Le futur grec (Magnien)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The conclusion is, in brief, that all Greek futures except those like ei/xt and ISoywai, and also the Italic s-futures",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261459",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Le futur grec (Magnien); The Clown in Greek Literature; Der Emporkommling",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Magnien, however, does considerably less than justice to the rival theory that the Greek future is in the main an aorist subjunctive.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261460",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Inscriptiones Graecae, Editio Minor II-III (Kirchner)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "When two inscriptions, obviously different in date, are recorded on the same stone, they are edited together",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261461",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sophocles quid debeat Herodoto (Rasch)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The writer, however, believes that the influence of Herodotus upon Sophocles can be proved more con- clusively by a critical examination of the parallels",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261462"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261463",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Beitrage zur Geschichte von Lesbos im vierten Jahrhundert (Pistorius)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Pistorius presents a critical narrative sketch of Lesbos in connection with, and as a part of, the general Greek development of the fourth century b.c.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The author has given his work the title Anaximenea without indicating that possibly Anaximenes did not write the treatise under consideration.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Anaximenea notice in closing: attribution and papyrus against MSS.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261464",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Anaximenea (Eisemann)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "It is further an attempt to bolster up the readings of the fif- teenth- and sixteenth-century MSS on which the editions of Spengel (1854) and Hammer (1894) are based",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "He fails to see that the usage of the MSS may not be set as a Procrustean bed for the new readings of the papyrus.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Eisemann lets word-order usage of the MSS decide against Hibeh papyrus readings; reviewer rejects; attribution to Anaximenes questioned.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261465",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vormundschaftsrechtliche Studien (Taubenschlag)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "He discovers interpolations in the Digest with an assurance that suggests divinatory skill.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "But the criteria which Taubenschlag accepts are certainly not adequate.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review rejects interpolation-hunting in Digest passages on word-level indicia.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261466",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Index Verborum Catullianus (Wetmore)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it still remains true that even word-indexes are of great and permanent value",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261467"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261468",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Divisions in the Plays of Plautus and Terence (Foster)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Foster regards the vacant stage as an essential criterion of act-division",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The act-divisions in the plays of Plautus were, of course, first defined by Renaissance editors and are quite without respectable manuscript authority",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Composition of the plays into acts; review notes divisions lack MS authority and faults Foster's criteria.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261469",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Scythians and Greeks (Minns)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "This is an imposing summary of facts and opinions regarding the history and antiquities of the region north of the Black Sea.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "his sugges- tion (pp. 12 f .) that Nicobulus remains on the stage as a silent actor during Chrysalus' monody (Bac. 925 ff.) certainly deserves consideration",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from end of Foster review on act divisions at particular lines.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1914-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262287",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Caesar's Conquest of Gaul (Holmes)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the chapter on the credibihty of the narrative, which has been cut from seventy-two to forty-five pages",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "he defends the authenticity of some with great skill; sometimes his arguments seem inadequate",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review: authenticity of bracketed passages (B.G. v. 12-14) and authorship of the Commentaries discussed.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262288",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Agnostos Theos (Norden)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the point of fusion between the heart of oriental mysticism and the mind of Hellenic speculative thinking",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Now the Tornaesianus is known to have been in the collection at Cluni in the twelfth century",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Clark lecture in window/closing.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262289",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Recent Developments in Textual Criticism (Clark)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "The first development in the field of textual criticism, which Professor Clark discusses, is the increased attention now being given to local scripts.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the new textual criticism will be conservative rather than skeptical, and that it will tend to substitute objective and mathematical tests",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Stichometric unit decides omission vs interpolation at Cicero passages.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262290",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lexicon Plautinum, fasc. 7 (Lodge)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The extent to which foras and foris are dis- tinguished from each other furnishes vis with a delicate test of the vulgar element in the language of Plautus.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262291"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262292",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Beneventan Script (Loew)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "What has been more needed than anything else is a thorough historical study and exposition of the writing of individual centers and regions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Palaeography: history of a script as scribal practice.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262293",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in the Odyssey (Thompson)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "deals with the origin and growth of those traditions which found final expression in the Odyssey.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262294",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in the Odyssey (Thompson); Les pretres danseurs de Rome (Cirilli)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "I think it far more likely that Odysseus was a human ruler with a human wife than that he was once a divine wolf",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262296",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sull'Autenticita dell'Idillio VIII di Teocrito (Rostagni)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "It defends the authenticity of the Eighth Idyll — a matter which has been much discussed ever since the days of Valcke- naer",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Dr. Rostagni holds that nothing has been lost between lines 52 and 53, but that the strophe 57-60 should be omitted.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authenticity confirmed on organic unity and refuted linguistic objections; one strophe excised.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262297",
"kind": "review",
"title": "L. Annaei Senecae ad Lucilium epistulae (Hense)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "In 40.9 he has had the courage to retain qui itaque, with which many editors have toyed.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The second edition is wholesomely conservative, culling the best from the brilliant but unwarranted guesses of Lipsius, Fickert, and other scholars of distinction.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262298",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Beitrage zur lateinischen Syntax (Bahrens); Der Staat der alten Italiker (Rosenberg)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Especially interesting are the examples where the indicative and the subjunctive are found side by side without any apparent difference in meaning.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262299",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tendenz, Aufbau und Quellen der Schrift vom Erhabenen (Mutschmann)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "B",
"span": "he presents the evidence for holding that the author of this treatise was opposed to Caecilius of Calacte in his rhetorical theory",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "B: apparent discrepancy between summary and chapters removed by subordinating topics in the structure.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262300",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tendenz, Aufbau und Quellen (Mutschmann); Die lateinische Ubersetzung der Didache (Wohleb)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "he sometimes errs in regarding what seems to have been common stock of the rhetoricians of that period as the peculiar property of Theodorus",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "His text is therefore closer to the MS tradition.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 from Fuhr's Andocides edition in window/closing.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262301",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Andocidis orationes (Blass, ed. Fuhr)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "This is a thorough revision of the third edition (1906) of Blass's Teubner text of Andocides.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In the text Fuhr has in a considerable number of cases restored the MS reading as against a conjecture adopted by Blass",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262302",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Historische attische Inschriften (Nachmanson); Griechische Inschriften (Laudien)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "contains 87 inscriptions illustrative of the history of Athens from the sixth century B.C. to the fourth century a.d.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In a few cases where Blass inadvertently omitted the sign < )>, though in the critical note he referred to the addition of the word, Fuhr restores the sign",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D1 from end of Andocides review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262303",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dikaiomata (Graeca Halensis)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Papyrus Halensis I is of the third century B.C., probably from the end of the reign of Philadelphus.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262304",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dikaiomata (Graeca Halensis); Die antiken Odyssee-Illustrationen (Muller)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "There are sixteen paragraphs of Alex- andrian civic law presented to us in Halensis I.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262305",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Friedrich Lubker's Reallexikon des klassischen Altertums",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It is really a first help for the ignorant, not, of course, for the wholly ignorant, but for the advanced student",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261773",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Collected Literary Essays, Classical and Modern (Verrall)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Verrall's great purpose as a scholar was the recovery of the \"ancient and correct estimate of Euripides as a consummate artist.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Memorial appreciation of a scholar and his programme.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261774",
"kind": "review",
"title": "W. S. Teuffels Geschichte der romischen Literatur III",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The third volume of Teuffel covers the period from Juvenal to Aldhelm and Baeda.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Notice of a revised literary-historical handbook.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261775",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die Lebensalter (Boll)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "failed to note that the latter passage does not stand alone but reproduces a view which Aristotle presents in opposition to that of the Pythagoreans",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261776",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Primitive Text of the Gospels and Acts (Clark)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "The conclusion drawn is that some parent MS was written in narrow columns, having 10 to 12 letters to the line",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "They are therefore best explained as omissions of columns or series of columns in the common ancestors",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Line-length of ancestors decides whether passages are interpolations; reviewer doubts wholesale application.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261777",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Primitive Text (Clark); De Platonis Phaedri temporibus (Barwick)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "That other variants are due to the careless omission of single lines or groups of lines by copyists is equally well known",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "but any such wholesale acceptance or rejection of doubtful passages can never be convincing",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261778",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Platonis Phaedri temporibus (Barwick)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "His argument rests mainly on alleged contradictions or developments of the thought of other dialogues which he finds in it, and on the evolution of Plato's psychology.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "These postulates seem to me improbable both on a priori grounds and in their special application to Plato.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey rejects early dating built from developments across dialogues; Sprachstatistik and parody retained.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261779",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Works of the Emperor Julian II (Wright)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "In vii. 219B, the translation misses the fundamental distinction between the case of Herakles and that of Dionysos.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This chronology is, of course, impos- sible if we accept the two almost certain parodies of Isocrates in Plato",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "D2 from end of Barwick review (Phaedrus date).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261780",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Quantity and Accent in the Pronunciation of Latin (Westaway)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "Except when the u before another vowel is preceded by ng, and in suavis, suesco, suadeo, with their compounds and derivatives, u before a vowel is generally a vowel.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261781",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Papyri Iandanae; Griechische Papyri zu Giessen; Papyrus Grecs (Lille); Hamburg papyri",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The eighteen private letters (Fasc. II) range in date from the second to the seventh century and present some points of interest.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261782",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Homer, Erster Teil (Finsler)",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "only when he touches the subject of Homeric authorship does he lose that clear vision with which he beholds other matters.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Does it seem credible that two poets separated by a century or more should be one in all those hidden and intimate character- istics",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: Finsler holds Iliad and Odyssey by different poets; reviewer argues one poet from shared characteristics, similes, bards.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261783",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Influence of Isocrates on Cicero, Dionysius and Aristides (Hubbell)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author limits himself to a treatment of Isocrates' theories as to the purpose of oratory and the powers of the orator",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261784",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Livy, Book xxvii (Campbell)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The notes are, on the whole, excellent. The things that need explanation are made clear.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition with commentary.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-3287348",
"kind": "notice",
"title": "The \"Journal\" and \"Classical Philology\"",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The chief matter of business discussed and decided at the meet- ing of the Association was the relation of Classical Philology to the Journal",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Editorial notice from The Classical Journal on association business and subscription terms.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-05-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261376",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kalinka, Die pseudoxenophontische Athenaion Politeia",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "In i. 14 the difficulties involved on the MSS reading ol oorAeovres are overcome by reading ot jrAeWes.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The treatment of the text is charac- terized by conservatism and fidelity to the MSS tradition",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; passages decided one by one; date 430-424 accepted, author left unidentified.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261377",
"kind": "review",
"title": "von Arnim, Platos Jugenddialoge und die Entstehungszeit des Phaidros",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "if we can show that the full understanding of one dialogue presup- poses acquaintance with another, we may fairly presume that they were published in the sequence",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The earlier and independent publication of the first book of the Republic is confirmed by the fuller and more convincing development of some of its ideas in the Gorgias.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review reports a chronology of dialogues from presupposition relations; date of works, D2.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261378",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Friedlaender, Die Chadhirlegende und der Alexanderroman",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the episode of the fountain of life, which forms the connecting link between the two.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261379",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kleine Schriften von Franz Skutsch",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Skutsch concluded that Plautus employed only monosyllabic nemp. These facts admit the older scansion n&mpe' equally well, however.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261380",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bethe, Homer, Dichtung und Sage I: Ilias",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Professor Bethe offers a new and final solution of the problem of the composition of the Iliad.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the author has found contradictions where none exist",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Composition of one work from earlier songs (D2, not a corpus partition); reviewer defends unity from consistency across the whole.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261381",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Taeubler, Imperium Romanum I",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This volume is a study of the form and content of treaties contracted by Rome during the period of the Republic.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the Bethe review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261382",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sihler, Annals of Caesar; C. Julius Caesar",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The chief political events at Rome for each year are given with a detailed account of Caesar's activities.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261383",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sleeman, Caesar in Britain and Belgium",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Caesar in Britain and Belgium. By J. H. Sleeman. Cambridge: University",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School text; extract is mostly the tail of the Sihler review and the next school-text notice.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261384",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hodges, Caesar, The Gallic War: Books 1-7",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This text is intended for secondary schools and is one of the Macmillan Latin series.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School texts; page also carries the Sleeman review's body.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261385"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261386",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Heseltine and Rouse, Petronius; Seneca, Apocolocyntosis (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Mr. Heseltine's style is, generally speaking, adequate, and, while consistent and thorough in expurgation, he has preserved practically all that is of real value in the Satyricon.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In 5-18: fortuna (MSS, Buecheler) is preferable to furtiva, adopted from Heinsius' conjecture",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; extract opens with the end of the Barbagallo review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261387",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Corpus Medicorum Graecorum V 9, 1 (Galen on Hippocrates)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "We have before us the first instalment of the great Corpus Medicorum Graecorum",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "stress, are shown to be of no value, because they were corrected and supple- mented in the Aldine and subsequent editions from inferior MSS of Hippoc- rates.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition and tradition; Aldine lemmata discarded, oldest Hippocrates MSS confirmed.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261388",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roscher, Die hippokratische Schrift von der Siebenzahl",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Dr. Roscher's contention that the earlier chapters of Hippoc- rates IIcpi lySSo/xaSw are the oldest extant document of Greek Uterary prose",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "or second quarter of the fifth century B.C., at least in its earlier chapters; but it is unlikely that it dates from the sixth century.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer accepts a pre-Hippocratic date but rejects Roscher's sixth-century date.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261389",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roese, De Ovidii Heroidum codice Gissensi",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "vss. 18 and 19 are found in only a few of the manuscripts mentioned in early editions and in only one of the manuscripts known today",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "and they are all genuine for one who is not prorsus ab Ovidio alienus",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Stemma of lost portions in x used to decide genuineness of passages.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261390",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Staehlin, Das Motiv der Mantik im antiken Drama",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "seventeen times it is employed as an exit or entrance motive",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Dramatic use of divination as a practice; extract opens with end of Roese review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261391",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rowald, Repertorium lateinischer Woerterverzeichnisse und Speziallexika",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "furnishes the Latinist with a similar catalogue of the general and special lexicons",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Bibliographic tool.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261392"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261393",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Influence of Art on Description in the Poetry of P. Papinius Statius",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Henkt W. Peescott University of Chicago The Influence of Art on Description in the Poetry of P.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Body of this review is not in the extract (opening is the Helm review's tail); coded from title, low confidence.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261394",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Clark, Numerical Phraseology in Vergil",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "how far in this respect the poet was dependent upon his models or originals, and how far he was independent of them.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261395",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Merrill, The Archetype of Lucretius; Corruption in the Manuscripts of Lucretius",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he discusses Lachmann's theory concerning the archetype of all existing MSS of Lucretius.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "he concludes that \"the use of the archetype as a critical aid is extremely disappointing,\"",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Merrill denies the reconstructed archetype can decide critical difficulties.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261396",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Harrington, The Roman Elegiac Poets",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The editor has examined a number of MSS of the authors included in the volume (Catullus, Tibullus, Propertius, and Ovid)",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Baehrens' dates for V and G, which Harrington quotes, can be definitely rejected. V belongs to the fifteenth century and G was written about 1460.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition; reviewer judges texts and apparatus and redates manuscripts.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261643",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dussaud, Les civilisations prehelleniques dans le bassin de la Mer Egee",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "M. Dussaud has put together in convenient and readable form the results of the excavations of Arthur Evans at Cnossus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261644",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roscher, Omphalos",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "an elaborate investi- gation of the myths, cults, and monuments of the Greeks which have to do with the idea of a \"navel of the earth,\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261645",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Storr, Sophocles (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "He not only does not misconstrue (a thing which ought to, but does not, go without saying)",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review, coded A as judgement of renderings.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261646",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bennett, Horace: the Odes and Epodes (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Such renderings as \"poets\" for Mercurialium virorum (2. 17. 29) and \"lonely\" for caelebs (2. 15. 4) presuppose the juxtaposition of the text.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In 1. 38. 6 cura is read without good reason Bentleii periculo!",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; reviewer faults departures from the transmitted text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261647",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Miller, Cicero De officiis; Rackham, Cicero De finibus (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Loeb Classical Library offers in these volumes, one by an American, the other by an English scholar, two translations worthy of high commenda- tion.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261648",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mustard, The Piscatory Eclogues of Jacopo Sannazaro",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Professor Mustard's introduction deals at length with the popularity and influence of Sannazaro's Piscatory Eclogues.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261649",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fuhr, Demosthenis Orationes I",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The Teubner text of Demosthenes has long been in need of a thorough- going revision.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "he is even more conservative than Butcher, seldom rejecting a reading of S that can possibly be retained.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer approves refusing hiatus, breves and rhythm rules as grounds for deciding readings.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261650",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kern, Inscriptiones Graecae",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In publishing this selection of photographic reproductions, Kern has in mind those students of Greek epigraphy",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the Fuhr review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261652",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Belzner, Homerische Probleme II: Die Komposition der Odyssee",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "For the unity of the Odyssey, Dr. Belzner advances two main arguments",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "whatever flaws minute inspection may discover in the Iliad and Odyssey, there exist no better-composed long poems in the world.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3 secondary: reviewer answers the chorizontes, arguing Iliad and Odyssey are too alike to be by different authors.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1915-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261991",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Diels, Antike Technik",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "these are a few of the fascinating things woven together by Professor Diels in the six lectures",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261992",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Sandys, A Short History of Classical Scholarship",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Sir John Sandys has compressed into one useful volume what he regards as the essential contents of 1,692 pages.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261993",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Duff, L. Annaei Senecae Dialogorum Libri X, XI, XII",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "The editor has thrown new Ught on several important questions. Among them are the exact date of Gallio's governorship of Achaia",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The text leaves little to be desired, and the conjectures are reasonable.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Commentary edition; extract opens with end of the Sandys review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261994",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Robison, Syntax of the Participle in the Apostolic Fathers",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "His purpose was to classify the uses of the participle found in the texts indicated according to the scheme provided by Burton's New Testament Moods and Tenses",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261995",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Laum, Stiftungen in der griechischen und roemischen Antike",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "it presents the documents, literary and epigraphical, relating to foundations in antiquity",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the Robison review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261996",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Norden, Ennius und Vergilius",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Norden undertakes to rearrange the fragments of the seventh book of Ennius' Annaks and to prove some new instances of Vergil's dependence upon Ennian episodes.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "In the former task he is on the whole successful.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: reassignment of Ennius fragments among books, accepted by reviewer against the received arrangement.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261997",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Harmon, Lucian II (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "exhibits the same sound feeling for both Greek and English idiom.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; extract opens with end of the Norden review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261998"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261999",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Petersen, The Greek Diminutive Suffix -isko- -iske-",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The new monograph applies the same point of view and the same method to a semantically similar body of material.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the Pizzagalli Theogony review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262000",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Riese, Das rheinische Germanien in den antiken Inschriften",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The present work is devoted to the col- lection and classification of all epigraphical material, from whatever source derived, referring directly or indirectly to the Rhine country.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the Petersen review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262001",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thomas, Studien zur lateinischen und griechischen Sprachgeschichte",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "This valuable collection comprises thirty-six notes on passages in classical literature",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He believes that the MS reading should in each instance be given a chance, and wins the reader's acceptance of the soundness of his attitude",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "both",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262002",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Samter, Die Religion der Griechen",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Die Religion der Griechen. By Ebnst Samteb. Leipzig: Teubner, 1914.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract is mostly the tail of the Thomas review and the next (Durham) review; coded from the Samter notice.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262003",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Durham, The Vocabulary of Menander Considered in Its Relation to the Koine",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "\"An examination of Menander's vocabulary as compared with his predecessors and successors.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262004",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Foerster, Libanii Opera VIII",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Foerster rejects a compo- sition that has hitherto been ascribed to Libanius",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "Of the 30 eK<^poo-as only 7 are accepted as genuine.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authenticity of pieces under one name decided by a language test across the corpus; D2, not a partition among named persons.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262511",
"kind": "review",
"title": "White, The Scholia on the Aves of Aristophanes",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "The Introduction contains an admirably clear account of the sources of this commentary.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "and so the order of words in the MSS should not be changed in schol. 369.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Transmission of the scholia and an edition; editor adds many conjectures, reviewer defends MS readings at several loci.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262512",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ziegler, Menschen- und Weltenwerden",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "(1) the Symposium myth parodies Empedocles and Anaximander; (2) it touches very closely upon the account of man's creation in Gen., chap. 2",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with the end of the White scholia review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262513",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cooper, Aristotle on the Art of Poetry",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "To this end he has first of all subdivided the translation into small sections and provided it with marginal glosses",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Amplified translation with English-literature illustrations; extract opens with end of the Ziegler review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262516",
"kind": "review",
"title": "San Nicolo, Aegyptisches Vereinswesen zur Zeit der Ptolemaeer und Roemer I",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The clubs and societies found in Egypt during the period dealt with are grouped in five chapters",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of Vollmer's Ilias Latina review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262517",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Dieterich, Nekyia (2d ed.)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "upon the relationship between the eschatology of the syncretistic religion of the Hellenistic mysteries and the equally syncretistic eschatology of the Chris- tian apocals^pses",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262519",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Woodward and Mattingly, St. John Damascene, Barlaam and Ioasaph (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the first complete English version of Barlaam and Ioasaph, which is itself, despite prosiness and preaching, an interesting narrative",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; extract opens with end of a review on katharsis.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262520",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Butler, Propertius (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Professor Butler has equipped his translation with a brief Introduction on the Life of Propertius, the Manuscripts, the Division into Books",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "but his text is on the whole conservative and good.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; reviewer also defends MS authority for the cognomen.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262521",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Miller, Xenophon Cyropaedia (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The precision of the translation is, perhaps, best seen in the particles.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": "Translation review; reviewer argues senses of particles and a verb from cited occurrences.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262522",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Peterson and Hutton, Tacitus: Dialogus, Agricola, Germania (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Candor compels the assertion that the accuracy of the translations leaves much to be desiderated.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In. eleven contexts he has rejected emendations of his own or of other scholars in favor of the manu- script readings.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Translation review; extract opens with end of the Cyropaedia review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262523",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Schenkl, Marci Antonini Imperatoris in semet ipsum libri",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "This new edition of Marcus Aurelius in the Teubner series naturally challenges comparison with those of Stich and Leopold",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The editor himself has been prolific of emendations and more or less hesitating suggestions introduced with fortasse or malim.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; reviewer adds his own emendation at vi. 43.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262524",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Uri, Cicero und die epikureische Philosophie",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Uri would have Antiochus Cicero's principal authority in the refutation of Epicureanism",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Quellenforschung; extract opens with end of the Schenkl review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262525",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hirschfeld, Kleine Schriften",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "pro- poses the theory that the Roman tribes were first created in 495 B.C. in con- nection with the secession of the plebs",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262526",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Diehl, Euripides Medea mit Scholien; von Arnim, Supplementum Euripideum; Diehl, Supplementum Sophocleum",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Diehl's edition of the Medea, containing as it does a judicious selec- tion of scholia and critical notes, is particularly valuable for use in a pro- seminar.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the Ichneutae, the text of which has been bettered at several points in the last two years and still demands many additional improvements.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Small text editions including new papyrus fragments.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262527"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261862",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Elliott, The Acharnians of Aristophanes",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the editor per- sonally examined and collated all the fourteen manuscripts of the Acharnians in their respective libraries.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "tend to strengthen a belief in the value and trustworthiness of the archetype of the extant manuscripts",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261863",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Boll, Aus der Offenbarung Johannis",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "proceeds to show that the author derived his imagery in large measure from the astral notions current in his Hellenistic environment.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Elliott review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261864",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Veniero, Paolo Silenziario",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The translation follows the original closely and is, so far as I have tested it, correct.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Monograph with Italian translation and commentary; extract opens with end of the Boll review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261865",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Norvin, Olympiodorus fra Alexandria og hans Commentar til Platons Phaidon",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "his comprehensive study of the methods and ideas of Olympiodorus is a contribution to that complete and systematic interpretation of the whole school",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer adds his own reading of Phaedo 93A.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261866",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Owen, P. Ovidi Nasonis Tristia, Epistulae ex Ponto, Halieutica, Fragmenta",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "By way of preface Mr. Owen supplements a brief but comprehensive account of the manuscript tradition with some notice of recent monographs.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The fragmentary Halieutica — the genuineness of which Mr. Owen follows recent criticism in sustaining",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261867",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Waldstein, Greek Sculpture and Modern Art",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "He has set himself to elucidate the twofold thesis: (1) that the Hellenic principle of art is eternal",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261868",
"kind": "notice",
"title": "Meillet, Introduction a l'etude comparative des langues indo-europeennes",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The present edition, which was in press before the outbreak of the war, is a reimpression, with a few minor changes",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Brief notice of a reprint; page also carries end of Waldstein review and start of Showerman review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261869"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261870",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Tyrrell and Purser, The Correspondence of Cicero III (2d ed.)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Fam. ii. 10. 3 proves that he received the honor after the battle of Amanus.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Showerman Ovid review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261871",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Barbelenet, De la phrase a verbe etre dans l'ionien d'Herodote",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The sentence is cited as an example of the omis- sion of the copula.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Tyrrell-Purser review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261872",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Alexander, The Kings of Lydia and a Rearrangement of Some Fragments from Nicolaus of Damascus",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Less convincing is the conclusion that Meles was not one of the regular line of kings, but a usurper during the reign of King Ardys I.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "assigning Frg. 49 in Muller (F.H.G.) to book iv instead of to book vi (Muller).",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: reassignment of a fragment to another book by content convergence.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261873",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rusch, Grammatik der delphischen Inschriften I",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "We have now before us the first volume of a grammar of the Delphian inscriptions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Alexander review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261874",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Rabbow, Antike Schriften ueber Seelenheilung und Seelenleitung I",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "it is not surprising to find that Seneca and Plutarch are regarded as having derived much of their argu- mentation from him.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Quellenforschung.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261875",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Teufer, Zur Geschichte der Frauenemanzipation im alten Rom",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Dr. Teufer begins his study with the report given by Livy xxxiv. 1-8, of the alleged debate between the elder Cato and L. Valerius",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Same opening page as jstor-261874; coded as the Teufer review that continues onto p. 357.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261876",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ballou, The Manuscript Tradition of the Historia Augusta",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "Miss Ballou tries to assign the corrections and changes in P to the proper emenders, and then to date the Renaissance copies",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Could not B and P be copies of an almost contemporary x, as is the case with MSS V (Fulda) and M (Hersfeld) of Ammianus?",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Stemma study; Petrarch as corrector is transmission after antiquity; reviewer questions B's dependence on P.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261877",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Peter, Historicorum Romanorum Reliquiae I (2d ed.)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Forty-four years after the appearance of the first edition of this (first) volume, the veteran editor had completed his revision",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "his prin- cipal conclusions have been changed comparatively Uttle.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Ballou review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261878",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Egbert, Livy, Book XXI and Selections from Books XXII-XXX",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The notes are concise and give just the information needed by the young student to master the text.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261879",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Richter, Das alte Rom",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author must be congratulated on having achieved his purpose, which was to write a handy guide for travelers interested in pagan Rome.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Topographical manual.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261880"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261881",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lindsay, Sexti Pompei Festi de verborum significatu",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This volume, which is to be followed by a second, gives the complete text of what remains of Festus and of the epitome of Paulus.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The result is a sufficiently conservative text, conveniently arranged, with a full critical apparatus.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Helm Apologia review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261333",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roberts, Patriotic Poetry, Greek and English",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The original lec- ture, based on a comparison of Henry V and the Persae, has been expanded by supplementary notes",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Shorey calls it an announcement, not a review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261335",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Haines, The Communings with Himself of Marcus Aurelius Antoninus (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In iv. 30 Tpo<j>a<s ras Ik tS>v itaB-qpAruv does not mean \"I get no living out of my learning.\" It is metaphorical, and, as the context shows",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review; extract opens with end of the Frank Roman Imperialism review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261337",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ernout, Lucrece de la Nature IV",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "the text and critical notes evince close examination of the Leyden facsimiles.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The text differs little from that of Giussani; I have noted no original emendations.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Cocchia review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261338",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Perrin, Plutarch's Lives I-II (Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In chap. 19, d.<p' trcpas apx*)* means \"alio ab initio,\" as Doehner translates it, rather than \"from a second empire.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review; same opening page as jstor-261337.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261339",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Burnet, Die Anfaenge der griechischen Philosophie (tr. Schenkl)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This translation of Professor Burnet's Early Greek Philosophy, second edition, contains a few minor changes and corrections made by the author.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Extract opens with end of the Perrin review.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-261340",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in Archaism in Aulus Gellius (Foster)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This monograph, which discusses primarily the archaisms in the vocabu- lary and the syntax of the Noctes Atticae",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-261341"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-261342",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Epitome Thesauri Latini; La République romaine (Bloch)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "That is to say, the work is a scientific lexicon and not a dictionary designed primarily as a help to translation.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-4387350",
"kind": "notice",
"title": "The Classical Weekly, Vol. X No. 6 (editorial; General Index)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "How much demand would there be for a General Index to Volumes i-io of The Classical Weekly",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Editorial notice on indexes; closing pages discuss Latin terms of literary characterization.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1916-11-13",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262488",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Companion to Greek Studies (Whibley, 3d ed.)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "When the first edition of this handbook appeared in 1905, it represented what were supposed to be the sound and safe conclusions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262489",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Benutzung der philosophischen Schriften Ciceros durch Lactanz (Fessler)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "For a thorough study of the use by Lactantius of Cicero's philosophical writings there might per- haps be a place",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262490",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Defeat of Varus and the German Frontier Policy of Augustus (Oldfather and Canter)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "to show that the traditional view of the Germanic policy of Augustus is untenable, and to advocate a more natural and satisfactory theory",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262491",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Poseidonios und die jüdisch-christliche Genesisexegese (Gronau)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "he fails utterly, in my opinion, to prove the use of a single Posidonian source",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262492",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Gronau, Poseidonios (cont.); Menander Studien and Menandri reliquiae (Sudhaus)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "He fills out ingeniously, if rather boldly, the large lacunae.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "That some of his supplements are ingenious, without being convincing, would not evoke criticism",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of Sudhaus' Menander edition; reviewer doubts supplements at lacunae; also Gronau source-criticism continued.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262493",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Semantic Variability and Semantic Equivalents of -oso- and -lento- (Nichols)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "an adjectival termination in Latin may have a wide range of semantic variability, determined primarily by (a) the stem to which it is attached",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262494",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Amoris et Psyches Fabella Apuleiana (Schroeder)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Schroeder holds that the famous story is a primitive folk-tale, somewhat disguised by its Alexandrian dress and satiric embellish- ments",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262495",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Military Annals of Greece (Snyder)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Mr. Snyder's book appears to be an uncritical compilation from the older handbooks",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262496",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die orientalischen Religionen im römischen Heidentum (Cumont); A Grammar of the Greek New Testament (Robertson)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Franz Cumont's Les Religions orientales dans le paganisme romain was first published in 1906",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262497",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Grammar of the Greek New Testament in the Light of Historical Research (Robertson)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "might almost be described as a historical Greek grammar in which special attention is given to the Greek of the New Testa- ment",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262498",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Prodikos von Keos und die Anfänge der Synonymik bei den Griechen (Mayer)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "he is able to deduce certain general principles that Prodicus followed in the discrimination of synonymous terms",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-01-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262499"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-263238",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Apuleius: The Golden Ass (Adlington, rev. Gaselee; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "He ought to correct Adlington, where Adlington has radically misunderstood the meaning of Apuleius.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263240",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Phoutrides on the Euripidean chorus (end); Pliny, Letters (Melmoth rev. Hutchinson; Loeb)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "after a careful examination of the ancient testimonia, the author decides that a hyporcheme was",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263241",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Oidipus. Geschichte eines poetischen Stoffs im griechischen Altertum (Robert)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "decides that the \"authentic\" burial-place was not Colonos but Eteonos",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263243",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Jews among the Greeks and Romans (Radin, end); Spain under the Roman Empire; Syria as a Roman Province (Bouchier)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Mr. Radin gives an account of the more serious Jewish revolts down to Severus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263244",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Griechentum (von Scala); Das Altertum im Leben der Gegenwart (Cauer); Die homerische Dichtung (Finsler)",
"reach": "D3",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "the Iliad is the work of one poet, Melesigenes of Smyrna (Homer is a by-name), who completed and wrote down this epic about 700 B.C.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "The Odyssey, too, represents a fusion of distinct stories, but into a more perfect unity, by a single author who is simply \"Der Dichter,\" not Melesigenes-Homer.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review reports Finsler's partition: Iliad one poet (Melesigenes-Homer), Odyssey a different single author; unity and inconsistencies decide.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263245",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die baugeschichtliche Entwicklung des antiken Theaters (Fiechter)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Before the Hellenistic period the Greek theater had no proscenium. This was an importation from abroad",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263246",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Birds of the Latin Poets (Martin)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "gives us a \"picture of the Roman attitude toward bird life as reflected in their greatest poets.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263247",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Birds of the Latin Poets (end); Studi di Letteratura e Filologia Latina (Stampini); Selections from Catullus (Stewart)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "This prevalent Roman feeling is due, in my judgment, to the widespread ancient belief in the metamorphosis association.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263249",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Auswahl aus den Iliasscholien (Deecke); Firmicus Maternus, Matheseos libri VIII (Kroll, Skutsch, Ziegler)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the editor attempts to give a contracted but faithful conception of the meaning, wealth, and sources of the Homeric scholia",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-263250"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-263251",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Firmicus Maternus, Mathesis (end); De l'aspect verbal en latin ancien (Barbelenet)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "There are in Latin two aspects, and two only: the imperfective and the perfective",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "we may expect to see a number of studies stimulated by this trustworthy edition",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: review of the Kroll-Skutsch-Ziegler edition of Firmicus, judged trustworthy.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263252",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Case Usage in Livy (Steele); Clio Enthroned (Lamb)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The title of these papers suggests a purely syntactical treatise on the accusative and ablative in Livy.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263347",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Classical Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities (Walters); A Concordance to the Works of Horace (Cooper)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "The student of the classics accords a warm welcome to a classical diction- ary that is fairly up to date",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263348",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Concordance to the Works of Horace (Cooper)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The student equipped with this volume must be dull, indeed, if he fails to discover any passage which he needs",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263349",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch's Lives, Vols. III-IV (Perrin; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "surely cannot mean \"but the leading men among them felt some jealousy of the preliminary good fortune of Nicias",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "It would be better perhaps to adopt Solanus' emendation",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review correcting renderings passage by passage; recommends an emendation.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263351",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Caesar, The Civil Wars (Peskett; Loeb, end); A Study of the Cognomina of Soldiers in the Roman Legions (Dean)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "all of the evidence dealing with the whole subject is derived from inscriptions and papyri",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263352",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Stoicheia II: Studien zum antiken Sternglauben (Pfeiffer)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the author has given a comprehensive treatment of Greek and Roman astrometeorology",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263353",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Geschichte, 2d ed. (Beloch)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "In the arrangement of the tribes and trittyes, Beloch detects a species of \"gerry- mandering\" that would have been favorable to Peisistratus.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The meter points to the early Alexandrian period as date.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: Pfeiffer's appendix dates Homeric Hymn to Ares viii late, from an astrological source, by metre.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263354",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plautus, Vol. I (Nixon; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "Capt. 441, inventum inveni is something more than \"do not lose this friend you have found.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263356",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Menaechmi of Plautus (Drake); P. Terenti Afri Andria (Sturtevant)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "Sturtevant's Andria is intended for students who are making their first acquaintance with Roman drama",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The appendix contains for the most part discussions of readings adopted in the text, which in general is conservative.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "School edition and translation; D2 only for the conservative text of the Andria edition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262746",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Essays and Studies Presented to William Ridgeway (Quiggin, ed.)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "D. S. Robertson (\"The Authenti- city and Date of Lucian De Saltatione\") upholds the genuineness of the piece and assigns it to 162-65 a.d.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Mr. E. Harrison questions the usual reading of Polybius iii. 25. 6",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Festschrift review: Lucian authenticity upheld, Platonic dialogue order, Polybius reading questioned, Pindar reading changed.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262747",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die griechische Komödie (Körte); The New Greek Comedy (Legrand, tr. Loeb)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "His account of Sicilian comedy is not qualified by skepticism regarding the traditional record of Epicharmus' activity",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262748",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Latin Sentence Connection (Mendell)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This treatise is a study of the means used by Latin writers to define sentence relations.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262749",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Geography of Strabo, Vol. I (Jones; Loeb); Pseudogaleni in Hippocratis de Septimanis Commentarium (Bergstraesser)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "the author again supports Pais against Niese in the thesis that Strabo wrote at Amasia — far from Rome — some time about 7 B.C.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "neither is it due to the pen of Galen, as a study of Hardy's extracts long ago convinced me",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review reports a date and place for Strabo's Geography (settled) and denies the commentary to Galen.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262750",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Pseudogaleni in Hippocratis de Septimanis Commentarium (Bergstraesser)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "We have at last here presented in a scholarly edition a work about which much has been said since Hardy many years ago published extracts from it.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "neither is it due to the pen of Galen, as a study of Hardy's extracts long ago convinced me, nor does its unknown author contribute anything of importance",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition of an Arabic-transmitted commentary; reviewer denies Galenic authorship.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262751",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Leben und die Lehre Epikurs: Diogenes Laertius Buch X (Kochalsky)",
"reach": "D1",
"reach2": null,
"span": "On almost every page of the critical notes the editor betrays his immaturity and his want of acquaintance with the work of competent scholars",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "gravely proposes, as his own emendation, Kara iravra, which (so far as is known) originated with me",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of translation with critical notes; emendation priority at Ep. Hdt. 38.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1917-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263757",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Fragments of Sophocles (Pearson)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "A general introductory essay of a hundred pages studies the history of the text and the sources of the fragments",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "A great monument of English scholarship is worthily completed.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of a fragment edition and commentary; praised, with plot reconstructions kept apart from facts.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263758",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Religious Thought of the Greeks (Moore)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Like all descriptions of Orphic ideas and practices, it is an imaginative reconstruction of a certain religious attitude rather than an authentic account of known facts.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263759",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Religious Thought of the Greeks (Moore, end); An Index to Facsimiles (Dean); Roman Cursive Writing (Van Hoesen)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the vast debt which Christianity owes to the enlightened thought of Greece and the West",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263760",
"kind": "review",
"title": "An Index to Facsimiles in the Palaeographical Society Publications (Dean); Roman Cursive Writing (Van Hoesen)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The new Egyptian material, dating from the first to the fifth century, has at last made it possible to reconstruct the process of the development of the Roman cursive",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263761",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Roman Cursive Writing (end); Lucretius, Of the Nature of Things (Leonard); The Diamond (Laufer)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "a Latinist might question the italicized words, for if they were translated back into the Latin it is improbable that the retranslator would hit on the",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263762",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Diamond: A Study in Chinese and Hellenistic Folk-Lore (Laufer)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "The source of the legend he finds in the Hellenistic Orient.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263763",
"kind": "review",
"title": "P. Cornelii Taciti Dialogus de Oratoribus, 2d ed. (Gudeman)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "The history of the controversy is given with much detail, and the arguments for Tacitean authorship marshaled with rare skill.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "It is safe to say that the ghost of anonymity or heteronymity conjured up by Beatus Rhenanus and Justus Lipsius has finally been laid.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authorship confirmed for Tacitus; a second lacuna inferred from leaf-counts of the lost Hersfeldensis; new stemma.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1918-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263123",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ingram Bywater (Jackson)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "For of all British scholars few have rendered such services to learning as Bywater",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263124",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Flosculi Rossallienses",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "line 2 the ablative can only be understood as an ablative of quality by reference to the English",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263125",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Value of the Classics (West, ed.)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Nothing on the place of the classics in education has ever before been published so weighted with authority",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263126",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Études syriennes (Cumont)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the Syrian examples are seen to be a link in the long chain beginning with the ordinary earth tumulus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-263127"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-263128",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Le Satire di Orazio (Ussani); Virgil, Eclogues, Georgics, Aeneid i-vi (Fairclough; Loeb)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "In the volume before us the same editor presents a similar treatment of the Satires of Horace.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-263129"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-263130",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Virgil (Fairclough; Loeb, end); The Greek Genius and Its Influence (Cooper)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "F",
"span": "To me the volume seems to serve admirably the purpose for which it was prepared.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263131",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Greek Anthology, Vols. I-III (Paton; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "I think that Mr. Paton with other interpreters has misapprehended the meaning of the last two lines",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263132",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Biblical Libraries (Richardson)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This book is an attempt to trace the development of libraries during the period of Bible history.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263264",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Horace and His Age (D'Alton)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "the poet suffered a genuine reconstruction after Philippi and became, if not the inspired spokesman, at least the willing disseminator, of the Augustan propa- ganda",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263265",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Horace and His Age (D'Alton, end); Procopius' Works, Vols. I-II (Dewing; Loeb)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the evidence for the acceptance of astrology by the Stoics is neither convincing nor positive",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263266",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Gai Suetoni Tranquilli de vita Caesarum, Libri i-ii (Westcott and Rankin)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "This gives in about one hundred and fifty divisions the main stylistic facts, with one or more examples of each.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262949",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vie de Porphyre (Bidez)",
"reach": "B",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "these seeming inconsistencies, in great part at least, are to be explained from changes in Porphyry's philosophic position",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The Philosophy of the Oracles, which gives a complete system of theurgy, is, as Eunapius perceived, a very early work.",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Doctrinal inconsistencies resolved by a chronology of periods, which also dates the works.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1918-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262951",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch's Lives, Vol. V (Perrin; Loeb); Seneca, Epistulae Morales, Vol. I (Gummere; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "But, as is clear from chap- ter xxviii as well as from this passage itself, avrovopxtv means not \"independent of the King\" but \"independent of Thebes.\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "This emendation seems to me somewhat difficult and not altogether in accord with the context.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation corrections; D1 secondary where reviewer doubts Capps's emendation adopted in Seneca Ep. 13.14.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1918-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262953",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Latin Satirical Writing Subsequent to Juvenal (Weston, end); Dio Cassius, Vols. I-VI (Cary; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In Dio xi. 8. 2, \"mentally\" might be substituted for \"morally\" to render <f>povr(Sa",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1918-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263626",
"kind": "review",
"title": "L. Annaei Senecae Ad Helviam Matrem de Consolatione (Favez)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The text is based almost entirely upon Gertz. The editor deviates only in a few cases",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "he rejects the faecis of the Danish scholar for the luis of EUis, which is textually sounder",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; text conservative and sounder at the loci named.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263627",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Zur Geschichte der gymnischen Agone an griechischen Festen (Klee)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "Its chief contribution is the first publication of about thirteen pages of inscriptions from Cos",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263629",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Linguistic Change (Sturtevant, end); Studies in the History of the Roman Province of Syria (Harrer)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The subtitle to chapter iv, \"Semantic Change Erratic,\" is as untrue as the old idea of phonetic changes.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263630",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in the History of the Roman Province of Syria (Harrer); Pagan Ideas of Immortality (Moore)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "He has collected carefully the avail- able data bearing on the identity and chronology of the officials who served as governors or procurators of the province",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263085",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Greek Theater and Its Drama (Flickinger)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to elaborate the theory that the peculiarities and conventions of the Greek drama are largely expli- cable by its environment",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263086",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Notice sur le manuscrit latin 4788 du Vatican (Thomas)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "the fight it throws on the culture and classical scholarship of the early fourteenth century",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Professor Thomas establishes the identity of the two Pierres by the style and also by the fact that Simon Le Rat",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3 secondary: two works under the name Pierre de Paris joined as one maker by style and convergent biography; medieval, not ancient.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-4387849",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Classical Weekly 12 (May 19, 1919): Essais d'étymologie et de critique verbale latines (Niedermann), with notices",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "our author suggests that palma, in its original sense of 'hand' (Greek iraXd^r;), formed a diminutive palmula, which was changed by dissimulation to parmula.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "parallels",
"note": "Page also carries the end of a review, a society report and a query on the toga praetexta.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-05-19",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262933",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Interpreters of Foreign Languages among the Ancients (Gehman)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "A",
"span": "\"The Institution of Interpreters\" might have been enriched by considerable material found elsewhere, such as the means available for learning languages",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262934",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Epictetus, The Discourses and Manual (Matheson)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "In iii. 23. 34 fuixip' is I think \"inconsistency,\" not \"sordid struggle.\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "for the theory that the Rhesus was a \"pro-satyric drama, written by the youthful Euripides in imitation of Aeschylus",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "D2 secondary from the start of the Rhesus review on the same pages (Euripidean authorship held).",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262935",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Rhesus of Euripides (Porter)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The present editor devotes a generous portion of his Introduction to the problem (pp. xxxv-lii), but maintains that",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the investigations of critics have failed to adduce any facts sufficient to warrant us in disregarding the testimony which assigns it to Euripides",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition upholds Euripidean authorship of the Rhesus; reviewer keeps some reserve given its peculiarities of style.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262937",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Poeti Alessandrini (Rostagni); Poeti e Personaggi Catulliani (Pascal)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Certain passages in the hymn to Apollo are directly imitated in Propertius iv. 4.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262938",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die rednerische Disposition in der alten TEXNH RHETORIKE (Hamberger)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Mr. Hamberger in his book attempts to piece together our knowledge of the evolution of one of these divisions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263506",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Latin Epigraphy (Sandys)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "The author adopts (chap, iv) the usual classification: (1) inscriptions proper {titvli), and (2) documents (acta).",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263507",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Inscriptiones Latinae Selectae, Vol. III, Pars 1 (Dessau)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": null,
"span": "This volume contains the first nine parts of the index to Dessau's well- known selection of Latin inscriptions.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1919-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263508",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Gothic History of Jordanes (Mierow)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "in his criticism of the importance assigned by Mommsen to Ablabius as a source for Cassiodorus",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "He hardly succeeds in his attempt to identify his author with Bishop Jordanes of Crotona",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D2 secondary: reviewer rejects the identification of the author with the bishop of Crotona and of Vigilius with the Pope.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263509",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Classical Studies in Honor of Charles Forster Smith",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The trite objection that the play lacks unity Professor Hendrickson meets by the consideration that the action within the palace",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the action within the palace from Herakles' punishment of Lycus to his slaying of his children is continuous",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Festschrift review; D2 for the defence of the unity of Euripides' Herakles; other papers on style, sense and history.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1919-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263550",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Caesar, The Gallic War (Edwards; Loeb)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Mr. Edwards does not seem quite to have made up his mind as to what style he should adopt.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "other passages equally suspicious pass without comment, including iv. 10, about which even the most skeptical can hardly doubt",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": "Translation review; D1 secondary where reviewer names passages suspect of interpolation.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1920-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263551",
"kind": "review",
"title": "W. S. Teuffels Geschichte der römischen Literatur, 6th ed., Vol. I (Kroll and Skutsch); Storia dei Romani (De Sanctis)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "As in the two previous volumes the revision has observed the bounds set by the original plan of the work.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263552",
"kind": "review",
"title": "L'Età delle Guerre Puniche (De Sanctis)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Our author's plan is to give an unbroken chapter of historical exposition with essential notes at the foot of the page",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263553",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Doctrine of Literary Forms (Hack)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "there is a basic error in the critical method which has commonly been followed",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263443",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Kostes Palamas: Life Immovable (Phoutrides)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Here is a volume that brings the reader into contact with an unusual personality and sends one happily wandering in verses that breathe the spirit of classical tradition",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263444",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Romanization of Roman Britain (Haverfield)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the author discusses the Romanization of the country in (1) language, (2) material civilization, (3) art",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263445",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Q. Valerii Catulli Carmina (Pascal)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Usually an intelligible text is furnished, even where the text is in great dispute, but some of the old cruces are left \"crucified\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "The volume will be preferred by some to Ellis' Oxford text for its greater conservativeness",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition; judged more conservative than Ellis.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1920-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263446",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lucan de Bello Civili viii (Postgate)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The historical Introduction deals exhaustively and critically with Pompey's last days.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262801",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aspects, Aorists and the Classical Tripos (Harrison)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "It appears that there are two chief aspects, the imperfective and the perfective.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-07-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262802"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262803",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Manilius Astronomicon III (Housman)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Housman's edition of Book III of Manilius is a continuation of his editions of Books I and II",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The names of Scaliger and Bentley are those which are most frequently attached to emendations accepted in the text",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review of an edition whose text rests on accepted emendations.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1920-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262804",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Poetae Latini Minores V, Dracontius (Vollmer)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Two short poems which were included by Baehrens and whose Dracontian authorship is based on mere guess are omitted in the new edition.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "Many of the latter's conjectures are rejected in favor of those of Duhn, the first editor of the complete Romulea, or of the manuscript readings.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition drops guessed attributions, restores MS readings over Baehrens' conjectures.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1920-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262805",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Master of the Offices (Boak)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "a complete history of the mastership that will cover the whole period of its existence",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263305",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Etymologicum Gudianum (De Stefani)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the new editor has based his text upon the Codex Barberinus, which is not only a superior MS to that owned by Gude",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "De Stefani's edition shows a marked improvement upon that of Sturz",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "New edition rebases text on a different codex, displacing Sturz's text.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1920-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263306",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch's Lives VI-VIII (Perrin)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is \"at one word of command,\" not \"at one level,\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-3287997",
"kind": "article",
"title": "Archaeological Research in Greece in Relation to Classical Philology, 1869-1919",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Com- plete knowledge can be gained only by combination of the two methods.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1920-11-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263321",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Martial, the Epigrammatist; and Other Essays (Kirby Flower Smith)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In this volume Professor Wilfred Mustard has collected a number of papers written by his friend and colleague",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263323",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die germanische Urgeschichte in Tacitus Germania (Norden)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "no one has analyzed the relations of the two authors with such thoroughness and plausibility as Norden",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263324",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Hellenistic Influence on the Aeneid (Duckett)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the second and third discuss the influence of Hellenistic life and thought upon the Aeneid",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263325",
"kind": "review",
"title": "L'Arte Classica (Ducati)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "To write a history of classic art in one volume is certainly a tour de force",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263328",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Modern Greek Stories (Vaka and Phoutrides)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "In the volume before us we have ten tales adequately translated by Demetra Vaka and Aristides Phoutrides.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263330",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Fasti Triumphales Populi Romani (Pais)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The edition of the fasti that follows is conservative and reliable",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262838",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Mausoleum und Tatenbericht des Augustus (Kornemann)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "the Res Gestae of Augustus, as we have it, is made up of an original portion with successive additions and revisions",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "The third chapter, the principal part of the work, contains a critical analysis of the text of the inscription",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Review endorses Kornemann's layered composition of the Res Gestae.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262839",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Teuffels Geschichte der romischen Literatur II, 7th ed.",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The present revision is the second made by Professor Kroll and his colleagues",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262840",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Four Centuries of Greek Learning in England (Bywater)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the lecturer outlines the story of the introduction of Greek studies into Oxford and England from Italy at the Renaissance",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-04-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262841"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262842",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A. Cornelii Celsi quae supersunt (Marx)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "the Medicina of Celsus is a translation of the Greek treatise of T. Aufidius Siculus",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "On the whole one will be pleased also with the editor's judgment in constituting the text.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; source thesis accepted; text judged sound. Page also carries end of a review of Meyer.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262843",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ciceronis Orationes, editio altera (Clark)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Few second editions of Latin texts differ so radically from the original edition as does this one.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Clark has become more conservative in his attitude toward supposed interpolations.",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "New edition rests on the Cluny MS found at Holkham; restores lines formerly deleted.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263143",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Phéniciens (Autran)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "L",
"span": "M. Autran's reconstruction of the course of human development from prehistoric times down through the entire pre-Hellenic age",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263145",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch's Lives IX (Perrin)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "should be rendered \"and Agathocles the Sicilian as Island Governor\" rather than \"and Agathocles as Island Governor of Sicily.\"",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the text is almost certainly corrupt. Lindskog-Ziegler after Stephanus indicate a lacuna.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263146",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Seneca, Epistulae Morales II (Gummere)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Egeram is rather from egero and means \"I shall put into written form.\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "In modo is exactly what is required here.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263147",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Herodotus I (Godley)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The word had not yet become technical. It means merely \"wise men.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263148",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ovid Metamorphoses (Miller)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "the device of converting translation into a manner of explanation",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262912",
"kind": "review",
"title": "La Critica dei Poeti Romani in Orazio (Pascal)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "a very useful collection of the material bearing on Horace's attitude toward some of the most important Latin poets",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262913",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Res Metrica (Hardie)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "completed before his death this excellent introduction to Greek and Latin metric",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262914",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Horace in the Literature of the Eighteenth Century (Goad)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "She has collected the quotations of Horace and the references to him in Rowe, Addison, Steele, Prior, Gay, Pope",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262915",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Delphi (Poulsen)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Dr. Poulsen's prevailing interest is in the additions to our knowledge of Greek art brought by the French excavations.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262916",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vergil and the English Poets (Nitchie)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the other sums up the entire Vergilian tradition of English literature in 244 pages",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262917",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Homer, The Odyssey II (Murray); Homers Odyssee (Ameis-Hentze-Cauer)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Mr. Murray's English prose reflects the epic simplicity and dignity, its composure, and swiftness of movement.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "leaves the text intact, but adds indications of the more evident interpolations",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Two short reviews; the school commentary keeps the text but marks interpolations.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": [
"jstor-262918"
]
},
{
"id": "jstor-262919",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Travel among the Ancient Romans (Mooney)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "to put into one volume the essential facts connected with the topic",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262920",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Catulli carmine sexagesimo quarto (Sell)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Catullus in his soul-stirring love affair with Lesbia had sufficient background for the narration of the Ariadne story and did not need to rely on his Greek predecessors.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-4388224",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Ancient Times (Breasted); notices on Brewster and Murray's Preface to Bywater's Poetics",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "To compress within 300 pages, for text-book pur- poses, the history of the ancient world from earliest man down to the German invasions",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1921-10-31",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262635",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Grundfragen der Homerkritik, 3rd ed. (Cauer)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "the emendation of r 453, which would clinch the proof of a single archetype, has become more important than ever.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "I believe it can be shown that the external evidence against A 123 is warrant for regarding it as an interpolation.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Reviewer (Bolling) argues archetype and interpolations from papyri; not a corpus partition.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-262636",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Greek Theater of the Fifth Century (Allen)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "The whole is mainly intended to establish two highly important theories concerning the history of the Athenian theater.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-01-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263478",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Homeric Catalogue of Ships (Allen)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Mr. Allen posits a historical document whose authenticity has been impugned.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "the Catalogue as a whole, measured by the Iliad as a whole, is a late and secondary document",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Allen argues the Catalogue early and authentic; reviewer (Fitch) holds it late and secondary by its relation to the whole Iliad.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263479",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Verskunst (Wilamowitz)",
"reach": "L",
"reach2": "G",
"span": "there are no new or helpful ideas for the practical study of Greek metric",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263481",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Recherches sur l'Éphébie attique (Brenot)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "Her conclusions are that nothing warrants the opinion that the Attic Ephebeia was an old or fifth-century institution",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263483",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Titi Livi ab urbe condita II, libri VI-X (Walters and Conway)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "With the appearance of this volume we have at last a trustworthy text and apparatus of the first decade of Livy",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "there are no startling changes in the Oxford edition",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "New MSS added; archetype's line-length reconstruction used to emend particular places.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263484",
"kind": "review",
"title": "P. Vergili Maronis opera, editio maior (Janell)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "the apparatus has shrunk, in some places almost to the vanishing point of usefulness",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "His announced purpose is to free the text from Ribbeck's often reckless changes and restore the tradition.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition review; restores the tradition against Ribbeck.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263485",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Altgriechischer Baumkultus (Weniger)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "discusses the signifi- cance of the symbolism back of the employment among the Greeks for a variety of usages of leaves and branches",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263486",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Die altgriechische Bühne (Frickenhaus)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "M",
"span": "that Lycurgean theater at Athens and its predecessor differed from all other Greek theaters known to us",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263488",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Cicero de Divinatione I (Pease)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "The full notes emphasize chiefly the history of philosophic ideas, religion , religious antiquities, and, I regret to say, folklore.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263489",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Der junge Platon I (Horneffer)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "the main thesis of the book which is that the Delphic oracle which pronounced Socrates the wisest was genuine",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263490",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aus Goethe's griechischer Gedankenwelt (Bapp)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Sixty out of the ninety-nine pages of this volume are occupied with a study of Goethe and Heraclitus",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263491",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Bronzi arcaici e ceramica geometrica nel Museo di Bari (Gervasio)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The ceramics of the archaic necropolis may be divided into two groups, indigenous and imported.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263492",
"kind": "review",
"title": "The Platonism of Philo Judaeus (Billings)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "B",
"span": "Philo's thought is essentially Platonic, though he frequently adopts the terminology of other schools",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Secondary B: Philo's alleged inconsistencies on God traced to Plato.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263493",
"kind": "review",
"title": "De Ciceronis Libro Consolationis (Van Wageningen)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "He believes that the chief and virtually the only source of this was Crantor's essay de luctu.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263494",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Libanii Opera X (Foerster)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The present volume contains the first instalment of the Letters and a conspectus siglorum for the MSS, editions, and commentaries cited.",
"d_direction": "open",
"d_span": "certain pieces which are, says Foerster, the work of Choricius of Gaza, though they have come down to us under the name of Libanius.",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Edition notice; reassigns pieces transmitted under Libanius to Choricius.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-04-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263603",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Griechische Mythologie II (Preller-Robert)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": "E",
"span": "Robert has made especial effort to trace the growth of each myth in poetry and art from the earliest form which can now be discovered",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263604",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Archaeological Excavation (Droop)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Stress is laid throughout upon the duty of conducting excavations for the purpose of extracting from a site all the information it can yield",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263606",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Study of the Commerce of Latium (Adams)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "It deals with the foreign commerce of Latium from the early Iron age to the end of the sixth century.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263607",
"kind": "review",
"title": "La Légende socratique et les sources de Platon (Dupréel)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "\"Parallels\" between Plato and contemporary or later spurious literature are treated as evidence, not of the imitation of Plato, but of the use of a common source.",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "neither Professor Dupreel's methods nor the particular arguments on which he relies go far to overcome this unfavorable presumption",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: Dupréel makes Socrates a literary invention and parcels Plato's arguments out to Hippias, Prodicus; Shorey rejects it.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263608",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Philostratus and Eunapius, Lives of the Sophists (Wright)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is not, I think, \"a boisterous Greek dance\" but is used metaphorically as in Stob. Flor. 68.37",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "both",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263609",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Thucydides I-III (C. F. Smith)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "\"was held to account\" should be \"was punished.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263610",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Plutarch's Lives X (Perrin)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is an adjective agreeing with Trpovrayiincriv, not \"Macedonians.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263611",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Das Wesen des römischen Kaisertums; Vom Prinzipat zum Dominat (Schulz)",
"reach": "C",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The constitutional theory that the Princeps derives his authority from the Senate disappears, according to Schulz, with the accession of Carus in 282",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263612",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Vergil: A Biography (Frank)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "The author evidently thinks that the authenticity of most of these poems may now be granted and proceeds on this basis.",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "in the case of the Culex and many epigrams of the Catalepton the argument for authenticity is quite valid",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Authenticity of Appendix Vergiliana poems taken one by one (D2); reviewer accepts some, doubts others.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-07-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263015",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Iuliani Imperatoris Epistulae (Bidez and Cumont)",
"reach": "D2",
"reach2": "D3",
"span": "the order of the 79 letters in Hertlein reflects no MS tradition, has no chronological sequence, and is a medley of spurious and authentic",
"d_direction": "both",
"d_span": "we could then continue to assign this decidedly Julianic epistle to Julian",
"evidence": "mixed",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "D3: letters reassigned between the emperor Julian and the sophist Julian of Caesarea; reviewer contests some.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263016",
"kind": "review",
"title": "A Companion to Latin Studies, 3rd ed. (Sandys)",
"reach": "G",
"reach2": null,
"span": "The work of revision has been restricted by the desire of the editors to retain the original pagination.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263017",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Aristotle, De Generatione et Corruptione (Joachim)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "The parenthesis, if parenthesis there be, is rather our later sentence",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "Mr. Joachim's text presents few emendations.",
"evidence": "locus",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263018",
"kind": "review",
"title": "New Chapters in Greek Literature (Powell and Barber)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "D2",
"span": "The purpose of this volume is to give some account of \"recent discoveries in Greek poetry and prose of the fourth and following centuries b.c.\"",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "decides definitely in favor of the authorship of Ephorus, and there can be little doubt that his contention is right",
"evidence": "find",
"relation_decides_locus": false,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Secondary D2: attribution of the Oxyrhynchus Historian to Ephorus, accepted by reviewer.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263019",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Etruscan Tomb Paintings (Poulsen)",
"reach": "M",
"reach2": "C",
"span": "Thus the paintings illustrate Etruscan history, as well as Etruscan burial customs and family life.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263020",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Lucian III (Harmon)",
"reach": "A",
"reach2": null,
"span": "is perhaps rather \"reduce to mood and figure\" than \"solve fallacies.\"",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": "passage",
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263021",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Freiwilliger Opfertod bei Euripides (Schmitt)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": "D1",
"span": "Euripides' debt to Aeschylus' Seven against Thebes in this drama, it is shown, is not for a leit-motiv",
"d_direction": "confirm",
"d_span": "the author defends the original text of the hastily written Heracleidae against the hypothesis of a lacuna after line 608",
"evidence": "relation",
"relation_decides_locus": true,
"sense_method": null,
"note": "Defends Heracleidae text; rejects Aelian fragment as un-Euripidean in speech and technique.",
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": true,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263022",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Seneca the Philosopher and His Modern Message (Gummere)",
"reach": "F",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Mr. Gummere traces his influence from the first century on through the Middle Ages and the Renaissance down to the present day.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263024",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Orazio Lirico (Pasquali)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Pasquali well shows how Horace takes a line or phrase from Alcaeus and develops it in an original fashion.",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
},
{
"id": "jstor-263026",
"kind": "review",
"title": "Studies in the Songs of Plautine Comedy (Law)",
"reach": "E",
"reach2": null,
"span": "Leo weakened his position by assuming that certain songs in the Persa, Mostellaria, and Stickus were songs in the Greek originals",
"d_direction": null,
"d_span": null,
"evidence": null,
"relation_decides_locus": null,
"sense_method": null,
"note": null,
"span_ok": true,
"d_span_ok": null,
"date": "1922-10-01",
"dups": []
}
]