[{"hid": "r:jstor-261361:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261361", "s": "Hauvette argues with some plausibility that Aristotle's statement shows that there is nothing to prove that the poet actually witnessed the eclipse; it may not have been that of April 6, 648, visible at Thasos, but that of April 15, 657, a total eclipse for countries east of Rhodes.", "prev": "Thus, with regard to the eclipse of frag. 74, which has been regarded as affording the one sure chronological fact in the history of the poet, M.", "next": "Of the dates to which the dx/xij of the poet is referred, 688 is that of the beginning of his adventures at Thasos, 665 that of his sojourn at Paros after his return.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.541, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262266:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262266", "s": "For the fifth and fourth centuries we have more than a plausible argument against the use of such a boot.", "prev": "We can not be so positive with regard to the Hellenistic period, but the literature that we have knows no name for such a boot.", "next": "The literature of the period has no name for any special tragic boot ; the drama is full of lively action which the six-inch and higher sole we are asked to believe in almost precludes ; the art of the period never pictures it either as a symbol of tragedy with the mask or as the foot-wear of actors, and the most positive piece of evidence on either side of the question, the Piraeus Relief, repres", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.702, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262267:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262267", "s": "For the fifth and fourth centuries we have more than a plausible argument against the use of such a boot.", "prev": "We can not be so positive with regard to the Hellenistic period, but the literature that we have knows no name for such a boot.", "next": "The literature of the period has no name for any special tragic boot ; the drama is full of lively action which the six-inch and higher sole we are asked to believe in almost precludes ; the art of the period never pictures it either as a symbol of tragedy with the mask or as the foot-wear of actors, and the most positive piece of evidence on either side of the question, the Piraeus Relief, repres", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.3, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262269:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262269", "s": "Here we have a complete list of instances for the early period, followed by a full and convincing discussion, showing that the attracted clause is preferably in the same time-sphere as the clause on which it depends; that its favorite position is between the introductory conjunction (when such exists) and the verb of the governing clause; that its verb rarely expresses", "prev": "The most valuable part of the treatise is that dealing with the scope and limits of attraction for early Latin.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.955, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262270:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262270", "s": "Here we have a complete list of instances for the early period, followed by a full and convincing discussion, showing that the attracted clause is preferably in the same time-sphere as the clause on which it depends; that its favorite position is between the introductory conjunction (when such exists) and the verb of the governing clause; that its verb rarely expresses Book Reviews 195 precise temporal and modal force; that the clause as a whole is rather generalizing than determinative, and more frequently temporal than relative.", "prev": "The most valuable part of the treatise is that dealing with the scope and limits of attraction for early Latin.", "next": "In undertaking to explain the origin of attraction Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.625, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262270:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262270", "s": "Frank is less convincing.", "prev": "In undertaking to explain the origin of attraction Mr.", "next": "Attraction, he holds, is not merely a formal assimilation, but its beginnings are to be sought in sentences like mittat quern velit, in which, following Hale, the author regards velit as being as much a jussive as mittat — \"let him choose his man and send him.\" But even if we admit the justice of this particular interpretation, one can hardly regard as parallels examples like Bacch. 656, furetur q", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.702, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262271:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262271", "s": "Frank is less convincing.", "prev": "In undertaking to explain the origin of attraction Mr.", "next": "Attraction, he holds, is not merely a formal assimilation, but its beginnings are to be sought in sentences like mittat quern velit, in which, following Hale, the author regards velit as being as much a jussive as mittat — \"let him choose his man and send him.\" But even if we admit the justice of this particular interpretation, one can hardly regard as parallels examples like Bacch. 656, furetur q", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.384, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-3286898:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-3286898", "s": "We can not hope to convince the authors of these treatises or the great mass of students that these things, in the ele- ments at least and initial stage, may be more effectively learned through humanistic studies.", "prev": "The wisdom of life and letters, too, is now taught from systematic modern handbooks of psychology, ethics, political science, sociology, rhetoric, literary criticism.", "next": "But we may show our own students that through such studies largely interpreted they may combine with discipline and aesthetic delight something of the philosophic breadth which they seemed to renounce in electing the classical and philo- logical curriculum.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.915, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262018:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262018", "s": "He too often, however, conde- scends to the \"immature\" thinker of an earlier time, and reads the greatest dialectician who ever lived lessons in elementary logic, and in his endeavor to detect fallacies, inconsistencies, and chronological develop- ments in the dialogues he verifies again my thesis that such attempts, however plausible a priori, almost always wrrrep imrrjSes, as if by some fatality, lead to misinterpretation.", "prev": "Professer Gomperz' analyses of the Platonic dialogues are always suggestive and sometimes illuminating.", "next": "Thus in II, p. 332, and III, p. 50, he argues that the Gorgias must be earlier than both Rep.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.405, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262020:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262020", "s": "Although the evidence is rather scanty, yet Ashby seems to have made out a plausible argument for assigning the earlier sketches at least to Coner.", "prev": "This Coner is wholly unknown except from an inventory of his goods, preserved in the Archivio di Stato in Rome, which shows him to have been a learned man with a large library.", "next": "He was a friend of Bramante's, for there are several sketches by the latter in the collection, and some drawings in Florence — generally, though as it seems wrongty, ascribed to Michelangelo — are shown to have been copied from those of Coner.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.822, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262077:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262077", "s": "I feel convinced that they play an important r6le, but I am still somewhat skeptical regarding the possibility of arriving at very definite results in the search for ultimate causes.\" A clearer distinction between \" ultimate \" and \"immediate \" causes would, I believe, have modi- fied Vossler's discussion of \" mechanical \" changes,'\" for the immediate causes of certain phonetic changes can certainly be purely mechanical.", "prev": "y psychical (emotional) states of the individual in influencing the form of his utterance.^ These have been occasionally referred to before (as for the aspirated compara- tives and superlatives of the dialect of West Somerset,' or forms like the Sanskrit Qrdusat\"), but they have never been so strongly emphasized as is done here, where they appear as the sole ultimate cause of all phonetic changes.", "next": "Like Vossler's earlier book the present volume is suggestive throughout.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.79, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262081:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262081", "s": "Thus there is a convincing resum6 of the evi- dence for the continued production of painted vases in Attica down to the time of Alexander (pp. 11, 12); there is a description, with excellent illustrations, of an open-work Greek shoe (pp. 13, 14); there are hints regarding the later development of Greek ornament (pp. 74-76) ; and so on.", "prev": "The work abounds in information and suggestion on an unexpectedly varied range of subjects.", "next": "Naturally there is considerable space devoted to burial customs, as exemplified in the Greek cemetery of Abusir, but the lion's share falls to the art of the joiner, as exemplified in the chest-like coffins of wood found on this site and in southern Russia.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.881, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262082:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262082", "s": "Thus there is a convincing resum6 of the evi- dence for the continued production of painted vases in Attica down to the time of Alexander (pp. 11, 12); there is a description, with excellent illustrations, of an open-work Greek shoe (pp. 13, 14); there are hints regarding the later development of Greek ornament (pp. 74-76) ; and so on.", "prev": "The work abounds in information and suggestion on an unexpectedly varied range of subjects.", "next": "Naturally there is considerable space devoted to burial customs, as exemplified in the Greek cemetery of Abusir, but the lion's share falls to the art of the joiner, as exemplified in the chest-like coffins of wood found on this site and in southern Russia.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.781, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262085:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262085", "s": "Such articles, to quote from Traube's preface, are to be \"durch Gleichheit der Schule oder voile Einigkeit liber die philologischen Wege und Ziele unter sich verbunden.\" That means, among other things, that these studies will have recourse, wherever possible, to that fusion of the sciences of history, paleography, and the transmission of texts which gives an indispensable clue to the investigator of the early Middle Ages, as Traube himself has so brilliantly and convincingly set forth in many publica- tions.", "prev": "It is a pleasure to greet the appearance of the initial number in Traube's Quellen und Untersuchungen, a publication which will give at least partial expression to its founder's great plans for mediaeval Latin philology, by including editions or investigations of large scope either suggested directly by him or developed under his supervision.", "next": "It means also that the contributors — I am sure I voice the feeling of them all — are at one in their devotion to Traube, to his enlivening genius, his humane sympathies, his universal learning, without the aid of which much of their work would be impossible.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.137, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262085:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262085", "s": "This latter point has not been emphasized before, I believe, and seems entirely convincing.", "prev": "Chap, v attempts to show that Ephorus and the other fourth-century writers, excluding the orators, return to the earlier and truer version, and give due credit to Pausanias and the Spartans for the decisive victory at Plataea.", "next": "Thereafter in brief chapters Wright follows the course of the influence of the Herodotean version in the remaining biographers and historians of antiquity who touch upon the battle.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.968, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262086:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262086", "s": "This latter point has not been emphasized before, I believe, and seems entirely convincing.", "prev": "Chap, v attempts to show that Ephorus and the other fourth-century writers, excluding the orators, return to the earlier and truer version, and give due credit to Pausanias and the Spartans for the decisive victory at Plataea.", "next": "Thereafter in brief chapters Wright follows the course of the influence of the Herodotean version in the remaining biographers and historians of antiquity who touch upon the battle.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.533, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262089:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262089", "s": "Despite the learning displayed, the interpretations proposed of the Eleusinian Relief, of the Echelos and Basile relief, as of many other sculptures, are not convincing.", "prev": "It is also to be regretted that the author indulges in such lengthy discussions of the individual pieces of sculp- ture.", "next": "In regard to the relief in which Echelos and Basile appear, the views of Professor Kekule von Stradonitz in the Berlin Winckelmannsprogramm for 1905, based it is true partly on new evidence, are much more simple and probable.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.512, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262089:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262089", "s": "Professor Jones convincingly demonstrates the incorrectness of this theory, as well as the inadequacy of others that have succeeded, treating with special thoroughness and ability the highly subjective theory of Haase.", "prev": "mmarians ancient and modern concerning the principles governing the employment of cases with similis and its compounds, beginning with that of Flavius Caper of the second century, who laid down the proposition : illius similis ad mores refertur ; illi similis ad vultum — a theory which, though now banished from most of our Latin grammars, is still unfortunately current in much esoteric teach- ing.", "next": "The author's own conclusions are that the difference in case usage with similis and its compounds marks not a logical distinction, but one partly of time, partly of style.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.756, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262090:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262090", "s": "Professor Jones convincingly demonstrates the incorrectness of this theory, as well as the inadequacy of others that have succeeded, treating with special thoroughness and ability the highly subjective theory of Haase.", "prev": "mmarians ancient and modern concerning the principles governing the employment of cases with similis and its compounds, beginning with that of Flavins Caper of the second century, who laid down the proposition : illius similis ad mores refertur ; illi similis ad vultum — a theory which, though now banished from most of our Latin grammars, is still unfortunately current in much esoteric teach- ing.", "next": "The author's own conclusions are that the difference in case usage with sim,ilis and its compounds marks not a logical distinction, but one partly of time, partly of style.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.571, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262091:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262091", "s": "And for these breaks he is able to offer plausible explanations in the political conditions of the time and to show that a method was followed even in starting afresh upon the cycle of tribes.", "prev": "It not only completely restores confidence in his secretary-canon for the periods where its applicability was most disputed, but enables him to establish the fact that there were breaks in the system and to date them.", "next": "Without following the author in the details of his demonstration, we may present an outline of the periods which he establishes and the means of control which he has made available for all future constructions of the archon lists: Year 352/1 to 322/1.. 307/6 to 262/1 .. 261/60 to 231/30 230/29 to 138/7 . 137/6 to 104/3 . . 103/2 to 88/7... 87/6 Official Order of Tribes Fol- lowed by Secretaries to", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.489, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261667:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261667", "s": "Professor Usener's brilliant conception that Plato's original text came forth after that time from the cellar in Scepsis and formed an authentic basis on which our own parchment MSS rest, necessarily failed to convince, because one hypothesis had been built upon another, and of real proofs there was nothing.", "prev": "Kenyon seems to forget, firstly, that these copyists of Homer were still very remote from Homer, whilst those of the Phaedo and Laches were quite near to Plato (later, perhaps, by one century), and secondly, that after that age there came for Homer a critical reformation, carried through by the best grammarians, while for Plato we know of nothing of the sort.", "next": "The most interesting variant is Phaed. 68 e, avSpa7roS(ii8r] instead of evrjOrj.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.581, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261681:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261681", "s": "The poet wanted a daughter of Chryses, and invented Chrysels, and devised Briseis as a companion-piece to her — without mention of Wila- mowitz's plausible explanation of Briseis as the 'Maiden from Bresa.' Much of this view that has been presented is 'subjective ' and uncon- vincing.", "prev": "Chryses and Chrysa are related to each other as Apollo to Artemis.", "next": "Parts of it are almost anachronistic.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.518, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261681:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261681", "s": "This treatise by Wecklein is interesting and suggestive, but not convincing in detail nor very important. 2 Yale University Index verborum Propertianus.", "prev": "Attention does not seem to have been called to the fact that in the Hymn to Demeter the temple and altar to that goddess, fol- lowing the most natural interpretation, were erected in a single day, and so this temple, too, must have been a mere shrine (296-304, 384 f.).", "next": "Fecit Ioannbs S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.772, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261682:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261682", "s": "This treatise by Wecklein is interesting and suggestive, but not convincing in detail nor very important. 2 Yale University Index verborum Propertianus.", "prev": "Attention does not seem to have been called to the fact that in the Hymn to Demeter the temple and altar to that goddess, fol- lowing the most natural interpretation, were erected in a single day, and so this temple, too, must have been a mere shrine (296-304, 384 f.).", "next": "Fecit Ioannbs S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.596, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261683:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261683", "s": "In regard to their \"national patrimony,\" they are convinced that all others, and especially we of Germanic speech, are barbarians, in somewhat the ancient sense of the word; hence their refusal to grant to foreigners, responsible scientific bodies included, permission to conduct excavations on Italian soil, even though, as in Greece, the objects found be deposited in the national col- lections.", "prev": "The Italians — be it said with all respect by one who knows and admires them — are excessively sensitive and clannish.", "next": "This is irritating to those who view archaeological investigations as a part of historical science and not as a privilege of ' making finds,' especially since permits are readily granted to more or less ignorant Italian speculators, whose only desire is to find what they can and sell it at the highest price.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.406, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262143:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262143", "s": "But we shall not soon see another such editor. 234 Book Reviews The introduction presents first a life of the poet, including an account of the island of Ceos and of the court of Hieron, and a convincing, though reluctantly maintained, argument that the spiteful allusion aKpavra yijpvcTov (O. 2. 96) is aimed at the pair Bacchylides and Simonides.", "prev": "Of \" investigators \" and investigations there is no lack.", "next": "Bacchylides' place and rank in Greek literature is then defined in a lucid sketch of the history of lyric poetry from Terpander to Timotheus and the feeble successors of Philoxenus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.377, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262236:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262236", "s": "Since the publication of this book, Thalheim (Hermes CXL, pp. 152 ff.) has shown quite convincingly that the contention (p. 222) that the decision of a private arbitrator was not legally binding, unless given under oath, is not sustained by the proofs offered.", "prev": "If this explanation, which is the only one that accords fully with Greek legal procedure as we know it, is not right, it is idle to attempt to solve the puzzle.", "next": "Lipsius reiterates (p. 228) his previously expressed view (Ber. d.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.657, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262237:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262237", "s": "Since the publication of this book, Thalheim (Hermes CXL, pp. 152 ff.) has shown quite convincingly that the contention (p. 222) that the decision of a private arbitrator was not legally binding, unless given under oath, is not sustained by the proofs offered.", "prev": "If this explanation, which is the only one that accords fully with Greek legal procedure as we know it, is not right, it is idle to attempt to solve the puzzle.", "next": "Lipsius reiterates (p. 228) his previously expressed view (Ber. d.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.438, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262247:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262247", "s": "This task has been executed with great thoroughness, and, in the main, the conclusions drawn are convincing.", "prev": "The aim has been to \"search all the extant sources to which Augustine could have had access,\" and thus to deter- mine his probable authorities.", "next": "For his survey of Roman history in the early books Augustine is shown to have used Florus and Eutropius, as well as Sallust and Livy.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.28, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262249:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262249", "s": "The German civilians have a plausible reason for adopting a new system in expoimding the civil law, since their purpose has been (especially in their Pandekten) to explain, not the ancient Roman law of Justinian, but the modern Roman law in force in the German states.", "prev": "The ordinary method pursued in systematic treatises has been to depart from the order of Gains and Justinian, and to substitute an arrangement more or less in conformity to that adopted by the German writers.", "next": "But such a reason does not exist in the academic study of the Roman law in the English universities.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.415, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262342:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262342", "s": "The argument for the old theory of the verse has never, in fact, been stated in so convincing a way as Leo presents it in his monograph.", "prev": "Keller, Thurneysen, Lindsay, and Skutsch, when suddenly the banner of the quantitative cause is carried vigorously to the fore again.", "next": "The essen- tial features of his book lie in his method of approaching the subject, in the argument drawn from the history of Latin verse, in his discussion of the source from which Caesius Bassus drew, in his study of the diaeresis, in his adoption of several types of Saturnian verse, in his assumption of the use of rising and falling rhythm, and in the use which he makes of similar Greek verses.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.198, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262342:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262342", "s": "All these points go to show the quantitative nature of the extant Satur- nian verses, and will probably be convincing to most readers of Leo's work.", "prev": "The case is materially strengthened by the similar Greek verses which Leo draws from the CIG., and else- where, whose development was like that of the Saturnian (cf. pp. 71-79).", "next": "It is another matter to determine the characteristic features of the verses which have come down to us, and many will lay down this book feeling that great progress has been made toward that end, but that the last word on the matter has not yet been said.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.57, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262345:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262345", "s": "Still less convincing is M.", "prev": "And these were naturally city-men and city-customs.", "next": "Croiset's suggestion that Aristophanes was a country boy (pp. 14 ff .).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.612, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262346:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262346", "s": "The poet's liaison with Gnathaena gives the prin- cipal clue, which Wagner follows up with subtle and, for the most part, convincing reasoning.", "prev": "With these facts to begin with Wagner attempts in his first chap- ter to define more closely the chronology of the life of Diphilus, especially the date of his birth.", "next": "Plays in which this woman is mentioned along with Pythonice, who followed Harpalus to Babylon in 330, must be anterior to that date, and among these plays the Orestautocleides of Timocles must be placed as near as possible to 345, when the hero was already notorious (Aesch.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.2, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262347:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262347", "s": "On the basis of arguments which are certainly persuasive, if not in every detail convincing, Helbig maintains that in the early period the Italian kings and nobles employed war chariots similar to those shown on the familiar Mycenaean stelae and described in the Homeric poems; in three terra-cotta chariots (reproduced pp. 69, 70) found in graves he sees small models of such cars.", "prev": "One interesting suggestion, however, must be men- tioned.", "next": "As he suggests pp. 60 f ., it is highly desirable that the remains of weapons from early graves should be sys- tematically studied for the light they may throw on this and many other questions of early Italian warfare.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.904, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262348:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262348", "s": "Kunstprosa, pp. 94, 184 f., 190, and in the analyses passim. 484 Book Reviews But for the theory of the school, in the absence of extant rhetoricians of that persuasion, we are forced to fall back upon Cicero and his Roman successors as our only sources — unsatisfactory as they are — for the rules of rhythmical composition.", "prev": "Rhythmen der att.", "next": "Cicero's own method is summarized by Blass in the statement that he combined Asian practice with Attic theory.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.412, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262356:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262356", "s": "After the list of all the occurrences of the construc- tion, a summary presents the statistics for each book separately, from which Canter draws the conclusion that \"Livy employs the historical infinitive less frequently, though not quite uniformly less, passing from the earlier to the later books.\" This chronological explanation is hardly convincing in view of such striking variations as the three examples of book xxvi as compared with the thirty-four of book xxvii.", "prev": "The chapter devoted to the historical infinitive has been worked out with the greatest detail.", "next": "Would it not be better to seek in the character of the narrative some hint for the reason of the more or less frequent use of the construction?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.713, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262358:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262358", "s": "He has prepared a critical edition of a ninth- century commentary on Boethius' Opuscula sacra, and by careful and cogent reasoning ascribes it with every probability to Johannes Scotus himself.", "prev": "I, p. 429, of this journal, in welcoming the series.", "next": "Traube's preface points out the varied aspect of text trans- mission in the Middle Ages; the new light thrown on Boethius' and Scotus' relations to mediaeval thought; and the probable connection of Scotus with Otto III and Henry II, through Gerbert, Hincmar, and the learned circle at Reims — an illustration of the value of paleographical detail for literary history, since it is the insular handwri", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.763, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262359:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262359", "s": "He has prepared a critical edition of a ninth- century commentary on Boethius' Opuscula sacra, and by careful and cogent reasoning ascribes it with every probability to Johannes Scotus himself.", "prev": "I, p. 429, of this journal, in welcoming the series.", "next": "Traube's preface points out the varied aspect of text trans- mission in the Middle Ages; the new light thrown on Boethius' and Scotus' relations to mediaeval thought; and the probable connection of Scotus with Otto III and Henry II, through Gerbert, Hincmar, and the learned circle at Reims — an illustration of the value of paleographical detail for literary history, since it is the insular handwri", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.355, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262044:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262044", "s": "Although I am far from convinced of the correctness of the author's new interpretation (pp. 232 ff.) of the use of the medial in place of the Greek aspirates (e. g., aflpovpe; = 6<j>pves), which is the most marked peculiarity of Macedonian, and the one which has played the principal rdle in all recent discussions, yet it must be admitted that this diver- gence from all the recognized Greek dialects is not in itself sufficient to debar Macedonian from a place among them if the other evidence points in that direction.", "prev": "Macedonian was then a Greek dialect, and a survey of its characteristics (pp. 232 ff.) shows that it is to be regarded as a sister dialect of Thessalian (p. 253).", "next": "And on the whole I believe that Hoffmann's general conclusion is the one which best accords with the combined evidence, and in all probability is actually the correct one.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.621, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262045:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262045", "s": "He is stimulating and suggestive, though he is not always convincing.", "prev": "The views of such a veteran scholar as Breal are well worthy to be read by philologists, even when he leaves the field in which he speaks with the fullest authority.", "next": "Breal's main thesis is that the Homeric poems are true works of art, and not the products of the untaught genius of the people; made with the help of the art of writing, composed neither by a single author nor by a crowd, but by an organized group of poets who were charged with the celebration of religious festivals in Asia Minor, in an age of culture and art, and in the midst of a people devoted ", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.146, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262061:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262061", "s": "Mulder has advanced startling yet convincing theories of the manner and age of the composition of the Iliad.", "prev": "No one had advised Hector to abandon his country, so there is no occasion for Homer using this thrilling verse of some elegiac poet.", "next": "However one may approve of the argument, it seems impossible that the Greeks themselves should have assigned such authority and antiquity to the Iliad had it been founded on poems of the age of Tyrtaeus and Callinus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.316, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262061:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262061", "s": "Unless more convincing evidence can be shown, there is no need of a new hypothesis.", "prev": "But the instances adduced by Plenkers, it seems to me, rather prove than dis- prove Traube's views.", "next": "In any event, it is now possible to edit, with few chances of mistake, the original autograph of S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.751, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262062:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262062", "s": "Unless more convincing evidence can be shown, there is no need of a new hypothesis.", "prev": "But the instances adduced by Plenkers, it seems to me, rather prove than dis- prove Traube's views.", "next": "In any event, it is now possible to edit, with few chances of mistake, the original autograph of S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.236, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262064:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262064", "s": "And as to the first line, even if his reasoning were cogent, what of it?", "prev": "Why, of course !", "next": "Who disputes that Hephaestion's description is metrically correct ?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261757:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261757", "s": "Nevertheless the theory which he defends is plausible and may be true; and at any rate he shows a wide acquaintance with extant monuments and the relevant literature and strews his path with valuable detailed observations.", "prev": "Thus the vase-painting which he cites (p. 61) as the first of several repetitions of the central group on the cista appears to me to have no demonstrable connection with the composition in question.", "next": "F _ R Taebell", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.965, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261758:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261758", "s": "Nevertheless the theory which he defends is plausible and may be true; and at any rate he shows a wide acquaintance with extant monuments and the relevant literature and strews his path with valuable detailed observations.", "prev": "Thus the vase-painting which he cites (p. 61) as the first of several repetitions of the central group on the cista appears to me to have no demonstrable connection with the composition in question.", "next": "F _ R Taebell", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.94, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261802:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261802", "s": "I cannot 348 Book Reviews honestly say that any of them seems to me convincing, but the discus- sion of crucial passages which accompanies them is scholarly and suggestive.", "prev": "Renkema adds several new emenda- tions to the already large collection recorded by Giarratano.", "next": "Renkema naturally deals with many of the points raised by Langen's usually trustworthy commentary (1890), and his criticisms appear to me to raise real questions and to open up solutions which may be right.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.586, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261804:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261804", "s": "He has thus completed a necessary preliminary task, and obtained the convincing results that the book drew largely from the most 350 Book Reviews sensational histories of Alexander's achievements, and possesses a per- ceptible Ptolemaic flavor.", "prev": "The author has sought everywhere to establish real or reported facts as the points of departure for such incidents and episodes in the romance as are not mere errors of composition; and he holds the attitude and bias of Ptolemaic Alexandria mainly responsible for the shape these facts finally assumed.", "next": "It, accordingly, sought, or affected to seek, a reputation for veracity; but whether this was a genuine ambition, or a literary artifice, Ausfeld might have determined differently, had he lived to finish his work.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.576, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261805:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261805", "s": "The editor has possibly erred in not adopting what seems to have been a practice of Suetonius, in imitation of Varro, of writing Hrodus, Hrianus, hrinoce- ros, since he is evidently convinced that they were so written by the author.", "prev": "Thus incoho is everywhere read on the author- ity of Diomedes in place of inchoo, cena is everywhere substituted for caena, -tt- is read in the perfects rettuli, attuli, etc.", "next": "The courage which leads an editor to write Ptolemaeus seven times in the face of an unvarying MSS tradition in favor of Ptolomaeus, to write Sameramin on the authority of a Sardinian inscription and of the Memmianus in which the form has been corrected by the second hand, and to assume that Suetonius invariably wrote the genitive of 352 Book Reviews proper nouns in -ius with a single i, in the fac", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.643, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261808:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261808", "s": "So far as I Book Keviews 357 have been able to subject them to such an examination, they have in most cases carried conviction — as was of course to be expected.", "prev": "It is probable that the attention of topographers will be directed for some time to their careful examination.", "next": "In a work of this sort, where there are so many hundreds of references of the most diverse kinds, it seems to be impossible to avoid errors of citation and there are a number in this book.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.717, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261812:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261812", "s": "But like others of the \"New School,\" he assumes that the mere metrical analysis will be sufficient to convince his readers.", "prev": "Herkenrath's groupings are valid rhythmically, and that he has satisfied his own ear of the validity of them all.", "next": "It will not.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.549, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261434:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261434", "s": "One feels, after reading this, that almost the last word has now been said on the subject, and we still do not know whether the empress Plotina persuaded Trajan in his last moments to adopt her favorite, or failing in this, falsely asserted that the adoption took place.", "prev": "Chapter i, \"The New Emperor,\" deals mostly with the question of the adoption of Hadrian by Trajan.", "next": "Chapter ii covers the period from the accession to Hadrian's arrival in Eome.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.39, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261436:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261436", "s": "A large part of the introductory chapter is occupied with a lucid argument to prove that \"Homer was not an archaeologist,\" which Homeric students will find more convincing than Andrew Lang's more diffuse treatment of the same question in his recent volume, Homer and His Age.", "prev": "\"Some parts of them may have been two or even three cen- turies older than others,\" but as yet attempts to determine the limits of the old and the new have not been successful, mainly because the archaeological and philological tests point to embarrassingly inharmo- nious conclusions.", "next": "The poet sings of a time somewhat remote, but reflects the customs, ideas, and life of his own day.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.499, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261437:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261437", "s": "Moreover, convincing logic is enlivened by a fascinating literary style; these two features constitute the chief characteristics of the author's writing.", "prev": "Holmes's book, but even a cursory reading will show that a painstaking effort has been made to secure every scrap of available evidence, that the handling of this evidence is judicious, and that the conclusions based upon it are sound.", "next": "Part I includes also separate chapters on Caesar's first and second invasions and one on the results of these invasions, the history of Britain being sketched through the reign of Caligula.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.926, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261438:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261438", "s": "Moreover, convincing logic is enlivened by a fascinating literary style; these two features constitute the chief characteristics of the author's writing.", "prev": "Holmes's book, but even a cursory reading will show that a painstaking effort has been made to secure every scrap of available evidence, that the handling of this evidence is judicious, and that the conclusions based upon it are sound.", "next": "Part I includes also separate chapters on Caesar's first and second invasions and one on the results of these invasions, the history of Britain being sketched through the reign of Caligula.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.347, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261438:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261438", "s": "The conjecture of Lewin that the oppidum of Cassivellaunus was no other than London is interesting but it is not convincing because we cannot say absolutely that Londinium, though it is a Celtic name, existed at the time of Caesar's invasions.", "prev": "Albans.", "next": "The earliest mention of London is in the Annals of Tacitus (xiv. 33).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.671, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261438:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261438", "s": "While we must acknowledge that Hense uses great ingenuity in trying to show how the ancient poets made a virtue, sometimes by undra- matic and inartistic means, of the cruel necessity which the full mask imposed, we must say that he frequently fails to convince.", "prev": "In the Eumenides the priestess creeps out of the temple for a similar reason.", "next": "For he strives to show a connection between the use of the mask and many con- ventions of the stage which would never be thought of as related, con- ventions which are readily explainable on other grounds.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.867, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261439:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261439", "s": "While we must acknowledge that Hense uses great ingenuity in trying to show how the ancient poets made a virtue, sometimes by undra- matic and inartistic means, of the cruel necessity which the full mask imposed, we must say that he frequently fails to convince.", "prev": "In the Eumenides the priestess creeps out of the temple for a similar reason.", "next": "For he strives to show a connection between the use of the mask and many con- ventions of the stage which would never be thought of as related, con- ventions which are readily explainable on other grounds.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.414, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262433:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262433", "s": "He was a convinced and consistent Puritan.", "prev": "But those who know their fourth Christian century are aware that, in spite of his schw&rmerei for Athens, Julian was no Hellene, and that he was about as well qualified to revive the ethics and aesthetics of the Periclean Greeks as to achieve an Attic lucidity of thought or the charm of the Attic lit- erary manner.", "next": "Plato could write of the Beautiful with such passion that the Good, however explicitly set up as the highest educational ideal, pales a little by contrast.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.251, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262436:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262436", "s": "The division of Homer into strata in accordance with the divergence from the original number of nouns is a clever and interesting piece of linguistic dexterity, but will convince no one inclined to doubt.", "prev": "The author clearly presses his theories too far.", "next": "How- ever, as a study of language and the development in syntax the book is of unusual merit.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.965, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262446:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262446", "s": "The other arrangement ignores national lines and is (for the most part) founded on the chronological sequence of the Greek worthies, and Ziegler has made it seem plausible that this arrangement was derived from the first.", "prev": "In three pairs — Coriolanus-Alcibiades, Aemilius Paulus-Timoleon, and Ser- torius-Eumenes — the Komans precede.", "next": "Curiously enough, the extant family of MSS (X) which preserves this later edition contains only its first book, while the order of citations from Plutarch in Photius' Bibliotheca shows that he was acquainted with the second book — in fact, this two-book recension had probably been made only shortly before his time.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.599, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262447:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262447", "s": "Should not a complete and convincing account of Juvenal's originality start from a careful study of a number of passages, not necessarily a large number, in which the concrete facts of the social environment described by the poet are known from reliable sources, or the literary tradition ascertainable, or both the facts and the tradition avail- able ?", "prev": "The conclusions are very likely true so far as they go, but they refer rather exclusively to Juvenal's point of view, and to one or two phases of his composition.", "next": "From such passages conclusions may safely be drawn as to Juvenal's originality, and these conclusions transferred and applied with reasonable safety to other parts of the poet's work of which the sources are not attainable.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.742, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262447:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262447", "s": "To some extent the author employs this method, but by analyzing three satires in the sequence of verses, he necessarily treats in succession passages of very different content with respect to available sources; in most cases he may only describe, or make plausible sugges- tions ; the description and the suggestions would be more convincing if based on a preliminary study of those passages, doubtless few in num- ber, in which the material for a study of sources is, comparatively speak- ing, rich and reliable.", "prev": "If there are no such passages, the task is hardly worth attempting.", "next": "We are none the less grateful for a careful and sympathetic study of a few phases of the poet's art of composition, in the course of which the author offers many independent interpretations and continually suggests to the thoughtful reader opportunities for deeper investigation.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.842, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261833:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261833", "s": "In such cases the etymological analysis becomes largely a matter of conjecture, and the investigator must count not only on the reader's intelligence, but also — to a certain extent — on his willingness to be convinced.", "prev": "The difficulties of course are much greater in the case of names inherited from an extinct race or tribe of whose language we have hardly any other traces but these very names.", "next": "This being so we cannot, in my opinion, but congratulate ourselves that Fick has deemed it worth his while to concern himself with the problem of pre-Hellenic Greek names.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.392, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261833:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261833", "s": "As entirely convincing I would also regard Fick's attitude toward the much- ventilated question of the Pelasgians (see esp. pp. 97 and 143 f.).", "prev": "I would refer, e. g., to Fick's result, pp. 34 and 123 f., that very few Greek names (the Index, p. 167, gives 9 such names, three of them with a question mark) can with some certainty be claimed as Phoenician.", "next": "The Pelasgians with him have ceased to be a mere name or a kind of a specter.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.687, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261837:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261837", "s": "Does Herr Friedrich really think it just as convincing to determine the proper text of an author by his own cerebration working upon little evidence, as to determine it by the consideration of much, and immediately pertinent, evidence?", "prev": "For, according to the pronunciamento of Herr Friedrich, even the discovery of the lost Veronensis itself would probably be an event of no real importance, as all the readings of V are very possibly included in one or another of its extant descendants, or may be inferred from their readings.", "next": "It may further be remarked that Friedrich apparently professes to base his judgment of the extremely low value of R upon his own examination of that codex in Rome.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.457, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261838:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261838", "s": "The assertion of the editor's opinion that the apparent independence of Bland, is due solely to the accident that this part of the Satires is missing in A B and C, and that if they had contained the passage they would undoubtedly have shown the same reading, will convince no one.", "prev": "Not even Vollmer himself follows this classification to its logical conclusions, for while he does not concede any independent value to Bland., he adopts in Serin. 1. 6. 126 the reading campum lusumque trigonem for which it is the sole authority.", "next": "Professor Vollmer does not claim finality for his work.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.677, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261838:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261838", "s": "The seventh and ninth books, with the last ten chapters of the eighth, which had been called in question by Aubert and Wimmer, are also rejected, upon convincing grounds.", "prev": "Dittmeyer agrees with previous scholars in regarding the tenth book as spurious.", "next": "The text is a painstaking and, on the whole, a conservative one, though occasionally an ill-considered departure from the manuscript readings is found, as for instance the emendation of avdpanros to yiVvos, A 1, 488 a 27, which seems to rest upon a misconception of the force of da\" which here", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.93, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261840:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261840", "s": "Not a few convincing emendations are found, as, for example, SxTKapiBiov A 1, 487 6 5 for oujttiSw of the best manuscripts.", "prev": "In the present work they are repeatedly distinguished from, and contrasted with, Terpd- no8a, \"four-footed animals.\" Lack of continuity with the main thread of the narrative seems hardly adequate ground for rejecting such passages as B 15, 506 a 26 to 31 and B 17, 508 b 4 to 8, in a treatise which is, as Dittmeyer himself points out, Preface xxv, preliminary notes for a finished work.", "next": "Bekker with some manuscript authority had read i/nrl&w.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.311, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261847:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261847", "s": "In many cases Beck's arguments are not convincing, but in general his position is well taken, that there is so much uncertainty about a majority of the \"errors\" that they cannot safely be used as a criterion in the construction of a stemma.", "prev": "Even the reading fugio rabiosi tem- pora signi (Serm. i. 6. 126) finds in him a champion.", "next": "Moreover, he is right in his assertion that there is no good reason for assuming that the Horatian tradition was at a standstill for nearly two hundred years.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.872, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261848:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261848", "s": "In many cases Beck's arguments are not convincing, but in general his position is well taken, that there is so much uncertainty about a majority of the \"errors\" that they cannot safely be used as a criterion in the construction of a stemma.", "prev": "Even the reading fugio rabiosi tem- pora signi (Serm. i. 6. 126) finds in him a champion.", "next": "Moreover, he is right in his assertion that there is no good reason for assuming that the Horatian tradition was at a standstill for nearly two hundred years.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.783, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262408:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262408", "s": "The evidence for this interpretation Miss Millerd reviews somewhat more fully than previous writers; nothing very material, however, is added to Burnet's convincing argument, except a pertinent citation from Theophrastus, De sens. 20.", "prev": "Periods (1) and (3) are, for opposite reasons, \"acosmic;\" our world belongs to period (4).", "next": "On the other hand, the author repeats an error of Burnet's in assigning the \" whole-natured forms\" of Fr. 62 to a different period from that of the hybrid monsters of Fr. 61.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.575, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262379:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262379", "s": "The argument is enforced usually by cogent examples, but a more elaborate treatment is needed to insure conviction.", "prev": "This tradition, however, is blurred: in the larger part of the first two books the MSS show the effects of \" contamination.\" The conclusion is that the two families are equally serviceable; the z family is less trustworthy; the x family represents the \"traditional\" text : if the readings of the two families are intrinsically equivalent, the x family is to be preferred.", "next": "Remembering the value of so-called inferior MSS revealed by the papyri, we cannot feel that in such a complicated situation as the editor discov- ers his text should be determined very largely by a theory of MSS tradi- tion.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.498, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261897:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261897", "s": "The brilliant and ingenious combinations from which infor- mation as to the details of the life of Lucilius is derived by all these scholars more frequently arouse our admiration than convince us.", "prev": "Miiller, Marx, and Cichorius.", "next": "Cichorius rightly emphasizes the value of Lucilius as an historical source, since he furnishes the only contemporary document, with the exception of a few fragments of the orators, for the period from the middle of the Numantine war until near the close of the struggle with the Cimbri and Teutones, and we cannot but wish that the interpretation of the fragments were less doubtful.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.774, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261898:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261898", "s": "The brilliant and ingenious combinations from which infor- mation as to the details of the life of Lucilius is derived by all these scholars more frequently arouse our admiration than convince us.", "prev": "Miiller, Marx, and Cichorius.", "next": "Cichorius rightly emphasizes the value of Lucilius as an historical source, since he furnishes the only contemporary document, with the exception of a few fragments of the orators, for the period from the middle of the Numantine war until near the close of the struggle with the Cimbri and Teutones, and we cannot but wish that the interpretation of the fragments were less doubtful.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.382, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261898:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261898", "s": "Both agree in making him the posses- 110 Book Reviews sor of estates in Sicily, but on evidence which is not very convincing.", "prev": "Cichorius also disagrees with Marx in regarding Lucilius as a Roman citizen and a member of the equestrian order.", "next": "Perhaps the least successful effort of Cichorius is his attempt to show that Lucilius made a journey to Greece and there met Clitomachus, who dedicated a book to him.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.61, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261899:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261899", "s": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 110 Book Reviews sor of estates in Sicily, but on evidence which is not very convincing.", "prev": "JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico.", "next": "Perhaps the least successful effort of Cichorius is his attempt to show that Lucilius made a journey to Greece and there met Clitomachus, who dedicated a book to him.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.308, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261902:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261902", "s": "On the other hand, Axtell grants that certain abstract deities were probably derived from epithets, e. g., Iuventas and Libertas ; but the derivation of Fides from an epithet of Jupiter he is inclined to doubt, objecting that the theory of such origin depends wholly on the fact that the three chief flamines took part an- nually in her worship and on the proximity of her temple to that of Jupiter ; but these he does not regard as cogent reasons for the view of Wissowa and his school.", "prev": "This view is supported by the practice of other Italian peoples, for the Sabines worshiped Salus, at the Dm- brian town of Ocriculum there was a cult of Valentia, and the Latins themselves worshiped Fors Fortuna.", "next": "His protest against the excessive use of simi- larity in dates of festivals and of temple foundations to establish rela- tionships between divinities is also timely and well made.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.732, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261905:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261905", "s": "The array of evidence marshaled in support of the con- tention that the term regnum as applied to Noricum was a popular sur- vival of former usage and carried with it no especial political significance, is convincing.", "prev": "This is not to say that Miss Peaks has given us merely a \"useful compilation.\" In more than one instance she has modified prevailing views although these contributions are mostly relegated to the footnotes.", "next": "Cf. p. 165, n. 9.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.729, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261906:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261906", "s": "The array of evidence marshaled in support of the con- tention that the term regnum as applied to Noricum was a popular sur- vival of former usage and carried with it no especial political significance, is convincing.", "prev": "This is not to say that Miss Peaks has given us merely a \"useful compilation.\" In more than one instance she has modified prevailing views although these contributions are mostly relegated to the footnotes.", "next": "Cf. p. 165, n. 9.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.325, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261908:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261908", "s": "It is by no means a difficult task for an ingenious critic to propose several conjectures for a corrupt passage, all of which will appear plausible.", "prev": "Nevertheless, his emendations are for the most part supported by sound argument; all are possible; but some to say the least are improbable.", "next": "Two doubtful emendations that we hesitate to accept have already been pointed out by Dr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.905, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261908:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261908", "s": "Of the others, some of which are convincing, I cite the following: €Kda-TO<r' (13), 6£<r<l>dT0K (27), (^pccas weSt\" 05rXdKTv<^', &i (83), addition of 8e Tot' (115), of /9aXw (123), lao- (128), Bi (129), iKwvKd^ov (IM), S,8' Irepo^povt (155), 8eiiaT£ (160), Ti Kviiari (193), /uydSa (225), KaKKcyov/ifva (317), 7rp6ki<l>'", "prev": "(812).", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.953, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261909:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261909", "s": "It is by no means a difficult task for an ingenious critic to propose several conjectures for a corrupt passage, all of which will appear plausible.", "prev": "Nevertheless, his emendations are for the most part supported by sound argument; all are possible; but some to say the least are improbable.", "next": "Two doubtful emendations that we hesitate to accept have already been pointed out by Dr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.331, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261909:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261909", "s": "Of the others, some of which are convincing, I cite the following: IkootW (13), 0«r<£aTo« (27), Operas ireSC SirkoKTvcp' , &s (83), addition of 8e rot (115), of 0aXw (123), p.^ (128), U (129), iKwvK<i£ov (134), S>8' Irepo^povt (155), 8ei£aT£ (160), ti Kvpari (193), /xtydSa (225), KaKKcyov/itva (317), irpo\\t^>' Book Reviews 121 (332), (Tta-qixATurrai (452), kXvo) rmv (553), 8a (554), op.pa (564), reXtux (751), apTi<j>pu)v w (763), Ta8e (836), Ta8' (886), oirou o-<pi (994), <pS> (1048).", "prev": "Verrall in the Classical Review (XXII. 247) — Trap, «'k«(692) and <r<irrr)pia(812).", "next": "The notes are full and instructive.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.364, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262211:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262211", "s": "To one who is convinced that \"the proofs are just as good that Mexican is Aryan as they are that English is Aryan\" the reason can only be that \"radically new ideas make way slowly\" and that \"incredulous silence or caviling opposition is what great discoveries have invariably encountered.\" A colleague of the reviewer's is quoted to the effect that philologists should either accept the work or try to refute it, and the author rules out the excuse of \"too busy\" by stating that \"any comparative philologist may decide in an hour's time as to the value of the work, and it is not neces- sary to under", "prev": "In the introduction the author explains why his discovery, already made known in his previous publications, that \"Mexican is an Aryan language closely akin to Sanskrit and Avestan but more primitive than either, in fact Aryan of the proethnic period,\" has not received appropri- ate recognition among scholars or in the daily press.", "next": "One is disappointed at the small percentage of really striking coincidences, such as might rank with the famous equations of Lycian lada 'woman' with English lady, or Mexican teotl 'god' with Greek 0eo's (our author prefers to connect teotl with Latin dews, etc.).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.497, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262214:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262214", "s": "Schuster's argu- ment on the requirements of fr. 80 is convincing; if we do not accept his conjecture koX Karaxpeio/xau, I would suggest «at xcipaSp-eva.", "prev": "Such is the logic of the context, and such the obvious implication of the passages cited in illustration by Professor Diels.", "next": "In fr. 82 (from Plato Hippias Maj. 289 A) Burnet and Diels follow Bekker in reading avOp<biro)v yera for oEAAa) yera of the MSS.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.688, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262219:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262219", "s": "One of his identifications is not sufficiently convincing, namely that K is surely the Maffei liber of Statius.", "prev": "The dissertation, besides simplifying the work of future editors of Catullus by showing that the critical apparatus of Statius has now no value for the constitution of the text, is an interesting and valuable con- tribution to our estimate of the classical scholarship of the Eenaissance.", "next": "A careful scrutiny of the numerous citations from the Maffei liber and of the readings of R makes it clear that Maffei liber was either R or a lost descendant of R, but Dr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.584, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262172:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262172", "s": "Birt is often ingenious and occasionally convincing, but in general we feel that the editor's hand is rather heavy for poems that require the delicate touch of the master-critic.", "prev": "We admit that we are as easily deceived as Varius or Tucca. 382 Book Reviews The interpretation of the poems is as difficult as it is tempting.", "next": "Farmers are not lazy in Koman literature; so we must call them ignari, not ignavi (Priapea i. 4); but if Priapus is afraid they may burn him up instead of looking elsewhere for firewood, there seems to be good reason why he should call them lazy rather than ignorant.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.715, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262172:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262172", "s": "Seldom do Birt's changes in the text seem plausible; namque quatenus (ii. 2) is boldly made into amputatus et, although the correlation between quatenus and ita (vs. 5) seems natural and essential.", "prev": "But we admit that the generally accepted Delia is a poor emendation, for it offers no reasonable explanation of the corruption.", "next": "Is this a case of quatenus = quomodo, a usage of late Latin, instead of a causal quatenus as Buecheler thinks?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.787, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262173:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262173", "s": "Birt is often ingenious and occasionally convincing, but in general we feel that the editor's hand is rather heavy for poems that require the delicate touch of the master-critic.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 382 Book Reviews The interpretation of the poems is as difficult as it is tempting.", "next": "Farmers are not lazy in Koman literature; so we must call them ignari, not ignavi (Priapea i. 4); but if Priapus is afraid they may burn him up instead of looking elsewhere for firewood, there seems to be good reason why he should call them lazy rather than ignorant.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.134, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262173:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262173", "s": "Seldom do Birt's changes in the text seem plausible; namque quatenus (ii. 2) is boldly made into amputatus et, although the correlation between quatenus and ita (vs. 5) seems natural and essential.", "prev": "But we admit that the generally accepted Delia is a poor emendation, for it offers no reasonable explanation of the corruption.", "next": "Is this a case of quatenus = quomodo, a usage of late Latin, instead of a causal quatenus as Buecheler thinks?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.206, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262178:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262178", "s": "To do this with even the appear- ance of plausibility demands considerable scholarship and appalling labor.", "prev": "All of these he removes by emendation.", "next": "But in view of the enormous antecedent improbability we must be permitted to wish that all this toil had been devoted to a better cause.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.89, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262178:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262178", "s": "Though some of these emendations are ingenious, few, if any, carry conviction.", "prev": "This plainly does not justify the wholesale emenda- tion attempted here.", "next": "There is space for only two or three speci- mens of Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.938, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262179:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262179", "s": "To do this with even the appear- ance of plausibility demands considerable scholarship and appalling labor.", "prev": "All of these he removes by emendation.", "next": "But in view of the enormous antecedent improbability we must be permitted to wish that all this toil had been devoted to a better cause.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.644, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262179:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262179", "s": "Though some of these emendations are ingenious, few, if any, carry conviction.", "prev": "This plainly does not justify the wholesale emenda- tion attempted here.", "next": "There is space for only two or three speci- mens of Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.799, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262183:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262183", "s": "The book concludes with an ingenious argument to the effect that the original was in the form of a dialogue, and a plausible outline is suggested.", "prev": "It appears that the author has been duly conservative in what he attributes to Cicero, and he has succeeded in giving them a truly Ciceronian form.", "next": "This last does not pass in our judgment the bounds of mere conjecture.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.777, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262184:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262184", "s": "The book concludes with an ingenious argument to the effect that the original was in the form of a dialogue, and a plausible outline is suggested.", "prev": "It appears that the author has been duly conservative in what he attributes to Cicero, and he has succeeded in giving them a truly Ciceronian form.", "next": "This last does not pass in our judgment the bounds of mere conjecture.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.365, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262184:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262184", "s": "In his discussion of the reasons for the failure of the final infinitive to develop further, Ogden uses this cogent sentence (p. 44): lam si quaeritur quare usus infinitivi finalis vel consecutivi apud Hom- erum non ultra processerit, duae causae praecipue sunt adferendae; una quod aliae constructiones infinitivi iam adoleverant, altera, quod nee forma causalis nee partieula auxiliaris ei comitabantur quibus notio finis vel con- secutionis plane indicaretur.", "prev": "There are in Homer 387 examples of an infinitive of purpose; ;^Weber found 459 examples of final clauses with final particles.", "next": "Si enim conformatio qualis est i$i\\ v tovto -n-vdij- 8ai solebat significare : ' dixi me hoc exquisisse' molestum fuisset si potuisset significare: ' hoc dixi ut exquirem.' Qua ex re factum est ut finitivi huius- modi nisi in conformationibus usitatis ac simplicibus facile usurpari non Since this thesis itself is a summary, it is difficult to summarize.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262185:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262185", "s": "In his discussion of the reasons for the failure of the final infinitive to develop further, Ogden uses this cogent sentence (p. 44): lam si quaeritur quare usus infinitivi flnalis vel consecutivi apud Hom- erum non ultra processerit, duae causae praecipue sunt adferendae; una quod aliae constructiones infinitivi iam adoleverant, altera, quod nee forma causalis nee particula auxiliaris ei comitabantur quibus notio finis vel con- secutionis plane indicaretur.", "prev": "There are in Homer 387 examples of an infinitive of purpose; ;^Weber found 459 examples of final clauses with final particles.", "next": "Si enim conformatio qualis est ^(pv\" tovto rvdij- Bai. solebat significare : ' dixi me hoc exquisisse' molestum fuisset si potuisset signiflcare: ' hoc dixi ut exquirem.' Qua ex re factum est ut finitivi huius- modi nisi in conformationibua usitatis ac simplicibus facile usurpari non Since this thesis itself is a summary, it is difficult to summarize.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.3, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261271:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261271", "s": "(3) Thracians \"in Thessaly, Phokis, and Attica (Eleusis).\" This classification seems in itself plausible enough and is to a cer- tain extent substantiated by outside evidence.", "prev": "(2) the Illyrians, on both sides of the Adriatic Sea and, according to Fick, traceable to scattered regions in Greece proper;", "next": "If accordingly, however, we expect to find a clear-cut distinction in the pre-Hellenic nomenclature between Indo-European and Hittite names, we probably shall be disap- pointed.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.239, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261271:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261271", "s": "Nor can I convince myself that the question is settled in favor of the Indo-European by the Messapian inscriptions.", "prev": "Dan. 29-32) there are very few, if any, that seem to contain Indo-European elements.", "next": "Fick, it seems to me, has to a certain extent obviated his own dis- tinction between Hittites and Danubians by admitting (V.O. 142) the possibility of a mixture between (Hittite) Lelegans and (Indo-Eur.) Illyrians, and by assuming (Hatt. u.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.46, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261272:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261272", "s": "Without strain- ing the evidence, or abandoning himself to fantastic conjectures, Pro- fessor Ritter contrives to bring the few known facts of Plato's life into plausible relation with the political and literary history of his time in the most illuminating fashion.", "prev": "The account of Plato's life and character, occupying 193 pages, is the best and most readable with which I am acquainted.", "next": "Very attractive, too, is the warm, yet sober and restrained, enthusiasm for the personality of Plato that per- vades the whole.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.149, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261273:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261273", "s": "Professor Schroeder's instinctive feeling of the true rhythm may convince himself.", "prev": "Now, much as it is needed, I do not know of the existence of any considerable study of this kind for Greek.", "next": "But to convince others he must show that where he affirms ascending choriambic and bacchic movement in logaoedics or epitrites there is something in the word endings, the Book Reviews 517 plirasal units, and the relation of unimportant to important syllables that tends to confirm his reading.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.546, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261273:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261273", "s": "But to convince others he must show that where he affirms ascending choriambic and bacchic movement in logaoedics or epitrites there is something in the word endings, the Book Reviews 517 plirasal units, and the relation of unimportant to important syllables that tends to confirm his reading.", "prev": "Professor Schroeder's instinctive feeling of the true rhythm may convince himself.", "next": "Such evidence may be inadequate and unsatisfactory.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.553, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261273:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261273", "s": "It is only this systematic division that yields the regular ascending iambic movement ~ - - - of the second half, and that lends any plausibility to the conjecture \" strophae structuram ex Aeolica Anacreontis stropha yowoviMi <r' iXa<l>r)- jSdXe imitatione dixeris esse expressam.\" Unless we also divide system- atically, artificially, and emphatically, yovvov/iai a', e — Xa^jj/SoXe ^av6r] waX Ai- — os, aypiiav there is for the natural ear little resemblance between the two strophes.", "prev": "But I see nothing to necessitate the sharp rhythmic bisection of the lines, which, if it means anything, involves an improbable pause in o — re and ijjtte — rtpov.", "next": "In Birds 929, the division Tea K£ — ifxiXa deXwi seems very arbitrary, as does in 1374 the treatment of -irov nrepvyca — crt Kov<j>(Ui as ch. ba.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.865, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261300:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261300", "s": "Capps's efforts to disentangle the plots ; his ingenuity is ever of the better sort : it starts from a basis of fact ; he discriminates between plausible conjecture and sound con- viction.", "prev": "Space does not permit a discussion of Mr.", "next": "The deviations from the papyrus, when it is legible, are fewer than in KQrte's text.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.348, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261300:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261300", "s": "White's article makes unnecessary the space devoted to this theme ; if such material were condensed, Menander's style — his freedom in the collocation of words, his peculiar sentence structure — and special phases of Hellenistic usage might receive more convincing treatment.", "prev": "Mr.", "next": "In H. 20 the interpretation of ri<Tvxjj is more easily understood by a comparison of Theocr. xiv, 27 (cf . 10) and other Greek examples than by the quota- tion of the Latin phrase in the note.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.646, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261307:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261307", "s": "Plato on the other hand is thinking of the art of persuasion, and with a char- acteristic recurrence to etymology defines rhetoric as a guidance of the soul by discourses.", "prev": "So in Evag. 10 the point is merely that poetry possesses in rhythm and other ornaments means of entertaining and moving the feelings which prose lacks.", "next": "This appears in the later statement that some souls are easily persuaded, that is, led, by one type of argument, and others by another.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.889, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261307:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261307", "s": "This appears in the later statement that some souls are easily persuaded, that is, led, by one type of argument, and others by another.", "prev": "Plato on the other hand is thinking of the art of persuasion, and with a char- acteristic recurrence to etymology defines rhetoric as a guidance of the soul by discourses.", "next": "There is no real connection between the Isocratean and the Platonic passages, and Dr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.912, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261933:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261933", "s": "Instead of these things he gives a generalized yet vividly concrete and picturesque description by the methods of Renan of how the thing might have happened, thus plausibly leading us to his conclusion that it did in fact so happen.", "prev": "He has actually accomplished the feat of writing nearly three hundred pages on the Homeric problem with little or no mention of Wolf, Lachmann, and the Villoison scholia.", "next": "He describes after Wilamowitz and on the analogy of the Germanic invasions of the Roman empire the weltering chaos in which the Mycenaean civilization broke up, and out of which emerged dimly discerned in the dark ages the Greece that we know — the Greece of the iroXts.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.841, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261934:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261934", "s": "Instead of these things he gives a generalized yet vividly concrete and picturesque description by the methods of Renan of how the thing might have happened, thus plausibly leading us to his conclusion that it did in fact so happen.", "prev": "He has actually accomplished the feat of writing nearly three hundred pages on the Homeric problem with little or no mention of Wolf, Lachmann, and the Villoison scholia.", "next": "He describes after Wilamowitz and on the analogy of the Germanic invasions of the Roman empire the weltering chaos in which the Mycenaean civilization broke up, and out of which emerged dimly discerned in the dark ages the Greece that we know — the Greece of the iroXts.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.247, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261939:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261939", "s": "I give a few specimens: Lucullus 44, convincitur (coniungitur, MSS) ; 113, hi minores (mihi or mi minores, MSS); 124, merus numerus (numerus, Bentley; mens, MSS), Timaeus 8, fit (sit, MSS).", "prev": "The editor has incorporated in the text a score or more of his own emenda- tions.", "next": "When the text differs from the best MSS and often when it differs from the editions cited, the reading adopted is supported by references to articles by modern scholars or by cross-references to Cicero's other works.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.762, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261940:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261940", "s": "I give a few specimens: Lucullus 44, convincitur (coniungitur, MSS) ; 113, hi minores (mihi or mi minores, MSS); 124, merus numerus (numerus, Bentley; mens, MSS), Timaeus 8, fit (sit, MSS).", "prev": "The editor has incorporated in the text a score or more of his own emenda- tions.", "next": "When the text differs from the best MSS and often when it differs from the editions cited, the reading adopted is supported by references to articles by modern scholars or by cross-references to Cicero's other works.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.375, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261943:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261943", "s": "The whole makes a very significant group of texts, and Wilcken's interpretation of them is striking and suggestive, if not in all points convincing.", "prev": "Wilcken holds, as formerly, that these so-called Acts of Martyrdom represent a novel type of Alexandrian literature, based upon official sources, but worked up for partisan purposes.", "next": "Edgar J.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.676, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261948:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261948", "s": "The combination by which Ciaceri reconstructs the features of the festival of \"ApTCfus ayyeXAos is ingenious and convincing.", "prev": "The relation between the $toydfua and the sacrum anniversarium Cereris seems reasonably sure.", "next": "On the other hand, chaps, iv and v, while valuable as containing convenient narrative sum- maries of the dispersion of the worship of the minor divinities and the heroes, do not give such clear evidence of independence and conservatism.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.179, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262324:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262324", "s": "Merguet treats all these works except Priapea, Dirae, and Lydia, but the omission of the first two is most untimely, as they have recently been claimed for Virgil with no little plausibility; the value of the Lexikon for investigations of the genuineness of the minor poems is thus distinctly diminished.", "prev": "Besides the acknowledged works of Virgil, Wetmore includes those poems of the Appendix Vergiliana which can by any chance be genuine, namely Culex, Oris, Copa, Moretum, CatalepUm (including Priapea), Dirae and Lydia; the line is drawn just at the right place.", "next": "The text chosen by both scholars is that of Ribbeck's editio minor (1895), but while Merguet refers, in a rather general way, only to variants in other editions, Wetmore records minutely and skilfully every important deviation in the MSS as well as the editions, and indicates by a dagger the presence of an unimportant variant; the user of the Index can feel sure, as he cannot from the citations in", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.341, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262327:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262327", "s": "Hist. vi. 579, 9) the most plausible one that has yet been suggested.", "prev": "The new location of the tomb of Themistocles on the left as one ap- proaches the entrance to the Piraeus harbor is in every respect (save possibly the application of Aristotle An.", "next": "The theory is not new.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.742, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262328:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262328", "s": "Hist. vi. 579, 9) the most plausible one that has yet been suggested.", "prev": "The new location of the tomb of Themistocles on the left as one ap- proaches the entrance to the Piraeus harbor is in every respect (save possibly the application of Aristotle An.", "next": "The theory is not new.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.352, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262328:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262328", "s": "Perhaps, however, it is worth while to call attention to the paragraph on the third attributive position (p. 63), where three out of a list of eleven examples have been very plausibly emended away (xxi. 8; xxv. 27; xxix. 19).", "prev": "In the matter of critical readings, he is in the main very careful.", "next": "On p. 54 one misses a citation of the Homeric original of to Kprjyvov (xx. 19; cf.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.863, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261616:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261616", "s": "A writer on the poetry of Lincoln in the North American Review for February, 1911, prints the chief speeches of Lincoln in plausible blank verse, and a writer in the Classical Review for June, 1911, p. 104, shows that it is unsafe to argue from verse tags in Livy to a poetical source, because the verse tags are all over the shop, even where Livy is following Polybius.", "prev": "All prose consists of longs and shorts which a very little ingenuity suffices to reduce to something that may be called meter.", "next": "But to waive this point, much good Greek, Latin, French, and English prose is really rhythmical, and admits of approximate metrical schematiza- tion with only a moderate percentage of allowance for the taste, caprice, or personal equation of the reader.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.379, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261619:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261619", "s": "But, however we may abhor statistics, some figures are necessary to convince us of the norm; a single play of Plautus would", "prev": "The implication is that the examples of various sorts discussed in the abstract are not real, but only apparent, violations of the norm.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.991, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261620:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261620", "s": "But, however we may abhor statistics, some figures are necessary to convince us of the norm; a single play of Plautus would Book Reviews 503 furnish, temporarily, sufficient and suggestive evidence; we cannot easily grant that the examples are merely apparent exceptions until we know the proportion in which they stand to the total.", "prev": "The imphcation is that the examples of various sorts discussed in the abstract are not real, but only apparent, violations of the norm.", "next": "Nor is the writer fortunate in his choice of the inseparability of res divina, luppiter supremus, as evidence to support the generalization; formulas, especially ritualistic formulas, will be the last to yield to separation; one might as well quote iusiurandum as luppiter supremus; yet precisely this type of groups we should be glad to see the writer enlarge from Plautus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.384, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261620:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261620", "s": "Keep's examples to find that in the different types of iambic and trochaic verse the adjectives before the caesura or diaeresis fall within a very limited number of metrical types; a study of these metrical types, molossic words, bacchiac words, etc., in a single play might lead to convincing conclusions as to the dominant factor in such separation.", "prev": "on is rightly called (p. 154) to cases in which adjective and noun appear respectively before the principal caesura or diaeresis, and at the end of the verse; this feature is very general in many varieties of classical verse; now the very fact that the caesura and the end of the verse appear in this description should suggest metrical conditions as dominant factors, and one has only to look up Mr.", "next": "In other words, fully as he knows the metrical pecul- iarities of the end of the verse, the author does not discover for himself the peculiarities that mark the end of the shorter metrical phrase.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.569, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261620:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261620", "s": "On the top of p. 163 the inference with regard to bonus is not convincing until we know how often the adjective stands at the beginning of the verse in Plautus, quite apart from the ques- tion of emphasis.", "prev": "The generalization on the top of p. 162 is important and warrants more careful account of the exceptions.", "next": "In the list that follows, the adjectives, except verus, seem to belong to special categories (size and quantity) that set them apart; 504 Book Reviews in this same class would fall the cases of omnis on p. 164.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.69, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261621:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261621", "s": "Scholars have reason to be grateful to the late Albrecht Dieterich for persuading Domaszewski to gather into a volume his most important articles on Roman religion.", "prev": "M. 6.", "next": "Hitherto these have been accessible only to such as were near the largest libraries, for they originally appeared in widely scattered publications.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.864, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261622:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261622", "s": "Scholars have reason to be grateful to the late Albrecht Dieterich for persuading Domaszewski to gather into a volume his most important articles on Roman rehgion.", "prev": "M. 6.", "next": "Hitherto these have been accessible only to such as were near the largest libraries, for they originally appeared in widely scattered publications.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.239, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261624:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261624", "s": "This position he supports with proofs which seem to the reviewer at least convincing.", "prev": "The word yvwo-ts he holds means \"direct vision of God,\" that secret knowledge which can be obtained only through direct revelation and personal relation to divinity.", "next": "He further discusses at length certain of Paul's words and phrases, the most important of which may be mentioned here.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.569, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261522:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261522", "s": "Martin argues plausibly that the increase occurred under", "prev": "M.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.994, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261523:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261523", "s": "Martin argues plausibly that the increase occurred under Book Reviews 97 Augustus, not, as has been believed, between 68 and 71-72 a.d.", "prev": "M.", "next": "The epistrategoi were purely civil officials — equestrian procurators in fact — the military power being once more concentrated in Alexandria, where the prefect resided.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.573, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261526:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261526", "s": "Minor imperfections could not obscure for him the great merits of Livy (p. 16), nor could the mere paraphernalia of criticism or display of erudition convince him of the value of \"reconstructing\" plays from the fragments (p. 33) or of marking \"hidden\" quantities (p. 61).", "prev": "A thorough scholar himself, he had what so few specialists have, a saving sense of proportion.", "next": "This fundamental sanity, again, is at the bottom of his satire on bio- graphical writing in his \"Real Persius\" (pp. 62 ff.) and is conspicuous in his notes on Persius and Lysias.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.809, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261526:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261526", "s": "The least convincing is \" Quintilian's Quotations from Horace.\" Here Morgan has undoubtedly overestimated the value of these quotations as a source for the text of Horace (cf.", "prev": "In this he has conclusively proved that the date of this oration cannot be earlier than 66 — not 76 as Landgraf thought.", "next": "Cole Classical Review XX, 47).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.937, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261534:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261534", "s": "Kpvirra£a>) © 272, io-aencero (v. wra£<i>) SI 607. elm 6 571 is rather attractive, but is not absolutely necessary; nor is Bekker's rjpa>o>v Aavaw 6 578 convincing.", "prev": "Kpvrrrao-iK (v.", "next": "In X 371 where Sitzler reads ol ri rot avriS, there is no need of correction, since 01 toi ap ' avr<3 . . . . ap ' hrovro is merely a com- bination of two familiar constructions, e.g., o 541 and a 331.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.826, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261535:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261535", "s": "Kpvirra£a>) © 272, io-aencero (v. wra£<i>) SI 607. elm 6 571 is rather attractive, but is not absolutely necessary; nor is Bekker's rjpa>o>v Aavaw 6 578 convincing.", "prev": "Kpvrrrao-iK (v.", "next": "In X 371 where Sitzler reads ol ri rot avriS, there is no need of correction, since 01 toi ap ' avr<3 . . . . ap ' hrovro is merely a com- bination of two familiar constructions, e.g., o 541 and a 331.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.417, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261542:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261542", "s": "I of the Introduction (pp. 1-20) the editor discusses the author- ship of the sixth book, lucidly and convincingly refuting the arguments of those who would assign it to the Eudemian Ethics, and adducing evidence in support of his view that Aristotle was indeed its author.", "prev": "In sec.", "next": "The positive argument is not so strong as the negative, but is well calculated in form and temper to confirm the natural presumption in favor of the authenticity of the book.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.812, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261543:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261543", "s": "I of the Introduction (pp. 1-20) the editor discusses the author- ship of the sixth book, lucidly and convincingly refuting the arguments of those who would assign it to the Eudemian Ethics, and adducing evidence in support of his view that Aristotle was indeed its author.", "prev": "In sec.", "next": "The positive argument is not so strong as the negative, but is well calculated in form and temper to confirm the natural presumption in favor of the authenticity of the book.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.403, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261550:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261550", "s": "The \"scripsi's\" are compara- tively few, very few considering the state of the text, and usually they are convincing.", "prev": "Many of the readings of former editions are adopted, sometimes against the concurrent reading of all the manuscripts.", "next": "The lacunae are still numerous.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.627, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261554:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261554", "s": "The chief new material is a collection from Theocritus of passages bearing on the constellations which the writer thinks reveal a sympathy with the practical standpoint of Aratus, but the imposing list of authors of works called Phaenomena given in an anonymous life of Aratus (among them several Hellenistic writers, including Alexander the Aetolian, also a contemporary and, perhaps, friend of Theocritus) does not make such material particularly convincing.", "prev": "Professor Murray may properly suggest that Wilamowitz' positive contention that Aratus is an obscure Coan friend of Theocritus is far from inevitable, but he has hardly succeeded in re-establishing the old view.", "next": "The argument from probability is legitimate and alluring, but the chronological issues from the identification of Aratus with the poet are too important to be based upon such a foundation.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.739, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261964:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261964", "s": "At first sight it would seem highly improbable that a person should refuse to accept specific performance from any source, but in the light of the custom of demanding damages for all wrongs it is more plausible.", "prev": "Hephaestus' question, ir5s av iym o-e S«u/u; shows that he contemplated the early form of suretyship but he finally agreed to accept specific performance by Poseidon in case of Ares' default.", "next": "A wronged person with a hostage in his hands would not be satisfied with mere performance when he had it in his power to exact substantial damages by disposing of the person of the surety.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.425, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262103:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262103", "s": "This diatribe is prompted by Miss Harrison's learned, interesting, and persuasive book.", "prev": "The collecting of interesting material appears somehow or other to blunt the logical faculties.", "next": "The work owes its origin, as Miss Harrison herself tells 359 360 Book Reviews us, chiefly to the conviction that the Olympians were not only non-primitive but positively in a sense non-religious; but that, on the other hand, the cultus of Dionysus and of Orpheus were essentially religious.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.25, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262103:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262103", "s": "If it sometimes seems to take the reader far afield and to be expanded by the consideration of matters only remotely connected, the treatment is always interesting and persuasive.", "prev": "As he Book Reviews 361 has said above, the work is full of learning and insight.", "next": "Indeed one must be on his guard lest he be carried along against his own judgment.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.472, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262103:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262103", "s": "But when Miss Harrison goes on to say that to the cardinal features of the story belong the hiding, killing, and dismem- berment of the child, who then is to be brought to life again, she is stating something which cannot be proved, and the arbitrary equation Kouros= Zeus, or Dionysus, or Zagreus, combined with the doctrine of expurgation, will not convince all readers.", "prev": "This certainly is the beginning of the familiar story of the protection of the infant Zeus by the Kouretes.", "next": "The sarcophagus from Hagia Triada is interpreted with a confidence as to the relation of the scenes depicted and their details that is somewhat startling.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.7, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262104:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262104", "s": "M. 764, 6 : TpayiuSia, on to. ttoXXo. ol x°P ' * K SoTvpwv mwiaravro, ovs (koXow Tpayovs, more plausible ?", "prev": "Ridgeway that we are here on uncertain ground, is not the common view, expressed in Et.", "next": "The author's long chapter (iv) in which he attempts to point out sur- vivals in extant Greek tragedies of what he regards as the primitive type of the Tpoyucos x°P°s does not materially strengthen his theory.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.81, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262105:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262105", "s": "M. 764, 6 : TpayiuSia, on to. ttoXXo. ol x°P ' * K SoTvpwv mwiaravro, ovs (koXow Tpayovs, more plausible ?", "prev": "Ridgeway that we are here on uncertain ground, is not the common view, expressed in Et.", "next": "The author's long chapter (iv) in which he attempts to point out sur- vivals in extant Greek tragedies of what he regards as the primitive type of the Tpoyucos x°P°s does not materially strengthen his theory.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.317, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262111:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262111", "s": "I have cited only the more plausible generalizations of this chapter.", "prev": "As regards (6), Sophocles distinguished between characters with definite names and messengers, herdsmen, nurses, etc. — the latter, being recognizable from their clothing, are never introduced\" (chap. iii).", "next": "It is a weakness of Graeber's to formulate a rule or general statement upon the slightest excuse.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.541, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262112:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262112", "s": "Taken together they offer a most plausible explanation for the high position held by women in Asia Minor under Roman sway.", "prev": "Braunstein's theory really supple- ments the explanation offered by Paris.", "next": "Braunstein himself remarks that \"diese mutterrecht- lichen Zustande\" are not the causa efficiens, but the conditio sine qua non.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.81, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262112:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262112", "s": "The weakness of the thesis lies in the lack of convincing evidence of the persistence of Mutterrecht in Asia Minor.", "prev": "Braunstein himself remarks that \"diese mutterrecht- lichen Zustande\" are not the causa efficiens, but the conditio sine qua non.", "next": "New material may furnish such evidence.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.847, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262114:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262114", "s": "More convincing than this somewhat doubtful proposition is the second and familiar argument drawn from the references in similes to usages never attributed to the actual life of the heroes.", "prev": "Belz- ner thinks that the possibility of conscious archaizing in Homer is clearly proved by two facts: First, the poet himself thought that the sun rose from 380 Book Reviews the stream of Ocean, but he consistently makes his personages speak of it as coming up from the darkness beneath the earth.", "next": "In strictness then we must distinguish the Homeric \"culture\" of the poet from the epic \"culture\" of the heroes.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.407, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262114:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262114", "s": "Many of these emendations are plausible, but the frequent resort to this extreme measure will only further confuse a tradition which Roemer frankly confesses is already the despair of the sane and sincere investigator.", "prev": "Roemer goes so far in his enthusiasm for Aristarchus as to emend the scholia in order to shift from Aristarchus to his predecessors the responsibility for irrational interpretations.", "next": "We shall await with interest his forthcoming work on Aristarchus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.74, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262115:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262115", "s": "Many of these emendations are plausible, but the frequent resort to this extreme measure will only further confuse a tradition which Roemer frankly confesses is already the despair of the sane and sincere investigator.", "prev": "Roemer goes so far in his enthusiasm for Aristarchus as to emend the scholia in order to shift from Aristarchus to his predecessors the responsibility for irrational interpretations.", "next": "We shall await with interest his forthcoming work on Aristarchus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.212, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262116:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262116", "s": "Novelties in punctuation are more numerous, and it is pleasant to see the ingenious and convincing suggestion of Samuelsson on ii. 5. 91 adopted by a second standard text.", "prev": "There is an index of proper names and a Ust of \"initia satirarum.\" The text is on the whole conservative, and more weight is given to the readings of the Blandinian manuscripts than by Keller and Holder or Vollmer.", "next": "In the introduction the chapter on the relation of the Old Comedy to Satire is particularly interesting and suggestive.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.895, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262116:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262116", "s": "Leo and Hendrickson\" are subjected to a careful critique and rejected, but the book was printed before the appearance of Hendrickson's convincing article in Class.", "prev": "The views of \"MM.", "next": "Phil.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.926, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262117:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262117", "s": "Novelties in punctuation are more numerous, and it is pleasant to see the ingenious and convincing suggestion of Samuelsson on ii. 5. 91 adopted by a second standard text.", "prev": "There is an index of proper names and a list of \"initia satirarum.\" The text is on the whole conservative, and more weight is given to the readings of the Blandinian manuscripts than by Keller and Holder or Vollmer.", "next": "In the introduction the chapter on the relation of the Old Comedy to Satire is particularly interesting and suggestive.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.425, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262117:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262117", "s": "Leo and Hendrickson\" are subjected to a careful critique and rejected, but the book was printed before the appearance of Hendrickson's convincing article in Class.", "prev": "The views of \"MM.", "next": "Phil.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.47, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261481:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261481", "s": "I am not quite convinced.", "prev": "But he has carefully considered the general probability that stylistic differences may be due to the subject- matter, and he believes that he has eliminated that objection in respect of 492 Book Reviews the formulae included in his statistics.", "next": "The nature of the theme, if we extend the phrase to include dramatic setting, polemic or satiric intentions, and the character of the respondents, affects the style in more subtle ways than Sprachstatistik has yet taken cognizance of.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.735, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261487:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261487", "s": "Thus he has left the corrupt passage in 11. 3 as a locus desperatus, in spite of the easy and convincing emendation of Sylburg, and Jordan's almost certain conjecture of Acilius Piso in 10. 2 into Acilius <ei> Piso has not been accepted.", "prev": "However, in some instances the editor has perhaps been over-conservative.", "next": "Similarly, in 20. 3 he has retained without question the meaningless clause quae repente exierat, which in spite of many attempts has never been success- fully emended, and which is probably to be regarded as a gloss on the preceding excitam.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.573, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261495:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261495", "s": "Thus the best type of support is usually lacking and parallels from Propertius, Ovid, etc., do not suffice to carry conviction.", "prev": "The total amount of text is so small that it is often impossible to cite parallels for your conjecture from the text of the poet whom you are trying to \" improve,\" and the style is so normal that it is even harder to prove that your conjecture is peculiarly Tibullian — to say nothing of Lygdamus, Sulpicia, and the rest.", "next": "If Dr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.482, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261495:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261495", "s": "Approximate analogies will convince nobody unless the conjecture be brilliant inde&d.", "prev": "A similar dearth of the best support blights all the rest of the conjectures.", "next": "The sophistical reasoning which marks some of Dr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.634, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261495:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261495", "s": "A contribution to the extensive literature dealing with the first six Odes of Horace's third book can hardly be expected to offer very much that is new and at the same time plausible.", "prev": "Pp. viii+182.", "next": "Slijpen's book served as a dissertation, but was primarily written in a prize contest in which these Odes were assigned as the subject with the limitation that the opinions of scholars from Momm- sen to Corssen (1889-97) be critically examined and the writer's own inter- pretation given.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.906, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261496:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261496", "s": "A contribution to the extensive literature dealing with the first six Odes of Horace's third book can hardly be expected to offer very much that is new and at the same time plausible.", "prev": "Pp. viii+182.", "next": "Slijpen's book served as a dissertation, but was primarily written in a prize contest in which these Odes were assigned as the subject with the limitation that the opinions of scholars from Momm- sen to Corssen (1889-97) be critically examined and the writer's own inter- pretation given.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.449, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261501:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261501", "s": "Cautus (for captus) at ii. 23. 10 is plausible, though I do not feel certain that the MSS are wrong.", "prev": "At ii. 16 a new and quite possible order is suggested.", "next": "Again at iv. 6. 80 reddita signa Remi is a good emenda- tion, if the text be really in need of any.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.967, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261502:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261502", "s": "Cautus (for captus) at ii. 23. 10 is plausible, though I do not feel certain that the MSS are wrong.", "prev": "At ii. 16 a new and quite possible order is suggested.", "next": "Again at iv. 6. 80 reddita signa Remi is a good emenda- tion, if the text be really in need of any.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.305, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261502:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261502", "s": "The division at vs. 21, advocated by Ites, and Rothstein's theory that the girl of the latter part of the elegy is another than Cynthia, are convincingly refuted.", "prev": "Enk has Book Reviews 517 given us is his argument for the unity of ii. 33, and his excellent interpretation of the poem.", "next": "At ii. 5. 28 the author rightly retains the reading of the MSS, viz., Cynthia forma potens, Cynthia verba levis, but apparently does not appreciate the motive of the scholars who proposed verna levis (Peiper), and lingua levis (Richards), which was to provide a nominative in the second half to parallel forma in the first.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.332, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261504:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261504", "s": "None of these are convincing.", "prev": "Nor do there seem to be more than about 15 of his modestly made suggestions even in the apparatus.", "next": "No conjectures of scholars since Baehrens seem to be accepted into the text — unless there be a few which have escaped the reviewer.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.63, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261504:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261504", "s": "It seems to be certain that DV are of no value (except as offering plausible conjectures) where NA, or (after ii. 1. 63 where A ends) NF agree (see Classical Philology, loc. cit.).", "prev": "Hosius follows Baehrens in putting too much trust in DV.", "next": "We should therefore accept the reading of these MSS wherever possible, e.g. iii. 11. 24, where NF have Nee and DV (followed by Hosius) have Ne.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.662, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261505:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261505", "s": "Chap, iv (pp. 92-117), \"Die antike Forschung und ihr Material\" is one of much interest, and on the whole is convincing.", "prev": "The first or fivOuios Adyos agrees essentially with Livy's sober account and lacks the romantic coloring of Vergil; the second or aXrflio-Ttpos Adyos is purely rationalistic and therefore of secondary interest.", "next": "Miinzer discusses the treatment of the myth in (1) Servius on Aeneid viii. 203, partly dependent on Verrius Flaccus;", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.693, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261505:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261505", "s": "Gellius, who calls Cacus a Campanian king, any more convincing.", "prev": "Nor is the attempt to connect this ingeniously woven mythical complex with the notice of Cn.", "next": "At most we should be justified in using the evidence of this passage only as a possible indication for the Cumaean origin of the Hercules legend at Rome.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.955, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261411:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261411", "s": "Heinze's program in the New Jahrbucher of 1907 may be realized if the student is persuaded by the practical sug- gestions of Bethe, Wendland, and Norden.", "prev": "The constant criticism of the uninitiated that the classical field offers no opportunities because it has been worked for so many centuries may well be met by a reference to these inspiring accounts of what remains to be done, especially in technique;", "next": "H.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.303, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261412:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261412", "s": "And, as I could not have the comedies acted, I had them read aloud to me, with the result that my ear was thoroughly convinced.", "prev": "One of the first tests to be applied to a translation of a play is, Would it act ?", "next": "Mr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.577, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261416:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261416", "s": "If the dialogue was composed at Alexandria, as Albers plausibly argues, this might be a contributory reason for rejecting Lucian's authorship, as we have no specific grounds for believing that Lucian was settled in Egypt in his earlier years and certain peculiarities seem inconsistent with his author- ship unless the dialogue be referred, as has been suggested by others, to his juvenilia.", "prev": "On grounds of the rhetorical color- ing and sophistic method and the peculiarities of diction common to the second Christian century — whether in the way of successful, though over- careful, Atticizing or of actual slips in Attic usage — Albers makes out a case for the possibility of authorship by some rhetorician of the period other than Lucian.", "next": "As the unknown author himself lays stress on the novelty, not of the subject-matter, but of the use of dialogue as a vehicle for an encomium, Albers, assuming that it was not by Lucian, concludes that it could not have been written until after 162 a.d., when Lucian had furnished, in his Imagines, a model for this new departure in literature.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.376, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261420:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261420", "s": "Beltrami also accepts the explanation of carmina and of the metrical structure, but is not convinced by Elter's arguments on the subjects of the inscription and Scipio's apotheosis.", "prev": "He accepts his interpretation of car- mina (vs. 11) and his explanation of the variation from the Lex Meinekiana, and thinks that the other points for which he contends deserve careful consideration.", "next": "But while these reviewers partially approve the author's contentions, the others are distinctly opposed to them.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.777, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261421:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261421", "s": "Beltrami also accepts the explanation of carmina and of the metrical structure, but is not convinced by Elter's arguments on the subjects of the inscription and Scipio's apotheosis.", "prev": "He accepts his interpretation of car- mina (vs. 11) and his explanation of the variation from the Lex Meinekiana, and thinks that the other points for which he contends deserve careful consideration.", "next": "But while these reviewers partially approve the author's contentions, the others are distinctly opposed to them.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.366, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262462:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262462", "s": "There is a certain plausibility in the general assumption that variant doublets represent substituted or alternative lectures in repeated courses.", "prev": "Jaeger with material for a great many more ingenious minor com- binations which it would require a volume as large as his own to test.", "next": "But he often finds such doublets where we probably have nothing more than the natural self -repetition of a hurried metaphysician possessed of some fixed ideas, but uncertain of his goal.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.751, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262463:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262463", "s": "Into this rhetorical world of beautiful plausibility Socrates enters with the questions: How is the thing really ?", "prev": "The principle of relativity and the universal anthesis of the two logoi are symbols and reflections of the opposing theses and argtmients in rhetorical debate.", "next": "What is the truth of the matter ?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.622, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262464:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262464", "s": "The conspectus of reminiscences from the Tragedians is not very convincing but the tragic coloring of the vocabu- lary in the Tragopodagra is evident.", "prev": "Both the bad syntax and the inane repetition of dull expressions present in the Ocypus, are at least inconspicuous in the Tragopodagra.", "next": "The argument from the order observed in the various codices is ingenious and adds weight to the rejection of the Ocypus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.655, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262464:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262464", "s": "Although the argument that Lucian would not have repeated this same theme in a second piece seems hardly cogent in view of the many instances to the contrary in the Lucianic canon, the inferior character of the Ocypus itself is made out well enough.", "prev": " the mocking satire upon the orthodox gods in the claims put forth by Podagra, and in one sentence briefly remarks: \"Nee sane Podagra fabula tarn facete composita Luciani ingenio indigna est,\" yet he might well have supplemented the more obvious suggestions of vocabulary and meter by a fuller discussion of the delicate criteria of Lucian's humor which may, perhaps, be detected in the Tragopodagra.", "next": "Zimmermann, finally, tries to prove that the Ocypus was written in the year 364 a.d. by Acacius the friend of Libanius.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.782, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262465:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262465", "s": "Although the argument that Lucian would not have repeated this same theme in a second piece seems hardly cogent in view of the many instances to the contrary in the Lucianic canon, the inferior character of the Ocypus itself is made out well enough.", "prev": " the mocking satire upon the orthodox gods in the claims put forth by Podagra, and in one sentence briefly remarks: \"Nee sane Podagra fabula tarn facete composita Luciani ingenio indigna est,\" yet he might well have supplemented the more obvious suggestions of vocabulary and meter by a fuller discussion of the delicate criteria of Lucian's humor which may, perhaps, be detected in the Tragopodagra.", "next": "Zimmermann, finally, tries to prove that the Ocypus was written in the year 364 a.d. by Acacius the friend of Libanius.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.274, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261698:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261698", "s": "The footnotes, on the other hand, are few, Book Reviews 367 and, as a six months' trial has convinced me, insufficient for novices.", "prev": "They consist of a significant title, a complete bibliography, and just enough narrative to explain the situation presupposed by the document.", "next": "Even in the publications of Grenfell and Hunt, which are intended for scholars, more corrections of misspelled words and misused cases, tenses, forms, and pronouns are given than in this chrestomathy for beginners.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.766, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261699:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261699", "s": "Book Reviews 367 and, as a six months' trial has convinced me, insufficient for novices.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.", "next": "Even in the publications of Grenfell and Hunt, which are intended for scholars, more corrections of misspelled words and misused cases, tenses, forms, and pronouns are given than in this chrestomathy for beginners.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.114, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261702:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261702", "s": "Niese's view has been generally accepted, but Cardinali's discussion of the matter is keen, clear, and in the main convincing.", "prev": "The second essay deals with the administration of the ager puhlicus before the Gracchan period, for the purpose of overthrowing Niese's conten- tion that legislation fixing the amount of public land to be held by any indi- vidual dated only from a few years before 133 B.C., and formed no part of the Licinian laws of 367.", "next": "He seems to have shown with reasonable certainty that some form of limita- tion was contained in the Licinian legislation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.675, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261702:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261702", "s": "He also maintains with much plausibility that the lex Thoria of 111 B.C. was not a reactionary measure as is generally supposed.", "prev": "In tracing the history of the lex Sempronia, Cardinali takes a position half-way between those who believe that the law was fully carried out, and those who think that, although the ager pvblicus was separated from that rightfully in the hands of individuals, little actual distribution took place.", "next": "S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.812, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261703:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261703", "s": "Niese's view has been generally accepted, but Cardinali's discussion of the matter is keen, clear, and in the main convincing.", "prev": "The second essay deals with the administration of the ager puhlicus before the Gracchan period, for the purpose of overthrowing Niese's conten- tion that legislation fixing the amount of public land to be held by any indi- vidual dated only from a few years before 133 B.C., and formed no part of the Licinian laws of 367.", "next": "He seems to have shown with reasonable certainty that some form of limita- tion was contained in the Licinian legislation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.263, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261703:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261703", "s": "He also maintains with much plausibility that the lex Thoria of 111 B.C. was not a reactionary measure as is generally supposed.", "prev": "In tracing the history of the lex Sempronia, Cardinali takes a position half-way between those who believe that the law was fully carried out, and those who think that, although the ager pvblicus was separated from that rightfully in the hands of individuals, little actual distribution took place.", "next": "S.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.398, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261704:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261704", "s": "By a series of convincing proofs and parallels the author shows that this reading is a distortion of the following: (a) AOtTtiTai [ wo ZrjvoSorov Kal 'ApioTo^avous ], OTi yeXoTos ktX..", "prev": "(j8) awoXoyov/jLcvoi. 8e <j>a(Ti,v, OTi to ck tv;^s <rv/u.^£j8»;K69 aiTuiTiKmi c^cvjjvo^^ev (Ariston.).", "next": "(fi) [ KaKoig • koI avTiXiya Si' xnrofivrjfM- riav 'Api<rTapx<K ] on to ktX.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.495, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261707:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261707", "s": "Just as in his monograph on Horace's Donarem pateras, his arguments, though often plausible and ingenious, rest on evidence that either shows a glaring defect in some detail or is in general too flimsy to be considered seriously.", "prev": "Elter does not establish his thesis.", "next": "As the first step in his contention he points out that the route from Milan to Palestine in the Antonine Itinerary is practically identical with that in the Itinerarium Burdigalense, except for the fact that the less important stations (the mutationes) are omitted in the former.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.796, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261708:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261708", "s": "Just as in his monograph on Horace's Donarem pateras, his arguments, though often plausible and ingenious, rest on evidence that either shows a glaring defect in some detail or is in general too flimsy to be considered seriously.", "prev": "Elter does not establish his thesis.", "next": "As the first step in his contention he points out that the route from Milan to Palestine in the Antonine Itinerary is practically identical with that in the Itinerarium Burdigalense, except for the fact that the less important stations (the mutationes) are omitted in the former.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.659, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261709:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261709", "s": "But he clearly indicates the method by which the problem must be attacked and offers the most plausible solution that has yet been proposed.", "prev": "It would be claiming too much to affirm that Professor Immisch has here definitely disposed of the vexed question of the Platonic Letters.", "next": "He wastes no time in proving that the Letters in their present form could not have been written by Plato.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.281, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261709:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261709", "s": "He shows that the Epistles, which contain much of this kind of admonition adapted to various political situations, might plausibly be regarded as the fulfilment of this program.", "prev": "Professor Immisch argues that in Plato's view this third exposition of political theory would treat of the rectification or reformation by counsel or admonition, of existing erroneous or diseased governments.", "next": "That they were in fact so interpreted in later Platonic tradition he proves from Apuleius and a sentence of the so-called, 'AAkivoou ciW-yw-y^, XXXIV, which I quote somewhat more fully than he does: viroypa^a, Se k<u aAAas TToXiTilai ii i-iroOicnmi, mv iarlv r] re iv No/tots Kal ij Ik SiopOma-eioi iv EjriCTToXais y )(prJTai, irpos Tcts vevocrrjKVMi iroAeis tws iv Tots No/tois.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.55, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261709:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261709", "s": "It is the kmd of rhetorical Umstilisierung 388 Book Reviews which we look for in the /uapaKiuSes and hva-rpi^iKov style of Timaeus, and as an ornament of his history composed at Athens after 317, we may plausibly conceive this precious epistle of Dexippus.", "prev": "The rhetoric and display of sophistical erudition are too silly not only for the practical statesman Dexippus, but even for that \"Pusillus Thucydides\" Philistus.", "next": "Thence the compiler of the Platonic Letters took it, first because he had no epistles of Plato addressed to the elder Diony^ius and, second, because it illustrates a necessary topic of the collection, the warnings, the admonitions to be addressed to one who is about to seize upon a tyranny.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.798, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262538:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262538", "s": "The greater irregularity here is plausibly explained as due to leveling within the paradigm : KarQipxy led to KarOyo-ia, etc.", "prev": "The same prepositions in composition with verbs show 88 exceptions to the rule out of a total of 649 occurrences.", "next": "Most of the apocopated forms in noun compounds conform to Ehrlich's law.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.149, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262538:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262538", "s": "Thus dyicas, \"in the arms,\" is plausibly explained as a locative plural of ayKmv. 5<ppa and To<j>pa may well contain *5-<pi (from *o-<pi) and *r6-<pi, instrumental adverbs.", "prev": "It is, however, still possible to find a few stereotyped case forms that have lost a final short vowel.", "next": "Since the final syllable of the first member of a compound is treated as an absolute final, ravavrroSa must come from *Tava/:6- iroSa. <£ep«r/2tos from *<ptpe<r{f}ios is a formation of the type of eXxtcriirarXos.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.265, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262538:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262538", "s": "There is therefore no objection to admitting such of Kretschmer's earlier instances as are plausible in themselves.", "prev": "remarks elsewhere (p. 2): \"Nicht einmal ein Lautwandel, der auf unbetonte Silben beschrankt ist, muss in jedem Falle eine Wirkung schwacher Expiration sein.\" It is clear that we have before us a law of dissimilation rather than of syncope, and who can say, in the present state of our knowledge, whether or not a purely musical accent can determine which of two vowels is to be lost by dissimilation?", "next": "For example, vkldpov is more likely to be a younger form of iriXtOpov than a different ablaut grade.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.447, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262538:3", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262538", "s": "There is no convincing evidence for a stress accent in Greek before the Christian era, except in the speech of some very low social stratum at Athens in the fourth century.", "prev": "It is difficult to see why we should suppose that the accent had any connection at all with the change.", "next": "Ehrlich treats in detail a number of points which concern his main thesis only indirectly, and these excursuses embrace some of the most valuable contributions in the book.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.488, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262540:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262540", "s": "Much that he says is plausible, but the theory is pushed too far, and the superstructure topples of its own weight.", "prev": "In an appendix we have a table which represents Costa's idea of the appear- ance of the original fasti from 330 to 387 auc.", "next": "S.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.235, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262549:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262549", "s": "Thus he admits the presence of taboo and magic in many religious rites, but sees no sign of totemism. 502 Book Reviews He convincingly refutes Frazer's theory of the magician-king (pp. 49-53) as well as his theory of married deities.", "prev": "The reader becomes absorbed in the volume as a history, not only of Roman religion, but also of the development of the nation; and the accu- racy and sober judgment with which the author has sifted the evidence on doubtful points are everywhere conspicuous.", "next": "He advances strong arguments against Wissowa's conjecture that the Argei represented Greeks who were at some earlier period sacrificed by drowning.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.703, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262550:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262550", "s": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 502 Book Reviews He convincingly refutes Frazer's theory of the magician-king (pp. 49-53) as well as his theory of married deities.", "prev": "JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico.", "next": "He advances strong arguments against Wissowa's conjecture that the Argei represented Greeks who were at some earlier period sacrificed by drowning.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.165, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262550:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262550", "s": "A number of plausible emendations due to Mrs.", "prev": "The footnotes supply all needed dates and references Book Reviews 503 to the numerous passages of classical literature imitated by Julian.", "next": "Wright herself, or communi- cated by friends, improve corrupt passages of the text, if they do not certainly restore Julian's hand.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.608, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262551:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262551", "s": "A number of plausible emendations due to Mrs.", "prev": "Book Reviews 503 to the numerous passages of classical literature imitated by Julian.", "next": "Wright herself, or communi- cated by friends, improve corrupt passages of the text, if they do not certainly restore Julian's hand.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.193, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261590:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261590", "s": "Wilamo- witz plausibly reconstructs the plot and quotes and interprets the chorus' quest for the cattle and Cyllene's teasing speech.", "prev": "The 'IxvtvTal ^drvpoi, of which some four hundred lines have been rescued, deals with the theme of the Homeric Hymn to Hermes.", "next": "From the style he infers that the play belongs to the earlier period of Sophocles' irocpov kol Kardrexvov manner.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.954, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261591:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261591", "s": "Wilamo- witz plausibly reconstructs the plot and quotes and interprets the chorus' quest for the cattle and Cyllene's teasing speech.", "prev": "The 'IxvtvTal ^drvpoi, of which some four hundred lines have been rescued, deals with the theme of the Homeric Hymn to Hermes.", "next": "From the style he infers that the play belongs to the earlier period of Sophocles' irocpov kol Kardrexvov manner.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.5, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261592:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261592", "s": "Poulsen argues convincingly for the Phoenician origin of most of these objects, and uses them constantly in the later chapters to prove Phoenician influence in works found in Greece and Italy.", "prev": "The earlier chapters are devoted to a careful and illuminating analysis of the famous bronze bowls from Nimrud; the bronze and silver bowls from Cyprus, Crete, the Greek mainland, and Italy; the carved ivories from Nimrud and elsewhere; the so-called tridacna shells from different sites; and various other objects that have been brought into connection with Phoenician art.", "next": "The titles of the later chapters and their conclusions are as follows: chap, vi, \"The Cretan Shields\" (these are close copies by Cretan workmen of Phoenician shields, showing almost no originality) ; vii, \" Early Rhodian Art\" (it was strongly influenced by Phoenician products, but here we see the earliest manifestation of the Greek spirit, transforming the oriental models); viii, \"The Ivory Figure", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.611, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261593:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261593", "s": "As regards the translation: iii. 290 and 1131 are so much alike that one wonders why Ov/jlov of the former passage should not be emended to Ov/im. iii. 117, \"playing for golden dice,\" not \"with,\" is almost convincing.", "prev": "The latter alternative still seems to me more probable.", "next": "But it puts an unusual strain upon the verb, as if it were a verb of striving, iii. 1060, TOW y' '(EKrjTi is rendered \"thereupon.\" While this is a faint render- ing of the Greek, one cannot question its correctness.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.655, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261594:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261594", "s": "They were indeed fortunate who heard the lectures and could enjoy Dieterich's persuasive enthusiasm.", "prev": "It is a more just and agreeable thing to express appreciation of the historical grasp and insight which the paper displays.", "next": "The volume has as frontispiece an excellent portrait of Dieterich in his library, and as introduction Wiinsch has reprinted with slight changes his biographical notice which first appeared in the Jahresbericht for 1910.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.876, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261567:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261567", "s": "Could the expression mean iravrutv (neut.) /ca0airTOyu.evos wpoo-eifrvtTo, ttoxti. vpoa-e<j>vero /caoWrd/vicvos, he was growing on to everything, i.e., he was getting his clutches into everything f\" This is not convincing, and the London Athenaeum reviewer seems right in defending the ordinary interpretation.", "prev": "The MSS show no variations, and emendation is excluded.", "next": "In § 24: tl yap /cat y8ovA.dyu.ei/ot p.eTen-ip.ireo-6' av, Goodwin simply trans- lates: \"With what possible object [/cat] would you have been sending?\" Humphreys' note is: \"r( yap /cat ySouAd/uevoi, 'With what conceivable pur-", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.958, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261568:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261568", "s": "Could the expression mean iravrutv (neut.) /ca0airTOyu.evos wpoo-eifrvtTo, ttoxti. vpoa-e<j>vero /caoWrd/vicvos, he was growing on to everything, i.e., he was getting his clutches into everything f\" This is not convincing, and the London Athenaeum reviewer seems right in defending the ordinary interpretation.", "prev": "The MSS show no variations, and emendation is excluded.", "next": "In § 24: tl yap /cat y8ovA.dyu.ei/ot p.eTen-ip.ireo-6' av, Goodwin simply trans- lates: \"With what possible object [/cat] would you have been sending?\" Humphreys' note is: \"r( yap /cat ySouAd/uevoi, 'With what conceivable pur- 206 Book Reviews pose?'\" Cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.338, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261569:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261569", "s": "Now, once the biographer is granted freedom to cull from a book epigrams that confound his chronology and redate them with no other compelling cause at a much earlier period, he can impose almost any conclusions.", "prev": "In the second in response to criticism the writer reiterates his arguments in only slightly emended form.", "next": "Allow him further the argwnentum ex silentio — perhaps the most hazardous available to man as a reasoning animal — and he may well be grateful.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.337, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261570:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261570", "s": "Hous- man's particular critical enunciations, but this general position has not appeared to convince the prudent, in spite of the contemptuous vigor with which he asserted and carried it out in the case of Book I (cf . op. cit, p. xxxi £f .) .", "prev": "There is of course much truth in certain of Mr.", "next": "At the present time Mr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.66, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261570:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261570", "s": "Garrod's; it is simpler than when he published the first book; for he has meanwhile become convinced that V (Vossianus 390), as well as Urbinates 667 and 668, is in direct descent from M (Matritensis M31), and may 212 Book Reviews therefore be disregarded.", "prev": "Housman's stemma is not merely simpler than Mr.", "next": "His new stemma accordingly includes only GLL^M, and shows no such troublesome serpentine lines of intertwining as Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.691, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261571:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261571", "s": "The argument of Munro on the numbers of the Persian army, ingenious, and, in some points, convincing as it is, in my opinion is valuable only as an explanation of the figures we have in Herodotus, but is utterly worthless for determining the actual size of the army of Xerxes.", "prev": "Having said so much by way of commendation, I may select a point or two for criticism.", "next": "Munro is right in concluding that there were thirty archontes, instead of twenty-nine, from the fact that thirty times 60,000 (the arehontal division given in 8 . 126 and 9.96) is 1,800,000, the number of the Asiatic land force; and because six generals-in-chief imply a multiple of six for the inferior officers.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.545, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261571:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261571", "s": "So far we are on fairly safe ground; but, plausible as it looks, it is not a certain inference that Hydarnes is the missing thirtieth archon; that the arehontal division was therefore 10,000, not 60,000; that 60,000 was the division of the general- in-chief ; and that Herodotus made the mistake of assuming it to be arehontal and so reached his absurd figure, 1,800,000.", "prev": "Munro is right in concluding that there were thirty archontes, instead of twenty-nine, from the fact that thirty times 60,000 (the arehontal division given in 8 . 126 and 9.96) is 1,800,000, the number of the Asiatic land force; and because six generals-in-chief imply a multiple of six for the inferior officers.", "next": "Even if this result could be unhesitatingly accepted, I should not be able to follow Munro to the con- clusion that Xerxes' army actually numbered 180,000.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.602, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261573:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261573", "s": "Here he was anticipated by Valk in 1902, whose reasoning, however, was far less cogent.", "prev": "The author's general position is that the poem is far nearer completion than has hitherto been considered.", "next": "Lacunae and trans- positions Mussehl generally rejects ; many stop-gaps he shows are inadequate ; apparent duplication of arguments is proved to be demanded by Lucretius' method.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.512, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261574:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261574", "s": "Yet these are difficulties of detail rather than of principle, and over against a few unconvincing paralleUsms must be set the combined weight of many that are cogent, so that there results from Lammert's study the recovery, not of the form, but yet of the substance of many interesting passages from the work of Donatus.", "prev": "In such an argument as this critics will always differ as to the significance of individual resemblances, as, for example, in the instances cited above.", "next": "The arrangement of the article is clear and methodical, and the understanding of its plan is aided by an excellent table of contents which similar works might well imitate.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.671, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261575:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261575", "s": "Yet these are difficulties of detail rather than of principle, and over against a few unconvincing parallelisms must be set the combined weight of many that are cogent, so that there results from Lammert's study the recovery, not of the form, but yet of the substance of many interesting passages from the work of Donatus.", "prev": "In such an argument as this critics will always differ as to the significance of individual resemblances, as, for example, in the instances cited above.", "next": "The arrangement of the article is clear and methodical, and the understanding of its plan is aided by an excellent table of contents which similar works might well imitate.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.267, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261575:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261575", "s": "Since the appearance of his Commentationes Tullianae in 1910, in which he lucidly and convincingly demonstrated his general principles of criticism, and elucidated a consider-", "prev": "Sjogren promises to be a valiant and perhaps a better substitute for him.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.975, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261576:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261576", "s": "Since the appearance of his Commentationes Tullianae in 1910, in which he lucidly and convincingly demonstrated his general principles of criticism, and elucidated a consider- Book Reviews 221 able number of individual passages from the Letters, expectation of solid and trustworthy work from him has been fully justified.", "prev": "Sjogren promises to be a vafiant and perhaps a better substitute for him.", "next": "This first fascicle of his critical edition is without preface, for the preface is properly to be found in his Commentationes.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.554, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261577:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261577", "s": "Marou- zeau's contentions are convincing; often, however, it is difficult to accept his conclusions.", "prev": "In general, M.", "next": "In Bud. 531 it is two men who have just come from the water, not two women as Marouzeau says (p. 266).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.941, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261728:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261728", "s": "More convincing would be the statement that Sophokles (Philok. 400 ff.) represents Ge as the goddess whom Odysseus especially honored, were it not that the exegetical method by which this result is obtained is unsound.", "prev": "after his return near a cave and hid his treasures therein, and the detailed description of this cave is taken to show that originally it must have been conceived as the lair of a chthonic demon, who issued thence to slay the suitors; he meets his mother Antikleia in the Nekyia, hence she is prob- ably the Earth, and Laertes, by a daring etymology (der Vereiniger des Volkes), is, therefore, Hades.", "next": "Rossbach construes, namely (To), fuiKaipa ■ . . . t<5 Aapriov <rej3as wepTarov, as \"blessed mother earth, most highly honored in the eyes of Odysseus.\" He thus proposes an interpretation opposed to the authority of all the scholars whom I have been able to con- sult, from the Scholiast on down to Rademacher, which, though gram- matically possible, is wholly unsuitable to the context, and destroys ", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.624, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261730:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261730", "s": "Indeed, the whole section on invention is much less convincing than the others.", "prev": "It was the attitude substantially of many of his contem- poraries and there is evidence that it was not altogether unwarranted by experience.", "next": "M. de Decker (p. 9) expresses surprise that his method of attacking the subject had not been anticipated.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.669, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261731:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261731", "s": "Indeed, the whole section on invention is much less convincing than the others.", "prev": "It was the attitude substantially of many of his contem- poraries and there is evidence that it was not altogether unwarranted by experience.", "next": "M. de Decker (p. 9) expresses surprise that his method of attacking the subject had not been anticipated.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.428, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261457:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261457", "s": "It is a plausible theory — sug- gested apparently by Meillet — and it probably represents a part of the truth.", "prev": "The conclusion is, in brief, that all Greek futures except those like ei/xt and ISoywai, and also the Italic s-futures, as well as the Sanskrit and Lith- uanian futures, come from Indo-European desiderative presents of the types represented by Latin viso, Sanskrit vivrtsati, Lithuanian kldusiu (from *kleuesi e / o) , and perhaps one or two others.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.984, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261458:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261458", "s": "It is a plausible theory — sug- gested apparently by Meillet — and it probably represents a part of the truth.", "prev": "The conclusion is, in brief, that all Greek futures except those like ei/xt and ISoywai, and also the Italic s-futures, as well as the Sanskrit and Lith- uanian futures, come from Indo-European desiderative presents of the types represented by Latin viso, Sanskrit vivrtsati, Lithuanian kldusiu (from *kleuesi e / o) , and perhaps one or two others.", "next": "Book Reviews 453 Magnien, however, does considerably less than justice to the rival theory that the Greek future is in the main an aorist subjunctive.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.594, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261461:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261461", "s": "As for the connec- tion between the stories of Paris and Cyrus — the idea is Carl Robert's — when we consider that the only fragment of Sophocles' Alexandros that throws light upon its plot is /Sorijpa vlkSlv avSpas doriTas, even though this hint and the form of the Paris myth in later writers enable us to make a plausible reconstruction of the plot, we cannot accept such a reconstruction as valuable evidence of Sophocles' indebtedness to Herodotus.", "prev": "In the former case the resemblance is evident, and the possibility of borrowing undeniable, but I cannot say that Rasch's elab- orate argument makes it more than a possibility to me.", "next": "It is an original idea of Rasch that the scene in which Athena urges Ulysses to stay and behold the madness of Ajax was suggested by the Candaules-Gyges story: \"Aequae,\" he says, \"sunt utriusque fabulae condi- ciones: et Gyges et Ulixes inviti et precibus frustra effusis a dominis faventi- bus coguntur, ut miseras illas personas intueantur nudatas; nam Aiacis quoque, qui pessima insania oppressus ", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.585, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261464:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261464", "s": "On p. 44 his defense of the text (99, 23-100, 1) against the arguments of Ipfelkofer seems convincing.", "prev": "The remainder of the first half of the dissertation is devoted to a discussion of various noteworthy examples of word-order which the author has reserved for special treatment.", "next": "In the last half of the dissertation Eisemann attempts to prove that the old readings of the MSS are superior to the new readings of the Hibeh papy- rus.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.802, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261464:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261464", "s": "Very few of his arguments are at all convincing.", "prev": "In the last half of the dissertation Eisemann attempts to prove that the old readings of the MSS are superior to the new readings of the Hibeh papy- rus.", "next": "He fails to see that the usage of the MSS may not be set as a Procrustean bed for the new readings of the papyrus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.839, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261465:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261465", "s": "On p. 44 his defense of the text (99, 23-100, 1) against the arguments of Ipfelkofer seems convincing.", "prev": "The remainder of the first half of the dissertation is devoted to a discussion of various noteworthy examples of word-order which the author has reserved for special treatment.", "next": "In the last half of the dissertation Eisemann attempts to prove that the old readings of the MSS are superior to the new readings of the Hibeh papy- rus.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.383, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261465:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261465", "s": "Very few of his arguments are at all convincing.", "prev": "In the last half of the dissertation Eisemann attempts to prove that the old readings of the MSS are superior to the new readings of the Hibeh papy- rus.", "next": "He fails to see that the usage of the MSS may not be set as a Procrustean bed for the new readings of the papyrus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.419, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261465:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261465", "s": "The plausibility of his conclusions may be granted.", "prev": "Taubenschlag's book is technical and will be profitably read only by those already familiar with the substance and methods of modern legal research.", "next": "But that he has convincingly demonstrated them is more than doubtful.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.755, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261465:3", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261465", "s": "But that he has convincingly demonstrated them is more than doubtful.", "prev": "The plausibility of his conclusions may be granted.", "next": "That, however, is due not to anything which characterizes the author's own reasoning, but to the vicious method which he shares with more than one German Romanist, of great and little degree.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.762, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262287:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262287", "s": "Book Reviews 91 complete and convincing refutation of the attacks made on Caesar's trust- worthiness.", "prev": "Otto Sumpff,\" etc.", "next": "Here the author is at his best, especially in his discussion of the views of Ferrero, whom he dismisses with a triumphant \" It is dangerous to mate skepticism with imagination; for the offspring thereof will be illegitimate fiction.\" The articles in the geographical index have been subjected to a thorough revision, especial attention being given to the spelUng of proper names.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.537, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262293:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262293", "s": "The fact that we have such convincing evidence of divine honors paid to historical characters warrants the assumption that a similar thing took place at an earlier age.", "prev": "Paul does not prove that he was once a god.", "next": "How flat the promise of Calypso to make Odysseus divine, if the hearers of the poem had already regarded him as a god!", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.88, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262294:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262294", "s": "The fact that we have such convincing evidence of divine honors paid to historical characters warrants the assumption that a similar thing took place at an earlier age.", "prev": "Paul does not prove that he was once a god.", "next": "How flat the promise of Calypso to make Odysseus divine, if the hearers of the poem had already regarded him as a god!", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.392, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262297:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262297", "s": "This book is an important and timely contribution to Roman consti- tutional history, and its arguments must be reckoned with even though they do not in every instance carry conviction.", "prev": "Pp. 142.", "next": "In the first chapter the author derives the Roman aedileship from Tusculum on the basis of Eph.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.859, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262297:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262297", "s": "His argument on this point seems to me convincing and of some importance.", "prev": "The third chapter concludes from Oscan inscriptions that the early Italic censorship coincided with the regular duoviral magistracy of every quinquennium, i.e., that the quinquennalitas was the original censorial magis- tracy of Italy and that the separate censorship of Rome was therefore a new^ invention.", "next": "In chap, iv the author infers that the quattuorvirate of the i This fact first recorded by Taylor (Cults of Ostia, 1912, p. 18) has now been reiterated by Kornemann (Klio, 1914, p. 194) in a review of Rosenberg.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.971, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262298:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262298", "s": "This book is an important and timely contribution to Roman consti- tutional history, and its arguments must be reckoned with even though they do not in every instance carry conviction.", "prev": "Pp. 142.", "next": "In the first chapter the author derives the Roman aedileship from Tusculum on the basis of Eph.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.394, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262298:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262298", "s": "His argument on this point seems to me convincing and of some importance.", "prev": "The third chapter concludes from Oscan inscriptions that the early ItaUc censorship coincided with the regular duoviral magistracy of every quinquennium, i.e., that the quinquennalitas was the original censorial magis- tracy of Italy and that the separate censorship of Rome was therefore a nevi: invention.", "next": "In chap, iv the author infers that the quattuonirate of the 1 This fact first recorded by Taylor (Cults of Ostia, 1912, p. 18) has now been reiterated by Kornemann (Klio, 1914, p. 194) in a review of Rosenberg.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.552, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261773:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261773", "s": "In advan- cing his views Verrall was so keen, so original, and so daring that Euripidean scholarship was alarmed and offended, rather than convinced.", "prev": "When Euripides is charged with being unworthy of a place beside Aeschylus and Sophocles, it is not Euripidean art that is at fault, but the critic.", "next": "\"Splendid Emendax\" was the witty sobriquet his treatment of the text called forth, and his critical work in general was sometimes spoken of as \"brilliant, but wrong- headed.\" Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.534, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261776:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261776", "s": "Clark's criticism of Hort (p. 55) is deserved and timely, and the emphasis he has thrown on the possibility of omissions in the early MSS cannot fail to be helpful to New Testament scholars; but any such wholesale acceptance or rejection of doubtful passages can never be convincing.", "prev": "The logical result of such a study would be to accept the longest text as original, an assumption certainly not more unreasonable than Hort's preference for the shorter text; but the truth probably lies between the two.", "next": "A similar study of the text of the Acts with equally startling discoveries is given in chaps, xi and xii, while in chap, xiii results are summarized and new and even sharper criticisms given of the adoption and defense of the \"Shorter Text\" by Hort and his school.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.815, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261777:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261777", "s": "Clark's criticism of Hort (p. 55) is deserved and timely, and the emphasis he has thrown on the possibility of omissions in the early MSS cannot fail to be helpful to New Testament scholars; but any such wholesale acceptance or rejection of doubtful passages can never be convincing.", "prev": "The logical result of such a study would be to accept the longest text as original, an assumption certainly not more unreasonable than Hort's preference for the shorter text; but the truth probably lies between the two.", "next": "A similar study of the text of the Acts with equally startling discoveries is given in chaps, xi and xii, while in chap, xiii results are summarized and new and even sharper criticisms given of the adoption and defense of the \"Shorter Text\" by Hort and his school.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.396, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261779:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261779", "s": "Of the some half-dozen plausible emendations proposed by Mrs.", "prev": "Isoc. i. 29 and the phrase <rireipmv eis axdpurra.", "next": "Wright Koivbv for Kaivov in 240B seems to me certain.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.702, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261780:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261780", "s": "Of the some half-dozen plausible emendations proposed by Mrs.", "prev": "Isoc. i. 29 and the phrase <rireipmv eis axdpurra.", "next": "Wright Koivbv for Kaivov in 240B seems to me certain.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.278, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261376:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261376", "s": "The arguments advanced in support of attempts to be more accurate are not convincing.", "prev": "It is pretty generally agreed that the date lies somewhere between 430 and 424.", "next": "The assumption that no writer would have enumerated among the advantages of sea power the ability to seize olktt) Ttpoi-^ovcra rj vf)ox>s rrpoKu/xevri rj crrevojropdv ti (ii. 14) before the capture of Pylos implies a very poor opinion of the intelligence of people who for two generations had been the predominant sea power in the Mediterranean.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.663, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261377:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261377", "s": "In the first half of the first volume, Professor von Arnim applies this plausible method to the so-called minor or earlier dialogues with great acu- men and, in the main, resisting the temptation to strain the evidence in favor of his thesis.", "prev": "And con- versely, if we can show that the full understanding of one dialogue presup- poses acquaintance with another, we may fairly presume that they were published in the sequence that would make them intelligible.", "next": "The Protagoras (presumably the earliest dialogue) precedes the Laches because Nicias in the Laches proposes as well-known Socratic doctrine a definition of courage elaborated as something new and unfamiliar in the Protagoras.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.367, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261377:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261377", "s": "The earlier and independent publication of the first book of the Republic is confirmed by the fuller and more convincing development of some of its ideas in the Gorgias.", "prev": "The assumption in the Charmides that oiKeta is an accepted synonym of aya&i would commend itself only to a reader who knew the Lysis.", "next": "It follows the Laches and the Protagoras, since it takes as a matter of course the parallelism of rixvri and dperrj which they work out.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.448, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261393:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261393", "s": "Helm destroys the effect by inserting non; the MS reading is more to the point: \"this fellow, alive to be sure, and only dead asleep, etc.\" But more attractive, perhaps, is the suggestion of Miss Braunlich, which I hope she will soon make quite convincing, that tantum .... quod .... nuncu- patur is a significant example of tantum quod introducing a clause of result: \"so dead asleep that he is called by the same name as I.\" P. 65/21-22: the new edition wisely removes Leo's < saevis > , but I have always suspected the true reading to be (insanisy in [insani] modum Aiacis.", "prev": "A guard, dead aslee'p, is watching a dead body; certain witches exert their spells crying \"surge, mortue\"; the guard, being dead asleep, unwittingly responds to the call instead of the corpse.", "next": "Henkt W.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.309, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261393:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261393", "s": "Here the writer makes his point quite clear, but in some of the examples cited he is less convincing.", "prev": "One feels that with him the description is what is of prime importance, whereas in previous poets it was merely a setting for the narrative.\" The mode adopted by Statius became the fashion for later poets like Sidonius Apollinaris and Claudian.", "next": "In the second chapter there is a brief discussion of some passages cited by Legras, in Jiltude sur la Thebaide de Stace, viz., iv. 40 ff.; vi. 416 ff.; vi. 678 ff.; vi. 834-69.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.633, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261393:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261393", "s": "The discussion, in connection with the Theseus myth, of septena corpora (shown to mean seven, not fourteen), is thorough and convincing, and the remarks made upon the so-called magic number three are very interesting.", "prev": "Some of the most important of these are the myth of Hercules and Cacus (Aen. viii. 185), the Theseus myth (Aen. vi. 20), the ship-race (Aen. v. 115), the description of the Pan-pipe (Eel. ii. 36), and the boy's age (Eel. viii. 37).", "next": "We are inclined to wonder, however, whether the common use of three, while unquestionably characteristic of magic rites, is not much more general in its range, going back perhaps to the limitations of the primitive mind in counting.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.945, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261394:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261394", "s": "The discussion, in connection with the Theseus myth, of septena corpora (shown to mean seven, not fourteen), is thorough and convincing, and the remarks made upon the so-called magic number three are very interesting.", "prev": "Some of the most important of these are the myth of Hercules and Cacus (Aen. viii. 185), the Theseus myth (Aen. vi. 20), the ship-race (Aen. v. 115), the description of the Pan-pipe (Eel. ii. 36), and the boy's age (Eel. viii. 37).", "next": "We are inclined to wonder, however, whether the common use of three, while unquestionably characteristic of magic rites, is not much more general in its range, going back perhaps to the limitations of the primitive mind in counting.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.52, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261644:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261644", "s": "I am not convinced by Roscher's view (pp. 51 f., 75, n. 136) that the ©-like object, a dot or boss within a circle, shown on the gable of Apollo-temples, is an omphalos in orbe terrarum.", "prev": "In minor matters, this admirable work leaves little to criticize.", "next": "It seems better to regard it as a <j>iakri d/u.<£a- \\u>TTJ, a vessel which appears to have a special and significant connection with the mantic god.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.662, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261646:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261646", "s": "I must abstain from any lengthy quotations, but the student will find a convincing solution of many troublesome passages and many vigorous phrasings of favorite odes.", "prev": "The only difficulty not solved in some way is peritus Hiber (2. 20. 19).", "next": "Every reader will of course discover occasional lapses.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.416, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261652:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261652", "s": "They are of course much more plausible in the case of a late and less significant writer such as Nemesios.", "prev": "These postulates make wild work in the study of Cicero's, Plutarch's, and Philo's relations to their sources.", "next": "But even here, I think, their systematic and uncompromising application may mislead.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.829, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261995:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261995", "s": "Norden's ready optimism as regards his own hypotheses is contagious, but I have not always yielded to the persuasion of his style.", "prev": "Accordingly, Ennius, book vii, contains an exordium, a brief history of Carthage, a description of Rome's first fleet, the quarrel with Carthage over Sardinia, the Gallic wars of 225-222, and the beginning of the Second Punic War.", "next": "For instance, I am not convinced that the line \"dum censent terrere minis\" (256) must necessarily refer to Gauls simply because these people are said to gesticulate at times.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.789, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261995:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261995", "s": "For instance, I am not convinced that the line \"dum censent terrere minis\" (256) must necessarily refer to Gauls simply because these people are said to gesticulate at times.", "prev": "Norden's ready optimism as regards his own hypotheses is contagious, but I have not always yielded to the persuasion of his style.", "next": "On \"Geminae Belli portae, sic nomine dicunt\" (Aen. vii. 607) he affirms: \" Wer hat die Jani portae so benannt ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.808, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261996:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261996", "s": "Norden's ready optimism as regards his own hypotheses is contagious, but I have not always yielded to the persuasion of his style.", "prev": "Accordingly, Ennius, book vii, contains an exordium, a brief history of Carthage, a description of Rome's first fleet, the quarrel with Carthage over Sardinia, the Gallic wars of 225-222, and the beginning of the Second Pimic War.", "next": "For instance, I am not convinced that the line \"dum censent terrere minis\" (256) must necessarily refer to Gauls simply because these people are said to gesticulate at times.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.395, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261996:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261996", "s": "For instance, I am not convinced that the line \"dum censent terrere minis\" (256) must necessarily refer to Gauls simply because these people are said to gesticulate at times.", "prev": "Norden's ready optimism as regards his own hypotheses is contagious, but I have not always yielded to the persuasion of his style.", "next": "On \"Geminae Belli portae, sic nomine dicunt\" (Aen. vii. 607) he affirms: \" Wer hat die Jani portae so benannt ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.415, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262001:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262001", "s": "In the latter, however, and in most of his other propositions based on Greek, he is less convincing.", "prev": "Similarly he sees in Petr. 132. 2 f., catorogare, the meaning \"to give a beating\" from Karopyav.", "next": "In Petr. 62. 3, \"apoculamus nos\" (cf. 67. 3), he rejects the derivations from awoKakem as well as that from airoKv\\(o> and sees in it a hybrid form dw-oculare, \"to withdraw from sight,\" comparing Plaut.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.621, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262001:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262001", "s": "Likewise in his discussion of Latin words he is most convincing when he is most simple.", "prev": "Trin. 989, \"ab oculis abire,\" and Livy xxv. 16. 2, \"ex oculis abire,\" and seems to prove his point.", "next": "In Petr. 30. 1, \"non licebat multaciam considerare,\" multaciam is a anra$ dpqiicvov, meaning \"die Mannigfaltigkeit\" or \"die mannigfaltigen Dinge.\" To his explanation of Apuleius Metamm. ii. 2, p. 26, 2H, execrabiliter, he might have added the English \"d - - d.\" In Petr. 52. 7, \"excipimus urbanitatem iocantis,\" where some postulate a lacuna and supply some expression like plausu nos, this is unnece", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.678, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262002:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262002", "s": "In the latter, however, and in most of his other propositions based on Greek, he is less convincing.", "prev": "Similarly he sees in Petr. 132. 2 f., catwogare, the meaning \"to give a beating\" from Karopyav.", "next": "In Petr. 62. 3, \"apoculamus nos\" (cf. 67. 3), he rejects the derivations from d7roKaA.ea> as well as that from aTTOKvXim and sees in it a hybrid form dw-oculare, \"to withdraw from sight,\" comparing Plaut.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.143, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262002:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262002", "s": "Likewise in his discussion of Latin words he is most convincing when he is most simple.", "prev": "Trin. 989, \"ab ocuUs abire,\" and Livy xxv. 16. 2, \"ex oculis abire,\" and seems to prove his point.", "next": "In Petr. 30. 1, \"non licebat multaciam considerare,\" multaciam is a aTro^ dprjixivov, meaning \"die Mannigfaltigkeit\" or \"die mannigfaltigen Dinge.\" To his explanation of Apuleius Metamm. ii. 2, p. 26, 211, execrabiliter, he might have added the English \"d - - d.\" In Petr. 52. 7, \"excipimus urbanitatem iocantis,\" where some postulate a lacuna and supply some expression Uke plausu nos, this is unnec", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.183, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262512:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262512", "s": "But the commonplace parallels of detail are not so convincing as the case taken as a whole.", "prev": "Granting that it is only the salient features of the Empedoclean system, not its details, that suggested the trend of Aristophanes' speech, one is disposed to agree that there may be a real relation between the two, and the author's service in so carefully investigating all possible points of contact between them is highly to be commended.", "next": "Turning to mythology, and especially to the Orphic cosmogonic myths, the author finds here the source of many of the details of the Aristophanic story.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.6, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262512:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262512", "s": "Professor Ziegler's arguments are all interesting and suggestive, some of them convincing; but to secure the complete concurrence of scholarly opinion throughout the complexities of so involved a subject, calling often for conjectural explanation, would be well-nigh impossible.", "prev": "This of course is only a con- jecture, and an argument might be made against its necessity; granting that the material Plato uses is not original but even very old, must we assume that Plato was not capable of himself mingling in one context for comic effect the ideas of many men — the more incongruous the better?", "next": "The use of fragmentary text material, over-ready assumption of the existence of real literary parallels, and the nice distinction between actual sources and the far less tangible ancestry of those ideas which filter down from age to age and finally become incorporated in literature — all these have their perils for the investigator.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.825, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262513:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262513", "s": "Professor Ziegler's arguments are all interesting and suggestive, some of them convincing; but to secure the complete concurrence of scholarly opinion throughout the complexities of so involved a subject, calling often for conjectural explanation, would be well-nigh impossible.", "prev": "This of course is only a con- jecture, and an argument might be made against its necessity; granting that the material Plato uses is not original but even very old, must we assume that Plato was not capable of himself mingling in one context for comic effect the ideas of many men — ^the more incongruous the better?", "next": "The use of fragmentary text material, over-ready assumption of the existence of real literary parallels, and the nice distinction between actual sources and the far less tangible ancestry of those ideas which filter down from age to age and finally become incorporated in Uterature — all these have their perils for the investigator.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.229, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262516:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262516", "s": "Among minor points of interest might be noted Vollmer's acceptance of the name Baebius Italicus for the author, as given in the late Vindob. 3509, together with convincing arguments for its correctness (pp. 16, 142 f .) ; the suggestion that the mediaeval ascription to Pindarus is due solely to a mis- understanding of Bishop Benzo's Pindarus sen Homerus, by which really the Greek authors were meant (p. 143, nn. 1 and 2) ; and that the well-known vss. 900 f . point rather to the period of the Flavian emperors than to that of the Claudian.", "prev": "Book Reviews 229 would be hard to find a critical commentary better adapted as a model for philological exercises in a pro-seminar, where it would furnish an excellent addition and supplement to Lindsay's brilliant Introduction.", "next": "An interesting separate report upon the early printed editions, from 1477 to 1541, has been made by the skilled hand of Dr.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.207, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262519:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262519", "s": "The cognomen Nauta, for example, is certainly not \"demonstrably absurd\" because \"Propertius expresses the liveliest terror of the sea in his poems.\" Indeed, no convincing argument has ever been brought forward against the manuscript authority on this point, and of recent years scholars have even shown a disposition to retain Aurelius, which Professor Butler rejects for the traditional reasons; cf.", "prev": "In the Introduction there are a great many errors of fact and some expressions of opinion with which few students of Propertius will agree.", "next": "Marx {Lucilius, II, 198), \"librarios Aureli nomen temere addidisse Propertio in codicibus nondum demonstratum est : immo commendat poetae nomen duplex Aurelii Opilii grammatici ratio.\" The text seems to be a slightly revised version of that contained in Pro- fessor Butler's complete edition of 1905, which was based upon the work of", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.927, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262520:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262520", "s": "The cognomen Nauta, for example, is certainly not \"demonstrably absurd\" because \"Propertius expresses the liveliest terror of the sea in his poems.\" Indeed, no convincing argument has ever been brought forward against the manuscript authority on this point, and of recent years scholars have even shown a disposition to retain Aurelius, which Professor Butler rejects for the traditional reasons; cf.", "prev": "In the Introduction there are a great many errors of fact and some expressions of opinion with which few students of Propertius will agree.", "next": "Marx {Ludlius, II, 198), \"Ubrarios AureU nomen temere addidisse Propertio in codicibus nondum demonstratum est : immo commendat poetae nomen duplex Aurelii Opilii grammatici ratio.\" The text seems to be a slightly revised version of that contained in Pro- fessor Butler's complete edition of 1905, which was based upon the work of Book Reviews 237 Baehrens, Postgate, and Phillimore.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.322, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261867:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261867", "s": "From the blind and persistent tendency in the evolution of Greek archaic art and from the supreme achieve- ments of its classic period, we are persuaded to induce the universal — that all truly artistic production results from the adaptation of the idea to the limitations of the material.", "prev": "He shows them in the inchoate and experimental stages of their marble sculpture admitting helplessly into it technical devices proper to the manipu- lation of other materials, of wood, bronze, or clay — until its own nature was intimately comprehended and overcome.", "next": "More than that, the material with its limi- tations, with its immanent suggestions of form dimly outlines the idea destined to speak through it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.556, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261871:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261871", "s": "As the writer points out, the resemblance between these two fragments \"is certainly striking,\" and it seems to me that the argu- ment, so far, is plausible.", "prev": "Proceeding from this Alexander concludes that the Meles of Frg. 24, whom Moxus rrjs TvpawiSos *a0«Ae, is the same as the King Meles of Frg. 49, who withdrew from the kingdom for three years KaOrjpao-dai rbv <j>6vov (Aolo-kvXov).", "next": "Less convincing is the conclusion that Meles was not one of the regular line of kings, but a usurper during the reign of King Ardys I.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.805, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261871:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261871", "s": "Less convincing is the conclusion that Meles was not one of the regular line of kings, but a usurper during the reign of King Ardys I.", "prev": "As the writer points out, the resemblance between these two fragments \"is certainly striking,\" and it seems to me that the argu- ment, so far, is plausible.", "next": "This view seems to be based almost entirely upon the word TvoavviBos in Frg. 24, a dangerous inference, for in Herodotus 1. 14, 15 we find such phrases as ttjv TvpawiSa ovt<o io~)(pv ol Mtp/wdSai, Tvyrj?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.828, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261872:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261872", "s": "As the writer points out, the resemblance between these two fragments \"is certainly striking,\" and it seems to me that the argu- ment, so far, is plausible.", "prev": "Proceeding from this Alexander concludes that the Meles of Frg. 24, whom Moxus rrjs TvpawiSos *a0«Ae, is the same as the King Meles of Frg. 49, who withdrew from the kingdom for three years KaOrjpao-dai rbv <j>6vov (Aolo-kvXov).", "next": "Less convincing is the conclusion that Meles was not one of the regular line of kings, but a usurper during the reign of King Ardys I.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.403, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261872:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261872", "s": "Less convincing is the conclusion that Meles was not one of the regular line of kings, but a usurper during the reign of King Ardys I.", "prev": "As the writer points out, the resemblance between these two fragments \"is certainly striking,\" and it seems to me that the argu- ment, so far, is plausible.", "next": "This view seems to be based almost entirely upon the word TvoavviBos in Frg. 24, a dangerous inference, for in Herodotus 1. 14, 15 we find such phrases as ttjv TvpawiSa ovt<o io~)(pv ol Mtp/wdSai, Tvyrj?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.426, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-261877:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-261877", "s": "The chapter on Valerius is much longer than in I, and contains an able and convincing discussion of his use of rhetorical art for the purpose of confounding Claudius Quadrigarius and the Claudii in general.", "prev": "A noteworthy addition to the chapter on Claudius Quadrigarius is the argument (pp. cclxxxvii-cclxxxix) to prove that Claudius began his annals with the Gallic invasion in order to rehabilitate the Claudii and to plead their cause against the Fabii, in the same way that Valerius Antias (p. cccxiv) began his at an earlier date in order to extol the Valerii at the expense of the Claudii.", "next": "On p. cccxxxvi Niese is incorrectly quoted among those who believe that Sisenna was born in 151 b.c.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.767, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262490:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262490", "s": "While Gronau is able to show the presence in Basil and Gregory of scien- tific ideas which are attested as Posidonius' or which may be plausibly attributed to him, and of commonplaces to which he may well have given expression, but of which he was clearly not the originator, he fails utterly, in my opinion, to prove the use of a single Posidonian source.", "prev": "Then by pointing out reminiscences of the Timaeus or by showing, often with the aid of Chalcidius, that the subject falls within the range of a commentary on the Timaeus, he attempts to prove that the source is Posidonius' commentary.", "next": "We know very little about Posidonius' commentary on the Timaeus; there are but few references to it in antiquity.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.864, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262491:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262491", "s": "While Gronau is able to show the presence in Basil and Gregory of scien- tific ideas which are attested as Posidonius' or which may be plausibly attributed to him, and of commonplaces to which he may well have given expression, but of which he was clearly not the originator, he fails utterly, in my opinion, to prove the use of a single Posidonian source.", "prev": "Then by pointing out reminiscences of the Timaeus or by showing, often with the aid of Chalcidius, that the subject falls within the range of a commentary on the Timaeus, he attempts to prove that the source is Posidonius' commentary.", "next": "We know very little about Posidonius' commentary on the Timaeus; there are but few references to it in antiquity.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.193, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262491:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262491", "s": "While the parallels between Cicero and Gregory cannot be denied, I am not convinced by the arguments of Schmekel and Corssen that the Posidonian elements in the first book of the Tusculans are as great as they think.", "prev": "He thinks that all references to the im- materiality of the soul were added by Gregory himself.", "next": "For example, it seems to me improbable that Tusc. i. 66 and 70, both of which passages Gronau cites as parallel to Gregory, are Posidonian.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.693, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262492:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262492", "s": "In the Periceiromene Sudhaus has plausibly restored many passages and added to the understanding of the play.", "prev": "Q 1 ) , still clung stubbornly to his notion that Sophrona is the mother of Pamphila, although Sophrona has long since been accepted (as, e.g., in Terence's usage) as a standing name for a nurse, the r61e, moreover, that best suits the character in the closing scenes of this play.", "next": "In this particular play the tempta- tions are great to fill out the lacunae and to build up the interpretation on the supplements.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.733, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262492:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262492", "s": "That some of his supplements are ingenious, without being convincing, would not evoke criticism if the editor (or editors) had been more uniformly careful (as, for example, on the text of the Leipzig fragment) 1 Had he lived to complete the revision, probably U 1-2 would have been differently- placed.", "prev": "In this particular play the tempta- tions are great to fill out the lacunae and to build up the interpretation on the supplements.", "next": "For argument to disprove Robert's combinations of U 1-2 , Q 2_1 , Bl -1 see AUinson, AJP, No. 142, pp. 185-202.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.751, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262493:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262493", "s": "Nichols, and he expressly disclaims any credit for them (p. 1), seeking merely to accumulate the convincing evidence for them.", "prev": "These propositions are not original with Dr.", "next": "In this he has succeded.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.758, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262493:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262493", "s": "This is hardly susceptible of proof, but the presentation is clear and convincing.", "prev": "For Schroeder holds that the famous story is a primitive folk-tale, somewhat disguised by its Alexandrian dress and satiric embellish- ments, but still a folk-tale, and one that had its origin, not in any myth of the gods, but in the universal dreams that result from repressed desires of sex.", "next": "The reprinting of the text that follows is hardly justified by the few notes, or rather references to the argument, that accompany it.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.905, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262494:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262494", "s": "Nichols, and he expressly disclaims any credit for them (p. 1), seeking merely to accumulate the convincing evidence for them.", "prev": "These propositions are not original with Dr.", "next": "In this he has succeded.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.382, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262494:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262494", "s": "This is hardly susceptible of proof, but the presentation is clear and convincing.", "prev": "For Schroeder holds that the famous story is a primitive folk-tale, somewhat disguised by its Alexandrian dress and satiric embellish- ments, but still a folk-tale, and one that had its origin, not in any myth of the gods, but in the universal dreams that result from repressed desires of sex.", "next": "The reprinting of the text that follows is hardly justified by the few notes, or rather references to the argument, that accompany it.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.758, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262495:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262495", "s": "His book may commend itself to Professor Ferguson's \"hypothetical general reader.\" Students, however, will be convinced by a very cursory inspection that this work is without scientific value.", "prev": "It cannot be denied that he has occasional flashes of insight, and that his pages sometimes afford rather interesting reading.", "next": "William D.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.946, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263352:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263352", "s": "For the earlier Stoics, Cleanthes and Chry- sippus, the evidence quoted by the author is not convincing.", "prev": "Emp. ix. 78 f.).", "next": "We read in Euseb.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.727, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263353:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263353", "s": "I do not find his arguments in defense of his theory of the ten tribes convincing.", "prev": "The author makes out a good case for his Cylon theory.", "next": "If Cleisthenes, he says, saw that it was desirable to break up the old clans, Peisistratus must have seen it before him (cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.598, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262748:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262748", "s": "The instances of repetition of category on pp. 53 f. and 78 f. are much more convincing. 446 Book Reviews The book is excellently prepared with few typographical errors.", "prev": "Rather it is the parallelism due to repetition of the ablative that serves as a unifying element here.", "next": "On p. 38, 1. 25, utatuur occurs for utatur; on p. 168, 1. 6, cognosite for cognoscite.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.786, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262749:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262749", "s": "This hope, it appears, was doomed to disappointment; for neither is it due to the pen of Galen, as a study of Hardy's extracts long ago convinced me, nor does its unknown author contribute anything of importance, either to Hippocrates or to the solution of the problems raised by Roscher.", "prev": "Roscher regarding the date of the earlier parts of Hippocrates, irtpl ift&o/jASmv, scholars may have hoped to derive some light on that treatise from this commentary.", "next": "The value of the treatise, if it prove to possess any, will presumably be found to lie in the light it may some day shed on the later history of Greek medicine and on the devious ways of commentators.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.842, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262750:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262750", "s": "This hope, it appears, was doomed to disappointment; for neither is it due to the pen of Galen, as a study of Hardy's extracts long ago convinced me, nor does its unknown author contribute anything of importance, either to Hippocrates or to the solution of the problems raised by Roscher.", "prev": "Roscher regarding the date of the earlier parts of Hippocrates, irtpl ift&o/jASmv, scholars may have hoped to derive some light on that treatise from this commentary.", "next": "The value of the treatise, if it prove to possess any, will presumably be found to lie in the light it may some day shed on the later history of Greek medicine and on the devious ways of commentators.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.582, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263757:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263757", "s": "On the basis of this evidence the plots were reconstructed with remarkable acuteness; and the results, though necessarily often conjectural, can be checked, even where they fail to convince, by the openly displayed material of the sources quoted.\" While taking account, however, of all the material collected by Welcker and Nauck and the more adventurous Hartung, Mr.", "prev": "He had spared no exertion in sifting the whole of the data provided by the mythographical authorities, and in comparing them with the relevant indications of the tragic fragments.", "next": "Pearson is not dependent upon them.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.252, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263757:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263757", "s": "Pal. 7. 49, v/yvurt rav Bvarav vaparos loropiav, \"destroyed the inscription which described Euripides as mortal.\" But the first two lines of the epigram distinctly say that Euripides himself was killed by the lightning stroke, and something like Bury's amparoi appMvtav is the more plausible reading. 96 Book Reviews 181 : dx/oaos &v is PpSxriv aXkovs i£epivdt,us \\6yw.", "prev": "Pearson refers to Headlam (Classical Review, XVI, 438), on Anth.", "next": "It is true that Athenaeus in Eustathius says impoifuaxov 8k avro to vor/pa ofioiov T<3 dircu'8evros <Sv wSs av tTtpous muSevcraas.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.384, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263758:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263758", "s": "But the reader becomes more convinced of these things and more regretful when he has discovered how ably and how successfully the author has handled his proper theme.", "prev": "The essential lack of unity in the book and the inappropriateness of the title should be apparent from the chapter-headings in the Table of Contents when the book is first opened.", "next": "One could hardly send a student to a better brief exposition of the Hellenic and pagan elements in Christian theology and of the sources of these elements in Hellenic and post-Hellenic philosophy.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.925, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263759:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263759", "s": "But the reader becomes more convinced of these things and more regretful when he has discovered how ably and how successfully the author has handled his proper theme.", "prev": "The essential lack of unity in the book and the inappropriateness of the title should be apparent from the chapter-headings in the Table of Contents when the book is first opened.", "next": "One could hardly send a student to a better brief exposition of the Hellenic and pagan elements in Christian theology and of the sources of these elements in Hellenic and post-Hellenic philosophy.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.42, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263761:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263761", "s": "The author is convinced (pp. 42-46) that the adamas of the ancients was actually the diamond, but concludes that ancient gem- workers did not understand the process of cutting and polishing diamonds to add to their luster (pp. 46-50).", "prev": "There are two further points of interest in this study for the classicist and archaeologist.", "next": "The study contains other information which will be attractive chiefly to Sinologists and to those interested in the history of the diamond.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.922, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263762:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263762", "s": "The author is convinced (pp. 42-46) that the adamas of the ancients was actually the diamond, but concludes that ancient gem- workers did not understand the process of cutting and polishing diamonds to add to their luster (pp. 46-50).", "prev": "There are two further points of interest in this study for the classicist and archaeologist.", "next": "The study contains other information which will be attractive chiefly to Sinologists and to those interested in the history of the diamond.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.802, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263125:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263125", "s": "Refusal to be influenced by it would be refusal to listen to the most convincing of all witnesses, life itself.", "prev": "Any teacher or friend of the classics who wishes to make a wholesome impression upon hostile or unsympathetic colleague, principal, president, trustee, school board, investigator, editor, taxpayer, or doubting student, or who is himself in need of the foundations of faith, will find the book a ready means.", "next": "Somehow this achievement of Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.462, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263264:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263264", "s": "In a review of Pfeiffer's Studien zum antiken Sternglavben (Classical Philology [July, 1917] pp. 316 ff.) the present reviewer endeavored to show that the evidence for the acceptance of astrology by the Stoics is neither convincing nor positive and that the cosmic theories of Plato and Aristotle precluded a belief in astrology.", "prev": "Pro- fessor D'Alton in the historical study of astrology follows Cumont and other modern scholars in ascribing anticipations of astrology to the Pythagorean Plato and Aristotle and in the hypothesis of a fusion of Stoicism and astrology.", "next": "The reference cited by the author (Cic. de nat. deorum ii. 15. 39) proves only that the Stoics believed that the stars shared in the divinity of the universe.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.862, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263265:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263265", "s": "In a review of Pfeiffer's Studien zum antiken Sternglavben (Classical Philology [July, 1917] pp. 316 ff.) the present reviewer endeavored to show that the evidence for the acceptance of astrology by the Stoics is neither convincing nor positive and that the cosmic theories of Plato and Aristotle precluded a belief in astrology.", "prev": "Pro- fessor D'Alton in the historical study of astrology follows Cumont and other modern scholars in ascribing anticipations of astrology to the Pythagorean Plato and Aristotle and in the hypothesis of a fusion of Stoicism and astrology.", "next": "The reference cited by the author (Cic. de nat. deorum ii. 15. 39) proves only that the Stoics believed that the stars shared in the divinity of the universe.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.267, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263085:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263085", "s": "Its statements are clear, its arguments cogent, and its conclusions sane.", "prev": "Like all of the author's numerous articles previously pub- lished, it is written in a pleasing and forceful style, and gives evidence of sound scholarship and of a firm grasp upon the problems with which it deals.", "next": "More- over, it abounds in literary citations and is enriched with many illustrations which for the most part are well selected and beautifully reproduced.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.107, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263085:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263085", "s": "The discussion of the use of masks (pp. 221 ff.) does not at all points carry conviction.", "prev": "No hint is given that the Rieti statuette (Fig. 66) represents an actor of a late period, and the failure to reproduce or even to mention the charming actor-relief from the Peiraeus is regrettable.", "next": "This is particularly true of the thesis that \"the dramatists sometimes try to explain the immobility of the actor's mask,\" as in Sophocles' Electra.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.649, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263086:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263086", "s": "A plausible explanation of the strange jargon which he makes of Boethius' Greek quotations would be the hypothesis that he con- sulted some Cyprian Barlaam who, himself unable to translate the classical Greek, substituted for it edifying short sentences of his own which Pierre took down by ear, together with his guide's translation of them.", "prev": "Professor Thomas does not attempt to write an exhaustive monograph on the sources and psychology of Pierre's blunders.", "next": "A specialist in mediaeval philosophy could perhaps discover the sources of the singular disquisition on time in Pierre's prologue.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.749, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262937:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262937", "s": "Hamberger's at- tempt to prove that Korax was the founder of a school and that Teisias was his pupil, is not convincing.", "prev": "Korax, according to Aristotle, prescribed seven divisions for a speech: npooifuov, rrpoKaTao-Kevr}, TTpOKa.Ta<rTa<rvi, Ka.TaxTTa<TVi, ayutvei, jrap€K0«ris, ejnAoyos.", "next": "Part II: Thrasymachus, Gorgias, Theodorus, Licymnius, and Evenus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.838, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262938:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262938", "s": "Hamberger's at- tempt to prove that Korax was the founder of a school and that Teisias was his pupil, is not convincing.", "prev": "Korax, according to Aristotle, prescribed seven divisions for a speech: npooifuov, rrpoKaTao-Kevr}, TTpOKa.Ta<rTa<rvi, Ka.TaxTTa<TVi, ayutvei, jrap€K0«ris, ejnAoyos.", "next": "Part II: Thrasymachus, Gorgias, Theodorus, Licymnius, and Evenus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.728, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263552:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263552", "s": "The ultimately great historian will so suffuse his painfully sought knowledge with the vivifying power of his artistic imagination that the past is brought compellingly, or even irre- sistibly, into the general active interest of our life and thought.", "prev": "If we may refer once more to a great contemporary and compatriot of our author, we may recall Croce's doctrine that there is not an essential difference in kind between the intuitive Book Reviews 101 imagination of the student and of the artist.", "next": "In this way is achieved the historian's lofty ambition worded so unforgettably by Thucydides.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.718, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263553:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263553", "s": "The ultimately great historian will so suffuse his painfully sought knowledge with the vivifying power of his artistic imagination that the past is brought compellingly, or even irre- sistibly, into the general active interest of our life and thought.", "prev": "Book Reviews 101 imagination of the student and of the artist.", "next": "In this way is achieved the historian's lofty ambition worded so unforgettably by Thucydides.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.183, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262803:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262803", "s": "Several new and convincing interpretations offered in the Introduction are so clearly put that one wonders how scholars failed to see the truth before.", "prev": "It is this which causes his often intolerant contempt for inaccuracy on the part of the author whose work he expounds and on the part of modern interpreters.", "next": "The commentary is in a way a return to eighteenth-century methods, in that it combines critical apparatus with interpretative material, all in Latin, though the Introduction is in English.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.767, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262804:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262804", "s": "Several new and convincing interpretations offered in the Introduction are so clearly put that one wonders how scholars failed to see the truth before.", "prev": "It is this which causes his often intolerant contempt for inaccuracy on the part of the author whose work he expounds and on the part of modern interpreters.", "next": "The commentary is in a way a return to eighteenth-century methods, in that it combines critical apparatus with interpretative material, all in Latin, though the Introduction is in English.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.36, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263306:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263306", "s": "In the \"Life of Phocion\" (chap, ii) rj Kal rbv kou/aov 6 0eos Aeyerai SioiKtiv, oi /3ia£o/xevos, aXXa iraddi Kal \\6y<p irapayotv Trjv avdyKrjv is translated by Perrin \"and this is the way, we are told, in which God regulates the universe, not using compulsion, but making persuasion and reason introduce that which must be.\" Plutarch is referring here to Plato's Timaeus 48A, of which passage de procreatione animae 1026B is also a reminiscence: Kal Xoyos dywv iraOoi p.ep.iyixivrjv ava.yK.rjv. avdyKrj is not \"that which must be,\" but the original disposition of matter, which God, in the creation o", "prev": "In the \"Life of Eumenes\" (chap, ix) d7ro/JA.«ro- pevovs must be passive, not middle, \"the cynosure of every eye,\" as Frazer translates it.", "next": "The translation, therefore, should be: \"guid- ing, or overcoming necessity by persuasion and reason.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.582, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263306:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263306", "s": "The translation, therefore, should be: \"guid- ing, or overcoming necessity by persuasion and reason.", "prev": "niverse, not using compulsion, but making persuasion and reason introduce that which must be.\" Plutarch is referring here to Plato's Timaeus 48A, of which passage de procreatione animae 1026B is also a reminiscence: Kal Xoyos dywv iraOoi p.ep.iyixivrjv ava.yK.rjv. avdyKrj is not \"that which must be,\" but the original disposition of matter, which God, in the creation of the world, partly overcomes.", "next": "\" In chapter x wa-rrtp rrj irAcovefta p.6vov irra^Qik Kal Awnjpous ovras, oi)(l /xaXkov, ocroi irpos vfipiv Kal <p$6vov r/ opyrjv t] <piXoveiKiav two, xpfivTai Tip Swaardai, tovtous SeSiorw Kal irpo(3aW.oiAtv<i>v tS>v iroWGtv is translated as if rrj irXeove^ta pAvov went with StSiortov Kal 3rpo/8aAAo//.ci/a>v, whereas it would more naturally go with itraxOm Kal Xuxjjpovs.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.645, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263321:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263321", "s": "The essays, moreover, are good, and it is characteristic of him that in the first of them instead of repeating all the time-worn arguments, so old, so tattered, and so frayed, he selects a single one, the value of the classics for the study of English and the development of an English style, and elaborates it in a way that is at once genial and vigorous, persuasive and effective.", "prev": "But 82 Book Reviews 83 secretaries of associations must have papers for their meetings and Kirby Smith was always ready to help.", "next": "In the \"Humanities in Education,\" among other good points, he draws attention to the character of German education in the period before August, 1914: Now it is safe to say that for more than a generation the most obvious and striking characteristic of German education was that, apart from being highly organized and relentlessly thorough, it has been more exclusively scientific and technical than a", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.602, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263323:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263323", "s": "Plinius et Cluvius), but no one has analyzed the relations of the two authors with such thoroughness and plausibility as Norden.", "prev": "Plinius, Germanicorum bellorum scriptor; ibid. xiii. 20 (55 a.d.) Fabius Rusticus ....", "next": "He has made use of the work of all his predecessors in the field (he pays special tribute to Munzer's monograph Die Quelle des Tacitus fur die Germanenkriege) , and has added substantial contributions of his own.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.533, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263328:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263328", "s": "Some of the author's conclusions are that the Roman conception of magic was essentially the same as ours; that, so far as we can judge from our knowledge of Roman law, religion, science, and literature, belief in magic existed among the Romans from the earliest period and was not imported from Greece or the Orient; and that the attempt of educated Romans to appear superior in such matters does not convince one that they had really shaken off their inherited belief in magical agencies.", "prev": "New York: Columbia University Press.", "next": "While none of these conclusions is new, in no other work known to the reviewer has the evidence been so carefully collected and so wisely judged.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.809, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263143:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263143", "s": "It displays fine taste, a charming style, and a very engaging spirit of frankness and intellectual rectitude quite evident in the opening words of the Preface: \"Ceci est une ceuvre 'de bonne foy.' Je ne cherche ni a etonner ni a contredire, mais seulement a me convaincre et a m'instruire.\" But the author is not unmindful of the serious nature of the task he has undertaken, for he continues: \"Aussi ne dissimulerai- je point que vingt ans de recherches et la pratique de la plupart des langues usitees dans l'antiquit6, de l'Inde a la M&literranee, m'ont amene a une conception de l'histoire ancien", "prev": "The work is done with that refine- ment of literary quality which we have come to expect as a matter of course from a Frenchman of letters.", "next": "Autran's reconstruction of the course of human development from prehistoric times down through the entire pre-Hellenic age and far into Greek times is indeed new and revolutionary.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.065, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263147:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263147", "s": "This woman they equipped in full armour, and put her in a chariot, giving her all such appurtenances as would make the seem- liest show, and so drove into the city; heralds ran before them, and when they came into the town made proclamation as they were charged, bidding the Atheni- ans \"to give a hearty welcome to Pisistratus, whom Athene herself honoured beyond all men and was bringing back to her own citadel.\"' So the heralds went about and spoke thus: immediately it was reported in the demes that Athene was bringing Pisistratus back, and the townsfolk persuaded that the 304 Book Reviews wom", "prev": "There was in the Paeanian deme a woman called Phya, three fingers short of four cubits in stature, and for the rest fair to look upon.", "next": "In the much disputed passage inclosed in parentheses Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.52, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262912:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262912", "s": "The chapter on Lucilius is, from my prejudiced point of view, unsatis- factory, as it does not even mention certain interpretations, which seem to me more than plausible, of passages in the fourth and tenth satires (see T.A.P.A., XLVIII, 111 ff., and Classical Philology, X, 270 ff.), though these articles are mentioned in an introductory footnote.", "prev": "We must agree with Pascal that Horace's attitude toward Plautus, as far as it is expressed, is thoroughly unfavorable.", "next": "Examples are Serm. i. 4.21-22 and i. 10. 11-14.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.647, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262912:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262912", "s": "Pascal's defense of Lucilius is not convincing.", "prev": "Considerable space is given to Lucilius' use of Greek words, which Horace criticizes.", "next": "The rest of the chapter is devoted to Horace's indebtedness to Lucilius.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.719, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-4388224:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-4388224", "s": "Ferrero has very plausibly brought to the fore the political considerations which made such a union desirable.", "prev": "Pro- fessor Breasted repeats Plutarch's story of Antony's infatuation for Cleopatra as determining his action at Alexandria (241).", "next": "One should amend the state- ments on page 253 by stressing the capriciousness rather than the cruelty of Nero's despotism.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.145, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262635:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262635", "s": "Allen, op. cit., 46 ff. — The linguistic argument (pp. 227, 233 f.) is not cogent, for we do not know the form of \"Central Greek\" dialect once spoken in the Argolis.", "prev": "Cauer (p. 231) has failed to detect the weakness of Leaf's attack on Aulis, cf.", "next": "It is at least possible that it would form as good a basis as Thessalian-Boeotian for the \"Aeolisms\" of the epos. — The tp&tov tpevSos in Delia Seta's work (cf. p. 280) is the assumption that 'Ax<uoi is a metrical handicap.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.788, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-262636:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-262636", "s": "In my opinion, this theory, plausible as it is, cannot be accepted in tote.", "prev": "Thus, the proscenium of the fully developed theater was not a later addition or an afterthought but a transformation of the original unit of the structure.", "next": "On a subsequent occasion I hope to propose another sequence of developments which seems to me to explain the known facts somewhat more adequately.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.924, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263479:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263479", "s": "For thirty years' uninterrupted practice of viva voice reading of Pindar and the choruses of tragedy with students has convinced me that the termi- nology which goes beyond the names of the feet and a few of the more promi- nent combinations is not only of no use, but actually multiplies occasions for equivocation and logomachy.", "prev": "But I could not a month ago, and shall not be able to a month from now.", "next": "I have heard Professor Wilamowitz read Greek poetry; in fact he \"scans\" most Greek verses about as I or any other student, who began with Westphal and Christ and the schemes of Jebb's Sophocles and Gildersleeve's Pindar, would read them.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.356, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263481:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263481", "s": "How- ever, the chapter dealing with the difficulty arising from the use of the term Tre/otiroAos is not so successful and is perhaps the least convincing of the whole treatise.", "prev": "In chapter ii of Part I the author is not unsuccessful in taking issue with those who see in Thu- cydides' use of ol vewraroi (ii. 13. 7; 21. 2) a reference to the ephebi.", "next": "Others (Girard, Did. des Antiq., s.v.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.679, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263481:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263481", "s": "Wilamowitz, op. cit., p. 194) does not convince us that there may not have been something much earlier from which the late fourth-century institution developed.", "prev": "Even the suggestion that Plato is responsible for the institution (p. 41;", "next": "No one pretends to doubt that changes came in it in the course of the third century.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.886, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263489:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263489", "s": "This is interesting and plausible enough.", "prev": "It is this earlier Socrates that Aristophanes' Clouds portrays, in caricature to be sure, but on a basis of truth without which the comedy could have had no meaning.", "next": "But why will Professor HornefTer spoil it by trying to prove too much?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.467, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263491:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263491", "s": "This attractive theory is not wholly convincing, but both scenes are treated in the spirit of caricature which we only find again in the Kabeiroi vases.", "prev": "The author here sees the caricature of a potter's workshop; one Satyr kneads the clay for the pots, the other two melt the varnish, and to right are the finished speci- mens of their work.", "next": "The stamnos may be dated towards the middle of the sixth century B.C.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.419, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263491:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263491", "s": "It is interesting to note that he is not convinced by the arguments of the scholars who try to show that Philo is largely dependent upon Posidonius.", "prev": "Billings gives a clear and concise survey of the history of Philonic interpretation.", "next": "At the end of this chapter Billings states his own point of view: Philo's thought is essentially Platonic, though he frequently adopts the terminology of other schools, and at times assumes a syncretistic attitude, as, for example, in identifying the Platonic Ideas, the Stoic logoi, the angels of the Old Testament, and the Greek demons.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.837, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263492:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263492", "s": "It is interesting to note that he is not convinced by the arguments of the scholars who try to show that Philo is largely dependent upon Posidonius.", "prev": "Billings gives a clear and concise survey of the history of Philonic interpretation.", "next": "At the end of this chapter Billings states his own point of view: Philo's thought is essentially Platonic, though he frequently adopts the terminology of other schools, and at times assumes a syncretistic attitude, as, for example, in identifying the Platonic Ideas, the Stoic logoi, the angels of the Old Testament, and the Greek demons.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.09, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263492:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263492", "s": "But a careful reading of these passages will convince anyone that the vision of ideal beauty, even, can come only after intellectual activity.", "prev": "le, as Billings says, that Philo regarded to ov, especially in the Parmenides, as a philosophical term for God. 180 Book Reviews On page 16 Billings says: \"It is sufficient here to point out that the vision of true being is, for Plato, attained, not through intellectual activity, but in moments of divine madness, and under the influence of Eros,\" and he cites Phaedrus 249 C-E, and Symposium 211 E.", "next": "We may observe how in the Symposium Plato uses the language of the intellect; cf. 210 D: Kcrn'S^ two. iiri<TT^/j.rjV Toiavrrjv, rj cori Kakov roiov&t, and 211 C: ecus airo tu>v pjxOrfpA- Tiav «ir' £#C£ti/o to fj,d0rifia TcXevrrjurj, o e<rri ovk aXXov r) airov tKtivov rov KaXov fidOr/fia.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.21, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263492:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263492", "s": "Billings has successfully vindicated Philo's right to be called a Plato- nist, even though we are not in every case convinced of the essential agree- 184 Book Reviews ment of his thought with Plato's.", "prev": "Dr.", "next": "We may perhaps wish that he had chosen to devote more consideration to Philo's place in the history of Platonic interpretation.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.845, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263493:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263493", "s": "This reconstructed Consolatio is plausible as to contents, less so as to arrangement, and still less so as to spirit.", "prev": "Such a dislocation is sufficient to shake our confidence.", "next": "It is far too artificial and impersonal.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.703, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263494:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263494", "s": "This reconstructed Consolatio is plausible as to contents, less so as to arrangement, and still less so as to spirit.", "prev": "Such a dislocation is sufficient to shake our confidence.", "next": "It is far too artificial and impersonal.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.481, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263603:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263603", "s": "The details of the developed cycle he discusses through more than a hundred pages with results which are interesting if not always convincing.", "prev": "Robert finds the origin of the whole myth in the union of a Thessalian story with the sacred myth of a Corinthian goddess, Medea.", "next": "Points of difference cannot be handled in a brief notice, and the reviewer hesitates to oppose a scholar so learned and sane as Robert, but he cannot refrain from expressing his doubts whether it is necessary to postulate a complete reversal of the mythical geography by Milesian poets.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.649, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263015:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263015", "s": "As for Letter 16, To Maximus, to mention only one of the other sophistic letters here assigned to the rhetorician, I am convinced by its style and by the reference to the ordeal by water of the Celts, for which see Julian, Oration 2. 81 D, that it was written by the Emperor, probably from Gaul.", "prev": "Finally, there is not a shred of evidence that Julian of Caesarea had the faintest interest in Iambli- chus or philosophy.", "next": "That the Zeno of Letter 45 (Cumont 58) can be the teacher of Oribasius, whose Life we have in Eunapius, seems hardly possible, for that Zeno (of Cyprus) lived, says Eunapius, \"down to the time of Julian the Sophist\" who died in 340 a.d., and is therefore too early for a correspondent of the Emperor.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.659, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263015:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263015", "s": "They even ignore in several instances their own earlier emendations, brilliant and convincing to some students of Julian as these seemed to be, and with rare and perhaps misplaced modesty leave such passages as loci desperati.", "prev": "There are abundant lacunae and corrupt passages on which to exercise ingenuity, for Bidez and Cumont are as conservative in their handling of the text as they are revolutionary in their theories of authorship.", "next": "They can therefore hardly be criticized for their omission of many suggestions by other scholars, such as Cobet, Hertlein, Asmus (e.g., at 380 A his \\vkov and at 432 D his kcuvov seem almost certain), Buecheler, and Weil.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.809, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263021:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263021", "s": "Admetus in the r61e of the hero of a \"retarding moment\" is hardly convincing.", "prev": "The poetic dramas of personal self-devotion of Alcestis, Evadne, and Lao- damia resist at times the schematic analysis of the writer.", "next": "For the language of sacrifice Euripides, the writer proves, borrowed much from the ritualistic forms.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.757, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263022:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263022", "s": "Admetus in the r61e of the hero of a \"retarding moment\" is hardly convincing.", "prev": "The poetic dramas of personal self-devotion of Alcestis, Evadne, and Lao- damia resist at times the schematic analysis of the writer.", "next": "For the language of sacrifice Euripides, the writer proves, borrowed much from the ritualistic forms.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.237, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263024:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263024", "s": "His attempt to discrete the Alcaic elements in the poem are less convincing.", "prev": "Horace has reference to a newly established orgiastic worship of Dionysus at Rome.", "next": "The argu- ment that Horace borrowed from Ennius in the phrase sacra vile is very hazardous.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.28, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263024:1", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263024", "s": "His new contribu- tion is the suggestion that the crisis referred to is the desire of Augustus to retire to private life — i. 2 is quoted in support of this view, which is not entirely convincing.", "prev": "Pasquali devotes much space unnecessarily in vindicating the allegorical interpretation of i. 14 and in dating it soon after Actium.", "next": "It is assuming too much to say of iii. 12 that the severe uncle caught the girl drinking wine in her room.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.318, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263024:2", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263024", "s": "I am convinced that many of the odes had their inspiration in the daily events of Horace's life.", "prev": "In other poems, too, the immediate purpose or inspiration is overlooked in favor of comparisons with Hellenistic authors, often obscure.", "next": "To be sure, he then proceeded to treat them in a thoroughly literary manner, which involved the adaptation of his Graeco-Roman learn- ing.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.508, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263024:3", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263024", "s": "The first article shows rather convincingly against Vahlen and Skutsch that the Scipio of Ennius was one of the satires.", "prev": "Ennius receives the most space; other articles deal with Lucretius, Cicero, Catullus, Virgil, Ovid, Horace, Tacitus, Seneca, Gellius, Lactantius, the Anthologia Latina, and inscriptions.", "next": "The text of the known fragments is printed, with detailed comments.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.819, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263024:4", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263024", "s": "In writing of Cicero's famous line, fortunatam natam me consuls Romam, Pascal develops in a very plausible way a suggestion of Pascoli's, that natam was not in the original version but was inserted by one of Cicero's detractors.", "prev": "It concludes with the suggestion that Lucretius in his invoca- tion to Venus is following the teaching of Epicurus that one must give heed to political considerations.", "next": "In putting together and commenting on the Catullian glosses, Pascal errs, I think, in interpreting Scaliger.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.91, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "r:jstor-263026:0", "src": "cp_reviews", "id": "jstor-263026", "s": "An essay in the Virgilian group explains in a convincing way why the unfolded roll in the Virgil mosaic found at Susa carries line 8 of the Aeneid (Musa mihi, etc.) rather than the conventional Arma virumque cano: the words are better suited to the picture, as two Muses stand by Virgil's side .", "prev": "When such a mid-Victorian attitude toward manuscripts is found, it is difficult (to para- phrase Juvenal) not to write a big book instead of a short review.", "next": "An interesting paper shows how the later African writers defended Dido.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.179, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261349:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261349", "s": "When a division does occur in these three classes i Such cases as SANO | TI and EMP | TVS, therefore, gain greater weight. 2 The figures in Table A (p. 61) would be convincing even if we knew that there was no grammarians' rule, but they are especially significant since they represent the usage that existed in the face of a firmly established, traditional rule of syllabification. 3 This method was employed also by Augustus ;", "prev": "It is avoided by the use of ligatures or abbreviations, by super- imposed and circumscribed letters, 3 by spreading words, and by extending the line out into the frame or molding surrounding the inscription.", "next": "Suetonius Aug. 87 : notavi et in chirographo eius [Augusti] ilia praecipue : non dividit verba nee ab extrema parte versuum abundantis litteras in alterum transf ert, sed ibidem statim subicit circum- ducitque.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.758, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261353:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261353", "s": "Much of the persuasive force of Mr.", "prev": "I shall not now raise the more obvious questions regarding the validity of his method in general, but desire briefly to call attention to two points of minor importance.", "next": "Schlicher's presentation arises from the circumstance that his theory so well fits the facts of German grammar that those who are imbued with the idioms of that language will be tempted to accept it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.435, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262254:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262254", "s": "The emergence of the question from the shadow of scholastic debate into the light of public discussion was, I suspect, largely due to the heavy weight of authority and persuasiveness which Cicero threw into one side of the scale by the treatise De oratore.", "prev": "That the words of Cicero which challenged Caesar to a reply were in turn directed against earlier theorists, holding a position exactly analogous to Caesar's, would be my justification for contending that the ranks of the Atticists (though the name had not yet come into vogue) and of their rhetorical opponents were already sharply arrayed when the De oratore was written.", "next": "For as it can be made probable, I think, that Cicero's utterances elicited Caesar's work, so it is likely that a fuller record of the time would reveal his influence upon the contributions to this controversy which were made by others.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.055, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262260:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262260", "s": "The word was always apt, the humor Attic, the argument cogent.", "prev": "His quick intelligence grasped a subject in all its aspects, and he stated himself with singular charm.", "next": "In the delicately blended force and refinement of his mind, and in his unfailing sense of proportion, he was thoroughly Greek.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.874, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "Doubtless many who have not committed their ideas to print have had the same experience as the present writer, who confesses to having spent many an odd hour over these 43 broken lines, convinced that the published interpretations were often wholly wrong, never wholly right, only to lay aside for further reflection his own incomplete restorations with numerous queries still unanswered.", "prev": "It is not surprising that no two of the scholars 1 who have discussed them, have until recently agreed in their interpretations.", "next": "But the problem has recently been brought appreciably nearer a solution by Alfred KOrte in Rhein.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.037, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "My restoration has changed little since then, except for the addition of Kdrte's discoveries in 1098 a and that, convinced by his arguments, I have gone back to Anaxandrides as the principal poet in 1098. 2Lenaea : IG, II. 972, col.", "prev": "To do this he had 1 Before 1903; see p. 25, n. 69 (on Aristomenes) of my Introduction of Comedy into the City Dkmysia.", "next": "I ;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.137, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "I am convinced that he could not ; but I am obliged to content myself with a single calcu- lation by averages. 4 Fortunately this happens to be fairly con- 1 The reasons for these assertions are given in my Introd. of Com. into the City Dion., pp. 24 ff. 2 For the classification see Am.", "prev": "II on the strength of a victory won in 410 (409) ?", "next": "Jour.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.44, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "So when Korte acutely recognized the titles 'Lreppol and 'HfftoSot, of a period fixed by the name Xenophilus, his identification of their author as Telecleides was absolutely convincing.", "prev": "Plutus or Adelphi would give us the choice of several, but Pytine or Heautontimo- rumenus would be practically decisive if the period of their authors were right.", "next": "Of the titles remaining in 11. 1-6 the unusual \"tirepa <rihr)pa is not known from other sources, while \"Zdrvpoi was used by at least three poets of the Old Comedy, Ecphantides, Cratinus, and Phrynichus, all of whom are excluded by their periods.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.571, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "But when we find on this stone, in a didascalic record corresponding in period covered to Aristomenes, in a category certainly Lenaean and almost as certainly devoted to exhibitions which won third prize, and finally in the year of an archon whose date may quite well be 424 2 and the genitive of whose name ends in -ous, the unusual title Ko\\eo<f>6poi<;, palaeo- graphically 3 so near the readings which the MSS give for the play with which Aristomenes in the year of Stratocles was third at the Lenaea, the conclusion, as it seems to me, is irresistible that these are not chance coincidences but i", "prev": "The play which Aristomenes produced is reported in the didascalic notice variously, as \"T\\o<f>6poi<; in V and as 'O\\o<f>vpoi<; in r, ®, Aid. 1 The reading of V has in late years been accepted as correct.", "next": "For some may regard it as remotely possible that the name of Lysippus once stood in the victors' lists for a first victory won in JThe earlier editors ' 0\\o<t>vp/tois. 2 It is the second entry after Morychides, 439. 3 The first source of the error was doubtless due to the initial k being written like v. * The second Plutus, we now learn, was produced at the Lenaea; see note on 1097, 1.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.688, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262005:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262005", "s": "But Korte's arguments against this have seemed convincing, especially since Anteros as a play by Epicrates rests wholly upon a conjecture of Bergk.", "prev": "I once thought that the poet of the main portion of 1098 was probably Anaxilas, mainly because of the titles 'I<6 and Av/3o]7roto5, Epicrates being introduced into 1. 12 as the author of the 'Avrepw.", "next": "In the restoration a line of ca. 56 letters has been taken as a fair approximation after a calculation of the average length of the titles and archons in this inscription.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.742, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262006:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262006", "s": "The Helen Episode in Vergil's Aeneid 225 Heinze's argument is, I am convinced, an elaborate example of special pleading.", "prev": "So Troiae et (573) = Troiae et (x. 214), and Troia, arserit (581) = Troia antiqua (iv. 312).", "next": "The soliloquy will appeal to most readers as unusually impressive, and from the artistic standpoint seems to be modeled with great care.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.429, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262011:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262011", "s": "In his preface he intimates his knowledge of \"Libri Plorentini octo,\" and adds \"De his propediem alio loco agetur.\" 3 See the preceding page. 264 John Williams White edness to Seidler for readings from both the Venetus and the Ravennas, 1 as likewise Fritzsche in 1837. 2 Bekker had inspected also Venetus 475 (G) and in 1818 had collated the Ravennas anew, convinced that the collations used by Invernizi were not to be trusted.", "prev": "Many such books are preserved, especially in the libraries of northern Europe. 2 Two years earlier, in his Ranae (1824), Dindorf gives readings of \"Plorentinus b\" on the first one hundred and eight verses, but fails to designate the book so that it can be identified.", "next": "In Paris he had collated also, for the Plutus, Nubes, and Banae, certain \" Codices Mutinenses,\" which had been brought thither from northern Italy. 3 All this material appeared in his edition of Aristophanes published in London in 1829.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.408, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262013:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262013", "s": "And yet the evidence is abundant, consisting not only of numerous representations of the garment in vase-painting and sculpture, but also of several more or less specific indications in our literary sources. 1 Under these circumstances it would seem as if a convincing solution must be attainable.", "prev": "Every one of the numerous modern statements on the subject with which I am acquainted is either indistinct or, in my judgment, erro- neous.", "next": "We are in the habit of applying the name \"chlamys\" with a great deal of confidence to all small brooch-fastened outer gar- ments represented in Greek art.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.093, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262066:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262066", "s": "The change was plausible and brought the statement of Anon.", "prev": "The two considerations which appear to have induced Clinton to make the change would seem to be as follows: In the first place, the consideration that our versions of Eusebius ascribe to Menander a victory in 321-20, according to Hieronymus, or, according to the Armenian version, in 322-21 ; and that Philocles was archon in the year 322-21.", "next": "De com. into partial agreement with those of our versions of Eusebius. 2 The second consideration would appear to be that, as Clinton thought, a closely analogous confusion of the names Diocles (archon in 409) and Philocles (archon in 392) was to be found in a scholium to Aristophanes Plutus 179.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.258, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262066:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262066", "s": "His arguments for a date of composition prior to the death of Alexan- der are cogent and convincing, but we can not suppose for a moment that Menander postponed the production of his play for two years out of a desire to polish it off carefully.", "prev": "Bethe believes, therefore, that this play was written by Menander before the year 323, but that, in accordance with the notices of our versions of Eusebius, it was not produced until 321 or 320.", "next": "In view of the fact that he wrote some hundred and five plays in about thirty-three years, he must soon have learned to work much more rapidly.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.603, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262066:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262066", "s": "Legrand's arguments relating to the inconsistencies of the play, however, have weight; and, together with Bethe's suggestion, afford convincing proof of the early date of Menander's drama. * CIA.", "prev": "For such a conclusion there is as little warrant as there would be for concluding that Menander's play the 'AXaefc was brought out at the deme 'AXal ' Apa<j>r)vi8e<; because, as we know, its action takes place in that deme.", "next": "II. 470. *See Haigh Attic Theatre*, p. 43.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.683, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262067:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262067", "s": "The ten gentes, accordingly, were made up of twenty familiae, but no plausible connection of the XII that follows pumper'ias with either the ten or the twenty has been suggested (cf.", "prev": " 1 ff. : seme- nies tekuries sim kaprum upetu. tekvias famer'ias pum- per^ias XII, i. e., 'semenies (?) decuriis suem, caprum deligito. tekvias ( ?) familiae *quincuriae XII.' Following this passage we have the names of ten gentes, eight of which are divided into two parts (the Atiedii, the second Atiedii, etc.), one, the Casili, . into three parts, while there is but one branch of the Perasnanii.", "next": "Biiche- ler Umbrica, p. 140) .", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.237, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262067:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262067", "s": "Since pomperias in Oscan is defined by Mamertius, which is not only the name of a month in Latin, but in Oscan is an attribute of eiduis 'idibus;' since there are also Fisian pom- perias and Fisian ides; and since pumper\" ias in Umbrian is associated with XII, the number of months in a year (the XII having no apparent connection with other numbers in the con- text), it seems to be a plausible conclusion that the pomperias, proved by no. 38 to be bodies of men, were bodies that changed from month to month.", "prev": "Conway had an inkling of the true mean- ing when he remarked: \"the case of the following numeral is The Oscan and Umbkian Pumpekias 331 doubtful, possibly XII means mensis duodecimi\" (p. 650, s. pum- ped i as).", "next": "From this conclusion we get at least a little light upon the iovilae inscriptions.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.255, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262067:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262067", "s": "Such an assumption is not more than plausible, and can not therefore be strongly urged in settling the meaning of acnu.", "prev": "Nor do we know definitely that the ten vef of swine's fiesh and five of goat's are intended to be a fair exchange for four p. of grain.", "next": "On the whole, however, it may be claimed that in the Umbrian passage some measure of time would be the most suit- able meaning.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.725, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262073:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262073", "s": "There follow then the words: haec ipsa quae volvuntur ab illia (dialecticis) solvere malim et expendere, ut persuadeam [the goal of rhetoric], non ut imponam [dialectic].", "prev": "Against an emotion of the human breast such as fear stronger weapons must be used.", "next": "There follow accordingly rhetorical exempla drawn from the words of famous leaders, exhorting their men in the face of certain death.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.436, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262080:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262080", "s": "The suggestion as to source is plausible; as for the contamination, there is another possibility, a modification of P.'s Book Reviews 423 view.", "prev": "As to the source of the latter, P. can suggest nothing ; that of the former he would find in a pseudo-Hesiodic poem on the same theme, from which Tzetzes Prol. ad Lycophr. 261 cites two lines (fr. 94 Marckscheffel); with these P. compares vss. 26-28 of Catullus, and with fr. 218 M., which he thinks may belong to the same epithalamium, vss. 386-88.", "next": "He does not remark on vs. 251, parte ex alia (cf .", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.525, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262080:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262080", "s": "The arguments drawn from mythical considerations are neither clearly stated nor convincing; linguistically T. errs, both in supposing that aXXd could be used to introduce vs. 565 as a continuation of vs. 534, and in translating epi^cro /3ot)Aa9 534 by \"thwarted the will\" of Zeus.", "prev": "Th. 535 ss.,\" pp. 139-44, advances the theory that Theog. 535-64 belonged originally between Op. 48 and 50, Op. 49 having been inserted as a stop-gap after the passage had been transferred to the Theogony.", "next": "Syntactically this phrase must mean \"matched wits\" with Zeus, and it is evidently an amplification of the epithets ttoikiXov <noAdju.??ra> 511, and iroiKiX6^ov\\ov 521, just as imepKvBavra 510 is further developed in 514 ff . and d/uipTivoov 511 in 512 f.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.703, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261659:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261659", "s": "Bflckh was convinced of the antiquity of the Lenaea as well as of the Anthesteria.", "prev": "It will be instructive first of all to consider what explanations have been given by those who have maintained the doctrine of three urban festivals.", "next": "He dated both before the awotictvfuk of Theseus but did not attempt to decide which of the two was the older.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.246, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261659:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261659", "s": "Or supposed to date from Orestes) which convinced him of their greater antiquity.", "prev": "Is it because it was not situated \"toward this part of the city,\" and was therefore not available as an indication of the extent of the ancient city?", "next": "And he may have judged partly by the Upbv, precisely as the writer of the oration In Neaeram judged that the sanctuary iv Alfivais was older than any of the others. 1 Aristot.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.843, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261660:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261660", "s": "Analogy explains sufficiently te persuadeam (46), meos fruniscar (44) and quod frunitus est (43).", "prev": "Suchier Archiv III, p. 165).", "next": "The popular mind grasps the broad truth, with slight regard for the subtle limita- tions which the grammarian puts on it in practice, that the accu- sative is the case of the direct object, and this general principle Use op Language in Peteonius 47 it is likely to extend to any transitive verb in the language, and in this category fall persuadere and frunisci, although perhaps in the case of fruni", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.562, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261660:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261660", "s": "The popular mind grasps the broad truth, with slight regard for the subtle limita- tions which the grammarian puts on it in practice, that the accu- sative is the case of the direct object, and this general principle Use op Language in Peteonius 47 it is likely to extend to any transitive verb in the language, and in this category fall persuadere and frunisci, although perhaps in the case of frunisci one may say that of the two constructions allowable in early times after frui and its derivatives popular speech retained the accusative, because this construction con- formed to the general case ", "prev": "Analogy explains sufficiently te persuadeam (46), meos fruniscar (44) and quod frunitus est (43).", "next": "In a similar way aediles male eveniat (44) is probably to be explained, although Btlcheler regards the use of the accusative here as a Grecism. male evenire conveys an idea sufficiently transitive to justify to the popular mind the case commonly used after transitive verbs, belle erit (46) illustrates a colloquial usage common enough from the time of Plautus on.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.567, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261661:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261661", "s": "It is difficult to convince oneself that the two following schemes belong to the same measure (p. 70): He points out (p. 31) that, if the accent on the final syllable is not pleasing to our ear, yet the same rhythm occurs in the drama.", "prev": "F, as does the term lyric.", "next": "It would have been helpful in this con- nection if he had illustrated the melody of such a hemistich as (p. 69) inserinuntur, jc. *, j. j. ^, by giving us parallels from later literature, for some readers will be forced to confess that such rhythms also \"unser Ohr nicht leicht und erfreulich beruhren.\" iln comparing notes with Professor Radford I find that he has independently arrived at the same ", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.351, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261662:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261662", "s": "In the first place, it does not account in a convincing manner for the use of the mood in those consecutive clauses which express a fact, as well as in those which express a tendency or possibility.", "prev": "SCHLIOHBB The current explanation of the Latin subjunctive in consecu- tive clauses holds that it is in its origin a potential, or mood of limited or modified assertion. 1 This explanation is unsatisfactory for several reasons.", "next": "Elsewhere in the language the potential subjunctive represents things as likely to happen, as possible, as sure to happen under conceivable conditions, and the mood thus serves to distinguish things of this sort from those which actually do, did, or will happen, and which are expressed by the indicative.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.047, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261663:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261663", "s": "Had the whole supplement come into the hands of Balbus with the other, we may suppose that it would have been published at the same time; if the final revision and the sending of the latter part of it to Balbus were prevented by the death of Hirtius (in April, 43 b. a), we may conjecture that Balbus tried to make good the loss by persuading different persons who were eye-witnesses of the operations of the African and Spanish wars to write concerning them, and that this is the reason why we find so great a diversity of style and treatment in the last three books of the Caesarian corpus; the pro", "prev": "rs ; and he considered his narrative of events from the beginning of the Alexandrian war to the end of Caesar's life a com- pletion of Caesar's unfinished \"commentary.\" Whether the matter of this supplement was arranged in one or more books we do not know, nor can we explain why the interjected \"commentary\" has been preserved while the supplement, or at least the greater part of it, has been lost.", "next": "Pbancis W.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.895, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262128:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262128", "s": "Furthermore, with this interpretation of in utramque partem an allusion to the actor's art is in perfect keeping, so that there is now no convincing reason for rejecting the next three verses (48-50).", "prev": "On the other hand, some arrangements (for example, that suggested by Dziatzko and published in his edition) are rendered more probable by the fact that they increase the oratio 's effectiveness.", "next": "These were bracketed by Wagner and Umpfenbach because they appear also in the Hecyra (vss. 49-51) and are lacking in the Bembine manuscript, though this position has not commended itself to later editors; and doubtless their objection was largely due to their not seeing the appropriateness of these lines in this place.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.614, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262128:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262128", "s": "There is much plausibility in these objections, for such a procedure was often followed; cf., for example, Poenulus 123: ego ibo, ornabor.", "prev": "XXII [1894], p. 194) has objected to Bentley's view on the ground that, as Ambivius was dressed as a prologus, and as Menedemus and Chremes come on the scene in conversation together, Ambivius must have retired behind the scenes before beginning his part.", "next": "It is also true that upon the somewhat similar occasion of the HecyrcCs third presentation Ambivius appeared in the prologue's costume (venio ornatu prologi, 9), but it must be noted that in that play 1 Skutsch made a valiant effort to justify the present arrangement of lines.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.813, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262128:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262128", "s": "In view of these considerations, Karsten's arguments do not seem to me convincing.", "prev": "It thus appears that on this occasion the speaker of the prologue took up his part in the play without going behind the scenes, and there- fore without change of costume.", "next": "In conclusion, I think that Bentley was approximately correct in his idea of what actually happened, viz., that Ambivius began the play at the end of the prologue without change of costume and without going behind the scenes; but my opinion is quite independent of the precise meaning of vs. 3.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.958, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262129:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262129", "s": "On the other hand, I am not fully convinced by Hale's 2 presentation that the verb in such ex- pressions stands in the \"potential\" subjunctive.", "prev": "I find it impossible with Elmer ' to annihilate them by translation.", "next": "I mean that the expressions as a whole convey this peculiar force, not the mood of the verb alone.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.507, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262129:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262129", "s": "These have for- tunately received a convincing discussion by Mr.", "prev": "At. 514) which closely resemble our idiom, although they are rarer.", "next": "Hale (ZV.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.591, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262131:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262131", "s": "For Rohde (Psyche, pp. 295 ff.) gives much ancient testimony and cogent arguments showing how the orgiastic worship of the Thracian god was introduced comparatively late into Greece ; and how it contaminated the cult of Apollo.", "prev": "The Homeric instance of the union of Dionysus and Apollo is too early either to explain their connection in Greece or to be explained as the result of missionary influence from Delphi.", "next": "But at Ismarus it is not at once evident which god first pos- sessed the shrine.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.899, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262134:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262134", "s": "The conjectures proposed have been as little convincing as the attempts to interpret.", "prev": "exive, would understand the verse to mean \"poems which nobody would think equal to his own.\" With modern punctuation and its inverted commas the true meaning can be made clear to the eye, but Propertius had no means of accomplishing this for his readers, any more than for his hearers, and we may, therefore, safely conclude that he did not intend the line to be taken as Professor Postgate takes it.", "next": "Perhaps the best of them is Palmer's carmina quae quaevis non putat aequa suis, but the quae quaevis is distinctly cacophonous.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.233, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262134:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262134", "s": "If we accept Eossberg's /aufor, a plausible infer- ence from the /awmor of PL, and the favor of N, we may perhaps assume that Proper- tius had in mind not Faunus, but Pan himself. 2 The Glossae Graeco-Latinae likewise indicate that the words for liming and fowl- ing were interchangeable terms.", "prev": "Finally, I can myself call to mind only two allusions in Latin litera- ture to shooting birds with arrows; if there are others, it is certainly incumbent upon the upholders of the \"arrow\" interpretation to produce 1 Faunus is the reading of DV.", "next": "Cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.551, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262134:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262134", "s": "Fischer' to pro- nounce the pentameter an interpolation, and one need only look at Eoth- stein's painful attempt at interpretation to be convinced that the line cannot be genuine as it stands.", "prev": "The insufferable tautology of the last distich led W.", "next": "Of the corrections suggested, that of Bahrens, stultus liberam erit siquis amare volet, best satisfies the requirements of the context, but a less violent change is the transposition of nullus and siquis. nullus would then be used in the sense of an emphatic non,^ as in Plant.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.609, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262134:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262134", "s": "But the Latin poet knew no canon compelling him to mention both his Greek masters whenever he mentioned one of them.", "prev": "If we could be sure that Propertius had Philetas (and not Callimachus) in mind, it would be an acceptable conjecture.", "next": "In fact, he has twice alluded to Callimachus alone (ii. 1. 40; iv. 1. 64).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262134:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262134", "s": "Housman's praemia may be accepted (and it is at least a plausible conjecture) I would read: haecne marita fides, et pactae praemia noctis, cum rudis urgenti bracchia victa dedi?", "prev": "If Mr.", "next": "\"Is this wedded faith, and my reward for the night I pledged when a raw recruit in love, I surrendered to your attacks?\" The pentameter will depend upon pactae, and will signify, metaphor apart, \" when, new to love, I agreed to your proposal of marriage.\" Mr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.956, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "But the distribution of -ev and -etv, -rjv is not such as to lend any plausibility to either view, and has, I believe, no more bearing on the grouping of the dialects than that of the imperative endings -vreo and -vtcov.", "prev": "For example, the infinitive in -ev is often classed as a Doric characteristic, while vice versa, Hoffmann, De mixtis graecae linguae dialectis, pp. 60 ff., claims it as an \"Achaean\" element which has survived in some Doric dialects.", "next": "Yet I recognize that no two scholars will agree in all details in their judgment of what is sig- nificant and what is accidental, and claim nothing final for the selection made.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.058, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "For I am convinced that this is the proper application of this much-abused term, and the only objection is that it is used by others in such widely different senses. 1 The results of the chart are not to institute any radically new groupings, but mainly to confirm conclusions, some of which have long been evident, and others clear to many in recent years, but not so universally recognized as to make it superfluous to give them emphasis.", "prev": "For the group which is represented in the historical period by Arcadian and Cyprian I have generally been satisfied with Arcado-Cyprian, but one feels the need of a different term when referring to pre-Doric conditions (it is incongruous to speak of an Arcado-Cyprian survival in Argolis or Laconia), and I have been tempted to follow Solmsen in calling the group Achaean (Hoffmann's South Achaean).", "next": "The close connection between the North- west Greek and the Doric dialects was surmised by Ahrens, who pointed out (I, p. 2) that the statement of Strabo (viii. 333) according to which they were Aeolic was unsupported by any other evidence, either traditional or linguistic.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.095, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "Gram?, p. 66, and the literature cited) is convincing.", "prev": "XXX, pp. 565 ff.), nor that of Goidanich-Brugmann (Brugmann Gr.", "next": "And, whatever the true factors, they are in part wholly independent of dialectic variation.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.17, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "It is less cogent against *irpoa.Tos, but this also involves the assumption that the regular contraction of oa in Doric is d.", "prev": "Ill, pp. xxi ff.", "next": "And, while this is the accepted doctrine at present and is not doubted by Eulenberg, I can see no way of reconciling it with the evi- dence of other forms, which points rather to a contraction of oa to a> in all dialects.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.405, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "Some few of them, I am fully convinced, were common to all the West Greek dialects, though quotable from only a very few, and there are some others for which this is a possibility.", "prev": "These phenomena are West Greek in the sense that they are found only among West Greek dialects, and they are often cited among the Doric characteristics.", "next": "On the other hand, many of them are distinctly limited in scope. 16. lfi.lv = ifxol.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.508, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262222:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262222", "s": "XXV (1905), p. 50, which the editor, loc. cit., p. 53, calls \"the first instance of iv = els in Doric,\" is, I am convinced, to be attributed to Aetolian influence, which has long been recognized in late Messenian inscriptions (iravrow, etc.; see 29).", "prev": "Stud.", "next": "The appearance of is in a fifth-century inscription of Delphi, BCH.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.653, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262224:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262224", "s": "The leno has with him at this time a hospes Sicu- lus, Agrigentinus, who persuades him to close up his affairs at Cyrene and set sail for Sicily (49-66, 356 ff.).", "prev": "The girl tells her own story in 216-19; see also 393, 394, 649. 714, 736-44, 1104, 1105.", "next": "He is ship- wrecked, however, on the first night of his voyage and he and the daughter of Daemones come ashore near Cyrene.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.317, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262225:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262225", "s": "Clark in Classical Philology I, pp. 313 ff., has convinced me that the archonship of Philippos, and hence the death of Menander, do really belong to 292/1 B. c.", "prev": "THE DEATH OF MENANDEK By William Scott Fbeguson The excellent article of Dr.", "next": "His proof, which is grounded on the sound maxim that the birth- years of celebrities were often ascertained in antiquity by calcu- lation, while the years of their death rested upon contemporary records, starts with the pretty demonstration that Menander and Epicurus became ephebes, the former in 325/4, the latter in 324/3.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.064, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262227:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262227", "s": "These are the words of Cleocritus, the herald of the mysteries, who tries to persuade the Athenians that it is to their interest to cast off the yoke of the Thirty, it is for their sake rather than his own that he speaks, hence the present and not the aorist.", "prev": "Hell. ii. 4. 21: irpbs OeZv Trarpigiav kcu firjrptouiv fir) rreiOeade tois dvo<rtu>raTois TpiaKovra.", "next": "Sym. 8. 6: Trpos to>v 6ea>v, a> ' kvTi<rdeve<>, fiovov fir) cnry/coi/^? fie.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.766, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262230:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262230", "s": "Yet nobody has offered a plausible interpretation of the accepted reading (cf.", "prev": "Lindsay's conservatism in retaining euriosam, which I should add is confirmed by Nonius (455. 2) in his quotation of the verse, is a notable exception.", "next": "Ussing, Wagner, Prancken ad loc); at best it is a coined word to prepare for the pun in cura in 564, and the possibility of connection with curio, the term applied to the priest of a curia, hinders rather than helps a satisfactory interpretation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.389, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262230:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262230", "s": "The context is clearly Greek; if the references to Geryones and Argus and Pirene do not sufficiently prove it, the obvious 335 336 Notes and Discussions translation of TravoVnjs in oculeus totus (555) is convincing (cf.", "prev": "This line of thought, however, is demonstrably right.", "next": "Oster- mayer De historia fabulari in corn.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.527, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262330:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262330", "s": "They are quite comparable with the more recent artistic activities of the great Napoleon, which convinced the hereditarily facetious descendants of the ancient despoilers that Frenchmen were thieves and robbers, non tutti, to be sure, ma buona parte.", "prev": "We may justly condemn, from our more enlightened aesthetic and ethical standpoint, the lamentably rude and violent methods by which the appropriation to Roman life of the artistic riches of Greece was sometimes carried out.", "next": "We may properly smile at the naive form of marine insurance effected by the Roman conqueror of Corinth in the interest of his valuable cargoes.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.604, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262331:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262331", "s": "This is a plausible conjecture, but if we adhere strictly to the MSS it must be affirmed that neither the Agamem- non nor the Memnon seems to illustrate to us the use of irapaaK-q- viov or Trapaxopriyrj/j^a as defined in the passage.^ We are thus justified in disregarding the references to these plays.", "prev": "Hermann') understand under the title Agamemnon the whole triology and find in the passage a reference to the situation in Choeph. 889, where a fourth person is actually required for the part of Pylades.", "next": "The rest of the passage yields an intelligible meaning, To begin with the last clause, \"if a fourth actor should speak anything (rt) in sup- plement [\"Trapd), this was called \"parachoregema,\" i. e., a fourth speaking\" actor was designated by the word parachoregema.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.189, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262331:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262331", "s": "A correct inter- pretation of the simple word x^PVyVH'\"' will enable us to give a plausible answer to this question.", "prev": "What then is the meaning of Trapaxoprj^yrjiia ?", "next": "It should first be observed that x^PVyVH-^ 'was never used in classical Greek nor is it ever found as a synonym of xopV'Y^\"' in its technical sense of \"oflBce of choregus,\" though etymologically it might have been so used.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.36, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262333:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262333", "s": "So convincing were the arguments of Hudtwalcker' and Meier ^ that their leading opponents were won over to their view and thus the matter stood until Hubert and Lipsius' insisted upon giving due weight to the testimony of the lexicographers and turned the balance in favor of compulsory arbitration for nearly all private suits.", "prev": "Disregarding to some extent the scanty and often obscure notices of the lexicographers, they examined with great care the extant speeches, seizing upon every bit of evidence that seemed to sup- port the view that arbitration was not always compulsory in private suits.", "next": "This view was apparently so strongly confirmed by Aristotle [Ath.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.057, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262333:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262333", "s": "Pischinger and Hubert' have misgivings in classifying inheri- tance cases as arbitration suits, but are convinced by the mention of arbitration in an affidavit of doubtful authenticity inserted in Euhulides v.", "prev": "BONNEK This consideration is materially strengthened by the fact that in no case that indisputably came before an arbitrator is there any attempt to introduce new evidence or any sure indication that the speaker is not fully aware of the evidence he has to meet.", "next": "Macartatus.^ The facts are briefly as follows: The estate of one Hagnias was claimed by a young man, whose mother Phylomache had at first been triumphantly adjudged in court heiress of the estate but in subsequent litigation had been defeated by the father of Macartatus, the defendent in the present suit.' Now the plaintiff Eubulides gives a detailed account of this liti- gation and calls for evid", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.478, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262335:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262335", "s": "It will therefore be convenient at this point to state very briefly the main considerations which may be urged in sup- 1 In his Latin Language, which represents a revision of the Appendix to his Latin Grammar, and which has just appeared as this article goes to press, Bennett seems inclined to regard the arguments of Vendryes as convincing. 446 Frank Frost Abbott port of these two views.", "prev": "The adherents of the pitch-theory are influenced largely by the statements made by the Latin writers concerning the accent, while those who believe in the stress-theory find support for it mainly in evidence of the second sort.", "next": "This presentation of the facts will show, I hope, that it is very difficult, if not impossible, to accept either theory in its present form, and that some via media is the only way out of the difficulty.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.118, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262355:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262355", "s": "After the list of all the occurrences of the construc- tion, a summary presents the statistics for each book separately, from which Canter draws the conclusion that \"Livy employs the historical infinitive less frequently, though not quite uniformly less, passing from the earlier to the later books.\" This chronological explanation is hardly convincing in view of such striking variations as the three examples of book xxvi as compared with the thirty-four of book xxvii.", "prev": "The chapter devoted to the historical infinitive has been worked out with the greatest detail.", "next": "Would it not be better to seek in the character of the narrative some hint for the reason of the more or less frequent use of the construction?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.83, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262030:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262030", "s": "Bennett has convincingly overthrown the proofs upon which Elmer laid the greatest stress, Cornell Studies IX, pp. 1-30.", "prev": "At least such a possibility is suggested by sentences like : quid est causae cur non is, qui Catilinam ex urbe 1 1 need not undertake a detailed discussion of Elmer's arguments.", "next": "Semantics of Modal Constructions 11 pepulit, pertimescat; .... cur sibi confidat is qui .... cura- vit ?", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.48, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262030:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262030", "s": "The occurrences in the past tense, like Bud. 842, caperes aut fustem aut lapidem, have also received a convincing analysis by Morris (ibid., p. 281) : Obligation is one of the many meanings of the subjunctive in the present, though it is somewhat infrequent, and it is the only one which has, so to speak, survived the transfer from present time to past.", "prev": "If so, their history is something of a parallel to the Sanskrit \"prescriptive,\" though they are humbler in tone and probably related to expres- sions of will rather than of wish.", "next": "The other shades of will or desire cannot be used of a past feeling.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.514, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262034:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262034", "s": "However, the argument of this critic fails to convince because of his evident determination '\"Essai sur le regne de Trajan,\" Bibliothique de Vicole des hautes itudes XXXII (1877), p. 3, n. 5. 2 Geschichte der rOm.", "prev": "To be sure, Schiller, as I have said, will have it that Trajan was decidedly lacking in modesty.", "next": "Kaiserzeit I, p. 545 and Anm. 6 (Gotha, 1883-87). s Stddt.everwaltung imrdmischen Kaiserreiche, p. 163 (Leipzig, 1900).", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.408, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262035:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262035", "s": "Now these structures completely surrounded the assumed site of the ara, and a glance at the map will convince anyone of the impropriety of Ovid's using the verb prospicit (ii. 860) of the god enshrined at this point, provided any definite topographical sense is to be assigned to the word at all.", "prev": "When the Fasti (5), (6) were written, at the beginning of the first century, there were between Htilsen's site of the old ara Martis and the Equiria the thermae and Pantheon of Agrippa, the temple of Minerva Chalcidica, the first temple of Isis and Serapis, and the great Saepta Iulia, as well as the porticus Argo- nautarum and the basilica of Neptune.", "next": "It is not the distance between this site and the Equiria that is the objection, but the fact that the former was quite cut off at this time from the latter.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.886, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262037:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262037", "s": "I am convinced that the author of the Greek considered o-v/wravres hardly strong enough to represent universi, and so added 6/xodvfia86v, which is etymologically a rough equivalent to the Latin word.", "prev": "Wolfflin, loc. cit., p. 266, thinks that owexfi? stands for apud omnia pulvinaria, but o~wex<<>s comes little, if any, closer than o/xo6vfw.S6v to a correct reproduc- tion of the Latin words.", "next": "If Mommsen is correct, and I think he is, in supposing that the word ending in r is represented by crwex^s, not by oixoOv/mSov, then neither the 87 88 Notes and Discussions unanimiter of Wolfflin (p. 266) nor the concorditer of Bormann and Schmidt (Philologus, 1887, p. 80) can be right.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.288, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262037:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262037", "s": "Of course the length of continenter lays it open to the objection offered to frequenter, but a careful examination of the facsimile has convinced me that there is ample room for fifty-seven letters in the line, five more than Mommsen allows.", "prev": "Certainly a better equivalent for crw^Jls than either frequenter or semper is continenter.", "next": "To save the space of one letter, it might be desirable to accept supplicaverunt, preferred by Wolfflin to sacriftcaverunt on the ground that supplicare is regularly used with apud omnia pulvinaria.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.356, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "A more cogent reason for joining 6eS>v with wpSna is the fact that in Homer there is not a single passage where irpGyra or any of its varied adverbial forms is used in an address of devotion, where Otmv is not joined with it.", "prev": "In xix. 303 the phrase |ev«j t« rpdirt^a has dropped out, and the metrical makeshift \\maros Kal aptoros has taken its place, without in any way changing the construction of the sentence, and the verse here should read ictto) vvv Zeus trpuyra 0€wv, viraros Kal dpiaros.", "next": "The examples are iii. 418 f.: KapiraXCjxuy; pot, TtKva (piXa, KprpjvaT' ee\\8u>p, o<pp' ij tol irpwrurra $tmv IXacraop,' 'AdrjvrjV, xiv. 158; xvii. 155; xx. 230: toro) vvv Zeis 7rpG>Ta 0tG>v, fewij re rpdire^a, Iliad xvii. 568: Ss <pdro, yriOrja-ev St 0ta yXavKwms 'AOrjvrj otti pd ot irduirparra OtStv r\\p-iKTaro irdvrmv.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.148, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "The reason why Telemachus was so quick to admit evidence and was so ready to believe, while the others, and above all Penelope, were so hard to persuade, is because of their different sorrows in the absence of Odysseus.", "prev": "The age of Telemachus, when his father left for Troy, makes the remem- brance of any sign impossible; hence none could be used.", "next": "Tele- machus never mourned for his father from any longing for his compan- ionship, but he wanted the benefits that his return might bring him, Telemachus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.287, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "Notes and Discussions 93 Her desire and affection are so intense that she can hardly be convinced, and, like the disciples of Jesus, she \" believed not for joy.\" A striking parallel to this recognition scene in Homer is found in Sophocles' Electra.", "prev": "Penelope yearns for Odysseus not for her own, but for his sake; her words xx. 79 ff. are typical of her unselfish devotion : (os ep' diorwo-eiav OA.up.iria Stupar' l^ovres, rji p.' «WA.o(cop,os ftakoi *Aprepts, 5<f>p' 'OoW>}a oaaopevr] Kal yatav vwo crTvyeprjv a(j>iKoiprjV.", "next": "Chrysothemis sees the offerings made at the grave of Agamemnon, and from these tokens reasons that Orestes is still alive, while the keenly interested Electra cannot be convinced until she sees the certain proof and sign, the signet-ring of her father.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.422, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "Chrysothemis sees the offerings made at the grave of Agamemnon, and from these tokens reasons that Orestes is still alive, while the keenly interested Electra cannot be convinced until she sees the certain proof and sign, the signet-ring of her father.", "prev": "Notes and Discussions 93 Her desire and affection are so intense that she can hardly be convinced, and, like the disciples of Jesus, she \" believed not for joy.\" A striking parallel to this recognition scene in Homer is found in Sophocles' Electra.", "next": "In 1222 Orestes says: Trp/Se irpoaftXapaad /*ov <r(ppayi8a irarpos €K/jux8' el <ra<prj Xiyu).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.44, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "It is not \"das innige Verhaltnis, welches psychologisch zwischen Orestes und Chrysothemis herrscht,\" that explains her readiness to be convinced, nor does its absence make Electra so slow to believe.", "prev": "In 1222 Orestes says: Trp/Se irpoaftXapaad /*ov <r(ppayi8a irarpos €K/jux8' el <ra<prj Xiyu).", "next": "So in Homer, Telemachus' desire for his father's return is a calm, selfish one which easily listens to evidence; while Penelope's yearning is of that intense, personal sort which can scarcely be convinced, lest it be deceived in the end.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.464, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "So in Homer, Telemachus' desire for his father's return is a calm, selfish one which easily listens to evidence; while Penelope's yearning is of that intense, personal sort which can scarcely be convinced, lest it be deceived in the end.", "prev": "It is not \"das innige Verhaltnis, welches psychologisch zwischen Orestes und Chrysothemis herrscht,\" that explains her readiness to be convinced, nor does its absence make Electra so slow to believe.", "next": "The same reason applies to the others to whom a sign was given, though in a less degree.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.478, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262038:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262038", "s": "Telemachus was the easiest to convince, since he had never known his father and could feel no loss of personal companionship in his absence.", "prev": "Penelope was the slowest to believe, because the personal presence of Odysseus meant the most to her.", "next": "Iliad xviii. 284 ff.: TlovXvSdpa, <rv ph> arvKtr' ifiol <f>(Xa Tavr' ayoptvas, os KeXeu Kara aoru dXrj/xcvai avrvs tovros. r) ov voi KtKoprprOt ieXpevoi ev8o#i irvpymv; irpw fiiv yap Hpidfioio iroAiv /tieporrcs avOpiinroi mures p.v0i<TKOvTO TroXvxpwTOv iroXv)(aXKov • vvv Si Sr) ItjaTroXiaXe oofiwv Kap.r}Xux naXd, iroXXa.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.509, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262060:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262060", "s": "Mulder has advanced startling yet convincing theories of the manner and age of the composition of the Iliad.", "prev": "No one had advised Hector to abandon his country, so there is no occasion for Homer using this thrilling verse of some elegiac poet.", "next": "However one may approve of the argument, it seems impossible that the Greeks themselves should have assigned such authority and antiquity to the Iliad had it been founded on poems of the age of Tyrtaeus and Callinus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.723, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261732:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261732", "s": "But I propose to give in this short paper a reason, and to me a convincing one, for believing that Caesar's account of the campaign of Curio in Africa, which occupies the last twenty-one chapters of Book ii, could not have been written until after his return from his own campaign in that province, viz., until after the beginning of June, 46 B. o.", "prev": "Warde Fowler As the question stands in this heading, I confess I cannot answer it with complete confidence.", "next": "And if my argument has any weight, it will carry with it a presumption that the rest of the work was composed at the same time.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.075, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261732:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261732", "s": "If then (1) Caesar had never been at Utica before the spring of 46, and (2) if we have convincing indications in these chapters that he had been on the spot when he wrote them, we get a termi- nus ex quo for the composition of the second half of Book ii of the Civil War, and a strong presumption that the whole work was written after the campaign of Thapsus.", "prev": "he posi- tion before Utica is the work of a general, accustomed for many years to examine the lie of the ground in military operations: it is the pivot on which Caesar's criticism of Curio's movements turns; and I cannot believe that he would have ventured to criti- cise them as he did, even if he had enjoyed the modern advantage of photography to help him, without having been himself on the spot.", "next": "As I have already said, the most natural and convenient time for their composition would be immediately after he left Africa (June 13) , or any time between that date and the end of the following November.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.969, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261733:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261733", "s": "Plausible as such an hypothesis may seem in explanation of some of the later instances of ydp in wish, more is required for its proof than the citation of a few examples where the ydp may be disregarded in translation.", "prev": "Thus the distinc- tion between the wish formula with ydp and that without ydp is one of emphasis.", "next": "The logical relation of the wish sentence to the context must be analyzed and shown to be neither the causal nor derivative from the causal.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.113, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261734:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261734", "s": "Thus all united to persuade the Princeps to continue to watch over the state.", "prev": " ruse to strengthen his position, 4 he announced his intention of resigning his extraor- dinary powers 5 — a resignation impossible with an aristocracy indifferent to the common weal and eager for the lucrative posi- tions and for the gifts or advantageous leases of lands, by which the shrewd Augustus was binding them to his cause, and with a plebs mindful of recent donatives and hopeful for more.", "next": "But the sudden popularity thus arising would not last of itself, nor would the games given with unwonted magnificence in the name of Marcellus 6 satisfy the Roman's desire for great and glorious achievements.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.571, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261734:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261734", "s": "How much negotiating was necessary to persuade Phraates to send an embassy to Rome and to offer to submit to the form of a surrender in order to recover his kidnapped son, we do not know, but the efforts of Agrippa were finally successful, for in the late summer or the early autumn of 23, 3 envoys from the Great King arrived in Rome asking for the surrender of Tiridates and the return of the young prince. 4 Augustus refused to deliver Tiridates to his rival — he might yet prove serviceable, and his promises to make Parthia a vassal-state of Rome might still be made use of, should Phraates fail", "prev": "The Mission op Agkippa to the Oeient 151 willing to conceal the object of his journey under the cover of a retirement from court, Mytilene, where illustrious Romans had ere this lived in exile, 1 would seem a natural place in which to spend the years of an ablegatio, and was, moreover, a charming spot 2 in which to tarry until the transaction should be completed.", "next": "For the Emperor himself was to go to the Euphrates to receive the submission of the Parthian monarch, 7 and in connection with it to make an elaborate tour of inspection through all the provinces of the East.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.786, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261735:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261735", "s": "No explanation can be really complete, however, which does not recognize the fact that the slurred forms of deo, die and scio occur not only in weak, but also in fairly emphatic uses of these words, which does not meet the very plausible arguments which the opponents of Old Latin synizesis advance at this point.", "prev": "Radford in several cases to the weakened uses of some of these forms, e. g., to the trite or emotional use of deo and the parenthetical use of scio (loc. cit., p. 181, n. 1; pp. 195 f.).", "next": "For the latter claim that all iambic words like dSo, die, sold, etc., which have a distinct accent, have their final syllable shortened by the accent, and there- fore cannot well have the first or accented syllable slurred in subordination to the second.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.341, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261735:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261735", "s": "I myself am inclined to accept, for every foot except the last, the anap. scansions perdidi, aiireas, since these latter seem to me to rest on plausible grounds of historical develop- ment, which I have briefly stated elsewhere (Am.", "prev": "In my judg- ment, no certainty has yet been reached for anap. verse respecting either the limits of shortening or the occurrence of synizesis except in the case of iambic words.", "next": "Jour.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.573, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261737:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261737", "s": "Ad Att. ii. 22. 5: unum illud tibi persuadeas velim, omnia mihi fore explicata, si te videro; sed totum est in eo, si ante (sc. te videro) quam ille ineat magistratum.", "prev": "Cic.", "next": "The range of expressions that may be expanded by substantive st-clauses is quite considerable.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.427, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261737:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261737", "s": "Adfam. vii. 10. 4: sic enim tibi persuadeas velim, unum mihi esse solatium, quare facilius possim pati te esse sine nobis, si tibi esse id emolumento sciam. 1 Oic.", "prev": "Cic.", "next": "P.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.503, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261738:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261738", "s": "\" By way of rec- reation,\" says Plato, \"one may find pleasure in plausible theories of becoming.", "prev": "The t&v axn&v of the text has no variants, and it seems also clear that its function is to represent the tov? yeveo-eayt irept el/coTon which goes before.", "next": "Let us therefore in this spirit proceed to discuss the probabilities of the same.\" On the Pronominal Use of 6 avTfc in Plato 187 Tim. 66a: Bia Tairas Tat BwdfieK Bpi/xda irdvra roiavra i\\.e%0r), t&v Be avr&v Trpo\\e\\e7rTV<r/jJva>v fiev virb ar)ireB6vo<i, eh Be Ta<; crrevas <f>\\efia<; evBvo/ievcov ....", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.589, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261739:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261739", "s": "The precise bond between them might even now be inferred, but can doubtless be more convincingly established when more of the copies of Spirensis have been collated, and A N once more reviewed with care.", "prev": "Vindob. 162 (Jordan's and Urlichs' A) will show, even more clearly than could be judged from the readings of N as given by Urlichs, the very close relationship between A and Spirensis.", "next": "My own scanty experience in the collation of MSS before collated by others, or by myself, and in the submission of my own collations to critical review by the care- ful eyes of others, has taught me that the only way to secure an approach to accuracy in the report of MS readings is through such independent and repeated collations, followed by a careful com- parison once more with the original on a", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.765, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261745:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261745", "s": "I have nothing to add to my previous statement, but I did not wish, by my silence, to convey the impression that Professor Knapp's argumentation was to me convincing.", "prev": "How often have we all had the experience of miswriting a word where the error afterward seemed absurd and could be explained only by preoccupation of mind!", "next": "Walter Dbnnison TKANSPOSITION VARIANTS IN CICERO'S PRO CLUENTIO [The sigla are as in A.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.937, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261746:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261746", "s": "I have nothing to add to my previous statement, but I did not wish, by my silence, to convey the impression that Professor Knapp's argumentation was to me convincing.", "prev": "How often have we all had the experience of miswriting a word where the error afterward seemed absurd and could be explained only by preoccupation of mind!", "next": "Walter Dbnnison TKANSPOSITION VARIANTS IN CICERO'S PRO CLUENTIO [The sigla are as in A.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.841, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261747:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261747", "s": "I have nothing to add to my previous statement, but I did not wish, by my silence, to convey the impression that Professor Knapp's argumentation was to me convincing.", "prev": "How often have we all had the experience of miswriting a word where the error afterward seemed absurd and could be explained only by preoccupation of mind!", "next": "Walter Dbnnison TRANSPOSITION VARIANTS IN CICERO'S PRO CLUENTIO [The sigla are as in A.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.325, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261785:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261785", "s": "Deinde Bel- lerophontes victor e Caria redit, facinora sua describit, Proeto perfidiam exprobrat, ab eodem novis insidiis petitus Stheneboeae cuius indicio servatus erat, simulate amore persuadet, ut Pegaso vecta se in Asiam comitetur.", "prev": "Quasi alterum prologum habemus.", "next": "Pegasum autem ipsum in ea scaena inductum esse in qua Bellerophontes victoriam de Chimaera reportatam narrabat, novo fragmento edocti sumus, quod nuper Photius Berolinensis obtulit, Traio) Hi/iaipav eh crifiayd^, irvpcK S' adi^p ^aXKei fie Kal touS' al6a\\ol ttvkvov irrepov} Qui Pegasus ligneus esse vix poterat (risissent opinor Athenien- ses), sed equus verus alis ornatus, quern manu ducebat histr", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.522, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261786:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261786", "s": "But other experts have differed; and I am myself now convinced that the movement of the writing is somewhat freer than Petrarch's.", "prev": "The light curving and rising final stroke of the e's, the long sweep of the uirgula, and the angle of the two strokes of the a's, are in Petrarch's manner.", "next": "It was always a difficulty, too, that notes in Petrarch's style of comment were lacking in the margins.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.404, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261786:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261786", "s": "I am also convinced that Novati is wrong [Epistolario di Coluccio Salutati I. 222, footnote 2) in attributing the ownership of G, on the basis of notes which he does not specify, to Coluccio.", "prev": "The resemblances are complete, not only in the style of the letters (some of which have very marked peculiari- ties), but in the manner of making the frequent braces, the draw- ing of the pointing hands, and the character of the many examples of .No. used for the same purpose.", "next": "The hands of G^ and Coluccio are similar, but not the same.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.432, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261787:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261787", "s": "Metella, the wife of Sulla, had also the same wish, and they persuaded Pompeius to put away Antistia and to take to wife Aemilia, the stepdaughter of Sulla, the child of Metella by Scaurus, who was living with her husband and was pregnant.", "prev": "Long) : As Sulla admired Pompeius for his superior merit and thought that he would be a great support to his own interests, he was anxious in some way to attach him by family relations.", "next": "This matter of the marriage was of a tyrannical character and more suited to the interests of Sulla than conformable to the character of Pompeius, for Aemilia, who was pregnant, was taken from another to be married to him, and Antistia was put away with dishonor and under lamentable circum- stances, inasmuch as she had just lost her father also, and that too on her husband's account; for Antistius", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.658, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261788:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261788", "s": "Now the Delian games, which had become extinct or nearly so, were revived and reorganized by the Athenians in 426. ' Does not this suggest a plausible hypothesis ?", "prev": "The Palm of Viotoey 267 according to which the palm was first given by Theseus in insti- tuting the Delian games.", "next": "The Athenians, we may conjecture, either at the first celebration of the new quadrennial festival or not long thereafter, bestowed palms upon the victors in the games.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.382, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261788:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261788", "s": "But any one who has examined the evidence mar- shaled by Petersen in Die Kunst des Pheidias, pp. 43, 44, must be convinced that the crown, or at any rate a crown, was pre- sented immediately after the conclusion of the contest.", "prev": "The matter would be more in- telligible, if we could find two different occasions subsequent to a victory, at one of which the palm was bestowed, and the crown at the other.", "next": "It seems almost certain that the palm was given at the same time.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.429, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261788:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261788", "s": "If these suggestions do not carry conviction, then we must take the view that Pausanias not only wrote a muddled passage, but also on an important point misrepresented the facts.", "prev": "My theory of the matter is that the change from Koo-ftr}o-cu( ?) to crrefavow was the starting-point of the corruption of the text, and that this blunder led subsequently to the interpolation of the sentence, ol Be ay&ve: <j>otviicos e%ovo~iv ol iroXKol are^avov.", "next": "In any case the statement that the palm was commonly used for crowns of victory ought to disappear from our books of reference.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.986, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261791:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261791", "s": "LAV credo CPH mihi persuasi vs.", "prev": "LAV om. tarn CPH crebro vs.", "next": "LAV persuasi mihi CPHV quorsum vs.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.472, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261791:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261791", "s": "LAV persuasi mihi CPHV quorsum vs.", "prev": "LAV credo CPH mihi persuasi vs.", "next": "LA quorsus CPHV atqui vs.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.473, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261791:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261791", "s": "ERI vixerit C l or C 2 often furnishes readings which would be plausible enough if supported by other MS authority.", "prev": "ERI et p. 155. 37 C vixit vs.", "next": "As worthy of notice, I would cite: p. 133. 23 vetustum; 133.33 C 2 hoc futurum est; 134. 35 C 2 efferent; 136. 4 C quae scientia iuris et augurandi; 137. 6 C 2 infirmum; 137. 11 C 2 ab his; 138. 31 C 1 fiorescentis ; 139. 14 C 1 qui propter; 140. 2 serunt; 143. 15 C 1 opertus; 150.1 ego] ergo; 150. 5 tantillo; 151.7 rerum rusti- carum; 153. 24 aut iam etiam de; 154. 26 at tamen haec morositas; 155", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.546, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261791:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261791", "s": "C 1 hi qui, C 2 hi quidem — 7 C 1 extimescunt, C 2 extimescent. qui- dem ut miehi — 8 C 1 rerum, C 2 studiorum — 9 certa studia — 10 sunt et — 12 eius] huius. ne] num — 13 sunt autem — 14 occidunt etiam — 16 mortis affert maturum. equidem non enim — 17 quid] quod — 18 melius cernere michi — 19 tu Publi Scipio tuque Gai Leli — 24 C 1 altissimo, C 2 aptis- simo— 26 C scilicet in locum, C 2 locum (om. scilicet in). — 28 C 1 terrain, C 2 terras — 30 C 1 non, C 2 nee — 31 sed etiam. ita in gloss — 33 Picthag. et Picthag. — 34 qui cum. nominati quondam — 37 die vite (vitae). p. 159. 1 C 2 disseruit(", "prev": "A New Manusceipt of Cicero's De Senectute 301 p. 158. 1 C 1 nee, C 2 ne — 2 passus est carere. quod] quas — SC'sepe, C 2 esse — 4 C erecto, C 2 recto, unde nunquam se red. — 5 C 1 quod, C 2 quid.", "next": "C sententie, C 2 scientie — 7 animus agitetur — 8 ipse se. ne] nee — 9 sit] C 2 esset — 10 esset] om.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.936, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261791:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261791", "s": "C 1 diutius, C 2 iustius — 29 persuaderi nunquam — 30 C 1 exissent, C 2 excessissent — 31 turn — 33 admistione — 36 et cet. — 37 discedant. p. 160. 2 discedit — 3 C 1 tarn mortis, C 2 morti tam — 7 C 1 sunt, C 2 sint — 8 C 1 cum plane se vinculis corporis relaxaverint, C 2 laxaverint, C 2 cum se plane corporum vinculis relaxaverint — 9 C 1 colite, C 2 colitote — 10 C interitus est, C 2 interiturus — 12 C pulcritudinem omnem, omnem] C 2 communem — 14 Cyrrus vero hec quidem — 16 Paulum et A/fricanum (bis). — 17 C 1 et multos, C 2 multo — 20 ipsos] posse — 21 an ne. meipso — 23 isdem] iisdem — 25", "prev": "C 1 qui, C 2 quod — 16 arripere] accipere — 17 fere sunt — 19 dixit, karissimi — 21 nee] neque — 22 videbatis meum — 25 C 2 videbatis — 27 C 1 eorum, C 2 illorum.", "next": "C 1 unde, C 2 de quibus — 2 C 1 con- scripsi, C 2 conscripsi — 4 C neque tanquam pilam retorsit, C 2 nee retorserit. quis] C 2 qui — 5 C ex hac vite etate repueriscam tenera, C 2 repetam — 7 enim vita habet — 8 C sane habeat, C 2 habet sane — 10C 1 licet, C 2 libet— 11 C indocti, C 2 docti — 13 C 1 et ex vita hac ita, etc., C 2 et ex vita hac ex hospitio discedo non tanquam domo — 14 e] om.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.96, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261792:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261792", "s": "G. 2. 10. 5: \"persuader! ut . . . . morarentur neque .... ferrent;\" B, C. 3. 92. 2: \" praedixerat ut . . . . exclperent neque .... moverent,\" Livy's Use of Neqve and Neve 311 per cent.);", "prev": "Caec. 52: \"suadebit tibi ut . . . . discedas neque respondeas;\" De or. 1. 19: \"hortemur ut . . . . oomplectantur jiegtte .... confidant.\" Caesar B.", "next": "Caesar 11 times consecutive, twice final (15.4 per cent.);", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.691, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261803:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261803", "s": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 348 Book Reviews honestly say that any of them seems to me convincing, but the discus- sion of crucial passages which accompanies them is scholarly and suggestive.", "prev": "JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico.", "next": "Renkema naturally deals with many of the points raised by Langen's usually trustworthy commentary (1890), and his criticisms appear to me to raise real questions and to open up solutions which may be right.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.168, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261803:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261803", "s": "He has thus completed a necessary preliminary task, and obtained the convincing results that the book drew largely from the most", "prev": "The author has sought everywhere to establish real or reported facts as the points of departure for such incidents and episodes in the romance as are not mere errors of composition; and he holds the attitude and bias of Ptolemaic Alexandria mainly responsible for the shape these facts finally assumed.", "next": "", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.981, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261809:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261809", "s": "Book Keviews 357 have been able to subject them to such an examination, they have in most cases carried conviction — as was of course to be expected.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.", "next": "In a work of this sort, where there are so many hundreds of references of the most diverse kinds, it seems to be impossible to avoid errors of citation and there are a number in this book.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.179, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261433:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261433", "s": "Some may be only plausible or possible. 1 Schenkl 25. 20: o-vvderov yap «rri to vSuip « re tov vwop.evovTos koi tov avriKeip-evov T(5 elSei tu> evvTrdp\\ovri pteXXovTOs dcpos yevrjo-ecrOai.", "prev": "The majority are I think certain.", "next": "We must read Tip ewvdp)(eiv (or ewirdp£eiv) p.eXXovri aepos yevop.evov.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.541, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262421:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262421", "s": "I am convinced that a full understanding of the meaning of the word will justify its position, that it has no connection in thought with iniuria and contumelia but a connotation that makes cupiditas and petulantia congenial company.", "prev": "Leo asserts that this is out of place, that its asso- ciation is properly with iniuria (29) and contumelia (30).", "next": "The idea best suited to the grouping here is suggested in Capt. 583: est miserorum ut male- volentes sint atque invideant bonis; cf. malevolentia et invidia Sail.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.731, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262421:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262421", "s": "Leo rather plausibly emends to inertia (Archivfiir lat.", "prev": "Ineret etiam is usually read as inerit etiam (Lindsay notes that the MSS reading may represent inhaeret).", "next": "Lex.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.765, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262421:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262421", "s": "Peescott before us in the prologue: inopia is not necessarily the poverty of the inops or pauper amator, but the condition of being without the object of one's love whether through lack of money or any other cause; this appears also from this same play 650, 651: Eutychus tries to persuade Charinus not to go into exile on account of his losing his sweetheart; quid tu ais? quid quom illuc quo nunc ire paritas veneris, | si ibi amare forte occipias atque item eius sit inopia, iam inde porro auf ugies, . . . . ?", "prev": "The asso- ciation of iurgium and inopia may well justify the arrangement 20 Hbney W.", "next": "This sort of inopia is not limited to our play; cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.8, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262421:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262421", "s": "Studies in the Grouping of Nouns in Plautus 23 870, persuasit maeror anxitudo, error dolor Accius 349, mihi maerores illi luctum, exitium illi exsilium mihi Ennius Trag. 230 K. 5.", "prev": "Bohnenblust Beitrage zwm Topos wepl <pMas (Bern Diss., Berlin, 1905), p. 11. 2 This established fact must be the starting-point of any interpretation of the grouping ; it at once prevents any such chiastic grouping as Leo suggests.", "next": "Exsilium inopia. — The passage from Ennius just quoted shows how congenial this pair is to the preceding pair.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.927, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262422:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262422", "s": "(Quum dicis decern, unguem indicis in medio figes artu pollicis.) 2 A comparison of the figurative passage of Jerome with the prosaic instruction of Bede furnishes convincing proof that each was familiar with the same method of the representation of numbers.", "prev": "Centum vero in dextra quemadmodum decern in laeva facies.", "next": "To return to Augustine, one somewhat indirect proof of the frequent use of \"finger-counting\" may be cited.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.801, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262423:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262423", "s": "Soph. ii. 31). 2 Book ii in Schepers' edition, the numbering of which I follow throughout. 8 The title, (k twv Al\\tavov Aypoi.Ki.Kwv (TcurTohdv shows that these twenty letters formed part of a larger collection. 34 Campbell Bonnek Thus he argues very plausibly (pp. 34 ff.) that in four letters (13-16), which depict the character of a crusty and misanthropic farmer, Aelian has derived several ideas from the Timon of Lucian.", "prev": "May not an argument for their authenticity be drawn from the phrase chosen by Philostratus to describe his style? i/TTlKi}€ Si fixnrep of £i> tt} iitaoyelq. 'A0r)vaTot (Vit.", "next": "But when he finds in the fact that Aelian gave another name to his churl a proof that he was carefully concealing his debt to Lucian, it is impossible to follow him (p. 35).", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.176, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262423:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262423", "s": "This will convince nobody who is versed in the history of literary forms, and it may well be doubted whether Reich himself would employ such reasoning today.", "prev": "In the first place, Reich infers from Aelian's unquestioned inferi- ority to Alciphron in style and diction that the poorer artist imi- tated the abler (p. 39).", "next": "Again, Reich calls attention (pp. 42 ff.) to the fact that Aelian represents his characters as Attic farmers (Ep. 20), but fails to produce the local color of Attica, as Alciphron does, by intelligent allusions to Attic festivals, place-names, etc.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.238, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262424:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262424", "s": "Birt's other arguments, though plausible, have not convinced all scholars, and further light, if it can be obtained, will not be without interest.", "prev": "It may be remarked that seventeen of these show IIII for III, and only five show III for IIII.", "next": "After giving evidence tending to show that the first book remained separate from the rest of the elegies during antiquity, Birt (op. cit., p. 425) remarks that the Tetrabiblos was better known and more widely read than the Monobiblos.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.423, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262426:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262426", "s": "XXVIII, p. 554. 2 Dass seit Gründung der Tempel die Berge um ein gutes Stück kleiner geworden sind, ist hier ausser Acht gelassen worden; es hat keinen Zweck, wenn man mit Bruchteilen einer Sekunde rechnet, und davon überzeugt ist, das die Minuten nicht genau sind.", "prev": "Mus.", "next": "Die Abnahme beträgt aber jedenfalls mehr als 1, o. m. für das Jahr- tausend. 8 Die Richtung der Axe fällt gerade in die Passhöhe des Weges von Capaccio-Rocca d'Aspide (Pino di Vesole) ; der etwa 100 m höhere Mte.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.737, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262430:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262430", "s": "I am now convinced that the remedy is simpler, though the resulting sense is the same: for KaXSs, read kSXXw.", "prev": "Because of the words just quoted I had thought of ttovtcos as probably displaced by xaAius, by a sort of dittography, as KaAak stands, and properly stands, at the head of the following verse.", "next": "\"and yet your parents have left you in the lurch, though they are at 'the term of life' to die in any case, but nobly save their son and win them ame in dying.\" Alcestis pointedly suggests that they should make a Notes and Discussions 85 virtue of necessity and live on in fama super stes.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.552, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262442:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262442", "s": "The attempt, however, to show that the order of the whole was iii, iva; ivfe, ii, v, vi; vii, i, is far from convincing.", "prev": "Definite references of Seneca to the order in which different parts of the subject are presented make it probable that Book iii was written before iva, ivfe before ii, v before vi, vii before i.", "next": "It is maintained as certain — and this is the corner-stone of the argument — that the preface of Book iii was the introduction to the whole work.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.382, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "At any rate they found Rome's reasons inadequate, and felt the necessity of adding others more plausible in the light of contemporaneous politics.", "prev": "The motives of the Romans in entering upon the war were seemingly not clearly understood by the historians of a hundred years later.", "next": "To illustrate this point, I shall con- trast the account of Polybius with the accounts of later writers.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.134, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "Colin's view that the publicani had learned through their business in Sicily to desire increase in domain is not plausible.", "prev": "The civilization that brought forth the Porcian legislation and the laws forbidding senators to engage in commerce could hardly require many of the products of the East.", "next": "We know that Sicily had hitherto been a burden, not a source of wealth.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.294, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "Mao. 9. 3, Paus. vii. 8. 1, Just. xxix. 2, Livy xxx. 25. 14, will be convinced that there was much of this suspicion, even if he attributes half of the language he there finds to vaticinia ex eventu.", "prev": "Now, anyone who reads Pol. x. 25, App.", "next": "Nevertheless, Greek suspicion does not prove the Romans hypocrites.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.34, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "If then we re-read the sources of the second Macedonian war, pruning out the various anachronisms from the ancient and modern narratives, I think we shall be convinced that the war was not inspired to any appreciable degree by a policy of expan- sion, be it political or commercial, and that, in the treaty of peace and in the final settlement, Rome shows no intention of exacting terms or establishing conditions which shall involve her in future arbitrament of Greek affairs.", "prev": "In the spirit in which the senate later refused to accept the gifts of domain when offered by Bocchus and Ptolemy, in that spirit the senate now, regardless of the dictates of philhellenism, kept its hands off eastern territory.", "next": "We now come to the war with Antiochus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.532, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "The speech minimizes the atrocities of Philopoemen's treatment of Sparta, it incorrectly implies that Rome's intervention in Achaean affairs was uninvited, and, what is palpably false, it claims that the Achaean generals were not responsible for the massacre of the eighty Spartan envoys at Compasium. 1 Thus Polybius with commendable devotion to the cause writes a persua- 1 Philopoemen's responsibility in the massacre may be established by a careful examination of Polybius' own account of the affair (as it appears in Livy xxxviii. 33) careful though he is not to mention his hero's name.", "prev": "His prejudice appears unmistakably in the famous speech which he attributes to his father (see Livy xxxix. 36, apparently a direct translation from Polybius) .", "next": "Note the impersonal way in which it is described : cum auersis auribus pauca locuti essent, damnati omnes et traditi sunt ad supplicium.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.725, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "When Claudius arrived, Lycortas in the pres- ence of the league defended the course of Achaea toward Sparta with arguments that gained much applause, but were far from convincing to the Roman.", "prev": "Livy xxxix. 33) .", "next": "Claudius' answer was brief and brutal: dum liceret uoluntate sua facere gratiam inirent ne mox inuiti et coacti facerent (Livy xxxix. 37).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.855, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261822:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261822", "s": "A Chapter in the Story op Roman Imperialism 137 the Fabian school of Philopoemen, proposed trying persuasion with the Romans again.", "prev": "The senate, however, showed no resentment at this refusal.", "next": "His motion carried, but, unfortunately for his plan, his enemy Oallicrates secured the first place on the new embassy.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.937, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261824:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261824", "s": "Croiset, as I have said, accepts the dialogue as giving us, in con- junction with the Hermotimus an account of a moral crisis in Lucian's life, when philosophy aroused in him an emotional excite- ment and almost persuaded him to throw in his lot with her.", "prev": "He maintains that \"historisch ist darin nur der wesenttiche Inhalt von Nigrinus Vortrag,\" but it is not clear why the destructive criticism which he applies to the historic aspect of the rest of the dialogue should not be extended to cover the whole.", "next": "We are, according to him, to consider it literally true that Lucian at the age of twenty-five, having up to that time paid little attention to spiritual matters, heard from Nigrinus the discourse which he reports to us, and experienced a moral revolution:^ II lui sembla tout-a,-coup que tout ce qu'il avait esp6r6 ou poursuivi jusque \\k n'6tait qu'illusion, et que le tranquille detachment dont Nigr", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.792, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261824:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261824", "s": "He was not concerned to adhere with servility to the Attic vocabulary and syntax, but admitted some words and constructions that had come into use in his day and were necessary for the vitalization of his style.' On the whole he wrote with greater precision, with completer flexi- bility and with more convincing ease in the use of his medium than any Greek prose author since Demosthenes.", "prev": "He chose the longer road to rhetoric, following in the footprints of Plato and Demosthenes, and the result is his amazing Attic style.", "next": "After all necessary deductions are made it would be difficult to find ground for a serious charge against the sophistic training, if Lucian's works were our only evidence as to what it could do for a man.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.976, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261825:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261825", "s": "Photius says that Josephus is pure in his style, masterly in giving the effect of dignity combined with clearness and charm, and is convincing and pleasing in his speeches .... fertile in enthymemes on either side and sententious if any man ever was; also most able to represent passions by his discourse and skilled at arousing and soothing the emotions.", "prev": "Jerome.", "next": "The long eulogy of Arrian 1 may be quoted entire to illustrate Photius' command of the technical language of criticism.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.281, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261825:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261825", "s": "Kal ^Bovrj<! airocrTa^ovaai).'''' Athanasius: 5 \"His letters are composed in a style refined, bril- liant and clear, being convincing and blooming with charm (fiera tov %aplevTO<; avOovaai) .\" Philip: 6 \"He is a spouter of words (7ro\\v%ov?) without urban- ity or grace, and is nauseating (•w/joo-ko/s^?).\" Philostorgius: 7 \"He drags down {yrrocrvpeaOai) the hearer ek to a<ra<pe?", "prev": "His epistles drip with grace and charm (j(apiTO<;", "next": "Kal ovk ael ^apiei'.\" Philostratus: 8 \"Teeming with sweetness {/3pva)v y\\vkvt??to?) .\" Andronicianus: 9 \"He makes great promises in his introduction which are not fulfilled.\" John Philoponus : 10 MaAAov 8k /xaratoTovos!", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.788, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261825:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261825", "s": "He divides his farce into four parts and therein says nothing convincing or sensible.", "prev": "He babbles like a fool and talks insolently.", "next": "For the unfortunate John, Photius feels a more than theological hatred.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.813, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261826:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261826", "s": "The arrangement suggested seems plausible, though I know of no certain case of two inscriptions on a base one below the other.", "prev": "As a result he again econo- mized by making the next line as wide as the stone would allow, at the same time crowding his letters.", "next": "Perhaps C.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.597, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261828:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261828", "s": "A study on the spot from the point of view of a practical general of what was likely to take place con- sidering the local topography and the relative position of the two armies convinced Stoffel that after their first unsuccessful encounter with the Romans the Helvetii retreated to an elevation in the direction of the present village of Montmort and that there occurred the second conflict.", "prev": "Gall. i. 23) was eighteen miles from the point where he left the pursuit of the Helvetians, and by Stoffel's discovery in 1886 of a Roman intrenchment, apparently thrown up hastily, on the hill of Armecy.", "next": "Caesar's words are, \"Tandem vulneribus defessi et pedem referre et, quod mons suberat circiter mille passuum, eo se recipere coeperunt \" (Bell.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.283, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261839:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261839", "s": "The assertion of the editor's opinion that the apparent independence of Bland, is due solely to the accident that this part of the Satires is missing in A B and C, and that if they had contained the passage they would undoubtedly have shown the same reading, will convince no one.", "prev": "Not even Vollmer himself follows this classification to its logical conclusions, for while he does not concede any independent value to Bland., he adopts in Serin. 1. 6. 126 the reading campum lusumque trigonem for which it is the sole authority.", "next": "Professor Vollmer does not claim finality for his work.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.269, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261839:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261839", "s": "The seventh and ninth books, with the last ten chapters of the eighth, which had been called in question by Aubert and Wimmer, are also rejected, upon convincing grounds.", "prev": "Dittmeyer agrees with previous scholars in regarding the tenth book as spurious.", "next": "The text is a painstaking and, on the whole, a conservative one, though occasionally an ill-considered departure from the manuscript readings is found, as for instance the emendation of avdpanros to yiVvos, A 1, 488 a 27, which seems to rest upon a misconception of the force of da\" which here 218 Book Reviews no doubt means \"throughout life,\" not \"in all instances.\" The context readily shows that ", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.526, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261839:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261839", "s": "Not a few convincing emendations are found, as, for example, SxTKapiBiov A 1, 487 6 5 for oujttiSw of the best manuscripts.", "prev": "In the present work they are repeatedly distinguished from, and contrasted with, Terpd- no8a, \"four-footed animals.\" Lack of continuity with the main thread of the narrative seems hardly adequate ground for rejecting such passages as B 15, 506 a 26 to 31 and B 17, 508 b 4 to 8, in a treatise which is, as Dittmeyer himself points out, Preface xxv, preliminary notes for a finished work.", "next": "Bekker with some manuscript authority had read i/nrl&w.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.729, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262392:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262392", "s": "Hie simulatque imperii potitus est, persuasit Lacedae- moniis ut (Nepos Ages. 2. 1.) Tum victu revocant vires fusique per herbam Implentur veteris Bacchi pinguisque ferinae.", "prev": "Nam Lysandro suffragante Agesilaus antelatus est.", "next": "Postquam exempta fames epulis mensaeque remotae, Amissos longo socios sermone requirunt.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.228, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262393:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262393", "s": "Reich's argument upon the relation of Longus and Alciphron, as illustrated by the above passages, is about as follows (pp. 53, 55, 65 f.): Longus studied Theocritus closely and imitated him freely — a point which Reich demonstrates in an interesting and thoroughly convincing manner (pp. 56-65).", "prev": "But a pas- sage much more similar in feeling to the above quotations from Longus and Alciphron is Theocr. vi. 44 f.: ttipXeSi'T' €v (juiXaKa ral Troprm avriKa woUj..", "next": "Alciphron, on the other hand, shows only an occasional and superficial reminiscence of Theocritus (p. 55).", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.26, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262395:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262395", "s": "Arval., p. 93, 94), the ablative of the thing offered is especially cogent evidence for the vigor of the ablative construction with verbs of \"sacrificing ;", "prev": "Plautus Poem. 451 \"s. ullum turis granum;\" immolare: in view of the original meaning of this verb= 'to pour meal on' (cf. particularly Henzen Acta Frat.", "next": "\" examples, to say nothing of literary instances which may be turned up in the lexica (see particularly Ateius Capita, ap.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.204, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262398:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262398", "s": "We get by this change, instead of a monstrosity for which no plausible etymology can be suggested, a good epic word; for, though the compound in Ik- is not used by Homer, it is found in Hesiod Sc. 44.", "prev": "Let us first consider the form.", "next": "The change was produced by a metathesis of t and X, and Kkorwreuav was further changed to K\\oT07revav through the analogy of ^irep-07revav.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.941, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262399:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262399", "s": "We get by this change, instead of a monstrosity for which no plausible etymology can be suggested, a good epic word; for, though the compound in Ik- is not used by Homer, it is found in Hesiod Sc. 44.", "prev": "Let us first consider the form.", "next": "The change was produced by a metathesis of t and X, and Kkorwreuav was further changed to K\\oT07revav through the analogy of ^irep-07revav.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.295, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262400:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262400", "s": "Trist. iv. 5. 22, and other passages mentioned, for example, in Pritzsche's large edition, but by a convincing passage in Theocritus' contemporary, ApoUonius Khodius i. 644, which so far as I am aware has escaped the notice of commentators and of students of the Daphnis legend.", "prev": "Ovid Amor. iii. 9. 27;", "next": "The poet digresses to describe the herald Aethalides, whose memory was unfailing whether he was on earth or in the other world: owS' ETt vvv TTtp aTTOixo/xeyov 'A^epovTOi Siva's Snrpo(j>a.TOvi ^v^v iTnSiSpofi,£ XriO-q.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.528, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262366:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262366", "s": "To turn first to the Commentarius antiquior: Everyone will agree, I am convinced, with Schlee and Wolfflin, that the pref- atory explanations are by one author.", "prev": "Such comments appear in the later folios of D and E, and come, Schlee believes, from some complete commentary of the eleventh century or later, of which various MSS in Rome, Munich, and Paris give evidence.", "next": "If so, though it is conceivable that the original work consisted merely of scene intro- ductions, it is more probable that with due allowance for accre- tions, the bulk of the scholia belongs to the same author.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.081, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262366:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262366", "s": "No positive statement can be made on the basis of our present material, but I am convinced that in general it is safe to use the Halensis as the fundament for an edition, with the other MSS for corroboration.", "prev": "Bruns notes carefully certain additions in a much later hand,^ and in one or two instances the scholia of the first hand include comments not in the original work.", "next": "Proceeding on this plan, we may analyze the contents of the Commentum Brunsianum [Com.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.312, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262366:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262366", "s": "Rand preserved in the Monacensis,' and it agrees substantially with that included by Schlee^ in his Commentarius recentior; the only divergences are \"quia quando\" for \"et cum\" (1. 7) and the omission (accidental, I am convinced) of \"et . . . . vero\" (11. 12— 14).", "prev": "K.", "next": "The latter work, therefore, to which I will henceforth refer as the Expositio, the name used by Sabbadini, borrowed the argu- ment from Com.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.629, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262371:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262371", "s": "B. das As diriov iv X«p<\" TiOa (446), das, von der Riickgabe eines erwachsenen Madchens gesagt, allzu sehr KaTaxptio-TutZs ist.\" This comment of Cauer's would be perfectly cogent, if the true rendering of the phrase were \"put her in the arms of her father,\" a rendering given in the notes of most editors in America; cf. editions of Seymour and Sterrett.", "prev": "Auflage), p. 492: \"Fast alle Verse dieser Partie kommen ganz oder stuckwise auch anderwarts vor, und zwar vielfach dort passender als hier; so z.", "next": "A young woman of the maturity of Chryseis would have been a heavy burden in the arms of her father, by pre-eminence 6 yipu>v.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.712, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262372:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262372", "s": "B. das As diriov iv X«p<\" TiOa (446), das, von der Riickgabe eines erwachsenen Madchens gesagt, allzu sehr KaTaxptio-TutZs ist.\" This comment of Cauer's would be perfectly cogent, if the true rendering of the phrase were \"put her in the arms of her father,\" a rendering given in the notes of most editors in America; cf. editions of Seymour and Sterrett.", "prev": "Auflage), p. 492: \"Fast alle Verse dieser Partie kommen ganz oder stuckwise auch anderwarts vor, und zwar vielfach dort passender als hier; so z.", "next": "A young woman of the maturity of Chryseis would have been a heavy burden in the arms of her father, by pre-eminence 6 yipu>v.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.57, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262378:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262378", "s": "And finally, as significant of Schroeder's criteria in constructing his schemes, take one of his statements of principle on p. 158: \"Messen kann man den Umfang eines metrischen Gebildes nicht nach der in der sprachlichen Ausstattung vorliegenden Summe von langen und kurzen Silben, sondern, auf Grand versgeschichtlicher Her- leitung, allein nach der Zahl der in ihnen erklingenden oder latenten Hebungen, wobei auf die aus silbenzahlenden Versen stammenden urspriinglich viersilbigen Metren aolichen oder ionischen Stiles immer zwei Hebungen fallen.\" It will be seen that this, however plausible in ", "prev": "To all this add a fondness for the more complicated systems of nomenclature adopted by the later metri- cists, in preference to rhythmical analysis in the manner of Aristoxenos, and a disdain for all endeavors toward simplicity and freedom from ambiguity in notation.", "next": "With its context this reminds one of the most arbi- trary eurhythmy of J.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.417, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262378:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262378", "s": "The argument is enforced usually by cogent examples, but a more elaborate treatment is needed to insure conviction.", "prev": "This tradition, however, is blurred: in the larger part of the first two books the MSS show the effects of \" contamination.\" The conclusion is that the two families are equally serviceable; the z family is less trustworthy; the x family represents the \"traditional\" text : if the readings of the two families are intrinsically equivalent, the x family is to be preferred.", "next": "Remembering the value of so-called inferior MSS revealed by the papyri, we cannot feel that in such a complicated situation as the editor discov- ers his text should be determined very largely by a theory of MSS tradi- tion.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.958, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "And the latter have usu- ally contented themselves with suggesting the most plausible inter- pretation of the text before them without considering the other instances.", "prev": "The discussion of the matter has greatly suffered from being conducted (for the most part) by means of brief notices in the periodicals or of such notes as the editors of the three (extant) plays in question could find room for.", "next": "Of course, it is conceivable that the numbers were not uniformly derived or that their arrangement was a purely arbitrary one; and in that case its recovery would now be neither possible nor, if possible, particularly valuable.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.071, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "This last instance is the most plausible one for the theory, since among Euripides' extant titles ^Einleitung in die griech, TragOdie (Heracles, Vol.", "prev": "Korte would refer it to an alphabetical arrange- ment.^ Ranke' had made this suggestion for the Aves numeral long ago, and Wex* brought it forward again after the publication of the Alcestis numeral in 1834.", "next": "I, Isted.), p. 150, note 55: \"Zwei notizen scheinen darauf zu fuhren, dass die tragodien auch eine laufende num- mer ftlhrten, in der hypothesis der Alkestis .... und in der der Antigone .... aber Bie haben sich bisher jeder deutung entzogen.\" Analecta Euripidea, p. 133: \"Opi- nantur sane vulgo, propter iiroiiiBri illud potissimum, numeris illis quota f abula a poeta conscripta sit indicari, et qu", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.089, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "Numerals in Gkeek Dramatic Hypotheses 11 advice and in a most convincing manner ; cf . his Oxford edition of Aristophanes II, pp. 524 f.: \"Est igitur qui in libris traditur numerus Xe aperte corruptus et, si quid litterarum ductibus tribu- endum, fortasse restituto te' corrigendus.", "prev": "Greece I, p. 449, n. 1.", "next": "Ita ad novem, quas Avibus antiquiores esse fabulas ex didascaliis constat, quinque aliae de ceteris accedere debebunt.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.557, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "We thus obtain an adequate and plausible explanation for an error that has caused scholars much trouble.", "prev": "Therefore, I conclude [we may represent Anonymous as saying] that in his second attempt Aristophanes fared still worse than before and was awarded fourth or fifth place.", "next": "It remains to point out that such an arrangement as I have suggested would not have seemed an unnatural thing to the ancients.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.793, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "Rex 808), my explanation gains plausibility.", "prev": "Oed.", "next": "But however this may be, I think there can be little doubt that Pollux and Photius had this line of the Clouds in mind.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.929, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261883:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261883", "s": "On the other hand, parallels to justify interpreting e as a numeral are little more convincing.", "prev": "Cf.' aSa^a-ai- TO KVTJdax, ovK Iv Tio <^o^ oSa^rjiTai .... ' KpuTTo4>avrfi iv 'OXkoxtw, and dA.oa- (xavTa- (V Tm a, ^ipexparrp Iwvw .... dXo^aai iv rm rj.", "next": "Plays are regularly cited in the dative case either with or without the preposition €v.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.963, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261884:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261884", "s": "Lib. xxvi: 3, 8, more ras. ex morte || 4, 3, nequaqua ras. ex nequaq. da || 4, 3, uince P 1 uincere P 2 sed ras. uince restitutum est || 4, 5, se ras. ex ses || 4, 10, q. ras. ex quiin || 5, 8, quae ras. ex quaes || 8, 4, yre ras. ex tyre || 8, 6, qui ras. ex quiqui || 8, 7, opsideretur ras. ex opsideren- tur || 11, 12, breuis ras. ex breuiuis || 12, 18, litteraeque ras. ex litterae- quae || 12, 19, manibusque ras. ex manibusquae || 13, 18, a cruciatu ras. ex acscruciatu || 15, 9, peruasit ras. ex persuasit || 15, 10, turn ras. ex tuum I 15, 10, legatae ras. ex legataes || 16, 8, ager ras. ex ", "prev": "P 1 arreptisque P 2 quod nunc erasum est || 30. 11, e ras. ex se || 32, 8, tertia ras. ex tertiae || 32, 8, adiunctis ras. ex adiunctiis || 36, 16, cnaeum P b supra u scripta rursus erasa || 37, 1, deleti ras. ex delectis || 37, 13, haec ras. ex haeo || 39, 3, ignes ras. ex signaes || 39, 7, captis ras. ex capitis || 39, 7, altera ras. ex alteram.", "next": "P || 18, 10, impetus ras. ex imperat impetus || 19, 4, sine ras. ex sitne || 21, 4, meriti ras. ex meritis || 21, 7, uis P 1 uas P 2 mine ras. uis restitutum || 22, 8, requiesse ras. ex requiessem || 22, 13, marcellu ras. ex marcellus || 22, 15, consulere ras. ex consulerere || 24, 13, etholis ras. ex etholiis || 24, 15, satis ras. ex satiss || 25, 2, altergo ras. ex saltergo P 1 alterno P 2 * || ", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.431, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261885:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261885", "s": "It is vital to our problem that in Tr. 447-65, where Ovid is defend- ing himself for his own practice in the Ars amatoria and would there- fore choose as convincing an example as possible, he does not choose Tib. i. 4, 2 a completely didactic elegy, but i. 6, only part of which is didactic.", "prev": "When, therefore, he assumes the role of praeceptor and instructs each sex how to make love success- fully, both role and teachings are the results of abundant suggestions from his predecessors.", "next": "The conclusion is irresistible that Ovid regarded as praecepta not alone entire elegies written from the didactic point of view, but also all passages (parts of elegies) in which the poet assumes the role of erotic expert and instructor — the passages in which, if I may desecrate a term, he speaks ex cathedra.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.218, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261886:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261886", "s": "The argu- ment from similarity of vocabulary is generally deemed most cogent and has not been seriously questioned.", "prev": "Nearly everyone who has discussed the tenth book in recent years has emphasized this point.", "next": "The purpose of this paper is to extend to each book of the Iliad the investigation which has been given to Kappa, and also in a less degree to Iota, Psi, and Omega.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.113, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261888:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261888", "s": "The one which at once suggested itself to me appears convincing.", "prev": "A different explanation must be found.", "next": "Let us turn back in until we reach an interstice.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.404, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261894:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261894", "s": "I cannot hope to convince all students of Plautus that the last three syllables of incen- dium may be treated as a dactylic foot in this verse; perhaps some will object to the complete absorption of (t)uom in the first syllable of incendes ; so only will Lambinus' verse scan.", "prev": "Of course, editors have been slow to adopt Lambinus' suggestion, not only because they question the authenticity of the MSS evidence, but also because the verse involves us in metrical difficulties.", "next": "But I may remind the incredulous that the dactyl in question stands in the fifth foot of a trochaic septenarius, and that Seyffert and Skutsch (r«pas, p. 137, n. 4) in spite of Leo (PI.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.804, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262188:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262188", "s": "Viel mehr als mit Sophokles ist Aischylos geistesverwandt mit seinem Zeitgenossen Pindar: Pindars Prophetengeist schaute in gläubiger Hoffnung nach einem seligen Jenseits, das, wenn auch nach langen Mühen, dem müden Erdenwanderer als rettender Ruheport winkte, und die tiefsinnige Feuerseele des Tragikers rang dem Weltlauf trotz Sünde und Tod eine Theodizee ab, überzeugt von dem Dasein einer weisen Gottheit, die in dem hinter der Erscheinungswelt liegenden Dunkel in Gerechtigkeit die Fäden des Schicksals spinnt.", "prev": "[Classical Philology V, April, 1910] 129 130 Wilhelm Nestle bei genauerem Zusehen ein sehr erheblicher Unterschied zwischen der Religiosität der beiden letztern Dichter.", "next": "Beide Dichter ergriffen mit Innigkeit die geläuterten religiösen Vorstellungen der orphischen Mystik und erhoben sich dadurch über den Volksglauben, dessen unreine Züge sie zu beseitigen, zu mildern oder mit schon- endem Schweigen zu übergehen bestrebt waren, in einer wenn auch noch so pietätvollen Kritik.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.041, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262192:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262192", "s": "Mart. vi. 11. 202 Paul Nixon or twice convincingly sincere, but always musical, Herrick's verses, gay or plaintive, pensive or triumphant, complimentary or advisory, to his fair, imaginary mistresses will probably never lose their place among the most captivating and delightful trifles in the language.", "prev": "\"748;", "next": "Through them we first become acquainted with the poet ; to them we most frequently return; and in them, in their number as in their form and content, we have further and conclusive evidence that the prevailing interests and the real genius of the poet were not akin to Martial's.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.97, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262193:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262193", "s": "He created plausible causes of delay, such as the request that they assist him in the work of reconciling the Pharsalians and Haliaians. 2 The demand of the Chalcidians in the inscription cited above set ten days as the maximum delay permissible at Athens before the Chalcidian embassies should be presented to the Boule and the Assembly.", "prev": "Philip himself was anxious to put off swearing the oath as long as possible until he had some Thracian fortresses in his power.", "next": "Consequently I conclude that in most cases even at Athens, where the demands upon the time of the Boule were great, ambassadorial business was customarily handled in a shorter time.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.519, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262152:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262152", "s": "After an analysis of the fragments with reference to the rule of three actors, the writer is convinced that the plays of Menander were written and exhibited regardless of any limitation of the number of actors allowed for their production.", "prev": "Wilamo- witz 2 has already called our attention to a situation in the Peri- ceiromena where the action seems to demand a fourth actor.", "next": "The internal evidence for a limitation of performers in the fifth- century tragedies and comedies, because of their inherent structure, might at first seem to be of considerable weight.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.078, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262152:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262152", "s": "K (vss. 595 ff .) ; vs. 632 Ta'^a S' elo-ofi' has the tone of an aside and is plausibly assigned to Moschion. lead me beyond the limits of this paper to enter into a detailed discussion of the distribution of these lines among the characters.", "prev": "Moschion's eaves-dropping on the scene seems to begin with the interview between Glycera and Pataecus in frag.", "next": "But whatever arrangement of the lines we accept, we are forced, as it seems to me, to assume the presence of four characters upon the scene.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.503, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262157:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262157", "s": "Osthoff's discussion of the former (BB. 29, 266 f.) is not convincing, although he is very likely right in thinking that o is a graphical representation of U as distinct from Attic v; i. e., the two words should very likely be identified.", "prev": "The etymology of Cretan icofifia \"icopmvw\" Hesych., and Kvpfin, a bird, Emped., Hesych., is obscure.", "next": "They may con- tain our suffix.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.213, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262160:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262160", "s": "Such kings sometimes rule by virtue of hereditary right, sometimes by the election of the people, who, it may plausibly be said in a panegyric, give the offices to those whom they think the best.", "prev": "There is a presumption, then, that the \"kings\" which the ideal Athens 362 Notes and Discussions of Plato's encomium has \" always\" had are wise, authoritative rulers, not those technical survivors, the king archons, whose intrusion here would be irrelevant.", "next": "Simi- larly, Isocrates (12. 153) says: Kal rrjv ti 8r)p*>KpaTiav KaTa<TTr)<ravTOS Trap? avTois tt)v opidTOKpaTia. p£p.iyp.€vyjv, yyirtp tjv Trap' yp.lv, Kal Tas dp^os ov KX-qpm- tws aXX' atpcTos iroirjo-avTos- Cf .", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.597, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262169:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262169", "s": "The task is much more difficult in Latin comedy than in the Greek drama: the text-tradition, the ambiguity of Plautine prosody, militate against convincing conclusions;", "prev": "It is already clear that Sudhaus has applied to the cantica of Plautus the methods and principles applied to the cantica of Greek drama by Schroeder.", "next": "\"es will auch gar nicht schnell tiberzeugen,\" the author admits, and asks only for careful testing of his theory.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.946, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262170:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262170", "s": "The task is much more difficult in Latin comedy than in the Greek drama: the text-tradition, the ambiguity of Plautine prosody, militate against convincing conclusions;", "prev": "It is already clear that Sudhaus has applied to the cantica of Plautus the methods and principles applied to the cantica of Greek drama by Schroeder.", "next": "\"es will auch gar nicht schnell tiberzeugen,\" the author admits, and asks only for careful testing of his theory.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.352, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261260:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261260", "s": "The Boeotian Federal Constitution 411 of those who see in the Lycian council and the Achaean Congress (<rvi/o8os) representative bodies become more plausible. 1 In any event this single instance of true representative government shows conclusively that the representative principle is not a modern discovery.", "prev": "But he underestimates the importanceof garrison service.", "next": "There is no trace of a Boeotian popular assembly; in both local and federal matters the senates were supreme.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.49, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261260:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261260", "s": "Glotz very plausibly suggests (op. cit. 272, note 2) that the Boeotian federal court served as a model for the central court of the second Athenian confederacy.", "prev": "Freeman op. cit. 163.", "next": "If this is true it would tend to confirm the opinion of those who maintain that this court was composed of both Athenian and allied representatives.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.714, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261261:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261261", "s": "And I am convinced that the pallor and flatness, the strange futility as of a bungling artist who cannot get a thing said although he keep talking round it — all this means not that the Culex is a bad picture, but that the picture is sorely in need of cleaning. 2.", "prev": "Yet there were glimmerings of beauty in it sufficient to move [Classical Philology V, October, 1910] 418 The Text of the Cvlbx 419 Spenser to do it into English.", "next": "I premise then that the Culex is a gravely, exceptionally corrupt text.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.087, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261261:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261261", "s": "In a good text such as Virgil or Terence it is folly to multiply conjectures; in a moderately good text such as Propertius, the onus probandi is strong on each conjecture; but in a text as bad as I believe the Culex to be, and starting from the axiom that Virgil is the author, I venture to think we may a priori plausibly redress the poem to conform metrically and in style of language to a period between the Lucretian-CatuUine and the matured Virgilian.", "prev": "In 324 for Hectoreo victor lustravit corpora Troiam all our MSS give Hectora lustravit victor de corpora Troiam which shows not honest corruption but bad patching, and so on: instances are innumerable.", "next": "That is to say, such broken-backed verses as: perfidiam lamentandi mala : perfide multis and iret inevectus caelum super: omne propinquo and mente prius docta fastidiat et probet illi .... stand self-condemned, inviting emendation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.119, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261261:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261261", "s": "If in even one or two of them I can convince the reader that emendation gives Latinity and coherence to what was solecistic nonsense, he will, I hope, admit the probability that the Culex only needs more emendation to be restored to coherence and Latinity throughout. 1-41: The structure of this exordium suggests that to vss. 11-23 Latonae magnique lovis decus, aurea proles containing the double invocation of Apollo and Pales, there were afterward added vss. 1-10 and 24-41, to serve some occasional pur- pose of the author's.", "prev": "Phillimore series of suggestions.", "next": "I suppose he had been praised to Octavian as a poet and was pressed to produce something which he might offer to the venerandus sanctus -puer:^ he had the Culex in his desk and furnished it with a suitable new headpiece.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.141, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261261:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261261", "s": "A remedy for mente prius docta is not so simple; but supposing menteprius to be an anagram for temperius, the small consequential change of docta into docto gives us a plausible Latin phrase to express \"precociously learned,\" the contrary of o^ifiaOi^^ as it were a irpaniiaOrji;.", "prev": "Five of these objections are removed by reading si quol non pauperis usus fastidia praebet ovilis.", "next": "O the jolly idleness of a shepherd — unless precocious learning puts a man out of conceit with the business of the humble sheep fold: O bona pastoris (si quoi non pauperis usus temperius docto fastidia praebet ovilis) Vs. 60: otia, luxiuiae spretis incognita curis quae lacerant avidas inimico pectore mentes ! mentes in vs. 61 now becomes unexceptionable, whether Leo's defense of inimico pectore be", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.38, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261262:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261262", "s": "Such a study, enforced by some general considerations, will result, I hope, in a more convincing explanation of the facts.", "prev": "Add to these Leo G.G.A. 1898 (I), Erotic Teaching in Eoman Elegy 445 bring out new aspects of these parallels.", "next": "In order to trace the course of this Greek influence those erotic motives must be studied in which the didactic tone is clear and for which a sufficient number of Greek parallels exist.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.465, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261264:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261264", "s": "In one case at least I am convinced that such an addition can be certainly ascribed to him.", "prev": "But after all, is it 472 Frank Egleston Bobbins unlikely that these interpolations are the work of the scribe of F?", "next": "From this it would appear that the scribe of F had a taste for such correction, and it is easier to postu- late that one man of such tastes revised the MS than to assume that there were two or more revisions of the same character.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.629, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261265:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261265", "s": "I am convinced that they did, but only in the B F family.", "prev": "Another question to be answered is, did indices, like the indices of B, exist in other MSS?", "next": "I can find absolutely no evidence for their exist- ence in M, V, or in the \"eight-book\" tradition. 2 In F, however, there are traces of the influence of indices, which in two or three places are quite convincing.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.544, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261265:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261265", "s": "I can find absolutely no evidence for their exist- ence in M, V, or in the \"eight-book\" tradition. 2 In F, however, there are traces of the influence of indices, which in two or three places are quite convincing.", "prev": "I am convinced that they did, but only in the B F family.", "next": "For the purposes of this paper it may be assumed without argument that B and F are closely akin, both descendants of a mutilated MS extending through v. 6, omitting iv. 26, and that Aldus' Paris manuscript was of the same family, but of an earlier branch, which left the main stem before the mutilation seen in B and F took place.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.546, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261267:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261267", "s": "I cannot expect that all readers will be convinced that my understanding of the thought is identical with the poet's intention.", "prev": "The epigram, of all the literary types, must suggest rather than explicitly set forth the transition in thought.", "next": "But my interpretation of ptoyai Kct'jreTos carries with it my understanding of rj\\0e.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.678, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261267:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261267", "s": "The former word is an emendation, but a very plausible conjecture involving slight change in the text, and in harmony with the conclusion of the epigram.", "prev": "But he came, too, marked by features that find no explanation in what we have as yet heard about him: he was Tpi^t- 8i.<l>0€ptai and /hovoA.ijkv^os.", "next": "What does Tptxi8i<^^ep«»s mean?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261267:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261267", "s": "If this evidence is scanty, the state- ment of Pollux (iv. 120) carries conviction: tois 8k irapaa-iTois Trpoa-ea-ri koL o-rAeyyis koX Xi^kvBos.", "prev": "Plautus Stick. 230-31; it is not possible to say whether a fragment of Aristophanes' AoiraXas (207 K.) is concerned with a parasite: ovS' ioTiv avTw <7TA.€yyis ovSe XrJKvOoi.", "next": "Movo\\'^kv6<k, therefore, like Tpixt8i(f>0epiai, suggests Phyromachus as he was known to the audience in the theater.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.845, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261268:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261268", "s": "The possible objection that the comparison, drawn from the sphere of divinity, would not be applied to mortals does not seem cogent in view of the thoroughgoing anthropomorphism with which human attributes and appurtenances are given to gods — from /?ow7r« or xp v(r °- Opovos Hera down to weapons of offense or defense, like this goat-skin arm- or chest -protector.", "prev": "That the aegis was at least not foreign to the poet's range of thought, as one of the scraps from the Homeric banquet-table, may be inferred from the fact that he makes reference to it in both of the other parts of this trilogy, i.e., Choeph. 593 and Eum. 404. 4.", "next": "In II. xviii. 204 Athena herself lends the aegis to a mortal, Achilles.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.582, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261286:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261286", "s": "Compare the following statements of Skutsch and Lindsay in reference to the pronunciation of words like uoluptatem: \"Everyone can convince himself by a practical experiment how difficult it is, when speaking with a certain degree of rapidity, to give its proper length to the middle syl- lable of a group consisting of - - - , if the first or the third syllable has an expiratory accent of the strength which we must ascribe to the Latin accent : one's own experi- ment will convince one better than a theoretical argument\" (Skutsch Forschungen 7).", "prev": "Historical Latin Grammar 34 f.", "next": "Lindsay says (Latin Language 201 f.) : \" The normal scansion of all these second syllables is that of classical poetry ; but the position of the syllable between a short syllable on the one hand and an accented syllable on the other made it especially liable to be slurred in pronunciation, so that the dramatic poets, who followed more closely the pronunciation of everyday life than others, felt th", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.274, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261286:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261286", "s": "In some cases, no doubt, a different division of syllables would get over the difficulty: a-psurde, Ale-xander, volu- ptatem, sene-ctutem, o-mnes, etc., are conceivable, though hardly plausible.", "prev": "ably to shorten a syllable which is long by position (i.e., closed by a consonant and followed by another consonant) is in some cases physically impossible except by dropping one or more of the consonants. 1 Are we then to suppose that the word apstulisti was pronounced a-stulisti in ordinary speech and in the Aulularia of Plautus, 1. 645 (Quid apstulisti hinc t beginning a trochaic septenarius) ?", "next": "But a-pstulisti is unpronounceable, and so is e-xprobras.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.523, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261287:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261287", "s": "Hirzel's view that \" way \" or \" custom \" is a derived rather than the original mean- ing of SUv is not convincing. 2 Anyone may resist attacks upon himself or his property.", "prev": "Maine op. eit. 5, and Hirzel op. cit. 57.", "next": "But the law requires that the resistance shall not be more than is sufficient for the purposes of self-defense ; for the prevention of a wrong, not its redress, is the object of self-defense.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.089, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261287:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261287", "s": "\"Without discussing at this point the various interpretations that have been offered, I shall present the explanation that seems to me to be the most plausible.", "prev": "Like all the scenes represented on the shield this really combines a series of pictures. 5 That is to say, several pictures would be required to illustrate the poet's description.", "next": "The text is given for convenience of refer- ence: 6 497 Axtot 8' civ ayopy 2<rav adpooi • Iv&a 8k viiKos otputpu, Svo 8' 5v8pK iveiKeov etvexa iroLvrjs dvSpos anro<j>6ilx,€vov • o /jjkv cv)(c.to iravr cwroSovvai l Il.sy\\. 387-88;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.526, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261288:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261288", "s": "This appears to be stated in all serious- ness, and we leave it to carry conviction as it may, without further comment.", "prev": "Pla- giarism by ® is decreed because in Z the description is \"magnificent,\" the poet calling special attention to Hector's o/fensive weapon as he visits his brother Paris, who is at the moment furbishing his defensive armour and bow.", "next": "It is added that Zenodotus did not read the lines in © — though it is difficult to see how they can be cut out.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.39, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261292:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261292", "s": "At the time this article was written it did not seem to him that the new names offered any additional points of contact between Hittite-Mitannian names and those \"pre-Greek\" names collected and discussed by Kretschmer, Einleitung in die Geschichte der griechischen Sprache, but further study has convinced him that this con- clusion was due to a too hasty examination of the material.", "prev": "The writer was especially interested in the new personal names furnished by these tablets; see a paper on \"Some Hittite and Mitannian Personal Names,\" The American Journal of Semitic Languages XXVI (January, 1910).", "next": "Names like Akissi, Sissi, Sizzi, Kanissi, Papassi, Kirbassi (AJSL XXVI, 97), certainly show the same ending as the names with the s-suffix in Kretschmer, op. cit., 311 f.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.264, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261916:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261916", "s": "Of what word or phrase Varro's gloss is an explanation we can only conjecture, but not without plausibility.", "prev": "That the Plautine Questions would scarcely afford occasion to consider satura as the name of a form of literature need not be said.", "next": "The archaic phrase per saturam is quoted from Laelius, from T.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.556, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261916:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261916", "s": "The Indignatio of Valerius Oato {ibid. 11) in the mouth of the editor of Lucilius, and with its suggestion of Juvenal's faeit indignatio, has the look of a Lucilian satire. 2 Let me say in passing that I feel convinced that the eight lines prefaced to i. 10 in a part of our text tradition are Horatian, and that the flctus adversarms of the poem is generalized from Oato and his school.", "prev": "At all events by the time Horace's second book appeared the usage had become sufficiently recognized in literary and gram- iThe satire of Lenaeus {Magni Pompei libertus) directed against Sallust belongs to this time (Suet, de gram. 15).", "next": "Thus, for example, simius iste would represent some character like Furius Bibaculus (whom Horace makes ridiculous in vs. 36), the faithful satellite of Cato and doctus cantare Catullum (cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.956, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261918:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261918", "s": "There could be no more cogent reason than these statistics for assigning the Iliad and Odyssey, the Urilias, and the additions to a single period, a period widely separated from the time of the origin of the poems of Hesiod and the Homeric Hymns.", "prev": "Homeric Hymns 4:1.", "next": "Such was the spell or pall cast by disintegrating criticism that Stummer, von Christ, and the reviewer passed coldly by these important results and saw nothing in them but a failure to reach anything of value.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.507, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261918:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261918", "s": "Not only is it impossible to separate the Iliad from the Odyssey on the basis of the definite article, but however plausible the test when apphed to individual books, as for example to K, the Doloneia, it breaks down at last, since Odyssey a and <o, two of the most despised books in Homer and presumably the latest, show the most restricted use of the definite article.", "prev": "From the above figures it is clear that the distance from Homer to Hesiod is many times greater than the distance from Hesiod to the Homeric Hymns, while the advance from the Iliad to the Odyssey is just that which might easily be made within the life of one man.", "next": "If the books of Homer could be dated by the use of the demonstra- tive pronoun as a definite article, then the oldest books would be Odyssey a, f, to, the latest would be Iliad A, K, A, X, '^.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.556, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Accord- ingly he defines rhetoric as \"a faculty of discerning all the possible means of persuasion in any subject\" (i. 2).", "prev": "Breitenbach books, and, on the other hand, the sophistical method, which involves numerous devices or tricks, such as introducing matters foreign to the issue but designed to work on the feelings of the audience. 1 In opposition to these methods he declares : \" It is clear then that the only proper subjects of artistic treatment are proofs\" (i. 1).", "next": "That no reference to the domain of form or expression is implied at this point is indicated by the threefold analysis of the subject which he immediately makes: \"The proofs provided through the instrumentality of the speech are of three kinds, consisting either in the moral character of the speaker, or in the production of a certain disposition in the audience or in the speech itself by real or ap", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.083, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Answering the question for the Rhetoric, we may say that, obviously, the aim and purpose is to produce persuasion.", "prev": "What is the effect on the hearer that he aims to produce by means of the speech ?", "next": "Indeed this is the essence of Aristotle's definition of rhetoric, \"a faculty of discerning all the possible means of per- 168 H.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.305, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Breitenbach suasion in any subject.\" 1 Now to be consistent with himself, Aris- totle should make the means of persuasion include only proofs appealing to the intellect.", "prev": "P.", "next": "In point of fact, he does this, as we have seen, at the outset of his treatise.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.311, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "The means of persuasion are to be confined to proofs appealing to the intellect.", "prev": "Evidently, then, Aristotle starts out with an intellectual point of view.", "next": "But in a very short time he shifts his position, and we find him admitting into consideration appeals to the emotions.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.349, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Its function is not to persuade but to discover the available means of persuasion in any subject.\" From what fol- lows, however, his meaning is clearly that it should succeed so far as is possible, although, like the art of medicine, it must sometimes fail.", "prev": "\"Strict justice, indeed, if applicable to rhetoric, would con- 1 In the previous chapter he has declared :\"....", "next": "The De Compositions of Dionysius 169 fine itself to seeking a delivery such as would cause neither pain nor pleasure.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.366, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "In short, the aim of the speaker is persuasion, and not by intellec- tual means alone.", "prev": "Here also another factor now comes to view — his low opinion of the popular audience as referred to above in the words, \"the depraved character (/j.ox0vpt av ) of the audience.\" This opinion is expressed with various degrees of candor in several other passages of the Rhetoric, e.g., ii. 21, iii. 16, iii. 14.", "next": "Aristotle goes even farther than to admit emo- tional appeals among the means of persuasion: he admits also \"apparent demonstration\" as well as \"real\"; by this he means fallacious or specious reasons, etc.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.4, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Aristotle goes even farther than to admit emo- tional appeals among the means of persuasion: he admits also \"apparent demonstration\" as well as \"real\"; by this he means fallacious or specious reasons, etc.", "prev": "In short, the aim of the speaker is persuasion, and not by intellec- tual means alone.", "next": "Examples of this \"sophistical\" element are to be found in iii. 14, 15, 16, etc.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.402, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:7", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Ac- cording to Aristotle, the attitude of the hearer is that of intellectual hedonism; the aim of the speaker is to produce persuasion, even by appeals to the emotions or by sophistical proofs; the discourse is organic in structure.", "prev": "The fundamental presuppositions of the two authors have now been set forth with reference to the three aspects of discourse.", "next": "According to Dionysius, the attitude of the hearer is that of artistic appreciation; that of the speaker corresponds, his aim being to produce artistic enjoyment; the discourse is archi- tectural in structure.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.632, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261919:8", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261919", "s": "Aristotle supposed on the hearer's part an intellectual attitude; in the speaker, the aim to persuade; in the discourse, an organic character.", "prev": "Both of them investigated the same phenomenon, Greek oratory, and in part they examined the same phase of it, the topic style; but their fundamental principles, as has been shown, are altogether diverse.", "next": "Dionysius requires in the hearer an aesthetic attitude; in the speaker, the aim to produce artistic effects; in the discourse, an architectural character.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.875, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261942:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261942", "s": "The whole makes a very significant group of texts, and Wilcken's interpretation of them is striking and suggestive, if not in all points convincing.", "prev": "Wilcken holds, as formerly, that these so-called Acts of Martyrdom represent a novel type of Alexandrian literature, based upon official sources, but worked up for partisan purposes.", "next": "Edgar J.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.882, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261947:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261947", "s": "Especially convincing is the treatment of the Heracles myth, which Ciaceri rightly believes represents a Boeotian-Argive influence.", "prev": "It should serve as a corrective to the overemphasis on this element by Holm and Freeman.", "next": "In the chapter on the Greco-Roman divinities the author rightly lays stress on the position of Rhodes as the original seat for Sicilian cults 252 Book Reviews such as Zeiis 'Arafivpios, 'AttoWwv Kapreios, Arjpvqrrjp and Kopr;, and upon the position of Syracuse and Gela as disseminating centers.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.555, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261947:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261947", "s": "The combination by which Ciaceri reconstructs the features of the festival of \"Aprcfus ayycXXoi is ingenious and convincing.", "prev": "The relation between the $toyd/ua and the sacrum anniversarium Cereris seems reasonably sure.", "next": "On the other hand, chaps, iv and v, while valuable as containing convenient narrative sum- maries of the dispersion of the worship of the minor divinities and the heroes, do not give such clear evidence of independence and conservatism.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.671, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262306:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262306", "s": "This whole episode in fact may be thought of as a mime cast in the narrative form, and the same conception may be applied with great plausibility to the entire story of Encolpius.", "prev": "The r61e makes a great hit, and all the vagabonds in the company play their assumed parts in their daily life at Croton with such skill that the legacy hunters of the place load them with attentions and shower them with presents.", "next": "We have thus far been attacking the question with which we are concerned from the side of the subject-matter and tone of the story of Petronius.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.84, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "Particularly convincing are examples a, e, h, k.", "prev": "Maris F. g. i. 13. 13: aug 2 e ( = augure) A augure N edd. augere F. h. i. 14. 19: arabium A N edd., but in A the word can easily be taken for arabtum (as Baehrens wrongly took it) ; arabtum F. i. i. 20. 21: houm ( = heroum) A heroum N edd. hominum F. j. ii. 1. 31: c (=cum) A cum N edd. est F. k. ii. 1. 53: circeo A N edd., but in A the word closely resembles cureo; cureo F.", "next": "Examples /, g, i, j show errors due to misreading of abbreviations uncommon in northern Italy in the fourteenth century.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.541, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "Still more convincing is the following formidable list, based, it will be remembered, on a re-examination of A and F, and on photo- graphs of these MSS which are before me at this moment.", "prev": "Examples /, g, i, j show errors due to misreading of abbreviations uncommon in northern Italy in the fourteenth century.", "next": "In all of these cases A 1 has corrected an error of his, but so carelessly (generally without erasure) that, without close scrutiny, one would fail to notice the correction at all, or else would mistake the scribe's intention.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.544, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "The only plausible explanation for these cases is that A's archetype had the 1 Another example should probably be added to this list.", "prev": "In one case, however, the supposedly incorrect reading is supported by N and, therefore, should probably not be included in the list (example y).", "next": "I have no photograph of A showing i. 17. 19, at which line Baehrens reports peperissent AF sepelissent A» (N edd.).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.603, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "If he is correct in his main conclusions, he has done a most important piece of work, but I must confess that I have not been convinced by the evidence thus far submitted.", "prev": "Far more pretentious than Simar's article is Richmond's, 2 as he has in mind the preparation of a critical edition.", "next": "Briefly, his main argument is that he has unearthed certain fifteenth-century MSS which ultimately go back to an earlier source than any existing MS.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.913, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "He argues, plausibly enough, that only an old book suffers dislocations, that, therefore, his new MSS go back to an old source.", "prev": "In the first place, Rich- mond lays great stress on the dislocations in his new MSS.", "next": "But that is not necessarily true.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.928, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "Many MSS of Catullus show similar dislocations, MSS which I am convinced are not descended from an ancient arche- type, although I realize that Richmond would argue to the contrary.", "prev": "But that is not necessarily true.", "next": "There is another explanation just as plausible.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.931, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "There is another explanation just as plausible.", "prev": "Many MSS of Catullus show similar dislocations, MSS which I am convinced are not descended from an ancient arche- type, although I realize that Richmond would argue to the contrary.", "next": "Perhaps the arche- typal MS had never been bound, and so was easily disarranged.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.935, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262308:7", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262308", "s": "In the same way Richmond's arguments that the errors are most easily explained as being due to an Irish archetype do not convince.", "prev": "But I doubt if even so much can be admitted.", "next": "Rasce from nisee, canna from omne, which he cites as examples, are quite as easily explained from a humanistic archetype, if we assume that the copyist knew little or no Latin.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.99, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262309:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262309", "s": "At any rate, I am not persuaded to grant to the passage the merit of preserving independent information concerning the practice of simulation in ancient Greece merely because .it adds this feature to the description of the rite contained in the papyrus.", "prev": "So the assertion of Pollux that the bridegroom figured as prominently as the bride in the rite of the airavXia is, to say the least, surprising.", "next": "I am inclined to think that the lexicographer's account simply incor- porates a tradition of the Naxian custom with various embellish- ments as to details, the source of which it is impossible to fix.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.84, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262312:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262312", "s": "But cogent as this reasoning may seem, a moment's reflection will show that it betrays a hint, at least, of the logical circle.", "prev": "Klotz's reason, however, for considering the Imagines as the necessary source lies in the fact that, in Varro's continuous and prolific literary activity, the point of time obviously did not exist before and could not recur again when the sum of his writings was exactly (ad eum diem) seventy hebdomads.", "next": "In effect he says: Varro is the author of the catalogue.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.252, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262312:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262312", "s": "His explanation of the item Antiquitatum 45 may be allowed as plausible.", "prev": "With regard to the second of Klotz's assumptions, that Jerome has curtailed the Varronian catalogue by conflation of numbers, with consequent suppression of titles, it is obviously sound with reference to the item libri singulares 10.", "next": "But the fact that 1 Ut intellegamus nos Epimenidis dormire somnium, etc. s Cf. the introductory words: et quia non (?) otiosum est apud Latinos Grae- corum voluminum indicem texere, de eo qui Latine scripsit aligua commemorabo, etc. 338 G.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.403, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262312:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262312", "s": "But Klotz urges with apparent plausibility that the words are indefinite, and he sees no reason why the range of their meaning may not be extended to a point of time which shall include the eightieth year.", "prev": "The natural meaning of this phrase is obviously the beginning of the twelfth hebdomad, that is, the seventy-eighth year of Varro's age, which yields the year 39, as Ritschl assumed without question.", "next": "That this in fact is the case, Klotz says (p. 9), is shown by the inclusion of the rerum rusticarum in the catalogue.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.475, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262313:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262313", "s": "However, these are general arguments, but in this particular case there is a most cogent reason for not naming Peisistratus in the Iliad, and that reason is he was born to Nestor after the departure of the Greeks for Troy.", "prev": "Nestor was far more inclined to refer to the days of his childhood than to those of his children.", "next": "He was a young man of about the age of Telemachus, as the words of Peisis- tratus show: y 49: dAAa veiarepos icrriv, 6p.rj\\iKir) 8 ifx.cH avriS.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.398, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262315:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262315", "s": "It is not so but [the diversity of customs that lends plausibility to this view is due to the fact that] just as men err in their estimates of what is advantageous in respect of health, etc., so the many make many mistakes in the general and particular application of the principle of utility.", "prev": "The elliptical logic of this Epicurean argument runs: Our principle of utility (rightly understood) refutes the skeptical doctrine that right and wrong are matters of opinion depending solely on the positive enactments of law.", "next": "Illustrations follow, introduced by Kal yap.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.782, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262316:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262316", "s": "It is not so but [the diversity of customs that lends plausibility to this view is due to the fact that] just as men err in their estimates of what is advantageous in respect of health, etc., so the many make many mistakes in the general and particular application of the principle of utility.", "prev": "The elliptical logic of this Epicurean argument runs: Our principle of utility (rightly understood) refutes the skeptical doctrine that right and wrong are matters of opinion depending solely on the positive enactments of law.", "next": "Illustrations follow, introduced by Kal yap.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.371, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261597:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261597", "s": "Niese (Zeitschrift fur deutsches Altertum, NF. 30, p. 149) very plausibly suggests that in the war against the Cisalpine Gauls after the close of the Second Punic War it was the Boii who suffered most heavily from the revenge of the Romans.", "prev": "They seem to have been very nomadic in their tendencies, for they participated in almost all the various Gallic movements for several cen- turies.", "next": "They were driven from their homes, and many of them forced out of the country.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.305, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261597:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261597", "s": "And yet Hirt is carried away by the arguments of Niese, and feels them to be so cogent that he would follow Niese even if he did not have the sup- port of Polybius {Die Indogermanen 1, 171).", "prev": "Against such paucity of genuine information, the reason- able account given by Livy must still be credited.", "next": "It is noticeable that E.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.816, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261598:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261598", "s": "Stuart's theory is wrong, not- withstanding its general plausibility, and in spite even of the extraor- dinary neatness with which the Swedish custom just mentioned fits into it and seems to support it.", "prev": "But I believe that Mr.", "next": "At any rate my own reading in the field of primitive custom has led me to take another view of it. • Since the body of this paper was put into type, I have seen K.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.14, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261598:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261598", "s": "Mythol. und Religionsgesch., p. 916) about the origin of the sacrifice of virginity are not convincing. 408 Campbell Bonner better is that we are here [referring to the Babylonian and similar rites] dealing with a special modification of a widespread custom, the custom of destroying virginity before marriage so that the bride- groom's intercourse should be safe from a peril that is much dreaded by men in a certain state of culture; and here as in other ritual it is the stranger that takes the peril upon himself.\" This view is accepted by Nilsson (he. cit.) and Cumont (Les religions orientates ", "prev": "Tylor 189-202. 1 I must content myself with adopting the view conveniently stated by Farnell {pp. tit, p. 88): \"The explanation that fits the facts far 1 Gruppe's remarks (Griech.", "next": "Hartland (p. 201) finds the theory of the danger of sexual contact questionable, and treats ceremonial deflora- tion as a puberty rite, a formal introduction into sexual life.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.777, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261600:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261600", "s": "Scott of this paper to test the plausibility of Athenian interpolation by the study of internal evidence, reserving the external evidence for later investigation.", "prev": "Wir sind vollkommen in der lage die richtigkeit seiner conjectur zu prufen.\" It is the purpose [Classical Philology VI, October, 1911] 419 420 John A.", "next": "The chief grounds for the assumption of such interpolations would, I presume, be (1) the assignment to Athens of a more prominent place than her historical position in the Mycenaean Age would war- rant;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.144, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261606:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261606", "s": "Convincing cases of mar- ried women with loose hair are hard to find.", "prev": "The difficulty, however, was not insuperable, and the maiden goddess could hardly have followed a practice which on earth was confined to married women.", "next": "Theophante on her grave- monument (Conze 309= Athens 1055) may be a case in point, but her status is in some doubt and her hanging locks may mean nothing but the disarray of illness.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.542, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261508:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261508", "s": "But, waiving the question whether densus populus can stand for \"densa populi [i.e., hominum] series\" (and I am convinced that it cannot unless this sense is imposed by the context), what is the stream of people doing here ?", "prev": "Stil. i. 138 are cited).", "next": "The situation is very different in Prop. iii. 16. 25, where the poet prays that he may not be buried on a public high road \"qua facit adsiduo tramite uulgus iter.\" But it may be urged that if the densus populus has no business in this context populus itself has none either.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.821, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261510:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261510", "s": "At the least, they have placed those who believe Terence translated but one play with no essential modifications under the disagreeable necessity of discovering a plausible explanation. 2 It may be added that there is some uncertainty whether Act I stops at vs. 212 (accord- ing to the vulgate) or at vs. 229, 3 and that neither arrangement satisfies Donatus' dictum: \"est igitur attente animaduertendum, ubi et quando scaena uacua sit ab omnibus personis, ita ut in ea chorus i Cf.", "prev": "No student of Terence can disregard these difficulties, which have given rise to or have seemed to substantiate charges of wholesale alteration or of contaminatio.", "next": "Class.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.087, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261510:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261510", "s": "Of course, both companies were represented by the same set of x°P eVTa h but the poet had no compelling motive for keeping the connection between them unbroken.", "prev": "XOPOY 1 It will be at once observed that, though both choruses are similarly- constituted, their identity is not preserved, for this ica>(io$ is approaching down the street through one of the irdpoSot, while the other had disappeared within the <ncr)vri at the beginning of the act.", "next": "From the spectators' point of view the two bands were quite distinct — one a group of guests, thus standing in definite relationship to one of the dramatis personae, the other a chance crowd of drunken youths who only by accident came down the street and before the houses represented by the proscenium. 2 Bethe is unalterably opposed to any interpretation of Menander's fragments which will result i", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.594, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261511:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261511", "s": "The compelling force of metrical convenience may be roughly esti- mated by answering two questions: Do the adjectives in epic diction fall into a limited number of metrical categories ?", "prev": "It does not immediately follow that metrical convenience is an exclusive or dominant factor in the position of the deferred adjective.", "next": "Are words of these same metrical types limited to a definite position in the verse ?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.109, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261511:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261511", "s": "There is no reason to doubt that this effect in some degree represents the conscious intent of the poet; but the reader should be careful not to be too quickly persuaded of the importance of this factor.", "prev": "The particular adjectives deferred to the beginning of the verse suggest to anybody familiar with Homeric usage ideas that are naturally thrown into bold relief: irdvre'i, iroKKoC, adjectives of material, TravTOio?, aWos, jta/epo's, v-^ij\\o'?, Se<Ws, eV0A.o'?, ofv?, a>«vs, &KVTTOW, Sel-uk, SeS-irepo*;, vrfirKK, o^erA-ios, \\v7p0'?, apya\\eo?, Qwireaios.", "next": "Whoever explains a iroWol at the beginning of a verse as due to the prominence of the thought must presently reckon with a tto\\v? that is barred from the beginning of the verse or any other emphatic position.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.256, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261511:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261511", "s": "I, 245, n. 82; exceptions in Trin. 141; 1 To a few more exceptions I refer for the sake of completeness, without attempting any convincing explanation: I suspect that the position of opportunitate in Ep. 203 is largely determined by metrical considerations and the symmetrical scheme of sound effects (cf . op. cit.", "prev": "I, 245), \"in all cases of separation (by the verse end) in which meus, tuos, or suos follows a substantive, .... the possessive stands at the beginning of the second verse.\" (For list of cases cf. op. tit.", "next": "I, 237) ; a comparison with Merc. 964 seems to support this view.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.835, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261516:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261516", "s": "A recent opportunity to inspect the stone has convinced me that this is indeed the case, and that the hero Eudromus must follow the new wine into the realm of ghosts.", "prev": "KeramopouUos reads « tov Spopjov, instead of «s to ['E\\vSp6px>v, stating that the space between and Y in which HomoUe supplied E is not a new break but an old hoUow in the stone, so deep that it was passed over by the engraver of the inscription.", "next": "But I do not beUeve that K. has drawn the proper inference from the new reading.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.468, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261516:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261516", "s": "This reading in the Labyada* inscription C45, which Solmsen Inscr. select, gives after Nikitskij, I had not ventured, in the face of previous readings, to regard as certain, but a subsequent inspection of the stone has convinced me that it is beyond any doubt, and indeed it seems clear enough in the photograph published in B.C.H.", "prev": "Icryovos is quoted with a query.", "next": "XIX.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.875, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261517:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261517", "s": "This reading in the Labyadae inscription C45, which Solmsen Inscr. select, gives after Nikitskij, I had not ventured, in the face of previous readings, to regard as certain, but a subsequent inspection of the stone has convinced me that it is beyond any doubt, and indeed it seems clear enough in the photograph published in B.C.H.", "prev": "On the other hand, while four dialects have regularly «=6k, there are also some which have traces of es, though usually showing e/c or e£. x Cf . my Greek Dialects § 100 with a, where Delph. lo-yovos is quoted with a query.", "next": "XIX.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.358, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261517:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261517", "s": "It is to be regretted in any case that the Thesaurus has no lemma, coniurius, which the reading of BCD would justify even if my plea for it in the text should not be convincing; the editor of the Lexicon Plautinum rightly gives the word a place.", "prev": "Once (As. 318) Plautus uses coniuratus in the sense we require for coniurius; except for the aversion to an ictus falling on the last syllable of a spondaic word-ending, one might better read coniuratum in our verse than the undeservedly popular convicium.", "next": "Henry W.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.959, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261520:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261520", "s": "With regard to a-to/ua — crrjfia, my point was that though we may plausibly associate it with <£ao-Koixra« oi £fjv to £fjv the resemblance of the phrasing is not sufficient to make it probable that Aristophanes did.", "prev": "But this too is obiter dictum.", "next": "It is a far- fetched \"parallel passage.\" The main issue, the attribution of the Platonic doctrine of ideas to both Socrates and the Pythagoreans, I shall discuss in a later number of this journal.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.783, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261527:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261527", "s": "Minor imperfections could not obscure for him the great merits of Livy (p. 16), nor could the mere paraphernalia of criticism or display of erudition convince him of the value of \"reconstructing\" plays from the fragments (p. 33) or of marking \"hidden\" quantities (p. 61).", "prev": "A thorough scholar himseK, he had what so few speciahsts have, a saving sense of proportion.", "next": "This fundamental sanity, again, is at the bottom of his satire on bio- graphical writing in his \"Real Persius\" (pp. 62 ff.) and is conspicuous in his notes on Persius and Lysias.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.408, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261527:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261527", "s": "The least convincing is \" Quintilian's Quotations from Horace.\" Here Morgan has undoubtedly overestimated the value of these quotations as a source for the text of Horace (cf.", "prev": "In this he has conclusively proved that the date of this oration cannot be earher than 66 — not 76 as Landgraf thought.", "next": "Cole Classical Review XX, 47).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.543, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261953:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261953", "s": "Rarer, but of convincing evidence, are correspondences between gly conies and pure iambics: 'JSXeidvia, irdpeSpe M.oi-pav ftadvcfjpovcov = e7rel Terpdopounv &6' - dp/idrav £vyol<;", "prev": "Suppl. 1000, 1023).", "next": "(Pind.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.112, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261953:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261953", "s": "First be it observed that our aim here is not so much investiga- tion and the attainment of the most plausible possible result as instruction;", "prev": "In the antistrophe, 635, 6 voa&v, Lobeck's elegant emendation for r) voa&v, but otherwise no material departure from the tradition.", "next": "I wish to show the method by which the analyses and the number of periods of the cantica were reached, and by which they should be read.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.591, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261954:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261954", "s": "ON THE ORIGIN OF ROMAN SATIRE By Robert Henning Webb The question raised in the title of this paper was a disputed point of literary history as early as the time of Suetonius, and anyone who has followed the extensive researches which modern scholarship has devoted to its solution, must feel convinced that no line of investigation has been left untried, and that practically every interpretation of the facts at our disposal has already been made.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.", "next": "My excuse in venturing to discuss the subject further is my belief in the necessity of recapitulating these same facts in view of some recently published theories which come dangerously near dis- regarding them.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.036, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261954:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261954", "s": "Leo, while not agreeing that Livy and Horace used an identical source, believes that both writers are immediately beholden to the annalists. 2 For the principle of parallelism, Elmore, equally skeptical, substitutes with less plausibility the principle of \"duplication.\" — \"Livy's Account of the Dramatic Satura\" PAPA XXXIV (1903), pp. lxvii f. 8 Cf. also Ferdinando de Paola he origini detta satira romana, Citta di Castello 1909, p. 15.", "prev": "Hendrickson maintains the common source to be Accius's Didascalica.", "next": "On the Origin of Roman Satire 179 form is in Horace Serm. ii. 1. 1.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.168, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261954:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261954", "s": "At any rate his thesis is plausible; and since Valerius, as well as Livy, uses the word satura, Orendi 's theory should certainly be refuted before the statement is hazarded that this word is an innovation due to Livy himself.", "prev": "That it is, however, not a mere paraphrase of Livy, but derived from the same source which Livy employed, is the contention of a monograph by Julius Orendi. 1 His arguments I cannot here discuss.", "next": "Moreover, apart from the question of Livy's source, can we be sure that salura as a literary term was not used before Livy?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.21, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261954:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261954", "s": "If we accept the cogent reason- ing of Klotz in Hermes XL VI (1911), 1-46, 4 Jerome's catalogue of Varro 's writings was based on a similar list drawn up by Varro himself in the introduction to his Imagines.", "prev": "This raises a question which offers a still more serious objection to the acceptance of Hendrickson's theory — namely, the titles of Varro 's own satirical productions.", "next": "In this list the word satura occurs twice: No. 35, satirarum Menippearum libri cl, and No. 39, satirarum libri iiii.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.294, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261954:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261954", "s": "Indeed it might be maintained that the etymology was introduced expressly for the purpose of lending plausibility to an imported term.", "prev": "But of course the presence of this etymological explanation would not necessarily prove that the word saturae was not, as the skeptics claim, a term fabricated to supply a missing link in the evolution of the drama.", "next": "But that such was not the case is indicated by the tone of the passage as a whole.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.652, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261955:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261955", "s": "Homerists are now persuaded that there was, after all, a Homer, however they may differ as to his floruit and his share in the final construction of the epics.", "prev": "The general feeling, \"whether we like it or not, \" says another, is in favor of unity of authorship.", "next": "The fight has \"swayed oft this way and that\" since the days of Wolf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.028, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261955:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261955", "s": "Monro was not convinced; the Telemachy especially could never have had independent exist- ence.", "prev": "In Britain Jebb admired and hesitated.", "next": "And now men are free to believe again in an indivisible Odyssey.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.261, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261955:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261955", "s": "The thesis is attractive and seems not improbable, but the arguments are less convincing than Drerup 's other demonstrations.", "prev": "He sees in it the Mdrchenpoesie of the Mycenaean Age, and assigns it in its inception to Crete.", "next": "The Catalogue (on which see Allen in J.H.S., 1910, 292 ff., and C.B., 1906, 193 ff., Recent Homeric Literature 197 and Draheim, Odyssee, 55 f .) is held to be late, Crete unknown to the Iliad and its heroes in that poem supernumeraries, and the ethnological document in r 175-77 a late insertion.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.329, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261955:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261955", "s": "But Kret- schmer (Glotta, II, 341 f.) does not find his essay altogether clear and convincing, and so we must wait and hope again.", "prev": "Ehrlich, however, finds that it was grounded in the oldest Ionic.", "next": "Hermann's Probe eines sprachivissenschaftl.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.495, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261955:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261955", "s": "Mag., 1911, 157) claims him as \" thoroughly convinced by the Pisistratus tradition, \" he makes a very misleading statement.", "prev": "But when Murray (Oxfd.", "next": "There has always been a regrettable tendency to vagueness in discussions and conclusions in this matter.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.864, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261957:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261957", "s": "Consequently %qp.la, in the definition of the last mentioned words means \"loss, damage \" rather than \"penalty \" or \"reproach.\" There is no longer any great plausibility in the connection proposed by various scholars (see Boisacq s.v.) between Kapvq and Lat. carino \"revile,\" Olr. caire \"reprimand,\" OB. koru \"contumelia,\" karati \"punish,\" etc.", "prev": "Hesychius' glosses icdpov peyaXq cucpk and icapo?' .... <j>0opd can scarcely be separated from each other, and the former belongs with icop-voyfr, etc., as clearly as the latter does with Kap-vq, and with Kap-awo<i' ■f) &n(a, Hesych.", "next": "Still another word for \"locust\" is recorded by the lexicographers as follows: d/copvot- drreXefioi, Hesych.; oKopvovs- roiis irdpvo7ra<;.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.468, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261976:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261976", "s": "The work of Helm is interesting and ingenious but in no doubtful case are his emendations convincing.", "prev": "I have, however, noticed a few errors, such as the spelling filosophos, p. 9, and two slight inaccuracies in the crit. app., one on p. 2, where innitens is given as Oudendorp's text, though it is only a suggestion in the crit. app., and again, p. 41, Van der Uliet suggests commotam but gives the MS reading commentam in his text.", "next": "Thomas K.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.979, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262093:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262093", "s": "More persuasive even than their direct statements are their casual, incidental references to him, where real opinions most surely manifest themselves, and which simply could not have been written had these authors held the Tacitean view of him.", "prev": "But for eighty years after his death, we find all sorts of writers — moralists, philosophers, publicists, satirists, and poets — who did not hesitate to speak freely about certain other Caesars, making statements about Tiberius indicating that the \"established tradition\" as known to them was quite differ- ent from that which this theory requires.", "next": "Can we suppose that Juvenal, if he had heard such stories as appear in Tacitus, would have found no tarter phrase to apply to him than a reference to his tranquil old age — \"secura senectus\" f l Indeed it would appear from Tacitus himself that his sources were rebellious to his general theories, since how else can we explain the preponderance in his book of statements of public actions by Tiberius", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.159, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262093:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262093", "s": "\" 3 We may note that the modern psychologists assert that this is the sound psychological method of persuasion. 1 Quintilian xii. 1 . 40 ;", "prev": "History is written to tell a tale, not to demonstrate it — \"ad narrandum non ad probandum.", "next": "Juvenal vii. 151;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.435, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262093:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262093", "s": "Appeals to passion. — In place of argument great stress was laid by the writers on appeals to the feelings or passions of those whom one wishes to persuade.", "prev": "The Tacitean Tibeeixjs 277 3.", "next": "This is the greatest glory of the art, says Cicero, and Quintilian urges his disciples frequently to keep their narratives sufficiently embellished to stir up the feelings of the auditors, for the chief power of the rhetorician lies in exaggeration and disparagement. 1 For this purpose one should have \"purple patches\" ready at hand to interject into his narrative, so as to liven it up, catch the a", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.441, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262093:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262093", "s": "The mastery of unscrupulous persuasion developed in ancient writers by a sedulous and almost exclusive devotion to rhetorical studies, based on a sound empiric psychology, has during all the succeeding centuries filled the world with a mass of distorted, contradictory, and impossible stories in all branches of human thought.", "prev": "Yet by the author's skilful use of about a dozen invented passages, innuendoes, and declarations of secret thoughts made according to the rules of rhetoric, the general effect of the recital on ordinary readers, and on some scholars, is to make them forget the tame facts and remember the striking embellishments; and the impression produced is that one is reading the record of a bloody tyranny.", "next": "When even today so justly eminent a scholar as Dr.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.899, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262094:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262094", "s": "This looks convincing, if one does not open his Homer: \"Fling but a stone, the giant dies.\" The full passage in the old stratum is as follows: E 76 EupijjruXos 8' 'EiKUjuovt&js \"Yxj/rjvopa Slav, vlbv virep6vfi.ov AoX(wribvos , os pa 'Xicap.a.vBpov aprfTrjp irirvKTO , 0eos 8 ' <os rCero 8yp.<p , rbv p.kv ap' Evpu5ru\\os 'Evatfiovos ayXaos vids.", "prev": "B 736: Efy>u7rt»Xos 'Evtu7«>i>o? ayXabi vuk, cited as a late phrase in a late stratum.", "next": "Why go back to the Catalogue of the Ships ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.637, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262095:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262095", "s": "Alb. be 'Eid, Schwur,' ChSl. beda 'Not,' bediti 'zwingen,' Goth, baidjan 'zwingen, gebieten,' etc., root bheidh- 'press, urge : convince {Trelday); be impelled, convinced, trust, believe [fldo); press oneself on, rest on, abide' (OE.", "prev": "But foedus cannot be derived from the meaning 'trust' but rather 'bind, con- strain.' Compare especially OE. bad 'pledge, thing distrained; impost' (bddian 'take a pledge').", "next": "Udan 'remain, continue,' etc., Mod.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.15, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262095:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262095", "s": "From this may come 'take long steps, stride, spring, hasten' in Norw. langa 'take long steps,' MHG. lingen 'vorwarts gehen, ge- deihen, gelingen,' linge 'eilig,' OHG. lungar 'rasch, munter, riistig,' Skt. laghH-s 'rasch, schnell : gering, leicht' (here the idea of light- ness comes from quickness), Idnghati 'springt fiber, schreitet iiber,' langhayati 'betritt, beriihrt, packt, fallt an, bewaltigt, verletzt, krankt,' vi-lahghan- ' hiniiberspringend oder gelangend; dringend zu,' Gk. e\\eyxo<: 'proof, trial; reproach, insult,' e\\e7%«D 'examine, prove; overpower, convince, refute, confute, reproac", "prev": "In all the above the meaning 'stretch out, extend' is apparent.", "next": "As indicated above, the meaning 'light' came probably from 'quick.' As the root occurs with and without a nasal, there is no reason for separating Lith. ilgas 'long' from Lat. longus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.256, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262096:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262096", "s": "The rupture of the Caudine treaty in 321 B.C., as described by Livy (ix. 10) is unhistorical and cannot be invoked as evidence in the question (see Nissen's entirely convincing exposition in Rhein.", "prev": "For the century before that date we are in some doubt about the current interpretation of the rules.", "next": "Mus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.848, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262097:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262097", "s": "The failure of the second naval confederacy had convinced him that union could now be brought about only by an outside power; this power he saw and welcomed in Philip.", "prev": "He shows how, at the time of the writing of the Philippus, in the summer of 346, between the conclusion of the Peace of Philocrates and the destruction of the Phocian towns, Isocrates had abandoned his earlier hope that union of Hellas could be effected along the lines proposed in the Panegyricus.", "next": "Up to this point no one will question Wendland's statement.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.537, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262097:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262097", "s": "Demosthenes does, it is true, in the speech on the Symmories, recognize the fact that union of the Greek states is a necessary pre- requisite for a movement against Persia; but whereas in the Panegyricus Isocrates seeks to secure this unity by persuasion and to use it for a grand invasion of Asia, Demosthenes has no illusions as to the possibility of such an invasion.", "prev": "The only serious criticism to which the paper is open is that in the earlier part there is an overemphasis on the points of similarity between the position of Demosthenes and that of Isocrates with respect to a pan-Hellenic invasion of Persia.", "next": "He sees the possibility of unity only as the result of some movement against Hellas which should force the states to make common cause in defense.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.84, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261471:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261471", "s": "One can hardly, I think, make any such prolonged examination in detail without being convinced that in regard to augmentation the two tenses are identical.", "prev": "Testing for the syllabic alone over a large area of Koch's selections and in A-H, I find no difference between aorists and imperfects.", "next": "These ideas seem to be unsubstantial bases on which to work, but a number of pieces of positive evidence are presented for our 404 A.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.482, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261471:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261471", "s": "The extension to rjpripei (and mpmpei) is secondary; but even here the p still keeps us in sight of the tradition, which is quite lost in r/vwyei-ov, by this time perhaps felt as imperfects.\" But will this persuade anybody?", "prev": "\"The primary example is r/prfpeio-TO, where the use of the augment is exactly parallel to the lengthening of a short syllable under ictus (r/prfpeurro: :Ov\\vp,-jroio).", "next": "\"Primary\" character of rjp-qpeuno, \"secondary extension,\" the \"tradition\" and the effect of the p — it seems all mere guessing.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261471:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261471", "s": "On The Homeric Augment 411 the other hand, my searchings and countings, which have occupied months, have convinced me that there is nothing inconsistent with the prevailing view of the Homeric use of the augment.", "prev": "Wherever I have tested the statistics, they are indecisive.", "next": "I am com- pelled to leave the matter for the present, but I hope someone else may continue the test.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.959, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261472:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261472", "s": "This explanation is all the more plausible, since even modern critics, like Habbe and Peterson, were guilty of the same error or, like Sabbadini, Annibaldi, Wissowa, and others, failed to notice the glaring discrepancy between the statements of the MSS and Decembrio now existing.", "prev": "dence, so far as I have been able to ascertain, that these terms were ever employed as synonyms in the fifteenth century or earlier and, since Decembrio uses folia consistently and repeatedly in its proper sense, there is but one way out of the dilemma, and that is, to assume that the common source of ABE had inadver- tently substituted the possibly more familiar term pagina or pagella for folium.", "next": "While the unimpeachable testimony of Decembrio, based as it is on documentary evidence, enabled us to determine once for all the exact extent of a lacuna indicated in our MSS, thus disposing of a long-standing problem which would have remained insoluble without the accession of new material, the codex Aesinus, already referred to, renders still more valuable service in another direction. 1 Op. tit", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.384, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261472:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261472", "s": "This remarkable coincidence might at first glance suggest some causal relation between the two passages as the most plausible explanation of Decembrio's reading.", "prev": "That the effective anaphora represents the genuine reading is rendered certain by a Ciceronian parallel, De fin. 5.57: \"nihil abiectum, nihil humile cogitant,\" where, it will be noticed, not only the adjectives are in the same order as given by Decembrio, but we also have cogitare as their governing verb.", "next": "But such an infer- ence is open to serious objections.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.825, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261472:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261472", "s": "It remains to suggest some plausible explanation for the unanimous reading of all our MSS.", "prev": "For what we know of the work of this Italian humanist makes it extremely improbable that he was so profoundly conversant with Cicero's voluminous dialogue as to recall a phrase not intrinsically noteworthy, and that this untimely reminiscence then prompted him to make an arbitrary change of a passage which he cited, as he did eight others, for the purely technical reason pointed out above.", "next": "I can account for the transposition variant in no other way than by sup- posing, that nihil abiectum or nihil humile, having been accidentally omitted, owing to the anaphora, a frequent source of error, was subsequently placed above the line, XY inserting the words in one place, Decembrio in another, the archetype furnishing no clue to the original collocation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.855, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261473:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261473", "s": "Studies in Greek Noun-Formation 427 Iliad (16. 234) Se'XXot, for which Fick plausibly proposes afMj)l 8e a' \"EXXoi <rol vaiovai.", "prev": "Hoffmann, Maked. 42, points out that the alphabetic order guarantees this spelling.", "next": "\"EXXijw? is a parallel derivative from the same primitive.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.365, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261473:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261473", "s": "Walde s.v. fades). /cmXijifr : iea>\\r}, kS>\\ov, etc., is formed with -tjtt- : Lat. apis, according to Boisacq s.v. icmkop (but?). toXvttt) \"clew of carded wool\" was plausibly connected by Fick, Gott.", "prev": "(cf.", "next": "Gel.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.751, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261473:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261473", "s": "Bidvvol Se fuXtVow? oticlm, Hesych., is prob- ably not a Greek word, and so Prellwitz' comparison with aap-ydvq and ffo/3-o? should be rejected, aa-rpainj, aarpaTrrto, etc., have often been connected with ao-Trjp, darpov (see Boisacq s.v. ho-Tpairrj) , but the etymology is not convincing.", "prev": "KifiarroiR.", "next": "The source of the it in the following words is still obscure, rdpiri] , Tapir6<s, rapTrdvr) \"wicker-basket\" seems related to rapadf \"crate, basket.\" dy<nrda>, Hom.,+, from which dydtrr} LXX,+, is a back formation, is perhaps connected with ayafiai, ayavos, but Prellwitz' comparison of the final element with Skt. pa- \"protect\" is not con- vincing.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.774, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261474:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261474", "s": "We have then a very plausible explanation of the line if we can justify the meaning given to laganum.", "prev": "The leeks would take the place of the vegetables and onions.", "next": "There is a fair amount of evidence in addition to the Scholiast's note as interpreted by Wickham.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.32, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261476:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261476", "s": "If a convincing explanation differing from that of Professor Hendrickson can be given for the facts presented under this head, his entire theory will have but little to commend it.", "prev": "The remaining points are in fact either involved in or subsidiary to this main issue.", "next": "Now the cardinal defect of Professor Hendrickson's argument on this point is that he takes too narrow a view.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.1, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261398:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261398", "s": "It is significant too, if not in itself convincing, that he uses the same words, \"tela in nostros conicere\" (conicerent) in both references to the attack.", "prev": "ter is a very definite and unmistakable expression, meaning \"the day before,\" and the reference can hardly be to anything other than the attack referred to in the preceding chapter; for if a second attack had been made on the Romans, it seems scarcely conceivable under the circumstances that Caesar should not have mentioned it, or at least have added the word iterum to his reference in chapter 47.", "next": "The meaning \"on the following day\" is given to biduo post by Stock and Herzog in their editions of the Gallic War (and perhaps by some others), and I gave the words the same meaning independently in my own edition.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.19, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261399:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261399", "s": "If the action occurs before Amphitruo's home what possible sense can be extracted from his threat in 583 ff.: \"at te ego faciam hodie proinde ac meritus es, ut minus valeas et miser sis, salvos domum si rediero: iam sequere sis?\" Obviously Amphit- ruo has not returned home and is not very near to it if he may say conditionally, \"salvos domum si rediero\"; there are some risks, imaginary but plausible, before he can reach home.", "prev": "Unhappily Leo has misconceived the entire situation: in his view ii. 1 takes place before or in close proximity to the house of Alcmena; but he can hardly have noted significant phrases in ii. 1 which clearly indicate that the action takes place at a considerable distance from Alcmena's house.", "next": "And if Sosia is standing near the very house that he attempted to enter the night before, why in 603 does he say \"prius multo ante aedis stabam quam illo adveneram\"?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.742, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261399:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261399", "s": "Palmer says: \"Amphitruo .... is on his way from the harbor to his home.\" » It is at present immaterial how the change of scene was managed; but it should be noted that if the interpretation above is convincing and the scenes appeared in the Greek original, the question whether there was a change of background in the supposed c hanges of scene in the Old Comedy can hardly be considered in future without includ- ing the pertinent material in the Amphitruo.", "prev": "Studien, 237) found to be invalid.", "next": "", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.98, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261402:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261402", "s": "A young Athenian named Plesidippus is in love with a girl belonging to the leno Labrax, and has already paid part of the sum necessary to obtain her; but Labrax is persuaded by another procurer to go to Sicily, and accordingly takes ship, with this girl and one other.", "prev": "The scene of the Rudens is laid on the coast near Cyrene.", "next": "A storm comes up just after they leave the harbor, their ship is wrecked, and the passengers barely escape with their lives.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.102, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261407:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261407", "s": "If however Plato wrote OeSn/ — which I cannot help regarding as doubtful — I am convinced that he used this strange phrase with some deliberate purpose.\" Others take ayaX/ja as \"delight\" or \"glory,\" rather than in the derived sense; but this still leaves the difficulty that, at this stage of the Timaeus, no \"gods\" exist beyond the one Artifex of the universe — 6 yewycras irwrrip.", "prev": "But nowhere else does Plato call the ideas gods, and the significance of so calling them is very hard to see.", "next": "Is the following a possible hypothesis ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.816, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261408:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261408", "s": "If however Plato wrote Oew/ — which I cannot help regarding as doubtful — I am convinced that he used this strange phrase with some deUberate purpose.\" Others take ayaX/ja as \"delight\" or \"glory,\" rather than in the derived sense; but this still leaves the diflSculty that, at this stage of the Timaeus, no \"gods\" exist beyond the one Artifex of the universe — 6 yEvi/^(ras iraT^p.", "prev": "But nowhere else does Plato call the ideas gods, and the significance of so calling them is very hard to see.", "next": "Is the following a possible hypothesis ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.673, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261409:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261409", "s": "If however Plato wrote OeSn/ — which I cannot help regarding as doubtful — I am convinced that he used this strange phrase with some deliberate purpose.\" Others take ayaX/ja as \"delight\" or \"glory,\" rather than in the derived sense; but this still leaves the difficulty that, at this stage of the Timaeus, no \"gods\" exist beyond the one Artifex of the universe — 6 yewycras irwrrip.", "prev": "But nowhere else does Plato call the ideas gods, and the significance of so calling them is very hard to see.", "next": "Is the following a possible hypothesis ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.149, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261409:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261409", "s": "The parallelism between 11. 51 ff. of this tract (I cite according to Anspach's numbering) and Etymologiae II, 16. 2 is in itself almost convincing proof of Isidore's authorship.", "prev": "It is attributed to him in the MS, the MS itself is Spanish, and, as Anspach points out, the omission of the verb of saying, thinking, etc., is in Isidore's manner; as will appear below, the method of compilation is that adopted by Isidore elsewhere.", "next": "Other instances might be added; e.g., 11. 60, 61 of our tract read: \"amorem pecuniae velut omnium materiam scelerum evitantem\"; cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.436, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262448:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262448", "s": "Homolle Fouilles de Delphes IV, 56, makes the plausible suggestion that Charopinus was a Parian sculptor who had taken up his residence at Delphi.", "prev": "The dialect, however, is mixed; toC is Delphian, but aveOevav Ionic.", "next": "This would explain at once the Delphian character of the dedication by his sons.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.266, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262448:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262448", "s": "Att., p. 14, is not entirely convincing.", "prev": "This last is in puzzling contrast to the converse substitution of UvQayopcK by the Samian artist (above, p. 138), and even the explanation suggested by Mess Quaest. de epigr.", "next": "The use of the Ionic alphabet is, in spite of Kirchhoff, perhaps of no special significance here.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.414, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "To show the plausibility of this I first call attention to the following example: the Latin word fartum, meaning stuffing, often used in the plural, farta, became in Italian the collective feminine singular farsa — the very word which has often been quoted as a parallel to satura from the standpoint of the development of meaning.", "prev": "After a time the neuter plural satura came to be regarded as a collective feminine singular.", "next": "The survival of the word in Italian shows that it belonged to the popular speech in Latin, and the roots of this popular speech extend back to early times — when satura became a noun.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.109, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "Perhaps the most plausible explanation is to assume an origin from the culinary sense, and, in the later examples, an influence from the abstract noun, or from the adjective satur.", "prev": "t it was a politico- legal one in origin, for it is used in a legal sense in the earliest examples, and whenever not so used there is almost always some indication that the context is figurative. 2 It is difficult to say whether the phrase is derived from the culinary use of satura or not. 3 In its later history, at least, it seems sometimes to be associated more directly with the meaning fulness.", "next": "Of the original use we have the following examples: Festus states that it was used in the sanctio of laws, \"neve per saturam 1 Note the analogy of the English word \"filling.\" • That it is used in a comparison by Fronto (see below) makes it certain that it could normally be applied only to legal matters.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.263, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "The interpreta- tion of per saturam that I have suggested is not only plausible in itself, but prepares for an explanation of Lucilius' line in its context that is, it seems to me, more likely than Marx's.", "prev": "Legibus solvere is a common phrase, as Marx shows, and since it was by the senate that laws were suspended, we must understand senatus as the antecedent of qui.", "next": "Marx has shown that the first book, to which this verse is attributed by Diomedes, 1 Bannier has, as he himself says, merely pointed the way for a thorough study of these glossaries — a study well worth making. 180 B.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.355, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "St., I, 336) suggests, plausibly enough, that the imperium mentioned in the citation from Luscus was that granted by Gracchus' land bill to the three commissioners. * Lange, RBm.", "prev": "Mommsen (R.", "next": "AlterthUmer, III (2d ed.), 86. • For other instances see ibid., II (3d ed.), 471.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.4, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "Wheeler has shown that the absence of the word satura from extant writings antedating Horace's first book of satires is easily accounted for, his argument concerning the usage of Varro and Cicero being particularly cogent; but with regard to Horace he is not so convincing.", "prev": "For cooking terms in literature we may compare also \"macaronic poetry.\" Let us take up, then, Hendrickson's main thesis, as outlined at the beginning of this article.", "next": "The elegy of Propertius which he cites is not a perfect analogy.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.622, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262450:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262450", "s": "Hendrickson has shown in a most interesting and convincing way that there was great enthusiasm for Lucilius in the ten years follow- ing 40 B.C.", "prev": "We might perhaps grant, if strong evidence were presented, that the title of one of these works was altered, but that this could have taken place in the case of all three is utterly incredible.", "next": "Now Lucilius' poems were called saturae, \"miscellanies,\" but the striking element in them was the satirical — so striking that the word satura lost to a large extent its original meaning and took on during this period of enthusiasm the new meaning of satire. 3 It is much easier to suppose that because of the great interest in the satirical element of Lucilius' saturae this title acquired the meani", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.719, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262451:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262451", "s": "The difficulty of squaring these two facts has called out several very different etymologies, no one of which, however, can be considered plausible.", "prev": "At the same time the word in Homer, frequently at least, 4 means \"of or pertaining to formal marriage,\" and universally bears this meaning in the later literature.", "next": "The derivation from icovpos, \"youth,\" is certain for the following reasons: (1) it is so obvious that if any reasonable explanation can be given it must be accepted, and this explanation can in my opinion be furnished;", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.319, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262451:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262451", "s": "Being thus carefully chosen, there can never be any doubt of the perfect propriety and legitimacy of this marriage, and of course under normal conditions 1 If Samson's marriage was, as has been very plausibly suggested, originally of the mol'a type, it is especially significant that the redactor, in trying to make an older tale agree with the regular conventions of his time, chooses just this circum- stance as characteristic of the typical Hebrew marriage. ' It may not be commonly known that child-marriages took place in England even as late as the times of Queen Elizabeth.", "prev": "By virtue of the dowry she brings with her, or because of the total loss of the bridegift if she be divorced (not to speak of the offense that would be given her kin and the weakening in capital or labor-power that would result to her husband's house), the first wife is strongly fortified in her position by permanent economic considerations of a very substantial sort.", "next": "The depositions that were taken in the Bishops' Court of the diocese of Chester in the trial of certain of these cases during the years 1561-66 have been edited by Mr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.498, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262451:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262451", "s": "Oldfather for the three passages in the Homeric Hymns where the word occurs, 6, 17; 2, 136; and especially 5, 127, where Aphrodite persuades the not unnaturally very credulous Anchises that she is the virgin daughter of Otreus of Phrygia, come especially to wed him.", "prev": "A.", "next": "In only one case might there be a reasonable doubt, that where Patroklos promises to make Briseis the icovpiSio<: aXo^o? of Achilles, on his return from Troy (T 297 ff.).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.97, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262453:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262453", "s": "What I have said is that the allegation that 'the metrical structure of Aeolic verse must have been logaoedic because we moderns cannot read it in any other manner' is not convincing.", "prev": "On the contrary, I have been reading it, in conformity with what I believe is its true metrical form, for half a dozen years with increasing ease and pleasure and have discussed the matter with many correspondents.", "next": "I am responsible for no part of this allegation.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.085, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261686:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261686", "s": "My present excuse for participating in the controversy is three- fold : in the first place, I have a few small bits of evidence or of new interpretation to add to the discussion; secondly, I am convinced that proper solutions for most of the points at issue have already been proposed by others and need only to be assembled into a composite whole which will itself be new, though its constituent members are old; and thirdly, I wish to protest against some recent methods of procedure.", "prev": "The origin-of-tragedy mongers are abroad in the earth, and their theories are promulgated with bewildering frequency.", "next": "Of course, our evidence is far from being as complete as we could wish, and must therefore be supplemented at many points by conjecture pure and simple; but this fact does not justify us in throwing all our data overboard and in beginning de novo.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.028, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261686:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261686", "s": "Now Pindar (01. xiii. 19) called Arion's dithyramb \"ox-driving\" (fiorfKaTrf;) , and this epithet is most plausibly explained by reference to the practice of an Arcadian community, the Cynaethaens, of whom Pausanias speaks as follows: \"What is most worthy of note is that there is a sanctuary of Dionysus here, and that they hold a festival in winter, at which men, their bodies greased with oil, pick out a bull from a herd .... lift it up, and carry it to the sanctuary.", "prev": "Frag., p. 115).", "next": "Such is their mode of sacrifice\" (viii. 19. 1, Frazer). 1 Arion must have taken such rude beginnings and developed them into a literary composition — i^e<pavev x«P\"\"e?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.312, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261686:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261686", "s": "There is nothing improbable about the tradition nor any cogent reason for supposing it borrowed from the history of early comedy.", "prev": "Dieterich 1 and Wilamowitz 2 refer to it in all seriousness.", "next": "It is natural to suppose that Thespis did not restrict his activities to Icaria but extended them to such other demes as were interested or found them appropriate for their festivals.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.691, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261686:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261686", "s": "Tbagedy and the Satyric Drama 277 We have seen that (p. 264, above) according to a natural and plausible interpretation of Aristotle all the early Attic performances were \"satyric,\" though none of them was called a \"satyric drama,\" and that (p. 274) non-satyric rpayw&oi were the choreutae of Sicyonian performances early in the sixth century.", "prev": "Diogenes Laert. v. 92.", "next": "Presently (p. 282, below) we shall find reasons for believing that the early Attic choreutae were not satyrs but silenoi.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.715, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261688:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261688", "s": "Fay I am personally convinced of the integrity of Carmen 2 as it stands in a conservative text like Simpson's, and the difficulties raised seem to me to meet their solution if we interpret the poem on the following theory of its composition, viz., that at an early period of their acquain- tance Lesbia became angry with Catullus and banished him from her presence (cf. the record of such a quarrel, later on, in C. 8).", "prev": "Stephanas in his Thesaurim, s.v. ^\"iftepos,\" writes: \"est etiam Id in oculis quo intuentium amor conciliatur,\" citing the technological writer Pollux (2.63), a century after Pliny, for Kal t6 aw' airwv iiroppiov tfiepos, and if Stephanus was troubled for the defini- tion of d,Topp4oy, he should have bethought himself of the philosophical term dwoppoal- ttSiaXa (so Hesyohius). 304 Edwin W.", "next": "In his efforts to regain admittance he despatched a note superscribed with some form of words such as Catullus passeri, melculo desiderioque suae puellae, something to pique angry Clodia into opening the note.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.396, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261688:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261688", "s": "The construction of the sic-clause as parataxis for O.O. after credo seems to me much less convincing than to take credo with the previous statement.", "prev": "The paratactic type of /or-sentence introduced by ita is very common in Plautus (see my Mosteliaria, § 74. 3).", "next": "Cattjllus \"Carmen\" 2 307 (cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.766, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261692:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261692", "s": "There is, then, no great plausibility in the theory that Ko/acvyjr, and Koprrtfr, icopv-ty (?), are regularly developed forms of kokkvI; and icopvi; respectively.", "prev": "We have also mythic H6\\vfto<;, UoXvftr), and KaXvftr), and Suidas cites ToXvftr).", "next": "They more probably differ from these latter in containing the suffix -ft-, which is fairly common in personal names.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.451, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261692:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261692", "s": "Sturtevant (ti<£os, to) \"marsh,\" is plausibly connected with tiaos \"thin stool\" by Persson, op. cit. 464, 566.", "prev": "H.", "next": "If Italic Tiber and Tifernus are related the labial suffix is Indo-European.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.93, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261692:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261692", "s": "Persson, op. cit. 227, plausibly connects OHG. helawa, MHG. helwe, helewe \"chaff.\" On the stem-form, cf. under tiro's (above).", "prev": "(kcXv^os, to).", "next": "(Aivov <f>os), pap.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.963, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261695:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261695", "s": "The received text sounds plausible, but is really impossible, I think.", "prev": "This reading yields the sense required by the context, and is subject to only slight objections, which will be explained away in the sequel.", "next": "I see but one way to defend it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.943, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261696:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261696", "s": "The received text sounds plausible, but is really impossible, I think.", "prev": "This reading yields the sense required by the context, and is subject to only slight objections, which will be explained away in the sequel.", "next": "I see but one way to defend it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.323, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261696:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261696", "s": "They are wild by nature, and the suggestion that they have \"run wild\" is merely an unconscious endeavor to lend plausibility to the meaning assumed by Burnet for iiia-rr/Ke here.", "prev": "Nor have the species of which he is thinking \"run wild\" or degenerated.", "next": "He is right in his final statement that Aristotle cannot mean to say that all brutes c&br^Kc t^s <£ixre<os, and that is what necessitates some such emendations as that which has been proposed.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.725, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261706:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261706", "s": "(2) the steps taken by him to convince the public of his truthfulness and the truth or accuracy of his record;", "prev": "Especial atten- tion is directed to three points: (1) the means employed by the historian in quest of the truth;", "next": "(3) the artistic or conventional devices adopted by him in setting forth the truth to render it convincingly vivid and objective.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.537, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261706:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261706", "s": "(3) the artistic or conventional devices adopted by him in setting forth the truth to render it convincingly vivid and objective.", "prev": "(2) the steps taken by him to convince the public of his truthfulness and the truth or accuracy of his record;", "next": "Under the first head are considered the extent of the historian's direct knowledge and the character and use of such other sources of information as he possessed; under the second, accounts of personal experiences, autopsy, and the citation of authorities, real or ficti- tious; under the third, such tricks of invention as the introduction of speeches by Thucydides and the rhetorical means employed", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.548, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262529:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262529", "s": "But the argument was not sufficient to convince Messrs.", "prev": "It is not necessary to rehearse Stern- kopf's argument, with which in general the present writer agrees.", "next": "Tyrrell and Purser {Correspondence of Cicero, V, 221 f.), who \"with much hesitation .... thought it best to adhere to the ordinary view which places this letter in April 710 (44), especially as that date suits the time at which Ventidius Bassus may be assumed to have commenced his candidature for the praetorship.\" Mr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.058, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262529:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262529", "s": "(?) \"Catal.\" 10, and Ventidius 395 convincing identification could be desired ?", "prev": "\"Fam.\" xv. 20, Vebg.", "next": "The Transpadane mule- driver has not retired from active life; he has only retired from mule- driving.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.524, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262530:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262530", "s": "The likeness, verbally considered, is not convincing, and as before it may be objected that Ovid does not mention Ntucos at all, while his deus is not very like $iX6t7/s.", "prev": "Aen. iv. 119. 404 Frank Egleston Robbins to the center, things came together to be one.", "next": "Instead of comparing Ovid i. 26-27: ignea conuexi uis et sine pondere caeli emicuit summaque locum sibi fecit in arce, with Emped. v. 261 M. : [eic6ope fitv Tpoyrov Tvp] Kapirdkifjiu)s avbiraiov it is much better to cite Lucr. v. 459 f . : .... erumpens primus se sustulit aether ignifer et multos secum leuis abstulit ignis.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.238, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262530:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262530", "s": "One of these is Tusc. disp. i. 17. 40: \"persuadent enim mathematici terram in medio mundo sitam ad uniuersi caeli complexum quasi puncti instar obtinere, quod nevrpov illi uocant; earn porro naturam esse quattuor omnia gignentium corporum, ut, quasi partita habeant inter se ac diuisa momenta, terrena et humida suopte nutu et suo pondere ad paris angulos in terram et in mare ferantur, reliquae duae partes, una ignea, altera animalis, ut illae superiores in medium locum mundi grauitate feran- tur et pondere, sic hae rursum rectis lineis in caelestem locum sub- uolent, siue ipsa natura superiora ", "prev": "They are not so much con- cerned with the world's origin as with the arrangement of its parts, but still they will be of service.", "next": "The similarity of these passages to Ovid's description of the arrangement of the world is obvious (cf. especially vs. 26-31).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.459, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262533:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262533", "s": "I in his Com- mentationes Homericae, Leiden, 1911) advanced with convincing arguments and great assurance the theory that the Iliad describes not the end of a long war, but a campaign embracing only a single summer.", "prev": "XXXVIII, 396 ff.; and republished as part of chap.", "next": "The Greeks, he believes, having ravaged the islands which lay along their course, and having sacked the allied towns in the Troad and adjacent regions, prepared to storm the walled city itself.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.051, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262539:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262539", "s": "In the opinion of the reviewer, however, his elaborate argument fails to carry conviction.", "prev": "To the accomplishment of this task — the magnitude of which is only equaled by the naive assurance of the author that he has been successful — • Costa brings ripe scholarship, an astonishing command of the material, and a still more astonishing degree of ingenuity in the combination of data.", "next": "It is developed by successive inferences from quite uncertain hypotheses, which in the author's mind have gradually established themselves as facts.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.561, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262539:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262539", "s": "Much that he says is plausible, but the theory is pushed too far, and the superstructure topples of its own weight.", "prev": "In an appendix we have a table which represents Costa's idea of the appear- ance of the original fasti from 330 to 387 auc.", "next": "S.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.837, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261582:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261582", "s": "Perdiccas then persuaded the inhabitants of the small Chalcidic coast towns to migrate to Olyn- thos, and, in addition, he gave them a part of the land of Mygdonia for cultivation as long as the war should last.' Thucydides tells us that an alliance was formed, including Potidaea, the Chalcidians, and the Bottiaeans, but he fails to men- tion the formation of the Chalcidic Kotvbv.", "prev": "Potidaea had already revolted and had made an alliance with Perdiccas.* The Chalcidians and the Bottiaeans also revolted and joined this alliance.", "next": "His narrative, however, shows that so far as external affairs were concerned the Chalcidians acted together and formed a distinct body.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.357, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261583:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261583", "s": "If the repetitions are to be relied on for disproving the originality of a passage, every parallelism in it must be considered, and cogent grounds discovered for the inference of imitation or plagiarism.", "prev": "And unless we are to deny absolutely to the poet the privilege of repetition which is established by the whole body of the poetry and illustrated on every page of it, there is no reason for suspicion.", "next": "Sober procedure of this kind is a characteristic of the commentary in Monro's edition of v-ca.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.567, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261584:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261584", "s": "I do not feel convinced, however, that the inference is justifiable.", "prev": "This view rests mainly upon the fact that they were required to pay Rome a certain annual tax.", "next": "The combined tax of the four states amounted to only $100,000 per year, or about one-half of what before had been paid into the royal treasury.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.858, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261585:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261585", "s": "At first this suggestion seemed very attractive, but on further consideration it has not appealed to me as at all convincing.", "prev": "(My.) adeon me esse peruicacem censes . . . . ?", "next": "The exclamatory infinitive must be sharply distinguished from the repudiative subjunctive and from all forms that are a substitute or a periphrasis for the latter.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.46, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261585:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261585", "s": "COMIC AND TRAGIC FRAGMENTS Naev. 72 : quae ego in theatre hie meis probaui plausibus ea non audere quemquam regem rumpere . . . . ! quoted under \" Illustrations of Origin.\" tantum bellum suscitare conari aduorsarios contra bellosum genus! nihilne, nihil tibi esse quod edim! .... men seruasse ut assent qui me perderent!", "prev": "Merc. 785 (Bennett).", "next": "Cf. the Greek translation given by Appian, Bed.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.677, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261586:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261586", "s": "The first conjecture is the more plausible, though the second one was adopted by Vergil (Aen. viii. 346), by Martianus Capella in his statement (iii. 273) that, in pronunciation, the word had the acute, grave, and circumflex accents, and by Martial (i. 117: Argi nempe soks svbire letum), though Martial in the use of tmesis is perhaps only playing with the word, or possibly wishing to rival the saxo cere com- minuit brum of Ennius.", "prev": "NOTES AND DISCUSSIONS THE ARGILETUM AND THE ROMAN BOOK-TRADE The discussions in Latin writers as to tlie origin of tlie word ArgiUtum have at least this value, that they imply that the name was first given to some limited spot because of its connection either with beds of clay (argiUa), or with the death (letum) of a legendary Argiis.", "next": "These and other etjmiologies from several ancient authors are conveniently brought together in the Thesaurus Linguae Latinae.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.234, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261587:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261587", "s": "Rolfe's citations in support of the view that biduo ante is synonymous with pridie are in great part \"doubtful cases in which haste or speedy action is implied or called for by the context.\" In view of the purely subjective nature of the interpretation of such passages, I shall not enter upon a detailed discussion of his citations, but content myself with brief comment upon the three cases which he deems most convincing.", "prev": "Mr.", "next": "In Caesar B.G. i. 47. 1-2, is described the aftermath of the treacherous attack of Ariovistus' horsemen upon Caesar's legionaries.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.65, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261595:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261595", "s": "They were indeed fortunate who heard the lectures and could enjoy Dieterich's persuasive enthusiasm.", "prev": "It is a more just and agreeable thing to express appreciation of the historical grasp and insight which the paper displays.", "next": "The volume has as frontispiece an excellent portrait of Dieterich in his library, and as introduction Wiinsch has reprinted with slight changes his biographical notice which first appeared in the Jahresbericht for 1910.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.098, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261555:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261555", "s": "Another more cogent objection urges the conservatism of religion, which would make it quite natural that the architecture of the tomb should lag far behind that of the house.", "prev": "be the same as that which is responsible for the false windows on the side-walls of the hut-urns, for the false doors of the Grotta delle Camere finte^ at Corneto, and for the sham armor of the Regulini-Galassi tomb.' In fact there are, as we shall see, innumerable cases where much ingenuity and labor were expended to make the roof of the tomb an exact imitation of the timbered ceiling of a house.", "next": "To form a con- ception of early dwellings, however, we have almost no guides but those furnished by religious usage, namely, urns and tombs; for in the very few cases where foimdations of actual Etruscan houses 1 One may query whether it would not have been possible to use a sort of movable curtain or wooden shutter to close an opening in the roof, just as the smoke-hole could be closed.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.156, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261556:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261556", "s": "In the course of the litigation between Apollodorus, the son of Pasion, and Phormion, the former repeatedly asserts that the alleged will of Pasion produced by Amphias is a forgery, and that in fact Pasion made no will at all. 3 Hagnon and Hagnotheus, claimants for the estate of Nicostratus, denounce as a forgery the document presented by Chariades and purporting to be the will of Nicostratus. 4 The alleged will of Astyphilus, by the terms of which the son of his cousin Cleon succeeded to his estate, was attacked as a forgery by his half-brother. 6 Diodes is charged with having defrauded his h", "prev": "A common charge with the orators is that a will has been forged by the person or persons claiming under it.", "next": "The second of the two alleged wills of Dicaeogenes, son of Menexenus, by the terms of which his cousin Dicaeogenes, son of Proxenus, claimed the whole of his estate, 8 was virtually repudiated as a forgery by the court, when Lycon, one of the witnesses to the instrument, was found guilty of perjury. 9 The invalidation of the will was not com- pleted, however, as Dicaeogenes succeeded in arranging ", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.134, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261556:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261556", "s": "Apollodorus asserts that the lease of Pasion's bank and shield manufactory put in evidence by Phor- mion 4 is, like the will, a forgery. 5 In the speech against Callicles the defendant is charged with having once persuaded a cousin to bring suit for the property of the son of Tisias on the strength of an agreement which was repudiated by the court as a forgery. 6 A most interesting case in connection with a criminal action is described in the speech On the Murder of Herodes.", "prev": "This proved that he had collected over seven talents owing to the estate on bottomry loans, and other minor sums, the whole amounting to nearly ten talents. 2 Other -private documents. — Written agreements and contracts, account books, and letters were not infrequently offered as evidence of transactions, 8 and there are a number of cases in which these are alleged to have been forged.", "next": "The defendant states that the persons who are charging him with the slaying concocted and \"planted\" at the scene of the murder a letter purporting to have been written by himself to his friend Lycinus, in which he stated that he had killed Herodes.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.33, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261556:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261556", "s": "This bit of evidence was manufactured after the first slave examined by torture had failed to incriminate the defendant, when the case against him seemed about to collapse. 7 The speaker's account of the proceeding is reasonable and convincing. 8 Genuine agreements and accounts, like wills, might be fraudu- lently altered, or forged papers might be substituted for the genuine.", "prev": "The defendant states that the persons who are charging him with the slaying concocted and \"planted\" at the scene of the murder a letter purporting to have been written by himself to his friend Lycinus, in which he stated that he had killed Herodes.", "next": "In the Trapeziticus of Isocrates, the speaker asserts that the banker i Lys. 32. 5 ff. » Ibid., 14 ff. 3 Cf .", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.354, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261556:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261556", "s": "Apollodorus asserted that Phormion, with the collusion of his wife, the mother of Apollodorus, made away with the accounts of Pasion. 7 This charge, like that regarding the will and the lease, does not carry conviction. 8 However, the fraudulent destruction of papers was not uncommon.", "prev": "hinus, in order that there might be no suspicion of fraud. 6 Parmenon, in his litigation with Apaturius, relied upon the testimony of his slave-secretary to expose any fraud which might have been practiced in connection with an arbitration agreement which the slave had written down. 6 Documents of this kind could also be concealed or destroyed, in order that they might not be produced as evidence.", "next": "Aristocles, to whom an arbitration agreement between Apaturius and Parmenon had been intrusted, suppressed the document at the instigation of the former and his friend Eryxias, and asserted that his slave had fallen asleep and lost the paper. 9 The guardians of Demosthenes, with the connivance of Xuthus, destroyed the terms of agreement under which the latter had received a bottomry loan of sevent", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.43, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261556:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261556", "s": "DOCUMENTAEY FRAUDS IN LITIGATION AT ATHENS 143 frauds practiced upon documents which they had themselves written. 1 A precaution sometimes taken in making a will was the addition of solemn imprecations upon the person or persons who should violate its provisions. 2 However, since witnesses often did not know the content of documents, 3 since seals could be counterfeited without great difficulty, 4 and since there were no handwriting experts, 5 the integrity of a document would seem oftentimes to have depended upon the somewhat precarious chance that the depository and his slaves were proof aga", "prev": "Isoc. 7. 1.", "next": "In actual practice, however, the pro- duction of original documents was not regarded as very important, 8 and there are very few cases indeed in which the handwriting, the seals, or the appearance of an instrument are used directly as proof. 9 1 [Dem.] 33. 17: oi irbppu <p&<TKtnv divai rbv %\\eyxoi>, et Tt KaicovpyoiTo ircpl ri. ypdwmra • yeypa<j>(vai. yap airb. oIk(ti)v iavrov.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.81, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261558:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261558", "s": "Blass (Interpol., 214), quoting the scholium 'ApuxTO(f>6Lvrjs /cat 'Apiarapxos iripas ttjs 'OSvaaeias rovro iroiovvrai, is convinced, \"though he cannot prove it,\" that this was not a mere conjecture, but a tradition, and that there were copies or editions which closed at this point.", "prev": "The first-named (Odyssee*, 532) seems to deny the atheteses within the \"Continuation,\" but these are undeniable.", "next": "Monro (on \\p 296) thinks Aristarchus distinguished between a continuation by a late poet and two still later interpola- 1 Cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.078, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261559:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261559", "s": "Equally convincing to me is his discussion of ne in mocking responses, e.g. egonef: :tune, Capt. 857; see pp. 186-7, below.", "prev": "H.T. 950.", "next": "In the second part of his paper, pp. 76-82, Warren argued that the ne seen in these instances was an affirmative ne, distinct from the interrogative ne (which he considered as of negative origin).", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.044, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261711:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261711", "s": "It is, indeed, rather unlikely that newer conjectures will be markedly more convincing than the many that have been offered to the choice of the investigator.", "prev": "GENS, FAMILIA, STIRPS By Max Radin To advance a new theory of the Roman gens is, in effect, to attempt a reconstruction of early Roman history, and scholars may be forgiven if they show scant patience with those who undertake to darken counsel on this subject.", "next": "But it may very properly be questioned whether all the facts on which these conjectures ought to be based have been ascertained.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.044, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261715:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261715", "s": "Thus the soul from their point of view as explained by Aristotle becomes, in spite of Plato, both <£wris and <£«o-« tS>v Trpwratv and yet remains material. 316 Notes and Discussions 317 I would construe then: \"For a [the] movent thing [which the soul of which we are speaking manifestly appeared to be] they conceived to be [of] the nature of first things — not without plausible reason.", "prev": "The pre-Socratics, of course, thought of the soul as something that moves, and so identified it with that one of the material elements which was most closely associated with motion.", "next": "Whence some thought it to be fire.\" I do not myself think this construction in the context strained.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.56, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261716:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261716", "s": "Notes and Discussions 317 I would construe then: \"For a [the] movent thing [which the soul of which we are speaking manifestly appeared to be] they conceived to be [of] the nature of first things — not without plausible reason.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.", "next": "Whence some thought it to be fire.\" I do not myself think this construction in the context strained.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.06, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261716:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261716", "s": "I find, then, no trouble with Miss Harrison's challenge of the accuracy of Plutarch's interpretation of the ceremonial that he describes, though I am unable to agree with her upon the substitute that she would adopt in its place — this for the reasons, convincing, as they appear to me, that I have set down.", "prev": "If only it were yet technically called in the liturgy an oblation, while still otherwise explained, the parallelism to Plutarch's misunderstanding of the rite he describes would be even more perfect.", "next": "But if her explanation is to be rejected, her point about the ritual meaning of dwap^at must at any rate be dealt with.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.581, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "Its noble and stately, if sometimes monoto- nous, pijropeia has been confounded with the flat, unraised style of the epistles or the solemn and cumbrous preciosity of the Epinomis for the maintenance of the genuineness of those plausible imitations.", "prev": "y IX, October, 1914] 345 346 Paul Shokey systematic expositions of the Platonic philosophy, of relegating the Laws to an appendix, as it were, and the neglect of countless definite coincidences of thought and formula with the more dramatic dia- logues have confirmed the impression that the fullest and most explicit enunciation of Plato's teaching is of interest only to pro- fessional philologists.", "next": "A few petulant Carlylean declamations, a few wilful Ruskinian boutades, 1 have completely blinded liberals of the school of Grote and Gomperz to the true historical significance of this unique com- bination of an Aristotelian wealth of good sense, political wisdom, and discriminating observation with a divinatory insight and a depth of Hellenic feeling that forever elude the dialectical net and th", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.051, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "The ideal principles of social reform having been once adequately expounded, it remained to portray their plausible application to a conceivable Greek city.", "prev": "The inevitable decay of the imagination in old age, and the literary motives already glanced at, the avayiai ^oyoypafaicf), amply account for all significant differ- ences between the Republic and the Laws.", "next": "Such a hypothesis necessitated an immense mass of superadded detail, 2 and a more matter-of-fact treatment.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.331, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "This outrages the liberal senti- ments of Grote and Mill as much as it surprises the natural Greek feeling of the interlocutors Megillus and Cleinias. 6 They overlook the fact that the virtuous youthful tyrant is simply an ideal postu- late of method, an evxtf with which Plato pleases his imagination even while recognizing its impracticability as a continuing form of government so long as human nature remains what it is. 8 All apparent inconsistencies are due to the fact that Plato cannot for- bear to oppose to the liberal politician's conception of government by plausible palaver, under the f", "prev": "That thought, too, appears in Republic 502B: els luavos yevofievos woXtv exw irei- doidvrjv.^ It assumes the form of wilful paradox in Laws 709E: rvpavvovnivrjv (wl dore rf/v ir6\\iv.", "next": "But in 540D the idea of the revolution that establishes the reformed state is more prominent.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.418, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "Plato's \"Laws\" and the Unity of Plato's Thought 363 than their feeble successors. 1 But intellectually and morally they stood on the level of the constituents whom they flattered. 2 They were ministers of the people's desire, not educators of its will. 3 They gave the citizens docks and arsenals instead of soberness and right- eousness, and they could not teach their knack, such as it was, to their sons or successors. 4 The true political art is the care and charge of souls. 6 The genuine statesman persuades the many to right opinion, and can teach the few by knowledge to carry on his work.", "prev": "Aristotle's discussion of this distinction, Politics 12766 30 ff., 1238a 37. » Laws 705E.", "next": "In this sense Socrates, prototype of the guardians of the Republic and Laws, is Athens' only master of the political art — the only one who never loses sight of the end, 6 the only one who begins at the true beginning. 7 With these ends in view Plato in his Utopian constructions goes beyond even the practice of the normal Greek iroXts in the subor- dination of the individual to the common weal. 8 ", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.726, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "These little sermons are woven into the design of the Laws by virtue of the two principles, that the lawgiver must always keep in view his conscious moral purpose and that every law should have a persuasive preamble.", "prev": "But Plato anticipates our irony with the apology that in an age of transition and disintegration of all tradi- tional restraints even the slightest reinforcement of the moral sense by good words is worth the hazard of the skeptic's scorn. 1 2.", "next": "The first we have in large measure anticipated.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.857, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "The unex- plained sic volo sic jubeo of the legislator is the method of the empiric slave doctor who prescribes a treatment without vouchsafing explana- tion and bounces away to the next case. 2 The lawgiver who first seeks to persuade resembles the physician who consults with his patient and both learns and teaches. 3 To the objection that this is education, not the practice of medicine, Plato replies that his purpose is to educate.", "prev": "The exhortation addressed to the first colonists of the new city in 716 ff., Plato says, is a sample of many things which a legislator who shares his moral purpose must make opportunity to say, but which do not suit the <rxvv& of positive law. 1 Plato is inexhaustible in illustration of this idea.", "next": "The true legislator is the kindly parent who exhausts admonition before resorting to threats and force. 4 This distinction, he argues in 719-20, must be observed throughout the laws, and he proceeds to exemplify it further by a specimen law of marriage, accompanied by a proem, embodying the ideas of the Symposium. 6 The law and the proem are repeated in substance in the body of the Laws. 6 Here th", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.936, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261448:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261448", "s": "The proem to the Laws as a i 718B. 2 720C, 857C. 3 Note the parallel and the contrast with the false rhetoric of the Gorgias, which boasts that it is more persuasive than the physician himself (456BC). * 859A. 6 773-74. « 721. 7 857C. 8 716-18. ' 723D : &v oi% <■\" irpooiiuafS/ievos etwes r6re. » 726-34E.", "prev": "This, which occupies the first half of the fifth book, 10 is a compendium of ethical philosophy recalling, though not slavishly, many of the motives of the Gorgias, Phaedo, and Republic.", "next": "Plato's \"Laws\" and the Unity of Plato's Thought 369 whole is thus finished, 1 though it is to be observed that the entire treatise on natural theology which fills the tenth book is not only a special prologue to the law of impiety, 2 but, in some sort, an indis- pensable proem of all legislation. 3 The long disquisition on the application in criminal law of the distinction between voluntary and in", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.962, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261453:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261453", "s": "In line 24 Woodward's suggestion of tSsv olSlkuv for rwv aiddwv is very plausible.", "prev": "No. 149.", "next": "No. 173.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.287, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261453:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261453", "s": "Wilhelm's restoration of No. 211, while attractive, is far from convincing, not only because the cttolx^ov arrangement is so poorly kept, but also for the very sound objection which Wilamowitz has to urge.", "prev": "The traces of letters at the beginning of line 4, 1 0, favor the restoration [Srip]o rather than [9e]o.", "next": "The frequent use of o for ov in the inscription would imply an earlier date, but there seems to be a revival of archaisms in the years 349-340 b.c.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.297, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261453:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261453", "s": "I am not convinced that Wilhelm's combination of the four fragments in this inscription is correct unless they actually join, and this does not seem to be the case.", "prev": "No. 675.", "next": "Fragment a has 43 letters Notes on Attic Inscriptions 431 to a line, while the other fragments have only 42.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.576, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262277:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262277", "s": "Decision will be helped by a consideration of the long list of examples selected by Otto in the article cited above; it will be more facilitated by a careful examination of all the variants in such an apparatus criticus as my forthcoming edition of Books i-ix will furnish. 1 But full examination will hardly fail to convince the unprejudiced observer (as Otto was convinced) that the nine-book ■I may be permitted to say here that the complete manuscript of this book, the preparation of which was delayed more years than I like to reckon by difficulties in the way of sufficient journeys to Europe,", "prev": "Further discussion of details must be omitted in this outline sketch.", "next": "After delays due to the printers had long enough interfered with the final stages of the publica- tion, the intervention of the present war has put a stop to progress for an indefinite time to come.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.287, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262277:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262277", "s": "That the text of D has not suffered a fifteenth-century course of emendation is inferred from a comparison of the general mass of variants between it and the other eight-book MSS — just such a process (and even more convincing) as leads to the verdict concerning the earlier emendation of the nine-book family.", "prev": "stimony of the two other MS families; for the later discovered codex Mediceus (M) of the nine-book class agrees in the fifth book with the index in B, and in the arrangement and numbering of, and order within, the eighth and ninth books, as well as in the fifth book, with Aldus, who certainly knew nothing of either B or M, and must have taken his order from The Tradition of Pliny's \"Letters\" 21 P.", "next": "The second example of an unemended copy of Veronensis is not an elegant book, but a mere little scratchy notebook of miscellaneous brief copies, such as many that are still extant, which fifteenth- century scholars who were not calligraphers made more or less hastily for their own use.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.753, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262279:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262279", "s": "Immediately upon the completion of the investment of Potidaea by Phormio, which must have taken seyeral days at any rate, measures were taken by the Corinthians and others to persuade the Lacedaemonians to make war on Athens, and a meeting was called in Sparta to discuss matters. 4 As Phormio arrived at Potidaea probably no earlier than October 1, and as it must have taken him 1 See p. 34, above. * Ibid. u. 70. 2 Thuc. i. 64. « Ibid. i. 67. 42 Allen B.", "prev": "This brings us at least to the month of November.", "next": "West some time to make the investment complete, about twenty days must have elapsed between his arrival and the meeting at Sparta.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.401, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262280:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262280", "s": "Lit., 221, 6). 6 Nepos is conjecturally, but not very plausibly, connected with the school.", "prev": "Galli bracas deposuerunt, latum clavum sumpserunt.\" * He was much like them in the characteristics of his style (Quint, x. 1. 113), and also in his narrow standards, which led him to find fault with the language of other writers (references in Teuffel, Bdm.", "next": "Indeed, the individuals in the movement are, with a few exceptions, much in doubt. 56 J.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.123, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262284:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262284", "s": "In his second reference to an attack by the Germans, Caesar uses the very same words which he had used in his first reference: cf. i. 46. 1, \"Caesari nuntiatum est equites Ario- visti .... ad nostras adequitare, lapides telaque in nostros conicere,\" and i. 47. 2, \"conloquendi Caesari causa visa non est, et eo magis quod pridie eius diei Germani retineri non potuerant quin in nostros tela conicerent.\" This can hardly be accidental, and it still seems to me \"significant, if not in itself convincing.\" There are further arguments to be derived from Caesar's words.", "prev": "But since one man's assumption is as good as another's, I am willing to waive all the arguments based upon mere probability, and to confine myself to those derived from Caesar's own language.", "next": "In the first place, if the Germans made an attack on Caesar's camp between the time of the conference with Ariovistus and Caesar's refusal to consent to another parley, Caesar could hardly have described such an attack by the words \"Germani in nostros tela coniecerunt\" or \"Germani venerunt ut in nostros tela conicerent\"; cf. i. 50. 2, \"turn demum Ariovistus partem suarum copiarum, quae castra mino", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.451, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262285:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262285", "s": "At first glance this looks rather plausible.", "prev": "Among the numerous contributions, Burmann's variorum edition, Amster- dam, 1736, II, 365, gives the following from Achilles Statius: Saevius Nicanor Marci libertus, negabit Saevius Postumius, ast idem Marcus docebit.", "next": "Postumius (or Posthumius) is a natural inference from post huius and posthus of the MSS.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.335, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261762:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261762", "s": "Tacitus sketches him as a subtly persuasive speaker, an able bureaucrat with a dash of conscience, a safe guide for erring princes, and a foiled and disappointed hero, nothing in whose life became him like the leaving it.", "prev": "Gummere even so this brilliant son of a Spaniard grew to power and evoked tributes of admiration no less than doubts regarding his right to wield that power.", "next": "Dio Cassius sneers at his elaborate collections of curios;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.13, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261762:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261762", "s": "The great man, says Seneca, speaks freely and comfortably; his words are convincing rather than carefully constructed.", "prev": "he might have risen to lofty heights, had he guided his talents in a narrower path, had he been willing to make himself clear, had he not been slipshod even in his style.\" 1 In a lower class he singles out the philosopher Serapio, 2 who pours forth his eloquence like a torrent, grinding and pounding his words so that it seemed as if a human voice could not bear the strain, nor a human ear, either.", "next": "Reason, he feels — a 'deity who should be enshrined in her temple — is degraded if she be clothed in fashionable oratory and subjected to the mauling of dilettanti who dress elegantly, mount the platform with mincing step, and scratch their curly heads with their little fingers.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.572, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261764:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261764", "s": "Severinus, journeying by night for a distance of twenty miles to meet the Rugians, persuaded their leader to ad- vance no farther, but to intrust to him the peaceful distribution of the provincials among the various towns. 8 Thus they were saved from possible robbery and ill treatment at the hands of their semi- barbarous overlords, and lived thereafter \"in kindly alliance\" 9 1 xxvii. 3 and see xxviii. 1. 8 xv.", "prev": "But as soon as Feva, king of the Rugians, became aware of this centralization of forces on the part of the provincials, he set out with an army to take the city and scatter its inhabitants among the various towns tributary to himself, 6 one of which, as has been noted, 7 was Favianis.", "next": "I; xxvii. 1. • oppidi, quod Ioviaco vocabatur, viginti et amplius a Batavis milibus disparatum (xxiv.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.47, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261764:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261764", "s": "Lauriacum was saved from just such an attempt by the warning of Severinus. 4 He was constantly on the alert against impending raids, urging the provincials to keep close watch, persuading them to fight when there was any chance of success, and providing for a safe retreat when no other course was expedient.", "prev": "Sometimes the barbarians were content with what they could carry off from the fields, at others again they attempted to take the town itself by surprise, lurking in the surrounding forests with scaling ladders, and making the attack when the sentinels were off their guard.", "next": "His success in effecting the release of many captives taken by the various barbarian princes has already been mentioned. 5 Influenced variously by fear, respect, gratitude, or genuine good-will, the rulers of almost every tribe acceded to his demands and returned scores of unfortunate provincials.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.767, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261764:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261764", "s": "His influence over the barbarians is further shown by his success in persuading Feva to turn back with his army and to intrust to him the distribution of the provincials gathered at Lauriacum through- out the cities of the Rugi, 6 with whom they lived thereafter benivola .... societate.\" 1 However much we may doubt their mutual good-will, the fact remains that Severinus in securing a peaceful apportionment saved these provincials from slavery and possible annihilation.", "prev": "The proportion of those rescued must have been extremely small despite the numerous recorded intercessions on the part of Severinus.", "next": "VI.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.784, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261765:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261765", "s": "As to the relative value of the MSS, my collation of the lemmata and citations of the commentators has persuaded me that E, in spite of its countless individual errors and the countless corrections by various hands not easily to be distinguished, is more valuable than J, which I formerly preferred.", "prev": "Ambros.", "next": "E and J are of course the two most rotographs. see my former article.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.884, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261367:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261367", "s": "In the first place, there were occasions later than the funeral of Caesar when the tyrannicides could justify themselves with considerable plausibility in the belief that, after all, the people were with them: On the Date op Cic.", "prev": "But (2) raises an immediate question.", "next": "\"Fam.\" xr. 1 249 see, for example, the account by Appian (B.C. iii. 10: Kal 6 r&paxoj eiriiravTO, plaos 5k appryrov ej appi\\TOv evvoias tov Sripov irpos tov 'AvTuviov iyriyepTo) of conditions after the quelling of the disturbances created by Amatius; and Plutarch's statement of popular feeling soon after Caesar's funeral (Brut. 21: ^Sjj 8e nal 6 Sijpos ax06p.evos, 'AvToivlov <rx^5dv eis pavap-xiav", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.422, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261367:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261367", "s": "But I cannot see such a compelling coin- cidence in it as Schmidt at his second thought observed.", "prev": "Some wished to have them granted a pledge of immunity, if they would leave the city (aTOT^lxrl/aadai €k rijs woKeas inroinropdovs) ■ Here the extant excerpt unfortunately breaks off.", "next": "Hirtius is, to be sure, here inclined to amity, but so he was also later than March 16.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.491, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "It seems to me, however, that the identification of the scholiasts is not only possible but plausible, and that Kirchner's arguments against it are not irrefutable.", "prev": "Gildersleeve, pp. 151 ff. 'Quaestiones Horatianae, Leipzig, 1834, cap. ii, \"De utroque Tigellio.\" [Classical Philology X, July, 1915] 270 Horace, Catullus, and Tigellius 271 editors have followed Kirchner without question.", "next": "It is certain that the Tigellius mentioned in i. 2. 3 and i. 3. 4 is the same man that Cicero speaks of in several letters.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.046, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "I find that the Thesaurus gives the same meaning, quoting the convincing parallel bellus architectus in Att. xiv. 3. 1, where there can be no question of personal appearance.", "prev": "But a comparison of Cicero's next words (sat bonus unctor — or cantor) made me con- clude that bellus meant, not \"handsome,\" but \"good,\" being, after all, a diminutive of bonus.", "next": "Horace, Catullus, and Tigbllius 273 dissimilarities were greater.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.118, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "This situation, together with the fact that it is Horace's Stoic oppo- nent who brings Tigellius forward as the typical musician, makes it plausible perhaps that Tigellius himself was a Stoic. 2 In i. 4. 72 there is no reference to singing.", "prev": "It is just possible that Horace is hinting at another point at issue between himself and Hermogenes, for in the same passage Crispinus is mentioned as a Stoic, and in the fourth satire he clearly belongs to the literary circle, of Tigellius.", "next": "Tigellius is now a literary critic and perhaps a poet.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.24, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "Since it is obvious that a correct interpretation of this attitude is essential for an understanding of Horace's views, it has seemed that my presentation would be most effective and convincing if it led up to the interpretation of these lines.", "prev": "Ullman Calvum et doctus cantare Catullum\").", "next": "Horace's supposed attitude toward Catullus, as indicated by this passage, has been much discussed, and not without reason, for it affects our understanding of the attitude of the poets of the Augus- tan age to their immediate predecessors.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.373, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "The argument is put in its most ingenious form by Rand: \"In satirizing a Methodist of pre- Raphaelite leanings — I hope I am not straining analogy — whose acquaintance with English poetry was limited to two of his recently sanctioned hymns, the 'Crossing of the Bar' and the 'Recessional/ we should not thereby intend disrespect to Tennyson or Kipling.\" But this argument from analogy does not convince.", "prev": "Hobace, Catullus, and Tigellius 281 sneer is only for his imitators.", "next": "If reason tells us that there is no opposition between Catullus and Horace, intuition tells us that Horace's words, as usually understood, do convey a sneer, be it ever so mild, at Catullus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.406, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261369:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261369", "s": "One of the two is from the satires of Horace themselves, ii. 1. 46: \"Qui me com- morit Flebit, et insignis tota cantabitur urbe.\" The parallel is the more convincing because this satire is similar to the tenth in dealing with Horace's relation to satirical writing, and as one reads he naturally thinks of the tenth satire: \"I will satirize whoever attacks me — as the simius satirized Calvus and Catullus.\" We may per- haps preserve the tone of the tenth satire by paraphrasing thus: \"The simius who was taught by his teacher Hermogenes to sing but one song, 'Calvus and Catullus, Calvus and Catullu", "prev": "Q. fr. ii. 11. 1).", "next": "Horace's references to him are always more or less satirical, his opposition being due to differing ideals of literary style.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.981, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261371:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261371", "s": "If the witnesses to an alleged fact are agreed upon an explanation of it which would constitute a plausible motive for inventing it, this might, we cannot say must, be a reason for suspecting and, in an extreme case, rejecting it.", "prev": "e who takes this passage as it stands can doubt that the testimony of Priscian is like the testimony of Nisus in being abso- lutely untainted by any design to make a differentia between es, 'art,' and es 'eatest,' and that for this grammarian, and for those from whom he drew, the theory of Herr Vollmer is a figment. 1 The truth is that this method of argument is radically unscientific and unsound.", "next": "But if they disagree in their 1 In a footnote to p. 114 (n. 1) a passage of another grammarian, also quoted with- out its context, is misunderstood and the text corrupted: \"Eutych.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.418, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261372:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261372", "s": "Davies, in his edition of book I, argues against it, but his argument is not quite convincing.", "prev": "Only occasionally has exception been taken to the commonly accepted translation of the passage.", "next": "His own explanation, however, seems to me absolutely correct.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.249, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261374:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261374", "s": "But the situation is somewhat simplified and the explanation above suggested is made more plausible, when we consider a passage in the Achar- nians, produced but three years before the Wasps.", "prev": "To call it so is all the more humorous, if, like the notorious Cleonymus, his disposition is the opposite of warlike.", "next": "Lamachus the warrior is pitted against the peace-loving Dicaeopolis in amoebean verse, line for line.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.783, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261628:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261628", "s": "But even if these important considerations are disregarded, the case against the editors' view is still convincing.", "prev": "The failure of P to mention the local senates in connection with his account of the party struggles of the Boeotians is in itself sufficient to show that their functions were purely local.", "next": "For, after all, the question resolves itself into a choice between a statement of Thu- cydides and the silence of P.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.656, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261630:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261630", "s": "It is noteworthy that in Corsica, where the laurestine is so abundant, the surface of the land is almost wholly mountainous, and in olden times \"honey and wax were the chief productions of the island.\" In view, then, both of manuscript evidence and of intrinsic probability, we are convinced that the tinus is the plant intended by Virgil in the two lines cited from the Georgics.", "prev": "Both the Thymus vulgaris (common thyme) and the Thymus capitatus are \"common on dry hills in South Europe,\" and Virgil's farmer would not have to go up very far to find them.", "next": "At the same time we must admit that pinus was substituted for tinus at a very early day, for not only have we the statement by Philargyrius that Virgil himself left the word doubtful, but we find that Columella, who is largely indebted to Virgil and frequently cites him, includes among the plants to be cultivated for bees the semper virens pinus (De re rustica ix, chap. 4).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.89, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261631:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261631", "s": "A fourth passage is less convincing because of the intrusion of the exit rus, not yet located; but it is significant.", "prev": "This again argues for the opposition of the entrances.", "next": "At vs. 750 Tyndarus is led off to the quarries, therefore rus; but first he is to go to the blacksmith.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.347, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261632:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261632", "s": "It is less surely, but with some degree of plausibility, assumed that his governorship began in 44 by the ante mortem appointment of Caesar and that accordingly he was in Sicily either from some little time before Caesar's death, or, at any rate, from a time shortly thereafter.", "prev": "In 43-42 a Pompeius Bithynicus was governor of Sicily, where he was put to death by Sextus Pompey. 3 It is justifiably enough assumed that he was the son of the other Pompeius Bithynicus, dead six years earlier.", "next": "This, to be sure, corresponds with a longer term of office than the single year then allowed by law for praetorian provinces; but (1) no other incumbent or claimant of the post for the year 44 is known, (2) the selection of provincial governors for 43 (M.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.283, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261636:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261636", "s": "The greater aptness in the context of the noun in itself makes the emendation plausible.", "prev": "Plato Sophist 267E), \"I see a crack or a line of cleavage for a logical <Wpeo-«,\" or pos- sibly 8m<pvr)v (Plato Politicus 259D), which involves less change.", "next": "But there is much more to be said for it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.953, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261637:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261637", "s": "The greater aptness in the context of the noun in itself makes the emendation plausible.", "prev": "Plato Sophist 267E), \"I see a crack or a line of cleavage for a logical <Wpeo-«,\" or pos- sibly 8m<pvr)v (Plato Politicus 259D), which involves less change.", "next": "But there is much more to be said for it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.474, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261653:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261653", "s": "They are of course much more plausible in the case of a late and less significant writer such as Nemesios.", "prev": "These postulates make wild work in the study of Cicero's, Plutarch's, and Philo's relations to their sources.", "next": "But even here, I think, their systematic and uncompromising apphcation may mislead.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.208, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261654:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261654", "s": "The similarity in form and matter to the Lysianic type, the striking dissimilarity in tone, and the unwonted failure of the language to carry conviction convince Dr.", "prev": "That inherent con- vincing power (irettrTtKov), ascribed to Lysias by Dionysius, is utterly lack- ing here.", "next": "Leisi that the oration, while spurious as it stands, was probably originally adapted from a speech of Lysias.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.877, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261979:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261979", "s": "Hauler, Wiener Studien, XVII, 133, n. 16, thinks B may have come from Fleury, but his argument as a whole is not convincing.", "prev": "Apparently Va was still part of B.", "next": "Professor E.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.866, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261979:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261979", "s": "There is some reason, not perfectly convincing, for associating A with Poggio's circle.", "prev": "It probably remained in Niccoli's hands.", "next": "Biicheler was right in regarding the Leyden leaves (Va) as part of B; wrong in identifying B with Pithoeus' Altissiodurensis.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.925, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261980:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261980", "s": "He also thinks that the com- munity of the Italians on Delos was similarly organized, with a quasi-magisterial Master at its head and colleges of Masters as curatores fanorum, and is convinced that he has found record of one of these Masters who presided over the Italian community in an inscription of a certain Lucius Orbius. 3 Again, Kornemann 4 has advanced the view that the Italians at Delos were organized as a religious fraternity or college directed by a board of priestly Masters composed of three groups called respectively Hermaistai, Apolloniastai, and Posidoniastai.", "prev": "While accepting in the main Mommsen's ideas regarding the Masters in Campania, Schulten 2 believes that the entire conventus of Capua was embraced in one canton, the pagus Herculaneus, pre- sided over by one Master and having various colleges of Masters appointed for the care of its shrines.", "next": "This conception of the Delian community he seems to have discarded later 5 and to have accepted in its place the ideas of Schulten, at least in so far as the colleges of Masters are concerned.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.073, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261980:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261980", "s": "The \"magistki\" of Campania and Delos 33 learn elsewhere, the main activities of the magistri pagi themselves were concerned with the religious interests of their respective com- munities. 1 However, if these arguments are not in themselves convincing, the other objections raised by Hatzfeld also admit of answer.", "prev": "An exception is ThibUis which had two magistri pagi (CIL, VIII, 18896, 18900). • Ibid., XIII, 5, 412, 604, 1670, 2507.", "next": "First, in reply to the assertion that the dedications of the colleges of Masters were of too expensive a character to be erected at the cost of these men alone, it may be said that, as Mommsen pointed out, 2 the cessa- tion of municipal offices would make the most wealthy and influential men in the community candidates for these priesthoods.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.396, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261982:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261982", "s": "For several others there is evidence more or less convincing. •Leo (Plaut.", "prev": "CI., XLII [1914], 449 ff.) that the name and character of Byrria in the Andria was taken from Menander's Perinthia, and argues that the same was true of Charinus. * We are sure of the Stichus, and all but sure of the Bacchides and Cistellaria.", "next": "Forsch., ed. 2, p. 110, n. 1) says briefly that the difference between Plautus and Menander in the matter of names has now become clearer (through the discovery of the Menander fragments).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.976, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261983:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261983", "s": "The word epijSciXaKos has always been a stumbling-block to scholars, who, because of its inappropriateness to Athens,' have been led into various misinterpretations of this passage.* A brief r6sum6 of scholarly opinion on the fragment will convince us that it is not the word which Cratinus used.", "prev": "Tannee authorized to prepare another decree taxing the olive oil and to present it in the ninth prytany.' Undoubtedly he did so, and vvv aOdis may refer to this second decree.'' In the fragment (56K) with which we began our discussion, a very apt sarcastic allusion to Lampon has been lost through cor- ruption in some of the MSS of the text of Pollux who quotes it.", "next": "The early editions of Pollux (ix.99) •LI. 59-61: irepi Si toO i\\alov t^s irapxv^ (vyypd\\f>as, Ad/iiruv ^irtSeifdrw tJ fiov\\y irl T^s ivirri^ vpvTavelas, ij Si pov\\ii (Is rhv Sfj/Mv ^lecexWrw iirdvayKcs. ' Whether a decree taxing the olive oil was ever really passed we do not know positively.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.109, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261983:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261983", "s": "A still further objection to Schmidt's interpretation is convincingly urged by Schafer (174), who cannot see why the decree did not establish the limit for all time instead of prescribing that this same limit be set each year by the archon, without giving him any discretion in the matter.", "prev": "We have only to read this hypothesis to be ready to agree with Schafer (175) that no such function can have belonged to the new archon.", "next": "Schafer (175), though believing with Schmidt that this pro- vision has no relation to the calendar, has no explanation of the sentence to which he does not himself raise valid objections.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.766, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261983:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261983", "s": "Sauppe, 5: \"Atque ut de temporibus anno 446 proximis cogitemus ea nobis persuadent, quae de sociis Athenienses decernunt: nam gubernacula societatis etiam- tum validis manibus et animo obsequii certo teneri intelligimus.", "prev": "Cf. also Leo, Quaestiones Aristophaneae, US. 5 Cf.", "next": "Itaque cum Periclis uuius consiliis res publicae regi coeptae essent, haec Athenis acta esse apparet.\" ° Cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.847, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261983:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261983", "s": "He feels the force of this argument so strongly that he regards it as one of his most convincing proofs against the hypothesis of a recently received response.", "prev": "subjugation of Euboea in 446 and at the conclusion of the thirty-year peace in 445 was Athens in position to undertake with any hope of success such a project as that out- lined in our decree.' Undoubtedly another consequence of the defeat at Coronea, as Schmidt (690) points out, was that the Delphic oracle again came into the possession of the Delphians and was therefore hostile to the Athenians.", "next": "But as we (pp. 71-73) have not only overthrown Schmidt's other objections to regarding this oracle as one just received from the Pythia, but have given reasons for believing that it was a newly delivered oracle, we must the rather regard the attitude of the oracle toward Athens just after the battle of Coronea as further conclusive evidence against the year 446.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.89, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262500:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262500", "s": "Under these compelling circumstances a modern dramatist might make Gripus, if not thoroughly organic, at least less mechanically related to the action than the fisherman is in the Roman play.", "prev": "Gripus, essen- tial to the recognition theme, becomes prominent in the last two acts of the comedy.", "next": "A playwright today, for example, might put in the mouth of Daemones, The Interpretation of Roman Comedy 127 the master of Gripus, in some of the opening scenes of the play, a casual remark to the effect that Gripus has gone out fishing, and that he wonders how the slave has fared during the storm; thus the audience would be duly prepared for the advent of the fisherman in later scenes.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.083, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262500:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262500", "s": "Yet modern critics are so impressed by the obvious mechanism and general weakness of technique that they ascribe the supposed abnormalities to the botchwork of a later retractor, or insist that Plautus must have made over, at this point in the play, a Greek plot which, in its legal aspects, conflicted with Roman pro- cedure. 1 My own view is that the technique, however awkward, is explained so soon as we put ourselves in the place of the poet and the audience, and the Greek as well as Roman poet and audience. »A legal expert (Partsch, Hermes, 45, 613) ia not convinced by Wilamowitz' argument i", "prev": "These much- discussed verses (vss. 711-30), therefore, are the dramatist's way of solving his practical difficulties; and those difficulties inhered in the Greek plot.", "next": "Is not the slave-dealer in jeopardy more because of a general prejudice against his class than because of any technical liability ?", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.301, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262500:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262500", "s": "Pbbscott Leo's masterly analysis of the Stichus 1 has doubtless convinced many students of comedy.", "prev": "On the other hand, it should be clear that if Wilamowitz has not proved his case, Leo's evidence, which is largely from Leonidas of Tarentum, probably a younger contemporary of Menander, would only establish the fact that at the time of the New comedy the equipment ascribed to the Cynic in vss. 123 ff. was attributed to Diogenes and other members of the school. 136 Henry W.", "next": "Certainly the extraordinary structure of the piece may be satisfactorily explained as a combination of parts of three Greek plays; these three parts might be called \"The Faithful Penelopes,\" \"The Discomfiture of the Parasite,\" \"The Slaves' Carousal.\" The Roman play mechanically joins these alien elements by attaching to the first part a parasite, whose hopes of a dinner are twice frustrated in the", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.501, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262504:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262504", "s": "In Athens also appeals were based almost entirely on the affidavits presented at the arbitration. 4 It seems quite plausible, therefore, to suppose that the real motive for requiring affidavits was to insure that the appeal should be taken substantially on the evidence as originally presented.", "prev": "e irpoaOtiviu rols yeypappivois ptfHv. 2 This statement does not neces- sarily mean that the sole purpose of the provision was to facilitate the punishment of perjury, for the practice was never extended to the Blutgerichte, where the consequences of perjury were likely to be more serious than in the other courts. 3 In modern practice evi- dence is reduced to writing mainly for purposes of appeal.", "next": "Written evidence is fundamental in arbitra- tion proceedings as described by Aristotle. 5 Consequently the law instituting arbitration was either first enacted or radically revised when written evidence was introduced.\" 1 Both arbitration and perjury had occurred to me as probable reasons (Evi- dence in Athenian Courts [1905], p. 47).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.159, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262505:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262505", "s": "His most convincing arguments were drawn from the names of Egyptian, Pontic, and Numidian provinces, and these are the only parts of the empire which we need to consider here, as they give us our only good evidence as to the date of the Laterculus.", "prev": "Mommsen found indications in the document itself which seemed to him to point to the reign of Diocletian.", "next": "EGYPT The former imperial domain of Egypt was divided into three provinces at the time of the Laterculus: Thebais, Aegyptus Iovia, and Aegyptus Herculia. 4 The names of two of these provinces obviously refer to the titles Iovius and Herculius assumed by Dio- cletian and Maximian.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.333, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262505:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262505", "s": "He argues plausibly that the \"edict of amnesty\" which came between the two periods of persecution was issued at the time of the celebration of Diocletian's vicennalia (November 20, 303) ?", "prev": "It seems to me that Costa 1 is undoubtedly right in placing these governors in the order in which I have put them above.", "next": "But whether this is true or not, Eusebius tells us that the emperor's edict ordering the second period of persecution, the dies turificationis, was received in Palestine in the second year of the persecution; i. e., in 304. 3 That this is the right chronological order of the two governors is also clearly shown by the fact that Quintianus (I) is the last of a con- tinuous line of governors of the s", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.736, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262505:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262505", "s": "Of course the theory that it was drawn up about the time of Diocletian's retirement and represents his final arrange- ment of the provinces is a very plausible one, but we must remember that it is quite possible that the document dates from the time of Constantine and contains the names of provinces which were formed by him or some of his colleagues.", "prev": "I do not see how we can fix its date more closely.", "next": "As mentioned above, we have no proof whatever of the existence of the new Egyptian prov- inces or of Diospontus under Diocletian, and this statement applies to many other provinces.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.945, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262506:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262506", "s": "Anderson's argument that since u after q was a weak sound it could not have prevented equos from becoming equus at the time *dolos became dolus is not convincing.", "prev": "Although it is possible that the influence of turn made quom become cum before equom became ecum, it is probably safer in the absence of further evidence to assume that all words with unaccented quo suffered the change at about this time.", "next": "There seems to be no cogent reason for doubting the phonetic character of the Plautine and Terentian spellings qvom, eqvos, etc.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.893, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262506:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262506", "s": "There seems to be no cogent reason for doubting the phonetic character of the Plautine and Terentian spellings qvom, eqvos, etc.", "prev": "Anderson's argument that since u after q was a weak sound it could not have prevented equos from becoming equus at the time *dolos became dolus is not convincing.", "next": "The conclusions which Kent draws from his own paper and those of Mather and Anderson (Kent, pp. 55 f.) require one modification.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.904, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262510:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262510", "s": "Finally, to come back to Hirtius' letter (Att. xv. 6. 2), the editors by placing the letter before the plebiscite of June 1-2 have failed to see the point of the words : \" Nihil enim iam video opus esse nostra cura, quoniam praesidia sunt in tot annos provisa.\" Tyrrell and Purser give the usual view: \"[This] seems to refer to all the measures, military and otherwise, by which Caesar had sought to ensure the stability of the State.\" However, it is strange that measures taken by Caesar before his death on the Ides of March should now i If further proof of his presence at Rome were necessary, Att", "prev": "The phrases that follow the passage prove, therefore, to refer, not to Hirtius' fear of danger to himself, but merely to Hirtius' fear of danger to Cicero: ilk quidem and ego autem both refer back to the causes (auctor) why Cicero should remain away from Rome.", "next": "Phil, 1915, pp. 241 ff.).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.748, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262514:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262514", "s": "Pascal conjectures with great plausibility that originally some man feigning intoxication, i.e., possession by the god, stripped and beat (as at the Lupercalia) chance comers in an act of lustration.", "prev": "Some will undoubtedly commend themselves, as, for example, the combination of frgg. 645 and 655 of Koch's edition (p. 156), and the really brilliant argument that the mysterious hero Orestes of the Acharnians and the Birds can be understood only in connection with the Orestes of the Xots and the peculiar ritual of that feast.", "next": "Certainly the old footpad theory is demolished, whether applied in a generic or a specific sense, even if the new view may not quite amount to a demonstration.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.378, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262514:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262514", "s": "Most of the contributions, however, can neither inspire confidence or claim plausibility.", "prev": "Certainly the old footpad theory is demolished, whether applied in a generic or a specific sense, even if the new view may not quite amount to a demonstration.", "next": "Pascal belongs to that school, which, though growing less numerous, will probably never disappear, that persists in taking Aris- tophanes quite too seriously as a reformer.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.406, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262515:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262515", "s": "The principal emendations I have noted are in vss. 246, 286, 601, 751, 891, 983, and 1010, all quite convincing, except possibly vs. 983, where a brief statement of reasons would have been helpful.", "prev": "And yet the dagger-mark of despair appears frequently enough, for Vollmer is conservative in the constitution of the text, and few editors have exercised more self-restraint in printing their own suggestions.", "next": "In vs. 286 the rare regemet has been restored with certainty from regent et of the archetype- To the instances cited in the commentary may now be added Avianus 42. 8, where some manuscripts preserve the correct regemens and errors in the others point clearly to the same form.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.436, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262515:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262515", "s": "Among minor points of interest might be noted Vollmer's acceptance of the name Baebius Italicus for the author, as given in the late Vindob. 3509, together with convincing arguments for its correctness (pp. 16, 142 f .) ; the suggestion that the mediaeval ascription to Pindarus is due solely to a mis- understanding of Bishop Benzo's Pindarus sew Homerus, by which really the Greek authors were meant (p. 143, nn. 1 and 2) ; and that the well-known vss. 900 f . point rather to the period of the Flavian emperors than to that of the Claudian.", "prev": "It Book Reviews 229 would be hard to find a critical commentary better adapted as a model for philological exercises in a pro-seminar, where it would furnish an excellent addition and supplement to Lindsay's brilliant Introduction.", "next": "An interesting separate report upon the early printed editions, from 1477 to 1541, has been made by the skilled hand of Dr.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.74, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262518:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262518", "s": "So that the oIkoo, ySovr) of the drama lies simply in a \"convincing\" presentation of a terrible and pitiful theme.", "prev": "The artificial nature of Otte's argument appears in his explanation of rrjv djro «X«ov Kal <f>6f$ov Sto fufirjcreais rjhovrjv (1453612) by a reference to the Rhetoric 137164 ff.: irav o av ev /UfirtfLtvov fj k&v rj fit] iJ8i> avrb to p4.1x.rjp.ivov. ov yap an tovtib yaipei, aXka. o-vWoyurfios icrrtv on tovto iicavo (Lore pja.v6d.vuv ti o-vp.pa.lvu (note particularly the next sentence)!", "next": "Indeed, this is putting it more than fairly.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.633, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261851:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261851", "s": "In fact, it may be said that the persuasion of their spuriousness has almost ' The study presented herewith is a continuation of some earlier investigations.", "prev": "Occasional protests against this unanimity of judgment, and efforts to rehabilitate them as Horatian, have been made, but it must be confessed that these have failed to shake the steadfast verdict which three centuries of scholarship have passed.", "next": "To avoid needless repetitions.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.035, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261851:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261851", "s": "One of the principal grounds of suspicion of these lines, to the critics who have considered them, is the persuasion that \" the promise quam sis mendosus is not fulfilled.\"' This omission is the less toler- able because the author says pervincam, \"I will demonstrate trium- phantly.\" But is it true that the promise is not fulfilled ?", "prev": "Horace and Valerius Cato 255 however, for its choice here is somewhat different, and leads us to the first problem of interpretation which these lines present.", "next": "In any large or genuine sense, most certainly it is not; but for the captious satire which is here intended the argument is flawless.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.284, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261851:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261851", "s": "Hendrickson he convinced or silenced his detractors is not likely.", "prev": "L.", "next": "On the con- trary, it is the nature of such replies to afford new material for satiri- cal attack.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.933, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261853:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261853", "s": "The Lot Oracle at Delphi 281 There is, then, after all no compelling reason for the adoption of Furtwangler's dictum that the girl is a priestess and no goddess.", "prev": "The passage is Orestes 162-65 (Murray's text) and is of later date than the vase-painting.", "next": "Welcker 1 on the contrary has well said that her anachronistic appear- ance here flatters the Attic pride of race.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.195, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261855:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261855", "s": "The second scholium, no doubt written by the same hand, is less convincing, but contains one or two fairly clear indications.", "prev": "ubtedly in Cicero's mind when he wrote, De leg. agr. i. 4. 13: \"Hie tamen excipit Pompeium simillime, ut mihi videtur, atque ut ilia lege, qua peregrini Roma eiciuntur, Glaucippus excipitur.\" Of these passages, the first, written by a scholiast, asserts explic- itly that Archias was being prosecuted on the ground that he had illegally assumed the rights that belonged exclusively to Roman citizens.", "next": "The word causa is used more appropriately of a suit at law than of an investigation.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.583, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "Lipsius, although at first he adopted Hermann's view (MSL, p. 491, especially n. 46), has accepted Leisi's conjecture (cf. infra, p. 367, n. 1). 'Eirt(rK7?\\^ts AND THE AiKTj '^evSonapTvp'uav 367 Laws are entirely convincing only when there is supporting evidence.", "prev": "The exhaustive and scholarly discussion of the SIkti tfev- SonapTVpluv (pp. 120 ff.) deserves the highest praise. * 937B. 6 Op. cit., p. 126.", "next": "Plato was not limited to the Attic law in choosing the materials for his system, and it is at least possible that some of the details into which he enters so freely in the passage are modifications of Athenian procedure.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.081, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "Neither of these attempts to solve the difficulty can be called convincing.", "prev": "What man on trial for his life would neglect eiri- (TKrj^'is, which meant a stay of execution and a chance of life, and trust to friends to bring a ypa(j>ri avKocftavrias, which would expose the perjury only tjj'ik' ovSev riv en TrXeov rots weirovdoaiv ?", "next": "They are in fact based upon the assumption that has itself given rise to the perplexity they seek to solve, namely, that the procedure in perjury actions remained unchanged during the period covered by the sources.^ It was left for Leisi to discover the essential fact that 1 5. 95.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.259, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "The conjecture which San Nicol<5 {op. cit., pp. 348-49) bases on this case, that witnesses could be prosecuted years after the offense, irre- spective of whether or not there had been ixUrKnyfis, is not convincing, though the writer cannot agree with Lipsius (Recht, p. 987) in connecting the prosecution by Menexenus with the impeachment instituted by Polyaratus years before.", "prev": "For the details and chronology, see supra, p. 381, n. 1, and the notes of Wyse there cited.", "next": "As has been observed, the case is too obscure to afford safe ground for conclusions (cf. supra, loc. cit).", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.649, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "Here again is seen clearly the difference between the ancient and the modern attitude toward perjury.* And it may be plausibly con- jectured that in the Athenian handhng of perjury in the Areopagus we have the first step in a course of development which led to the modern treatment of the offense.", "prev": "oincidence that the Areopagus apparently was the only Athenian tribunal which insisted that pleadings be kept strictly to the issue.* Since other classes of pubHc actions may have pre- sented the same problem,^ it is unsafe to draw sweeping conclusions on this point in default of evidence, especially when there is so Httle information in regard to the detailed handHng of perjury in public actions.", "next": "Neither the Laws nor the Halle papyrus gives any information as to what magistrates had jurisdiction in perjury actions.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.708, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "The view that more severe penalties could be imposed in prose- cutions originating in public actions than in those which arose from private suits is based on insufficient evidence, and the arguments urged in its support involve misunderstanding of the sources as well as questionable logic' It had been generally assumed that the fine went to the prose- cutor, as in all private suits, until Bonner expressed a doubt \"that the fine was ever paid to the prosecutor in the way of damages.\"* While no very pertinent or convincing objection to Bonner's view has as yet been advanced,' his arguments scarc", "prev": "Furthermore, it is in no wise incon- sistent with the other passages in which artiua is said to be a penalty of perjury, as has been pointed out.* But it may be remarked that a careful review of the controversy on this point makes very evident the dangers of advancing positive assertions where the evidence is so slight.", "next": "But the question he raises ' Rentzsch, op. cit., p. 45: \"Nisi vero arbitramur his locis de tertia \\ji€vioiMprv- ftluv condemnatione cogitandum ease, quamvis nulla eius mentio iniciatur.\" The absence of a specific allusion to three convictions is sufficiently accounted for by the fact that Athenian audiences were thoroughly familiar with the circumstances under which drifJo entered into the punishm", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.798, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261322:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261322", "s": "Rentzsch and Leisi conclude from a statement of Isaeus that the conviction of a single witness was sufficient.'' But Lipsius very prop- erly observes that the phraseology is not so precise as to warrant a definite conclusion to this effect.' On the other hand, the argvunents by which Lipsius attempts to prove from the litigation over the estate of Dicaeogenes that the conviction of several witnesses was necessary cannot be regarded as convincing.* Even if Menexenus and his fellow claimants had convicted several witnesses, it would not prove that this was a legal prerequisite.* But Wyse is unqu", "prev": "The passage of the Laws which treats of the prerequisites for retrial is understood to mean that over half of all the witnesses introduced by the successful litigant must be convicted.^ That this is not to be applied to Attic procedure is very generally agreed.", "next": "Cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.865, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261323:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261323", "s": "As in the case of the augment, so for the forms now under con- sideration, the statistics fail to convince wherever they are tested, and those who believe, in whatever degree, in the unity of the poetry do not need to be disturbed by the very positive tone in which the results are announced.", "prev": "Certainly we have not had the last word on the point.", "next": "Not many are able to spare laborious days for the examination of such statistics, but those who can will find their reward in confirmed conviction as to the uniformity of the language and verse of Homer.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.915, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261326:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261326", "s": "Only the compara- tively important uses of diminutives to express youth or weakness are recognized below. 438 Walter Petersen True. 2. 8. 7 Quantillo mi opere nunc persuaderi potest, quantulus- cumque 'however small': Cic.", "prev": "I mean such minutiae as whether the diminu- tive idea implies smallness in length or area or bulk or quantity or number, or whether it is applied to the notion of time or abstract words, and the like.", "next": "De Or. 1. 30. 135 de hoc mea, quantula- cumqua est, facultate quaeritis;", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.486, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261331:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261331", "s": "Yet, serious or not, Plato must have intended to give his calculations a semblance of plausibility, sufficient at least to carry his hearers with him.", "prev": "\"The actual calculations are inspired by a desire to reach the total 729\" (Adam).", "next": "He has left us moderns a little puzzled.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.833, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261334:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261334", "s": "Rightly or wrongly, the reviewer has not yet been convinced by Professor Frank's arguments that ius fetiale determined so completely the action of the Romans that \"the first instance, so far as we know, of Rome's departure from the intents and purposes of the fetial institution\" did not occur until 282 b.c.", "prev": "To the probable errors that are due to the character of these sources must be added the possibility of a mistaken conception of the scope and binding force of ius fetiale, and therefore we must emphasize the necessity of caution in accepting the results of such a method.", "next": "(p. 65).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.213, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-261336:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-261336", "s": "Not only does Apuleius' reply to the charges made against him seem convincing, but his tone throughout the Apology is that of one who feels confident of the outcome, and is using the opportunity in part to display his learning and rhetorical skill.", "prev": "The reviewer must confess that the evidence adduced fails to turn him from the commonly accepted view that the trial resulted in an acquittal.", "next": "This conclusion appears stronger, if it is true, as seems probable, that the defense as we have it was revised after the verdict had been rendered.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.643, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262483:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262483", "s": "As for Pitholeon, it is a very brilliant and plausible conjecture of Bentley that he is identical with the M.", "prev": "It is noteworthy, however, that he belongs in the general category of Alexandrinism, and is named by Propertius as a precursor in elegy, along with Catullus.", "next": "Otacilius Pitholaus, whose carmina maledicentissima 1 directed against Julius Caesar are referred 1 Concerning the character of these compositions, we have only the evidence of the scholia: epigrammata effutivit magis quam scripsit.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.546, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262483:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262483", "s": "That is, however, only an ancient guess, as the alternative form of the scholium shows, though a very natural and plausible one in the context of the passage.", "prev": "At vs. 30 Canusini more bilinguis we have a personal allusion which doubtless was significant to Horace and his audience, but it escapes us, unless, as the scholiast surmises, it refers to Pitholeon.", "next": "Another personal allusion, which for Horace's time and circle had the value of a name, is contained in turgidus Alpinus in vs. 36.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.574, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262483:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262483", "s": "To me the identification seems in every way most plausible and clarifying.", "prev": "Rev., XV (1901), 217 contends that the Furius addressed and referred to by Catullus in a number of his poems is Furius Bibaculus.", "next": "The playful skit in which he is addressed about the location of his villa (26) — Furi villula vostra non ad Austri — will be recalled.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262483:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262483", "s": "Heidel's further suggestion that some of the Catullian imitations in the Catalepta are to be attributed to Furius is attractive and intrinsically plausible, but lacks evidence.", "prev": "In similarity of conceit and of technique (especially the concluding line of each) the resemblance is striking, and whether we accept the identification proposed or not, it can scarcely be doubted that Furius Bibaculus was in fact influenced by the epigram of Catullus.", "next": "One does not like to attribute the coarse but amusing parody of Catal. 8 (Sabinus Me quern videtis kospites) to Virgil, but, whoever the author, it would not be amiss to characterize him, with Horace, as simius doclus cantare Calullum. i The meaning of urbanus in this passage is discussed by Lutsch (\"Die Urbanitas nach Cicero,\" in Festschrift fUr Crecelius, Elberfeld, 1881).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.726, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262483:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262483", "s": "De or. ii. 230, and Quint, vi. 3. 14: \"longe venustiora omnia in respondendo quam in provocando.\" 2 Something could be said here with much plausibility, or even probability, for contentionibus instead of contionibus; for contio is only a specific and not a generic an- tithesis to sermo.", "prev": "Cic.", "next": "The larger antithesis is contentio (-ones) : cf.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.913, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263229:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263229", "s": "But the argument is not convincing.", "prev": "Such 'coverings' of paint and fresco were called tectoria.\" Now Juvenal 8. 157 has nothing at all to do with paintings on the outside 146 Chaeles Knapp It might indeed be argued that the very use of this kind of joke by Tranio proves that paintings on the outside of buildings (houses) were not unknown at Rome in Plautus' time.", "next": "The passages given below as referring to paintings (portraits) and frescoes (of.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.245, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263229:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263229", "s": "I am convinced that Plautus meant his audience to think of the dog in our passage as a painted dog, somewhere within the house, let us say on a side wall of the entrance-passage.", "prev": "Sequere me hac igitur.", "next": "Of course when the play was acted there need not have been a dog of any kind, painted, mosaic, or stuffed (see below), within the house.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.341, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263231:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263231", "s": "While the Boeotian type is in its origin, we are convinced, identical with that of Att.", "prev": "T&Xeco, above, p. 181).", "next": "Mei^s, it spread far beyond its usual limits in the case of the numerous longer names like MeaoiXXei, EwojUjuei, ' ABaviKKei, etc.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.609, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263231:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263231", "s": "But for those who are convinced that the r-infiection is original (see above, p. 177) there is no difficulty in regarding the vowel inflection here, and in Ionic and Lesbian, as secondary, due to the analogy of the masculine a-stems, just as the vowel inflection of (r-stem names in Lesbian and elsewhere (cf. my Greek Dialects § 108. 2) must be so regarded.", "prev": "Meister finds in these Cyprian forms confirmation of the view that names like MeV?;* were originally vowel stems.", "next": "Besides the confusion with the vowel declension, as seen in Ionic, Lesbian, Cyprian, and occasionally elsewhere, there is some confusion with <r-stem names in -77$.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.642, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263232:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263232", "s": "In short, I am convinced that the vase painter meant to celebrate a woman, not a small piece of country.", "prev": "Other instances may be found on pp. 39, 61, 98 of Klein's lAeUingsinschriften and on p. 50 of his MeistersigmUuren.", "next": "But that he would refer to her as the \"the Brasian woman\" rather than by her individual name does not seem very likely.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.711, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263233:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263233", "s": "In short, I am convinced that the vase painter meant to celebrate a woman, not a small piece of country.", "prev": "Other instances may be found on pp. 39, 61, 98 of Klein's lAeUingsinschriften and on p. 50 of his MeistersigmUuren.", "next": "But that he would refer to her as the \"the Brasian woman\" rather than by her individual name does not seem very likely.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.166, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263234:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263234", "s": "I cannot cite any exact parallel, but it seems a more plausible explana- tion than to derive the name of the gate directly from that of the city.", "prev": "If Schulze's view is true, why can we not explain the Porta Romana most easily by supposing that this powerful Etruscan clan, or family, dwelt at this northwest corner of the hill — where tradition puts the first settlement — and that the gate, as well as the whole inclosure, got its name from this fact ?", "next": "Samuel Ball Platneb TACITUS AGRICOLA 44.1 Agricola 44.1 states: \"excessit [Agricola] ....", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.877, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263235:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263235", "s": "I cannot cite any exact parallel, but it seems a more plausible explana- tion than to derive the name of the gate directly from that of the city.", "prev": "If Schulze's view is true, why can we not explain the Porta Romana most easily by supposing that this powerful Etruscan clan, or family, dwelt at this northwest corner of the hill — where tradition puts the first settlement — and that the gate, as well as the whole inclosure, got its name from this fact ?", "next": "Samuel Ball Platneb TACITUS AGRICOLA 44.1 Agricola 44.1 states: \"excessit [Agricola] ....", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.378, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263332:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263332", "s": "It remains an injustice, however, to deprive Hesiod of the paternity of the description, unless cogent reasons are adduced to show its spuriousness; and, I am sorry to say, the close examination to which I subjected Hesiod's text while conducting the exercises of the Greek seminar in the University of Pennsylvania in 1916- 17 has brought me to conclusions very different from those of Mr.", "prev": "In this way the conceits avoiXTeos (octopus), iiXtjkoitch (ferae), rpiirovs (senex), sup- posedly typical of the Hesiodic art, though they would be denied to Hesiod himself, would be preserved by his school, while the Ionian features of a part of the description would also be accounted for.", "next": "Evelyn-White and of most of the commentators.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.127, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263332:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263332", "s": "However, the exclusion of all the passages that seem more or less similar to preceding ones could be made only arbitrarily because the same Hesiodic features are found in them all, and even the sequence of ideas is easily discovered in the whole poem, provided one remembers that, although it is a poem of reason, it aims, as does popular oratory, to impress an idea par coups re'pe'tls, by reproducing the same considerations in another tone or under another slightly different aspect, so as to create a state of mind, rather than by a persuasion based on a strict argument.", "prev": "If, therefore, on such grounds one rejects the description of winter or portions of it, one must also hold in suspicion two- thirds of the poem.", "next": "Even this broad view of the poem, however, cannot stand in the presence of contradictions, and Mr.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.741, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263333:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263333", "s": "For reasons which follow I am convinced that the actual supervision and responsibility of the cleaning of the canals fell, for the greater part, upon Aelius Gallus when he was prefect of Egypt.", "prev": "The project is usually placed by modern historians in the prefecture of Gaius Petronius. 3 This is done because of Strabo's statement that the rise of eight to fourteen cubits produced satisfac- tory to excellent crops in the time of Petronius' prefecture («r' ene'ivov 6e ap^avros ttJs x&P as )- Strabo, however, nowhere ascribes the actual work to Petronius.", "next": "When dealing with the alluvial plain of the Tigris-Euphrates basin about Babylon, Strabo shows an unusually clear knowledge of the whole process of river irrigation. 4 He has a perfectly clear concep- tion of the paramount difficulty which arises in maintaining such a system in a low alluvial plain — namely, silting.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.514, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262737:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262737", "s": "It is the same point of view which we find specifically enunciated by so competent a theorist as Quintilian, and rests upon the persuasion which Quintilian develops at length — that the sound of Greek was far more pleasing and musi- cal than that of Latin.", "prev": "But not so.", "next": "To this subject a considerable section is devoted in the twelfth book (10. 27-34), which in this connection makes interesting reading.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.562, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262737:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262737", "s": "But was he convinced?", "prev": "s metuensque ne vitiosum colligeret, etiam verum sanguinem deperdebat.\" Horace and Valerius Cato 347 The point of the lines consists, not in their erotic content, but in Virgil's banter of Varius for his stern praecepta (Latinitatis) - 1 One might suspect that Virgil had already written the second line as it stands here; on being taken to task for the concluding word, he replied with this epigram.", "next": "Scarcely; the substitution sounds like an effort to ruin by parody a line which derives what poetry there is in it from the Greek word.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.814, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262738:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262738", "s": "Graec; and Diodorus ii. 58 — enough to give plausibility to the dramatic exaggeration in Eur.", "prev": "Hist.", "next": "Andromache, 173 ff . toioutoi\" Tar rb fiippapov yhot tar-ftp rt Svyarpl Tats re iirirpl piyrvrai KbpT) r' adc\\<pqi. ..... .... teal rur 5* o$8&r ifclpyei r6fiot.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.943, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "Nolhac's reasoning on this subject (I, 260 f.) is most convincing.", "prev": "The most famous instance of the expansiveness of which Pet- rarch's imaginative processes were capable in respect to the events of his intellectual life is to be seen in the development into an idSefixe Petrarch's Knowledge of the Life of Vergil 375 of the notion that he had once possessed the treatise of Cicero, De Gloria.", "next": "But we do not need to confine ourselves to one hypoth- esis, however attractive, to find support for another.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.258, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "The Servian Life does not contain the epigram of Sulpicius, but admitting, as does Cosenza, the significance of Ergone supremis as a source of suggestion to Petrarch, there is no compelling reason to send us beyond the poem and the Servian Life in order to account for every- thing that we meet in this context of the Epistle to Vergil.", "prev": "He should at all events have taken cognizance of the Servian Life as well, since it is almost as explicit on the subject of the frustration of Vergil's order to destroy the Aeneid as is the Life by Donatus.", "next": "How closely in thought and in motivation Petrarch approaches the poem, will be most apparent if we can bring ourselves to employ for a moment that analytic method to which the pedantic seeker after the well-springs of a poet's fancy often is compelled to resort.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.39, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "But, to account for this context in the Itinerarium, we are not restricted to speculations, plausible though they be, as to what — given a knowledge of the Servian Life — the powers of inference, the imagination, and the vocabulary of Petrarch might have achieved.", "prev": "The epitaph itself, in which Vergil looks forward to his interment at Naples as fait accompli, implies that the poet entertained the wish and anticipated its fulfilment.", "next": "Jerome, an author whose works were well thumbed by Petrarch, states directly (Euseb.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.536, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "However, a more plausible supposition is that Vergil, when he started on the journey that was to be his last, was so close to the beginning of his fifty-second year — in modern parlance was so near \"fifty-one and going on fifty-two\" — that the author of the Vita felt justified in disregarding the few weeks intervening.", "prev": "The Life attributed to Probus is that one of the ancient sources that is most precise in this respect : \" decessit in Calabria annum agens quinquagesimum et primum.\" The loose calculation of the Suetonian Life may be the result of carelessness.", "next": "Perhaps, as is likely to be the case in numerical approximations, a round even number had an appeal.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.694, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "I am not without hope that the reader of judicial mind has been persuaded to subscribe to my belief that, in the present state of our knowledge, we are not warranted in assuming that Petrarch used the Life by Donatus.", "prev": "It is apparent that, if Petrarch had read the Suetonian Life, his reliance on it was not even semi-occasional.", "next": "At all events, we may justly contend that the current theory has been revealed as resting on supports more tenuous than has hitherto been realized, that such assertions as Nolhac's \"il lisait, en effet, la vie de Virgile attribute a Donat\" and Sabbadini's \"il Petrarca adoperava certamente .... la biografia breve di Donato\" would better have been couched in more conservative phraseology.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.741, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "Let us see if a plausible solution may not he in a correct understanding of what Petrarch says.", "prev": "What we have learned in a recent instance recommends the wisdom of seeking first some other explanation than the hypothesis that Petrarch used biographical sources now lost to us.", "next": "Corrado, I believe, failed to grasp the precise shade of meaning that Petrarch intended to convey by the sentence \"nullum Virgilio praeceptorem legimus.\" The literal sense is \"we read of no teacher for Vergil,\" the dative, as, indeed, its intermediate position would show, being dependent on praeceptorem.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.918, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262739:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262739", "s": "By interpreting in this way the passage before us we obtain, in my opinion, the most plausible explanation of the genesis of Petrarch's statement.", "prev": "Pliny Ep. 7. 19. 7; it is strictly in conformity with the Latinity of Petrarch; see, for example, Variae 32, pp. 389-91 Frac.", "next": "I should assume that he had in mind at the moment of writing, to the temporary exclusion of his other sources, the data 402 Duane Reed Stuart offered by the Servian Life on the subject of Vergil's education.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.926, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262740:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262740", "s": "The study of literary genesis in classical literature seldom leads to convincing conclusions.", "prev": "In such a review I must be content, without pretentious bibliography or detailed analysis, to consider the broad foundations of this theory; the critical question which I have to answer is, how far the interpretation of the technique of Roman comedy must be influenced and determined by known facts regarding the development of the form of comedy in earlier stages of its history.", "next": "There are usually tremendous gaps in the evidence.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.036, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262740:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262740", "s": "One may, however, still insist on the plausibility of the general notion if it is limited to Old and Middle comedy, and may regard the weakness as mere botching, by some later hand, of a theory that was reasonable when first presented, perhaps in the course of the fourth century, as an explanation of the differences between Old and Middle comedy. 1 By this shift from explicit criticism to veiled attack and innuendo ancient theory accounts for essential changes in content; develop- ment in form it relates particularly to the gradual elimination of the chorus.", "prev": "At this point, therefore, ancient critics become purely rhetorical.", "next": "The statement of the case in Platonius 2 is blurred and inaccurate.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.112, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262740:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262740", "s": "A mythologi- cal travesty without parabases and chorika he represents to be typical of Middle comedy. 1 In my opinion this part of Platonius' statement is a plausible theory, if one revises the form of his expression in accord with known facts and conceivable conditions, correcting his obvious error and emphasizing what he left implicit.", "prev": "rescott and inaccurately includes, as if of the same date, a mythological travesty by Cratinus, the Odusses, which was probably exhibited as early as 440-38; and he explicitly refers this shift from lampooning comedy to mythological travesty, in respect to content as well as to form, to the necessity of diverting criticism from men and affairs to literary material as found in mythological tragedy.", "next": "Such a revised statement might run thus: Old comedy in the fifth century was devoted mainly to satirical criticism of prominent men.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.149, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262740:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262740", "s": "Prescott non-scurrilous mythological comedy, it would be difficult from extant evidence to resolve plausible theory into incontestable fact.", "prev": "(Van Leeuwen, Proleg. ad Aristoph., p. 173) and the critical apparatus of Kaibel 18/30. 412 Henry W.", "next": "And even if mythological comedy in the Middle period were satisfactorily accounted for by such reasoning, a coherent comedy of manners, sentiment, and intrigue such as emerges in the Middle period and becomes dominant in the New period would still remain unexplained.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.328, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262740:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262740", "s": "Pbescott lend greater plausibility to a theory of the influence of mythological than of biological mime.", "prev": "The certamen between sailors on river boats and sailors on 418 Henby W.", "next": "With substantial evidence of a mythological comedy in Sicily and hardly more than vague surmisings of a comedy of manners we turn to Crates and Pherecrates.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.626, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262741:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262741", "s": "A more convincing consideration is this.", "prev": "II, 16, is undoubtedly a letter out of the correspondence of Cleon's family. 4 It mentions events which occurred in the years 265 and 264 and was evidently written in the period 263-260 b.c Even that early Cleon is already close to the king.", "next": "The correspondence of the year 28, or 257 b.c, 6 shows that a certain village in the reclaimed area, named Philoteris, had long since been established, and the land around it brought under cultivation.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.809, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263747:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263747", "s": "He had practiced a shrewd trick on his stupid fellow-countrymen and convinced them thereby that they would enjoy a blessed immortality.", "prev": "Linfohth years in comparative comfort.", "next": "There is an implication that he had made a good profit for himself out of his sharp practice.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.709, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263748:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263748", "s": "He repeatedly professed and exhibited extreme solicitude that everyone, even the meanest citizen in Rome or the provinces (see Pro Sulla 41 ff.), should be convinced of the deadly character of the conspiracy, of the guilt of Catiline and his associates, of the fact that the consul had done nothing from beginning to end crudeliter aut regie.", "prev": "With the utmost deference to public opinion.", "next": "He did not venture to arrest and punish Catiline before he broke out in open rebellion.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.559, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263748:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263748", "s": "The unimpeachable evidence that he was able to produce was sufficient to convince even the cats of Rome.", "prev": "That he craved all possible moral support from the senate and from everybody else is evident enough, but, as to the other points, Cicero in fact appears, as he claims to be, alert, confident, bold, thoroughly informed.", "next": "Why, then, this unprecedented style of action ?", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.601, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263748:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263748", "s": "I believe that the answer may be found through noting the extreme solicitude of the consul to make widely known among the people as well as clear to the senate the convincing evidence against, and the confession of, the conspirators.", "prev": "The difficulty is manifest.", "next": "In this case there 48 Elmer Truesdell Merrill could be no question of a trial in which the accused might be supposed capable of putting up some kind of defense.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.745, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263748:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263748", "s": "Thus, I think, Cicero may have been able plausibly to defend his new procedure.", "prev": "The iudicium senatus was herein but a justifiable extension of the ordinary advisory function of that body.", "next": "The senate, to be sure, had already voted that the conspirators had acted contra rem publicam (cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.765, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263748:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263748", "s": "Very likely the conservatives cared nothing at all about theory, but were convinced that these criminals deserved death, and the consul evidently needed their votes to brace him up to see the thing through.", "prev": "What the rest of the senate, or rather, the majority, thought about the matter is not so clear.", "next": "But it may justly be remarked that Cicero does not always speak as if the senate were a competent court acting in this matter.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.814, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263113:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263113", "s": "The contention regarding the good courtezan I am willing to consider when any evidence is forthcoming, but being convinced that the bad courtezan is proved to be realistic by abundant contemporary evidence and perhaps, as a comic character, established in comedy as early as Pherecrates, I must in the meantime assume that the good courtezan is equally realistic, if slightly idealized and somewhat extravagantly employed for dramatic convenience.", "prev": "The Antecedents op Hellenistic Comedy 133 neglects her personal appearance because Phaedra is similarly lan- guid and neglectful. 1 The last three items, in which the common- places of Greek life and human experience are used to bolster up the Euripidean theory, I do not care to dignify by any discussion.", "next": "Somewhat dif- ferent from the content and technique of character treatment is the economic function of characters in the elaboration of the action.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.826, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263116:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263116", "s": "Until very recently it was assumed, apparently on purely a priori grounds. 8 But Lipsius in his latest discussion doubts that either form of plea was admissible in public actions, on no other ground, however, than the absence of convincing evidence. 4 There is no allusion to the use of irapaypa^ii in any but private suits, and it would seem that the lack of systematic and complete court records 5 must have rendered this form of plea ineffective for inter- posing a final bar to any ground of public action. 6 But in a majority 1 Lys. 23. 13-14.", "prev": "The admissibihty of special pleas in public actions has not been established.", "next": "This aspect of the case apparently escaped the notice of Lipsius (.Recht, p. 849, n. 12). 2 Isoc. 18. 11-12.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.624, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263116:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263116", "s": "However, if the writer's analysis of the legislation by which the amnesty was applied and made effective in the archonship of Euclides is correct, more convincing evidence is to be found in the law of Archinus and in the record of certain actions in which the amnesty was involved.", "prev": "Certainly neither the limitations of irapaypacfrri nor the fact that we have no instance of its use in a public cause justify us in denying its admissibil- ity.", "next": "Kennedy goes so far as to assert that irapaypa^ was first insti- tuted in the interest of those who were prosecuted for past political offenses, and that its use in civil litigation was an extension of its original functions. 1 This view goes back to Platner, who, without distinguishing between public and private actions, explains irapa- ypa<t>rt as a measure intended to establish and define by co", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.676, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263116:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263116", "s": "He it was who kept many of the city party from fleeing in their first panic to Eleusis and who later successfully resisted the attempt to swell the majority of the extreme democrats by the creation of new citizens/ he it was who haled before the fiovki) a man who undertook to disregard the amnesty and persuaded the members to put him to death, summarily, without trial, as an example for others. 6 Are we to believe that Archinus would have proposed for those who sought to bring political > Isoc. 18. 23 ff. * Ibid., 2. 3 ' Exw/SeXf a is found only in connection with private actions (Lipsius, Rec", "prev": "se &v r« Suc&f 7/rai irapa tovs BpKovs, which defines the scope of the enactment, expressly limits its application to civil cases if we understand Swc&f^rai in its normal and proper sense. 4 Furthermore, Archinus was the most enthusiastic proponent of the amnesty, the most uncompromising champion of those who demanded that the spirit as well as the letter of the agreement be scrupulously observed.", "next": "Assuredly it would not here have been prescribed if the rapaypaip^ had been intended to apply to public as well as private actions.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.864, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263118:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263118", "s": "The argument would be very plausible if we found the same agreement between Chalcidius and Plotinus concerning the question of the origin of matter that we find concerning its nature.", "prev": "Steinheimer (pp. 40-45) indicates many close parallels between this latter section and Plotinus, and concludes, notwithstanding several slight discrepancies which he points out, that Chalcidius' source is a neo-Platonist.", "next": "But in chapters 300-301 Chalcidius divides Platonists into two main classes : those who declare that matter is the creation of God, and those who regard it as uncreated.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.923, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263255:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263255", "s": "They blamed Pericles, because he had persuaded them to go to war, as the author of all their 1 Cf. ii. 38, ij rlpipis rb \\vtrripbv &7rX)}<r<rei.", "prev": "PERSONIFICATION OF ABSTRACTS After the remarkable description of the plague which wrought such fearful havoc at Athens and among the troops at Potidaea, and of the coincident Peloponnesian invasion of Attica, we are told that a change came over the spirit of the Athenians.", "next": "Personification in Thucydides 249 troubles.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.804, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263256:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263256", "s": "Even the irrational may escape censure if it be made plausible.", "prev": "Yet the poet has a use for what is not strictly true and logical.", "next": "And the marvelous is sweet.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.337, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263256:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263256", "s": "Here Odysseus, disguised in rags, wishes to convince Penelope that he, the Beggar, has seen the real Odysseus alive = A, a falsehood.", "prev": "We may take an instance from the 'Bath Scene' in the Odyssey} Turning to the 'Bath Scene' in Odyssey 19, we see the force of Aristotle's illustration.", "next": "Accordingly, he adds an accurate description of the hero's clothing = B.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.425, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263258:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263258", "s": "It seems to be the prevailing impression that externals, for the most part agreeable, entirely governed the handling of this season in the Roman poets, and that the seasonal melancholy which figures so largely in modern poetry is a comparatively recent innovation. 1 There is certainly much reason for this assumption, but a review of the evidence has convinced me that the modern idea was not alto- gether a \"sudden leap\" in evolution, but to some extent a develop- ment from plain suggestions in the Roman poets. 2 The present paper is designed to review in a cursory way the various aspects of aut", "prev": "A more delicate and interesting problem is presented by the autumn season.", "next": "Though my title seems to limit the consideration to autumn, I shall include such references to winter as bear directly on important poetical associations.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.083, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263259:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263259", "s": "A much more plausible suggestion is that the Nervians purposely exaggerated their losses. 1 They had, of course, every reason to do so, since their only hope lay in the clemency of the conqueror.", "prev": "Besides, by any calculation it would be difficult to make the levies of three years adequate.", "next": "In that case there is no real discrepancy between the facts as they are depicted in Book ii and in Book v.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.258, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263259:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263259", "s": "His relations are apparently so intimate that he can plausibly boast that Caesar offered to make him king of the Aeduans.", "prev": "To outsiders his reconciliation with Caesar is complete.", "next": "But of Diviciacus never a word.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.554, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263262:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263262", "s": "Walde, hardly convincingly, draws trames from trans and meo.", "prev": "ponding word from licio is lima 'file,' dependent on the meaning 'scratch.' To licio and traho belong times and trames 'trail.' The special sense 'boundary line' is quite secondary; thus Aen. 2. 697 \"turn longo limite sulcus,\" which not only hints at the ancient association of the furrow and the trail, but brings to notice sulcus from the root of IAxo> which dis- appeared from the Latin as a verb.", "next": "Along with limes goes limen from Hicsmen, like lumen from *lucsmen, the all-important 'line' between indoors and out of doors, superstitiously regarded by the bride especially and of sufficient importance to be presided over by a numen called Limentinus.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.668, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262940:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262940", "s": "A Semitic scholar from whom I asked an opinion on this very point replied, \"The cases I have looked into seem quite convincing to a Semitic student,\" and he commended the general method as clear and careful.", "prev": "My own experience is different.", "next": "Miller, \"Die Geographie des Odyssee,\" in Preuss.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.967, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262941:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262941", "s": "He supposes that the primitive man as he gazed into another's eyes identified the pupillary image of himself that he saw therein as the other person's soul. 3 As is well known, 1 At a time when I was persuaded by its arguments that the pupula duplex merely referred to a bicoloration, I foolishly remarked to a class that one of our university officials illustrated this phenomenon of the evil eye.", "prev": "Accepting what I hope to show is a misleading, if not an unsound, conclusion of Riess 2 concerning Pliny's reference to persons who have a double pupil in one eye and the figure of a horse in the other, that the presence of the latter phenomenon, as an ailment of the eye, \"was ascribed to a horse- shaped demon,\" he has resorted to a similar demonological explana- tion of the double pupil.", "next": "One of the women, prospered, I suppose, by the felix curiositas — or was it the curiosa felicitas of her sex ? — soon found a victim.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.074, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262941:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262941", "s": "Tokens of an \"Evil Eye\" 345 statement it is notable that this anomaly is commonly in only one eye and as a rule does not interfere with vision. 1 In passing to the phenomenon of the pupula duplex, we may define the physical basis 2 for the superstition much more narrowly and I hope quite convincingly.", "prev": "J ), pp. 335, 593.", "next": "While it is probably a fact that there is no such thing among human beings as a double pupil, that is to say, as two real pupils, in one eye, each opening possessing a sphincter muscle enabling it to contract and dilate, 3 there are appear- ances 4 of the eye which would lead an ancient to discern two pupils i Consult, e.g., Reference Handbook of the Medical Sciences, V, 216 ff.;", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.824, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262942:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262942", "s": "So they shrink from making final decisions and try to persuade them- selves that there may be some value after all in these unproved assertions, that at least they represent what the ancients thought, or that industry in collecting material for argument will compensate for lack of judgment in using it.", "prev": "They forget that the elimination of the false is as necessary to scholarly accuracy as the collection of the true.", "next": "They do not realize that the false beclouds the true, and that the effort to reconcile conflicting traditions with one another or with facts leads to the perversion, not the increase, of knowledge.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.43, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262943:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262943", "s": "Cf. p. 386. 364 Frank Egleston Robbins though its value was probably more, and another was sold for 40 minas. 1 Boeckh attempted to determine the average cost of the trireme from the inscriptions, but with not entirely satisfactory results. 2 There are, however, two pieces of evidence upon the matter that agree fairly well; it may be inferred from Polyaenus i. 30. 6 that a trireme could be built for a talent, and it has been very plausibly conjectured that by the payment of 5,000 drachmas in the case of a trireme and 5,500 drachmas in that of a horse transport a trierarch could fulfil his obli", "prev": "It is equally impossible to determine what was spent for garrisons, and the item is included merely for the sake of completeness. 2 The fourth item, a very important one in estimating the cost of ancient warfare, will be considered in connection with the various campaigns; the fifth unfortunately cannot be determined at all; but it is the least important of the five.", "next": "Two talents may confidently be assumed, for the present purpose, as a moderate estimate of the cost of both hull and rigging of a trireme.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.115, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262944:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262944", "s": "Role of the Cook in \"Ctjrculio\" 395 cook and provisions, a more plausible explanation can be invented. 1 Phaedromus, then, would enter the house in vs. 228, leaving Palinurus to engage in conversation with the leno, with the cook as a silent spectator of their colloquy until vs. 251. 2 Then, at the cook's bid- ding, Palinurus sets about the task of conveying the provisions within and otherwise making things ready for the cook.", "prev": "[1879], praef., xxii, n. 1) took exception to this, stating his own views as follows (op. tit., xxi f. ): \"Hoc demum saeculo Fleckeisenus post v. 273 maiorem lacunam detexit: sed cur idem neget scaenam II 2 esse absolutam non satis perspicio: immo praeter versus aliquot qui ad Palinurum pertinent plura intercidisse non video quo iure coniciamus.\" 1 De Plauti Curculione (1903), pp. 31 ff.", "next": "While going back and forth from house to stage he chances to see the parasite approach- ing and immediately calls to Phaedromus.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.513, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263616:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263616", "s": "If Lat. popularl is derived from populus, as seems to me most plausible in spite of other suggestions (see Walde, s.v.), it would indicate at the most that populus was also once employed in the specialized sense of 'folk army,' until later replaced by the 'trained army,' exercitus. 38.", "prev": " 2 ) asserts that Volk \"war ursprunglich Bezeichnung einer Kriegerschaar.\" But the more generally pre- vailing meaning 'people' even in Germanic, the meaning of the cognate Gk. ir\\i}6os, Lat. plebs, populus, and their obvious connec- tion with pel-, pie- 'fill,' ought to make it sufficiently clear that the meaning 'crowd, multitude, people' is the earlier, and that of 'armed band, army' secondary.", "next": "Mid.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.494, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263619:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263619", "s": "In Tr. 627-704 Lysiteles adulescens tries, in vain, to persuade Lesbonicus adulescens to give him his sister in marriage, sine dote.", "prev": "Poe. 578-81 (the opening verses of Act III, scene 2).", "next": "In 705-8 Stasimus servos, who has heard the whole discussion, exclaims Non enim possum quia exclamem, Eugae, eugae, Lysiteles, iroA.ii'! facile palmam habes: hie victust, vicit tua comoedia.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.404, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263621:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263621", "s": "Whoever will collect these remarkable archaisms — note the number of such excellent old forms as exemet, inaltod, marid, olorom, triresmos, navebos, numei, and na«>afed,' consider the non-appearance of such forms as qiwm, endo, and ai, which an antiquarian would naturally have selected, and remember that we have no sure case of conscious archaizing of inscriptions — should be convinced that at least the sub- stance of the inscription rests upon a genuine original.", "prev": "Dxjillius 75 that was taking place in the days of Plautus; and so on.", "next": "The recent aversion to the inscription seems to be based chiefly upon Norden's assertion' that in comparison with the simple and jejune epitaphs and honorific inscriptions of the following two centuries the Duillian eulogy is fulsome and rhetorical; that in fact it is too self-conscious an effort to be attributed to the Romans before the day of their first literary attempts.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.154, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263621:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263621", "s": "Even his explanation of the incon- sistent forms as being due to an attempt to restore the illegible words with plausible if mistaken archaisms is conceivably acceptable.", "prev": "It would seem then that the critics who reject the inscription have failed to sustain their case, and that WoelfHin's faith in the substance of it is fully justified.", "next": "This explanation, however, is open to two possible objections: in the first place, we know of no other instance of conscious archaizing, and, secondly, it seems strange that this hypothetical antiquarian would have sanctioned such modern-looking forms as aes, praeda, cum, and navales if he really desired to give his restorations an antique appearance.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.418, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263621:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263621", "s": "II, 49), and gave a full list of the honors voted him by the senate and people,^ not failing to note that his was the first naval triumph,' and perhaps adding the fact that huic per- missum est, ut ab epulis domum cum tibidne et funali rediret.* Indeed the prominence given by the elogium and by so many authorities to these vain honors can be plausibly explained if we assume that this peculiar inscription, which followed the pompous Greek fashion of recording such trivialities,* was their source.", "prev": "Ann.", "next": "At any rate Silius Italicus, who gives a fairly full list of the traditional details, seems to have had the monument and the text of the inscription in mind (Pun.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.916, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263622:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263622", "s": "He convinced the Thesmothetae that it was a proper action to bring under the circumstances.", "prev": "I am simply developing his theory of the •ypo^i) K/3pews.", "next": "We need not inquire whether he could have hoped to convince a jury. 3 The word vj3pi^oiv is significant (Dem. 36. 30).", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.971, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263622:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263622", "s": "We need not inquire whether he could have hoped to convince a jury. 3 The word vj3pi^oiv is significant (Dem. 36. 30).", "prev": "He convinced the Thesmothetae that it was a proper action to bring under the circumstances.", "next": "", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.984, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263076:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263076", "s": "(p. 61), \"them- selves afford a convincing proof that the traditions of the earlier Minoan and Mycenaean culture lived on in that of the Viking race of Greece,\" and Professor Burrows (p. 209) tells us that the story of the poems presupposes the civilization of Late Minoan III, a period in which, as we have seen, intercourse with the West was active.", "prev": "Min.", "next": "It is the sea lore of that age that is preserved in the Odyssey (Myres, Geogr.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.23, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263076:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263076", "s": "[1912], pp. 1081 ff .) with the reality and accuracy of the geography and topography and most other things in the poems, and he was convinced that he had found the site of Alkinoos' stronghold on the small peninsula of Kephali in the northwest of Corfu.", "prev": "He is a man imbued, I might almost say above all others (see his \"Con- fession of Homeric Faith,\" Wochenschr. filr Phil.", "next": "See Athen.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.487, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "Tragddie eine Akteinteilung t (Giessen, 1914), who convinces himself that choral stasima are not at all regularly the boundaries of logical chapters, although tragedy does provide \"bestimmte Richtlinien fur das Entstehen von ftinf Akten\" (p. 96).", "prev": "This asser- tion, so far as Greek tragedy is concerned, is vigorously contested by Holzapfel, Kennt die griech.", "next": "I have accepted, however, Leo's assumptions in the argument above without raising the question whether or not the so-called acts in tragedy or comedy are logical units; it seems proper to meet Leo on his own ground. 112 Henry W.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.159, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "In any case it is well to remember that, however a chorus may find its way into the drama at the start, once there it is very quickly made to perform desirable economic functions; the economic necessity of working with a limited number of actors and the artistic regard for a plausible representa- tion, however rough, of the lapse of time are neatly satisfied by the 114 Henry W.", "prev": "This form need not have been so directly due to the influence of tragedy, but may have arisen as a compromise between non-choral Sicilian comedy and choral scurrilous comedy.", "next": "Prescott choral interlude; and in a non-choral drama the same objects are obtained by interlude music, by stationary scenes, or by substantial pauses.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.234, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "At 229 I see no clear evidence of a break in the action; nor am I fully convinced by the arguments of Skutsch and Flickinger regarding the condition of the Greek original at 170. 3 The technique which I discern in the Greek original of the Persa is roughly analogous to admittedly Greek technique in other Roman plays in which interlude scenes, spoken or sung, are found, e.g., Captivi 460-98, 909-21, Cure. 462-86, Most. 313-47 (cf.", "prev": "Why may they not have performed this function in the Greek original ? 2 The conditions are particularly good at 409, where a night intervenes; at 748, where the ancillae may pass across the stage; and at 873, where the old men re-enter, having just left the stage at 872.", "next": "Leo, Der Monolog, 59 and n. 2, PL Forsch.*, 227, n. 3) .", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.338, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "Such problems, for example, are presented by a limited number of actors, by the necessity of covering plausibly time intervals, and by peculiarities of the stage setting.", "prev": "A non-choral type of drama has problems in common with choral drama but must meet them without a chorus.", "next": "Time for off-stage action and for change of r61es is easily provided by a chorus, whether organic or inorganic; non-choral drama is driven to a variety of substitutes for the chorus — to lyrical intermezzos by single actors or small groups of actors, to instrumental music, to dances, to monologues, or to dialogue scenes that may not always promote the action.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.361, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "The difference between my own views and the tendencies of modern criticism may be illustrated by a brief criticism of Leo's theory of the monologue. 2 To understand his argument we must outline the results of his study, which, by its scope, by the thorough marshaling of material, by the nice discrimination of stylistic qual- ities, and by the historical perspective of the investigator, excites the greatest admiration and doubtless carries conviction.", "prev": "With these considerations in mind we may better appreciate the most striking feature of the technique of New comedy.", "next": "Racial psy- chology prepares us for an extensive use of solo speeches in Greek liter- ature.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.372, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263077:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263077", "s": "He is quite convinced, however, that the prologue as a detachable expository speech is thoroughly Euripidean (ibid., 30 ff., 40, 45, 49). 2 Ibid., 28. 3 In this small matter I should probably not espouse any theory of origins or influence but content myself with the observation that comic and tragic dramatists, facing similar problems of exposition, solve the difficulties in similar simple ways.", "prev": "ies the solilo- quy form of his address, and in general satisfies all the demands of a modern sophisticated critic, to a negligent and relatively inartistic prologue in which the speaker seems to be almost impersonal, disregards motivation, external or internal, and is conscious of the audience, though he does not directly appeal to it. 6 And the 1 Frantz, De comoediae Alt. prologis (1891), 21 ff.", "next": "The modern playwright who opens his play with a dialogue between the butler and the maid need not have read ancient drama or contemporary drama; such devices are quickly conventionalized, of course, and become traditional, but they are weak props for any thoroughgoing theory of origins or influence. * Der Monolog, 14-26. 6 Explicit address to the audience in tragedy is so rare that Frantz (op. cit", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.66, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263078:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263078", "s": "Jebb's Homer, page 117, says \"Poets regard the Homeric poems as a unity; critics favor manifold authorship.\" No test seems to me more convincing than the test of the Aeolic infinitive in -tpev.", "prev": "Men who have judged Homer merely as poetry have had no standing in the supreme court of criticism, for in this court language holds the final decision.", "next": "This is clearly an archaic survival even in Homer and, as Witte has shown in his article on the Homeric language in Pauly-Wissowa, sub voce \"Homeros,\" p. 2217, this infinitive is not found in Ionic-Attic, Homeric poetry having inherited it from earlier songs.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.064, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263078:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263078", "s": "This argument in its final form as presented by Cauer was most convincing.", "prev": "ABSTRACT NOUNS I have luckily been able recently to trace to its source another great error of disintegrating criticism, namely the error with regard to the use of abstracts, an error that I pointed out in the Classical Review for February, 1910, pages 8ff.", "next": "Cauer shows how the Homeric language had slowly progressed, and how marked the stages are in the Iliad and in the Odyssey, as shown by the increas- ing use of the abstract, in Grundfragen, page 393: \"Maurice Croiset hat beobachtet, dass von Substantiven auf -irj, -abvt\\, -rvs die Bias 39 hat, die Odyssee 81.\" However, when we turn to Croiset we find that he gives the number for the Iliad as 58, an", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.837, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262923:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262923", "s": "Hildebrandt (De Scholiis Ciceronis Bobiensibus [Berlin, 1894], pp. 25-27) is convinced that the irak.ivtfo'la. is not an oration, but he does not attempt to establish its identity.", "prev": "P.", "next": "Still others (e.g., Schanz, Rom.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.15, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262925:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262925", "s": "In compiling my statistics I have followed the marking of these words in the standard editions; but I am convinced that we should always prefer the scansion amlcitia to amicitia, where either one is possible.", "prev": "There has been a strange unwillingness to admit the operation of the iambic law in the two words last mentioned, and consequently all editors prefer to scan them with the second syllable long wherever that is possible.", "next": "This is the case in Amph. 899 (pudicitiae), Poen. 1215, and Stichus 414.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.862, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262927:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262927", "s": "All authori- ties, even Cicero, agree as to the dignity of his birth, his rare intellectual equipment, and the persuasive charm of his personality.", "prev": "By nature he was pecul- iarly fitted to be the leader of a discontented faction.", "next": "At first his intentions were to seek reform through legitimate chan- nels.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.849, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263500:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263500", "s": "In the absence of any reference to the matter in Greek literature, Grote's theory that they were some- times killed is very plausible.", "prev": "Some- times also wounded men must have been picked up by their comrades and carried off the field during the actual battle. 3 The suggestion may be made that the personal attendants of the Athenian hoplites helped somewhat in carrying off and tending the wounded. 4 But the most puzzling question is the treatment given to the wounded of the defeated side by the victors.", "next": "Occasionally two or three days elapsed before the conquered were admitted to the field to pick up the dead, and even if left alive by the enemy, those who were too weak to escape would have died in the interval.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.349, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263500:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263500", "s": "It seems plausible that they were sent home whenever possible, for the Athenian state was not prone to do for its citizens what they could do for themselves. 4 Provision was made by law for those who were permanently disabled, 5 and it is quite possible that the law included the temporarily disabled when financial aid was a necessity.", "prev": "Lamachus is brought in wounded from a campaign preceded by an attendant who rouses the household to make preparations for the care of the wounded master.", "next": "The names of all who had been killed in action or died of wounds were recorded on stone and set up in the Ceramicus, where their remains were buried.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.41, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263541:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263541", "s": "THE \"OTJLEX\" Everyone will remember the faenerator Alfius of Horace's epode who was all but persuaded to become a farmer.", "prev": "It is my purpose in the following pages to show that most of the doubt which still persists regarding their authen- ticity is misplaced, and that the time has come when we may confidently make use of them in tracing the growth of Vergil's powers.", "next": "I think it has not been pointed out that the verses which so nearly converted him [Classical Philology XV, January, 1920] 23 24 Tenney Frank were no other than the pastoral scene in the Culex, or let us say at once Vergil's Culex.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.078, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263541:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263541", "s": "Indeed there can be little doubt that Horace in his epode not only expressed his amusement at the business man's backsliding but also intended to compliment Vergil on the persuasive powers of his verse.", "prev": "Curas .... haec inter obliviscitur [E. 38]. incognita curis quae lacerant .... mentes [C. 61]. laetum pecus, distenta siccet ubera [E. 46]. illi sunt gratae rorantes lacte capellae [C. 76].", "next": "The very position of the epode in the second place after the introductory tribute to Maecenas reveals the poet's pur- pose in honoring his friend. 1 We might also suggest that this epode was one of Horace's earliest, since he would probably have chosen one of the eclogues for comment had these been published.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.152, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263541:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263541", "s": "The subject alone is beneath the dignity of a serious poem, and that can be explained by a more plausible hypothesis.", "prev": "Nor would Horace have taken the pastoral scene out of this poem for serious purposes if it had been intended as a parody.", "next": "The author has himself said something about his purpose in the first few lines, but the text is unfortunately so corrupt that we cannot be sure what they mean.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.363, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263542:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263542", "s": "If there is any such relationship, a more plausible semantic connection is suggested by the intransitive use and its evolution in Skt. gal- ' drip, drop, vanish, pass away.", "prev": "Sprachen, II, 459 ff., assumes on the contrary that 'pain' is a weakening of 'death,' and derives the latter meaning from \"es (das Leben) auswerfen, \" connecting the root with that of Gk. /3dXA&>, NHG. quellen, Skt. galaii.", "next": "See Wood, \"IE. a* 99,\" Mod.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.743, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263542:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263542", "s": "Connection with Lat. tundo 'strike' (so Littre, deriving tuer from Hudere or tuditare) is obviously the most plausible on semantic grounds, and I am convinced that tuer is actually derived from tuditare despite the phonetic difficulty involved in Fr. w=Lat.", "prev": "Georges, 427, 1281.", "next": "H.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.984, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263544:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263544", "s": "Our evidence on this point is brief but convincing.", "prev": "It is therefore quite as probable that the use of the term (3ovko\\lkov was due to the recognized influence of the priapean verse upon the versification of the bucolic poets.", "next": "We have seen that a certain type of priapean verse, i.e., (Cat.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.769, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263545:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263545", "s": "In Menander's Georgos a man bewails the disadvantage under which a poor man labors (in the courts, apparently) ; no matter how just his case may be, it is impossible to convince people that his whole purpose is not personal gain; <rvK<xf>avTr}s is the name given to a man with a threadbare suit, regardless of the justice of his case. 6 Another of Menander's characters moralizes on the unfairness of this life; decency and honesty go unrewarded and rascality has the upper hand: \"Best of all fares the /c6Aa£ and second best the avKo<t>avTijs.\" 7 So also in a fragment of Philippides we are told tha", "prev": "nd make themselves generally useful. 3 It is quite clear that they were usually paid for their services and expected to receive pay on this occasion. 4 One of Terence's characters fears to lay claim to the estate of a deceased relative lest he be branded sycophanta. 6 We are not dependent upon the Latin versions of the Greek comedies for information about the continued prevalence of the sycophant.", "next": "Elsewhere 11 he states that Athens was full of flatterers, sailors, pickpockets, false witnesses, and syco- phants.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.222, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263545:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263545", "s": "To the latter class belongs Phormio. 3 A striking parallel to all this, that has apparently been overlooked, is found in Xenophon's Memorabilia*' Socrates persuades Crito to employ a \"watch-dog\" to keep off the sycophants that beset him. 8 Archedemus is the man chosen.", "prev": "The Stcophant-Paeasite 71 of her husband's deliction. 1 This caused a speedy change in the attitude of the old men toward him, and the play closes with his installation as amicus and parasitus. 2 Roughly speaking, the term sycophant may be applied to an agent employed for some particular business, parasite to one who serves one or several patrons regularly.", "next": "Like Phormio, he is \"poor but able.\" 6 Although he is not called by the name of sycophant, he is clearly one of their kind. 7 Crito is in constant fear that he may turn upon him, and for that reason does his utmost to keep his good-will. 8 So Chremes finds Phormio a dangerous enemy. 9 Archedemus undertakes to protect Crito's friends also from legal difficulties, 10 just as Phormio proves himself t", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.879, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263546:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263546", "s": "There is no occasion for surprise to find the scholiast on a chapter in Book vii referring to an earlier chapter in the same book as being in \"Book vii.\" One further indication of the beginning of one of the thirteen books has been noticed by Wilamowitz. 6 In Vaticanus B he observed that a new recension began at vi. 94, and plausibly concluded that one of the thirteen books began at this point.", "prev": "So we may read f '.", "next": "The problem of reconstituting the thirteen-book edition on the basis of this information has attracted considerable attention owing to its possible bearing on the question of separate publication of the history of the Archidamian or Ten Years' War.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.192, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263546:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263546", "s": "Curiously enough, while refusing to credit the scholiast who reported the fourth book as ending at ii. 78, and shifting it back to chapter 71, where the year ends, he himself in four instances fails to make the book divisions correspond with campaigns. 2 In view of these inconsistencies Kalinka cannot expect his criticism of the scholiast to be convincing.", "prev": "Con- sequently he modifies 1 the scheme so as to increase the minimum to 36.", "next": "It is clear that no mechanical scheme of book division will produce anything like the uniformity that is found in classical authors in general.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.366, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263546:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263546", "s": "The dis- tinction is not convincing. 3 The books in Festa's scheme end as follows: (1) i. 88;", "prev": "Se perd teniamo conto che il primo volume non aveva bisogno di quella dichiarazione, perche portava scritto da principio BovKv5i6r)s 'Afltjcolos ivviypa^e,\" etc.", "next": "(2) i. 146;", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.645, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263546:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263546", "s": "Thus modified Festa's theory becomes extremely plausible, if not convincing.", "prev": "Further- more, an author publishing the first instalment of his history of a war would, if he desired to engage public interest, most naturally include the history of one or two campaigns.", "next": "The bearing of this theory on the much-vexed question of the composition (Entstehung) of Thucydides' history 1 would seem to be important, but Festa has made no attempt to exploit it in this direction.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.772, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263432:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263432", "s": "It must have been entirely 7?} flefipeynlvri. 1 Archiv fiir Papyrutforachung, IV, 177. 2 I am not yet convinced, for example, that the crop rotations of the Fayum are to be accepted as oharaoteriatic of those to be found in the leases from other parts of Egypt, because of a possible difference in silt deposit.", "prev": "The chances of covering this particular farm entirely with water year after year, bounded as it was by irrigation ditches on three sides, were very great.", "next": "Material which I have already gathered may enable me to answer the question in a later article. * B.G.U.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.339, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263432:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263432", "s": "If these were requests for tax exemption or lowering of taxes the prefect would certainly not have had to issue an order each year compelling the landowners to hand them in.", "prev": "Westermann usually adding \"therefore I hand in the declaration.\" 1 There are three obvious objections to the customary explanation that these are requests for the lowering of, or for total exemption from, the annual land tax: 1.", "next": "People do not have to be compelled by order to seek a reduction in taxes. 2.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.822, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263433:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263433", "s": "So that, flat as it is to us, it was a wise choice for Horace, who was trying to make good his claim to Lucilian descent before he had really produced much of any convincing evidence to support that claim.", "prev": "The type was an easy one to imitate, and no doubt one that would make a popular appeal, introducing persons of prominence dealt with familiarly, sprinkled with obvious wit and more obvious burlesque, and avoiding all appearance of the evil of censoriousness which he had so earnestly disclaimed in his defense.", "next": "It would be foolhardy to try to find philosophic afl&liations for number seven.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.491, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263434:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263434", "s": "In the year 495 B.C., while the Volscians were marching to besiege Rome, the citizens repeatedly refused to enrol for the draft announced by the consuls, Publius Servilius and Appius Claudius.* Servilius, abandoning force and resorting to persuasion, finally secured a volunteer army for action against the enfemy.", "prev": "I wish merely to determine whether the chronicle as commonly recorded — admitting its bias; the details we cannot now recover — ^justifies the legend of the stern ancient discipline so often referred to by these historians.^ Insubordination appears early, when the Roman army was still a burgher army and fought in a formation similar to the Dorian pha- lanx.", "next": "The prom- ises that had been made to the burgesses, however, were not kept and so the consuls of the following year had no better success in their attempts at mustering in the citizens, although three hostile armies, Volscian, Aequian, and Sabine, were threatening Rome.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.326, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263434:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263434", "s": "It was calculated not only to encourage but also to persuade.", "prev": "Aug. 24, tells of how a Roman knight cut off the thumbs of his sons so that they might be ineligible for the draft is only an aggravated instance of the numerous attempts to escape military service.^ The cohortatio (I do not, of course, refer to the artistic speeches of the literature), the general's speech to his troops before action, may be noted in this connection.", "next": "If then one re-reads the record of the Empire, and especially such a work as the Histories of Tacitus, with this picture of the Roman soldier of the Republic in mind, one has at his control an additional factor which will help to explain the confusion and the insubordination of the year 69-70 a.d.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.926, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263436:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263436", "s": "The decipherment by Jensen, who thought to prove relationship between Hittite and Armenian, was generally rejected as fanciful, and the attempts by Sayce and later by Thompson convinced scholars only in some meager details.", "prev": "Of native Hittite records there were known for a time only those inscribed in hieroglyphics (pictographs) of unknown value.", "next": "Among the horde of cuneiform letters discovered in 1888 at Tell-el-Amarna in Egypt, mostly in Babylonian, which at the time they were written (about 1400 B.C.) was the international language of diplomacy in the Near East, there were a few in the same form of writing but not in the Babylonian language, 1 Cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.119, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263436:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263436", "s": "Many of the other comparisons are worthless as evidence for anyone not already convinced.", "prev": "I have purposely selected for mention those features in which the resemblance to Indo-European is most striking.", "next": "The author's earlier publication showed that he was not at home in Indo-European comparative philology and left some easy openings for the critic.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.5, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263436:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263436", "s": "In the Preface the author emphasizes the fact that he approached the study of the Hittite texts with no prejudice in favor of Indo- European relationship, rather quite the contrary, and that in the initial stages of his study he depended solely on internal evidence (important clues to the context being furnished by the frequently occurring Sumerian-Babylonian ideograms of known meaning), and that only after being thoroughly convinced that the language was Indo-European did he make use of the etymological method.", "prev": "All depends upon the correctness of the author's interpretation and identification of the grammatical forms.", "next": "Now to recall that Jensen made a similar and equally positive statement regarding his method of deciphering the Hittite hieroglyphics (\"ohne Hilfe des Armenischen allein aus den Inschriften oder sonsti- gen Quellen,\" Idg.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.615, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263436:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263436", "s": "It cannot then remain long doubtful whether the inflectional system set forth in the present work is a reality or a pyramiding of (certainly remark- able) plausibilities.", "prev": "Not until he has published the continuous texts with his interpretation shall we be in a position Hittite an Indo-European Language? 191 to know how well his method is justified by results.", "next": "If the interpretation of continuous texts of considerable extent is generally accepted by cuneiform scholars as in the main successful, then the grammatical constructions under- lying it will have proved sound.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.812, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263438:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263438", "s": "Diet.) says: \"Per- haps aemetta is for *demotjon, from ae, prefix; privative, and mot, a meeting for business.\" So far as the second element is concerned this derivation is not so plausible as the ad hoc addition of \"for business\" to the definition of mot may make it appear.", "prev": "Skeat (Concise Etym.", "next": "More likely aemetta contains a form of the root of metan \"measure, mete out,\" and meant originally \"lack of assignment, freedom from duty,\" hence \"leisure.\" Carl D.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.874, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263439:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263439", "s": "Wessely's suggestion there- fore adds a very interesting and persuasive bit of evidence for the theory that genu and genus are related.", "prev": "logie (XXXIV [1917], No. 16, cols. 377 f.) Wessely adds to our general store of information on the subject the fact that in Slavic we have two words, koleno and pokoleni, the former meaning either genu or genus, while the latter, itself a derivative of the former, is used to express one phase of genus \"generation.\" These SlaVic words are, of course, not etymologically connected with genu or genus.", "next": "But there stUl remains the question.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.28, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263439:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263439", "s": "Es soil auf ihn nichts ankommen, aber ganz stumm soil er doch nicht bleiben.\" This may sound plausible to anyone who thinks u)s iywiMu in literal English or German translation.", "prev": "Professor Wilamowitz' comment on this Platon i. 138, n. 1, is: \"Das eine Mai, wo Kritias das wort nimmt, 336d, ist Sokrates nicht ganz sicher, wer der Redende war.", "next": "In point of fact, however, this frequent Platonic phrase or idiom does not suggest uncertainty or doubt.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.888, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263440:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263440", "s": "Es soil auf ihn nichts ankommen, aber ganz stumm soil er doch nicht bleiben.\" This may sound plausible to anyone who thinks u)s iywiMu in literal English or German translation.", "prev": "Professor Wilamowitz' comment on this Platon i. 138, n. 1, is: \"Das eine Mai, wo Kritias das wort nimmt, 336d, ist Sokrates nicht ganz sicher, wer der Redende war.", "next": "In point of fact, however, this frequent Platonic phrase or idiom does not suggest uncertainty or doubt.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.469, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262792:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262792", "s": "Lucretius, too, uses the construction: \"non temere ulla vi <=ullo modo> convinci posse putabant\" (5. 1178).", "prev": "\" detrusus tota vi deiectusque Italia\" (Lucil. 825 Marx).", "next": "Qua vi is apparently used with the force of quo modo, although its exact meaning is at times hard to determine: e.g., \"quo pacto fiant et qua vi quaeque gerantur\" (Lucr. 1. 568; cf. 2. 549; 5. 77; 6. 380).", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.846, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262794:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262794", "s": "Such a suggestion cannot be made into any convincing explanation, although it is worth remarking that the activity of Sceledrus ends with the appearance of Pleusicles in the action, and that Sceledrus returns to the stage only in the last scene of the play after Pleusicles has left the action.", "prev": "Pleusicles leaves the stage just before the Lurcio scene begins, and this prevents the appearance of Sceledrus in the present scene.", "next": "Briefly put, the function of Lurcio as an inorganic puer, providing entertainment and padding the interval of time during the departure and return of the same character, and, pos- sibly, as a means of extricating the dramatist from difficulties due to a limited cast, makes him a weaker support for a theory of con- tamination than has generally been realized; but thereby I do not mean to say that i", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.55, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262794:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262794", "s": "(3) The Greek word choragus in the scene heading cannot be pressed unless we are convinced that Plautus is responsible for the scene heading.", "prev": "(2) These first two verses contain the dubious word halophantam, which, with the apparent assonance in sycophantam and possible punning in the two words, points to a Greek source rather than Plautine invention so far as these two verses are concerned.", "next": "It appears in the same Doric form in the text of Persa 159, Trin. 858.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.694, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263296:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263296", "s": "This edition, however, is practically a transcript of the above-mentioned manuscript. 2 1 quote from the text of Reifferscheid (Leipzig, 1860), in which a careful exami- nation of the manuscripts convinces me more than one reading will have to be changed. 'The edition of Beroaldus according to Panzer, IX, p. 411, 286, first appeared at Bologna in 1504.", "prev": "The reading of the Copenhagen manuscript differs but little from those of six of the others representing the best ' Tross in his edition of 1841 publishes the reading of the Leyden manuscript ethiologias.", "next": "I have a photographic reproduction, secured from the Royal Library at Berlin, of the edition printed at Strasbourg with Pliny (sic) De Viris Illustibua in 1510.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.113, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263296:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263296", "s": "This investigation, while certainly not exhaustive, has been sufficient to convince me that not only is aetiologia perfectly intelligible in all of the places to which I have referred, but in Quintilian at least is better suited to the context.", "prev": "Feeling certain that the various forms of aetiologia, as representing the manuscript tradition, must be restored to the text of both authors if the nxeaning will permit, I have endeavored to ascertain from the original sources the signification of each word.", "next": "Concerning aetiologia the testimony is fairly abundant.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.248, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263298:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263298", "s": "Laert. iv. 5), is in all probability an answer to Isocrates.' These two instances afford considerable plausibility to the view that Isocrates is referring to his own speech and its rivals.", "prev": "Speusippus' speech, Trpos rov apAprvpov (Diog.", "next": "Indeed he may have had in mind only the performance of Antisthenes, to whom he almost certainly refers in xi. 1 ff.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.239, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263304:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263304", "s": "To understand the Oedipus we must bear in mind enough of Greek poetical criticism of life to convince us that Sophocles could no more regard Oedipus as guilty than we do.", "prev": "Sheppard's chief point is that for the right interpretation of a Greek play we need, even more than technical and linguistic erudition, a conscious apprehension of the ethical and religious presuppositions which the poet and his audience took for granted.", "next": "Whatever the mythical or metaphysical background, the Oedipus of the play is an essentially noble man, the victim of circumstances — fate, the Lucretian caeca potestas, the something not ourselves that makes for our unhappiness.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.144, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263307:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263307", "s": "The second Appendix is a strong and to me, at present, convincing argument that the Epistle to Themistius was composed by Julian as Caesar in 355 and not as generally supposed at the end of 361 when he had been proclaimed Augustus at Paris.", "prev": "The first Appendix deals with the Paedagogus Mardonius, to whom Rostagni attributes a larger part in Julian's education than is usually assigned to him.", "next": "Among the chief argu- ments are the prudently colorless language about the divinity and the fact that Themistius who dates his own political career from 357 is spoken of as himself a devotee of the theoretic life who holds no office.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.949, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263312:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263312", "s": "Scott No argument advanced against the Homeric authorship of the Iliad and the Odyssey seems more convincing than the assumed fact that at an early date Homer was regarded as the source of all the earliest epics, the Thebais, the Epigonoi, the Cypria, and the rest, as well as of the Iliad and the Odyssey.", "prev": "HOMER AS THE POET OF THE THEBAIS By John A.", "next": "This idea is most sweep- ingly stated by Verrall and by Wilamowitz;", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.078, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263315:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263315", "s": "On the whole perhaps the most plausible connection is with ^Xl/Saros in the sense of 'deep, abysmal' (&vtp<# h> ^Xi/3aT<f>, etc.), as suggested by Adam, » Republic of Plato 1. 132.", "prev": "Mag.: dXi/Sdwras - tovs h> flaXiWjj rekevrricravTas.", "next": "Only we should not assume ciXi-=ijXi-, but dXt- beside ^Xi-, with vowel gradation. eX6£as, in Homer, Hesiod, Pindar used only in the sense of 'ivory,' from Herodotus on for the 'elephant,' is believed to contain an element which is seen also in Latin ebur and which in both cases is borrowed from Egyptian or Semitic (cf.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.424, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263322:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263322", "s": "The essays, moreover, are good, and it is characteristic of him that in the first of them instead of repeating all the time-worn arguments, so old, so tattered, and so frayed, he selects a single one, the value of the classics for the study of English and the development of an English style, and elaborates it in a way that is at once genial and vigorous, persuasive and effective.", "prev": "Book Reviews 83 secretaries of associations must have papers for their meetings and Kirby Smith was always ready to help.", "next": "In the \"Humanities in Education,\" among other good points, he draws attention to the character of German education in the period before August, 1914: Now it is safe to say that for more than a generation the most obvious and striking characteristic of German education was that, apart from being highly organized and relentlessly thorough, it has been more exclusively scientific and technical than a", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.194, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263329:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263329", "s": "Some of the author's conclusions are that the Roman conception of magic was essentially the same as ours; that, so far as we can judge from our knowledge of Roman law, religion, science, and literature, belief in magic existed among the Romans from the earliest period and was not imported from Greece or the Orient; and that the attempt of educated Romans to appear superior in such matters does not convince one that they had really shaken off their inherited belief in magical agencies.", "prev": "New York: Columbia University Press.", "next": "While none of these conclusions is new, in no other work known to the reviewer has the evidence been so carefully collected and so wisely judged.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.68, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "Yet in spite of this trend of contem- porary opinion it raises its head once more in this article in the American Journal, confident, unabashed, unafraid, and set forth with all that plausibility which Miss Waites's essays invariably show.", "prev": "\" 2 VII, 42-57. 3 P. 337: \"The Lares, who may have been the spirits of dead ancestors.\" [Classical, Philology XVI, April, 1921] 124 The Origin of the Cult of the Lares 125 The Religious Thought of the Greeks, 1 and by Fox in his volume on Greek and Roman Mythology.", "next": "I must confess that I was surprised to see it.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.082, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "In my opinion the theory has nothing to stand upon; and while I do not agree with all the points which Wissowa — for he, as Miss Waites rightly says, is its most vigorous opponent — has attempted to make against it, not one of the arguments urged in its favor is convincing.", "prev": "But its advocacy by so brilliant a scholar as Miss Waites and its pub- lication in so sober a periodical as the American Journal of Archae- ology almost drive me to the conclusion that it is one of those academic vagaries which we shall always have with us.", "next": "That the theory, in one form or another, appears in Roman literature is a familiar fact.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.101, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "The woolen images of men and women he explains as substitutes for an original human sacrifice. 3 It is his opinion that such a rite can belong only to a cult of souls or of some divinity of the earth and concludes with the far from convincing argument that insomuch as he has already proved that it is the Lar of the household (Lar familiaris) and not the Lar of the field that is the starting-point of the cult, all possibility of connection with earth divinities is excluded and it must be to the Lares as souls of the deceased that the images are suspended.", "prev": "This, he argues, shows that we have to do with a rite of a propitiatory character celebrated in honor of chthonic deities.", "next": "But he has not proved that the Lar familiaris is the starting-point of the cult.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.296, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "These parallels are interesting but not convincing.", "prev": "In certain parts of the Tyrol also crumbs thrown into the fire are supposed to reach the souls of the poor.", "next": "Wissowa 1 meets them by contending that in the Pliny passage Lar is used for the whole group of domestic gods, and that Pliny might just as well have used the word Penates.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.41, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "But any spirit connected with the hearth (as the Lar familiaris in its later develop- ment certainly was) might with equal plausibility be regarded as the deity to whom the offering was made.", "prev": "In countries where the souls of the departed were believed to haunt the hearth, they were thought of as the recipients.", "next": "Another point urged by the defenders of the ancestor theory is that the Lares must be connected with the goddess Larentia (also called Larentina and Larunda), whose festival, the Larentalia, was celebrated on December 23.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.436, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "As I have already indicated, most of his arguments against Samter seem to me cogent and conclusive.", "prev": "For while all would concede that it would be highly appropriate for girls on the threshold of womanhood to give up their dolls (as Wissowa interprets maniae), most of us would contend that it would be a uniquely inappropriate time to discard corsets. 1 Let us now examine the view held by Wissowa.", "next": "But his own explanation of the origin of the cult is not, as it seems to me, tenable.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.573, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "In these instances the Lares are obviously connected with persons, and attempts to explain such references as local should convince no one.", "prev": "In the tenth volume of the Corpus (8061, 1) we have the words Larum Galillensium on a seal, and from another inscription (ibid., 7852) we know that Galillenses was the name of a people.", "next": "There is even an example of Lares curiales given in the Bulletino Archeo- logico Communale, 1909, page 19, and commented on by Tomassetti there.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.627, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262829:7", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262829", "s": "The Origin of the Cult of the Lakes 139 plausible of the derivations is that which connects it with lascivus. 1 Certainly the waywardness and liveliness which that word connotes may be said to accord well with the familiar representation in sculp- ture and painting of the dancing Lar, as well as with Naevius' 2 phrase Lares ludentis and all that has come down to us in regard to the merriment of the Compitalia.", "prev": "Wort, p. 413.", "next": "Indeed one of the mysteries of the ancestor theory is how anyone can reconcile such merry sprites with the Romans' idea of their grandfathers.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.915, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262831:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262831", "s": "Horace as a convinced Epicurean quietly and dogmatically reaffirms the Epicurean opinion.", "prev": "And Cicero, sometimes speaking for himself, sometimes for the Stoics, repeatedly says, e.g., de Fin. ii. 18-19, that nisi aequitas, fides, iustitia proficiscantur a natura et si omnia haec ad utilitatem refer- antur virum bonum non posse repperiri.", "next": "The protest in Plato's Laws, 892, against a purely materialistic conception of nature and the natural anticipates and includes Epicurean utilitarianism and all similar theories.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.302, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263133:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263133", "s": "Thus it might plausibly be urged that the epithet rjdvyeKus is naturally pertinent to the description of an infant god destined to figure as a kind of tricksy sprite and farceur in many a legend from his birth on.", "prev": "I have implied above that these analogies are not equal in point of applica- bility if they are scrutinized by a severe critic.", "next": "The vagitus, a conventional feature in the legends of the birth of Zeus,' could be cited as proof positive that myth-mongers might sacrifice the miraculous for the realistic in portraying the birth of a god.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.386, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263133:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263133", "s": "Rationalistic study of the Suetonian Life of Vergil has demonstrated, in certain instances with certainty, in others with great plausibility, that exegesis and a{5Jr/<rts of passages in the writings of the poet, especially in the Eclogues and the Georgics where his ego may be most readily postulated, he at the root of dogmatic assertions.", "prev": "Inferences based on the writings of their subjects, reconstruction of the intellectual life of men of letters, of their personalities, of the actual events of their careers in such a way as to motivate the con- tent and spirit of their works, were devices constantly resorted to by the authors.", "next": "The most famous example is of course the treatment of the story of the eviction.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.693, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263133:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263133", "s": "Suffice it to say that, if we canvass plausibilities, Asconius Pedianus would present the strongest claims.", "prev": "Vergilii in his quae de ingenio moribusque eius tradiderunt, to try to locaUze exactly the agent responsible for the application of the hnes of the Edogue to the poet himself would seem to be sheer Alexandrianism.", "next": "The passage from Servius alluded to above shows that Asconius busied himself prayerfully with the problem of the identity of the puer.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.963, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263134:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263134", "s": "My object here is not to criticize Professor Phillimore' s doctrine as a whole; but the present inquiry was suggested to me by his \"Teren- tiana,\" and it has resulted in convincing me that the dogma that ego is always and necessarily emphatic is a mere a priori assumption.' This is, indeed, a paradox; but \"the time shall give it proof.\" In this article I have made only a beginning of the demonstration.", "prev": "Sonnenschein It is commonly believed that the pronouns ego, tu, etc., are only- expressed when emphatic; and this dogma has recently been made one of the foundation stones of a doctrine of \"recessive words\" in OL. verse by Professor Phillimore in the Classical Review.", "next": "Ego occurs over two thousand times in Plautus alone.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.089, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263140:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263140", "s": "It all sounds very learned and plausible in the exposition of Dr. von Scala and Professor Bury.", "prev": "ef note is Professor Bury's adoption of Rudolph von Scala's thesis that Polybius, beginning with Demetrius of Phaleron's sentimental and rhetorical conception of the r61e of Fortune in human affairs, advanced to the stern scientific faith in causation which left no place for fortune or the gods in \"pragmatic history,\" 1 and that later interpolations in his text reveal this progress in his thought.", "next": "There is but one objection to it: If you read Polybius you find that it isn't so.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.208, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263141:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263141", "s": "There is no convincing evidence that Gorgias added the comparison of the Olympic games to his parallel with Oedipus.", "prev": "(i. 10. 49) of this world.", "next": "True, Themistius may have made his implied contrast between the theater made by hands and the true Olympian temple because Gorgias had named the Olympic games.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.693, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263144:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263144", "s": "One of the most convincing articles in the book is that which deals with the \"Religious Meaning of the Toga Praetexta of Roman Children.\" The author shows clearly that the garment was holy, that it was worn by priests when they were performing their sacrificial duties and by curule magistrates, perhaps because they had the right to offer sacrifices in behalf of the com- munity.", "prev": "It naturally develops in the third stage to cover the whole sphere of worship and man's attitude toward the supernatural, and finally in the second century of our era, when the several creeds were clearly distinguished from one another and a keen rivalry sprang up between them, the word took on the meaning which we give it today.", "next": "In the household of a Roman freeman in early days the father acted as priest, and his children attended him as ministrants.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.4, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262900:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262900", "s": "We are not convinced that such districts were possible, but we are entitled to draw the conclusion that, just as geography settled the composition and arrangement of the other and more normal dis- tricts, so too it played its part in the production of these two — in Herodotus.", "prev": "This does not explain XIII; but in view of the neighborhood of the two pairs of nations it is plain that the reason for the one peculiar combination is the reason for the other.", "next": "We shall see presently that there are similar, though less startling, combinations in the army corps.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.228, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262903:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262903", "s": "If it be taken in association with rvpavvoLi, this is the most plausible explanation to give to the word.", "prev": "The emendations of Lipsius were for the most part adopted in the fourth Teubner edition revised by Fuhr (1913). * The word (npayaiaiv has generally been understood to refer to wholesale slaughter such as might take place in an attempt on the government similar to that of the fol- lowers of Cylon.", "next": "But a<t>ay7i could be dealt with by the homicide courts.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.232, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262903:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262903", "s": "In order to make this explanation plausible, Sauppe retains fi before inc6 tS>v ^aaCKkuiv and deletes fi before liri 4>bv(^.", "prev": "Therefore, since no mention is made of the Palladium either in the law of Solon or in the decree of 404 B.C., the phrase must refer to the Palladium, and the following words, kwi ij>bvtf t'k iari. <t>vyi), apply to involuntary homicide.", "next": "The remainder of the decree refers to decisions made by the heliastic courts concerning civil strife and would-be tyrants.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.972, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262905:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262905", "s": "Some scholar is for the moment \"raised to that bad eminence\" of being a leading light of Disintegrating Criticism; an argument ascribed to him is glorified (at times beyond its worth) as convinc- ing, overwhelmingly convincing — if the premises on which it is based are as stated.", "prev": "INFINITIVES IN -iftev IN HOMER, IMMANUEL BEKKER, AND PROFESSOR SCOTT By George Melville Bolling In reading the writings of the Unitarians, one is at times reminded of what used to be called kathenotheism in the study of the Veda.", "next": "Examination of these, however, shows always that this leading light either was unable to count (a simple form of mental testing), or had never read the Homeric poems, or had made some obvious blunder.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.108, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262629:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262629", "s": "They supplement rather than supplant each other, as Welcker (Der epische Cyclus, II, 333 ff.) convincingly argues.", "prev": "There is no real difficulty in assign- ing both of these fragments, containing each a curse, to one poem.", "next": "Furthermore, internal evidence points to their great antiquity.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.164, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262630:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262630", "s": "So air\\6rr)s is related to Lat. simplicitds, 5e£toT??s to Skt. ddksatdti- and Lat. dexteritas, Zhacfrpbr-qs to Lat. levitds, i\\ev9epi6rr}s to Lat. llbertds, 1 irkrjpoTrjs to Lat. plenitas, clKvk6tt]s to Lat. salsitds, Bripibrris to Lat. feritds. 2 From the small number of complete and convincing correspond- ences between Greek and other languages we may conclude that the productivity of the suffix was very slight in IE times, and this is further borne out by its rareness in Sanskrit and early Greek.", "prev": "Charisius 63 and 93 P. 46 Walter Petersen speak of the possibility of identical ultimate origin disturbed in the same way as in case of the t-stems.", "next": "As opposed to hundreds of these words in later Greek and in Latin, the Homeric poems have only nine: 6.(v)5poTrjs, 5t]iottis, naKorris, veorris, <£t\\oT»7s, ppa8vTr)s, TaxvTrjs, iorrjs tottis.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.056, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262630:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262630", "s": "Thus Iraporrjs ' tendency to go forward ' (cf . et/u) , bpy Chords ' tendency to anger, irascibility' (cf. bpyifa), mOavbrris 'persuasiveness' (cf. 1 Cf.", "prev": "s the notion of an attribute or permanent quality can easily pass over into that of an intermittent quality or of an activity which is the result of such a quality. 1 This development has not been undergone by those abstracts which are derived from adjectives expressing a tendency to certain kinds of action, at least not as long as the tendency is stressed, for such a tendency is a true attribute.", "next": "Paul, Principien der Sprachgeschicht#, 335. 68 Walter Petersen irelflu), ixiprikoTris ' imitativeness ' (cf. juijueojuai), even though indi- rectly associated with the verbs mentioned, are true adjectival abstracts of ira/xos, bpyiXos, TiBavbs, p.Lp,rfKbs.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.591, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262633:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262633", "s": "Badham's substitution for ndvov avrov of bvbp.ari in antithesis to XcVyois epyots re is ingenious but not convincing.", "prev": "Notes and Discussions 87 seditiones vocatae.", "next": "The familiar antithesis of name (not word) and deed is not called for further than it is already expressed in XcVyois tpyois re, which, however, is mainly intensifying here.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.192, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262633:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262633", "s": "As a more plausible solution I would propose ntv6vruv.", "prev": "Bitter rightly says that the present text is impossible and suggests airciv (of them, i.e. the arts of war) which is possible but awkward.", "next": "This yields a suitable antithesis between fighting abroad on sea or land and staying in the city.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.258, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-262634:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-262634", "s": "There is no desire on my part to lessen the brilliance of the work done by him, since I regard it as one of the soundest and most convincing contro- versial articles I have ever read.", "prev": "I am perfectly willing to substitute Professor Boiling's figures for my own in the article he attacks and then to leave the rest exactly as published.", "next": "The great hope for the progress of Homeric studies in America is found in just this fact, that we are developing a group of critics who are competent to find the weak spots in the arguments of their associates.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.928, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263471:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263471", "s": "Neither this nor any other interpretation which rests on the notion that these inscriptions are private advertisements has any plausibility.", "prev": "Both reject the theory of Skutsch, Glotta, I, 104 ff ., and rightly.", "next": "They are certainly Greek apupodov and the Oscan Eituns-Inscriptions 113 official notices, and with mention of gates and towers in four of the six, they no doubt have to do with military defence.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.259, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263471:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263471", "s": "But I am now convinced that we must definitely abandon his idea that they are directions to the allied soldiery in the Social War as to how to find their way to their stations.", "prev": "So far Nissen was right.", "next": "It may be recalled that Mau, Rom.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.275, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263475:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263475", "s": "As a neo-Platonist convinced that Plato and Aristotle meant the same thing he does not hesi- tate to read the Aristotelian ivipycva. into Plato's a 8wdp.e6a and o aTrepyd£e- rat.", "prev": "The reference to dian? recalls the passage to Simplicius' mind and perhaps quoting from memory, he generalizes its application to ras 8wa/*eis Kal Tas ovular tS>v TrpaypATtav.", "next": "And I am not sure that he was wrong.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.96, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263476:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263476", "s": "As a neo-Platonist convinced that Plato and Aristotle meant the same thing he does not hesi- tate to read the Aristotelian ivipycva. into Plato's a Swa/teSa and o dTrepyd^e- Tai.", "prev": "The reference to ctKoi; recalls the passage to Simplicius' mind and perhaps quoting from memory, he generalizes its application to ras Swa/teis Kal Ttts ovcrias rmv Trpay/jMTwv.", "next": "And I am not sure that he was wrong.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.518, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263476:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263476", "s": "Solil. 1. 10, \"prorsus mihi unus Ciceronis liber facillime persuasit nuUo modo petendas esse divitias,\" does not seem to be parallel. 'The reading, a conjecture of Hagen's, is uncertain, but fairly probable; it is accepted both by Hertz and by Hosius; codex S has \"pros (profi) um (petet anti) speotantia.\" The passage is quoted below.", "prev": "August.", "next": "", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.952, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263477:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263477", "s": "Solil. 1. 10, \"prorsus mihi unus Ciceronis liber facillime persuasit nuUo modo petendas esse divitias,\" does not seem to be parallel. 'The reading, a conjecture of Hagen's, is uncertain, but fairly probable; it is accepted both by Hertz and by Hosius; codex S has \"pros (profi) um (petet anti) speotantia.\" The passage is quoted below.", "prev": "August.", "next": "Notes and Discussions 145 The original meaning of the word, \"forward, straight ahead, onward\" (I, 1),' appears in ix. 4. 6, \"vestigia pedum habentes retro porrecta, non prosum spectantia,\" and in ii. 30. 4, \"undas faciunt (sc. venti a septen- trionibus)'non prorsus inpulsas sed imitus commotus.\" The figurative use (I, 2) does not seem to occur.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.362, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263482:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263482", "s": "How- ever, the chapter dealing with the difficulty arising from the use of the term Tre/otiroAos is not so successful and is perhaps the least convincing of the whole treatise.", "prev": "In chapter ii of Part I the author is not unsuccessful in taking issue with those who see in Thu- cydides' use of ol vewraroi (ii. 13. 7; 21. 2) a reference to the ephebi.", "next": "Others (Girard, Did. des Antiq., s.v.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.177, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263482:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263482", "s": "Wilamowitz, op. cit., p. 194) does not convince us that there may not have been something much earlier from which the late fourth-century institution developed.", "prev": "Even the suggestion that Plato is responsible for the institution (p. 41;", "next": "No one pretends to doubt that changes came in it in the course of the third century.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.324, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263598:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263598", "s": "There occurred to me, however, an explanation which seemed both simple and convincing.", "prev": "The existence of such a residuum would have been nothing surprising, and might well have been allowed to stand without explanation.", "next": "I stated it, therefore, in a form too brief, as the sequel has shown.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.091, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "In the cases alleged by Wilamowitz, Drerup, 1 and others I find none that is entirely convincing.", "prev": "Whether or how often Homer actually does this is a question of fact and the interpretation of particular passages.", "next": "Wilamowitz' chief example is the comparison at the end of the eighth book of the watchfires of the Trojans to the stars, which he thinks symbolizes the joyous confidence of the Trojans, and the, as he believes, consciously contrasted image at the beginning of the ninth book that compares the agitations of the Greek mind to a dark sea rent by contending winds from Thrace.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.316, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "And a reader who is accustomed to the sentiment of modern poetry and who recalls the phrase in the first simile \"and the shepherd's heart is glad\" will esteem it a plausible and happy thought.", "prev": "Wilamowitz is so sure of this that he deems anyone who cannot feel it outside the pale of rational discussion.", "next": "Yet a very slight con- sideration of Homer's habitual style renders it more than doubtful.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.329, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "The most plausible of Wilamowitz' examples are the similes of the beacon fire and the trumpet that signalize Achilles' reappearance at the trench and his shout {Iliad xviii. 207 ff.).", "prev": "But the familiarity of the comparison of an army to a vi<j>os may heal that.", "next": "Here for Wilamowitz (p. 168) the essential is that a beacon fire signals for help and a trumpet call may bring salvation such as Achilles brought to the Greeks.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.422, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:3", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "Professor Murray lends the charm of his persuasive manner to this scientific method.", "prev": "But the ordinary interpreter of Homer, he sadly adds, is insensitive to these refinements.", "next": "The poets of our Iliad scarcely need to have seen a lion, he thinks.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.606, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:4", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "\"Does this explanation fail to carry conviction?\" Professor Murray asks.", "prev": "So he kept it by him and the mention of a wall reminded him of the comparison of the hunters to a wall and he put it there.", "next": "It does, if for no other reason, because he is thinking in English.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.676, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:5", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "His next example is the two similes that compare the Lapiths defending the gate, first to two high-crested oaks, and then to wild boars: \"People who stand firm in front of a gate are not very like wild boars that rush out and tear up the undergrowth making a noise with their tusks.\" That has a plausible sound, but by parity of reasoning we could argue that Stonewall Jackson's name became a misnomer if he ever charged at the head of his troop, or that Tennyson could not possibly have compared his Princess to a stately pine set in a cataract on an island crag and to a bell that tolled ruin from ", "prev": "Iliad iv. 334).", "next": "Professor Murray's account aggravates the contradiction between the two Homeric similes by the comment: \"a moment after we are told of the same two men .... out they charged,\" etc.", "neg": true, "atom": true, "pos": 0.684, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263600:6", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263600", "s": "That has a plausible sound and gives an impression of profound insight on the part of the critic who seems to have been present at the very conception of the poems.", "prev": "And so the diaskeuast retained it regardless of concinnity.", "next": "It may conceivably be the true account of the matter in a few instances.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.894, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263004:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263004", "s": "No other profane Latin text offers such abundant and convincing evidence of the stages through which it has come down to us.", "prev": "The outline given above, based largely on Sabbadini's articles, furnishes the necessary background for discussing the relationship of the MSS of the Italian group.", "next": "This is all the more surprising because most of the evidence is derived from MSS of the fifteenth century, MSS in which we expect to find the traces of their descent obhterated or confused through the activity of the Humanists.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.196, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263005:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263005", "s": "Sonnenschein calls it in one sentence \"a common belief\" and in the next \"a dogma.\" Well, my teachers neglected to impart it to me, and after many years of expounding and studying Terence, I have only gradually convinced myself that Donatus was right when he said magna uis pronominum (ad Ad. 697), magna uis est in pronominibus (ad Andr. 271), sententiae quae a pronominibus incipiunt seria semper et uera promittunt (ibid., 330), magna uis in pronominibus et significatio est (ad Eun. 797), hoc pronomen (EGO) initium continet orationis graviter inceptae (ad Hec. 635), etc.", "prev": "Dr.", "next": "St.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.237, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263010:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263010", "s": "It may be that the proposed interpretation will persuade some critics that the three lines (or 887 alone) are not spurious after all, in spite of the objectionable £<us. __ Ivan M.", "prev": "Crosby's note will at any rate make it necessary for the com- mentators and translators to reconsider this passage.", "next": "Linforth ALEXANDER, THE SON OF DEMETRIUS POLIORCETES Professor M.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.897, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263011:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263011", "s": "It may be that the proposed interpretation will persuade some critics that the three lines (or 887 alone) are not spurious after all, in spite of the objectionable ^m.", "prev": "Crosby's note will at any rate make it necessary for the com- mentators and translators to reconsider this passage.", "next": "Ivan M.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.817, "verdict": true}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263012:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263012", "s": "It may be that the proposed interpretation will persuade some critics that the three lines (or 887 alone) are not spurious after all, in spite of the objectionable £<us. __ Ivan M.", "prev": "Crosby's note will at any rate make it necessary for the com- mentators and translators to reconsider this passage.", "next": "Linforth ALEXANDER, THE SON OF DEMETRIUS POLIORCETES Professor M.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.452, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263012:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263012", "s": "But there is another Alexander living at this time, with whom we could more plausibly, I think, identify this character, namely the son of Demetrius Poliorcetes and Deidamia, the sister of Pyrrhus.", "prev": "It is evident, as Rostovtzeff points out, 358 Notes and Discussions that he was a man of high rank, as he had owned at least two slaves, one a bath rubber and the other a coachman.", "next": "While we have no informa- tion that the son of Lysimachus was ever in Egypt, the only mention in history of this son of Demetrius is in Plutarch, Demetrius 53, where he says: \"He [Demetrius] had also, by Deidamia, a son Alexander, who lived and died in Egypt\" (os iv kiyvwTio KartfUwrt) .", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.575, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263013:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263013", "s": "But there is another Alexander living at this time, with whom we could more plausibly, I think, identify this character, namely the son of Demetrius Poliorcetes and Deidamia, the sister of Pyrrhus.", "prev": "For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 358 Notes and Discussions that he was a man of high rank, as he had owned at least two slaves, one a bath rubber and the other a coachman.", "next": "While we have no informa- tion that the son of Lysimachus was ever in Egypt, the only mention in history of this son of Demetrius is in Plutarch, Demetrius 53, where he says: \"He [Demetrius] had also, by Deidamia, a son Alexander, who lived and died in Egypt\" (os iv kiyvwTio KartfUwrt) .", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.139, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263025:0", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263025", "s": "The first article shows rather convincingly against Vahlen and Skutsch that the Scipio of Ennius was one of the satires.", "prev": "Ennius receives the most space; other articles deal with Lucretius, Cicero, Catullus, Virgil, Ovid, Horace, Tacitus, Seneca, Gellius, Lactantius, the Anthologia Latina, and inscriptions.", "next": "The text of the known fragments is printed, with detailed comments.", "neg": false, "atom": false, "pos": 0.315, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263025:1", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263025", "s": "In writing of Cicero's famous line, fortunatam natam me consuls Romam, Pascal develops in a very plausible way a suggestion of Pascoli's, that natam was not in the original version but was inserted by one of Cicero's detractors.", "prev": "It concludes with the suggestion that Lucretius in his invoca- tion to Venus is following the teaching of Epicurus that one must give heed to political considerations.", "next": "In putting together and commenting on the Catullian glosses, Pascal errs, I think, in interpreting Scaliger.", "neg": true, "atom": false, "pos": 0.454, "verdict": false}, {"hid": "a:jstor-263025:2", "src": "cp_articles", "id": "jstor-263025", "s": "An essay in the Virgilian group explains in a convincing way why the unfolded roll in the Virgil mosaic found at Susa carries line 8 of the Aeneid (Musa mihi, etc.) rather than the conventional Arma virumque cano: the words are better suited to the picture, as two Muses stand by Virgil's side .", "prev": "When such a mid-Victorian attitude toward manuscripts is found, it is difficult (to para- phrase Juvenal) not to write a big book instead of a short review.", "next": "An interesting paper shows how the later African writers defended Dido.", "neg": false, "atom": true, "pos": 0.669, "verdict": false}]